Ukubhala kweyanamhlanje Globe, uJohn Ibbitson uyaphendula kubagxeki bomfuziselo wezoqoqosho wasentsomini othi 'Anglo-Saxon', bexoxa ukuba ngaphandle kwezilingo zangoku zedemokhrasi yezentlalo, imodeli ye-'Anglo-Saxon' iya kubuyela ekuthandeni kwakhona, kuba 'imbali ibonakalisile ukuba iyasebenza.'
ULuiz Inacio da Silva waseBrazil kunye noNicolas Sarkozy waseFransi babonakala njengabaceli-mngeni kulo mzekelo we-Anglo-Saxon wobungxowankulu, ophawulwa ngu-Ibbitson 'njengolungele utyalo-mali, ojolise kumazwe angaphandle, onerhafu ephantsi kunye nokulawulwa kancinci.'
Ngelixa uLula exoxa kabukhali ukuba imeko yezoqoqosho ekhoyo iveze ukungazi kwabo bathi bayayazi yonke into de kube kutshanje, uSarko uncoma ungenelelo lukarhulumente, ummiselo, iinkqubo zentlalo kunye nokuzinzisa okuzenzekelayo.
Hayi ngokukhawuleza, utsho u-Ibbitson. Ngelixa ugqithiso lwamaxesha athile lweThatcher okanye iReagan kumele kuzisole, uqoqosho 'olulawulwa kakhulu, ukusasazwa kobutyebi kunye nokulawulwa ngurhulumente' lwenziwe ngokungaphaya kohlobo lwe-Anglo-Saxon ukusukela ngenkulungwane ye-18.
Ingxaki enkulu kuphela kwingxoxo ka-Ibbitson kukuba akayazi into ayithethayo: le modeli yase-Anglo-Saxon yasentsomini ayizange ibekho, kwaye ngokuqinisekileyo ayinaxanduva lophuhliso loqoqosho lwase-US kunye ne-UK ukusuka kwi-Industrial Revolution. .
UHa-Joon Chang, kwincwadi yakhe ka-2008 AmaSamariya amabi: Intsomi yoRhwebo olungaKhululwa kunye neMbali eyiMfihlo yoBungxowankulu, ibonisa ngononophelo ukuba uqoqosho oluphambili lwezoshishino njengeSouth Korea, i-US kunye ne-UK zikhulile kwaye zaphuhliswa ngokungenelela kukarhulumente kunye nokukhusela.
Ukuthatha umzekelo omnye, uChang ubonisa ukuba uqoqosho lwase-US lwalusanda kakhulu ngaxeshanye ukuba lolona qoqosho lukhuselayo emhlabeni (55). Uqukumbela uChang:
Kodwa imbali isixelela ukuba, kumanqanaba okuqala ophuhliso lwawo, phantse onke amazwe aphumeleleyo asebenzisa umxube wokhuseleko, izibonelelo kunye nolawulo ukuze aphuhlise uqoqosho lwawo. Imbali yamazwe asakhasayo anempumelelo . . . ibonisa ukuba. Ngaphezu koko, nembali yamazwe atyebileyo anamhlanje iyakungqina oko . . . [.] (61)
Uhlalutyo lwembali olwahluke kakhulu kune-Ibbitson, kodwa omnye umhlobo kwiinyani.
Ukubhekisela "kwizigaba zokuqala" yinto ebalulekileyo, kwaye inceda ukuchaza zombini isihloko sencwadi ye-Chang kunye nokugxothwa kukaLula okwaziyo-into eyaziyo phakathi kwe-'Anglo-Saxons.'
Ukuzuza ubutyebi kunye nophuhliso ngokwabo ngokuthatha isigqibo nge-Anglo-Saxon, abo baqhuba uqoqosho lwase-US, i-UK kunye nezinye izizwe baye banyanzela ngokuphindaphindiweyo kumazwe angaphuhliswanga kangako ngolawulo olufana nolo, 'imarike yasimahla' abanayo ngokwembali. ingahoywa.
Iziphumo ziye zaqikelelwa kwangaphambili kwabo uLula athetha ngabo egameni labo: ukukhula okubuthathaka, ukukhula okucothayo, ukulahleka kwempumelelo.
Ukutshintsha oku 'kukhaba ileli': ekubeni benyukele kwiindawo eziphakamileyo zophuhliso kunye nempumelelo, izityebi zikhaba ileli kude ukuze abo bangaphantsi bangabinalo ithuba lokulandela.
Kufana nokungathi umSamariya olungileyo wasebhayibhileni, kude lee ekulandeleni ibali likaKristu, wafika komnye umntu owayeswele waza wagalela ityuwa emanxebeni akhe endaweni yeoli yebhalsam, wamthwalela emhadini wamasela ukuze abethelwe okunye endaweni yokuba amse kwindlu yabahambi. ithuba lokuphumla kwaye uchache.
UmSamariya okhohlakeleyo ngokwenene.
Kufanelekile ukuthelekisa uhlalutyo lukaChang lophuhliso lwembali yoqoqosho lwehlabathi-uphuhliso lwalo lokwenyani, hayi intsomi yase-Anglo-Saxon-kunye nesiphelo sekholamu ka-Ibbitson Globe:
Ukudodobala koqoqosho kuya kuphela, ukukhula kuya kuqalisa kwakhona kwaye uqoqosho olusahlumayo luza kusondela ngakumbi kumfuziselo wamaNgesi namaMerika, kuba imbali ibonakalisile ukuba iyasebenza. Le nyaniso kufuneka ibe ngaphaya kwengxoxo, nangona ingumsebenzi onzima ukufumana abanye abantu ukuba bayibone.
U-Ibbitson ulungile ukuba 'ngumsebenzi onzima ukufumana abanye abantu ukuba babone inyaniso'-ungomnye wabo, ekubeni iingcamango zakhe ze-'Anglo-Saxon' zimi kwelinye icala le-gulf enkulu evela kwingxelo eyinyani.
"Uqoqosho olusakhulayo"-eneneni lonke uqoqosho-ekukhangeleni imodeli engqinwe yimbali kuya kwenza kakuhle ukuba baziqhelanise naloo rekhodi, kwaye bangayihoyi inkohliso yembali kaJohn Ibbitson's Anglo-Saxon Illusions.
I-ZNetwork ixhaswa ngemali kuphela ngesisa sabafundi bayo.
Nikela