Shirin Bush na yin satar bayanan jama'a na duniya ba tare da izini ba ba wai kawai lalata 'yancin jama'ar Amurka bane. Idan abin da na sani game da binciken FBI na baya da tattara fayil a kaina, yawan satar bayanan shugaba Bush ba kawai fushin tsarin mulki ba ne, har ila yau wata dabara ce don ƙarin ɓarna.

Sabuwar manufar ta ce tana da nufin 'yan kasar Amurka da ke karbar kiran waya daga kasashen waje.

Ina fata hukumomin Shugaba Bush na satar wayar jama'a don kama 'yan ta'adda ya fi abin da na sani game da satar bayanan da aka yi a baya. Mayakan mu na ta'addanci suna bukatar yin abin da ya fi darakta na FBI J. Edgar Hoover ya yi da ni. Zagin da aka yi min wauta ce kawai. Amma irin wannan hali a yau zai iya kawo munanan abubuwa a ƙasarmu. Wakilan Osama bin Laden ba ’yan barkwanci ba ne.

Unlimited, sauraran bayanan wayar da kan jama'a a kan irin wannan yaduwa yana da saurin samun kurakurai, ɓata lokaci, da ruɗani da gangan kuma mai haɗari. Abu daya shi ne, Usama da makiya masu jihadi sun san ana saurarensu kuma hakan ne ya sanya wasan na- leken asiri-ku-ku-ku-ku-ku-ku-ku-ku-ku-ku-ku-ku-ku-ku-ku-ku-ku-ku-ku-ku-ku-ku-ku-ku-ku-ku-ku-ku-ku-ku-ku-ku-ku-na-kuma-wane-fara-fara-yi?

Amma ko da tare da sa'a ga bangarenmu, tattaunawar sirri da aka tattara na irin wannan nau'in nau'in nau'in nau'in nau'in nau'in nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i nau'i). Yana lalata ɓata lokaci a cikin tattaunawa na gama gari ko mai daɗi. Yana tara ɗimbin ɗimbin kalmomin da ba a ji ba, waɗanda ke gayyatar yanke shawara na butulci ko kasala. Amma mafi muni, idan aka yi la'akari da halin ɓacin rai na Bushies na tsarin mulki da keɓantawa na sirri, suna da ra'ayin kiran marasa aminci waɗanda ba su yarda da manufofinsa ba, a buɗe don zaɓen ramuwa ga Amurkawa masu aminci waɗanda suka yi tunanin kurakuran Bush da tunanin su kansu barazana ne ga ƙasa. tsaro.

Ba a ambaci tsohuwar gogewa a cikin shari'ata ba a nan saboda sakamakon tare da ni ya girgiza ƙasa. Ba su kasance ba. Sun sami komai ba daidai ba, kuma hakan ya sa shugaban hukumar ta FBI a lokacin, J. Edgar Hoover, ya ci gaba da farautar kasar baki daya domin ya samu kazanta. A wurina, wauta ce kawai. Amma ya fallasa yadda manyan sauraran bayanan ke da alaƙa da mummunan rahoton tattaunawa da kuma raunin mutanen Bush ga maganar banza. Ahmad Chalabi, kwararre na Iraqi yana tabbatar wa Bush cewa lokacin da sojojin suka mamaye Iraki za su gai da wardi. Wasu wardi.

Kuma ziyarar da Mataimakin Shugaban Cheney ya yi a hedkwatar CIA a fili don tausa rahotannin sirri don tabbatar da mamayewar. Wardi na Chalabi da gurbatattun bayanan sirri sun haifar da mummunan sakamako ga Amurka. Ba wai kawai ya jawo asarar rayukan sojojin mu da kuma gurgunta hasarar rayuka ba, kashewa da raunata dubban mata da yara na Iraqi marasa laifi a cikin wannan kalmar batanci, "lalacewar hadin gwiwa." Amma ya bar Iraki, ba tare da wardi ba, amma yakin basasa mara iyaka.

Kwarewata ta kasance shekaru da yawa da suka gabata, tun kafin 9/11. Kuma aikin da aka yi mini ya kasance mai sauƙi-ko da yake tabbas ya jawo wa masu biyan haraji wasu kuɗi na gaske. Gaskiya ne, J. Edgar Hoover baƙon mutum ne wanda sau da yawa yana daraja talla fiye da ƙwazo. Amma, da aka ba da kurakurai tare da hukumomin yanzu don kama gargaɗin kafin 9/11, Fadar White House ta bar duk Saudis a Amurka su koma gida bayan 9/11, da ƙa'idodin Shugaba Bush kan ingantaccen aikin hukuma, kamar yadda a cikin kasawa mai ban tausayi a cikin bala'in New Orleans -“Brownie, kuna yin aiki mai wuyar gaske”—Ban tabbata cewa mun koyi abubuwa da yawa tun lokacin da Hoover ya damu da rashin hankali.

Kwarewata ita ce lokacin ɓarna na Gwamnatin Nixon, snooping, da kiyaye jerin maƙiyan siyasa. Nixon mutum ne mai hazaka mai fa'ida da rashin jin daɗi. Ni Mataimakin Manajan Editan Labaran Kasa ne a Washington Post, wata jarida wacce Nixon ke da ƙiyayya da ƙiyayya (yawancin masu ra'ayin mazan jiya ba sa son takardar a lokacin, amma yawancinsu 'yan mazan jiya ne waɗanda ke tunanin kawai labarin da ya dace shine ra'ayin mazan jiya. ).

Fadar White House Nixonites sun bambanta. Nixon yana jin daɗin rayuwa cewa ba a taɓa yarda da shi da gaske daga manyan mutane ba (kuma, hakika, lokacin da yake Mataimakin Shugaban ƙasa na Eisenhower, wakilan Washington sun lura cewa Ike bai taɓa jin daɗin Mataimakinsa ba). Bayan haka, manyan hadiman Nixon guda biyu, Ehrlichman da Haldeman, sun kasance mazan PR kuma lokacin da suka yi kuka da ni da sauran mutane, ya bayyana a fili cewa duk wani labari da ya tashi daga kyakkyawar dangantakar jama'a na haɓaka maigidan nasu an yanke hukunci - gafarta furcin - " son zuciya mai sassaucin ra'ayi."

Sanin sau nawa na sami korafe-korafe daga Fadar White House lokacin da ma'aikatan Post na kasa suka gano cewa Nixon ya kiyaye "jerin abokan gaba" da ke dauke da sunayen wakilan Washington, na yi sha'awar ganin matsayina na gwamnati. Amfani da Dokar 'Yancin Bayanai, na nemi kuma na karɓi fayil na FBI. Kamar yawancin fayilolin sirri da aka saki, nawa suna da jimloli da sakin layi gabaɗaya. Ina zargin cewa idan wata uwargida daga Kananan Sisters na Talakawa ta nemi nata, za ta sami wasu fasikanci a cikin rahotonta, ita ma, ("'Yar'uwa Clare ta yi mumbled da matins da wayewar gari"). Kasancewar kalmomi da jumlolin da aka tantance kawai suna nuna iko mai ƙarfi ta mai amfani da alƙalamin baƙar fata, da kuma ɓoyayyen tushe.

Ni ba Karamar Yar'uwar Talaka bace. Na kasance mai ba da rahoto kuma wakilin Washington da edita tsawon shekaru, wanda ke nufin ba da rahoto game da siyasa, da dai sauransu. Na rufe mutane da abubuwan da suka faru iri-iri kuma fayil na ya haɗa da yawancinsu, wanda FBI ta rufe. Amma abin da ba a baki ba da farko ya sa na yi dariya da babbar murya. Amma na daina samun abin ban dariya lokacin da na fahimci hauka da kurakurai masu kama da gaske a cikin fayilolina. Idan sun kasance irin na ’yan leƙen asiri-- “masu zagon ƙasa” shine kalmar fasaha a lokacin — na ji tsoron tsaron ƙasar.

Much of the report had to have come from reports of conversations at dinner parties where some of my conversation clearly was sent to the local agents. That in itself was unsettling. Could some social friends be false friends, or invited dinner guests made paranoid by the national witchhunts?. In my FOIA report, one volunteer FBI informant told the agency that I was “obsessed” with civil liberties and “was believed to belong to the American Civil Liberties Union.” That, at least, was true. I had done reporting on incidents of racial prejudice, cross-burnings and the like. And as long as I can remember I have been —- as George Bush’s father on television with a look of incredulous horror accused his opponent for the presidency, Michael Dukakis, of being – pause for emphasis – “a card-carrying member of the American Civil Liberties Union!”

Sai dai idan aka kwatanta Bush 41 ya fi ɗansa hikima.

Har yanzu ni memba ne mai ɗauke da kati na ACLU (Ba na ɗauke da shi a zahiri, amma ina da katin zama na yanzu a wani wuri). wata kungiya, ita ce sabanin abin da na fada.

Wani bangare na fayil din ya ce a wasu liyafar cin abinci wadanda ba a bayyana sunayensu ba (ba a bayyana sunayensu ba) sun ba da rahoton cewa "Na yi matukar kare wa Turkawa Ottoman a kisan kiyashin da suka yi wa Armeniyawa."

Hakan ya jefa ni.

Anan, Ina buƙatar saka wasu tarihin sirri. An haife ni a Anatolia, Turkiyya, inda mahaifina farfesa ne a kwalejin Amurka. Uwa ta. An haifi wani mawaki, da ƴan uwa mata huɗu kuma a ƙasar Turkiyya. Ni ma a can aka haife ni, amma a lokacin kisan kiyashin da Turkawa suka yi wa Armeniyawa ne, kuma lokacin da nake dan kwana 11, dangin sun gudu daga kisan kiyashin da aka yi a kan dusar ƙanƙara. Wannan lamari ne da aka kwatanta a wurare da dama, ciki har da rahotannin jakadan Amurka a Turkiyya Hans Morgenthau Jr. (da kuma a cikin tarihina na Double Vision).

Dubban mutane sun daskare har suka mutu a wannan ƙaura. A wani lokaci, mahaifina, yana ɗauke da ni da bargo a hannunsa sa’ad da yake gudu da baya yana tara ’yan’uwana mata. A wani lokaci, ya yi ƙoƙari ya tayar da ni, ban amsa ba, ya ɗauka cewa na yi sanyi na mutu. Amma ba lokaci ya yi da za a ɓata wa dangin da ke fama da wannan labari ba. Mahaifiyata tana kan dokinta, Mozart, sai ta suma, ta fara zamewa daga dokin. Mahaifina ya jefar da dam din don ya kama ta sai da daurin (ni) ya bugi kasa mai daskarewa, sai na saki kuka.

Abin al'ajabi, dukan iyalin sun tsira daga gwagwarmayar mako guda ta cikin dusar ƙanƙara da yanayin sanyi zuwa mafi kusa da layin dogo. Wasu ’yan’uwana mata biyu sun yi sanyin ƙafafu, kuma a cikin makonni biyu da saukarmu a Amirka, mahaifiyata ta kamu da cutar tarin fuka, ta yi shekara uku a ɗakin kwana, kuma ta rasu sa’ad da nake ɗan shekara uku.

Wannan shi ne abin da fayil dina na FBI yake magana akai a lokacin da ya ce na yi kakkausar suka na kare Turkiyya a kisan kiyashin da suke yi wa Armeniyawa.

Misali na ƙarshe na sirri na abin da satar saurare mara izini zai iya yi ga daidaito da kuma nuna hatsari na gaske.

Yayin da nake shugaban ofishin Ofishin Washington na Jaridar Providence da Bulletin maraice, sabon mawallafi, ya gaji ɗaya daga cikin mafi kyawun takaddun birni a cikin ƙasar. Mawallafin ya kasance mai sha'awar J. Edgar Hoover da FBI. Ya bukace ni da in yi wani dogon bayani kan jarumtakar Hoover a bikin cika shekaru 17 na Hoover da karbar ragamar hukumar FBI.

Duk wani wakilin Washington da na sani a lokacin, lokaci-lokaci yana samun buƙatun buƙatun labarai na bango daga ofishin gida kuma buƙatun nuttier duk sun tafi a cikin aljihun tebur na ƙasa da fatan za a manta da buƙatar. Draway na kasa yana da rabonsa na rashin hankali ko ƙananan buƙatun da aka karɓa kuma aka yi watsi da su kuma aka yi sa'a, yawancin an manta da su. Mai Hoover ya shiga tari a zane na kasa. Amma a wannan lokacin, mawallafin ya kasance da gaske. Editan gudanarwa na ya kira ni, ya amince da shi a asirce cewa ra'ayi ne na wauta, amma ya ce mawallafin ya zarge shi kusan kullum. "Amma menene na musamman game da bikin 17th?" ME ya ce, "Ba komai. Amma ka yi mini alheri a kan wannan.” Don haka na yi

Na yi iya ƙoƙarina don yin aiki na gaskiya. Na gano cewa Hoover a baya a cikin 1924 ya gaji hukumar da ba ta da tsari da cin hanci da rashawa kuma, a zahiri, ya yi aikin da ya dace na sake tsara hukumar ta zama mai gwagwarmayar aikata laifuka. Na kuma gano cewa yana da wawanci. Shi da babban mai taimaka masa suna zuwa tseren tseren kusa da Washington kowace rana, amma an umarci direban motarsa ​​da kada ya juya hagu. Lokacin da ake buƙatar hagu, direbansa koyaushe yakan zagaya toshe - dama-dama kuma ya fito kamar yadda hagu ɗaya zai yi. Dalili? Da zarar ya juya hagu, motarsa ​​ta Hoover ta yi karo kuma bayan haka ya hana sauran jujjuyawar hagu.

Na sanya a cikin bikin laifuffukan da hukumarsa ta warware da kuma shahararrun hoods da aka harbe. Amma na kuma sanya wani labarin da ya sanya ni abokin gaba na dindindin na babban mai binciken tarayya na kasa.

A lokacin yakin duniya na biyu na Shugaba Roosevelt ya yi amfani da FBI don binciken kasashen waje. Rashin kwarewarsu a cikin al'ummomin kasashen waje ya gamsar da FDR cewa kasar na bukatar wata hukuma da ta kware kan leken asiri da leken asiri na kasashen waje. A lokacin Yaƙin Duniya na Biyu an yi wannan ne ta ofishin ad hoc of Strategic Services (OSS) wanda wani tsohon ɗan leƙen asiri, William “Wild Bill” Donovan ke jagoranta. FDR ta nemi Donovan ya tsara wani tsari na sirri don sabis na leken asirin kasashen waje na dindindin bayan yakin.

Ya zama rahoton “Ido kawai”, ma’ana waɗanda aka zaɓa kawai – “ido kaɗai” na nufin waɗanda aka riga aka zaɓa kawai za su iya kallon sa, ba sakatarorinsu, matansu, masoyansu, ko masu ikirari su iya gani ba. An ayyana “idon” guda huɗu da aka halatta. Daya na shugaban kasa ne, daya na shugaban hukumar leken asiri a ma'aikatar tsaro, daya na J. Edgar Hoover, daya na Donovan kansa. Donovan ya yi aikinsa na gida tare da abin da zai zama CIA. Amma Donovan tsohon hannu ne a cikin tsarin mulkin gwamnati. Ya san cewa boye sirri ba wani bangare ne na al'adun kwayoyin halitta na Washington, asalin tsohuwar magana, "Jirgin ƙasa shine kawai jirgin ruwa da ke yabo daga sama."

Sanin wannan da rashin amincewa da Hoover sama da duk masu karɓa, Donovan kowane ɗayan kwafi huɗu cikin yare daban-daban. Babu wani bambance-bambancen da ya canza abu, amma kowanne yana da ƙananan bambance-bambance a tsarin jumla da alamar rubutu.

He delivered the four copies to the designated recipients. As expected, a few days later, the Chicago Tribune , a paper then an unrelenting bitter enemy of President Roosevelt, ran a Page One headline declaring that FDR planned his private own network to spy on Americans. It quoted Donovan’s the secret plan verbatim. It was the language of J. Edgar Hoover’s copy. I put that in my paper’s requested profile of Hoover. Later, when out of general curiosity, I asked for my FBI file, it included a reproduction of my story describing Donovan’s trick that embarrassed Hoover. On the margin of that paragraph of my story, presumably in Hoover’s own hand, was a written notation, “Never give this man anything – H.” (The FBI liked publicity and often tried to be useful to reporters.) In addition, he had asked every FBI bureau in the country to look at files in their local police for any information about me, especially any arrests or embarrassing items. The dragnet seemed to come up empty. That made me feel as though I was living too orderly a life. When I finished reading my file, I was struck by two things. They spent a lot of my tax dollars for this idiocy. But more important, with all their information gathering power and a full national search, the Federal Bureau of Investigation got so much that was precisely the opposite of what was said. What if it was not a reverse of my conversation but the reverse of a transatlantic call on something of genuine importance to the security of the country?

A yau, tare da ɗimbin kiran wayar da aka ji daga ƙasashen waje, duk an katse su tare da bincika mahimman kalmomi waɗanda za su iya bayyana shirye-shiryen ta'addanci, menene idan kurakurai irin waɗanda ke cikin mafi sauƙi na ya faru? Zai iya haifar da sakamako mai zurfi.

Kamar mil na kaset na tsohuwar kaset na latsa wayar FBI a asirce, kawai amfani da shi shine tsefe shi don abin da ake la'akari da mahimman kalmomi. A yau, 'yan ta'adda na iya yin rikodin mafi yawan adadin waya da sauran hanyoyin sadarwa, kuma babu makawa za su tsara kwamfutocin su don tsayawa kawai lokacin da suka gano wata kalma mai mahimmanci a cikin sadarwar 'yan ta'adda. Wasu mahimman kalmomi a bayyane suke.

Osama bin Laden. Jihadi. Abun fashewa. Golden Gate Bridge. Chicago Tower. Amma akwai wanda ya samar da kwamfuta mara kuskure?

Shin ma'amala ta yau da kullun kan adadin ruwan inabi nawa daga vintner a Tuscany, Italiya zuwa dillali a birnin New York suna da ɗaya daga cikin jam'iyyun, watakila tare da lafazin, faɗi "lissafin ɗaukar kaya" kuma mai saurara ya ɗauke shi a matsayin "bin" Ladan.?"

Ko kuma wayar da wata malamar aji hudu a Moscow, Idaho ta yi da kanwarta mai horar da doki a Palestine, Texas tana tambayar yaya Balarabenta mai tsarki? Mahimman kalmomi: Moscow, Palestine, Larabawa. Aha!

Sabon littafin Ben Bagdikian shine Sabon Kafofin watsa labarai Monopoly. Z's Future