Umthombo: Counterpunch
Engxenyeni ecasulayo ngeRussiagate, owayengumhlaziyi weCIA uRay McGovern usanda kukhumbula isitatimende esenziwa ngo-1981 nguMqondisi weCIA ngaleso sikhathi uWilliam Casey ngesikhathi somhlangano wokuqala weKhabhinethi likaMongameli uRonald Reagan. U-Casey utshele lo mbuthano, "Sizokwazi ukuthi uhlelo lwethu lwe-disinformation luphelile uma yonke into umphakathi waseMelika ekholelwa kuyo ingamanga." [1]
Isitatimende esishaqisayo esingase sibe usizo ukukhunjulwa njengoba imicimbi iqhubeka yenzeka ezinyangeni ezimbalwa ezizayo. U-Casey, vele, wayengeke abe nayo indlela yokwazi ngo-1981 ukuthi “uhlelo lwakhe lokubulala amagciwane” lwaluzonwebeka kangakanani.
Ukuphakama kweRussiagate
URay McGovern uphinde wabhidliza ngempumelelo (njengoba enze kaningi eminyakeni emithathu edlule) izisetshenziswa ezintekenteke ezibambe iRussiagate, ikakhulukazi “i-Intelligence Community Assessment” (ICA) elungiswe ngoJanuwari 2017 “ngabahlaziyi abakhethwe ngesandla” abavela ku-FBI, CIA kanye I-NSA (hhayi izikhungo zezobunhloli eziyi-17, njengoba kwafunwa uMqondisi Wezobunhloli Kazwelonke u-James Clapper kanye noMqondisi we-CIA uJohn Brennan).
UMcGovern uyabhala: “Mayelana ne-'Intelligence Community Assessment,' isihloko sesibhengezo esiphezulu se-New York Times ngo-Jan. 7, 2017 sabeka ithoni yeminyaka embalwa elandelayo: 'I-Putin Led Scheme to Aid Trump, kusho umbiko.' Ngesikhathi ngisebenza njengomhlaziyi we-CIA, njengesekela lesikhulu sezobunhloli kuzwelonke engusihlalo we-National Intelligence Estimates (NIEs), futhi ngisebenza ku-Intelligence Production Review Board, ngangingakaze ngibone uhlaziyo olungamanga olungako njenge-ICA. Nabo ababhali babonakala bebambe amakhala. Babone kufanele ukuthi bashumeke ku-ICA ngokwayo leli phuzu elihlanganisa i-derriere: 'Ukuthembela okuphezulu ekwahluleleni akusho ukuthi ukuhlaziya kuyiqiniso noma kuyiqiniso; izahlulelo ezinjalo zingase zibe zimbi." [2]
Kodwa lelo “nothi lokumboza i-derriere” alizange livimbe abezindaba abajwayelekile ukuthi baqhubekisele phambili i-Russiagate eminyakeni emithathu ezayo bangena embonini ezimele eyasinda embikweni kaMeluleki Okhethekile u-Robert Mueller (ongazange athole ukuhlangana kukaTrump-Russia), futhi kungenzeka asinde ekukhishweni kwakamuva kombiko woMnyango Wezobulungiswa Umhloli Jikelele uMichael Horowtiz mayelana nobunhloli be-FBI 2016.
Umbiko weHorowitz
Njengoba uMat Taibbi we-Rolling Stone ekubeka (Dec. 10, 2019), umbiko we-Horowtiz ukhombisa ukuthi "iminyaka yezihloko eziphefumulayo yayingalungile" mayelana neRussiagate, nombiko wembula "indaba emayelana nobuntatheli obubi obugcwele ubuntatheli obubi, obulinganiselwe engxenyeni yesithathu. ungqimba lokubika okungalungile….Nkulunkulu oNgcwele, yeka indlela uphenyo lukaTrump-Russia olwaluyinhlekisa ngayo.” [3]
UGlenn Greenwald we-The Intercept (Disemba 12. 2019) ucophelela kakhulu ekuhlaziyeni kwakhe umbiko we-IG, okhombisa "ukusebenzisa kabi amandla ayo kwe-FBI," "inkohliso yayo" lapho "ikhohlisa imibhalo, yafihla ukukhulula okubalulekile ubufakazi, futhi yaveza lokho ekwaziyo ukuthi ayinakwethenjelwa uma kungewona amanga asobala.” Ngenxa yalokho, “iminyaka eminingi yezimangalo ezinkulu nokulandisa okuvela kwabezindaba zase-United States kwaba ukukhwabanisa okukhulu.” [4]
Uphinde agcizelele “inkambiso eyingozi kakhulu yemithombo yezindaba hhayi nje ukuphinda iphutha leMpi yase-Iraq ngokuncika ngokuphuphutheka ezicelweni zamanxusa ombuso wezokuphepha kodwa, okubi kakhulu, manje sebebaqasha ezindlini zabo zezindaba ukuze bahlele izindaba... cishe akunakwenzeka ukuba vula i-MSNBC noma i-CNN ngaphandle kokushaywa ngoJenene, izisebenzi zeCIA, ama-FBI agents kanye nezikhulu ze-NSA manje ezisebenzela lawo manethiwekhi njengabahlaziyi futhi, ngokwandayo, njengezintatheli.” [5]
UGreenwald ubiza izikhungo zezokuphepha zaseMelika ngokuthi “azilawuleki, cishe amaqembu angenamkhawulo wamaphoyisa aqamba amanga, asebenzisa kabi amandla azo obunhloli nawokugcina umthetho, futhi edicilela phansi intando yeningi nenkululeko yomphakathi neyezombangazwe njengoba kunjalo.”
Kodwa isici esiyinhloko kulesi simo ukushaywa indiva.
I-US Intelligence "Outsourcing"
Ngokungangabazeki, lokhu esikubonayo kuwumphumela weminyaka ecishe ibe ngu-20 yokwenziwa kwangasese kwezinhlangano zezobunhloli zase-US, ezaqala ngasekupheleni kwawo-1990 futhi zanda ngaphansi kwesekela likamongameli wase-US u-Dick Cheney, owasebenzisa imicimbi ye-9/11 ukuze aqhubekisele phambili ubuhlakani obungaphandle kwabazimele. umkhakha ngaphansi kwe-War on Terror.
Umbiko wango-2011 obizwa ngokuthi “The Future of US Intelligence Outsourcing,” owashicilelwa yiBrown Journal of World Affairs, waphawula ukuthi ngo-2006 kwakunabasebenzi abangaba ngu-265,000 basembonini ezimele yase-US abenza umsebenzi wezobunhloli onenkontileka, uma kuqhathaniswa nabasebenzi bakahulumeni ababalelwa ku-100,000 emphakathini wezobunhloli. – ukubedlula ngezinombolo cishe ngo-3 kuye ku-1 (futhi lokho kwakuyiminyaka eyi-13 edlule). [6]
Okukhathaza nakakhulu, “Osonkontileka abakhulu bezobunhloli nabahlinzeki bezisebenzi zenkontileka ngokuyinhloko yizinkampani ezinkulu ezigxile kakhulu ebhizinisini lezokuvikela nezokuphepha kuzwelonke, njengoLockheed Martin, Northrop Grumman, Raytheon, Boeing, Science Applications International Corporation (SAIC) kanye noBooze Allen. Hamilton, phakathi kwabanye. " [7]
Umbhali walo mbiko, u-Armin Krishnan, uphinde waphawula (ngaphandle kokubhuqa) ukuthi ezobunhloli ezizimele “zinomkhuba wokweqisa kakhulu izinsongo zokuvikeleka kwezwe ukuze kugcinwe isidingo semikhiqizo namasevisi ahlobene nezokuphepha kazwelonke…Akunangqondo neze ukulindela izinto ezizimele. izinkampani ukuthi zibeke izithakazelo zomphakathi ngaphambi kwebhizinisi labo elizimele.” [8]
Labo sonkontileka abazimele bangasiza ngempela ukunquma ukuthi ubani “isitha”. Umbhali uyaphawula, “Osonkontileka babamba iqhaza elikhulu ekwakhiweni kwemikhiqizo yezobunhloli enegunya kunawo wonke, njenge-President’s Daily Brief, futhi ngaleyo ndlela bangathonya inqubomgomo yezangaphandle yase-US ezingeni eliphezulu kakhulu.” [9]
Ngokusobala, kunesidingo esibalulekile sokwaziswa okuthuthukisiwe, kodwa okwamanje noma nini lapho abezindaba abavamile (kanye neminye imithombo yezindaba) bencoma “izisebenzi zikahulumeni ezisebenza emphakathini wezobunhloli,” kubalulekile ukukhumbula ukuthi ngisho ne-CIA kade yaba khona. ngaphezu kwamaphesenti angu-50 enziwe ezizimele, nama-titans emishini yempi afana no-Lockheed Martin no-Raytheon ababiza isibhamu.
Imibhalo yaphansi:
[1] Ray McGovern, “Izingibe Ze-Pit Bull Russophobe,” Consortium News, Novemba 22, 2019.
[2] Ibid.
[I-3] UMat Taibbi, "Umbiko weHorowitz Wembula I-Steele Dossier Yayihlala Iyihlaya," uRolling Stone, ngoDisemba 10, 2019.
[4] U-Glenn Greenwald “Umbiko Womhloli Jikelele Wokuhlola I-FBI ka-2016 Wembula Ihlazo Lobukhulu Bomlando: Hhayi Owe-FBI Kuphela Kodwa Futhi Nama-US Media,” I-Intercept, Disemba 12, 2019.
[5] Ibid.
[6] U-Armin Krishnan, “Ikusasa Le-US Intelligence Outsourcing,” I-Brown Journal of World Affairs, Fall/Winter 2011: Volume XVIII, Issue 1.
[7] Ibid.
[8] Ibid.
[9] Ibid.
I-ZNetwork ixhaswa kuphela ngokuphana kwabafundi bayo.
Nikela