Mibvunzo yekubvunza Mutungamiri Obama nguva inotevera (zvakare kekupedzisira) unokokwa kune imwe yemisangano yake yevatori venhau:
Chii chinonyanya kukosha kwauri - kuparadza ISIS, kupidigura mutungamiri weSyria Assad, kana kurova mapoinzi kurwisa Russia?
Iwe unofunga kuti kana iwe wakataura kune vanhu veAmerica kuti Assad akaita zvakawanda kubatsira uye kununura maKristu muMiddle East makakatanwa kupfuura chero mumwe mutungamiriri wenzvimbo kuti izvi zvinoderedza ruvengo rwunonzwa neruzhinji rweUnited States nevezvenhau kwaari? Kana kuti iwe unogovana maonero emutauriri weDhipatimendi reHurumende akazivisa munaGunyana kuti "Hutongi hweAssad kutaura chokwadi ndiwo mudzi wezvakaipa zvese"?
Nei United States ichiramba ichiremara zvirango zvemari uye kurambidza rubatsiro rwemauto kuSyria, Cuba, Iran nedzimwe nyika asi kwete kuSaudi Arabia?
Chii chinofanira kuita Saudi Arabia kuti irasikirwe nerutsigiro rwakasimba rweAmerica? Kuwedzera kurwadziswa kwaro, kudimburwa misoro, kudimburwa mitezo, kurohwa, kutemwa nematombo, kurangwa nokuda kwokumhura nokuramba kutenda, kana kuroora kwokumanikidzirwa uye kumwe kudzvinyirirwa kwavakadzi navasikana? Wedzera rutsigiro rwayo rwemari yeISIS nemamwe mapoka ejihadist? Reurura kune basa rayo muna 9-11? Kurwisa Israeri?
Chii chinokunetsa zvakanyanya: Kubhomba kweSaudi kwevanhu veYemen kana kubhomba kweSyria kwevanhu veSyria?
Icho chokwadi chekuti ISIS haimborwise Israeri chinomutsa chero mubvunzo mupfungwa dzako?
Zvinokunetsa here kuti Turkey inoratidzika kunge ine chinangwa chekurwisa maKurds nemaRussia pane kurwisa ISIS? Uye inopa kurapwa kuvarwi vakakuvara ISIS? Kana kuti ISIS inobata mafuta ayo panharaunda yeTurkey? Kana kuti iyo NATO-nhengo yeTurkey yanga iri nzvimbo yakachengeteka yemagandanga kubva kuLibya, Chechnya, Qatar, uye kumwewo? Kana kuti gore rapfuura Mutevedzeri weMutungamiriri Biden akataura kuti hutongi hwemutungamiri weTurkey Erdogan hwaitsigira ISIS ne "mazana emamiriyoni emadhora nezviuru zvematani ezvombo"?
Dai NATO yakanga isati yambovapo, ndeipi nharo yaungapa nhasi mukuda kugadzira sangano rakadaro? Zvimwe kunze - sekutaura kungaitwa nevamwe - kuve murandakadzi anobatsira weUS yekune dzimwe nyika mutemo uye nekupa vagadziri vezvombo vekuAmerica nemabhiriyoni emadhora ekutengesa kwakavimbiswa.
Iyo United States inoronga kuburitsa chero humbowo hwayo hunofungidzirwa kuti itsigire zvayakadzokororwa zvekubhomba kweSyria nehondo yemakemikari kurwisa vanhu veSyria? Kufanana nemapikicha akajeka kana mavhidhiyo kubva kune ese eAmerican satellite makamera? Kana kuti humwe uchapupu hunovimbika?
Iyo United States inoronga here kuburitsa chero humbowo hwayo hwainoti itsigire yaidzokororwa yaidzokororwa yekupindirwa neRussia kuUkraine mugore rapfuura? Kufanana nemapikicha akajeka kana mavhidhiyo kubva kune ese eAmerican satellite makamera? Kana kuti humwe uchapupu hunovimbika?
Ko kubatana kwakawanda pakati pehurumende yeUkraine nemaNeo-Nazi kune chekuita nerutsigiro rweAmerica rweUkraine?
Iwe unofungidzira kuti chii chingave chakaitika muHondo Yenyika Yechipiri dai United States yaipikisa kupinda kweSoviet muhondo nekuti "Stalin anofanira kuenda"?
Ungade here kuti Russia haina kuita zvechiuto zvachose muSyria?
Vatongi vanogona here kupa ivo vashoma vevaSyria vanopikisa "vane mwero" vatakanzwa zvakanyanya nezvavo vobvumira vezvenhau kuti vabvunzurudze?
Wafunga kukudza vimbiso yako yekuti "Hapana bhutsu pasi muSyria" nekuda kuti mauto ese eAmerica apfeke sneakers?
Musaudze amai vangu kuti ndinoshanda kuState Department. Anofunga kuti ndinoridza piyano muimba yehure.
Zvidimbu kubva kuDhipatimendi reHurumende zuva nezuva, Mbudzi 24, 2015, zvichitevera kupfura kweTurkey kwendege yeRussia, kwakaitwa naMark Toner, Mutevedzeri weMutauriri:
MUBVUNZO: Mutungamiri Obama vakati vachasvika kuna Mutungamiri Erdogan mumazuva mashoma anotevera.
MR TONER: Ehe.
MUBVUNZO: Haana kutaura nezvaPutin. Izvi zvinonyatsokuisa parutivi rweTurkey, handizvo here?
โฆโฆโฆโฆโฆโฆโฆ
MUBVUNZO: Uri kuti Turkey ine kodzero yekuzvidzivirira; Mutungamiri Obama vakataura zvimwe chetezvo. Ndeipi dziviriro yauri kutaura? Pane anofunga kuti Russia yaizorwisa Turkey here?
MR TONER: Zvekare, ndinoreva, izvi -
MUBVUNZO: Unofunga kudaro here?
MR TONER: Tarisa, ini handisi kuda kuburitsa chiitiko ichi. Ndakataura zvakajeka kuti hatisati taziva chokwadi chese, saka kuti nditaure zvine mutsindo pamusoro pezvakaitika โ kutaura chokwadi, kungave kusaita basa.
โฆโฆโฆโฆโฆโฆโฆ
MUBVUNZO: Kunyangwe iwe ukabvuma shanduro yeTurkey kuti ndege yakafamba mamaira 1.3 mukati meTurkey uye yakatyora nzvimbo yayo yemhepo kwemasekonzi gumi nemanomwe - izvo zvinoenderana neTurkey - unofunga kupfura ndege chaive chinhu chakakodzera kuita?
MR TONER: Zvekare, handisi kuzokupa ongororo yedu panguva ino. Tichiri kuunganidza chokwadi.
โฆโฆโฆโฆโฆโฆโฆ
MUBVUNZO: Muna 2012, Syria yakapfura ndege yeTurkey inonzi yakarasika ichipinda munharaunda yayo. Mutungamiri Erdogan akabva ati, "Kutyora kwemuganhu kwenguva pfupi hakungambove chikonzero chekurwisa." Zvichakadaro, NATO yaratidza kushora kwayo kurwiswa kweSyria pamwe nekutsigira zvakasimba Turkey. Iwe unoona kusawirirana kwemhinduro yeNATO pane izvi?
MR TONER: Nezve izvo Mutungamiri Erdogan angave akataura mushure mechiitiko ichi, ndinokuendesa kwaari.
โฆโฆโฆโฆโฆโฆโฆ
MUBVUNZO: Mauto eTurkoman muSyria akati akauraya vatyairi vendege veRussia pavakadzika nemaparachuti.
MR TONER: Ehe.
MUBVUNZO: Mauto eTurkoman anotsigirwa neTurkey uye ari kurwisana neHurumende yeSyria, ivo vari chikamu chemauto evapanduki ikoko. Unoona here vapanduki ava semauto ane mwero muSyria?
โฆโฆโฆโฆโฆโฆโฆ
MUBVUNZO: Ndiri kuedza โ ndinoreva, unofunga kuti munhu wese ane kodzero yekuzvidzivirira here?
MR TONER: Tataura zvakajeka kuti vanhu vane kodzero yekuzvidzivirira.
MUBVUNZO: Ndizvo here? Kusanganisira hurumende yeAssad?
MR TONER: Kwete. (1)
Hugandanga here kana kuti chitendero? Mubvunzo une basa here?
Kubva pamazuva ekutanga eHondo yeAmerica yeKutyisa, uye kunyange zvisati zvaitika, ndaikurudzira kuona magandanga seasina pfungwa, mapengo akaipa kubva kune imwe nyika. Ndakanga ndisingatendi kuti vaikurudzirwa neruvengo kana shanje yerusununguko rweAmerica kana democracy, kana upfumi hweAmerica, hurumende yenyika, kana tsika, kunyange zvazvo George W. Bush aida zvikuru kuti titende izvozvo. Ndakaramba ndichiti, magandanga acho akanga achisundwa nemakumi emakore ezvinhu zvakaipa zvakaitirwa nyika dzavo nemutemo weUnited States wokune dzimwe nyika. Hapafanirwe kuve nekupokana pane izvi zvandakanyora, nekuti kune yakawanda mienzaniso yemagandanga ekuMiddle East anonyatso tsanangura maAmerican marongero sechikonzero chikuru chezviito zvavo. Uye yakashanda zvakafanana pasi rose. Munguva yemakore ekuma1950 kusvika kuma1980 muLatin America, mukupindura tambo refu yekupindira kwakashata kweWashington, pakanga paine zviito zvehugandanga zvisingaverengeki zvakaitirwa US diplomatic nemauto pamwe nemahofisi emakambani eUS. 9/11 yaive shanduro yepasi rose yeColumbine High School njodzi. Ukadheerera vanhu nguva yakwana vanenge vodzokera.
Muna 2006 Osama bin Laden akafemerwa kuti audze vanhu vekuAmerica kuti vaverenge bhuku rangu rinonzi Rogue State nekuti raiva nemafungiro angu anotevera nemamwe akafanana: โDai ndaiva mutungamiri wenyika, ndaigona kumisa kurwiswa kwehugandanga neUnited States mumazuva mashoma. zvachose. Ini ndaizotanga ndakumbira ruregerero - pachena uye nemoyo wese - kuchirikadzi nenherera, varombo nevanotambudzwa, uye nemamiriyoni akawanda evamwe vakawirwa nehupfumi hweAmerica."
Saka izvi zvinoreva here kuti ndinotsigira ISIS?
Kwete. Ndinofunga kuti ndemumwe wemuunganidzwa unosemesa wevanofungidzirwa kuti vanhu munhoroondo yese. Asi ndinoshamiswa kuti kazhinji sei avo vanovatsoropodza zvakanyanya, uye vanotsigira bato rekuvakunda, vanozeza kushora ISIS se chitendero simba; izvi, sezviri pachena, zvingave zvisina kururama mune zvematongerwo enyika. Nguva pfupi mushure mezviitiko zvinotyisa zveNovember 13 muParis ndakanga ndichiona nhepfenyuro yeTV yeChirungu yeFrench France 24, iyo yakapa hurukuro yetafura yezvakaitika muParis pakati pemhando ina kana shanu dzeFrench dzenjere. Hapana nomumwe wavo akataura shoko rakashata pamusoro peIslam; zvose zvakanga zviri zvemagariro evanhu, zvematongerwo enyika, zvehupfumi, zvepfungwa, nhoroondo, hudzvanyiriri hwekuMadokero, nezvimwewo, nezvimwewo. Hapana here kana mumwe wavo akambonzwa mumwe wevapari vemhosva kana vatsigiri vavo vachidaidzira kuti โAllahu Akbarโ?
Ini ndakabva ndaverenga ongororo yakadzama yechinyorwa chakaitwa naThomas Piketty, munyori wechiFrench weanonyanya kuzivikanwa 700-peji opus. Capital mune makumi maviri nekutanga Century, yakatengeswa zvakanyanya pasi rose gore rapfuura. Maererano nekuongorora mu Le Monde, Piketty akataura kuti kusaenzana ndiyo mutyairi mukuru wehugandanga hweMiddle East, kusanganisira kurwiswa kweParis, uye kuti nyika dzekuMadokero dzine mhosva yekusaenzana uku. Ugandanga uhwo hwakadzika midzi mukusaenzana, anotsinhira kudaro, hunorwiswa zvakanakisisa mune zveupfumi. Kwete shoko pamusoro paMuhammad muzana remakore rechinomwe, Sharia Mutemo muzana remakore rechi7, kana chimwe chinhu chiri pakati. (21)
Tevere, nekupesana, tinotendeukira kubvunzurudzo naMizanur Rahman, mumwe wevanonyanya kusimudzira vezvenhau veIslamic State, uyo Britain neUS vanozviona semuchengeti weISIS. Vakuru veBritain vanonyatsoongorora mafambiro ake uye vakatora pasipoti yake. Anopfeka bhandi remagetsi repagumbo rakapihwa nedare.
Rahman anozivikanwa nezviuru zvake zvematweets uye Facebook zvinyorwa, uye hurukuro dzinopisa paYouTube, dzakagadzirirwa kukurudzira vechidiki vanotambura. Anotsigira pachena hutongi hwepasi rose, nyika inotongwa neIslam sharia mutemo, iyo yaanoti idanho repamusoro rezvematongerwo enyika, zvemutemo uye zvehupfumi kune democracy. Mureza mutema weIslamic State rimwe zuva uchabhururuka pamusoro peWhite House yaanosimbirira, achiwedzera kuti varwi vangangokunda Washington nemauto, asi anotarisisa mazwi ake kuti asapomerwa mhosva yekukurudzira mhirizhonga. Zvakadaro, anopokana, pfungwa yekuparadzira Islam nechisimba haina kukudzwa kupfuura nyika dzekuMadokero dzinopinda muIraq kana Afghanistan kuparadzira democracy. [Ndinoshamisika kana achinyatsotenda kuti mutemo wekuMadokero wekune dzimwe nyika une chekuita nekuparadzira democracy.]
Rahman akadana kurwiswa kweIslamic State mwedzi wapera muParis "mhedzisiro isingadzivisiki" yekutora chikamu kweFrance mumubatanidzwa wekurwisa mauto. of facto guta guru muRaqqa, Syria. โHandifungi kuti pane munhu anofanira kushamiswa chaizvo nezvakaitika,โ akadaro. โMuhondo vanhu vanobhombana. Ini ndinofunga iwo mukana wekuti vanhu vekuFrance vanzwire tsitsi vanhu vemuRaqqa, vanotambura zvakada kufanana pese pavanorohwa nendege dzeFrance - vanhu vakakuvara, kuvhunduka, kushushikana. Hasha dzavanofanira kunge vachinzwa kuIslamic State iko zvino imhando yehasha idzo vanhu veIraq neSyria vanonzwa kuFrance. "
Anotaura kuti hazvina kuipa kuti Islamic State igure misoro yevatori venhau vekuAmerica pane kuti United States iuraye vanhu vechiMuslim mukuramwa kwemhepo. "Ndiri kusimudzira sharia nekuti ndinofunga kuti ndiyo yakanyanya kunaka," Rahman, aimbove accountant uye mugadziri wewebhu, akadaro mubvunzurudzo yechitoro chekofi muLondon. "Ndinofunga kuti zviri nani pane zvatinazvo, uye chii chakaipa nokutaura izvozvo?" [Hapana chinhu kunze kwekunge uchinakidzwa nemimhanzi, zvepabonde, uye doro uye uchiwana kunamata kashanu pazuva kunodzvinyirira zvakanyanya.)
Muna Nyamavhuvhu, Rahman akapomerwa mhosva muBritain ne "kukoka rutsigiro" kuIslam State, uye anotarisana nemakore gumi mujeri kana akabatwa nemhosva. Akasununguka pakubhadhara mari yechibatiso pasi pemamiriro akasimba, kusanganisira bracelet yegumbo.
Rahman akadana kupomerwa kwaakaitwa kuseka uye kutambudzwa kweMuslim. Akataura kuti hapana chaakaita kunze kwekuparidza hunhu hweIslam uye kuti haana kumbobvira atora chero munhu kuti apinde muIslam State kana kukurudzira chero munhu kuita mhirizhonga.
โIslam inopfuura bhuku rine nyaya yekare. Iyo ikodhi yehupenyu, "akadaro, achiwedzera kuti Islam ipurani yezvese kubva kuhutsanana hwemunhu kusvika kune hukama hwenyika. "Haisi nyaya dzekare."
Rahman akasungwa kekutanga muna Kukadzi 2002, paakabhadhariswa faindi yepondo makumi mashanu nekuda kwekusvibisa maposta ebhendi repop rairatidza vakadzi vaive vakapfeka zvinonyadzisa, chimwe chinhu chaaiona sechakashata. [Asi kumanikidza vakadzi kufamba vakanyatsovhara kubva kumusoro kusvika kutsoka, nemaziso chete achiratidza, hakusi kushata? Uye ndeupi mukadzi munyika yose angapfeka saizvozvo pasina dzvinyiriro huru inobva kunzanga inotongwa navanhurume?]
Peter Neumann, mukuru weInternational Center for the Study of Radicalization paKing's College muLondon akataura kuti Rahman ane hunyanzvi hwekunyengetedza vaMuslim kuti ibasa ravo rechitendero kupika kuvimbika kumutungamiri weIslamic State, vachiti Mwari anoda kuti nyika ibatane pasi pehutongi hwejekerere. caliphate, vasina kumbovadaidza zvakanyanya kuti vatamire kuSyria kana Iraq. [Tinofanira kubvunza kuti, Rahman anoziva sei zvinodiwa naMwari? Kune vanhu vasingaverengeki pasi rose vakavharirwa kuzvikoro zvemhirizhonga izvo, ivo vakasimbirira, kuti ndezvekupindura Mwari achitaura navo.] (3)
Vaviri vari muCaliforniaโฆ Tsananguro chete inogona kupa pfungwa dzangu dzechipegani dzisina kunaka pamaitiro avo asingatauriki โkufira kutendaโ. Vaiziva kuti kuita kwavo kwaizoguma nokufa kwavo uye vaitenda zvavakanga vadzidziswa - oh zvakanyanya kudzidziswa muKuran uye vakarovera mumisoro yavo kune imwe nzvimbo sechitendero chete chinogona - kuti kune vakafira kutenda kune mibairo yekudenga mukati. hupenyu hunotevera ... zvachose.
โPasina chitendero kana kuti chisina, vanhu vakanaka vachaita zvakanaka uye vakaipa vachaita zvakaipa. Asi kuti vanhu vakanaka vaite zvakaipa - zvinoda chitendero. " Steven Weinberg, nyanzvi yefizikisi yakahwina Nobel.
Notes
- Dhipatimendi reU.S. Daily Press Briefing, November 24, 2015
- Washington Post, Zvita 1, 2015, p.A11
- Washington Post, November 23, 2015
ZNetwork inopihwa mari chete kuburikidza nerupo rwevaverengi vayo.
dhoneta