Ndiani anotya izwi remudzidzisi? Yemubatanidzwa kuronga muzvikoro zvechata?
Kwete chete vanofungirwa vakajairwa pane anti-mubatanidzwa, anti-mudzidzisi, anti-ruzhinji dzidzo kure kurudyi. Zviitiko zvichangobva kuitika muNew York City zvinopa humbowo hunogutsa hwekuti NYC Dhipatimendi reDzidzo yeChancellor Joel Klein naMayor Mike Bloomberg mutambi uye anotora chikamu mu "musasa wekutya" uyu - uye nenzira dzekuti, zvirinani, vari skating. kumucheto kweNew York State Charter Law, iyo inorambidza zviri pachena kushandiswa kwemari yeruzhinji kupikisa kuedza kwevadzidzisi vezvikoro zvechata kuronga nekutengesa pamwe chete.
Ngano yedu inotanga Muvhuro wapfuura Mbudzi 9, pamusangano wakaitirwa muNew York City's Harvard Club yaisanganisira aimbove Munyori weBush weDzidzo Rod Paige semutauri wekudya kwemasikati. Ndiko uko murongi wemusangano, the Atlantic Legal Foundation, yakatanga zvayo "Charter School Advocacy Program." Mutambo wekutanga uyu waive nemusoro unoti โKuenzanisa Munda Wekutamba: Zvinodiwa Nevatungamiriri veChikoro cheNew York Charter NezveKuronga Kwemubatanidzwa. Izvi zvakaratidza veruzhinji 'kubuda' kwehunyanzvi "kunzvenga mubatanidzwa" uye mafemu ezvemitemo anobira mubatanidzwa munhandare yeNew York State Charter School.
ATLANTIC LEGAL FOUNDATION
Chii chinonzi Atlantic Legal Foundation [ALF]? Nemashoko ayo, iyo ALF inotsigira "hurumende shoma, inoshanda, bhizinesi remahara, rusununguko rwemunhu, sarudzo yechikoro uye sainzi inonzwika mudare redzimhosva." Irwo ruoko rwepamutemo rweakanyanya stridently anti-union corporation uye akabatana ari kure erudyi mapoka. Pamusoro pebasa rayo mundima yechikoro chechata, ALF yakaita mabasa akakosha mukudzivirira makambani makuru emakemikari neoiri kubva kumatare ezvehutano nekuchengetedzwa kwevashandi, mukukurudzira kodzero yekambani ye "kuda" basa, umo vashandi vanogona kuve. kubhadharwa nekudzingwa basa pasina chero nzira yakafanira, uye mukupikisa danho rekusimbisa.
Iyo ALF yakawana mari yayo kubva kune Sarah Scaife Foundation, ivo Lynde naHarry Bradley Foundation, the Jacquelin Hume Foundation, the Claude R. Lambe Charitable Foundation, the FM Kirby Foundation, ivo John M. Olin Foundation, uye Phillip M. McKenna Foundation. Iyo Bradley, Hume, Kirby uye Olin nheyo vatsigiri vakuru ve anti-union National Right-to-Basa Foundation. Iyo McKenna Foundation mutsigiri mukuru we Pennsylvania Kodzero-Kubasa sangano. Nheyo dzeScaife neLambe dzinopa tsigiro kune dzakasiyana-siyana dzinopesana nemubatanidzwa uye zvikonzero zviri kure chaizvo - zita reScaife rakava nemukurumbira wenyika panguva yehutungamiriri hwaClinton seScaife muridzi wenhau dzakadhindwa uye nheyo dzemhuri dzeScaife dzakatsigira nemari kumwe kurwiswa kwakanyanyisa kwenguva iyoyo, Zvikuru kupomerwa kuti maClintons aive neWhite House Counsel Vince Foster akapondwa.
In yayo 2004 mushumo wegore, ALF yakadada kuti yakabudirira sei kubatsira chimwe chikoro chavasina kudomwa cheNew York โkuramba chikumbiro chesangano remubatanidzwa.โ Iyo ALF yanga ichishandawo paNew Jersey charter chikoro chiitiko. Ikoko ALF yakarwira dzosera danho reNew Jersey Commissioner weDzidzo William Liberia kukanzura charter yePaterson Charter School for Urban Leadership nekuda kwekushomeka nekukanganisa mumashandiro ayo emari, utongi uye kutevedza mitemo nemirau yedzidzo. [Mabhuku eCharter School Advocacy Programme ane mashoko akajeka okurumbidza ALF kubva kumukuru wePaterson Charter School.] ALF yakadzivirirawo chinzvimbo cheRed Bank Charter School. mumatare edzimhosva aipomera mhosva yekutora mitemo iyo yakawedzera zvakanyanya dhigirii rerusaruraganda muzvikoro zveveruzhinji zvemudunhu diki reMonmouth County nekuunganidza nekuchengetedza nhamba dzisina kuenzana dzevadzidzi vechichena. MuNew Jersey, ALF inodyidzana neE-3 [Dzidzo Yakanaka kuMunhu wese], boka guru rehurumende rinokurudzira mavhocha.
JACKSON LEWIS
MuCharter School Advocacy Program, iyo ALF inotsamira chose pabasa reanti-union, manejimendi emutemo femu, Jackson, Lewis, Schnitzler & Krupman. Pakati pemafemu akadai emutemo, Jackson Lewis ane mukurumbira wakashata. Chinyorwa chaDecember 14, 2004 New York Times, "Unodzinga Sei Mubatanidzwa? South Carolina Fekitori Inopa Nyaya Yebhuku [$],โ inotsanangura zvakadzama mushandirapamwe wakaitwa paEnerSys bhatiri fekitori, ichitungamirwa naJackson Lewis. Yakatanga muna 1994, apo International Union yeVashandi veMagetsi yakatanga kuronga rutsigiro mufekitari, mushure mekunge vashandi varatidza kushushikana nezve โmapenjeni mashoma, vatariri vanodheerera, kukurumidza kwekugadzira uye matambudziko ekuchengetedza, kunyanya nekupisa kwakanyanya uye lead inoshandiswa mukugadzira. โ Kambani iyi yakaunza Jackson Lewis kuti aite chirongwa chekurwisa mubatanidzwa, asi muna Kukadzi 23, 1995, ruzhinji rwevashandi vachiri kuvhota musarudzo yeNLRB kuti vabatane.
Mushure mekukunda musarudzo dzemubatanidzwa, John Craig, mutungamiri wekambani iyi, akaudza vashandi vake vakuru "tinofanirwa kuita chero zvatiinazvo kubvisa mubatanidzwa uyu, zvisinei nekuti zvingatibatsirei." Kwemakore maviri ekutanga mushure mesarudzo, kambani iyi yakaramba kutaurirana uye kurwisa zvakabuda musarudzo dzeNLRB mudare, kudzamara dare redzimhosva ratonga kuti zvakabuda musarudzo ndezvechokwadi. Pakangotanga nhaurirano, kambani iyi yakati yaizomisa vashandi mabasa kunze kwekunge sangano revashandi rabvumirana kuti vadzimurwe nezvikamu gumi kubva muzana, izvo zvinodzikiswa nehurongwa hwekugovana mari. Nedzvinyiriro inobva kumubatanidzwa wenyika, vatungamiriri vemibatanidzwa yomunzvimbomo vakabvuma nokuzengurira. Kudimburwa kwacho kwakasvika 10%, uye kambani yakanyengedza nzira yekugovanisa kuti ipe vashandi "mabhonasi mashoma." Mubatanidzwa wakaunza mabhonasi aya kune mutongi gava, uyo, mushure memamwe makore maviri ekunonoka, akatonga achipokana nekambani. Asi pari zvino vashandi vakawanda vakatsamwira mubatanidzwa uyu, vasina kukwidziridzwa kwemakore matanhatu, uye mushandirapamwe wemubatanidzwa wekubvisa zvitupa wakatangwa, uchibhadhariswa mari zvisiri pamutemo nemari yekambani uye uchipiwa zano zvisiri pamutemo nenyanzvi dzekambani. Kambani iyi yakadzinga zvisiri pamutemo vakuru vanomwe vemubatanidzwa pamhosva dzakaita se "kunyepa" muhumbowo hwekupokana pamusoro pemabhonasi ekugovanisa mari, kubvisa kucherechedzwa kwemubatanidzwa zvisiri pamutemo, yakatanga imwe denderedzwa rekudzingwa muna 16, uye musi waGunyana 2001, 10, yakavharwa. pasi fekitari pasina kupa chiziviso chepamutemo.
Nepo NLRB isingawanzo shanda mukupindura kudanidziro dzemubatanidzwa dzakadai, mamiriro ezvinhu paEnerSys aive akashata zvekuti Bhodhi rakapa chichemo ichipomera kambani iyi mhosva dzinodarika zana nemakumi maviri dzemutemo wemubatanidzwa. Vakatarisana nechichemo ichi, EnerSys yakabhadhara $120 miriyoni mufaindi kuti igadzirise nyaya iyi, uye akamhan'arira Jackson Lewis, achimupomera mhosva yekutyora mutemo uye nekuirayira kuita zvisiri pamutemo. Kunyangwe mutungamiri wemubatanidzwa wenzvimbo iyi Gailliard achiti "kambani yakapa kambani yezvemitemo - femu yezvemitemo ndiyo yanga ichifambisa chirimwa ichi," uye EnerSys inoti Jackson Lewis akaita "mushandirapamwe wakasimba uye usiri pamutemo wekubvisa mubatanidzwa," Jackson Lewis anosimbirira. kuti yaipa zano rakanaka uye haina chayakanga yaita muSouth Carolina.
Nhasi, fekitari yeEnerSys yakanyarara, uye vazhinji vevashandi vakamboshanda ipapo havachashandi. "Kupfurwa, kushomeka kwekusimudzwa uye kuvharwa kwechirimwa zvese zvatumira meseji ine simba, "akapedzisa New York Times. "Mushure mezvose izvi," akadaro kune vatsigiri vakasimba vemubatanidzwa, "Handifunge kuti ungabhadhara vanhu vari pano kuti vapinde mumubatanidzwa."
JACKSON LEWIS PAALF CONFERENCE
Mukuru Jackson Lewis shamwari Roger S. Kaplan, munyori wezvinyorwa zvakati wandei zvekukunda mishandirapamwe yekuronga mubatanidzwa, anogara paALF Advisory Council. Kaplan akatungamira rimwe remapaneli maviri pamusangano weALF, pamusoro penyaya dzemutemo dzakapoteredza kuronga kwemubatanidzwa, nevamwe vatatu vaJackson Lewis vachiita mharidzo.
Muratidziri wekutanga, Jackson Lewis shamwari Thomas Walsh, yakaonekawo pakokorodzano yegore negore yaMarch wapfuura yeNew York Charter School Association, uko, maererano neAlF, akapa zano nhengo dzebhodhi rechikoro chechata pamusoro peโmiuyo inoshanda uye yepamutemo nokuda kwevatariri vezvikoro zvechata pavanotarisana nokuronga nhamburiko dzeUFT [United Federation of Teachers].โ Walsh akayambira kuti masangano anoronga โmukuita zvekubira,โ saka zvikoro zvechata zvinofanirwa kuita basa rekutanga, zvichipa โruzivo rwechokwadiโ nezvenyaya dzakadai seโmuripo wemibatanidzwaโ uye โmatambudziko ekudyidzanaโ mibatanidzwa isati yaoneka. Kune anopikisa mushandirwi "quirks" kuNew Charter Law, Walsh akanyunyuta: zvikoro zvechata hazvigone kushandisa "mari yeruzhinji" kudzivirira mubatanidzwa. Naizvozvo, mutemo haupi "sarudzo yechokwadi."
Muparidzi wechipiri aive Jackson Lewis shamwari Jeffrey Corrandino. Masangano evarairidzi anoti anotsigira zvikoro zvemacharter, akadaro, asi anongozvitsigira chero bedzi zvakafanana nezvikoro zveveruzhinji. Iwe uchanzwa rhetoric kuti isu tiri "mubatanidzwa mabhasikoro," Corrandino akabvumira, asi hazvisi zvechokwadi. Zvisinei, kutaurirana kwakabatana โkunonetsa,โ โkunodya nguva,โ uye โchiito chisina kunyatsoshanda chakaitwa nemunhu,โ umo munotaurirana pamusoro peโkoma yese, nguva yega yega.โ Zvibvumirano zvinokurukurwa mumamiriro ezvinhu e "hondo yehupfumi" nemubatanidzwa, akachengetedza, uye saka unomanikidzwa "kutengesa" kune "kukanganisa basa rechikoro chako."
Muparidzi wechitatu, Jackson Lewis shamwari Susan Corcoran, yakanangana nezvinofanira kuitwa nezvikoro kudzivirira mubatanidzwa maererano nekuvandudzwa kwemitemo yevashandi uye bhuku rekushandisa.
THE ALF/JACKSON LEWIS ZVINOTAURIRA PAKUDZIVISA MITAMBO MUZVIKORO ZVACHARTER.
Musangano uyu wakaparura โgwaro remutemoโ reALF rekudzivirira mubatanidzwa muNew York Charter Schools, iro rakatsikiswa pasi pemusoro wakafanana nemusangano. Yakanyorwa naJackson Lewis LLP, naKaplan naWalsh vachishanda sevanyori-vanyori. Iyo yakazara nezvikanganiso zvekutanga zvechokwadi maererano neNew York Charter School mutemo. Mumwe haakwanise kupfuura peji 2, semuenzaniso, munhu asati averenga kuti "zvikoro zvinosvika gumi zvakasarudzwa neSUNY Trustees sezvikoro zvisiri zvemubatanidzwa." Chokwadi, iyo NY Charter School Law haaiti chinhu chakadaro. Mutemo une chisungo chekuti vadzidzisi nevamwe vashandi muzvikoro zvecharter izvo zvinovhurwa nevadzidzi vanopfuura mazana maviri nemakumi mashanu vanomiririrwa nemubatanidzwa. MuChikamu 250, 2854, Ndima (b-3), ii, sangano rechata rinopihwa simba rekubvisa otomatiki hurongwa hwekuvhurisa zvikoro zvinosvika gumi zvinovhura nevadzidzi vanopfuura mazana maviri nemakumi mashanu; zvisinei, vadzidzisi nevashandi vari muzvikoro izvozvo vanochengeta kodzero dzakafanana nedzevadzidzisi mune zvimwe zvikoro zvechata kuti varonge uye vatsvage vamiriri vezvibvumirano zvemubatanidzwa kana zvavhurwa. [Tinozviganhurira kune mumwe muenzaniso pano nekuti hatisi mushishi rekuchenesa basa reunyope revashandi vemubatanidzwa.]
Izvi zvikanganiso zvezvakakosha hazvisi zvisingatarisirwi zvachose: chokwadi chechokwadi uye kukoshesa kwakakwirira kwechokwadi haisi iyo chaiyo sutu yakasimba ye "mubatanidzwa kudzivirira" nyanzvi. Asi kupihwa kweruzivo, kumwe kuri kwechokwadi, kumwe kwete, hakusi nyama yebhuku rino. Asi, chinhu ichi chinowanikwa muzvikamu senge zvinotevera rondedzero yezviratidzo zvemubatanidzwa kuronga chiitiko icho manejimendi anofanirwa kutsvaga:
"fomu itsva yezvikwata zvevashandi; "vatungamiri" vatsva vanobuda; nhaurirano dzinopisa dzinomuka pakati pevashandi; iyo "runyerekupe runyerekupe" inova inoshanda zvakanyanya - uye isina kujairika yakaipa munzwi; vashandi vanotanga kusangana mushure mebasaโฆโ
Kunyange mutemo wechikoro checharter uine chikamu [Chikamu 2855, 1, ndima (d)] chinoraira kumiswa kwechata ye "tsika uye maitiro ekutyora uye nemaune ... zvinosanganisira kupindira kana kusarura kodzero dzevashandi," the Kabhuku keALF kunopa rairo yekuti manejimendi ezvikoro zvechata anganzvenga sei chinangwa chakajeka chemutemo. Kuti gadziriro iyi ishande, iyo ALF inosarudza, panofanira kuva
โ[1] maitiro evashandirwi asina kunaka anopfuura mumwe; [2] inoratidza chirongwa chakafanana kana dhizaini nemushandirwi; [3] kuita nemaune zviito zvisiri pamutemo; uye, [4] izvo zviri zvomuzvarirwo wakanyanyisa kana kuti wakashata.โ
Unogona kutyaira marori asiri emubatanidzwa kuburikidza negomba iro, iro ALF naJackson Lewis vachadzivirira nemufaro mudare.
BAZI RENYC REDZIDZO - CHARTER CHIKORO - ALF CONNECTION
Kunyange zvichigumbura, kana kabhuku kaJackson Lewis kana kuti Jackson Lewis mharidzo zvanga zvisingatarisirwe: hapana anotarisira kuti ingwe ichachinja mavara ayo. Chaishamisa, zvisinei, ndechekuti ndiyani akaoneka pane imwe pani pamusangano weALF, uye zvavakataura. Pakati pevaratidziri vakarongwa paive naCaryl Cohen, mumiriri weDhipatimendi reDzidzo reNYC, mubatanidzwa wechikoro. New York City Center yeCharter Chikoro Kunakisa, uye vavambi nevatungamiriri vezvikoro zviviri zvechata Chancellor Joel Klein akoka kuNew York City kuti atange zvikoro zvechata pano, Norman Atkins we. Zvikoro Zvisingawanzoitiki uye Dacia Mutero we Kubudirira Kutanga. [Becca Weinstein weAchievement First akanga ari kumira-mira muminiti yekupedzisira yeToll.] Uncommon Schools anomhanyisa Williamsburg Collegiate Charter School and Excellence Charter School of Bedford Stuyvesant, zvose zviri muBrooklyn, uye Achievement First inoita Crown Heights Elementary Charter School, the Crown. Heights Middle Charter Chikoro uye East New York Elementary Charter Chikoro, ese muBrooklyn. Zvikoro zvese izvi zvakavambwa munaGunyana 2005.
Kubvumirana kwedare iri kwaive, sekutaura kwaNorman Atkins, "zvikoro zvakanaka zvechata zvinozvironga nenzira dzinoita kuti mibatanidzwa isabude." Kungotarisa zvishoma kudarika boka reJackson Lewis, boka iri rakazivisa serisina kutaurirana "pakuda" maitiro ebasa, aine kodzero yekubhadhara uye moto pasina chero nzira yakafanira, kubviswa kwekugara, uye kureba kwezuva rechikoro, vhiki uye. gore. Pakave nekutendeseka kukuru pamusoro pehuwandu hunoshamisa hwekuchinja kwevadzidzisi muzvikoro zvakanakisa zvechata, kusanganisira zvavo - hazvishamise kana ukafunga kuti mune zvimwe zvikoro zvechaja iyi pani inonzi hombe, vadzidzisi vanokumbirwa kushanda maawa gumi, mazuva matanhatu. mavhiki nemakore anopfuura mwedzi gumi neimwe. Asi pakanga pasina kudisa kupinda mukuzvirangarira kupi nokupi, kubvunza kana iyo chaizvoizvo yakanga iri nzira yakanakisisa yokudzidzisa vana kana kuti kukudziridza vadzidzisi vakagona, pazvidzidzo izvozvo kana kuti zvakafanana. Cohen paakataura pakupera kwedare kuti zvimwe zvikoro zvakanakisa zvechata muNew York City zvaive zvikoro zvekushandura charter zvichienderera mberi neUFT inomiririra, zvakaita sekunge muviri wake wangoerekana wava svikiro rezwi kubva kune imwe mativi, yakananga kunze. yenzvimbo yedzidzo yemasikati.
Kana pakambove nemubvunzo pamusoro pekukurudzira kwaChancellor Klein naMayor Bloomberg muchishuvo chavo chekutanga zvikoro zvitsva zvechata muNew York City, kana pakambove nekusahadzika kunonzwisisika kuti vavariro yavo yaive yekugadzira zvikoro zvakawanda zvisiri zvemubatanidzwa. muguta rino sezvavanogona, musangano waNovember 7th - uye basa rakatanhamara rakaitwa mariri nevamiriri veDOE's charter school arm uye charter chikoro network Klein akakoka kuNew York City - zvinoita kuti zvive pedyo zvisingaite kuchengetedza kusava nechokwadi kwakadaro.
Leo Casey anoshandira United Federation of Teachers. Imwe vhezheni yakareba yechinyorwa ichi yakaonekwa Edwize, blog yeUFT, musi waMbudzi 17, 2005. Tinotenda Ed Muir weAFT netsvakiridzo pamusoro peALF.
ZNetwork inopihwa mari chete kuburikidza nerupo rwevaverengi vayo.
dhoneta