Wani gungu mai ban tsoro, waɗannan Yahudawa masu ɗabi'a na jama'a. Kawai lokacin da kuke tunanin kun sami farfagandar su ta koma baya, tare da canji a cikin ikon Amurka kuma suna juya wasan gaba ɗaya.
Ka tuna lokacin da ba daidai ba ne don kwatanta sojojin Isra'ila na mamayewa ga Nazis? Rabbi Shmuley Boteach (wanda ya zargi mutane da yawa da kin jinin Yahudawa fiye da yadda zan iya lissafa su a cikin wannan sarari) ya yi iƙirarin cewa ya kadu da tsantsar Roger Waters a kan suna gudanar da wasan kwaikwayo a Palastinu da ta mamaye a matsayin daidai da "wasa [wasa] ga gwamnatin Vichy a cikin mamayar Faransa."
Domin “kwatantawa Yahudawa da ’yan Nazi,” rubuta Boteach mai fushi, Waters ya kasance "wani" wanda ya cancanci - kuma ya sami - lacca mai yatsa daga rabbi: "[Y] ba ku da ladabi, ba ku da zuciya, ba ku da rai."
To, a lokacin ne. A yau shi ne David Friedman, wanda Donald Trump ya zaba jakadan Amurka a Isra'ila, wanda zargin jama'a Yahudawa masu sassaucin ra'ayi na Sihiyona na J Street na kasancewa ko da mafi muni "Fiye da kapos - Yahudawan da suka juya a cikin 'yan uwansu Yahudawa a sansanin mutuwar Nazi." Amma a kwanakin nan, “kwatankwacin Yahudawa da ’yan Nazi” ba zunubin da ba a gafartawa ba ne da ya kasance – aƙalla, ba bisa ga Rabbi Boteach ba, wanda ya nace cewa ko da yake “harshensa bai dace ba,” Friedman “mutum mai-kyau,” wanda baƙar magana “ya jitu da ra’ayin yawancin Yahudawa da Isra’ilawa.”
Wataƙila kuna tunanin cheesy Boteach ya yi sauƙaƙan manufa? Amma ba shi kaɗai ke buga wasan ba. Nathan Diament, babban darektan kungiyar Orthodox na manufofin jama'a, ba shi da komai face yabo ga Friedman, bayanin JTA cewa jakadan da zai kasance daidai yana wakiltar ra'ayoyin waɗancan Yahudawa (mafi rinjaye a cikin al'ummar Orthodox, a cewar Diament) waɗanda suka zaɓi Trump. Ira Stoll mai rajin kare hakkin jama'a ya tafi har ma a cikin Orthodox Algemeiner, husuma cewa New York Times ya bayyana "bangaranci" a kan "Yahudawa masu goyon bayan Isra'ila" kawai ta hanyar ba da rahoton batancin "mafi muni fiye da kapos" na Friedman. (Stoll kuma ya ba da toshe ga mulkin kama-karya na Azerbaijan - na kowane abu - mai yiwuwa saboda, kamar yadda Times rahotanni, gwamnatinta "tana siyan na'urorin makamai na zamani daga Isra'ila don neman mai.")
Yanzu, ba dole ba ne ka zama haziƙi don ɗaukar tsarin bayan duk wannan ja da baya. Kamar yadda kiyayyar kyamar musulmi ta Donald Trump ta mamaye gazawarsa a idanun wani malamin Orthodox mai kyamar addinin Islama, David Friedman na gaba-gaba da bayar da shawarwari kan haramtacciyar haramtacciyar kasar Isra'ila ya tilasta wa masanan yahudawa sake tunani kan rashin jin dadinsu na kwatanta tsakanin Yahudawa da 'yan Nazi - kamar yadda ya saba. muddin aka zana kwatancen da sunan kasar Yahudawa.
Kawai idan har yanzu wani ya rasa ma'anar, Orthodox Jaridar Yahudawa gushe Friedman ya riga ya zayyana wani "tsari" na Gabas ta Tsakiya bisa ga yadda, a cikin kalmominsa, "[r] 'yan ta'addan Falasdinu na bukatar kawar da su da kuma kawar da su" ta yadda "sauran - watakila mafi yawan - Falasdinawa" su iya. "Amfani" daga shayar da Isra'ila ta yi na dukan Yammacin Kogin Jordan. Ɗauki ɗan lokaci don yin tunani a kan ma'anar waɗannan kalmomi - "'yan ta'adda" waɗanda dole ne a "kawar da su", "watakila," kasa da rabin yawan Falasdinawa - kuma za ku gane cewa wannan jami'in diflomasiyya na iya kasancewa a zahiri. rikodin kisan kiyashin da ke ƙarfafawa, don kada ya ce komai game da tsangwamarsa ga dokokin ƙasa da ƙasa. Kuma wannan, 'yan'uwa maza da mata, shi ne ainihin dalilin da ya sa jama'a masu ƙaunar Allah a wurin Jaridar Yahudawa kar ka damu idan Friedman kuma ya keta tsohuwar haramun game da “kwatankwacin Yahudawa da ’yan Nazi.”
Amma menene game da sauƙi, tsohuwar anti-Semitism? Lallai masu bin addinin yahudawa har yanzu basu yarda ba cewa?
To, ba wani ƙari ba - ba idan ya fito daga Trump & Co. Kasa da watanni 10 sun shuɗe tun Bethany Mandel, ɗan ra'ayin mazan jiya na Yahudawa, yi kuka cewa ta ci karo da "irin wannan abin ban tsoro da tsantsar kyamar Yahudawa" daga magoya bayan Trump bayan ta yi wasu kalamai masu mahimmanci game da dan takarar "cewa na sayi bindiga a farkon wannan watan." Mandel ya lura cewa "Labaran Breitbart, yanzu kaɗan ne kawai dandamali don masu haɓaka Trump," ya kasance wurin da aka fi so don cin zarafi na Yahudawa.
The Daily Beast ya amince da Mandel, dalla-dalla yadda Breitbart - da shugaban zartarwa, Steve Bannon - sun "sake [d] ƴan ta'adda masu ƙiyayya" a lokacin yakin neman zaben shugaban kasa. The dabba An nakalto wani Bayahude mai ra'ayin mazan jiya John Podhoretz, wanda ya bayyana tangila da "a zahiri neo-Nazi White supremacists" bayan sukar Trump da Breitbart. Podhoretz ya ce "[T] akwai wasu rudani anan [tare da Breitbart da Trump]," in ji Podhoretz. "Ba na jin ba zan iya danganta kasancewa mai goyon bayan Trump da kasancewa mai inganci ko mai bayyana wadannan ra'ayoyin ba… amma wani abu ya barke da shi."
To me ya faru lokacin da Steve Bannon da kansa - babban jami'in zartarwa a tsakiyar duk wannan cin zarafi na kyamar Yahudawa - aka nada shi a matsayin daya daga cikin zababbun mashawartan Shugaba Trump?
A yanzu, kun san amsar: ko da anti-Semitism shine kosher idan yana ɗauke da lakabin Trump.
Mai yiwuwa, Rabbi Boteach yana cikin farkon masu siyan sabuwar alama, tura hotunan kansa Tare da Svengali na alt-right kuma ya kara da cewa, "Steve Bannon ya nuna goyon baya ga Isra'ila kuma wannan gwamnatin ta yi alkawarin ba da karfi ga kasar Yahudawa." Ka tuna, wannan Boteach ɗaya ne wanda bainar jama'a tsohon abokinsa, Sanata Cory Booker, lokacin da ya goyi bayan yarjejeniyar nukiliyar Shugaba Obama da Iran; A bayyane yake Boteach yana shiga yanayin gafartawa da mantawa kawai lokacin da faɗaɗawar Isra'ila ke fa'ida.
Lori Lowenthal Marcus kare Bannon a cikin Jaridar Yahudawa ya kasance, idan wani abu, ya fi abin kunya, ba wai kawai don ta zargi waɗanda aka azabtar da Bayahude ba saboda "karfin kuzari" na kansu amma saboda ta yi watsi da sheda a sarari game da Bannon na ƙin Yahudawa kamar yadda "da'awar da tsohuwar matar ta yi a lokacin shari'ar saki. ” An san masu ƙaryata Holocaust da yin korafi game da tuhume-tuhume masu adawa da Yahudawa, kuma rashin dogaron “matar da aka zarge ta” ita ce gaskiyar da aka fi so na misogynists; amma samun wata yar jarida Bayahudiya wacce ta rungumi ra'ayoyin biyu, don kawai inganta wani da Bannon ya rubuta, yana da ban sha'awa sosai. Oh, eh - Marcus ya lura cewa "Bannon ya musanta zargin." Ina tsammani cewa yakamata a sasanta lamarin.
Ko da mawallafin masu sassaucin ra'ayi JJ Goldberg ya kasa kawo kansa don kiran ɗabi'ar da ke kewaye da Trump da sunansa na gaskiya - vortex na son zuciya da tsoron siyasa wanda ƙiyayyar Bayahude ta riga ta taka rawar da ba za a iya mantawa da ita ba. Da yake kiran shari'ar da ake yi wa Bannon "kusan mai ban dariya," Goldberg ya watsar da shi tare da nasa ra'ayi na kusan ban dariya: abin da ya fi jawo hankalin alt-right, ya rubuta, "ba son rai ba ne amma ainihin manufar adawa ga tsarin zamantakewa na shawarwarin Yahudawa. al'umma" akan abubuwa kamar "Pluralism, 'yancin tsiraru, rabuwa da jihar Ikklisiya da haɗin gwiwar duniya." To, hakan na iya zama haka, kamar tunatarwa mai taimako na Goldberg cewa "Musulmi/Isra'ila na hagu" kuma "wani lokaci" yana haifar da "saɓani mai kaifi… tare da manufofin Isra'ila da aiki." Amma ta yaya hakan zai bayyana guguwar cin zarafi a cikinta, a ƙarƙashin jagorancin Bannon, masu sukar Trump ana kiransu abubuwa kamar "Yahudawa slimy" da "daidai da tanda"? Sai dai idan irin wannan kalaman na nuna kiyayya wani lamari ne na gaba-gaba - kuma ba haka ba - babu kawai a kwatanta shi da yin Allah wadai da cin zarafi na wata kasa, duk da cewa an yi ta a zuciya.
Maganar Goldberg ba kawai rashin adalci ba ne ga masu sukar Isra'ila; yana lumshe munin ainihin munin kishin alt-right da Bannon ke watsawa. Breitbart News kanta yana da taimako ya bayyana bambancin tsakanin alt-right da neo-Nazi skinheads: “Skinheads, gabaɗaya, ƙananan bayanai ne, ƙananan ƴan daba na IQ waɗanda ke haifar da tashin hankali da ƙiyayya na kabilanci. Madadin haƙƙin shine gungun mutane mafi wayo." Samu haka? Taron Bannon ya bambanta da gashin fata saboda suna kwazo fiye da fata.
Kuma ga Ben Shapiro yana bayanin dalilin Tasirin Bannon a Breitbart News na ɗaya daga cikin dalilan da ya bar: “[Marigayi] Andrew Breitbart raina wariyar launin fata. Hakika raina shi…. Ya dage da cewa a kula da labarun kabilanci da kulawa ta musamman don gujewa ko da irin kalaman wariyar launin fata. [Amma] tare da Bannon ya rungumi Trump, duk abin ya canza. Yanzu Breitbart ya zama babban gidan yanar gizon dama-dama… tura fararen kabilanci-ƙasa a matsayin ingantaccen martani ga daidaiton siyasa, kuma sashin sharhi ya juya zuwa wani yanki na masu tsattsauran ra'ayi na farar fata."
Bayan shaida irin wannan, menene masu sassaucin ra'ayin yahudawa suke jira kafin su dauki kungiyar ta Trump? Wani sabon binciken Ayyukan Ba-Amurka?
Ni kaina, ba na jin matsalar karancin bayanai ne ko kuma rashin hankali. Ban ma ganin gazawar manufar siyasa ba.
A'a, ina jin tsoron matsalar ta fi sauƙi kuma ta fi zurfi. Da dadewa, shugabancin Yahudawa ya yi la'akari da kansa a matsayin mai kula da al'adar ɗabi'a mai girma fiye da mai kare kabila, wanda muradinsa - ko ta fuskar tasirin siyasa a Amurka ko kuma ikon soja a Isra'ila - ya zo gaban kowa. la'akari. A dabi'ance kabilanci dan daba na Trump yana jan hankalin Rabbi Boteach dan damfara, da kuma wani rabbin da ya sayar da jarin dabi'arsa ga siyasar mulkin Yahudawa da Isra'ila da dadewa. A halin da ake ciki, a bangaren masu sassaucin ra'ayi, manyan malaman addinin yahudawa kamar Goldberg sun kasance a koyaushe suna taka tsantsan don keɓe Isra'ila daga abubuwan da suka dace na ci gaban kansu. Idan ba su yi ba, ba za su iya ƙoƙarta cikin ɗaukakar ikon Yahudawa ba.
Don haka, a ƙarshe, Trumps, Bannons, Boteachs da Goldbergs na duniya duk sun hadu a wuri ɗaya: wurin da zai iya yin daidai, inda realpolitik ya shafi son zuciya, inda manyan tashe-tashen hankula da wariyar launin fata za su iya kiran kansu diflomasiyya, kuma inda fadin gaskiya game da wannan shi ne abu daya da ba zai taba faruwa ba.
Tabbas, akwai yahudawa - da wasu - waɗanda suka rabu da waɗannan shaidu kuma suna kiran Trump da taronsa abin da ya cancanci a kira su. Amma sai dai idan al'ummar Yahudawa, musamman ma shugabancinta, sun ba da muryar gamayya ga sukar da kuma tsayawa da zuciya ɗaya don adawa da gajimaren duhu da ke sauka a Washington, yana da haɗarin jefa al'ummar Yahudawan Amurka cikin rashin dacewa. Sama ta taimake mu duka idan shugabancin addini ya zaɓi hanyar.
ZNetwork ana samun kuɗi ta hanyar karimcin masu karatun sa.
Bada Tallafi