Umthombo: Convergence
Imibutho emininzi yaseKhohlo ijongene nobunzima obunzulu bangaphakathi njengoko isebenzela ukulinganisa ubulungu obukhulayo kwelinye icala kunye nentaphane yemingeni yezopolitiko kwelinye. Ingxoxo yangaphakathi kunye nengxabano ingaba nempilo, ekhokelela kuhlalutyo olubukhali kunye nobunye obuqinileyo. Kodwa ungquzulwano ludla ngokuyonakalisa kwaye lusishiye sibuthathaka. Inene, imibutho emininzi yaseKhohlo iye yahlukana okanye yafa ngenxa yokuba amalungu akakwazanga ukuzulazula esebenza kuzo zonke iiyantlukwano.
Sinokubandakanyeka njani kwingxoxo-mpikiswano ngaphakathi kwimibutho yethu kunye neentshukumo ngendlela esinceda ukuba sikhule somelele? Njengoko ilungelo lolawulo likhula kwaye imeko yemozulu iya isiba mandundu, iintshukumo zethu zezopolitiko ziya kutshintsha, kwaye oko kuthetha ukuba "iNhlohlo" ngokwayo iya kutshintsha. Kufuneka siyazi indlela yokusebenza ngokufanelekileyo nangobuchule kwiimbumba, kwaye sisebenzise idemokhrasi esizama ukuyikhusela kwaye siyenze nzulu. I-Convergence izibophelele ekuphononongeni imibuzo enjalo. Siyathemba ukuba inqaku elilandelayo, nangona ligxile kwi-DSA, liza kunika ulwazi olubanzi kulungiselelo lwasekhohlo. -Umhleli wokudibanisas
Iphulo leDemocratic Socialists of America (DSA) lokugxotha ilungu leNkongolo yaseMelika uJamaal Bowman alikho ingcambu yongquzulwano olubukhali olwenzeka ngaphakathi kumbutho. Kodwa yayisisiqalo sokunyuka kwayo kwingxaki esongela ikamva lombutho kwaye ineempembelelo ezinkulu kuKhohlo lonke. Ke ngaphambi kokuba singene kwiiyantlukwano zezopolitiko ezibangela iingxabano ezikrakra eziqhubekayo, masiqale apho.
U-Bowman, ilungu leQela, wonyulwa okokuqala ngo-2020 kukhuphiswano apho wafumana imvume ye-DSA. NgoNovemba 2021, waya kwi-J-Street exhaswayo uhambo oluya ePalestine kwaye wadibana noNdunankulu wase-Israel uNaftali Bennet. Emva koko wavotela inkxaso-mali yase-US yenkqubo yomkhosi yakwaSirayeli โye-Iron Domeโ.
I-DSA njengombutho izibophelele kumanyano lwasePalestine ngokubanzi nakwi-BDS (i-Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions) ngokukodwa. U-Bowman akazange abange ukuba umele i-DSA xa ethatha la manyathelo, kwaye imigaqo-nkqubo yobulungu ye-DSA ayiwathinteli amalungu ukuba angavumelani esidlangalaleni, okanye enze ngeendlela ezingahambelaniyo, nezikhundla zombutho. Kodwa ungumntu okwiprofayili ephezulu, kwaye kwakufanelekile kwaye kungenakuthintelwa ukuba izenzo zakhe zinokutsala ukugxekwa okumandla kwamanye amalungu.
Inani elibalulekileyo lamalungu liphakamise imfuno yokuba i-DSA mayidlulele ngaphaya kokugxeka izenzo zika-Bowman kwaye imgxothe kumbutho. Abanye abazange bavume ukuba le yayiyimpendulo efanelekileyo. Kwalandela ingxoxo enkulu phakathi kombutho.
Ukususela kumbono wokwakha amandla ekupheliseni inkxaso yase-US kwi-apartheid yase-Israel-umsebenzi oyintloko we-Palestine intshukumo yobumbano kweli lizwe-izenzo ngaphandle kokugxotha u-Bowman beziya kubonakala zilungelelene. Umzekelo, kuthekani nge-DSA ezibophelele kwiphulo elisezantsi kwisithili sase-Bowman ukufundisa abantu bakhe ngocalucalulo lwakwa-Israeli kunye nenkxaso ye-US kulo? Ukwabiwa kwezibonelelo zombutho, ukuhambisa abaququzeleli abahlala kwisithili kunye namalungu avela kwezinye iindawo, ukuchonga abalingani, kunye nenjongo yokwakha umbutho wokuvota oqinileyo kweso sithili samalungelo asePalestina? Ngenxa yaloo nto, kutheni ungaqalisi amaphulo anjalo kwezinye izithili apho kukho amalungu enkomfa aqhubela phambili (kunye nabanyuliweyo basekhaya kunye norhulumente) abakwisiphelo esiqhubekayo sezopolitiko kodwa, ngenxa yeentsilelo zabo zombini kunye nobuthathaka benkxaso yePalestine. kwizithili zabo, musa ukuma ngokuqinileyo kweli candelo libalulekileyo le-ajenda echasene nobuhlanga kunye nehlabathi?
Olu hlobo lwenzame lunokunceda ukwakha intshukumo yomanyano lwasePalestina. Ngokubonisa ukuba i-DSA yayizimisele ngokubeka izihlunu zayo zezopolitiko apho imigaqo yayo ikhoyo, inokutsala abantu abanokuba ngamaqabane, kuquka abonyuliweyo kunye nabantu abacinga ukungenela isikhundla. Ingabonisa ukuba i-DSA, umbutho omhlophe ongalinganiyo, uzibophelele ekwakheni ubudlelwane obuluqilima kunye neenkokheli eziMnyama ezinenkqubela, uBowman ngoyena mntu umnyama ubalasele kwiNkongolo yase-U.S. Amalungu e-DSA athathe inxaxheba kwiphulo elijongeka ngaphandle anokufumana amava atyebileyo kwaye abe ngabaququzeleli abangcono abaphumayo. Kwaye inokufundisa umbutho uphela kwiinyaniso ezithile zasekhaya malunga nokwenza ezopolitiko: awukwazi ukuphumelela "phezulu" into ongazange uyiphumelele kwisiseko; amagosa anyuliweyo awangomthombo wamandla agqithisileyo; zibonisa ukuba angakanani amandla esinawo (okanye esingenawo) ngawo.
Umzamo wokugxotha-Bowman, ngokuchaseneyo, ujonge ngaphakathi, ugxile ngakumbi ekucoceni amanqanaba e-DSA kunokuchaphazela umgaqo-nkqubo wase-US. Kwaye ngokubhalisa inxaxheba yamalungu angengawo e-DSA kwiphulo lokugxotha i-Bowman yongeze imiqobo emitsha ekuphumeleleni imibutho ebanzi-imibutho, amaqela enkolo, njl njl-ukwamkela i-BDS; loo maqela ngoku kufuneka ongeze kwiingcamango zawo ukuba kunokwenzeka ukuba imigaqo-nkqubo yawo yangaphakathi yombutho iya kucelwa umngeni ukuba, masithi, ilungu elibalaseleyo elingaxhasi i-BDS libonisa oko esidlangalaleni. Kunokuba ubonise ukuba i-DSA iyakha uhlobo lwesiseko oluya kwenza ukuba abakhethiweyo bathathe izikhundla ezingelula ukuthatha kwipolitiki yase-US namhlanje, i-ingqondo okanye ayikho-uphawu lokuba i-DSA ifuna abakhethiweyo ukuba banike ixesha elifutshane. -sike indlela eya ekufumaneni amandla ezopolitiko.
Emva kwengxoxo ebukhali kumaqumrhu ahlukeneyo kunye namaqonga osasazo asetyenziswa ngamalungu e-DSA ukuthathela ingqalelo imiba yezopolitiko, lo mba uye kwiKomiti yeSizwe yezoPolitiko (NPC) ukuze yenze isigqibo. Umzimba uvotele ukwala imfuno yokugxotha uBowman.
Izinto azizange zime apho
Kumbutho osempilweni okwintente enkulu, le voti ibinokusombulula oku kungavisisani. Idemokhrasi ithetha, phakathi kwezinye izinto, intlonipho yolawulo lwesininzi. Ingqungquthela kazwelonke lelona qumrhu liphezulu lokwenza izigqibo kwi-DSA, kwaye loo ngqungquthela inyula (okanye ichonge ngokusetyenziswa kweenkokeli zayo ezinyuliweyo) amaqumrhu agunyazisiweyo ukuba enze izigqibo ezahlukeneyo phakathi kweendibano. Xa isigqibo senziwe apho amalungu amaninzi angavumelaniyo naso, ayakwazi ukugcina izimvo zawo kwaye azame ukutshintsha umgaqo-nkqubo okanye abasebenzi kwindibano elandelayo. Kodwa kude kube ngoko, izigqibo zamaqumrhu agunyazisiweyo kufuneka zime. Kungenjalo, umbutho wehlela kuluntu oluxoxisanayo.
Akwenzekanga oko. Iphulo lokugxotha u-Bowman liqhubekile nje, ngomzamo woxinzelelo kwi-NPC ukuba itshintshe ivoti yayo. Amalungu angavumelaniyo akazange avele abhalise loo nyaniso, nto leyo eya kufaneleka ngokugqibeleleyo. Endaweni yoko, basebenzise amaqumrhu asemthethweni ombutho aphendula kubunkokeli (kubandakanywa neQela eliSebenzayo le-BDS lombutho) ukwenza iinzame zokuguqula isigqibo.
Indlela uninzi lwabameli abakhohlakeleyo beli phulo abaliqhuba ngayo ibonise, njengoko kuphawuliwe ngasentla, ukuba umba wezenzo eziphosakeleyo zikaBowman ngokunxulumene nePalestine yayingengowona mandla aqhubayo. Ukuba bekunjalo, iingxabano eziphambili eziphakanyisiweyo ziya kuba nenkxalabo malunga nendlela amagosa anyuliweyo (kunye nobudlelwane bobusoshiyali kubo) angena kwisicwangciso esisebenzayo sokwakha amandla okutshintsha umgaqo-nkqubo wase-US kwi-Israel / Palestine. Kukho zombini imbali etyebileyo kunye nenkqubo yangoku ebanzi ekufuneka ijongwe kulo mba.
Iinzuzo ezenziwe yi-anti-Zionist Palestine Solidarity Committee kwi-1980 ngokusebenzisa umsebenzi kwi-Rainbow Coalition, amaphulo ka-Jesse Jackson, kunye namaphulo kaHarold Washington kunye nolawulo eChicago abambe izifundo ezibalulekileyo. Ngoko yenza iinzame zangoku zokwakha inkxaso ye-Rep. Umthetho oyilwayo kaBetty McCollum ukukhusela amalungelo abantwana basePalestina, ewela kakuhle kwi-BDS kodwa yiprojekthi yomthetho ephambili yamaqela azimisele ukuphosa phantsi amalungelo asePalestina, ukusuka kwiPhulo lase-US lamalungelo asePalestina ukuya kwi-M4BL. (Umlinganiselo wokulinganisela kwemikhosi ejikeleze iPalestine kwiCongress, i-bill ngoku inabaxhasi be-32, bonke abaDemokhrasi, kuquka noJamaal Bowman.) Kodwa akukho ngxoxo yesicwangciso esijonge kula mava ayekho, kuncinci kakhulu kwiziko, ukuqhubeka nokugxotha-umzamo weBowman.
Endaweni yoko, ugqaliselo lwezopolitiko lwengxoxo lutshintshele kubudlelwane be-DSA neqela leDemocratic Party. Abona bacebisi abanoburhalarhume bokugxotha uBowman baye bayandisile ingxoxo yabo kwaye ngoku bayigxininise ekugxekeni kweSquad, uBernie kunye nabanye abaqhubela phambili kunye noonontlalontle abakholelwa ukuba ukulwela ubuhlanga, ubuni obubandakanya amandla ezopolitiko kweli nqanaba lembali kufuna ukulwa. ngaphakathi kweDemocratic Party malunga nomkhombandlela wayo. Ingxabano ngoku kukuba abo bachasayo ukugxotha u-Bowman bangathathi eso sikhundla kuba bacinga ukuba kungcono ukwakha ubumbano lwasePalestina; kunoko, batyholwa ngokuxhasa iiDemocrats ngokuchasene namaPalestine kunye nentshukumo yobumbano lwasePalestine.
Kwaye, ngaphandle kotshintsho kugxininiso lwezopolitiko, imikhosi ye-expel-Bowman iye yatshintsha iimfuno zabo zangoku kunye neengxoxo zokugxila kwizigqibo ezahlukeneyo zombutho ezenziwe yi-NPC.
Makhe siwahlele omabini la manqanaba.
I-ajenda yezopolitiko: hlukana neeDemokhrasi
Ukudibanisa kwe-Sen. Bernie Sanders iphulo elinomdla likaMongameli we-2016 kunye nokuphumelela kukaDonald Trump kwabangela ixesha lokukhula okuqhumayo kunye nokuguqulwa kwezopolitiko kwi-DSA. Nangona uBernie wayengelolungu le-DSA, ukuthandwa kwakhe โkwidemokhrasi yobusoshiyaliโ kwaba lukhuthazo olukhulu kumbutho owabelane ngolo hlobo lokuzichaza. Imikhankaso eyimpumelelo yabafazi abane bemibala abayila iQela ngo-2018, emva koko ngo-2020 umzamo wesibini kaBernie kunye nokwandiswa kweSquad ukuya kwisithandathu, baqhubela phambili loo ntshukumo. I-DSA isebenza kumadabi amaninzi ngaphandle konyulo, kwaye ukubandakanyeka kwamalungu ayo kukwanda kwanamhlanje kwemfazwe kunye nomanyano emsebenzini kubaluleke kakhulu. Kodwa ubukhulu becala kukuchongwa kwe-DSA kunye noBernie kunye namaza amatsha aqhubela phambili enkongolo, kwaye ukuya kuthi ga kwinqanaba elincinane amagosa abalulekileyo karhulumente nasekhaya, athe aqhuba ukukhula kwawo. Kwaye amandla ombutho okuthumela amavolontiya abakhankasi ibe ngowona mthombo uphambili wokusebenza kwawo.
Nangona le meko, ukususela ngo-2016 inxalenye yamalungu amatsha athe angena kulo mbutho akazange avumelane neqhinga lezopolitiko labagqatswa ngokwabo. UBernie kunye ne-Squad basebenza ngombono wokuba ukoyisa i-Republican Party ngoku elawulwa ngamagunyatho obuhlanga kunye ne-misogynist kuwo onke amanqanaba ngumsebenzi ophambili; ukuba oku kufuna ukwakha unyulo olubanzi phambi kwabo bonke abachasayo kwi-Trumpists kunye nokuvotela iiDemokhrasi ezingaqhubekiyo ukuba zibethe abaxhasi be-MAGA; kwanokuba le misebenzi kufuneka yenziwe ngaxeshanye nokwakha amandla okuqhubela phambili azimeleyo. Ngamafutshane, babelana ngeqhinga "langaphakathi-ngaphandle" elibandakanya umanyano kunye nomzabalazo kunye nemikhosi ephambili kwiDemocratic Party.
Inxalenye yobulungu be-DSA ayivumelani kakhulu nesi sicwangciso-qhinga. Kwaye ngaphakathi kweli qela kukho amaqela amaninzi okanye iicaucus ezinenye indlela ephuhliswe kakuhle. Ngokombono wabo, ukuphatha iDemocratic Party njengendawo yedabi yimpazamo enkulu ekhokelela ekulahlekeni kweprojekthi yesocialist. Kubo owona msebenzi uphambili weli xesha kukuseka i-pole revolution engaguqukiyo kubomi bezopolitiko baseU.S. Ukwenza oko akufuneki kuphela ukwahlula ipolitiki yesi sibonda kwinkululeko kunye nayo yonke eminye imisinga eshiyekileyo, kodwa nokuba yahluke ngokupheleleyo kumbutho. Ukuseka umbutho we revolution yodidi lwabasebenzi ke ngoko ngumsebenzi ophambili, ekufuneka ukuba yonke eminye imisebenzi ibe phantsi kwawo.
Nditsho ne-MAGA bloc ejonge ukubuyisela ilizwe kwinkqubo ye-hybrid edibanisa uJim Crow, ukongama kobuKristu, kunye noMcCarthyism, isixa sengqwalasela ehlawulweyo ekoyiseni loo bloc kwibhokisi yokuvota okanye naphina kwenye indawo ibonwa njengomcimbi wobuchule. Ngoko ke luhlobo luni lobudlelwane ekufuneka lwakhiwe kunye nabaqhubela phambili abangengobusoshiyali okanye oosocialists abakhuthaza umsebenzi obambene nabani na onamaDemokhrasi okanye naluphi na ulungelelwaniso olunqamlezileyo. Oku kufuneka kuqwalaselwe kuphela ngokwemigaqo yokuba banokuthi bawuqhubele njani okanye bangawuqhubeli phambili umsebenzi wokwakha umbutho wenguqu, ekutyholwa ukuba baqinisekisa โukuzimela kodidiโ okuyimfuneko kuso nasiphi na isindululo esiya phambili kwicala lobusoshiyali.
UBernie utshintsha umdlalo
Phambi kwephulo likaBernie, abo babebambe lo mbono babechasa ukuvotela nabani na kumgca wokuvota weDemocratic Party ngaphandle kokukhetha. Kodwa iphulo likaBernie lika-2016, apho wayebaleka njengeDemokhrasi wenza ukuba usoshiyali badume ngakumbi e-US kunokuba bekunjalo kumashumi eminyaka, wabetha umngxuma omkhulu kweso sikhundla. Yayingunobangela (nangona ingeyiyo yodwa okanye eyona nto iphambili) kwiqela elikhulu elinaloo mbonoโi-ISOโukuchithwa; kwizantlukwano phakathi kweNdlela yeSocialist; nakumalungu amaninzi eSolidarity kunye namaqela alo mbono ngaphandle kobunye umbutho oxhasa uBernie kunye/okanye ukujoyina i-DSA.
La matsha ntliziyo avumile ngoku, njengokuba benzile abantu abaneembali ezahlukeneyo kunye nabantu abaninzi abasandula ukuba neenguqu ezininzi, ukuba kwamkelekile ukuba amasoshiyali abaleke kumgca wokuvota weDemokhrasi. Kodwa kwabaninzi (hayi bonke) aba, akukho uthethathethwano olungaphaya koko lwaluza kuvunyelwa. Kwaye i-DSA kufuneka ivume kuphela oososhiyali abathembise ngokubeka phambili uxanduva lokuphendula kwi-DSA ngokwayo phezu koxanduva lokuphendula kwimbumba ebanzi enenkqubela phambili ekufuneka yenziwe ukuze naliphi na iphulo libe yimpumelelo. Injongo yayisekukwakha umbutho woguquko ozimeleyo, kodwa indlela eya kwikhefu elipheleleyo kunye neDemokhrasi-kubandakanywa nomgca wokuvota owahlukileyo, owawufanele ukuba wenzeke ngokukhawuleza-ngoku ubeka imfuneko yesikhashana yokubamba umbutho. Umgca wokuvota weDemokhrasi apho kunokwenzeka.
Umsebenzi wonyulo we-DSA wasemva kowama-2016, osoloko ubonakala ubonakalisa iinzame zombutho omanyeneyo, enyanisweni ibingumxube ontsonkothileyo. Amanye amalungu aqhube lo msebenzi njengenyathelo lokuya kwikhefu neDemocratic Party. Abanye balandele uhlobo lweqhinga โlangaphakathi-ngaphandleโ elenziwa nguBernie kunye nabaviwa ababa liQela. Uxinzelelo lwalukhona ngaphantsi komhlaba. Kodwa ekwenzeni, kumaphulo okuphumelela idemokhrasi yokuqala kunye nokuphumelela unyulo jikelele emva kokuba ulonyulo luphumelele, umanyano kunye noluhlu olubanzi lwamanye amaqela anenkqubela zombini zaziyimfuneko kwaye zinokwenzeka. Kwaye abaninzi abaqhubela phambili abangengobusoshiyali baye bangenela izikhundla kwiinkqubo ebezingacaciswanga kwezo ziphambili ngamalungu e-DSA yobusoshiyali.
Ngoko ke, ngaphandle kweenzame zabanye e-DSA zokwakha udonga oluphakamileyo phakathi kwamalungu athenjiweyo ombutho wotshintsho olululo oluza kusekwa kwakamsinyane, umanyano lwezopolitiko olunobuzaza kunye nobudlelwane obuphuhlisiwe phakathi kwamatsha ntliziyo onyulo amaninzi e-DSA kunye nezangqa ezibanzi. Kwaye kwezi zangqa zibanzi, iqhinga likaBernie kunye neQela, kubandakanywa nokubaluleka okuphezulu okubekwe ekoyisweni konyulo lwe-Trumpified GOP, yayi-kwaye-inamandla kakhulu.
Ngo-2019, xa abasekhohlo babenethemba elikhulu lempumelelo kaBernie ngo-2020 kwaye iiDemokhrasi eziphambili zasilela ukunika i-ajenda enyanzelisayo, umbono โwokuhlala kude neDemsโ kwi-DSA wawunomtsalane. Umphumo waba kukuwiswa kwesigqibo esithi โBernie okanye Bustโ kwindibano yeDSA yaloo nyaka. Kodwa ngeNtwasahlobo ka-2020 uBernie wavuma ukutyunjwa kwiBiden, wamvuma kwaye wenza iphulo elinzima kumchasi wakhe wexesha elinye.
Uninzi lwabantu abaqhubela phambili kunye neeradicals ngaphandle kwe-DSA, ngakumbi abo basebenza kunye noluntu lwemibala, basebenze nzima ukoyiswa kukaTrump. Kwaye emva konyulo, ingozi egqithisileyo eyenziwa yinkampu ye-Trumpist yagxininiswa yi-GOP yokuvala amanqanaba emva koJanuwari 6. Ngaxeshanye i-Democratic Party mainstream yasuka kwi-neoliberalism yangaphambili. Amalungu e-DSA aqhubele phambili kuvavanyo oluyinyani lolungelelwaniso lwenyani lwamandla kwipolitiki yase-US kunokuba kwakunjalo ngo-2019. Isigqibo esiqinisekisa kwakhona imbono ka-โBernie okanye i-Bustโ ngendlela eyahlukileyo (ifuna ukuba bonke abagqatswa abavunywe yi-DSA babandakanye iphulo loluntu ikhefu kunye neDemocratic Party kumaphulo abo) ayiphumelelanga kwiNgqungquthela ye-DSA ka-2021.
Kodwa icandelo labo babengavumelani nevoti yeNdibano alizange lizilungelelanise nokulinda de kube yiNdibano elandelayo ukuze baphinde baveze umbono wabo. Emva koko kwafika impazamo enkulu ka-Bowman malunga ne-Israel-Palestine. Nanku umba wokuba-ukuba u-Bowman wayegxothiwe-wayenokukhokelela kwikhefu kungekuphela nje naye kodwa kunye neqela lonke, uBernie, kunye nabanye abachonga njenge-radical okanye i-socialist kodwa babone iDemocratic Party njengendawo yomzabalazo.
Ngaphandle kwamathandabuzo abo baphambili ngokubaluleka kukwakha isiseko esisulungekileyo senguqu epheleleyo bakholelwa ukuba ukugxotha umnyulwa ongaqiniyo ePalestine yinto elungileyo enokwenziwa ngokwayo. Kodwa iqhinga labo elisisiseko lizinze ngakumbi kwimfuno yokwahlukana neeDemokhrasi. Ngaloo mxholo, impikiswano kaBowman yinto efanelekileyo "ye-wedge" yokufezekisa elo khefu ngaphandle kohlaselo lwangaphambili kwisikhundla esamkelwe kwindibano ye-DSA ka-2021.
Idemokhrasi yangaphakathi?
Ezo ziipolitiki ezibangela iphulo lokugxotha uBowman eqhubeka kwaye eqinisa emva kwevoti yeNPC. Umzamo, ubuncinci kangangexesha elithile, waxinanisela eminye imiba kwii-ajenda zesahluko kwaye yaba ngumbaxa kumajelo eendaba angaphakathi e-DSA. Intetho-ntetho nezityholo ziye zanda, kuxelwa ukuba zaya kutsho kwaye zibandakanya izoyikiso zokufa. Ukungavisisani kuye kwanda phakathi kwabantu kumacala ahlukeneyo nakwimibutho yobunkokeli. Abantu abaneembono ezahlukeneyo kwimiba ekhoyo bazama ngaxeshanye ukuthoba ubushushu bongquzulwano kunye nokunyusa umgangatho wezopolitiko. Kodwa ngokubanzi, ipateni eqhelekileyo ebonakalisa amadabi angaphakathi kumaqela obusoshiyali yabanjwa: imiba yedemokhrasi yangaphakathi kunye neenkokeli ezityholwa ngokuba โphezulu-phantsiโ ziye zabonakala, zifihla imiba yezopolitiko esisiseko songquzulwano lwangaphakathi.
Ngokuhlonelwa komgaqo wesininzi wophulwe (yayibhityile kwi-DSA kwindawo yokuqala) zonke iintlobo zokuziphatha ngendlela engaqhelekanga ziye zaxhaphaka. Inkokeli-kunye nabanye-bazama ukunyanzelisa imithetho yentlangano. Kodwa ukuhlenga-hlengisa amalungelo neempazamo kwimeko nganye ethile kwakuthabatha ixesha, kudinwa, kwaye kungekho mbulelo. Ngemisebenzi ebalulekileyo yangaphandle engafumani ngqalelo ebeyifuna, i-NPC iye yanikezela kwisilingo sokuzama ukuqhubela phambili ngokusebenzisa iindlela zombutho. Kule meko, oko kwathatha uhlobo lokufuduka ukurhoxisa iQela eliSebenzayo leBDS.
Abaxhasi bokupheliswa kwe-charter baxoxa ngelithi iQela loMsebenzi alihlali phantsi kwesigunyaziso salo njengequmrhu elingaphantsi kwe-NPC, lisebenzisa iindlela zombutho ukuchasa ulawulo lwesininzi kunye nokutyeshela izithethe zedemokhrasi; nokuba amalungu aliqela ayesenza izityholo ezixhaphazayo kwamanye amalungu eNPC. Benza ityala elinamandla. Kodwa ubulungu obuzibophelele ngokugqithisileyo kumanyano lwasePalestina luya kusabela ngokucacileyo ngendlela eyahlukileyo ekunqunyanyisweni kwekomiti egxile kwi-BDS kunesigqibo sokungamgxothi uJamaal Bowman.
Ingxoxo ebanzi kunye nenzulu kwintlangano malunga nokuphulwa kweQela eliSebenzayo kwimimiselo yentando yesininzi, kunye neenkcukacha ezingakumbi malunga nendlela eya kuqhubela phambili ngayo imizamo yokubambisana kwePalestina, kuya kufuneka ukuba ugweme omnye umjikelo wokungquzulana okukrakra. Endaweni yoko, ukucinywa kwesivumelwano, kunye nokungxama kwamanye amalungu e-DSA ukukhuthaza inkxaso kwisigqibo se-NPC phambi kokuba umbutho uphela ubenokufumana kwaye ufunxe zonke iinyani eziyimfuneko, kubangele iingxaki ezininzi kunokuba zizisombulule. Kwaye isigqibo sarhoxiswa kamva.
Ukusebenzisa iindlela zombutho kulikhondo eliyingozi, ngakumbi xa imiba ebalulekileyo yezopolitiko isisiseko songquzulwano lwangaphakathi. Ukuchonga nokuxoxa ngaloo miba phambi kobulunguโukubeka ezopolitiko phambiliโkulikhondo elilunge ngakumbi. Ukungaphumeleli ukwenza oku, kunye nokusilela ukusebenzisa onke amajelo akhoyo ukunika ulwazi lobulungu kunye nethuba lokuvakalisa izimvo zabo, phantse kusoloko kubuyisela umva. Ivumela abo bophula izithethe zedemokhrasi ukuba bathabathe isimo samaxhoba atshutshiswa bubunkokeli obutyholwa njengozwilakhe.
Ngokukodwa kumbutho oselula apho imibutho yobunkokeli ingekafumani gunya libalulekileyo lezopolitiko-kwaye inikwe ukunqongophala kokuphendula kobunkokeli kumaqela amaninzi adlulileyo obusoshiyali-oku kuma ngokubanzi kubangela uvelwano. Ngokwendalo yabo, ukophulwa kokuziphatha okuxhaphazayo okanye ukwaphulwa kwemithetho kunomlinganiselo omkhulu wobugxwayiba, โbathi, batshoโ izityholo kwaye ngamanye amaxesha iinyani nezityholo ziyimfihlo. Ezi ngxaki ziye zibe mandundu kwi-DSA kuba i-NPC, endaweni yequmrhu elizimeleyo, elingelilo elikhokelayo, lityunjwa njengomlamli wezikhalazo nezinye iindidi zeengxabano.
Konke okuye kwadlala kwi-DSA kwiingxoxo malunga nokurhoxiswa kunye nokusebenzisa ululeko kubantu abathile. Iimpazamo zenziwe macala onke. Ezi kufuneka zichongwe kunye nezifundo ezisetyenzisiweyo ekuphuculeni ukusebenza kombutho, mhlawumbi kwenziwe uhlenga-hlengiso oluthile, ukuya phambili. Kodwa nokuba zeziphi na iimpazamo ezenziweyo kweli cala, ayisiso isizathu sokungavisisani kwi-DSA ukuba kufikelele kwinqanaba elifikelele kulo.
Esona sizathu singundoqo iiyantlukwano zezopolitiko eziphembelela lo mzabalazo zikhokelele kukruthakruthwano kunye nonxunguphalo endaweni yokuqonda okukhulu kwezopolitiko sesi: Iqaqobana embuthweni lalile, kwaye lisangavumi, ukwamkela intando yesininzi, njengoko kuchaziweyo kwiNgqungquthela yokugqibela kwaye ivoti ye-NPC yala imfuno yokugxotha uJamaal Bowman.
Ukudiliza amalungu okanye ukuphakamisa amalungu phezulu?
Into eyongezelelweyo yenza umlo wangoku kwi-DSA ube yityhefu kakhulu. โInkcubeko yokubiza abantuโโukugxeka kabukhali abantu ababonisa iimbono zobupolitika umntu angavumelaniyo nazo neziphene zomlinganiswa okanye ukungabikho kokuzinikela kwicala ekujoliswe kuloโkuxhaphakile e-DSA, njengoko kuninzi kakhulu kwi-Left. Isiphumo kukuba iingxoxo zezopolitiko, ngakumbi kwi-intanethi, ziwohloka ngokukhawuleza kuhlaselo lomntu.
Isizukulwana sam asingomntu wasemzini sibi kwaye siyonakalisa yangaphakathi ingxoxo yaKhohlo. Iimfazwe zamahlelo esaziqhubayo ngeminyaka yoo-1970s kunye neeโ80s bezichasene nemveliso. Kodwa yayilihlelo lezopolitiko: saphulukana nayo nayiphi na ingqiqo yomlinganiselo, sazibaxa iiyantlukwano ezincinci, kwaye sanika iimbono zabachasi bethu zonke iileyibhile ezingentle ezisencwadini. Kodwa ubukhulu becala, sibathathele ingqalelo abachasi bethu njengabathwali beendlela ezimbiโnangokuchasene noguqukoโ, hayi abantu ababi. Besijonge ukuba โbaphumeleleโ kumbono wethu ebesithiwa ukhanyiselwe-โukunyanga isifo ukusindisa isigulana.โ
Kukho izifundo eziza kutsalwa koku kwiimpazamo zesizukulwana sam. Ewe, ngamnye wethu uthwala imithwalo evela ekukhuleni kuluntu oluzimeleyo olusekelwe kubuhlanga, ubuhlanga kunye nezinye iindlela zokunciphisa ubuntu. Kodwa abantu bangena kwi-radical movement kwaye bazibandakanye nombutho ofana ne-DSA ukufaka isandla ekutshintsheni olo luntu. Bamele baxatyiswe kwaye banikwe izixhobo zokukhula njengoko bebandakanyeka kwimisebenzi yezopolitiko. Ngaphandle kwee-arhente zamapolisa (xa sinokuzichonga ngokuqinisekileyo) kunye nomntu onamaxesha athile onakaliswe kakhulu ukuba angasebenza kuyo nayiphi na imeko edityanisiweyo, ukucinga kwethu kokusilela kufuneka kube kukuba wonke umntu wenza izinto ezilungileyo. Ukuhlasela ubuntu babantu okanye ukuphatha abanye ngendlela obungayi kufuna ukuphathwa ngayoโsingasathethi ke ngokusongela ukhuseleko lomntuโkufanele kube yinto engaphaya kwemida.
Oko akuthethi ukuba akukho mbono kunye nezenzo zezopolitiko eziyingozi. Nazi. Kodwa kufuneka zithathwe njengeembono zezopolitiko umntu acinga ukuba zilahlekisa kakubi, hayi njengezibonakaliso zokuba abo babaxhasayo ngabantu ababi okanye abazinikezele kangako kubulungisa bezentlalo kune "cala lethu."
Ezinye iintlobo zezopolitiko ziyonakalisa
Ukugcina loo mgangatho unxunguphalisayo engqondweni, kuseyinyani ukuba kukho imbono yezopolitiko ephethwe ngamanye amaxesha kwi-DSA engeyiyo nje impazamo kodwa eyonakalisayo. Nokuba zithini na iinjongo ezintle zabaxhasi bayo, iguqulela kuhlobo "lokulawula okanye ukutshabalalisa" ukwenza buthathaka okanye ukutshabalalisa uninzi lwemibutho yasekhohlo eU.S. nakwihlabathi liphela. Lo mbono ubambe ukuba ukwakha umbutho wenguqu ocociweyo ngumba ophambili obaluleke kakhulu kangangokuba kuthetheleleka ukwenza nantoni na efunekayo kwi-DSA ukufumana impembelelo kunye nokugaya loo mbono. Ukuba i-DSA ibuthathaka kakhulu okanye itshatyalalisiwe kwinkqubo, oko akwamkelekanga. Yinto entle leyo.
Lo mbono jikelele unembali ende kwintshukumo yesocialist. Eyona ndlela icacileyo iwachaza ngayo akakho amazwi abagxeki bayo, kodwa kulawo abaxhasi bayo. Umzekelo, umguquli ozinikeleyo kunye nomseki ophambili we-US Trotskyism uJames Cannon wayivakalisa njengoko wayenikezela ngeziphumo zeqela lakhe elingena kwi-Socialist Party USA ngeminyaka yoo-1930s, emva koko waphuma wayokwenza i-Socialist Workers Party:
โIndibano [yeSiseko se-SWP] yamkele yonke inkqubo yeSine saMazwe ngaMazwe ngaphandle kwenkcaso. Oku kwabonisa ukuba umsebenzi wethu wokufundisa wawucokisekile. Zonke ezi zinto ziphunyeziweyo zinokulungiswa njengobungqina bobulumko bezopolitiko bokungena kwethu kwiSocialist Party. Kwaye enye yazoโibe ingeyiyo elona qela lincinane kuboโyayikukuba xa iQela lobuSoshiyali lasigxothayo saza sathi sakuziphindezela ngokuseka iqela elizimeleyo elethu, iSocialist Party yazibulala. Ukusukela ngoko iSP iye yaqhekeka ngokuthe ngcembe yade yaphulukana nayo nayiphi na inkangeleko yempembelelo kulo naliphi na iqela lentshukumo yabasebenzi. Umsebenzi wethu kwiQela lobuSoshiyali waba negalelo koko. UComrade Trotsky wathetha ngako kamva, xa sasithetha naye ngesiphumo esipheleleyo sokungena kwethu kwiQela lobuSoshiyali kunye nemeko elusizi yombutho walo emva koko. Wathi oko kukodwa bekuya kuthethelela ukungena kwintlangano nokuba asifumananga lungu elinye elitsha. Ngokuyinxenye ngenxa yamava ethu kwi-Socialist Party kunye nomlo wethu apho, i-Socialist Party yabekwa ecaleni. Yayiyimpumelelo enkulu le, kuba yayingumqobo kwindlela yokwakha umbutho wenguqu. Ingxaki asikokwakha nje iQela lenguqu, kodwa yeyokususa imiqobo endleleni yalo. Lonke elinye iqela liyimbangi. Onke amanye amaqela angumqobo.โ
UJames P. Cannon, "Imbali ye-American Trotskyism," iPathfinder Press, eNew York, ngo-1972, iphepha lama-252-253
Mandiyicacele le nto. Ndicinga ukuba iilebula ezivela kwi-pre-1989 Ekhohlo-i-Maoist, i-Trotskyist, i-Marxist-Leninist, i-Stalinist, i-Social Democrat, njl njl-ininzi ayinamsebenzi ekuqondeni namhlanje ukuKhohlo. Ayingabo bonke abo bachonga iTrotskyism ababelana ngeembono zikaCannon okanye babandakanyeke kuyo nantoni na efana nohlobo lokuziqhelanisa aluncomayo. Kwaye bonke abaninzi abachonga ezinye iimbono zangaphambili kwi-1989 eKhohlo bazibandakanya "kulawulo okanye ukutshabalalisa" iingozi. Ngoko ke ukudityaniswa kweebrashi ezibanzi malunga nalo naluphi na utyekelo lweengcamango kufuneka kuchaswe. (Ukubethelela le ngongoma: kusetyenziswa ntoni iindidi zangaphambi kowe-1989 xa zikhokela amazwi kwi-"Stalinist/Tankie" yeQela lamaKomanisi e-USA. gxeka kabukhali Uhlaselo lwaseRussia lwaseUkraine, ngelixa amaqela amathathu asuka kwintshukumo yeTrotskyist (Isenzo soSocialist, Abasebenzi beQela leHlabathi, kwaye i Iqela leNtlalo yoLuntu kunye noKhuseleko) wenqabe ukugxeka urhulumente kaPutin kwaye ubeka ityala yonke imeko kwi-imperialism yase-US / NATO?)
Oko kuthethiweyo, kuya kuba kubude be-naivetรฉ ukungaboni ukuba kukho amaqela ngaphakathi kwe-DSA asebenza ngendlela ebeka phantsi isidima se-DSA ekuqondeni kwabo okulungileyo okuphezulu. Abanye bangene kwiDSA njengeqela ngoqeqesho lwabo; ezinye zivele ngaphakathi kwe-DSA ukusukela oko 2016 ukukhula okugqabhukileyo kunye nenguqu.
Isicwangciso sezopolitiko sisisiseko
Lo ayingomba i-DSA enokusonjululwa ngawo ngeendlela zombutho. Ingumba wokuchonga imiba yezopolitiko engundoqo kunye neembono ezahlukeneyo ezikhuthazwa yimisinga ekhoyo embuthweni. Gcoba yonke i-back-and-out malunga nokuba ngubani ophethe kakubi, yonke ingxolo kunye nokuhlaselwa kwe-call-out kwimidiya yoluntu, kunye nayo yonke imibuzo "ye-gotcha" yobuntu kunye nokuzibophezela kwabantu. Emva koko ufikelela kumgca osezantsi wokhetho lwezopolitiko ekufuneka lwenziwe yiDSA.
I-DSA inokujolisa ngaphandle kwaye iqhubeke nendlela eqhagamshelwe kakhulu ekukhuleni kwayo mva nje: ukuzimisa njengamandla obusoshiyali ngaphakathi kwendlela eqhubela phambili kwezopolitiko zase-US awona manani abalaseleyo nguBernie kunye neQela. Ukuthatha loo khosi kuya kuthetha ukugxila, njengeninzi enkulu yaloo mkhwa, kokubini ukoyisa ilungelo lolawulo kunye nokwakha amandla azimeleyo obulungisa boluntu kunye nemikhosi yobusoshiyali kwinkqubo. Ingakhomba ukudibanisa umsebenzi wonyulo kunye neenzame zokuvuselela intshukumo yabasebenzi; ukomeleza iintshukumo ezingxamisekileyo zobulungisa bobuhlanga, ubulungisa ngokwesini, kunye nokhuseleko lokusingqongileyo; kunye neengcambu umbutho abasebenzi beentlanga ngeentlanga, kubandakanywa isini. Kwaye kuya kubandakanya umsebenzi wokwakha kwakhona iintshukumo zoxolo kunye nomanyano olukrazukileyo kunye noluphazamisekileyo, kubandakanya neenzame ezinzulu zokwakha ibloko yokuvota ezinikele kumalungelo asePalestine kwizithili ezininzi zeCongress kangangoko kunokwenzeka.
Kungenjalo, i-DSA inokubeka phambili iinzame zokuzisulungekisa kwaye iseke ikhondo elibhekiselele ekwakheni umbutho omtsha woguqulo lobusoshiyali ngaphandle kunye nokuchasa loo ndlela. Gxotha u-Jamaal Bowman kwaye uhambe ukuze uqhawule ubudlelwane nabanye kwiSquad kunye noBernie kuba, ngokutsho komnye wabameli ababalaseleyo bokugxotha-Bowman:
"Abanyulwa" be-DSA kunye namahlakani, anjengoAlexandria Ocasio-Cortez, uRashida Tlaib, u-Ilhan Omar, kwaye ngokuqinisekileyo uBernie Sanders, bonke bayekile ukufana nokuba ngabachasi kwaye endaweni yoko bazibiza njengezona Democrats zikhululekileyo ezinokuzama ukusebenza nzima. kwinkonzo yeDemocratic Party. "
Olu khetho lungundoqo kwiingxabano zangaphakathi zangoku ze-DSA. Ingxoxo malunga nayo inokuqhutywa ngendlela ezisa ukukhanya okungaphezulu kunobushushu. Yingxoxo-mpikiswano eneenkalo ezininzi ukuba kule meko i-pivots kwisicwangciso sonyulo kodwa ibonisa uvavanyo oluhlukeneyo lwebhalansi yangoku yamandla e-US, ezopolitiko, iimbono ezahlukeneyo malunga nobudlelwane bomlo wedemokhrasi kunye nomlo we-socialism, kunye-yekhethekileyo. ukubaluleka-ubudlelwane phakathi kobungangamsha abamhlophe kunye ne-US capitalism kunye nokuba kuthetha ukuthini malunga nendalo kunye nobungozi be-Trumpist bloc yanamhlanje. (Ngaphandle koko kukwesi sincoko, uluvo lwam ngale miba luthiwe thaca kwiikholamu ezingama-20 nangaphezulu endizibhalele iConvergenceโeyayifudula iLungiselela ukuPhuculwaโkwiminyaka emibini edlulileyo, ikhona. Apha. Kwaye kugxeko oluthile lwezimvo ezimxinwa ngokugqithisileyo zomanyano olufunekayo ukucela umngeni ngokufanelekileyo kwi-capitalism yobuhlanga yase-US, bona i-Convergence symposium "IRiphabhlikhi emhlophe kunye noMzabalazo woBulungisa bobuhlanga,โ ngokukodwa isincoko sokugqibela Apha.)
Yakube i-DSA yenza olu khetho, inako kwaye kufuneka ivavanywe ixesha elithile. Abo bangavumelaniyo ngokuqinisekileyo banelungelo lokuhlala entlanganweni baze baphinde baveze enye imbono yabo ngexesha elifanelekileyo, ekusenokwenzeka ukuba yindibano yesizwe. Kodwa awukho umbutho wobusoshiyali onokusebenza ngokukuko ukuba uhlala uhleli kwiingxwabangxwaba zangaphakathi malunga nombuzo osisiseko onjengokuba uzibeke phi na kwezopolitiko zelizwe elisebenza kulo.
I-DSA ngowona mbutho mkhulu wobusoshiyali owabonwa yi-U.S. ubuncinci kwiminyaka engama-70. Ukukhula kwayo okugqabhukileyo ukususela ngo-2016 kuye kwakhuthaza wonke umntu kwicala eliqhubekayo le-spectrum ngexesha leentlekele ezisongela uluntu kunye nosongelo olubi oluvela kwi-authoitarianism ye-right-wing. I-Left yonke ine-stake kwicala i-DSA ekhetha ukulithatha.
I-ZNetwork ixhaswa ngemali kuphela ngesisa sabafundi bayo.
Nikela
2 izimvo
Eli nqaku libonelela ngeembono ezininzi eziluncedo kwimvelaphi yokulwa ngaphakathi kwe-DSA. Ndivumelana nezichaso zenqaku lokubiza-ngaphandle / ukurhoxisa inkcubeko kunye noguquko olupheleleyo olukhokelele ekulweni.
Nangona kunjalo, andivumelani nendlela inqaku elicwangcisa ngayo ukhetho olujongene ne-DSA. Ayilokhetho okanye ukhetho phakathi kokusebenza ngaphakathi kwemida yeqela leDemokhrasi kunye nokuqhawuka uye kuseka umbutho wenguqu.
Njengoko kubonakaliswe yimpumelelo ye-Socialist Alternative (SA), elinye lamaqela akhankanywe kweli nqaku, kukho indawo eninzi yokuba abantu besithathu baphuhlise. Imodeli ebonakaliswe nguMzantsi Afrika yeyokuba umbutho wobusoshiyali unokuba liqela lesibini elisebenzayo kwiinqaba zenkululeko efana neSeattle, ukutyhala i-ajenda iyonke ngasekhohlo. Ndingathanda ukubona le modeli iphinda iphinda-phindwa kwezinye iindawo ezinqatyisiweyo, kwaye-ndiyacinga-kwaya kuba njalo nombhali weli nqaku.
Ndingathanda kwakhona ukubona iqela lobusoshiyali libonisa impumelelo yonyulo kwindawo enqatyisiweyo apho iqela liya kuba liqela lesithathu. Kwinqanaba likazwelonke, kukho inkxalabo esemthethweni malunga nemiphumo ye-spoiler, kodwa i-stakes iphantsi kwinqanaba lendawo apho umngcipheko ufanelekile ukuba uthathe. Ukuba iqela lobusoshiyali liyaphumelela, liya kusinika sonke umzekelo omhle wokulandela. Ukuba iyasilela, nalapho kuya kubakho izifundo ezifundiweyo kwaye sinokuphinda umzamo wokuzama ngamandla kwixesha elizayo.
Qaphela ukuba kwinqanaba likazwelonke, kunyulo lukamongameli, umzekelo, umntu usengasebenza kunye neqela leSanders-Squad ngaphakathi kwesakhelo seqela leDemokhrasi, ubuncinci kude kube lelo xesha apho umntu wesithathu ongentla abe ngumbangi onzulu. Akukho kuphikisana apha - akukho mfuneko yokuba izicwangciso zasekhaya nezesizwe zifane.
Okubaluleke kakhulu, into endiyichazileyo ngasentla yindlela eyakhayo ngokusebenzisa i-ideological morass enika bonke abachaphazelekayo into ephathekayo yokwenza. Ndicinga ukuba amaqela abekho, siya kufuna uhlobo oluthile lwesakhelo esiphantsi wonke umntu anokuvumelana ngaso. Umzekelo, ubuncinci besakhelo siya kufuna ukuba kunyulo lukamongameli, kumazwe aguqukayo, i-DSA iyakuthethelela ukuvotelwa kweeDemokhrasi, ububi obuncinci. Abaxhasi beqela lesithathu banokungavumelani neso sikhundla, kodwa ngokutshintshela i-DSA iphosa izibonelelo zayo emva kokukhulisa iqela kunyulo lwasekhaya, oko kubonakala ngathi kukuvumelana okufanelekileyo.
Ndililungu lombutho osekwe kuluntu, Iintsapho eziXhathekileyo zaseWestchester, ezinze kwisithili seCongress of Rep. Bowman. Kukho eminye imibutho eqhubela phambili enjalo, kubandakanya nesahluko seDSA, esixhasa unyulo lukaBowman. Ngokuyinxenye, oku kwakungenxa yokuba wayemele umngeni ku-arch-fiend uEliot Engel, usihlalo weKomiti Yemicimbi Yangaphandle yeNdlu, umxhasi wazo zonke iimfazwe nohlahlo lwabiwo-mali lomkhosi, kunye โnomxhasi owomeleleyo wakwaSirayeli.โ โ Ukongeza, uBowman wayenerekhodi entle njengomfundisi-ntsapho kwaye wayehlonitshwa kwiindawo ezihlala abantu abaNtsundu kwisithili senkongolo. Inyani yokuba uBowman woyise uEngel kakhulu kwiDem. ophambili uthetha ngenkxaso yakhe.
Xa abanye abaxhasi be-DSA bafudukela ukugxotha u-Bowman kunye nezizathu ezichazwe nguMax Elbaum ngasentla, yayicinezelekile kubaxhasi abaqhubekayo bakaBowman (ubuncinci) ngezizathu ezibini. Okokuqala, njengoko kuphawuliwe kwinqaku, ukusebenzisana kukaBowman kunye ne-Squad kunye nenkcazo yakhe ephezulu njenge-Black radical kumajelo eendaba yayinenzuzo kuyo yonke intshukumo eqhubekayo, kungekhona nje kwezopolitiko zendawo. Okwesibini, uBowman wayefunda ngokucacileyo malunga nemicimbi yangaphandle, kwaye esp. I-Israel / iPalestine, kumbutho wakhe kwiqela kunye nesidingo sakhe sokuzikhusela rhoqo kuhlaselo oluvela kuluntu olulungelelanisiweyo kunye nolwamazwi kakhulu kwisithili sakhe.
I-curve yokufunda ivelise inkxaso eyandayo ngu-Bowman kwizikhundla ze-pro-Palestinian. Ngokomzekelo, usanda kujoyina abafazi be-5 be-Squad ekuxhaseni isisombululo sika-Rep. Tlaib malunga ne-Palestinian Nakba. Kukho eminye imizekelo yenkxaso yakhe kumaPalestina.
Ngokumalunga nengxoxo-mpikiswano ngaphakathi kwe-DSA, yayidanisile into yokuba bekukho umdla omncinci wokufumanisa ukuba yeyiphi inkqubela kwingcinga yesithili sase-Bowman. Ukuqonda kwam kukuba isahluko se-DSA sasekhaya asikukhuthazi ukugxothwa. Ndikwakholelwa ukuba u-Bowman wadibana neenkokheli zelizwe ze-DSA ukuze axoxe ngezimvo zakhe nge-Israel-Palestine, kwaye kwabakho ukuhlangana kweembono.
UMax Elbaum (ulwimi esidleleni?) ucebisa ukuba i-DSA ithumele abaququzeleli kwisithili sase-Bowman ukuze bancede basuse isiseko sika-Bowman sabavoti ukuya kwindawo exhasa iPalestine. Ngokuqinisekileyo bangamkeleka, kwaye thina bahlali sinokunceda ekufumaneni izindlu ezifikelelekayo kwaye sinike izikhombisi malunga nolungelelwaniso lwezopolitiko lwasekhaya.