Malunga 'neDebunking Economics' -
I-Debunking Economics ibhentsisa into ekrokrelwa ngabantu abaninzi abangengabo bezoqoqosho kwaye igcuntswana leengcali zezoqoqosho kudala lisazi: ukuba ithiyori yezoqoqosho ayithandeki nje kuphela, kodwa iphosakele. Xa iDebunking yoqobo yapapashwa emva phaya ngo-2001, uqoqosho lwemarike lwalubonakala lungenakoyiswa, kwaye ithiyori yezoqoqosho yesiqhelo 'ye-neoclassical' yagqama. USteve Keen waxoxa ngelithi oosoqoqosho abafanelanga nalinye kuzukiswa ngenxa yendlela eliqhube ngayo uqoqosho, kwaye 'ukuzithemba okungeyonyani okubangele uzinzo kuqoqosho lwemarike kukhuthaze abaqulunqi bomgaqo-nkqubo ukuba bawachithe amanye amaziko awayevele evele kuqala ukuzama ukuwagcina. Ukungazinzi phakathi kwemida'. Oko kungazinzi kuqhambuke ngentlekele yezemali ka-2007, kwaye ngoku ithwaxa uqoqosho lwehlabathi ngethemba lolunye uDado.
Kolu hlelo olutsha luhlaziyiweyo nolwandisiweyo kakhulu, uKeen wakhela phezu kokugxeka kwakhe ithiyori yezoqoqosho eqhelekileyo ngelixa echaza ukuba yintoni na iingcali zezoqoqosho zingenako: kutheni le ngxaki yenzekile, kutheni ibonakala ngathi ayinakunyanzelwa, kwaye yintoni ekufuneka yenziwe ukuyiphelisa.
Ibalulekile kuye nabani na owakhe wathandabuza iingcebiso okanye ukuqiqa kweengcali zezoqoqosho, iDebunking Economics ibonelela ngesalathiso kwikamva elingcono.
Malunga noSteve Keen -
USteve Keen nguNjingalwazi oNxibeleleyo wezoQoqosho kunye nezeziMali kwiYunivesithi yaseWestern Sydney. USteve waxela kwangaphambili ngentlekele yezemali kwakudala ngoDisemba ka-2005, waze walumkisa ngelokuba emva phayaa ngo-1995 ukuba ixesha lozinzo olubonakalayo lunokuba 'kukuzola phambi kwesaqhwithi'. Indima yakhe ephambili njengenye yegcuntswana leengcali zezoqoqosho ukuba babone kwangaphambili le ngxaki kwaye bayilumkise ngayo yamkelwa ngoontanga bakhe xa wayefumana iMbasa yeRevere evela kuPhononongo lwezoQoqosho lweHlabathi lokwenyani ngokuba ngusoqoqosho owalumkisa ngobuchule ngale ngxaki, kwaye. umsebenzi onokuthi uthintele iintlekele zexesha elizayo.
Funda ngakumbi ngoSteve Keen nge ZSpace
Uphengululo -
'Ujongo lukaKeen olunzulu kodwa olufikelelekayo kwisiseko esiqingqikayo sengqiqo kunye nezibalo ze-neoclassical economics iya kuba nomdla kakhulu kubafundi kunye neengcali zezoqoqosho ezivulelekileyo ngokufanayo. Kwaye uhlolisiso lwakhe olunengqiqo kwezinye izikolo zengcamango luxhasa ikhwelo lakhe lezoqoqosho olutsha.' -UDon Goldstein, uNjingalwazi oManyeneyo wezoQoqosho, kwiKholeji yase-Allegheny
'Uhlalutyo olunabileyo kodwa olufikelelekayo lweziseko zeneoclassical pedagogy' - uAlan G. Isaac, uNjingalwazi oNxibeleleyo wezoQoqosho, kwiYunivesithi yaseMelika
'Esi sicatshulwa silandela ngononophelo uhlobo lwengxoxo eqhelekileyo kubo bonke abafundi abangekathweswa izidanga kwezoqoqosho, ukuya kutsho kwizigqibo apho abafundi abangekathweswa izidanga badla ngokukhuselwa. Ukunqanda ukugxeka okanye i-baxo, imeko ayivezayo ibaluleke ngakumbi ekucaceni kwayo kunye nendlela ecwangcisiweyo'- uJohn M. Legge, uNjingalwazi oNxibeleleyo, kwiYunivesithi yaseLaTrobe
'I-Debunking Economicsโฆ iya kuguqula indlela uqoqosho olufundiswa ngayo kunye nokucinga' โ uJan Otto Andersson, uNjingalwazi wezoQoqosho, iYunivesithi yase-ร bo Akademi, eFinland
'Iingcali zezoqoqosho zibandakanya abagxeki bazo abangcono. USteve Keen ngomnye wezona zibalaseleyoโฆ eguqulela i-algebra kulwimi olucacileyo, usebenzisa uhlaselo lwethiyori olutshabalalisayo kwithiyori ye-neoclassical' - uHugh Stretton, iQela leZifundo zoLuntu kunye neSayensi yeNtlalo, kunye nombhali 'wezoQoqosho: Intshayelelo eNtsha. '
'Ivuselela inkanuko' - uGeoffrey Fishburn, iSebe lezoQoqosho, kwiDyunivesithi yaseNew South Wales
Izindululo kuhlelo lwesibini:
'Uqoqosho lusalindele iDarwin yalo. U-Keynes usondele, kodwa akasondelanga ngokwaneleyo. U-Keen usondele ngakumbi. Ezoqoqosho, njengebhayoloji yayifudula injalo, zihlala zisekwe kukholo. Ayikho incwadi esongela olo kholo njengencwadi yesibini neyandisiweyo yeDebunking Economics.' -U-Edward Fullbrook, uMhleli, uPhononongo lwezoQoqosho lweHlabathi lokwenyani
'Kuyadumela ukuba ngabona bafundi baphakathi kuphela abanesisu sokubambelela kwisidanga sezoqoqosho. Iingqikelelo ziba yingqondo emxinwa kwaye itonela-ibonwa kangangokuba iingqondo ezisekelwe kwinyani ziye zilahle. Kodwa uqoqosho ngokucacileyo lubaluleke kakhulu ukuba lushiyelwe kwiingcali zezoqoqosho. Ngethamsanqa, uSteve Keen yingcaphephe yezibalo ejonga uqoqosho ngokufanelekileyo nangokucwangcisiweyo. Emva kokuba enze imodeli ecacisayo yeenkcukacha-manani, wajonga kuncwadi ukuphonononga imbali yengcinga yezoqoqosho kwaye wabona ukuba kuncinci kangakanani uqikelelo lwanamhlanje olunokuba negalelo kwiReality Economics. Ngoko incwadi yakhe yenza izinto ezimbini. Okokuqala, icacisa ezinye zeendlela ezinentloko egwenxa ezikhokelele kuqoqosho lwanamhlanje 'lwentengiso yasimahla' yehle kwindlela ejikwe ngayo ukuze ilungelelanise imeko yangoku. Okwesibini, icacisa indlela yokujonga uqoqosho ngokwenyani, unobangela nesiphumo sokukhanya.' -UMichael Hudson, uNjingalwazi oBalulekileyo woPhando lwezoQoqosho, kwiYunivesithi yaseMissouri
'Kuya kuba nzima ukufumana umntu ocazululo lwemeko yezimali yangaphambili yenkqubo yezemali yehlabathi kunye nomsebenzi wezoqoqosho ufile ngakumbi kunokaSteve Keen. Uhlelo lokuqala lwale ncwadi alubonisanga nje kuphela ukungahambelani kwethiyori yale mihla, kodwa yaxela kwangaphambili ngentlekele enkulu yezoqoqosho nentlalontle eyenzekayo. Olu shicilelo lwesibini luhlaziya izahluko zangaphambili kwaye zongeza ezintsha ezijongene ngqo nezizathu zokuwa kunye nezizathu zokuba kutheni izisombululo eziqhelekileyo zingenamsebenzi. Le ncwadi imele ifundwe ngokupheleleyo kuye nabani na ozibuzayo ukuba yintoni ebangele le ntlekele nendlela esinokuyibeka ngayo emva kwethu.' โ Prof. John T. Harvey, umbhali we 'Currencies, Capital Flows, and Crises: A Post Keynesian Analysis of Exchange Rate Determination'
'Intlawulelo sesona sipho sikhulu sale ncwadi kwihlabathi eliye lakhula lixhomekeke kwiindlela ezifihlakeleyo zeenkolelo zemathematika ezithe, kwiminyaka engamashumi amathathu edlulileyo, zakwazi ukongamela ithiyori yezoqoqosho kunye nomgaqo-nkqubo. Incwadi kaKeen ngumbutho wabakhenkethi onika umfundi wayo ithuba lokukhuseleka kwezi, zisengamandla, iinkolelo zoqoqosho.' -Yanis Varoufakis, uNjingalwazi wezoQoqosho, kwiYunivesithi yaseAthene
'Unjingalwazi uKeen ubhale incwadi eza kushukumisa uluntu lwezoqoqosho kumbindi walo, kwaye ngesizathu esivakalayo. Ayinakubhalwa ngexesha elilunge ngakumbi.' โ Andrew Leeming, umbhali we Super Analysts