Kwincwadi yakhe yezifundo ka-2006, I-Genocide: Intshayelelo ebalulekileyo, isifundiswa saseKhanada uAdam Jones uyavuma ukuba “wagungqiswa kanobom kukubulawelwa kwabantu ngenkohlakalo.
Kodwa, uJones wongeza, kwenzeka ntoni
Ndifumana uthelekiso lukaJones phakathi kwe "Holocaust" kunye neziganeko kwi
Kwinyanga enye edlulileyo, u-Adam Jones waba lilungu lamva nje lecandelo elikhulayo le-"Genocide Studies" ukubonisa ukungonwabi kwakhe no-Edward S. Herman kunye nonyango lwam "lwe-Rwandan Genocide" kwincwadi yethu encinci, Ipolitiki Yembubhiso.[4] Ekugqibeleni siye sajikeleza ukuphendula uJones (bona "UAdam Jones kwiRwanda kunye neGenocide: Impendulo," ZNet, Agasti 14, 2010.) Njengoko mna no-Ed siphawula kwisiphelo sempendulo yethu, umbhali-mbali uRené Lemarchand usebenzisa ibinzana elithi "ukutolikwa ngokuchanekileyo kwezopolitiko ngokubulala abantu" ukubhekisa kwinto esiyibiza ngokuba ngumzekelo oqhelekileyo we "Rwandan Genocide," leyo uninzi lwababhali-mbali lukhuselayo. kwanaxa kukho ubungqina obuninzi obuchasene noko.
Kodwa ndiyakholelwa ukuba eyona ngongoma kaLemarchand kufuneka ichazwe ngenye indlela, njengesilumkiso malunga nenqanaba eliphezulu Ukoyika leyo ihlasela iiholo ze "Genocide Studies," apho izifundiswa zoyika kakhulu ukuba zilungile, ukuba oko kuthetha ukuqubha ngokuchasene nembali yembali ekhoyo, kwaye apho izityholo ezingcolileyo "zokuhlaziya" kunye "nokukhanyela" zizixhobo ezikhethiweyo ezisetyenziswa yimbali yabo. abachasi abaqhutywa ziingcamango zokukhusela umhlaba wabo (kunye nobomi babo bobuchule) kunye nokunyanzelisa imigca yeqela-ngamandla ngakumbi kunangexesha labo elidlulileyo. ibekweukutolikwa kweziganeko kusengozini. IConformism mhlawumbi ixhaphake ngakumbi phakathi kweengqondi njengodidi kunalo naliphi na elinye icandelo loluntu. (Ngaphandle kokuba mhlawumbi phakathi kwabasebenzi basemkhosini, imiyalelo yenkolo, kunye nokunye okunjalo-ke iqhina.)
Kwimeko yaseRwanda (engekho ngaphantsi kweYugoslavia yangaphambili), "ingcaciso echanekileyo" ijika ibe yileyo ehambelana nezopolitiko kunye neWashington, kwaye oko kwenza ukuba iiarhente ezifanelekileyo kunye neziganeko zijonge phantsi, yongeze izigidi ezininzi zamaxhoba kuwo wonke uMbindi Afrika anokuthi ubomi babo busindiswe, ukuba inyani yeRwandan Patriotic Front kaPaul Kagame ibixelwe ngokuchanekileyo phakathi kweminyaka engama-20 kunye ne-16 eyadlulayo. (kwangaphambili, ngcono, nangona ugqaliselo olujoliswe kulawulo lukaMongameli wamaHutu uJuvenal Habyarimana luphambukise ingqwalasela kude kwi-RPF), kwaye abaxhasi bayo bangaphandle bayimisa kumkhondo wayo, kunokuba bayibongoze ukuba iye phambili..
— UDavid Peterson
—- Imibhalo yokugqibela —-
[1] Adam Jones, I-Genocide: Intshayelelo ebalulekileyo (
[2] Njengoko uRené Lemarchand ephawula (ethetha “enkqantosi”): “AmaYuda akazange ahlasele iJamani ngenkxaso enkulu yomkhosi neyolungiselelo yelizwe elingummelwane; yaye akazange akhe alawule iJamani njengesixhobo sezobupolitika sobukhosi obupheleleyo; Ulawulo lohlanga olulawulayo; kananjalo amaqela angamaYuda awazange abulale abantu abangengomaYuda kwilizwe elingummelwane kwiminyaka engamashumi amabini anesibini ngaphambi kokuBulawa Kwabantu Ngenkohlakalo. Kwakhona, amaYuda akazange atyholwe ngokubulala intloko yelizwe elingummelwane (njengoko kwenzekileyo
[3[ Iimfazwe zamakhaya eBosnia naseHerzegovina ebudeni besiqingatha sokuqala seminyaka yee-1990. Jonga, umzekelo, kwiKholeji yoLuntu yaseManhattan (CUNY) kwingxoxo kaNjingalwazi uNaida Zukic ngesiqwenga sakhe sokusebenza kwedijithali, "Ubunzima bokungabi nantsingiselo,” kushicilelo lwekholeji yakhe kulo msebenzi,'Andifuni ukubonwa njengexhoba'," ngoNovemba 13, 2009.
[4] Malunga nezicatshulwa ezifanelekileyo, bona u-Edward S. Herman noDavid Peterson, Ipolitiki Yembubhiso ( ENew York: I-Monthly Review Press, i-2010), ngokukodwa icandelo elithi "Rwanda kunye neDemocratic Republic of Congo," iphepha 51-68 (elishicilelwe kwakhona ngokuthi "iRwanda kunye neDemocratic Republic of Congo kwiNkqubo yePropaganda," Ukuhlaziywa ngenyanga 62, hayi. 1, Meyi, 2010). Jonga kwakhona uGerald Caplan, "Ipolitiki yokukhanyela: Ityala elingaqhelekanga laseRwanda. Uphononongo 'kwiPolitiko yeGenocide'," Iindaba zePambazuka (Nombolo 486), Juni 17, 2010; U-Edward S. Herman noDavid Peterson, "UkuLalwa kwembubhiso kunye nokuPhathwa kweGenocide: Gerald Caplan kunye Ipolitiki Yembubhiso," UMRSine, kaJulayi 4, 2010; Adam Jones,"Ngabakhanyeli bembubhiso: Ucela umngeni uHerman noPeterson," Iindaba zePambazuka (No. 490), Julayi 15, 2010; kwaye U-Edward S. Herman noDavid Peterson, "UAdam Jones kwiRwanda kunye neGenocide: Impendulo," ZNet, Agasti 14, 2010.
I-ZNetwork ixhaswa ngemali kuphela ngesisa sabafundi bayo.
Nikela