Kutanga kwehondo hakuregi kusamboitika kwekurwisa hondo mumavhiki nemwedzi ichangopfuura, uye hazvipi chikonzero chekuderedza kuedza kwedu. Zvakatopesana.
Kurwira shanduko hakufanirwe kuve apocalyptic. Basa ndere kuunganidza zvishoma nezvishoma kuzvipira kuri kukura kudzivirira umambo hweUS, kupokana nedemocracy, zvisiri pamutemo, uye unzenza kurwisa nyika dzechitatu dzepasirese dzisina dziviriro. Tinofanira kuramba tichiramba hondo yeIraq, Iran, Syria, Venezuela, North Korea.
FBI yakataura kuti "kusimba uye kuwanda kwekupokana kwehondo inotungamirwa neUS kurwisa Saddam Hussein kwakura kusvika padanho rinopfuura chero kupikiswa kwakavapo muna 1991." (Wilgoren, NYT, 3/19/03) Hatina kudzivirira hondo iyi, asi handiyo yakakosha pakuongorora kuedza kwedu. Chinhu chakakosha ndechekuti kuedza kwedu kudzivirira hondo dzehupombwe kuri kuramba kuchikura uye kunoramba kuchishanda, uye vari munzira - nzira refu, kuve nechokwadi - kune kwete kudzivirira hondo dzakadai asi nekubvisa zvikonzero zvavo zvemasangano.
Hatifaniri kushandisa mipimo isina kururama kunhamburiko dzedu. Hatifanire kubvuta kukundwa kubva pashaya dzekukunda.
Kurwiswa kweIraq kuchave kunotyisa. Ngozi kuvagari vemo uye kuvanhu pasi rose ichave yakakura. Asi, panguva imwecheteyo, kubuda kwemafambiro makuru, akarongeka, uye ari kukurumidza kuwedzera uye ari kukura achipesana nehondo uye kudyidzana kwepasi rose kwemakambani pasi rose hakusi kungotarisira, kunonakidza, uye tariro. Zviro zvenyika itsva.
Ikozvino kune masimba maviri epamusoro pasirese, iyo New York Times yakaudza vaverengi vayo, mushure mekuratidzira kwaFebruary 15th.
Kune rimwe divi kune muchina wemauto eUS. Kune rumwe rutivi, kune maonero evanhu vemarudzi ose.
Ichokwadi, iyo yekupedzisira haisati yadzora yekutanga. Asi isu tinofanirwa kunzwisisa zvatakaita uye kuwedzera nhamburiko dzedu. Hatifaniri kuchema kutadza kwedu kudzivirira hondo sezvinoreva kuti tiri panzira yokurasikirwa.
Ongororo yechinangwa yakanaka asi kutadza kunoderedza zvatingagona kunyangwe tarisiro yekukunda isati yave pedyo.
Tinovimba kuti mibvunzo inotevera nemhinduro zvichabatsira varatidziri kubata nemamiriro ezvinhu akaoma, ane bongozozo angangotarisana nesu mumazuva nemavhiki ari mberi.
(1) Chinangwa chokuratidzira nokuronga ndechei? Inogona kukunda sei? Rinogona kukunda rinhi?
Isu tinoratidza kuti tihwine zvinobuda zvatinoshuvira - inogona kunge iri mihoro yakakwira, inogona kunge iri danho rekuita, ungave mutemo mutsva, kana, sezvazvino, unogona kudzivirira kana kumisa hondo inotyisa.
Kuratidzira hakuite zvine musoro kuti vakwikwidzi vachinje marongero avo. Uyewo kuratidzira hakukwizire mwoyo yavo uye kutungamirira kushanduko yetsika.
Activism inokunda kana ichinge yagadzira mamiriro mukati mekuti vepamusoro vanoita sarudzo dzakakomba vanonzwa kuti havana sarudzo kunze kwekuchinja maitiro avo. Vanoshanduka kana vafunga kuti kutevera mitemo yavo uye nekusafuratira zvido zvakakurumbira, nengozi yokuti izvi zvinopa simba kupesana, inzira yakaipa yekuita kwavari pane kusaita kudaro.
Panyaya yehondo muIraq, kwakazotevera kugara kweIraq, uyezve kurwa nevamwe vakawirwa neHumambo hweUS, hurumende yeUS - "Asses of Evil" - iri kutsvaga kushandura mitemo yehukama hwenyika. Vanoda kuwedzera kutonga pamusoro pemafuta uye simba rekubhuroka uye kumanikidza mhedzisiro iyo iyo kutonga inopa. Vanoda kuratidza simba reUS kutyisidzira, uye vanoda kunetesa uye pamwe nekuparadza zvachose mutemo wenyika dzakawanda kuitira kuti isadzore zvavanosarudza uye sarudzo. Asi kazhinji zvinoita sekunge vari kuda kugadzira nyika isina unipolar umo simba remauto - iro Washington inotonga - ndiyo chete mari, uye nekudaro inotonga neUS.
Kupokana kwedu kunofanirwa kukwidza mutengo wakakura kwazvo kune vevakuru, vachigadzira mamiriro ezvinhu mavanosarudza kuti kutsvaga kwezvinangwa zvavo hakuchafanirwa nekuti kupokana kwazvinokonzeresa kunodhura zvakanyanya kune zvavanofarira. Panzvimbo pekuwana simba rakakura uye kuzununguka sezvavanoshuvira kubva kuhondo, vepamusoro vanofanirwa kutarisana netarisiro yekuti hondo yedivi-mhedzisiro kusikwa kwevanopikisa vanozivikanwa kunotyisidzira kudzikisa simba ravo uye kusimba.
Ko sangano rinosimudza kutyisidzira kwakadaro ringakunda rini? Chero nguva. Iyo, semuenzaniso, yakatotendesa zvikamu zvakakura zvevaridzi nevatungamiriri vezvematongerwo enyika kuti kurwa neIraq kune njodzi kune zvavanonyanya kukoshesa: masimba avo. Zvinhu izvi, kusanganisira hurumende dzese, zvino zvinopikisa hondo. Kana kupokana kuchigonesa vanhu vakakwana vevakuru kuti hondo inoisa zvido zvavo panjodzi, marongero anozosiiwa.
(2) Inyaya dzipi dzakakodzera dzokuisa pfungwa padziri kuti dzinyatsobudirira? Kuedza kwedu kunofanira kunge kuri kwega here kana kuti nyaya dzakawanda?
Bato rinoshanda kune chaiyo nhanho yarinosvitsa kune vepamusoro chiratidzo chekuti kuramba vachiramba zvinodiwa nesangano kunotungamirira kukukura kwemitengo uye njodzi kwavari. Munyaya yedu yazvino, bato rinofanirwa kuratidza kuenderera mberi kwehondo nekugara muIraq, uyezve hondo inotevera yekurwisa zvimwe zvinangwa, inoburitsa kushorwa kusingade kuunza kuvepo. Iyi ndiyo pfungwa yekupikisa uye yevakakwirira maitiro kune iyo.
Saka, isu tinongoda kubvunza chete, rudzii rwekufamba runosimudza mitengo yemagariro uye inotyisidzira kuva dambudziko rinoramba richikura revakuru? Iri sangano rine pfungwa yakamanikana pahondo imwe chete kana mutemo mumwe chete? Iri sangano rinozopera kana nyaya yekutanga isisiri pamberi? Kana kuti isangano rinotarisana nemutemo unopokana - mune iyi hondo muIraq - zvichijekesa kuti kuenderera mberi kwehondo kuri kuwedzera kufamba, asi iyo inotambanudza uye inokura kugadzirisa humwe hukama hwepasirese uyezve. simba rehurumende nerezvematongerwo enyika, nokudaro richijekesa kuti kana sangano racho richigadzirwa nekuenderera mberi kwehondo, haizongoperi nekuguma kwehondo, uye kuti kana yangounzwa haizongoramba ichienderera mberi, asi ichashanda kuvhiringidza uye kupikisa matongerwo enyika pamativi akasiyana-siyana akaiswa pamberi pepamusoro nevakuru kupfuura hondo pachayo?
Kubvunza mubvunzo ndiko kuupindura. Isu tinofanirwa kuramba tichisvasvavirira uye nekuwedzera mafambiro kana gwara rayo rekusimudzira kuri kukwidza zvinodhura mari yevakuru. Asi isu tinofanirwawo kuratidza humbowo hwakajeka hwekuti kupikisa kuri kukura kuri kuwedzera kupfuura nyaya iripo kusvika kune yekutanga kutsanangura hukama uye masangano enzanga. Izvi ndizvo zvichaita kuti matunhu epamusoro anoshandirwa naBush azvifungire ivo pachavo "gwara redu rehondo riri kutyisidzira hutongi hwedu pamusoro penharaunda, kuri kukanganisa kugona kwedu kuita bhizinesi semazuva ese, kuri kutora chizvarwa chinotevera kubva kwatiri nekuvagadzira. muvengi wedu, kuri kuisa panjodzi zvinhu zvatinokoshesa zvakanyanya kupfuura mutemo wehondo - simba redu nehupfumi - saka, tinofanira kumisa kutsigira kwedu kuhondo.
(3) Panyaya yehondo pachayo, chii chatinofanira kunge tichikurudzira?
Tinofanira kudana kuti hondo ipere nokukurumidza.
Tinofanira kunyanya kushora kutyorwa kwemutemo wepasi rose wekubatsira vanhu, sekushandiswa kwemabhomba emapoka uye zvimwe zvombo zvisina tsarukano, uye kutariswa kwezvivakwa zvinodiwa nevanhuwo zvavo.
Tinofanira kushoropodza kuomerwa nevatori venhau uye tichida kuwanikwa kwenhau dzakazvimirira.
Tinofanira kushoropodza gadziriro dzekubatsira vanhu dzisina kukwana uye tinoda kuti sesimba riri kubata United States igamuchire basa rayo repamutemo rekupa hutano hweveruzhinji.
Tinofanira kusundira demokrasi muIraq, tichipa zvishoma kutaura kune mauto anopinda nechisimba sezvinobvira (uye izvi zvinosanganisira Turkey).
Isu tinofanirwa kusimbirira kuti US ine kodzero yekusava nemafuta eIraq. Ndiyo pfuma yevanhu veIraqi.
Pakangovimbiswa rubatsiro rwevanhu, mauto ese eUS anofanirwa kubviswa muIraq. Chero zvigadziko zvemauto kana kugara kweUS kuisirwa humambo uye hakugamuchirwe.
(4) Ndeipi nzira yakarurama yokushandisa kuti ibudirire zvikuru? Mafambiro edu anofanira kunge ari ega kana akawanda-maitiro uye nemusanganiswa upi?
Fungidzira kufamba kunoramba kuchikura, asi pasina kusiyana-siyana kwemaitiro, uye naizvozvo hapana humbowo hwekuwedzera kudzika kwekuzvipira nekutsungirira, kana kufamba kunoderera asi nhamba dzayo dziri kuderera zviri pachena kuti dziri kuramba dzichizvipira, kana kuti sangano riri kuramba richikura, uye iyo ine chikamu chiri kukura chenhengo dzinoratidza kukura kwechiuto uye kuzvipira uye kubatanidzwa kwavo kunoratidzika nekufamba kwenguva kuva nzvimbo yekuenda kune dzimwe nhengo dzese zvakare.
Hazvisi pachena here kuti sarudzo yekupedzisira inopa tarisiro inotyisa zvikuru kune vepamusoro? Kana zvirizvo, saka hazvisi pachena here kuti basa nderekubatanidza nzira dzakasiyana-siyana dzakakodzera zvikamu zvakasiyana-siyana asi pasina nzira ipi zvayo kuderedza kukwanisa kwesangano kusvika kune vanhu vatsva uye vasina kuzvipira uye kuti vatorewo chikamu chavo?
Chatinoda kubatanidza kana tichizove nekufamba kunoshanda zvakanyanya kusanganisa kwezviitiko zvekusimudza pfungwa, kuratidzira uye kufora, kurova uye kusateerera kwevanhu, zvese zvinotsigirana, uye hapana kana mumwe wavo akateedzerwa nenzira inokanganisa zvimwe zvese. .
Iyo nzira ndiyo inogona panguva imwe chete kuwedzera kufamba, kuita kuti kufamba kuve kunoenderana nenhengo dzayo, uye kusimudza kutyisidzira kukuru kwekuenderera mberi kwebudiriro uye njodzi kune vevakuru.
(5) Chii chinoitika uye tinoita sei kana paine kurwisa kwegandanga kuUS?
Tarisiro yekurwiswa kwegandanga kuUnited States kana vagari vekuAmerica kune dzimwe nyika ndeyechokwadi. Uye kana chero kurwiswa kukaitika kungangoshandiswa neBush manejimendi sezvakashandiswa 9-11 - kuunganidza pfungwa dzeveruzhinji kuseri kwekudzvanyirira kumba uye hutsinye hwakanyanya kunze kwenyika. Kutongwa kwakakomba kwevanhu kunowanzo nyanya kurwiswa nemagandanga uye hutongi hweBush hunoziva izvi. Bush kubvumidzwa kwechiyero kwakakwira kubva pa50 muzana mukupera kwaNyamavhuvhu 2001 kusvika ku89 muzana pasvondo nehafu mushure me9-11. National Security Advisor Condoleezza Rice akabvunza vashandi vake vakuru kuti "unoshandisa sei mikana iyi?" (yakataurwa muNew Yorker, 4/1/02) Uye vakashandisa mari huru.
Iyo Bush manejimendi ichati chero hutsva hutsva hwehugandanga hunoratidza hungwaru hwekuenda kuhondo. Asi nharo iyi haina musoro zvachose; hazviratidzi kuti Bush aive chokwadi asi kuti vatsoropodzi vake vaive.
Bato rekurwisa hondo rakacherekedza, semuenzaniso, zvingangokanganisa chero hondo yeUS kurwisa Iraq kungave "kubhadharisa" kunyorera masangano emhando yeal Qaeda, kushandisa mazwi aGeneral Wesley Clark. Uye chokwadi, ndizvo chaizvo zvanga zvichiitika. (Ona Sebastian Rotella, "Kutyisidzirwa kwehondo muIraq kuri kuwedzera kune dziva revanhu vanogona kutora Al Qaeda nevamwe," Los Angeles Times, 3/2/03; Don Van Natta Jr. naDesmond Butler, "Hasha paIraq Yaonekwa seNew Qaeda Recruiting Tool,” New York Times, 3/16/03.)
Kana ari Saddam Hussein, iyo CIA yakati muna Gumiguru 7, 2002:
Baghdad parizvino inoita kunge irikutara mutsara wekuita kurwisa kwemagandanga neyakajairwa kana CBW kemikari nezvombo zvebhayoloji kurwisa United States.
Kana Saddam akagumisa kuti kurwiswa kunotungamirwa neUS hakuchagona kudziviswa, angangove akanyanya kumanikidzwa kutora zviito zvehugandanga. Hugandanga hwakadai hunogona kusanganisira nzira dzakajairwa, sekunge Iraq isina kuyedza kurwisa kwemagandanga muna 1991, kana CBW (http://www.globalsecurity.org/wmd/library/news/iraq/2002/iraq-021007-cia01.htm)
Vakuru veUS vanonyatsoziva kuti hondo yavo inowedzera njodzi dzehugandanga kurwisa United States. "Pane chokwadi chekuti magandanga achaedza kurwisa United States nevatsigiri vayo," akadaro murongi weDhipatimendi reHurumende rekurwisa hugandanga. Mutevedzeri weMutevedzeri Mukuru weFBI akaudza maseneta kuti pane hungwaru nezvevaIraqi "inoratidza kufarira kutora zviito zvehugandanga kurwisa US" (CNN, 3/18/03) (Uku kumukira kwehungwaru, zvichipihwa kuti zvikwata zvevakazviuraya vakafora mumigwagwa yeBaghdad uye Saddam yayambira kuti vapambi vacharwiwa chero kupi zvako pasi rose.) Hussein anotarisira "kuvhundutsa uye kushamisa" ruzhinji rweUS, achiregeredza chidzidzo chakajeka chenhoroondo chekuti kutya kunowanzo buritsa ruvengo nekugadzirisa. than capitulation. Mutevedzeri weUS anogona kunge akakurisa zvekukurudzira kuzvipira kweIraq, asi hazvizoderedze ruvengo kuUnited States pasi rese.
Saka pane kudzikisa hugandanga hunopesana neUS, mutemo weUS une mhedzisiro - fungidziro yemhedzisiro - yekuwedzera. MuIsrael/Palestine tagara tichiona patani imwe chete iyi. Kana paine runyararo mumhirizhonga, uye mazano erunyararo ari mumhepo, hurumende yeIsrael inotanga kuuraya kana kuvhiya kwemauto kuuraya vanhu vazhinji. Pane kurwiswa kwePalestine kune vanhuwo zvavo, izvo zvinonzi neIsrael zvinoratidza kudiwa kwekuenderera mberi kwesimbi. Pane hukama hwehukama pakati pemagandanga kumativi ese mukuchengetedza kutenderera kwemhirizhonga.
Hutongi hweBush pasina mubvunzo huchaedza kushandisa chero chiitiko chehugandanga kuzvidza uye kunyaradza bato rekurwisa hondo. Mumamiriro ezvinhu akadaro, zvichatiomera kutaura. Asi tinofanira kudaro. Isu tinofanirwa kutora matanho aya:
” Tinoshora kurwiswa kwese kuri kuitwa vanhuwo zvavo uye tinonzwira tsitsi vanhu vakarwiswa seizvi.
"
” Sekuyambira kwakaita CIA nesangano rinorwisa hondo, mutemo wehondo weUS wakatungamira kukurwisa hugandanga hweUS.
"
"Matanho chaiwo ekutarisana nekutyisidzirwa kwehugandanga hunopesana neUnited States ave achikurudzirwa kwenguva refu nesangano rekurwisana nehondo, zvose kwenguva refu (kuchinja mutemo weUnited States wekune dzimwe nyika kuderedza kuvenga kweUnited States munyika) uye kwenguva pfupi (kurega kubva hondo isina kururama uye isingakoshi, kubhadhara zvakakwana vanotanga kupindura, kupa rubatsiro rwemari kumaguta akaparara, kuvaka zvisungo kune, pane kuparadzanisa vanhu vanobva kune dzimwe nyika, nezvimwewo). Kungotora muenzaniso mumwe chete, Congress yaida kuti Dhipatimendi reJustice riuye neshumo panosvika Nyamavhuvhu 2002 pamusoro pekusagadzikana kwenzvimbo dzemakemikari dzeUS. Chirevo ichi hachisati chagadzirwa uye hapana mutemo unoda kuti zvidyarwa zvemakemikari zvizvidzivirire uye hapana federal agency monitors kuti vakaita izvi nekuzvidira. (GAO-03-439) Panzvimbo yekutevera mitemo ingangove yakabata nekutyisidzira kwemagandanga, manejimendi, achipesana nemazano ese, akasarudza nzira yehondo, nemhedzisiro yayo - uye yakaipa - mhedzisiro.
"
(6) Chii chinoitika uye tinoita sei kana mapurogiramu epaTV achifara mumigwagwa yeBaghdad?
Tinofanira kuyeuka kuti zviri nyore sei kuti vezvenhau vape mufananidzo wenhema wezviri kuitika. Pentagon yanga ichiita zvese kuedza kusabvisa vatori venhau vakazvimiririra kubva munzvimbo yehondo, uye nenhepfenyuro inoteerera hazvina kuoma kuita kuti vashoma vatsigiri vekupinda kweUS varatidzike sevanomiririra kuita kweIraq.
MuAfghanistan vezvenhau vakatepfenyura zviono zvevakadzi vaifara vachirasa mabhureki avo sekunge ichi chaive chiitiko chakapararira. Muchokwadi, chaive chiitiko chakaganhurirwa kuKabul, kana kuti zvikamu zveKabul, uye mumwedzi yakatevera zviratidziro zvedu zveterevhizheni hazvina kutarisa nezvehondo yehondo kunze kweguta guru, kana mikana iri kupera yevakadzi, kana kuwanda kwevanhu vanoda rubatsiro. chikafu (chinopfuura icho pasi peTaliban), kana kusasvika kwerubatsiro rwekuMadokero rwakavimbiswa.
Saddam Hussein anozvidzwa nemaIraqi mazhinji uye mamirioni achafadzwa nekudzingwa kwake. Isuwo tinofanira kufara kubviswa kwake, kunyange zvazvo isiri nzira iyo yakaitwa nayo. (Hapana kupokana apa: magumo haapembedzi nzira. Kana mapurisa akabata mhondi, asi akauraya vanhu vakawanda vasina mhosva vakamira muchirongwa, tinofara kuti mhondi yabatwa, asi tinoshora maitirwo azvakaitwa. ) Kuti vanhu vatambe mumigwagwa pakudonha kwaHussein hazvitiudzi kuti vaifarira hondo yeUS (uye avo vakarara pasi pematongo ezvivakwa zvakarohwa nemabhomba eUS vangangodaro vasingapembereri.), uye zvirokwazvo haatiudze kuti chii chavo. mafungiro ndeekuuya kwekugara kweUS. Rangarira kuti Hussein paakaburitsa zviuru zvevasungwa muna Gumiguru apfuura, vanhu vazhinji vakapembera, pasina kutsigira mudzvanyiriri, kwenguva refu kana pfupi. “'Saddam igamba redu,' akadaro mumwe, asati awedzera nekukurumidza, 'nhasi.'” (Washington Post, Gumiguru 21, 2002)
(7) Chii chinoitika uye tinoita sei kana Saddam Hussein akashandisa zvombo zvemakemikari kana mauto eUS akawana zvombo zvinorambidzwa zvekuparadza kukuru? Zvinoreva here kuti Bush aive chokwadi?
Izvi ndizvo chaizvo spin iyo Bush manejimendi ichaedza kuisa pairi. Nechekare, vakuru vakuru vehurumende vakaudza New York Times kuti kuwanwa kwezvombo zvinoparadza zvakawanda “kuchareverera chisarudzo chehurumende chokuenda kuhondo.” (3/19/03) Asi izvi hazvina kusvibiswa zvisina musoro. Nyaya iri pano haisi yekuti Iraq ine WMD. Kunyangwe bato rekurwisa hondo rakanongedza kumhosva dzakawandisa uye kudzvanyirira humbowo hwekunyepedzera (seuchapupu hwakazara hwemutsigiri Hussein Kamel), chirevo chayo chaive chisiri chekuti Saddam Hussein akange asina zvombo zvakarambidzwa. Vazhinji vaongorori vehondo vaive vasina manyepo pamusoro paHussein uye vaiziva kuti aive nehunhu hwekugona kugadzira nekuviga WMD. Asi, chirevo chave chekuti chero zvombo zvingave naHussein (1) zvinokonzeresa kutyisidzira kwemauto kuUnited States kana chero ani zvake kunze kwemiganhu yeIraq; uye (2) njodzi yavaiunza yakanga iri kuramba ichidzikiswa nemaitiro ekuongorora.
Tichifunga nezverekodhi yehutongi hweBush yekumanikidza manyepo, magwaro ekunyepa, uye humbowo hwemifananidzo hwezvakataurwa naHans Blix zvine hungwaru "zvaigona kunge zviri nyore chiitiko," munhu anofanirwa kunge achifungira chero "kuwanikwa" kunotaurwa nemauto eUS. Asi chero chiitiko, iyo chete nzira iyo Bush ichave yakaratidza kuti ndeyechokwadi kana humbowo hukawanikwa hwekuti Hussein aive neWMD yekugona iyo yakaunza kutyisidzira kwemauto kwaisagona kudziviswa kana kuvhurwa nevaongorori.
Uye kushandisa kwaHussein kwezvombo zvemakemikari kurwisa kurwisa kweUS kunoratidza Bush chokwadi. Mukupesana, zvaizosimbisa kuti sangano rekurwisana nehondo rakanga rakarurama. Varwiri vehondo vaive vasimbirira nguva yese - vachitaura neCIA - kuti mamiriro ega angangofungidzirwa kuti Saddam Hussein aizofunga kushandisa chero zvombo zvemakemikari zvaangave nazvo zvaive chaizvo pakaitika kurwisa kweUS. Kushandiswa kwakadaro kwezvombo zvemakemikari kungave kusinganzwisisike uye kutyora mutemo wepasirese, asi hazvingaratidzi kuti zvombo zvingadai zvakashandiswa pasina kurwiswa kweUS (iyo pachayo inonyanya kusaziva uye inopesana nemutemo wepasirese).
(8) Tinopindura sei kune chikumbiro chokuti “tsigirei mauto edu” uye kutaura kwokuti kurwisana nehondo kupandukira?
Kunyangwe hondo isati yatanga, majingoist aizivisa kuti chero munhu asiri mutengesi anofanirwa kutenderera Washington "kutsigira mauto edu." Vanopikisa hondo vane mhinduro dzinoverengeka.
Tinogona kutaura kuti mauto edu muIraq haasati ari munjodzi zvachose nekuti ari kurwisa mupikisi wegumi asina nzira dzakakomba dzekudzivirira Iraq zvakanyanya kurwisa simba repasi rose.
Kana kuti isu tinogona kutaura kuti hupenyu hwemauto eAmerica hahuchakodzeri kutsigirwa netsitsi kupfuura hupenyu hwevaIraqi.
Uye zvechokwadi tinogona kutsanangura kuti kuburitsa mushandirapamwe we "kuvhundutsa uye kutya" nyika haina kururama uye unzenza, uye archetype yehugandanga hunoti US inopesana nayo.
Asi mhinduro yatinopa yakati siyanei. Ndezvekuti isuwo "tinotsigira mauto edu."
Tinotsigira mauto edu achiuya kumba ari mupenyu, asi isu tinotsigirawo mauto edu kuti asauraye vanhu muIraq. Isu tinotsigira mauto edu kusafira muIraq nenzira yekufananidzira kana chaiyo, mumuviri kana mupfungwa. Tinotsigira mauto edu achiuya kumba nemoyo yavo isina kutyoka, kuchengetedza hunhu netsitsi zvakakosha kuti tinzwe kubatana kwechokwadi nevaya vanotarisana nehudzvinyiriri kunze kwenyika, kana imo muno muUS nevarombo vayo vanosvika miriyoni makumi matatu.
Saka: Tsigira mauto edu, vaunze kumba, vape pekugara, vape hutano, vape mabasa akakosha munharaunda.
Tsigira mauto edu uye rimwe zuva vachabatana mukurwira kururamisira kune vese.
(9) Chii chinoitika uye tinoita sei kana hurumende ikadzvinyirira vanhu vanopikisa?
Pane mativi maviri kumubvunzo uyu. Chekutanga ndechekuti tinodzivirira sei kushandiswa kwemitemo inoparadza uye inokuvadza yekudzvinyirira nehurumende. Chechipiri ndechekuti, kusvika padanho ravanokwidza maitiro avo, tinopindura sei.
Izvo zvinotora sarudzo kunze kwekutamba kuhurumende kutenda kwavo kuti kushandisa sarudzo idzi kwaizokuvadza kuedza kwavo kupfuura kunaka. Sei hurumende isingadonhedze mabhomba kune varatidziri mumigwagwa yeWashington DC? Nokuti zvaizotungamirira kukura panzvimbo pokuderera kwevanopikisa; zvaizosimbisa pane kunetesa kuramba. Chinotara sarudzo yehurumende yemaitiro ifungidziro yavo yemhinduro yedu, uye nerudaviro rweruzhinji rwevanhu pakushandisa zano iri.
Chinozodzivirira vanopikisa vakanyanya kupikisa huwandu hukuru hwevapikisi vasina varwi vangazotsamwiswa zvakanyanya nekudzvinyirirwa kwemauto. Chinozochengetedza huwandu hukuru hwevasingapikisi mauto huwandu hwevanhu hunogona kushatirwa zvakanyanya nekudzvinyirirwa kwevanopikisa.
Kana tikabvumira kudzvinyirirwa kutiita kuti tinyarare, kukwanisa kwedu kuzvidzivirira kunoderera uye udzvinyiriri huchakura. Kana tikaramba tichitaura nevavakidzani vedu, vatinodzidza navo, vatinoshanda navo, tikakurukura nezvehondo navo, tikafumura nhema dzehurumende kwavari, tichiratidza kuti rusununguko rwedu tose rwuri mungozi sei, tinogona kuita kuti pave nemhoteredzo umo hurumende isingagoni. siyana nekudzvinyirirwa. Hatifanire kukurudzira paranoia nekuwedzeredza mwero wehudzvanyiriri, asi hatifanire kudzikisa hudzvanyiriri hwehurumende chaihwo.
Muchiitiko chekuti mitemo yekudzvinyirira iri kuuya, mhinduro yedu haifanire kunge yakasiyana nemhinduro yedu kumitemo yehondo pachavo. Iko kuwedzera kufamba, kuwedzera hukama pakati pesangano uye veruzhinji - uye panguva imwechete kuwedzera mamwe mauto ebato uye kuwedzera hukama pakati pavo nevamwe vanopokana.
Hapana chimwe chinodzivirira kudzvinyirirwa kana kunyange mhirizhonga hurumende mhinduro. Kusungwa kuchashandiswa kana vakaremadza kupokana, kudzivirirwa kana vakasimudzira kupokana. Hudzvanyiriri huchashandiswa kana hukaremadza kupokana, kudzivirirwa kana huchisimudzira kupesana.
Tichafanira kuita kudzvinyirirwa asi tinofanira kuzviita mumamiriro ezvinhu ekuenderera mberi tichiita kuhondo ... uye kuenzanisa uye kusanganiswa kwekucherechedza kwatinofanira kupa kune mumwe nomumwe kunofanira kusarudzwa, kwatiri, kunyanya neinowedzera uye inowedzera kupokana. Chero chii chinoshanda zvakanyanya kune izvozvo, isu tinofanira kuzviita. Chero chipi zvacho chisingashande kusvika pakadaro, tinofanira kusiya.
Chiyero chaicho chinogaronetsa kuziva, uye pane budiriro shoma mukurwa pamusoro pedzimwe sarudzo. Ingodziongorora, shandisa simba kune izvo zvinoita senge zvine hungwaru uye zvakakodzera… uye rega vamwe vaitewo saizvozvo.
(10) Chii chinoitika uye tinoita sei kana paine kukanganisa kukuru kune vanobva kune dzimwe nyika, maMuslim, maArabu, nezvimwewo?
Vanhu vanobva kune dzimwe nyika ndivo vari panjodzi huru saka tinofanira kuita nhamburiko dzokuvadzivirira. Hurumende inoteera vatorwa sechikamu chemaitiro ayo esalami, ichicheka chikamu chimwe chevanopikisa panguva, vachitarisira kuti vasiri vanobva kune dzimwe nyika havazoratidziri zvakanyanya nekuti "ivo" kwete "isu." Mhinduro yedu, saka, yakajeka: tinoda kudzivirira zvakasimba kodzero dzekutanga dzevatorwa.
Kuchengetedza kodzero dzevanobva kune dzimwe nyika, kunyanya maArabu nemaMuslim vanonyanya kusarudzwa, kunofanira kuva imwe yekutarisa kwekufamba kwedu, pamwe chete nehondo pachayo, uye nekusimudzira ruzivo rwakakura.
Izvi zvakanaka pahunhu uye zvakare zvine hunyanzvi. Bato risingasimuke mukubatana nevatsigiri varo isangano risingazochengete vatsigiri varo. Bato rinotadza kuchengetedza vanonyanya kutambudzika richaona kuti munhu wese ari panjodzi.
(11) Chii chinoitika uye tinoita sei kana Israeri ikashandisa hondo kuti iwedzere kudzvinyirira kwayo kwePalestine?
Mushure mehuwandu hwevanhu veIraqi, vanhu vari panjodzi zvakanyanya nekuda kwekurwiswa kweUS kuIraq maPalestine. Kubva munaGunyana 11, 2001, hurumende yeIsrael yakashandisa US "hondo yehugandanga" sevhavha uye chikonzero chekuwedzera kudzvanyirira maPalestine.
Nhasi Israeri inotongwa nehurumende yakanyanyisa-kurudyi. Inotungamirwa naAriel Sharon, munhu akawanikwa aine mhosva nekomisheni yeIsrael yekuuraiwa kwezviuru zvevaPalestine pamisasa yevapoteri yeSabra neShitila muRebhanoni, dare remakurukota rinosanganisira Uzi Landau (uyo akakurudzira kuita kune maPalestine "izvo maIraqi akaita kumaKurds. ” [Ha'aretz, 2/20/02]); Gideon Ezra (uyo akati nezvekurwisa kweUS kuIraq "Kunyanya kurwiswa kwacho kunowedzera, kunowedzera kubatsira Israeri kurwisa maPalestine. Kunzwisisa kungava kuti chakanaka kuita muIraq, chakanakirawo kuno." Christian Science Monitor, 8/30/02]); uye nhengo mbiri dzeNational Union Party, inodaidzira "kutamiswa" kwevagari vePalestine kuenda kunyika dzakavakidzana dzeArab (mumwe wevaviri, Benny Elon, akaudza Evangelical Christians muUS "Ngativhurei kuBhaibheri, rinotaura zvakajeka kwazvo. … tinofanirwa kuvagarisa patsva, kuvatamisa.
Mamiriro matatu akanyanya kunetsa: kana Iraq ikarova Israeri nezvipfuro, kana maPalestine achiratidza rutsigiro rweruzhinji rweIraq, kana rimwe boka rePalestine rakatanga kurwisa kwemagandanga kwakakura - zvinogoneka kuti mhinduro yeIsrael inogona kunge iri kudzingwa kwevanhu vazhinji vePalestine. Kunyangwe kana hurumende ikasaita izvi pachayo, kana mhomho dzevaIsrael vakatsamwa vakaedza kudzinga maPalestine, zvinogoneka kuti mauto haapindire - sezvavachangobva kubvumidza vagari vechiJudha kudzivirira maPalestine kubva kukohwa zvirimwa zvavo zvemuorivhi.
Sezvineiwo, hurumende yeUS, iyo inodyidzana nezvido zvehurumende yeIsrael, haidi kuti paitike zvingangokurudzira mafungiro echiArab pamusoro peUnited States hondo neIraq ichienderera mberi. Nepo Washington ingave ichida kubvumidza marudzi ese ehutsinye akanyarara achipokana nemaPalestine, zvinogona kuvharira chero zviito zvinotyisidzira kuve zvinotariswa nenyika. Basa rebato rehondo reUS rinobva rave pachena: isu tinofanirwa kuve nechokwadi chekuti kurwiswa kweIsrael kune maPalestine kunozivikanwa zvakanyanya uye kupikisa zvakanyanya.
ZNetwork inopihwa mari chete kuburikidza nerupo rwevaverengi vayo.
dhoneta