Chinyorwa chazvino cheMagazine Ino (Kurume/Kubvumbi 2007) chine chinyorwa chine mapeji mana nemutori wenhau weVancouver Jared Ferrie, chine musoro unoti “Kurambira kosi: sei Canada isingakwanise kuburitsa mauto ayo kubva muAfghanistan."
Nepo munyori achinyatso edza kudzoreredza nhare dzekubvisa kubva kuAfghanistan, zita racho chimwe chinhu chezita risiri iro. Ferrie anogovera imwe nzvimbo kushoropodza hurumende yeHarper pamwe nekusimudzira shanduro yakagadziridzwa zvishoma yemutungamiri webato reLiberal Stephane Dion pamusoro peAfghanistan. Mune zvinotevera, tichatarisa muchidimbu maonero ake pamusoro pehurumende uye vanopikisa zviri pamutemo, tobva tatarisa zvakataurwa naFerrie kuti inenge hafu yevanhu vekuCanada inotsigira "gwaro rinogona kukonzera kutambura kwemamiriyoni eAfghans."
Harper, Dion uye Zvinodhaka
Kupokana kukuru kwaFerrie kuhurumende yeHarper yazvino mutemo weAfghanistan inotarisana nehurongwa husina kunaka hwehurumende. Pano, anotsigira kushushikana kwevazhinji vatungamiriri vepfungwa vanofunga kuti kushaikwa kweruzhinji rweCanada kushingairira mishoni yeAfghan mhedzisiro yeTories 'ham-fisted maitiro ekutengesa hondo kune veruzhinji. Kuna Ferrie, izvi zvinonyatso ratidzwa nekuramba kwegurukota rezvekudzivirirwa kwenyika O'Connor kubvuma kuderera kwekuchengetedzwa kwemamiriro ezvinhu muAfghanistan uye nemafungiro enguruve yeConservative caucus kune humbowo hwenyanzvi hwakapihwa nemutungamiri weSenlis Council Norine MacDonald.
Sekureva kwaSenlis, inotungamira mutemo wezvinodhaka tangi, nharaunda dzepasirese dzinofanirwa kumisa indasitiri yepamutemo yeopium muAfghanistan, ine chinangwa chekupa narcotics inodiwa zvakanyanya kumusika wepasirese. Nepo Ferrie achidzokorora nharo dzaSenlis mukutsigira mutemo uyu, haape ruzivo rwekuti shanduko iyi ingaitwe sei. Nekuti chokwadi chakaoma ndechekuti nehutungamiriri hweAmerica hwemishoni yeAfghan, mikana yekuvhenekerwa kwemutemo mutemo wezvinodhaka unove wakatetepa zvakanyanya. Ferrie anoregedza vaverengi vake pasi kana atadza kuongorora mhedzisiro yeichi chikamu che "kugara kosi".
Mukusvetuka kwakafanana kwepfungwa, Ferrie anoenderera mberi achikwikwidza nzira yemutungamiri weRiberal Stephane Dion. Kukurudzira kwaDion kwechirongwa chitsva cheMarshall yeAfghanistan kunokwezva zvekuti Ferrie anokurudzira vanorwisa hondo kuti vakanganwe chinzvimbo chavo che "mauto" uye vasvetuke muLiberal bandwagon uye vanoda kuti mari yakawanda ishandiswe mukuvakazve uye zvirongwa zvekubatsira Afghanistan. .
Nepo manzwiro pamusoro perubatsiro rwekunze rwakawanda pasina mubvunzo anoyemurika, Ferrie ari parutivi-nhanho nhaurirano yekugoneka kwechirongwa chakadaro, sezvo zvirongwa zvekuvaka patsva nerubatsiro muAfghanistan zvinosangana nezvipingamupinyi zvakakura. Kunze kwekushaikwa kwakakurukurwa zvakanyanya kweNGO-inotungamirwa rubatsiro rwevanhu muAfghanistan, kuedza kwekuMadokero mukusimudzira kupora muAfghanistan kunodzoserwa kumashure nehuwori hwakapararira. Sekureva kweSunday Telegraph "Vakuru vedziviriro muUnited States neBritain vanofungidzira kuti inosvika hafu yerubatsiro rwese muAfghanistan iri kutadza kusvika kune vanhu chaivo." Vane mhosva vanosanganisira vakuru vehurumende vane huori, mapurisa nevechitendero, maererano nechinyorwa (Jan 28/07). Mimwe mishumo inoratidza kuti dzinenge mari dzese dzekuvaka patsva dzinopedzerwa muzvirongwa munharaunda kana pedyo nemaguta. Tichifunga kuti huwandu hweAfghanistan hwakawandisa hwekumaruwa, izvi zvinounza dambudziko rinotyisa riripo mukushuvira kufunga sekwaFerrie.
Peaceniks pasi pemoto
Zvimwe hazvina kunaka kunyatsoongorora maonero aFerrie maererano nemapato maviri makuru ezvematongerwo enyika, sezvo mabatiro aanoita zvinzvimbo nezviito zvavo zviri nani. Ruzhinji rwehasha dzake dzakachengeterwa avo vanodana kuti mauto eCanada abviswe muAfghanistan. Mukuita izvi, Ferrie anoshandisa zvisina chokwadi zvirevo zvevakuru vehurumende yeKarzai, zvakasanganiswa nekusashandisa humbowo humbowo, kupokana kusingatsigirwe, uye kushandisa kwakawanda kwekunyepedzera mukuyedza kushora avo vaasingabvumirani navo. Zviri pamusoro pechikamu chechinyorwa ichi kutsvaga kushandisa kwaFerrie kukanganisa uye manyepo, kunyangwe vaverengi vachikurudzirwa kunyorera vapepeti veMagazini Ino kuti vatevere nyaya yacho navo.
Polls
Mhosva yaFerrie yekuruboshwe inotsamira pane zvakati wandei zvakatorwa kubva kusarudzo mbiri dzemaonero. Asi kunyatsoongorora sarudzo idzi kunoratidza kuti Ferrie ari nani pane husimbe mukutarisa kwake chokwadi. Mukutaura vhoti yakaitwa kuCanWest Media neInnovative Research Group, iyo yakaona kuti 58% yevaCanada vanotsigira basa redu muAfghanistan, Ferrie anotadza kutaura kuti vhoti iri kutaurwa isarudzo yepamhepo. Chokwadi, rusaruro rwunonyatsozivikanwa rwuri musarudzo dzekuzvisarudzira dzakadaro dzinoita kuti dzive dzisingabatsiri kunze kwevanofunga.
Mukutaura nezvesarudzo yepamhepo, Ferrie anokwanisa kunzvenga chero kutaurwa kwesarudzo dzakagadzirwa zviri nani seyakaburitswa muna Gumiguru neStrategic Counsel iyo yakaona kuti "62 muzana yevaCanada uye makumi manomwe muzana eQuebecers vanoda kutaurirana neTaliban" (Toronto Star, Gumiguru 70/20). Sarudzo imwecheteyo yaive ne06% yevakapindura vachitsigira kubviswa kwemauto eCanada kubva kuAfghanistan (Globe & Mail, Gumiguru 54/19). Dzimwe sarudzo dzadzosa zvakafanana.
Ferrie anotonyanya kutaura kana achinge atora vhoti yakatarisana kumeso neWorld Public Opinion yakaitwa muAfghanistan yese muna Mbudzi 2006. Anotaura nezve data yevhoti kakawanda kuti aratidze rutsigiro rweruzhinji rweAfghan kuhurumende yeKarzai uye neruzhinji. gwara remutemo wehurumende. Dai Ferrie akanyatsoverenga chirevo chaanotaura, angadai akawana chokwadi chakajeka chinodzikisira nharo yake. Ongororo iyi inoona kuti 43% yevagari vemudunhu reKandahar neHelmand, uko mauto eCanada anga achirwa, vanofunga kuti kudonhedza hurumende yeTaliban "chinhu chakaipa". Kupfuurirazve, nhamba iyi yakasvetuka kubva mugore rapfuura, apo chete 13% yevaAfghan mudunhu rekumaodzanyemba vakanzwa saizvozvo. Pakanga pari mukati megore iroro apo Canada yakatora mabasa echiuto kubva kumauto eUnited States munharaunda uye takatanga kubatanidzwa kwedu muKandahar. Saka mushure megore rekuvapo kweCanada, vazhinji vevanhu vatinofungirwa kuti tibatsire vari kutanga kuvenga kuvapo kwedu. Kuregeredza uku kusimba kunenge kwechokwadi kutungamirira kunjodzi inodzivisika.
Hukuru hwekutadza kwedu hunojekeswa nenyaya yekuti sarudzo imwechete inoratidza kuti maTaliban anozvidzwa kumaodzanyemba kweAfghanistan, sezvazviri munyika yose. Izvi zvinoita sekunge nyonganiso apo vanhu vanodemba kupidigura hutongi hweTaliban hunogona kugadziriswa nekuona mupepanhau reAfghan kuti Afghanistan Independent Human Rights Commission "yakataura kuti vakanyoresa vanopfuura mazana matanhatu vakakuvara mumabasa akaitwa nemauto ekunze makore apfuura" (Pajhwok Afghan News, Ndira 600/7).
Kodzero Dzevanhu
Kana asiri kudzokorora zvisina tsarukano zvakataurwa nevakuru vehurumende yeAfghan, Ferrie anotaura muchidimbu zvekupomera hurumende yeKarzai, "kunyanya nemumiriri wechikadzi akashinga Malalai Joya." Zvakadaro mutsara unotevera unorondedzera kuti "rekodhi yekodzero dzevanhu yehurumende yeAfghan iri pamberi pemakore makumi matatu apfuura." Zvinonzwisisika kuti sei Ferrie achinzvenga kutaura chero zvakataurwa naJoya maererano nehurumende yenyika yake sezvo asina kujeka muongororo yake yekuti "hapana shanduko yakakosha mukutambura kwevanhu veAfghan" kubva pakabviswa hutongi hweTaliban (Sydney Morning Herald. , Kurume 8/07). Izvi hazvifanire kushamisa mukuona kwezvakataurwa naBarnett Rubin, mutungamiriri weAmerica paAfghanistan. Sekureva kwaRubin, chinangwa chekuedza kweUS muAfghanistan "chaive chisiri chekumisikidza hutongi huri nani hwevanhu veAfghan, asi kutora nekusimbisa varwi muhondo yavo yekurwisa al-Qaida" (Rubin, Council on Foreign Relations, Kubvumbi 2006) .
Joya haasi iye ega anoshoropodza zvakanyanya hurumende yeKarzai. Dhipatimendi reUS State Dhipatimendi reAfghanistan Country Report pamusoro peHuman Rights (2005) rakawana "rekodhi rekodzero dzevanhu reAfghanistan rakaramba riri rakashata", ichitaura nezve "kupondwa zvisiri pamutemo uye kurwadziswa" nemauto ehurumende nevakuru vehondo. Sangano reUnited Development Fund for Women rinocherechedzawo kuti "vakadzi veAfghan vanoramba vari pakati pevakanyanya kuoma pasi rose, kunyanya mumatanho ehutano, urombo, kushayikwa kwekodzero uye kuchengetedzwa kwechisimba" (UNIFEM, Aug 14 / 06). Uye Amnesty International inoshuma kuti "Mhirizhonga yakanangana nevakadzi nevasikana muAfghanistan yatekeshera", ichicherekedza "kuwedzera kwakataurwa mumichato yekumanikidzwa" (AI, Chivabvu 30/05).
Nepo kusarura kuri pachena kwaFerrie kuchimubvumira kuti atarise matambudziko aya, vamwe vatori venhau vekuCanada vanga vasinganyanyi kupenya muongororo yavo yehurumende yeKarzai. Mutori wenhau weCanadian Press Les Perrault akashuma gore rapfuura kuti "Zviremera zveAfghan zvinotsigirwa nemubatanidzwa unotungamirwa neUS, kusanganisira Canada, vachiri kupfigira vechidiki vane mhosva yehungochani uye vakadzi vachipomerwa hupombwe, kuhura kana kutiza varume vavo" (CP, Kukadzi 26 / 06).
Kudzoka kweTaliban
Ferrie anotaura zvakawanda zvekutaura kuti chero kwakakosha kubuda kwemauto eNATO kuchakurumidza kuunza kudzoka kwekutonga kweTaliban. Asi anoita seasingazive mamiriro akaita zvinhu muAfghanistan, sekutaurwa kwazvinoitwa nevatori venhau vakawanda vari kubuda mukati menyika. Pane humbowo hwakawanda hwekuti maTaliban parizvino ari kutonga nzvimbo dzakakura dzenzvimbo yeAfghan. Mhedzisiro yeichi chokwadi, pamwe nekuenderera mberi kwekuvapo kweNATO muchina wehondo, zvakarasika paFerrie.
Achinyora kubva kuAfghanistan kuToronto Star, mutori wenhau Chris Sands akarondedzera chirimo chapfuura kuti "vapanduki veAfghanistan vari kuwana ndima. Nzvimbo yavo yesimba yakapararira kubva kumatunhu eKandahar neHelmand - uko mauto eBritish neCanada ari kurwira kuvadzvinyirira - kutenderedza nzvimbo zhinji dzekumaruwa kumaodzanyemba kweKabul ”(Jun 2 / 06). Saizvozvo, Christian Parenti anoshuma kubva pasi kuti "Hafu yeAfghanistan iri pasi pehutongi hwevapanduki" (Truthdig, Nov 28 / 06).
Chete nekuregeredza zvinhu zvakashata muAfghanistan zvinogona vatsigiri vehondo vakaita saFerrie kupomera vamwe kusapindura mibvunzo yakakosha nezvehondo. Asi humbowo hunoratidza kuti tiri kuronda hondo ichakundikana uye nokudaro tichiwedzera nhamo isingatauriki kunyika inoziva kutambura kwakawandisa.
ZNetwork inopihwa mari chete kuburikidza nerupo rwevaverengi vayo.
dhoneta