Imibuzo onokuyibuza uMongameli Obama kwixesha elizayo (nakokokugqibela) umenyiwe kwenye yeenkomfa zakhe zoonondaba:
Yeyiphi eyona nto ibalulekileyo kuwe - ukutshabalalisa i-ISIS, ukubhukuqa umongameli waseSyria u-Assad, okanye amanqaku amanqaku ngokuchasene neRussia?
Ngaba ucinga ukuba ubonise abantu baseMelika ukuba u-Assad wenze okungakumbi ekuncedeni nasekuhlanguleni amaKristu kwingxabano yaseMbindi Mpuma kunayo nayiphi na enye inkokeli yendawo ukuba oku kuya kunciphisa inzondo yoluntu lwase-United States kunye neendaba eziziva kuye? Okanye ngaba uyavumelana nombono wesithethi seSebe likarhulumente owathi ngoSeptemba "Ulawulo lwe-Assad ngokunyanisekileyo luyingcambu yabo bonke ububi"?
Kutheni i-United States igcina izohlwayo zezemali ezikhubazayo kunye nokuvalwa koncedo lomkhosi eSyria, Cuba, Iran nakwamanye amazwe kodwa hayi eSaudi Arabia?
ISaudi Arabia kufuneka yenze ntoni ukuze iphulukane nenkxaso yayo eyomeleleyo yaseMelika? Ukwandisa ukungcungcuthekiswa kwayo, ukunqunyulwa iintloko, ukunqunyulwa amalungu omzimba, ukutywatyushwa, ukuxulutywa ngamatye, ukohlwaywa ngenxa yokunyelisa nowexuko, okanye ukutshata ngenkani kunye nokunye ukucinezelwa kwamabhinqa namantombazana? Ukwandisa inkxaso yayo yezemali ye-ISIS kunye namanye amaqela e-jihadist? Ukuvuma indima yayo kwi-9-11? Ukuhlasela uSirayeli?
Yintoni ekukhathazayo ngakumbi: Ibhombu yaseSaudi yabantu baseYemen okanye ibhombu yaseSyria yabantu baseSyria?
Ngaba inyani yokuba i-ISIS ayize ihlasele uSirayeli iphakamisa nawuphi na umbuzo engqondweni yakho?
Ngaba iyakukhathaza into yokuba iTurkey ibonakala izimisele ngakumbi ekuhlaseleni amaKurds namaRashiya kunokuhlasela i-ISIS? Kwaye ibonelela ngonyango kumajoni e-ISIS awenzakeleyo? Okanye ukuba i-ISIS ijongana neoyile yayo kumhlaba waseTurkey? Okanye ukuba iTurkey-ilungu le-NATO ibe yindawo ekhuselekileyo yabanqolobi abavela eLibya, Chechnya, Qatar, nakwezinye iindawo? Okanye kulo nyaka uphelileyo uSekela Mongameli uBiden wathi urhulumente waseTurkey u-Erdogan wayexhasa i-ISIS โngamakhulu ezigidi zeedola kunye namawaka eetoni zezixhoboโ?
Ukuba i-NATO yayingazange ibekho, yiyiphi ingxabano onokuyinika namhlanje ngokuthanda ukudala iziko elinjalo? Ngaphandle - njengoko abanye benokuthi - ukuba sisicakakazi esiluncedo kakhulu somgaqo-nkqubo wangaphandle wase-US kunye nokubonelela abavelisi bezixhobo baseMelika ngeetriliyoni zeedola zokuthengisa okuqinisekisiweyo.
Ngaba i-United States iceba ukukhulula nabuphi na ubungqina bayo obutyholayo ukuxhasa amabango ayo aphindaphindiweyo okuqhunyiswa kwebhombu yaseSyria kunye nemfazwe yeekhemikhali ngokuchasene nabantu baseSyria? Njengeefoto ezicacileyo okanye iividiyo ezisuka kwiikhamera zesathelayithi zaseMelika ezifumaneka kuyo yonke indawo? Okanye nabuphi na obunye ubungqina obunokuthenjwa?
Ngaba iUnited States iceba ukukhulula nabuphi na ubungqina bayo obutyholwa ukuba ixhase amabango ayo aphindaphindiweyo okuhlasela kweRussia eUkraine kulo nyaka uphelileyo? Njengeefoto ezicacileyo okanye iividiyo ezisuka kwiikhamera zesathelayithi zaseMelika ezifumaneka kuyo yonke indawo? Okanye nabuphi na obunye ubungqina obunokuthenjwa?
Ngaba unxibelelwano oluninzi phakathi korhulumente wase-Ukraine kunye neo-Nazis lunayo nayiphi na impembelelo kwinkxaso yeMelika yaseUkraine?
Ucinga ukuba bekuya kuba yintoni umphumo kwiMfazwe yesibini yeHlabathi ukuba iUnited States yayichasile ukungena kweSoviet emfazweni kuba โuStalin kufuneka ahambeโ?
Ngaba ungathanda ukuba iRussia idlale indima yomkhosi kwaphela eSyria?
Ngaba abalawuli banokubakho ngokobuqu abambalwa kwinkcaso yaseSyria โemodareyithaโ esikhe seva kakhulu ngayo kwaye ivumele abeendaba ukuba benze udliwano-ndlebe nabo?
Ngaba ukhe wacinga ngokuhlonela isithembiso sakho esithi "Akukho zibhutsi emhlabeni eSyria" ngokufuna yonke imikhosi yaseMelika ukuba inxibe iiteki?
Ungamxeleli umama ukuba ndisebenza kwiSebe likaRhulumente. Ucinga ukuba ndidlala ipiyano kwindlu yehenyukazi.
Izicatshulwa ezivela kwingxelo yemihla ngemihla yeSebe likaRhulumente, ngoNovemba 24, 2015, emva kokudutyulwa kwenqwelomoya yaseRashiya yaseTurkey, eyayiqhutywa nguMark Toner, uSekela-Somlomo:
UMBUZO: UMongameli u-Obama uthe uya kufikelela kuMongameli u-Erdogan kwiintsuku ezimbalwa ezizayo.
Mnu TONER: Ewe.
UMBUZO: Akazange akhankanye uPutin. Oko kukubeka ngokuthe ngqo kwicala laseTurkey, akunjalo?
โฆโฆโฆโฆโฆโฆโฆ
UMBUZO: Uthi iTurkey inelungelo lokuzikhusela; UMongameli Obama wathetha into enye. Uthetha ngantoni? Ngaba kukho umntu ocinga ukuba iRussia yayiza kuhlasela iTurkey?
Mnu TONER: Kwakhona, ndiyathetha, oku ku-
UMBUZO: Ngaba ucinga njalo?
MR TONER:Jonga, andifuni kusicalula esi sehlo. Ndatsho ngokucacileyo ukuba asikazazi zonke iinyani okwangoku, ngoko ke ukuba ndithethe ngokuthe ngqo malunga nokwenzekileyo kukuba โ ngokuphandle, kuya kuba kukungakhathali.
โฆโฆโฆโฆโฆโฆโฆ
UMBUZO: Nokuba uyayamkela inguqulelo yesiTurkey yokuba inqwelomoya ihambe umgama oziikhilomitha eziyi-1.3 ngaphakathi eTurkey kwaye yophule isithuba se-airspace yayo imizuzwana eyi-17 โ oko ngokutsho kweTurkey โ ucinga ukuba ukudubula inqwelomoya ibiyinto elungileyo?
Mnu TONER: Kwakhona, andizukukunika uvavanyo lwethu okwangoku. Sisaqokelela iinyani.
โฆโฆโฆโฆโฆโฆโฆ
UMBUZO: Ngo-2012, iSyria yadubula inqwelomoya yaseTurkey ekwakusithiwa yabhadula isiya kummandla wayo. Inkulumbuso u-Erdogan emva koko wathi, "Ukwaphulwa kwemida yexesha elifutshane akunakuze kube sisizathu sohlaselo." Ngeli xesha, i-NATO ivakalise ukugxeka kwayo uhlaselo lwaseSyria kunye nenkxaso emandla yeTurkey. Ngaba ubona ukungahambelani kwempendulo ye-NATO kule nto?
Mnu TONER: Ngokuphathelele ukuba uMongameli Erdogan wayenokuthini emva kweso siganeko, ndingakuthumela kuye.
โฆโฆโฆโฆโฆโฆโฆ
UMBUZO: Imikhosi yaseTurkoman eSyria ithe yababulala abaqhubi beenqwelomoya ababini baseRussia njengoko besihla ngeeparashute.
Mnu TONER: Ewe.
UMBUZO: Amabutho aseTurkoman axhaswa yiTurkey kwaye alwa noRhulumente waseSyria, ayingxenye yomkhosi wokuvukela apho. Ngaba ucinga ukuba aba bavukeli bangamajoni aphakathi eSyria?
โฆโฆโฆโฆโฆโฆโฆ
UMBUZO: Ndiyazama โ ndithetha ukuthi, ucinga ukuba wonke umntu unelungelo lokuzikhusela?
Mnu TONER: Sithethe ngokucacileyo ukuba abantu banelungelo lokuzikhusela.
UMBUZO: Kunjalo? Kubandakanya urhulumente ka-Assad?
Mnu TONER: Hayi. (1)
Ngaba bubugrogrisi okanye lunqulo? Ngaba umbuzo ubalulekile?
Ukususela kwimihla yokuqala yeMfazwe yaseMelika yoBugrogrisi, nangaphambi koko, ndakhuthaza ukubona abanqolobi njengabangaphezu nje kokungenangqondo, amageza angendawo asuka kwenye iplanethi. Andizange ndikholelwe ukuba baphenjelelwa yintiyo okanye umona wenkululeko yaseMelika okanye idemokhrasi, okanye ubutyebi baseMelika, urhulumente welizwe, okanye inkcubeko, nangona uGeorge W. Bush wayefuna ukuba siyikholelwe loo nto. Abanqolobi, ndahlala njalo, baqhutywa ngamashumi eminyaka ezinto ezimbi ezenziwa kumazwe abo ngomgaqo-nkqubo waseUnited States wezangaphandle. Akufunekanga kubekho mathandabuzo ngale nto ndiyibhalileyo, kuba kukho imizekelo emininzi yabanqolobi baseMbindi Mpuma abachaza ngokucacileyo imigaqo-nkqubo yaseMelika njengeyona nto iphambili ekukhuthazeni izenzo zabo. Kwaye kwasebenza ngokufanayo kulo lonke ihlabathi. Ngexesha leminyaka yee-1950 ukuya koo-1980 eLatin America, ukuphendula kumtya omde wongenelelo olubi lweWashington, bekukho izenzo zobugrogrisi ezingabalekiyo ngokuchasene neenjongo zozakuzo zase-US kunye nezomkhosi kunye neeofisi zemibutho yaseMelika. I-9/11 yayiyinguqulelo yehlabathi jikelele yentlekele yeSikolo samaBanga aPhakamileyo saseColumbine. Xa ungcungcuthekisa abantu ixesha elide ngokwaneleyo baya kuphindela.
Ngo-2006 u-Osama bin Laden waphefumlelwa ukuba axelele abantu baseMelika ukuba bafunde incwadi yam ethi Rogue State kuba iqulethe oku kulandelayo kunye nezinye iingcamango zam ezifanayo: โUkuba bendingumongameli, bendinokuluphelisa uhlaselo lwabanqolobi nxamnye ne-United States kwiintsuku nje ezimbalwa. Ngokusisigxina. Ndingaqale ndicele uxolo - esidlangalaleni nangokunyanisekileyo - kubo bonke abahlolokazi neenkedama, abahlwempuzekileyo nabangcungcuthekiswayo, kunye nazo zonke izigidi ezininzi zamaxhoba e-imperialism yaseMelika. "
Ngaba oku kuthetha ukuba ndixhasa i-ISIS?
Akunjalo. Ndicinga ukuba yenye yeyona ngqokelela ilizothe yabantu ekucingelwa ukuba kuyo yonke imbali. Kodwa ndiyamangaliswa kukuba kaninzi kangakanani abo babagxeka kakhulu, kwaye bexhasa intshukumo yokuboyisa, bathandabuza kakhulu ukugxeka i-ISIS njenge. zonqulo amandla; oku, ngokucacileyo, kuya kuba ngalunganga ngokwezopolitiko. Kungekudala emva kweziganeko ezimanyumnyezi zikaNovemba 13 eParis ndandibukele isitishi sikamabonwakude solwimi lwesiFrentshi. France 24, eyathi thaca ingxoxo yetafile engqukuva yokwenzeka eParis phakathi kweentlobo ezine okanye ezintlanu zeengqondi zamaFrentshi. Akukho namnye kubo owavakalisa igama elibi ngobuSilamsi; yonke yayiyinzululwazi yezentlalo, ezopolitiko, ezoqoqosho, ezengqondo, ezembali, ingcinezelo yaseNtshona, njalo njalo, njalo njalo. Ngaba akukho namnye kubo owakha weva nabaphi na abenzi bobubi okanye abaxhasi babo bekhala โAllahu Akbarโ?
Ndiye ndafunda uphononongo oluneenkcukacha lwenqaku likaThomas Piketty, umbhali ongumFrentshi we-opus enamaphepha angama-700. Inkunzi kwiNkulungwane yamashumi amabini ananye, oyena uthengisa kakhulu kumazwe ngamazwe kunyaka ophelileyo. Ngokophononongo kwi Le Monde, U-Piketty uthe ukungalingani ngumqhubi omkhulu wobugrogrisi baseMbindi Mpuma, kubandakanywa nokuhlaselwa kweParis, kwaye amazwe aseNtshona anecala elikhulu ngenxa yokungalingani. Ubunqolobi obusekelwe kukungalingani, uthi, yeyona nto ibhetele ukulwa nezoqoqosho. Akukho lizwi malunga noMuhammad ngenkulungwane yesi-7, uMthetho weSharia ngenkulungwane yama-21, okanye nantoni na phakathi. (2)
Okulandelayo, ngokuchaseneyo, siphendukela kudliwano-ndlebe kunye noMizanur Rahman, omnye wabakhuthazi beendaba zoluntu abadumileyo be-Islamic State, abo iBritane kunye ne-US bacinga ukuba ngumqeshi we-ISIS. Abasemagunyeni baseBritane babeke iliso elibukhali kwiintshukumo zakhe kwaye bayithathile incwadana yakhe yokundwendwela. Unxiba isacholo se-ankle esigunyaziswe yinkundla.
URahman waziwa ngamawaka akhe eetweets kunye neeposti zikaFacebook, kunye neentetho ezivuthayo kuYouTube, ezijolise ekukhuthazeni abantu abancinci abasesichengeni. Uthethelela ngokuphandle i-caliphate yehlabathi, ilizwe elilawulwa ngumthetho wama-Islamic sharia, athi yinkqubo ephezulu yezopolitiko, ezomthetho kunye nezoqoqosho kwidemokhrasi. Iflegi emnyama ye-Islamic State ngenye imini iya kubhabha ngaphezulu kwe-White House ugxininisa, esongeza ukuba amajoni mhlawumbi aya koyisa iWashington ngomkhosi womkhosi, kodwa uwajonge ngononophelo amazwi akhe ukunqanda ukutyholwa ngokukhuthaza ubundlobongela. Sekunjalo, uthi, ingcamango yokusasaza inkolo yobuSilamsi ngenkani ayinambeko kunamazwe aseNtshona ahlasela i-Iraq okanye i-Afghanistan ukusasaza idemokhrasi. [Ndiyazibuza ukuba ingaba ukholelwa ngokwenene na ukuba umgaqo-nkqubo wamazwe angaphandle waseNtshona unento yokwenza nokusasaza idemokhrasi.]
URahman ubize uhlaselo lwe-Islamic State kwinyanga ephelileyo eParis "sisiphumo esingenakuthintelwa" sokuthatha inxaxheba kwamaFrentshi kuhlaselo lweenqwelomoya zomanyano oluchasene nomkhosi. ide facto Ikomkhulu eRaqqa, eSyria. โAndiqondi ukuba kukho umntu ofanele ukumangaliswa koko kwenzekileyo,โ watsho. โEmfazweni, abantu bayadubulana. Ndicinga ukuba lithuba lokuba abantu baseFransi bavelane nabantu baseRaqqa, abafumana impembelelo efanayo nanini na xa behlaselwa ziinqwelomoya zaseFransi-iingxwelerha zabemi, ukothuka, uxinzelelo. Umsindo ekufuneka benawo ngakwilizwe lamaSilamsi ngoku luhlobo olufanayo lomsindo abantu base-Iraq naseSyria abavakalelwa ngayo ngakuFrance.
Uxela ukuba akukho nto imbi ukuba i-Islamic State inqumle iintatheli zaseMelika kunokuba i-United States ibulale abantu abangamaSilamsi kugwayimbo lwe-drone. โNdiyiphakamisa isharia kuba ndicinga ukuba yeyona ilungileyo,โ utshilo uRahman, owayesakuba ngumgcini zincwadi zemali kunye nomyili wewebhu, kudliwanondlebe lwaseLondon. "Ndicinga ukuba ingcono kunale nto sinayo, kwaye yintoni engalunganga ngokuyithetha loo nto?" [Akukho nto ngaphandle kokuba uyawonwabela umculo, isini, kunye notywala kwaye ufumanisa ukuthandaza izihlandlo ezihlanu ngemini kucinezela kakhulu.)
Ngo-Agasti, uRahman wamangalelwa eBritani "ngokumema inkxaso" kwi-Islamic State, kwaye ujongene neminyaka eyi-10 entolongweni ukuba ugwetyiwe. Ukhululekile ngebheyile phantsi kweemeko ezingqongqo, kubandakanywa nesongo se-ankle.
URahman wabiza izityholo ezichasene naye njengezihlekisayo kunye nentshutshiso echasene namaSilamsi. Uthe akukho nto ayenzileyo ngaphandle kokushumayela ubuhle be-Islam kwaye akazange afune nabani na ukuba ajoyine i-Islamic State okanye abongoze nabani na ukuba enze ubundlobongela.
โUbuSilamsi asiyoncwadi nje enebali elidala. Ngokwenyani yikhowudi yobomi,โ utshilo, esongeza ukuba iSilamsi sisikhokelo sayo yonke into ukusuka kucoceko lomntu ukuya kubudlelwane bamazwe ngamazwe. โAyiyonto nje intlekisa yamaxesha aphakathi.โ
URahman wabanjwa okokuqala ngoFebruwari 2002, xa wohlwaywa iipowusta ezingama-50 ngokonakalisa iipowusta zeqela lomculo wepop elalinamabhinqa anxiba kakubi, into awayeyijonga njengengafanelekanga. [Kodwa ukunyanzela abasetyhini ukuba bahambe begqubuthele ngokupheleleyo ukusuka entloko ukuya eluzwaneni, bebona ngamehlo kuphela, ngaba asikokuziintloni? Yaye ngowuphi umfazi ehlabathini lonke onokunxiba ngolo hlobo ngaphandle koxinzelelo olukhulu oluvela kuluntu olulawulwa ngamadoda?]
UPeter Neumann, intloko yeZiko laMazwe ngaMazwe leSifundo seRadicalization kwiKholeji yaseKing eLondon uthe uRahman unobuchule bokweyisela amaSilamsi ukuba luxanduva lwabo lwenkolo ukufunga ukuthembeka kwinkokeli yeLizwe lamaSilamsi, bephikisa ngelithi uThixo ufuna ihlabathi limanyane phantsi koburhulumente. i-caliphate, ngaphandle kokubabiza ngokugqithisileyo ukuba bafudukele eSiriya okanye e-Iraq. [Simele sibuze njani ukuba uRahman wazi njani ukuba uThixo ufuna ntoni? Kukho inyambalala yabantu ehlabathini lonke abavaleleke kumaziko ngokwenza ubundlobongela abathi, banyanzelisa ukuba kuphendule uThixo ethetha nabo.] (3)
Isibini saseCarlifonia โฆ Ekuphela kwengcaciso enokunikwa yingqondo yam yobuhedeni ngenxa yokuziphatha kwabo okungathethekiyo โkukufela ukholoโ. Babesazi ukuba isenzo sabo, ngokuqinisekileyo, siya kubakhokelela ekufeni kwabo kwaye bakholelwa oko babekufundisiwe-oh bafundiswa kakhulu kwiKuran kwaye babethelela iintloko zabo kwenye indawo njengonqulo kuphela - ukuba abafel 'ukholo kukho imivuzo yasezulwini. ubomi basemva kokufa ... ngonaphakade.
โUkuba lunqulo okanye lungekho, abantu abalungileyo baya kwenza izinto ezilungileyo baze ababi benze izinto ezimbi. Kodwa ukuze abantu abalungileyo benze izinto ezimbi - oko kufuna unqulo. " USteven Weinberg, ingcali yefiziksi ephumelele iBhaso leNobel.
amaNqaku
- I-US Department of State of State iDaily Press Briefing, Novemba 24, 2015
- Washington Post, Disemba 1, 2015, p.A11
- Washington Post, Novemba 23, 2015
I-ZNetwork ixhaswa ngemali kuphela ngesisa sabafundi bayo.
Nikela