Waa wax laga xumaado in la arko liberaaliga oo lagu qaaday mowjadda hysteria ee ku saabsan khatarta dagaalka macluumaadka ee Ruushka iyo saameynta suurtagalka ah ee ama xitaa qabashada madaxtinimada Trump. Waxa kale oo ay aad khatar ugu tahay daryeelka bini'aadamka maadaama ay gacan ka geysanayso xoojinta awoodda dhismaha milatariga-warshadaha, xisbigeeda dagaalka, iyo xoogagga siyaasadeed ee qotodheer ee dib-u-kicinta ee dawlad-goboleedka ay sheeganayaan inay ka soo horjeedaan. Xoogagga siyaasadeed waxay hagaajin karaan khad xisbi oo si dhakhso ah u noqda run aan la isku hallayn karin oo ka jirta warbaahinta guud (MSM). Sidaa darteed, iyadoo Midowga Soofiyeeti uu ku dhawaaqay "boqortooyo xun" waxaa si wax ku ool ah loogu calaamadin karaa dembiyo aysan gelin (tusaale ahaan, abaabulka isku daygii dilka ee Pope John Paul II ee 1981), iyo Saddam Hussein waxaa laga heli karaa xulafada Al Qaacida iyo Haysashada kayd badan oo hubka wax gumaada sanadkii 2003dii, waxay been tahay in MSM aysan dhib ku qabin liqidda.
Boris Yeltsin, oo u hoggaansamaya talada iyo cadaadiska Maraykanka ee 1991-2000, ayaa si xun u dhaawacay wanaagga dadkiisa (GDP Russia ayaa hoos u dhacay 50 boqolkiiba, intii u dhaxaysay 1991-1998), laakiin, halka uu sidoo kale abuurayay qaab-dhismeed dhaqaale iyo siyaasadeed oo kali-talis ah. waxaa lagu ammaanay inuu yahay dimuqraadi weyn MSM. Guushii doorashada Yeltsin ee 1996, oo ay si weyn u caawiyeen la-taliyeyaal Maraykan ah, talo iyo lacag, iyo haddii kale si xun u musuqmaasuq, waxay ahayd "Guul Dimoqraadiyadda Ruushka" (NYT, ed,, July 4, 1996). Ku-xigeenkiisii, Vladimir Putin, oo si tartiib tartiib ah u tuurayay ku-dhaqankii Yeltsin-ka, ayaa noqday khatar sii kordheysa. Dib u doorashadiisa 2012, in kasta oo ay hubaal ka musuqmaasuq yar tahay tii Yeltsin ee 1996, si adag ayaa loola dhaqmay warbaahinta. Ma jiro "guul u ah dimuqraadiyadda Ruushka" halkan, iyo maqaalka hogaanka NYT ee Maajo 5, 2012 wuxuu ka muuqday " dharbaaxo wejiga ah" oo ka yimid kormeerayaasha OSCE, sheegashada tartan dhab ah, iyo "kumanaan mudaaharaadayaal dawladda ka soo horjeeda ayaa isugu soo baxay fagaaraha Moscow si ay ugu qayliyaan ' Ruushka la'aantiis" (Ellen Barry iyo Michael Schwartz, "Doorashada ka dib, Putin wuxuu wajahayaa caqabado sharci ah"). Ma jirin โcaqabado dhanka sharciga ahโ oo lagu sheegay MSM guushii musuqmaasuqa ee Yeltsin ee 1996, inkasta oo ay ahayd mid aad u musuqmaasuq ah in Yeltsin laga yaabo inuu dhab ahaantii ku guuldareystay doorashada, laakiin tirinta khiyaanada ah (February 20, 2012, Madaxweynaha Ruushka Dmitri Medvedev ayaa ka naxay. koox yar oo booqdayaal ah iyagoo qiraya in Yeltsin laga yaabo inuu runtii lumiyay doorashadii 1996 ee Communist Gennadi Zyuganov).
Hannaanka joogtada ah ee jinniyada Putin wuxuu ka sii daray xiisadda Ukraine ee 2014 iyo daba-galka dagaalka Kiev ee ka dhanka ah Bariga Ukraine, taageerada Ruushka ee iska caabinta Bariga Ukraine, iyo aftidii Crimean iyo nuugista Crimea ee Ruushka. Dhammaan tani waxaa lagu dhawaaqay inay tahay "gardarrada" Maraykanka iyo xulafadiisa iyo macaamiishooda, cunaqabatayn ayaa lagu soo rogay Ruushka iyo dhismaha US-NATO ee xuduudaha Ruushka ayaa kordhay. Xiisada ayaa sii kordheysa iyada oo la ridayo diyaaradda Malaysian Airlines MH-17, si wax ku ool ah, laakiin ku dhawaad โโbeen abuur ah, eedeymo ah fallaagada "Pro-Ruushka" iyo Ruushka laftiisa (eeg Robert Parry, "Dhibaatooyinka Dhibaatada ee Warbixinta Cusub ee MH-17," Consortiumnews. com, September 28, 2016). Sababta kale ee shaydaanka iyo nacaybka Ruushka ka dhanka ah ayaa ka dhalatay faragelinta Ruushka ee sii kordhaysa ee Suuriya isagoo taageeraya Bashaar al-Saddaad iyo ka dhanka ah Daacish. Maraykanka iyo xulafadiisa Nato iyo xulafadiisa Bariga Dhexe waxay si gardarro ah u geysanayeen Suuriya iyo isbahaysi dhab ah oo ay la leeyihiin ISIS iyo Al-Nusrah, oo ka tirsan Al-Qaacida. Faragelinta Ruushku waxay rogtay jihada, hadafkii Maraykanka (iwm) ee ahaa in Saddaad meesha laga saaro ayaa ka xumaaday, waxaana si ba'an loo wiiqay xulafada Maraykanka ee ISIS. Hubaal dabeecadda jinniga. Wajiga xiga ee socda ee ka soo horjeedka Ruushka wuxuu ku salaysnaa gelitaanka la sheegay in Ruushka uu galay ololihii madaxtinimo ee 2016 iyo doorka sii kordhaysa ee CIA iyo adeegyada kale ee amniga Maraykanka ee hirgelinta hysteria, iyagoo isbahaysi dhow la leh MSM. Doodii saddexaad ee madaxweynenimada, Oktoobar 19, 2016, Clinton waxay ku dhawaaqday in Trump uu madaxweyne ahaan u noqon doono Putin โpupetโ, olโolaheeda ayaana arrintan xoogga saaray. Culayskan ayaa kor u kacay doorashadii ka dib, iyada oo gacan ka helaysa warbaahinta iyo sirdoonka iyada oo xerada Clinton ay raadinaysay inay sharaxdo khasaarihii doorashada oo ay suurtogal tahay in natiijada doorashada laga saaro maxkamadaha ama kulliyadda doorashada iyadoo ku eedaysay Ruushka.
Xidhiidhka Putin waxa dhiirigelin weyn siiyey January 6, 2017 oo uu soo saaray warbixin ka soo baxday Xafiiska Agaasimaha Sirdoonka Qaranka, kaas oo ku saabsanaa asalka qiimaynta hawlihii Ruushka iyo rabitaanka doorashooyinkii Maraykanka ee dhawaa Dukumeentigan gaaban waxa uu ku kharash gareeyaa kala badh booskiisa oo qeexaya Ruushka -Shabakadda RT-TV oo ay kafaala-qaadatay taasoo ay u muuqato inay tixgeliso il dacaayad aan sharci ahayn iyadoo inta badan ka warbixisa oo xitaa dhaleecaysa siyaasadda iyo hay'adaha Maraykanka. RT ayaa lagu eedeeyay inay qayb ka tahay "ololaha saamaynta" ee Ruushka, kaas oo ka kooban ka warbixinta mawduucyada ay hoggaamiyeyaasha Ruushku u arkaan inay danta Ruushka ku jirto. "Waxaan qiimeyneynaa ololaha saameynta uu ku rajeenayo inuu ka caawiyo madaxweyne-la-doortay fursadaha guusha ee Trump markii ay suurtagal tahay annagoo ceebeynayna Xoghaye Clinton oo aan si cad u barbar dhignay iyada si aan wanaagsaneyn iyo Madaxweynaha la doortay." Ma jirto wax caddayn ah oo muujinaya in uu jiray "olole" qorsheysan oo aan ahayn muujinta ra'yiga iyo xukunnada wararka ee la xidhiidha. Dhammaan caqli-galnimada iyo caddaymaha "ololaha saamaynta" ee Ruushka ayaa lagu dabaqi karaa ugu yaraan xoog la mid ah daaweynta warbaahinta Maraykanka ee doorasho kasta oo Ruush ah.
Marka la eego dadaalka ay ku doonayaan inay caddeeyaan in Ruushku si toos ah u soo farageliyay habka doorashada Maraykanka, qorayaashu waxay ku dhufteen iyagoo leh warbixintu ma bixiso "caddaynta buuxda", laakiin ma bixiso caddayn taageeraya - kaliya caddayn, qiimeyn, malo iyo qiyaasid. Waxay si cad u sheegaysaa in "Waxaan qiimeynay inโฆPutin wuxuu amray olole saameyn ah 2015" loogu talagalay in laga adkaado Clinton, iyo "si loo wiiqo caqiidada dadweynaha ee geeddi-socodka dimoqraadiyadda Mareykanka," laakiin ma bixiso wax caddayn ah wax kasta oo amar noocaas ah. Sidoo kale ma bixinayso wax caddayn ah oo sheegaya in Ruushku jabsaday emails DNC, Clinton iyo Podesta, ama in ay siiyeen macluumaadka la jabsaday WikiLeaks. Julian Assange iyo Craig Murray ayaa marar badan ku celceliyay in ilahan ay faafiyeen dad gudaha ku jira oo aan cidina jabin. Khubarada hay'adda sirdoonka ee ruug-caddaa ah William Binney iyo Ray McGovern ayaa sidoo kale ku doodaya in caddaynta WikiLeaks ay hubaal tahay in la sii daayay, oo aan la jabsaday ("Kiiska Dubious on Russian 'Hacking'," Consortiumnews.com, January 6, 2017). Waxaa xiiso leh in ka mid ah hay'adaha sirta ah ee saxiixay dukumeentiga DNI, mid ka mid ah boos celinta ugu weyn - oo kaliya "kalsooni dhexdhexaad ah" - wuxuu ahaa NSA, oo ah hay'adda si cad u haysata caddaynta Ruushka. jabsiga iyo u gudbinta Wiki-Leaks iyo sidoo kale "amar kasta" oo ka yimaada Putin.
Isla markiiba doorashadii ka dib, Clinton waxay ku eedaysay madaxa FBI-da James Comey dib u furitaankii ka dibna si dhakhso ah u xidhay kiiska iyada oo aan la ogolayn adeegsigeeda email-ka gaarka ah ee ay hore u isticmaashay, taas oo ah qodobka ugu muhiimsan ee guuldaradii doorashadeeda ("Clinton wuxuu ku eedeeyay agaasimaha FBI guuldaradii, โ NYT, Noofambar 13, 2016). Tani waxay soo jeedinaysaa in xitaa iyada iyo ololayaasheeda aysan u tixgelinin jabsiga Ruushka ee lagu eedeeyay iyo muujinta WikiLeaks mid muhiim ah. Laakiin xiriirka Ruushka iyo Putin wuu sii noolaa oo xitaa wuu sii kordhay.
MSM-ka ayaan wax dareen ah siinin siyaasadaynta hayโadaha sirdoonka ee kiisaskan. Kiiskii ugu cimri dheeraa ee muhiimka ahaa ee ku lug lahaa Ruushka ayaa dhaawac u geystay Trump iyo rajo kasta oo nabadeed oo laga yaabo in madaxweynanimadiisa uu keeno. Laakiin dhacdadii FBI-Clinton waxay dhaawacday Clinton waxayna ka faa'iidaysatay fursadaha doorashada ee Trump. Hal aragti ayaa ah in hoggaanka FBI-da ay u xaglinayeen Trump halka CIA-da ay u xaglinaysay Clinton. Aragti kale ayaa ah in hay'adaha sirdoonku aysan aamini karin midkoodna musharaxa, sidaas darteed si ba'an u dhaawacay Clinton ka dibna ay qoryahooda u rogeen Trump, iyada oo FBI-da ay u saxiixday hay'adaha wadajirka ah ee "Assessment" ka dib markii ay dhammeeyeen Clinton. (Robert Parry, "Afgembi Basaas ah oo Ameerika ka dhacay?" Consortiumnews.com, Disembar 18, 2016.)
Laakiin cadaawadda CIA-da ee Trump ayaa ahayd mid muuqata, iyo faragelintii foosha xumayd ee ay ku sameeyeen geeddi-socodkii doorashada waxa ay jabiyeen siyaasad adeeg sir ah. Madaxii hore ee CIA Michael Morell ayaa August 5, 2016 ku lahaa New York Times op-ed cinwaankiisu ahaa โI Ran the C.I.A. Hadda waxaan taageersanahay Hillary Clinton"; iyo madaxii hore ee CIA Michael Hayden ayaa wargeyska Washington Post ku lahaa maalmo uun ka hor doorashada, cinwaankiisuna ahaa "Madaxii hore ee CIA: Trump waa doqonkii waxtarka lahaa ee Ruushka" (Noofambar 3, 2016). Weeraradaasi waxay ahaayeen kuwo si aan kala goโ lahayn loogu aflagaadeeyay Trump, laguna ammaanay Clinton, in kasta oo xiisaha lihi aan la xusin faaโiidada iyo xumaanta musharraxiinta barnaamijyada siyaasadda gudaha. Way caddahay in habka qallafsan ee Clinton ee Suuriya iyo Ruushka ay aad uga door bideen u janjeersiga Trump ee gorgortanka iyo iskaashiga Ruushka.
Markaa ujeeddada iyo muhiimadda Qiimayntu way caddahay. Khafiif ah oo xitaa qosol leh in kasta oo caddaynteeda ku saabsan Putin uu amray olole dacaayad ah iyo jabsiga e-mailka Ruushka ee laga soo gudbiyay WikiLeaks ayaa laga yaabaa, sii daynta iyo riixitaanka waxyaabahan caanka ka ah dhabarka dambe ee maamulka imanaya waxay ahayd tallaabo siyaasadeed oo weyn oo ay qaadeen hay'adaha mabda'a ahaan. oo ka hooseeya hoggaanka siyaasadda. Dabcan waxa ay raacaysaa tabo la mid ah maamulka Obama ee xilka ka degaya, mid ka mid ah falkiisii โโugu dambeeyay waxa uu eryay 35 ka mid ah shaqaalaha safaaradda Ruushka si ay uga aargoostaan โโjabsiga Ruushka ee loo malaynayo (taas oo Obama aanu xataa rumaysnayn โ shirkiisa jaraaโid ee ugu dambeeyay waxa uu ku tilmaamay โleaksโ) halkii ay ka ahaan lahayd "jabsiga"). Laakiin barta siyaasadeed ee Qiimaynta waxay u muuqataa inay ahayd, ugu yaraan, in lagu xiro gacmaha maamulka Trump ee la macaamilka Ruushka.
Tani waxay sidoo kale ahayd run fadeexad dheeraad ah oo ku saabsan wicitaanka Michael Flynn ee ka yimid Safiirka Ruushka, oo ay suurtogal tahay in ay ku jiraan is-weydaarsiga ku saabsan tallaabooyinka siyaasadda mustaqbalka. Tan waxaa si degdeg ah u fahmay saraakiisha Obama ee xilka ka degaya iyo shaqaalaha ammaanka, iyadoo FBI-du ay su'aalo waydiinaysay Flynn iyo hadallo argagax leh oo ku aaddan falka Flynn, oo lagu eedeeyay inay suurtogal tahay inuu u dejiyo. Laakin kulammadan oo kale ee ka hor caleema saarka dublamaasiyiinta Ruushka waxay ahaayeen "caado caadi ah" sida uu qabo Jack Matlock, safiirka Maraykanka ee Ruushka ee hoos yimaada Reagan iyo Bush, iyo Matlock ayaa si shakhsi ah u abaabulay kulankaas Carter. Lataliyaha Obama ee Ruushka, Michael McFaul, ayaa qirtay inuu booqday Moscow si uu wadahadal ula yeesho saraakiisha 2008 xitaa ka hor doorashada. Daniel Lazare wuxuu dhigayaa kiis wanaagsan in sharci-darrada iyo hanjabaadda madowga ah ay tahay mid aan macquul ahayn, in su'aalaha FBI-da ee Flynn ay dib u soo celinayaan, oo uu waydiiyo waxa khaldan iskudayga in la yareeyo xiisadda Ruushka? "Haddana xorriyadda ka-hortagga Trump waxay isku dayayaan inay ka dhaadhiciyaan dadweynaha inay dhammaan 'ka daran tahay Watergate'." ("Dimuqraadiyiinta, Libaraalka, Qabta qandhada McCarthyistic," Consortiumnews.com, Febraayo 17, 2017.)
Mid ka mid ah sifooyinka wanaagsan ee ololaha Trump ayaa ahaa diidmada in la jinniyo Putin iyo calaamad muujinaysa rabitaan ah in la caadiyeeyo xiriirka Ruushka. Marka la eego kobaca iyo awoodda dhismaha militariga-warshadaha, iyo hay'adaha amniga, waxaa jiray dano gaar ah oo awood leh oo xiriir la leh Ruushka sii socda, oo ka muuqda qiimeynta iyo hay'adaha kale ee amniga si cad iyo qarsoodi ah, iyo iskaashiga warbaahinta (sida. daabacaadooda warqadaha doorashada CIA).
Isbarbar-dhigga culeyska Qiimeynta ee Ruushka "ololaha saameynta," MSM waxay noqotay mid aad ugu mashquulsan "warar been abuur ah," oo badanaa si cad ama si cad ugu xiran Ruushka. Xaqiiqda naxdinta leh ee macnaha guud ayaa ah in siidaynta emailada Clinton, DNC, iyo Podesta ee la sheegay in Ruushku jabsaday ay ku qeexeen xaqiiqooyinka ku saabsan wax is daba marinta doorashada iyaga oo ka wakiil ah ololaha Clinton oo laga yaabo in ay si fiican u saamaysay natiijada doorashada. Diirada la saaray faragelinta aan jirin ee jabsiga Ruushka ayaa ka caawisay in laga weeciyo xadgudubka doorashada dhabta ah. Wararka rasmiga ah iyo MSM ee been abuurka ah ayaa ka caawiyay aasitaanka wararka dhabta ah.
Dhacdadii ugu cajiibsanayd ee warbaahinta ee ololahan ka-hortagga saamaynta, taas oo ahayd iyo weli waa olole ka dhan ah Ruushka oo been abuur ah, waxa uu ahaa wargeyska Washington Post ee classic Craig Timberg, "Dadaalka dacaayadaha Ruushku waxa ay gacan ka geysteen faafinta 'warar been abuur ah' xilligii doorashada, khubaradu waxay yiraahdeen (Noofambar 24, 2016). Maqaalku waxa uu leeyahay warbixin uu qoray qoraaga ama qoraayaasha, PropOrNot, oo ah "koox ku adkaysta qarsoodinimada dadweynaha" sida ay qabaan tifaftirayaasha WP. Kooxdu waxay sheeganeysaa in ay heshay 200 oo mareegaha internetka ah oo si bareer ah ama aan ogeyn, ay ahaayeen "kuwa si joogta ah uga ganacsada dacaayadaha Ruushka." Iyagoo xumaanaya mareegahaas, โkhubaradaโ waxay diideen inay aqoonsadaan eedaymahaas iyagoo ka baqaya inay โbartilmaameedsadaan guuto tuugo xirfad leh.โ
Sida Matt Taibbi u leeyahay, "Ma waxaad doonaysaa inaad boqolaal dad ah ku qorto liiska madow, laakiin ma gelin doontid magacaaga sheegashadaada? Socdaal qaad.โ ("The 'Washington Post's 'Liiska madow' Sheekada waa ceeb iyo karaahiyo," RollingStone.com, Noofembar 28, 2016.) Laakiin WP waxay soo dhaweysay oo soo bandhigtay shaqadan sumcad-darrada ah, taas oo laga yaabo inay noqoto mid ka soo baxday Pentagon ama CIA-da dagaalka (iyo si fiican ayaa loo maalgeliyaa oo si weyn ayay u galaan ganacsiga dacaayadda).
NYT waxay la orday qoorta iyo qoorta WP si ay u kiciso cabsida dagaalka macluumaadka ee Ruushka iyo ku lug lahaanshaha aan habooneyn ee Trump. Waxay si sahal ah u khalkhaliyaan wararka been abuurka ah ee dhaleecayn kasta oo ka mid ah hay'adaha la aasaasay, sida Mark Scott iyo Melissa Eddy, "Yurub waxay la dagaallamaan cadowga cusub ee xasilloonida siyaasadeed: Warar been abuur ah," Febraayo 20, 2017; lagu falanqeeyay, in Robert Parry, "Wararka been abuurka ah ee NYT ee ku saabsan wararka been abuurka ah," Consortium news.com, February 22, 2017. Laakiin waxa ka sii cajiib ah waa isku mid ahaanshaha kuwaas oo wargeysyada caadiga ah ay aqbalaan CIA-da ee Qiimaynta jabsiga-gudbinta Ruushka WikiLeaks, cabsida laga qabo kiiska Flynn, suurtagalnimada ama suurtogalnimada in Trump uu yahay boombale Putin, iyo baahida degdegga ah ee kongareeska iyo "aan-mid la'aanta" baaritaanka sheegashooyinkan. Liqitaankan khadka cusub ee xisbiga ayaa si weyn ugu fiday warbaahinta xorta ah (tusaale, Robert Reich, Ryan Lizza, Joan Walsh, Rachel Maddow, shabakadda AlterNet, iwm.).
Diseembar 23, 2016 Madaxweyne Obama wuxuu saxiixay Portman-Murphy "Xeerka ka hortagga faafinta iyo dacaayadda," kaas oo loo maleynayo inuu u oggolaan doono dalkan inuu si wax ku ool ah ula dagaallamo dacaayadda iyo macluumaadka shisheeye (Ruushka, Shiinaha). Waxay dhiirigelin doontaa dadaallo badan oo dowladda ka dhanka ah dacaayadaha iyo bixinta maalgelinta hay'adaha aan dawliga ahayn kuwaas oo gacan ka geysan doona ka hortagga borobogaandada.
Waxay si cad u tahay daba-galka sheegashada jabsiga Ruushka iyo dacaayadda, waxaana laga yaabaa in xitaa la sheego inay daba socoto liiska 200 ee ogaanshaha ama "qalabka waxtarka leh" ee Moscow ee lagu soo bandhigay Washington Post. Waxaa laga yaabaa in PropOrNot ay u qalmi doonto kabid oo ay awood u yeelan doonto inay ballaariso liiskeeda 200. Libaraalka ayaa ka aamusay khatartan cusub ee xorriyadda hadalka, taas oo la saxeexay sharciga jimcihii, laga yaabee inay curyaamiyeen cabsida ay ka qabaan wararka been abuurka ah ee ku saleysan Ruushka. iyo dacaayad. Laakiin waxaa laga yaabaa in ay soo toosaan, xitaa haddii ay daahdaan, marka Trump ama mid ka mid ah ku xigeenadiisa ay ku dhejiyaan in ay ka shaqeeyaan fikradahooda ah warar been abuur ah iyo dacaayad.
Z