IFederal Bureau of Investigation imemezele ngoMsombuluko ukuthi isoftware yayo ehlonza ubuso, iNext Generation Identification (NGI), โisebenza ngokugcwele,โ iqinisa ukwethulwa kohlelo izinhlangano ezilwela amalungelo omphakathi ezixwayisa ngokuthi zingase zibe sengozini yokuguqula izakhamizi ezingenacala zibe abasolwa ngobugebengu.
"Isevisi ye-IPS yokuqaphela ubuso izohlinzeka umphakathi womthetho wezwe lonke ithuluzi lophenyo elihlinzeka ngamakhono okusesha izithombe ezihambisana nemininingwane yobugebengu," kusho ihhovisi. isitatimende sephephandaba. "Lo mzamo uyigxathu elibalulekile eliya phambili emphakathini wezobulungiswa bobugebengu ekusebenziseni i-biometrics njengokwenza uphenyo."
I-NGI ekuqaleni yathuthukiswa ukuze yandise amakhono okuhlonza i-biometric ye-FBI, kodwa ekugcineni izothatha indawo yohlelo lwamanje lokunyathelisa iminwe lwe-bureau. Isizindalwazi salolu hlelo sinamarekhodi angawodwana angaphezu kwezigidi eziyi-100 axhumanisa izigxivizo zeminwe, izithwebuli ze-iris kanye nedatha ebonwa ubuso enolwazi lomuntu siqu, isimo somthetho, amakheli asekhaya, neminye imininingwane yangasese, futhi uzothola izithombe eziqashelwa ubuso eziyizigidi ezingu-52 ngo-2015. Umuntu oyedwa angakwazi ixhunywe ezithombeni eziningi, okuhlanganisa nalezo ezivela kumarekhodi okuqashwa, izithombe ze-DMV, kanye nesizindalwazi sokuhlola ingemuva.
Amalungelo omphakathi kanye nabaqaphi bemfihlo balugxekile uhlelo ngamasu alo ahlaselayoโfuthi anganembileโ. Lolu hlelo, utshalomali lwebhiliyoni obelulokhu luthuthukiswa no-Lockheed Martin iminyaka emithathu, lwatholakala luhlonza umuntu ongalungile ngamaphesenti angama-20 esikhathi, izibalo ezikhula ngokuhamba kwesikhathi futhi njengoba isizindalwazi sikhula, i-Electronic Frontier Foundation. Wathola. Omunye umbiko otholwe yi-Electronic Privacy Information Centre (EPIC) uthole ukuthi uhlelo lune Izinga lempumelelo elingamaphesenti angu-85 lapho ukusesha kwenziwa phakathi kwezithombe ezicacile, ezibheke phambili ngaphandle kwezithiyo.
Ngokuhlanganisa izithombe ze-DMV nezithombe ze-DMV kudathabhesi efanayo, i-bureau ibeka engcupheni yokuhlonza izakhamizi ezingenawo amarekhodi njengabasolwa abangaba izigebengu, kusho i-EFF, yengeza, "Lena akuyona indlela uhlelo lwethu lwezobulungiswa olwaklanywa ngayo futhi akufanele kube uhlelo abantu baseMelika abaluvuma buthule. ukuqhubekela phambili.โ
USen. Al Franken (D-Minnesota), owayengusihlalo weSenate Subcommittee on Privacy, Technology, and the Law, engqungqutheleni kaJulayi 2012 yokulalela uhlelo lokubona ubuso ukuthi โkungahlukunyezwa ukuze kungagcini ngokukhomba ababhikishi kwezombusazwe. imicimbi kanye nemibuthano, kodwa ukuze iqondiswe ekuboshweni okukhethekile kanye nokushushiswa. "
"Ukuqoqwa kwedatha nokwabelana kungaba kuhle ekuxazululeni ubugebengu ezindaweni noma emingceleni, kodwa futhi kungaqhubeza ukuhlonishwa kwezinhlanga nobuhlanga, ukucwaswa emphakathini, nokungalungi kuzo zonke izinhlelo futhi kungavumela ukulandelwa nokubhekwa kukahulumeni ezingeni elingakaze libe khona ngaphambili," i-EFF. wathi ku Incwadi (pdf) kuMmeli Jikelele u-Eric Holder.
I-FBI yazivikela ngokuthi i-NGI, esetshenziswa yiziphathimandla zezomthetho ezweni lonke, yayingahloselwe ukunikeza ulwazi olunembile, kodwa kunalokho ukubuyisela uhlu lwalabo "abazokhethwa".
"Uhlu lwabantu abazongenela ukhetho lungobaphenyi hhayi omazisi," ihhovisi litshele i-EFF, likhala ngokuthi ngenxa yokuthi lolu hlelo alukhethi muntu, "ayikho isibalo esingalungile."
UJeramie Scott, uMeluleki Wezokuphepha Kazwelonke kwa-EPIC, utshele Amaphupho ajwayelekile ukuthi i-FBI "yaphinde yaqhubekela phambili ngobuchwepheshe bokuqapha obuhlaselayo ngaphandle kokubhekana ngokugcwele nezingozi zobumfihlo."
"Ukuqashelwa kobuso, okuvumela ukuhlonzwa kwabantu ngaphandle kwemvume, kunemiphumela efinyelela kude ekuyimfihlo yomuntu siqu futhi kuveza engcupheni yangempela yokubhekwa abantu abaningi," kusho uScott. โUMthetho We-E-Government ka-2002 udinga ukuhlolwa kobumfihlo bobuchwepheshe obuqoqa imininingwane yomuntu, futhi eminyakeni emibili edlule i-FBI yazibophezela ekuhloleni ubumfihlo bokusebenzisa kwayo ubuchwepheshe bokubona ubuso. I-FBI kufanele imise ukusetshenziswa kokuqashelwa kobuso kuze kube yilapho i-ejensi ilandela ukuzibophezela kwayo ekuhloleni nasekunciphiseni ubungozi bobumfihlo obuhlobene nokuqashelwa kobuso.โ
Abaqaphi bobumfihlo baphinde bazwakalisa ukukhathazeka ngezici ngazinye zohlelo lwe-NGI, njengesevisi ye-Rap Back, i-EPIC ethi "ilingana nokuhlolwa kwengemuva okuqhubekayo, okuqhubekayo."
"Akusetshenziselwa ukuqapha kuphela ukuthi abantu abangaphansi kokuqondisa kwezigwegwe bayaboshwa futhi, kodwa ukuqapha njalo izakhamuzi ezikhundleni ezethembekile (isb. othisha noma ababalisi basebhange)," kubhala i-EPIC iposi blog. "Izakhamuzi ezingaphansi kokuqashwa kwe-Rap Back kumele zithumele izigxivizo zeminwe kanye nezithombe ezingase zibe khona njengoba i-NGI manje isivumela ukuhanjiswa kwezithombe ekungeneni kwezakhamuzi."
Okwamanje ayikho imithetho yenhlangano ekhawulela ukusetshenziswa kwesofthiwe yokuqaphela ubuso.