Inkupho yangoku yeli phephancwadi (ngoMatshi/Aprili 2007) inenqaku elinamaphepha amane lentatheli yaseVancouver uJared Ferrie, elinomxholo othi โUkuhlala kwikhosi: kutheni iCanada ingakwazi ukukhupha imikhosi yayo e-Afghanistan."
Ngelixa umbhali eneneni ezama ukurhoxisa iifowuni zokurhoxa e-Afghanistan, isihloko siyinto engafanelekanga. UFerrie wabela isithuba sokugxeka urhulumente waseHarper kunye nokukhuthaza inguqulelo eguqulwe kancinane yomgaqo-nkqubo wenkokeli yeqela leLiberal uStephane Dion ngeAfghanistan. Koku kulandelayo, siza kujonga ngokufutshane kwiimbono zakhe ngorhulumente kunye neqela elichasayo elisemthethweni, emva koko sijonge inkcazo kaFerrie yokuba malunga nesiqingatha sabemi baseKhanada siyawuxhasa โumgaqo-nkqubo onokukhokelela ekubandezelekeni kwezigidi zabantu base-Afghan.โ
Harper, Dion kunye neziyobisi
Inkcaso ephambili kaFerrie kumgaqo-nkqubo wangoku wase-Afghanistan karhulumente wase-Afghanistan igxile kwiinzame zobudlelwane obuphantsi bukarhulumente. Apha, uphinda iinkxalabo zeenkokeli ezininzi zezimvo ezivakalelwa kukuba ukunqongophala koluntu lwaseCanada kwimishini yase-Afghan sisiphumo sendlela yeTories 'ham-fisted approach yokuthengisa imfazwe kuluntu. KuFerrie, oku kuboniswa kakuhle kukwala komphathiswa wezoKhuselo u-O'Connor ukuvuma ukuwohloka kweemeko zokhuseleko e-Afghanistan kunye nesimo sengqondo sehagu se-Conservative caucus kubungqina bengcali obunikwe ngumongameli weBhunga le-Senlis uNorine MacDonald.
NgokukaSenlis, itanki yokucinga ekhokelayo kumgaqo-nkqubo weziyobisi, uluntu lwamazwe ngamazwe kufuneka luseke ishishini le-opium elisemthethweni e-Afghanistan, elijolise ekuboneleleni ngeenarcotics ezifuneka kakhulu kwimarike yehlabathi. Ngelixa uFerrie ephinda iingxoxo zikaSenlis exhasa lo mgaqo-nkqubo, akanikezi mbono malunga nendlela olu tshintsho lomgaqo-nkqubo olunokwenziwa ngayo. Kuba inyani enzima yeyokuba ngobunkokeli baseMelika kwimishini yase-Afghan, amathuba omgaqo-nkqubo weziyobisi okhanyiselweyo obonakala ubhityile kakhulu. UFerrie ubayekela phantsi abafundi bakhe xa esilela ukuphonononga iziphumo zalo mba โwokuhlala ekhosiniโ.
Ngendlela efanayo, uFerrie uyaqhubeka nokulwela indlela yenkokeli yeLiberal uStephane Dion. Ubhengezo lukaDion lwesicwangciso esitsha seMarshall sase-Afghanistan sinomtsalane kangangokuba uFerrie ubongoza abaphembeleli abachasene nemfazwe ukuba balibale indawo yabo "yemikhosi" kwaye batsibe kwi-bandwagon yeLiberal kwaye bafune ukuba kusetyenziswe izixa ezikhulu kwiinkqubo zoncedo kunye nokwakhiwa kwakhona kwe-Afghanistan.
Ngelixa uluvo malunga noncedo oluninzi lwangaphandle ngokungathandabuzekiyo luncomeka, iFerrie ithatha inyathelo layo nayiphi na ingxoxo yokuba nokwenzeka kwenkqubo enjalo, njengoko iinkqubo zokwakhiwa ngokutsha kunye noncedo e-Afghanistan zijongene nemiqobo emikhulu. Ngaphandle kokungabikho okuxoxwe ngokubanzi koncedo olukhokelwa yi-NGO e-Afghanistan, iinzame zaseNtshona zokuvuselela i-Afghanistan zibuyiswe burhwaphilizo oluxhaphakileyo. Ngokutsho kweSunday Telegraph "Amagosa oKhuselo e-United States naseBritani aqikelela ukuba ukuya kuthi ga kwisiqingatha salo lonke uncedo e-Afghanistan ayasilela ukufikelela kubantu abafanelekileyo." Abenzi bobubi baquka amagosa karhulumente abonakeleyo, amapolisa kunye nabezenkolo, ngokwenqaku (Jan 28/07). Ezinye iingxelo zibonisa ukuba phantse zonke iimali zokwakha ngokutsha zichithwa kwiiprojekthi ezisezidolophini okanye ezikufutshane. Ukuthathela ingqalelo ukuba abantu base-Afghanistan bahlala emaphandleni kakhulu, oku kubangela ingxaki eyoyikisayo ekhoyo kwiminqweno efana nekaFerrie.
Peaceniks phantsi komlilo
Mhlawumbi akulunganga ukuphonononga ngokugqithisileyo iimbono zikaFerrie malunga namaqela amabini aphambili ezopolitiko, njengoko impatho yakhe kwizikhundla nezenzo zawo iyinto engathi shu. Uninzi lomsindo wakhe lugcinelwe abo bafuna ukuba kurhoxiswe imikhosi yaseCanada eAfghanistan. Ngokwenza njalo, uFerrie usebenzisa ngokukholelekayo izibhengezo zamagosa karhulumente waseKarzai, exutywe nokungasetyenziswa kakuhle kobungqina, iingxoxo ezingaxhaswayo, kunye nokusetyenziswa okuninzi kwenkohliso ngelinge lokunyelisa abo angavumelaniyo nabo. Kungaphaya kwemida yesi sincoko ukulandela uFerrie ekusebenziseni ukugqwetheka kunye ne-innuendo, nangona abafundi bekhuthazwa ukuba babhalele abahleli beli phephancwadi ukuze baqhubele phambili lo mbandela kunye nabo.
ngokweentloko
Izityholo zikaFerrie zasekhohlo zixhomekeke kakhulu kwiinyaniso ezininzi ezithathwe kuvoto lwezimvo ezimbini. Kodwa ukuphononongwa ngokusondeleyo kolu lonyulo lubonisa ukuba uFerrie ungoyena ukwimeko entle ekujongeni iinyani zakhe. Xa ecaphula i-poll eyenzelwe i-CanWest Media yi-Innovative Research Group, efumanise ukuba i-58% yabantu baseCanada bayayixhasa injongo yethu e-Afghanistan, uFerrie uyasilela ukukhankanya ukuba ukuvota okubuzwayo yi-poll ye-intanethi. Ngokuqinisekileyo, ucalucalulo olwaziwayo olukhoyo kuvoto lokuzikhethela olunjalo lubenza bangabi namsebenzi ngaphandle kweengcamango.
Xa ecaphula uvoto olukwi-intanethi, uFerrie uyakwazi ukubaleka nakuphi na ukukhankanywa konyulo oluyilwe ngcono olufana nolukhutshwe ngo-Okthobha nguMcebisi weQhinga ofumanise ukuba "iipesenti ezingama-62 zabantu baseCanada kunye neepesenti ezingama-70 eQuebecers bafuna ukuxoxisana kunye neTaliban" (Toronto Star, Oct 20/06). I-poll efanayo yayine-54% yabaphenduli abaxhasa ukuhoxiswa kwemikhosi yaseCanada e-Afghanistan (i-Globe & Mail, Oct 19/06). Olunye uvoto lubuyise iziphumo ezifanayo.
UFerrie wenza i-gaffe exela ngakumbi xa ezoba kuvoto lobuso ngobuso yi-World Public Opinion eyenziwa kulo lonke elase-Afghanistan ngoNovemba ka-2006. Ucaphula idatha yokuvota amatyeli amaninzi ukuseka inkxaso yoluntu lwase-Afghan kurhulumente waseKarzai kunye noluntu ngokubanzi. isikhokelo somgaqo-nkqubo karhulumente. Ukuba uFerrie wayeyifunde ngokusondeleyo le ngxelo ayikhankanyayo, ngewayefumene inyani ecacileyo ethi iyijongele phantsi ingxoxo yakhe. I-poll ifumanisa ukuba i-43% yabemi baseKandahar kunye nephondo laseHelmand, apho imikhosi yokulwa yaseCanada ibisebenza, bavakalelwa kukuba ukuchithwa kukaRhulumente waseTaliban "yinto embi". Ngaphaya koko, eli nani liye latsiba ukusukela kunyaka odlulileyo, xa i-13% nje yabantu base-Afghan abakummandla osemazantsi baziva ngolo hlobo. Kwakulo nyaka apho iKhanada yathatha imisebenzi yomkhosi kwimikhosi yase-US kuloo ndawo kwaye saqala ukubandakanya eKandahar. Ke emva konyaka wobukho baseKhanada, uninzi lwabantu ebekufanele ukuba silapho ukuze sibancede baqalisa ukubucaphukela ubukho bethu. Ukungahoyi oku kuguquguquka kuphantse kukhokelela kwintlekele enokuphetshwa.
Ubuzaza bokungaphumeleli kwethu bugxininiswa yinto yokuba i-poll efanayo ibonisa ukuba iTaliban idelelekile emazantsi e-Afghanistan, njengoko kunjalo kwilizwe lonke. Oku kubonakala kuxakile apho abantu bezisola ngokubhukuqwa kolawulo oluthiyileyo lweTaliban mhlawumbi isonjululwe ngokuphawulwa kumaphephandaba ase-Afghan ukuba iKhomishoni yaMalungelo oLuntu eZimeleyo yase-Afghanistan "yathi babhalise ngaphezulu kwe-600 yokwenzakala kwabantu kwimisebenzi eyenziwa yimikhosi yangaphandle kwixa elidlulileyo" (Pajhwok Afghan News, Jan 7/07).
Amalungelo abantu
Xa engaphindaphindi ngokungagxekiyo iingxelo zamagosa karhulumente wase-Afghan, uFerrie ukhankanya ngokufutshane izityholo ezinzulu ngakurhulumente waseKarzai, โngokukodwa lilungu lePalamente elinesibindi uMalalai Joya.โ Nangona kunjalo isivakalisi esilandelayo sichaza indlela "irekhodi langoku lamalungelo oluntu wase-Afghan iminyaka elula ngaphambi kwayo nayiphi na kwiminyaka engamashumi amathathu edlulileyo." Kuyaqondakala ukuba kutheni uFerrie ekuphepha ukukhankanya naziphi na iingxelo zikaJoya malunga norhulumente welizwe lakhe njengoko engathandabuzekiyo kuvavanyo lwakhe lokuba โakukho tshintsho lubalulekileyo kwingxaki yabantu base-Afghanโ okoko kwabhukuqwa ulawulo lweTaliban (Sydney Morning Herald). , Mar 8/07). Oku akufanele kusimangalise xa kujongwa amagqabantshintshi kaBarnett Rubin, igunya eliphambili laseMelika e-Afghanistan. Ngokutsho kukaRubin, injongo yeenzame zase-US e-Afghanistan "yayingekuko ukuseka ulawulo olungcono kubantu base-Afghan, kodwa ukugaya kunye nokuqinisa iimfazwe ekulweni ne-al-Qaida" (Rubin, iBhunga lezoBudlelwane bamazwe angaphandle, ngo-Aprili 2006) .
UJoya akanguye yedwa ogxeka ngokurhabaxa urhulumente waseKarzai. Ingxelo yelizwe lase-Afghanistan yeSebe lase-Afghanistan ngamaLungelo oLuntu (2005) yafumanisa ukuba "irekhodi lamalungelo oluntu e-Afghanistan lihlala lihlwempuzekile", lichaza "ukubulala ngokungekho mthethweni kunye nokungcungcuthekiswa" yimikhosi karhulumente kunye nabaphathi bemfazwe. I-UN Development Fund for Women iphawula ngokufanayo ukuba "abafazi base-Afghan baqhubeka bephakathi kwezona zinto zibi kakhulu kwihlabathi, ngokukodwa kwimilinganiselo yempilo, intlupheko, ukuvinjwa kwamalungelo kunye nokukhuselwa kobundlobongela" (UNIFEM, Aug 14 / 06). Kwaye i-Amnesty International ibika ukuba "Ubundlobongela obubhekiselele kwabasetyhini kunye namantombazana e-Afghanistan buxhaphake", ngelixa beqaphela "ukwanda okuxeliweyo kwimitshato enyanzelwayo" (AI, May 30 / 05).
Ngelixa ucalucalulo olucacileyo lukaFerrie lumvumela ukuba angazihoyi ezi ngxaki, ezinye iintatheli zaseCanada ziye zagqiba ekubeni zingaqaqambi kuvavanyo lwazo lukarhulumente waseKarzai. Umnxibelelanisi we-Canadian Press u-Les Perrault unike ingxelo kulo nyaka uphelileyo ukuba "Abasemagunyeni base-Afghan abaxhaswa ngumanyano okhokelwa yi-US, kubandakanya neCanada, basavalela abantu abakwishumi elivisayo abagwetywe ubufanasini kunye nabasetyhini abatyholwa ngokukrexeza, ukubaleka okanye ukubaleka abayeni babo" (CP, Feb 26 / 06).
Ukubuya kweTaliban
UFerrie wenza uninzi lweengcinga zokuba nakuphi na ukutsalwa okubalulekileyo kwemikhosi ye-NATO kuya kuzisa ngokukhawuleza ukubuyiselwa kolawulo lweTaliban. Nangona kunjalo ubonakala engayazi imeko esemhlabeni e-Afghanistan, njengoko inxulumene neentatheli ezininzi ezibika ngaphakathi elizweni. Kukho ubungqina obuninzi bokuba enyanisweni iTaliban ngoku ilawula iindawo ezinkulu zommandla wase-Afghan. Iimpembelelo zale nyaniso, kunye nokuqhubeka kobukho bomatshini wemfazwe we-NATO, ngokuqinisekileyo zilahlekile kwiFerrie.
Ebhala eseAfghanistan ebhalela iToronto Star, intatheli uChris Sands wathi kwintwasahlobo edluleyo โabavukeli baseAfghanistan baya kulawula umhlaba. Isiseko sabo samandla siye sasasazeka ukusuka kumaphondo aseKandahar naseHelmand - apho amabutho aseBritani naseKhanada alwela ukuwacinezela - ukubandakanya iindawo ezininzi zasemaphandleni ezantsi kweKabul "(Jun 2 / 06). Ngokufanayo, i-Christian Parenti ibika ukusuka kumhlaba othi "Isiqingatha se-Afghanistan siphantsi kolawulo olusebenzayo lwabavukeli" ( Truthdig, Nov 28 / 06).
Kuphela ngokutyeshela iinyani ezimbi e-Afghanistan abaxhasi bemfazwe abanjengoFerrie batyhola abanye ngokungahoyi imibuzo ebalulekileyo malunga nemfazwe. Ukanti ubungqina bubonisa ukuba sisukela imfazwe eza kusilela kwaye ngaloo ndlela songeza usizi olungathethekiyo kwilizwe elikwaziyo ukubandezeleka okukhulu.
I-ZNetwork ixhaswa ngemali kuphela ngesisa sabafundi bayo.
Nikela