Idan muka yi Allah wadai da harin da Hamas ta kai a Isra'ila a ranar 7 ga Oktoba, ba a zarge mu da kyamar Larabawa. Kuma bai kamata mu kasance ba. Babu wani abu da zai iya tabbatar da irin ta'asar da Hamas ta yi kan daruruwan fararen hula, wadanda su ne akasarin mutane 1,200 da aka kashe a sakamakon hare-haren da dakarun Hamas ke kaiwa. Kuma babu abin da zai tabbatar da yin garkuwa da fararen hula.
Amma idan muka la'anci Isra'ila saboda ayyukanta tun daga lokacin, ana iya zarge mu da nuna kyama. A halin da ake ciki, babu wani abu da zai iya tabbatar da irin ta'asar da Isra'ila ke yi a Gaza, inda a yanzu adadin wadanda suka mutu ya karu kiyasta a 32,000, yayin da wasu dubban Falasdinawa da ba a kidaya su ba binne a karkashin tarkace. kashi saba'in cikin dari daga cikin wadanda abin ya shafa sun hada da yara da mata.
Gwamnatin Amurka na ci gaba da yin ta'asar da aka yi. Kamar yadda Manjo Janar Yitzhak Brick na Isra'ila mai ritaya ya ce tsakiyar watan na biyu na yakin: "Dukkanin makami mai linzami, alburusai, bama-bamai masu shiryarwa, dukkan jiragen sama da bama-bamai, duk daga Amurka ne" Ya kara da cewa: "Kowa ya fahimci cewa ba za mu iya yakar wannan yakin ba. ba tare da Amurka ba. Lokaci.”
Saboda dokokin tarayya kuma kadan kadan, yakamata Amurka ta yanke duk wani taimakon soji da take baiwa Isra'ila tuntuni. Ya kamata a yi amfani da ma'auni ɗaya na haƙƙin ɗan adam. Amma bin wannan mai sauƙi, ƙa'ida ta asali na iya haifar da mugun hali na "antisemitism."
Batun dabara shine a daidaita Isra'ila da addinin yahudawa - sannan kuma a daidaita adawa da Isra'ila da kyamar baki.
Don haka, rubuta a cikin New York Daily News watan Nuwamban da ya gabata, wani jami'i a kwamitin Yahudawan Amurka ayyana cewa "kwayar cutar kyamar baki ta yadu zuwa Amurka, inda masu zanga-zangar adawa da Isra'ila suka mamaye harabar jami'o'i da titunan birnin, wadanda suka yi zanga-zangar, 'Daga kogi zuwa teku!' - kira ga kisan gillar da aka yi wa Isra'ilawa, da kuma 'Globalize the Intifada!' - roko na kashe Yahudawa a duk duniya."
Kamar yadda Peter Beinart nuna A cikin wata makala ta 2022, “A karkashin ma’anar kyamar baki da Kungiyar Yaki da cin mutunci, Kwamitin Yahudawa na Amurka da Ma’aikatar Harkokin Wajen Amurka suka gabatar, Falasdinawa sun zama ‘yan adawa idan suka yi kira da a maye gurbin kasar da ke fifita Yahudawa da wadda ba ta nuna wariya bisa kabilanci. ko kuma addini.”
Yayin da Isra'ila ke ci gaba da kashe yara, mata da maza - ba wani laifi ba face taron jama'a da za ku iya gani a wani babban kanti - tsananin rashin amfani da tuhumar "anti-tashin hankali" sau da yawa yana zuwa: Yi shuru. Kar a yi zanga-zanga. Kar ma ka yi magana.
Tabbas akwai kyamar kyamar baki a Amurka da sauran kasashen duniya, kuma ya kamata a yi Allah wadai da shi. A sa'i daya kuma, yin kukan kyarkeci - yin amfani da kalmar da ba ta dace ba don kokarin tsoratar da mutane cikin shiru yayin da Isra'ila ke ci gaba da cin zarafi a Gaza - cin zarafi ne na kalmar kyamar baki da kuma rashin amfani ga duk wanda ke son mizani guda na 'yancin ɗan adam.
Makon da ya gabata, malamai 17 da daliban limamai Ya tafi Capitol Hill tare da yin kira da a tsagaita bude wuta tare da kawo karshen taimakon da Amurka ke baiwa Isra'ila ba tare da wani sharadi ba. Rabbi Ya ya ce: “Mu malamai ne da ke wakiltar dubban daruruwan yahudawa masu alaka da kungiyar Yahudawa ta Voice for Peace Action muna rokon shugabanninmu da su kawo karshen hada baki da suke yi a yakin kisan kare dangi da sojojin Isra’ila ke yi da sunan tsit (adalci) da aminci na gaske ga dukan mutane."
Ya kamata mu yi imani cewa waɗannan malamai masu adawa da Yahudawa ne?
Marubuciyar Ba’amurke Ba’amurke Anna Baltzer ta girma tana koyo game da muguntar kyamar Yahudawa. "An kashe yawancin iyalina a cikin Holocaust," in ji ta rubuta. "Kakannina sun isa tsibirin Ellis cikin damuwa saboda kisan gilla da aka yi wa iyalansu a cikin ɗakunan gas na Auschwitz yayin da duniya ta bar shi ya faru." Kuma ta kara da cewa: "Dole ne mu gane cewa sharer da Isra'ila ke yi daga dukkan iyalai a Gaza ba ramuwar gayya ce kawai a ranar 7 ga Oktoba ba; Isra'ila na ci gaba da aiwatar da ayyukanta na korar Falasdinawa daga Falasdinu tare da rufe kofa a bayansu."
Shin kalaman Baltzer suna sa ta kyamaci?
A tsakiyar Oktoba, 43 Yahudawa marubuta, malamai da masu fasaha - ciki har da Michael Chabon, Francisco Goldman, Masha Gessen, Judith Butler, Tony Kushner, da V (wanda aka sani da Eve Ensler) bude wasika ga Shugaba Biden yana mai cewa: "Mun yi Allah wadai da hare-haren da ake kaiwa Isra'ila da Falasdinawa fararen hula. Mun yi imanin cewa abu ne mai yiyuwa kuma a hakika ya zama dole mu yi Allah wadai da ayyukan Hamas da kuma amincewa da zalunci na tarihi da ci gaba da ake yi wa Falasdinawa. Mun yi imanin cewa abu ne mai yiyuwa kuma ya zama dole mu yi Allah wadai da harin na Hamas da kuma daukar matsaya kan hukumcin gama-gari na Gazan da ke bayyana da kuma kara hanzari kamar yadda muke rubutawa."
Tare da yin Allah wadai da "laifi na yaki da ayyukan da ba za a iya karewa ba," sanarwar ta kara da cewa: "Mun rubuta don bayyana adawarmu ga abin da gwamnatin Isra'ila ke yi da taimakon Amurka."
Shin waɗannan kalmomi suna nufin cewa waɗanda suka sanya hannu a cikin maganar suna adawa da Yahudawa?
Ko yaya game da Yahudawa Yahudawa fiye da 100 da suka sanya hannu kan yarjejeniyar bayani An fitar da shi a wannan makon yana yin Allah wadai da AIPAC, zauren Isra'ila-ba-da-kuskure ba?
Shekaru goma da suka wuce, 40 da suka tsira daga Holocaust ya bayar da sanarwa La'antar Isra'ila saboda "kokarin da take yi na lalata Gaza." Sanarwar, wacce kuma mutane 287 wadanda zuriyar wadanda suka tsira daga Holocaust ne ko wadanda aka kashe suka sanya wa hannu, ta yi kira da a kawo karshen duk wani nau'in wariyar launin fata, gami da kisan kare dangi da ake yi wa al'ummar Palasdinu, ta kuma yi tir da "tsanani, nuna wariyar launin fata ga Falasdinawa a cikin al'ummar Isra'ila." wanda ya kai ga zazzabi”.
Shin Yahudawa 327 da suka sanya hannu kan maganar gaba da Yahudawa ne?
Don haka, lokacin da na rubuta a nan cewa gwamnatin Isra'ila tana ta yin kisan gilla da kisan kiyashi a Gaza, hakan yana nufin ina kyamar Yahudawa?
Akwai wata kalma don gani - da kuma faɗi - cewa Isra'ila na aikata manyan laifuka na cin zarafin bil'adama. Kuma waccan kalmar ba “antisemitism ba ce”. Gaskiya ne.
ZNetwork ana samun kuɗi ta hanyar karimcin masu karatun sa.
Bada Tallafi