"Inoshanda Utopia: Matanho eSosaiti Inodiwa naMichael Albert: Ongororo Essayโ
Oakland: PM Press, 2017. ISBN: 978-1-62963-381-7
Iri ibhuku rinokosha. Zvakakosha nekuti inobvunza mibvunzo isingawanzo bvunzwa, uye inoedza kupa mhinduro dzinoenderana kwavari. Nekudaro, kunyangwe uchibvumirana kana kusabvumirana nemhinduro dzaMichael Albert, kuita bhuku rino kuchabatsira mumwe nemumwe wedu kufunga zvatiri kuda kuona mune ramangwana. Nekuti seizvo Noam Chomsky anonongedza muSumo, nepo "itsva haisati yazvarwa," anowedzera, "Asi mafomu aangafungire achaenderana nezviito zvatorwa iye zvino uye zviono zveramangwana nzanga inovararamisa." Albert ari kuyedza kufambisira mberi zviito nhasi uye chiono chenguva yemberi nzanga kuti itibatsire kusvika kwatingade kuenda mangwana.
Albert ave achitora nguva yakareba mukufunga kwemaonero akadaro uye kuvaka masangano, saka izvi zvinopfuura kungoita seti yemazano akanaka; irwo ruzivo rwakaratidzwa rwemunhu anga akabatana uye achifunga nezve shanduko yemagariro kwemakore anopfuura makumi mashanu. Ane ruzivo rwakawanda, akabatana nevanhu vakasiyana-siyana mumakore apfuura, uye akapa kufunga kwakanakisa panguva ino. Iyi ndeimwe yekuedza kwake kwekupedzisira kutibatsira "kufunga" shanduko yemagariro inodiwa yeramangwana.
Kusiyana nevakawanda vedu, Albert anowedzera kufunga kwake munharaunda yese uye, kusvika pamwero wakati, kupfuura; haangotarisa nezvehupfumi kana kuti murume kana mukadzi kana rudzi kana zvematongerwo enyika, asi anozviona zvese zvakabatana uye zvakapindirana. Kufunga kwerudzi urwu, sekuziva kwangu, kwakatanga kuvandudzwa naAlbert naChomsky pamwe naLeslie Cagan, Robin Hahnel, Mel King, Lydia Sargent naHolly Sklar mubhuku ra1986 rine musoro. Liberating theory, uye Albert anoenderera mberi nazvo. Saka, Inoshanda Utopia.
Bhuku racho rakakamurwa kuva zvikamu zvitatu: โpfungwa dzedu,โ โzvinangwa zvedu,โ โmitoo yedu,โ mukutevedzana ikoko. Ini ndichaongorora bhuku, zvisinei, mune imwe hurongwa: Ini ndichatanga nemaitiro edu, ndichienda kune yedu mazano uyezve toenda kuzvinangwa zvedu. Chikonzero chandichaita zvakasiyana naAlbert ndechokuti ndinotenda kuti kurongeka kwangu kunotifambisa kubva pane zvishoma zvinokakavadzana kusvika kune zvinokakavadzana, uye ini handidi kuti zvinhu zvakanaka zvirasikike nekuve mushure mekufunga kwakakakavadzana.
Pfungwa huru kuchikamu cheโmaitiro eduโโuye rangarira, ndiri kutanga nechikamu chekupedzisira chezvikamu zvitatuโkudiwa kwekuva nechiratidzo chezvatinoda, uyezve hurongwa hwekuti tingazviwana sei. (Nemamwe mashoko, neino pfungwa iri mubhuku, Albert akatoronga chiono chake, uye zvino ari kunyora nezvekuita hurongwa hwekuchiwana.) Sezvaanotaura, โChimwe chezvinhu zvokutanga chatinodzidza kubva kumudzidzisi upi noupi anokoshesa pamusoro pazvo. chero mutambo unopokana-semuenzaniso, chess kana nhabvu-ndizvo kuti tive netarisiro yekuhwina tinofanira kuve nehurongwa."
Zvinoshamisa, zvakadaro, kuruboshwe kunoratidzika kunge kuri kushanda-uye pano, ndiri kuita zvakawanda, asi ndinotenda sezvazviri-pasina hurongwa chaihwo. Hatina kana pfungwa chaiyo yezvatinodaโtine dzimwe tsika dzakanaka, dzakajairika dzinoita kuti tinzwe zvakanaka, asi hapana muono chaiwo weimwe nzira yekugarisana nevamweโ kana yehurongwa hwekuishandisa.
Uye apo Albert anotanga nekunyora nezve zano, anokurumidza kukurukura nezvehutera hukuru, kushaya "kunamira," kwekufamba. Neizvi, ari kureva mamirioni avanhu vakazviona sechikamu chesangano pane imwe nguva yehupenyu hwavo kana imwe uye vakazotama, vachisiya kumashure. Anoona iri sedambudziko rakakura rekufamba kwedu, uye anotora nguva achigadzirisa zvinogona kukonzera kuti tisiye zvakadaro. Izvi zvakakosha kutariswa zvakanyanya nevanosiya.
Nenzira, Albert anoshandisa nhamburiko huru kuti ave akavharirwa sezvaanogona kana achikurukura nzira dzevamwe, kunyangwe idzo dzaasingabvumirani nadzo. Mhedzisiro ndeyokuti munhu haafaniri kubvumirana naAlbert kuti awane zvakawanda kubva mubhuku iri.
Pane zvakawanda zviri muchikamu chino zvandinofunga kuti zvakakosha uye zvakakodzera kufunga nezvazvo, asi zvinoratidzwa nenzira yakatwasuka, isina dzidziso uye inopokana nemasekete, uye ndinokurudzira vanhu kuverenga uye kufunga kufunga kwaAlbert pane izvi. Ndinoda kuenda kune chimwe chikamu, icho chiri pa "pfungwa dzedu," icho chinoratidzirwa sechokutanga chezvikamu zvitatu.
Ichi chikamu chipfupi, asi chakakosha; Ndakazvitaura pamusoro apa pandakataura kuti Albert nevamwe vakagadzira pfungwa iyi mubhuku Liberating theory, uye kuti Albert akaramba achivandudza izvi zvakare. Pfungwa yandiri kureva pano ndeyekuti nzanga inoumbwa nezvikamu zvina zvakasiyana: hupfumi, zvematongerwo enyika, ukama netsika. Izvi hazvina kuparadzaniswa, asi kuti zvakabatana uye zvakabatana. Kunze kwokupa nzwisiso yakarurama zvikuru yenzanga ipi neipi, yakakwana; uye inobvumira Albert kuti abatanidze zvakawanikwa kubva kune anarchism, feminism, radical "rudzi" kufunga, pamwe neMarxism (pamwe nezvimwe) mune imwe, yakabatana yakazara.
Nekudaro, Albert anovandudza pano, zvakare. Muhurukuro yake yehupfumi, anoramba tsika yechinyakare-vatambi modhi yeMarxists (vashandi nevaridzi) uye anoti kune "kirasi inopindira" pakati mamwe maviri, chaanodaidza kuti "murongi" kirasi. Vanhu vari muboka iri remurongi sevanoonekwa sevanhu vanoita basa rinopa simba, "kusiyana nevashandi vari pasi vanoita basa rinoremadza, rinonetsa uye rinonetesa."
Nekushandisa nzira dzakasiyana idzi, Albert anotambanudzira kufunga kwedu, kutanga munharaunda yese (kureva, kwete kuiganhurira kuchikamu chimwe chete kana maviri, asi achifukidza ese mana), uye chechipiri, anowana kunzwisisa kuri nani kwenzvimbo yehupfumi kubva kwainosimudzira kufunga. Uye zvino, ndinoda kuenda kuchikamu chebhuku rake chandinofunga kuti ndicho chakanyanya kukosha, asiwo ndinopokana ndicho chinonyanya kukakavara (uye chinonetsa): "zvinangwa zvedu."
Muchikamu chino, Albert anotarisana nenyaya yekuchinja kukuru kwemagariro evanhu kubva pakutsanangurwa kwezvinhu zvakasiyana-siyana zvinokosha, paanotaura kuti nzanga itsva inofanira kuva yakavakirwa. Hukoshero hwaanosimudzira kubatana, kusiyana-siyana, kuenzana uye kuzvitonga, nemusimboti wekupedzisira unobata pese pazvinogoneka, kunyangwe Albert achiziva kuti dzimwe nguva, sarudzo dzinosanganisira dzinofanirwa kuitwa padanho repamusoro rehurongwa hwemagariro. Kazhinji, zvisinei, anopikisa kuti idzi ndidzo tsika dzinofanira kuvhara chiono chedu chenzanga itsva. Anobva akurukura imwe neimwe yezvikamu zvina zvenzanga.
Chikamu chake chakasimba chiri pamusoro pehupfumi, apo iye naHahnel vakaramba vachishanda kuti vafunge kuti hupfumi hunobatanidzwa, "parecon" kwenguva pfupi, inogona kushanda sei. Albert anofambira mberi "vashandi nemakanzuru evatengi" semafomu ehurongwa anodiwa kuisa hunhu uhu. Anotaura kuti muripo unofanira kuvakirwa panhamburiko nokuzvipira, kwete nemhaka yokuti mumwe munhu akagara nhaka chimwe chinhu. Uyezve, "Basa rako rinofanira kuva rinobatsira munharaunda kuti ripiwe mubairo, asi mubairo hauna kuenzana nekubatsira kwaro."
Chinokosha, anotaura kuti basa rinofanira kugovewazve kuitira kuti munhu wose agovere zvose zviri zviviri โzvakanakaโ neโzvakaipaโ zvekushanda. Mune mamwe mazwi, pachinzvimbo chekuti vamwe vanhu vaite basa rinongonakidza, uye vanhu vazhinji vachiita basa risingafadze - wekupedzisira, mukufunga kwake, ari basa reshit-anopokana kuti isu tinofanirwa kugadzirisa patsva mabatiro atinoita kuti tibvise kupatsanurwa kwakagadzwa. yebasa rinowanikwa munzvimbo dzebasa dzemakambani. Asi izvi zvinosanganisira zvinopfuura mabasa acho pachawo kubatanidza nyaya dzesimba nechiremera zviri mukati memabasa ari nani. Anotsanangura:
โPachinzvimbo chekubatanidza mabasa kuitira kuti mamwe mabasa ape simba zvikuru uye mamwe mabasa anotyisa, zvekuti mamwe mabasa anoburitsa ruzivo nechiremera, mamwe mabasa achingoburitsa kuoma nekuteerera, parecon vanoti ngatiite basa rimwe nerimwe rifananidzwe nemamwe ese pahunhu hwaro. hupenyu uye zvakatonyanya kukosha mumhedzisiro yayo yekugonesa.
"Mukuwirirana nemabasa akaenzana [aanodaidza aya akagadziridzwa seti yevashandi], basa rega rega rinofanira kunge riine musanganiswa wemabasa nemabasa zvekuti simba rose rekuita basa rienzaniswe kune vese."
Uye Albert anopokanidza miuyo yezvemagariro evanhu iyo shanduko yakadaro ingareva kune avo vedu vanoshanda: โBasa redu [harizo]gadzirira vashoma vedu kutonga uye isu tasara kuteerera. Pane kudaro, basa redu [richagadzirira] isu tose kutora chikamu mukuzvitarisira isu pachedu kugadzira, kushandisa uye kugovera. โ
Anoenderera mberi achitaura nezvemasangano ari kushandiswa nhasi kugovera zvigadzirwa, izvo zviri misika kana kuronga kwepakati, uye vanoona zvichishaikwa. Anokurudzira "kuronga kubatanidzwa," uko "vashandi nevatengi vanotaurirana zvese izvi."
Iyi inhoroondo yakaganhurirwa zvikuru yokufunga kwake, uye ndingakurudzira vamwe kuiverenga kuitira kuti vazive kunaka nokuoma kunzwisisa kwokufunga kwake. Pandinoiverenga, pareconโnekusimbisa kwayo kutora chikamu kwemunhu wese munharaunda uye kugoneswa kwemutambi wega wega-ndiyo musimboti wekufunga kwake; Ndinoona kufunga kwake pamusoro pemamwe matunhu enharaunda - zvematongerwo enyika kana hurongwa hwezvematongerwo enyika, mhuri/hama hurongwa uye kudyidzana (zvichireva kudyidzana kwakasiyana kwenharaunda dzakasiyana, mupfungwa dzangu, zvine chekuita ne "rudzi") - hazvina kugadzirwa nenzira yakarongeka. uye akafambira mberi sebasa rake pahupfumi.
Asi iye achiri kuenderera mberi-kupfuura hupfumi, zvematongerwo enyika, hama uye tsika - kukurukura nezve nharaunda kana "inopindirana ecology" nekudyidzana nedzimwe nyika, kuratidza kunetseka uye kufunga nezvepasirese "zvakadzama" kupfuura nyika-nyika, zvakare. seโyakafara,โ tichifunga nezvevanhu vari pasi pose.
Uye panguva yaunopedza chikamu ichi, iwe watove nenhaurirano yakadzama yenharaunda yedu, yakakurudzirwa seti yehunhu kuti itungamirire kuti tinoda kuishandura sei, uye mazano pamusoro pechiono chakakura kuti tipe zano kwatinoda kuenda. .
Uye ini ndinofunga zvakakosha kune zvakataurwa naAlbert, kuzivikanwa kwaari kuti angave asina kuzviwana zvakanaka, kuti mamiriro ezvinhu ashanduke, kuitira kuti kwatinogumira munzira kusave kwaanofanoona nhasi. Nemamwe manzwiโuye ndinotenda izvi zvikuru, pandinotora nzira iyi mubasa rangu-ari kutaura chimwe chinhu sekuti โuku ndiko kufunga kwangu kwakanyanya; fungai, ngatikurukurei, tione kuti tingaivandudza sei, uye ngationei kuti tingaishandisa sei nenzira yakanakisisa inobvira, kunyange kusvikira tagona kuipfuura. Zvadaro, ngatirambei tichienda mberi. " Nemamwe mashoko, haasi kuti โInzira yangu kana kuti mugwagwa mukuru,โ asi ari kukumbira isu tose kuti tipindure, kuitira kuti awedzere kufunga kwake kana kuti, tokupfuura, tobva takudziridza mafungiro iwayo nepatinogona napo. .
Saka, zvakare, bhuku iri ibasa rakasimba, uye ndinofunga rakakodzerwa nechero kufambira mberi. Uye ndinotenda Albert nekuiisa kunze kuti itariswe.
-
Zvandinotaura zvino zvichanangana nechikamu chechipiri chebhuku rake, "Zvinangwa Zvedu." Ndichamupindura noruremekedzo sezvandinogona, sezvandisingabvumirani nazvo, asi handisati ndichizvidza kufunga kwake. Ndinovimba, pfungwa dzangu dzichaita kuti vanhu vatarise uye vaenzanise mazano / nzira, uye vobva vapa zano kuti tingaenderera sei.
Ndinofunga kuti Albert akatora nzira yehungwaru kubasa iri, achiburitsa pfungwa dzake pasina kuvharirwa nemamiriro emazuva ano; nemamwe mashoko, kwete kuganhurira kufunga kwake kune zvingaita sezvinobvira nhasi, asi kuedza kufunga zvaanoda. Kana tikazvisungirira kune zvingave zvichibvira nhasi-kunyangwe pasi penzira-takatokundwa muhondo. Kana tichida zvakatosiyana, sarudzo ye โrevolutionaryโ, chero zvipi, saka tinofanira kuzvibvisa pachedu nhasi. (Zvino, hongu, kana tangokudziridza chiono chedu, saka tinofanira kugadzira zano rekutibvisa kubva pano kuenda uko, uye nehunyanzvi hwekutisunde kuzadzisa zano iroro. Ndosaka Chikamu 3 chebhuku rino chakakosha .)
Zvisinei, zviri kutaurwa, handifungi kuti mazano ake anoshanda nenzira yaanofunga kuti inoita kana kuti yaanoda kuti iite. Ndine matambudziko makuru akati wandei nematauriro ake: (1) hapana kunyatsonzwisisa kuti nzanga yedu yakasvika sei kwairi; (2) zvikumbiro zvake zvinobva pamuenzaniso unoshanda wenzanga (kureva, masangano ese munharaunda anoita mabasa emagariro); (3) anovakira ongororo yake paโmasangano,โ ayo asingambotsananguri; (4) zvinoshamisa, mubasa rinonangana nekupa vanhu simba, hapana vanhu vari kukurukurwa zvakakomba muno; (5) hapana kubatanidzwa chaiko kwezvakatipoteredza mubhuku (kwandiri, rinoverengwa seโkuwedzeraโ); (6) uye hapana nzwisiso chaiyo yehumambo. Ndinofunga dai aizotora zvinonetsa izvi mune inotevera iteration yebasa rake, vaizoisimbisa zvikuru.
Rega nditsanangure. Inenge nzanga yese yave iripo-zvichida pakanga paine mamwe matrilineal societies kare kare, uye tinoziva kuti Cherokee Nation yaitongwa nevakadzi, panguva iyo vachena vakavawana, uye panogona kunge paine mashoma nzanga kubva ipapo, seanopikisa. -examples - yanga iri nzanga isina kuenzana; nokuda kwezvinangwa zvose zvinoshanda, ndinopokana kuti nzanga dzave dzisina kuenzana, dzichitongwa nevarume (kuburikidza negadziriro yenhaka yamadzibaba yavakagadza) vaiva nezvitsama zvikuru zvezviwanikwa. (Handisi kuzofamba nenhoroondo yevanhu pano; kungomisa nharo.)
Izvi zvine marudzi ese ezvimiro zvisina kunaka kune avo vaive kudivi "risina kuenzana" rehurongwa. Kune avo vasina kuramba kudzvinyirirwa, vaigarowana vanhu vari munzvimbo dzisina kusimba mumagariro avo kupfuura ivoโkungava mukati medzimba dzavo kana kunzeโuye vachibudisa hasha dzavo neshungu pavari. Iyo yakareba uye ipfupi pane iyi ndeyekuti vazhinji vedu vakabva kudivi re "vasina mukana" vakakuvadzwa, kungave nekusarura, kusarurana, kusarurana, kusarurana, heterosexism, nezvimwewo, uye zvinogona kubva kunze kwemba yemunhu kana mukati memhuri yako. Izvi zvakakonzera kukakavara kukuru kwevanhu pakati pevanhu avo, zvine chinangwa, vanofanirwa kuve vabatsiri. Kuburikidza chete nekuita imwe nzira yekupikisa uye/kana kubvisa izvi-kungave mukuita budiriro yemunhu, dzidzo yekuziva uye/kana kurwira zvematongerwo enyika-kukuvadza uku kunogona kudzikiswa kana kukurirwa.
Saka, zvinorevei izvi, ndezvekuti tinofanira kubata nevanhu chaivo sezvavanokudziridzwa nhasi. Hatingafungire kuti vanhu vese vakanaka, vane hanya, vanhu vane rudo, uye tinotarisira kuti vanozopindura nemwoyo wese kuchirongwa chinoenderera mberi; tinofanira kuziva kuti vamwe vakavhiringika, vamwe vari munzvimbo dzisina njodzi zvinogona kuita kuti vashandiswe neโmurume,โ uye vamwe vakaita zvinhu zvakashata, nezvimwewo. Tinofanirawo kuziva kuti vanhu vese havadi kutora chikamu. mukuita sarudzo munharaunda kana kupihwa simba; vamwe vanongoda kugara, kunwa doro kana kuputa dope uye kuona mitambo zuva rese.
Nyaya iri pano ndeyokuti hatigoni kufunga kuti vanhu vose vakafanana, vose vakanaka (kana kuti vose vakaipa!), nezvimwewo, asi pane kudaro, tinofanira kunge takagadzirira huwandu hwakawanda hwemaitiro evanhu.
Saka, ndiri kukakavara kuti tinofanira kuziva kuti tiri kurarama munharaunda ine vanhu vakasiyana uye kuti yakakuvadza vazhinji, kunyange vamwe kupfuura vamwe. Iyi ndiyo nhaka yatinofanira kugadzirisa.
Albert anoona nzanga yakavakirwa pamasangano - izvo zvaasinganyatso kutsanangura, uye zvisingakodzeri kukosha kwese kwaanovapa - uye masangano aya "aripo kuti aite mamwe mabasa." Ndiyo imwe nzira yekuzvitarisa nayo, asi inzira yenhoroondo.
Chokwadi ndechekuti nzanga-chaizvoizvo nekuti hadzina kuenzana, izwi rakanyatsojeka nderekuti "kurongeka kwevanhu," iyo yandichashandisa kubva zvino-yakange isina kuenzana kubva panguva dzekare, uye vanhu ivavo vane zviwanikwa uye simba remagariro, vakagadzira masangano mukati. hurongwa hwemagariro hwega hwega hunoitirwa kuchengetedza hutongi hwevakakwirira wega wega. Mapurisa kana mauto kana kurambana kana hukuru hwevachena, nezvimwewo, nezvimwewo, hazvina kusikwa kuti zvishande chero basa muhurongwa hwemagariro kunze kwekuchengetedza hutongi hwevakuru. Ndizvo chaizvo izvo zvakananga-mberi; hapana chakavanzika. Ikozvino, nemazana emakore, chinangwa cheizvi chakagadziriswa nevakuru kuti vabatsire vanhu-uye pamwe nedzimwe nzira dzavakaita, kana kuti pamwe vakabatsira mapoka madiki nemutengo mukuru-asi chinangwa chavo chikuru chave chekudzivirira. uye/kana wedzera mamiriro ezvinhu, kusaenzana, kurongeka kwemagariro evanhu nevakakwirira vanogara vachitonga. Uye tinofanira kugara tichiziva izvi.
Mashoko akanaka, zvisinei, ndeokuti havasi vanhu vose vakagamuchira mirairo yemagariro evanhu yakarongwa nevakuru. Apo patinokura sevanhu, uye tichiwedzera kuziva chokwadi chemagariro chatinotarisana nacho, tinokwanisa kudaira kukudzidziswa, kugarisana kwatakaitwaโkutangira mumba, uye kuwedzera muchechi, hurongwa hwedzidzo, mabasa, nezvimwewoโuye tinogona kuzvigamuchira, kuzviramba kana kuzvishandura. (Vazhinji vedu takadzidziswa kubva kumakore ekutanga kuti hatifanire kuita zvepabonde tisati taroorana; vangani vedu vakagamuchira kurambidzwa uku?)
Uye kana tikapindura pamwe chete-sezvishoma uye zvakaoma sezvazviri-tinokwanisa kufambisa makomo. Tisati tazvarwa, uye tichingotarisa kuUnited States, taive neAbolitionist Movement iyo yakaita basa guru mukupedza uranda. Taive nesangano revashandi rakamuka muma1930 uye ma'40s rinopa vanhu vekuAmerica vanoshandira mararamiro epamusoro-soro emhando ipi neipi yevashandi pasi rose. Muhupenyu hwedu, takaona kubudirira kweHuman Rights/Black Power, Women's, uye Anti-Vietnam War movements, uye mafambiro ese avakafuridzira. Uye takave nemafambiro akahwina budiriro huru, senge Environmental movement, uye takaona mafambiro achibuda seOccupy, Black Lives Matters, #Me Too, etc. Tichitarisa zvatanga tichipokana nazvo, izvi zvakawanikwa uye avo vevabatsiri vedu pasi rose-zvave zvinoshamisa.
Zvino, zviripachena, isu hatisati tanzwisisa kukosha kwekuisa izvi budiriro-uye mune dzimwe nzvimbo, takanga tisina kusimba zvakakwana, kunyangwe dai takaziva kukosha-uye nekudaro, havasati vasimbiswa kuti vamanikidze shanduko dzinoenderera. mumagariro edu. Asi shanduko dzakaitwa: hatisi munyika yandakaberekerwa muna 1951 (pre-Rosa Parks); hatisi munyika ini nevandinodzidza navo kuchikoro chesekondari takapinda muna 1969; uye hatisi munyika yataive mairi isati yatanga Kuderera Kwemari kwa2008-09.
Pfungwa yandiri kuedza kuita pano ndeyokuti pamwe chete, tine ruzivo rwakawanda uye ruzivo pamusoro pekuchinja kwevanhu. Nehurombo, sekucherekedza kwaAlbert, takarasikirwa nekuwana kwakawanda sezvo hupenyu hwevanhu hwachinja uye vabva kure nesangano. Asi izvozvo hazvirambe ruzivo rwedu neruzivo. Uye hazvireve kuti hatigone kudzosa vamwe vevanhu ivavo kuti vabatane nevaya vedu vasina kumbobva.
Kune nzvimbo mbiri hombe dzandinofunga kuti ruboshwe rwakawanda rwakashomeka - rusina kuganhurirwa, asi rwusina kukwana. Nekungwara kwedu kwese uye kushanda nesimba-uye ndinotaura izvozvo pasina kuzeza-HATINA KUNYATSO KUNZWISISA ZVINOGONESA ZVINHU ZVINOITA KUTI TISHANDIRE MAIRI.
Isu kuUS takaudzwa ad nauseum kuti tinogara munyika hurusa pasi rose, kuti munhu wose anoda kutamira kuUnited States, uye kuti vanhu pasi pose vanotarira kwatiri nokuda kwehutungamiriri hwepasi rose; saizvozvo, "isu" tinofanira kudada uye nekuita zvose kuchengetedza hutongi hwedu. Kana United States โikaita manyawiโ pasi roseโngatirangarirei hondo yeVietnam neSoutheast Asia, asi William Blum anoramba achitiyeuchidza, runyoro rwacho rwakarebesaโimhaka yekuti โisuโ tinokanganisa chokwadi; vavariro dzedu dzakanga dzakanaka, asi zvinhu hazvina kufamba nenzira yataida kuti zviitike. Pa, pa, pa, pa.
Asi funga nezveshoko ririmo. Kunze kwezvakajeka, meseji ndeyekuti isu tinzwisise kuti United States inyika imwe chete, uye ongororo yedu inofanirwa kuganhurirwa kune ino nyika imwe chete. Uye, nhamo, kuruboshwe-uye ndiri kushandisa izwi iri zvakanyanya-rakagamuchira ganhuriro iyi zvakanyanya.
Dambudziko nderekuti munhu haakwanise kunzwisisa mashandiro eUS asinganzwisise kuti inyika yekumusha kweUS Empire; kuti tinofanira kutora nzira yepasi rose. Tinogona kukakavara kuti US yanga iri purojekiti yeimperiya kubva payakavambwa muna 1789 (uye kuti chirongwa cheBritish colonial purojekiti isati yavapo kubva pakutanga); tinogona kukakavara kuti chirongwa cheumambo cheUS chakatanga muna 1898, neHondo dzeSpain-America nePhilippine-America; asi chokwadi ndechokuti kubvira muna 1945, chinangwa cheUnited States chave chiri chokutonga pasi rose. Period. (Ona bhuku raAlfred W. McCoy ra2017, โIn the Shadows of the American Century: The Rise and Decline of US Global Power,โ kubva kuHaymarket Books kana kuona wongororo yangu pa. http://digitalcommons.fiu.edu/classracecorporatepower/vol6/iss1/7/ ).
Ikozvino, ichikwanisa kuwedzera simba rayo uye kutonga kune yakawanda yepasirese, iyo US haina kukwanisa kutonga nyika yese kwemakore akati wandei mushure meHondo Yenyika II nekuda kwekuvapo kweUSSR, iyo Soviet. Union. Zvakadaro, payakaparara muna 1991โuye handisi kupokana kuti yaive yakanaka here kana kuti yakaipa; Ndiri kungopokana pano kuti Soviet Union yakaramba kuti US iwane nzvimbo dzepasirese-US yakazadzisa chinangwa chayo chekutonga pasi rose. Uye zvakange zvisina mubvunzo kusvika boka revaIraqi vasina kuwana memo yekuti US yakanga isingakundike, uye ndiani akazoikunda.
Chinhu chikuru chandinoda kutaura ndechekuti hatigone kunzwisisa zviri kuitika munyika ino kusvika tatora nzira yepasi rose; tinofanira kudarika, kudarika, chero nhanho yekuongorora yenyika.
Uye chinhu chakakosha chandanga ndichitaura kwemakore-uye ndicharamba ndichiita- ndechekuti vepamusoro munyika iyi vari kushandisa zviwanikwa zveUS, mauto, mari yemutero, nezvimwewo, kuchengetedza kana zvisiri kuwedzera Humambo hweUS, panguva mutengo wakananga wevanhu veAmerica (kuwedzera kune avo vanobatwa neUS mashandiro mhiri kwemakungwa). Mari inoshandiswa kutsigira mauto eUS haigone kushandiswa kupa hutano hwenyika, kuvandudza dzidzo, kugadzira mabasa, kuvaka patsva zvivakwa, kuderedza kushanduka kwemamiriro ekunze, nezvimwewo. https://faculty.pnw.edu/kim-scipes/wp-content/uploads/sites/20/2017/04/Neoliberal-Economic-Policies-for-US-2009.pdf -Ndiri kushanda kuti ndigadzirise.)
Zvino, zvandakaona mumakore gumi nemashanu apfuura ndichidzidzisa payunivhesiti yedunhu kuNorthwest Indiana-uye iyi haisi iyo nzvimbo yepakati pechinhu chinofambira mberi-ndipo pandinotsanangura zvinhu izvi kuvadzidzi vangu, ndozovabvunza kana vanofunga kuti US inofanira kuramba ichiedza kutonga nyika kana kutarisira vanhu veAmerica, vanenge vachibvumirana kuti United States inofanira kutarisira vanhu vayo.
Saka, gakava randiri kuita pano rakapetwa kaviri: imwe, isu tinofanirwa kutora nzira yepasirese kuti tinzwisise zviri kuitwa nevakuru veUS kutenderera pasirese uye, zviviri, kana tanzwisisa izvi, tinogona kukunda vanhu US kutsigira zvinzvimbo zvedu, uye izvo zvinosanganisira kuvaka kubatana nevanhu pasi rese.
Zvino ndati pane nyaya yechipiri yatisina kubata zvachose: shanduko yemamiriro ekunze uye kuparadza kwezvakatipoteredza. Handisi kuti izvi โzvakashata,โ uye kuti zvinonyadzisa kuti hatichakwanisa kuona mapere anoyevedza ari kushambira kune aya mazaya echando ari mumakungwa. Ndizvo uye zvakanyanya kuipa. Sainzi ichangoburwa yandiri kuverenga ndeyekuti kana tikasaita MAJOR, MAJOR kudzikisira mukugadzirwa kwedu kwemagreenhouse gases - zvese nemafekitori uye nemotokari - nekukasika 2030, ipapo tichaona kutanga kwekuparara kwevanhu. , mhuka nemiti yakawanda panozosvika 22nd Century (kureva, gore ra2100). Zviri nyore. (Uye ini ndinotaura izvozvo, nekuziva kuti chimwe chinhu chinogona kugadzirwa panguva ino kuchengetedza mbongoro dzedu dzakaungana, kuti izvi zvisatambe, asi hapana chinhu chiri kumberi chandakaona chinotopa mukana iwoyo; uye kuenda kuMars kuchave. usazviita.)
Saka zvino zvandanga ndave padandemutande iri, ndoita sei kuti ndidzokere kuongororo yaAlbert? Kutaura chokwadi, ndinofunga maitiro aAlbert akanyanya kuchengetedza. (Ndinoziva, ndinoziva: zvine nharo, ongororo yakanyanya kutenderedza ndeye, zvinoshamisa, ichinzi inochengetedza zvakanyanyaโฆ.)
Rega ndive pachena: kune kufunga kwakawanda kwakanakisa mubasa raAlbert, tichifunga kuti chinhu chakakosha mubato. Asi, zvakadaro, ndinopokana kuti basa rake remafuremu rakanyanya kushomeka.
Mafungiro andinofunga kuti tingaendera mberi ndeaya: kutanga, tinofanira kutora nzira yepasi rose yekunzwisisa zviri kuitwa nevakuru veUS. Uye ipapo, isu tinofanirwa kumisa shanduko yedu yemamiriro ekunze / kuparadzwa kwezvakatipoteredza mukufunga kwedu.
Ndinogona kunge ndisina kururamaโndinozvinzwisisa. Asi ndanga ndichifunga nezve zvinhu izvi kwenguva yakareba, kwemakore makumi matatu apfuura, kusvika pakukura kana kushoma. Ini ndinopokana kuti isu tinofanirwa kudzikisa zvakanyanya kugadzirwa uye isu tinofanirwa kudzikisa zvakanyanya yedu fossil-based transportation system. (Kana iwe uchida kufunga nezve kufunga kwangu zvakadzama, ndapota enda ku http://digitalcommons.fiu.edu/classracecorporatepower/vol5/iss1/2/, ine kumwe kufunga kwangu kwazvino.)
Zvakadaro, tichiri kuda chikafu, pekugara, zvipfeko, dzidzo, tsika, nezvimwe.: tichazvironga sei izvi?
Ini ndinofunga isu tinofanirwa kuchinjika kune pfungwa yebio-nzvimbo, apo vanhu vanozvironga ivo pachavo pahwaro hwekugara kwavo panzvimbo yezvino miganhu yezvematongerwo enyika. (Ona chinyorwa changu pa http://www.greens.org/s-r/48/48-04.html .) Uye zviri panoโmunzvimbo dzakasiyana-siyana dzezvipenyuโkuti tinofanira kuvaka nzanga itsva, dzine rusununguko. Uye iri pano kuti kufunga kwaAlbert hakungoshandi chete, asi kunodiwa.
APA ndipo panonzwisisika parecon kwandiri. Deredza kugadzirwa zvakanyanya, ronga patsva izvo zvasara zvakakosha uye zvinodiwa pahwaro hwenzvimbo dzezvipenyu, nekutengeserana kwematunhu kunogumira kune zvinodiwa, uye kuronga kugadzirwa nenzira dzinotora chikamu, dzinopa simba nekugovaniswa zvakaenzana.
Saizvozvo, shandisa nzira iyi kugadzira hutongi hutsva, uye itsva hama / mhuri network uye hukama hwepakati hwakavakwa pakuremekedza munhu wega wega nepasi. Sezviri pachena, pane zvakawanda zvinoda kuwedzerwa; Handifunge kuti maitiro angu ndeekuve zvese uye kupedza zvese zvinodikanwa zviratidzo. Nekudaro, ichi chiono chekwatinogona kuenda-uye, kusvika tapfuura, kwatinofanira kunge tichiziva takananga kuna Trump kana kusavapo Trump.
Kim Scipes murwiri wezvematongerwo enyika kwenguva refu akaburitsa zvakanyanya muUS nepasirese. Parizvino anoshanda saPurofesa weSociology paPurdue University Northwest muWestville, Indiana. Bhuku rake razvino imuunganidzwa wakagadziridzwa, "Kuvaka Global Labor Solidarity Munguva Yekuwedzera Kuwedzera Kubatana Kwepasirese" (Chicago: Haymarket Books, 2016). Unogona kuwana akawanda ezvinyorwa zvake zvinopfuura 200 pa https://faculty.pnw.edu/kim-scipes/publications/#2.
ZNetwork inopihwa mari chete kuburikidza nerupo rwevaverengi vayo.
dhoneta
3 Comments
James-Unobvunza mibvunzo yakaoma kwazvo, asi ndizvo zvatinoda, uye ndinokutendai nekutora nguva yekuidzikisa pasi.
Chekutanga regai ndibude pachena, handikwanise kupindura mibvunzo yenyu, uye handizivi kuti pane anogona here panguva ino.
Izvi ndizvo zvandinoziva: "kuruboshwe," sezvaunonongedza, wakakamurwa zvakanyanya. Isu hatina kufambidzana nevamwe, taura vanofambira mberi. Uye kunyange zvishoma nemhando dzisiri dzezvematongerwo enyika. Saka, izvo zvinoreva, pakati pezvimwe zvinhu, kuti hatisi kutaura nemumwe, kwete kudzidza kubva kune mumwe.
Chimwe chechikonzero ndechekuti tese takakanganisika-zvisinei nehukuru kana hudiki-nemagariro aripo. Nemhaka yokuti tinotsvaka nyika yakaenzana zvikuru, hatigoni kumanikidzira โzvishuvoโ zvedu kana kuti โzvatinodaโ kune vamwe, sezvinoita bhizimisi kana kuti hurumende; mukuenzanisa, tinotarisa pamwe chete.
Chimwe chinhu ndechekuti isu tese takadzidziswa kuti njere hadzina kutonhorera; kutaura zvazviri, inenge anti-America. Uye mukati memakore makumi mana kana kupfuura apfuura, takabva kune vanhuwo zvavo vachiedza kufunga zvinhu kunze-zvakanyanya kuomera pfungwa dzavo diki, vanoudzwa nevepamusoro uye vezvenhau vemakambani.
Mibatanidzwa INOFANIRA kuva nzvimbo imwe chete yekukunda izvi, asi kumasangano mazhinji-kwete ese, rombo rakanaka-zvavanoda chete pakuwana "zvakawanda" kunhengo dzavo zvakavasiya pasina chimwe kunze kwekufunga kwakadzikama kwakafanana (kunowanzozivikanwa sebhizinesi mubatanidzwa).
Vakuru nevezvenhau vavo vave vachititaurira kwemakore makumi mana apfuura kuti hatifaniri kutarisirana; zvichangotidzora shure. Izvi zvakagadzira yandinodaidza kuti "Ini ndine yangu, fuck you jack" tsika uye kurongeka kwevanhu.
Tinofanira kuramba ushamwari ihwohwo uye kuti kusava nehanya nevamwe; tinofanira kuuya pamwe chete kuti tivake nyika yedu iri nani.
Zviri kuitwa naAlbert nevamwe - mumaonero angu - kuyedza kubatsira mukukunda kusarudzika ikoko, uye kupa mazano ekumberi izvo-kana zvichiongororwa nevamwe-zvinogona kupa mikana chaiyo. Uye hapana anoziva kana zvichizoshanda, asi tiri kuita nepese patinogonaโuye tinovimba, kubudikidza nekunyora kwedu, kushingaira kwedu, kunyora nziyo dzedu, chero, kubaya mwoyo yevanhu, kuvaita kuti vabatane, uyezve. kuti vafunge kuti chii chakaipa uye kuti tingachikunda sei.
Chirongwa chinonakidza chandinoziva pachangu inzvimbo yemagariro enharaunda muMichigan City, Indiana, inozivikanwa sePARC (Politics, Art, Roots, Culture). Zvakatangwa neshamwari dzangu mbiri dzekare-isu tese tiri vekare veMarine avo "vakatendeuka" nekuda kwezviitiko zvedu tiri pabasa-PARC ingori nzvimbo iyo vanhu vanogona kuungana vachizorora, kuita mabiko, kuita misangano, kunzwa vatauri vanofarira, tarisa mafirimu ezvematongerwo enyika, kupinda muzvirongwa zvezvematongerwo enyika (sarudzo nekufamba), nezvimwewo, uye havafanirwe kutenga chero chinhu. Kuva nenzvimbo yakaita seiyi, INOKURUDZIRA vanhu kuti vauye pamwe chete uye-kufemereka!โkutaura kunoratidzika kunge kwakakosha, uye ndiri kutarisa nechido kuti izvi zvinokura sei. (Ona zvinyorwa zvaVince Emanuele pano paZ Net.)
Saka, hongu, nguva yave pedyo, uye tiri mushit yakadzika. Hatina nguva yakawanda, ichokwadi. Handichayeuke mashoko chaiwo, asi paiva nemuimbi-munyori wenziyo ainzi Charlie Murphy, uye akambonyora nezve โBurning Times,โ apo vakadzi vaiurayiwa vachinzi varoyi muSpain (chimwe chinhu chakaita semamiriyoni mapfumbamwe akapiswa kusvika afa. muBvunzurudzo pedyo nekupera kwema9). Zvisinei, Charlie akanyora pamusoro peizvi, uye akati (kudimikira), hongu, tiri mushit yakadzika; asi ino haisi nguva yekuvhunduka; tinofanira kudzikira, kuunganidza masimba edu, kufunga zvakajeka, uye kuvaka zvakasimba, nokuti hatigoni kukorobha zvinhu. Zvakakodzera kufunga nezvazvo.
Sevamwe vakawanda, handingonyore. Ini ndakabatikana nenyika nedzidziso yangu, nekushingaira kwangu, nekuedza kwangu kufunga zvinhu mushure memakore anosvika makumi mana semumiriri. Kana zvichiita, ndinofamba uye ndinotaura nevanhu. (Ndiri muVietnam izvozvi, ndichidzidzisa, sezvandinonyora izvi.)
Ndinofunga kuti chinhu chikuru chokuyeuka ndechokuti kuchinja hakuitiki kamwe kamwe; kuri kudonhera pasi apa, kudhirikira uko. Bernie Sanders haana kugadzira bato raakatungamira, asi akabatsira kwariri, uye akarisimudzira. Uye ndinofunga kuti tese tinofanira kuita zvakafanana (uye handisi kureva kukwikwidza musarudzo): funga zvakajeka, ita nepese patinogona napo, tsvaga vanhu vatinogona kushanda navo, uye kushanda pamwe chete kuvaka nzanga itsva.
Tinogona kuzviita nenguva here? Handizive. Asi pane chinhu chimwe chete chandino CHOKWADI NECHOKWADI: "vakomana nevasikana vakakura" (kureva, vepamusoro nevamiriri vavo) HAVASI kuzotiponesa, uye chokwadi, havape shit nezve chero mumwe wedu. โ tiri masvosve muumambo hwavo, uye vanoda kuti tose tiende.
Saka, ndinovimba, izvi zvave zvichibatsira. Ndinokutendai nekupa mhinduro pane yangu wongororo. Ndanga ndisingareve kuenderera mberi, asi izvi ZVINOKOSHA nyaya-ndatenda zvakare. Bestโ Kim
An$ ndivo vanhu ve telegenic varikuzviita.
Zvinoda kuti zvidaro, uye ndivo vanhu gumi nemumwe chete vari kuita izvi.
Kim,
Zvakanaka iwe wakaongorora bhuku. Asi zvino chii? Albert akanyora rondedzero nezve socialism nguva pfupi yadarika uye pakupedzisira akataura izvi,
โAsi chandinongotaura apa hachisi icho chinhu cheโismโ inodiwa, ingave yazadzwa pamusoro kana chimwewo chinhu, asi, panzvimbo pezvo, kuti chinhu chinofanira kunge chakakura kupfuura chero chinhu chinowanzo tsigirwa, icho. zvinoreva kuti kunyangwe vatsigiri vanopokana neTrumpism yakashata, uye vachimiririra yakakodzera maSanders-ism, ingave inonzi socialism kana kuti kwete, isu tinofanirawo kutsigirana uye nekubatana kurudzira, kuongorora, gakava, uye kusvika pane yakanyatsojeka inotaurika, yakagovaniswa chiratidzo cheicho. tinofarira."
Ongorora, gakava uye usvike. Pfungwa yangu yekukurumidza ndeyekuti, riini uye kwenguva yakareba sei ikozvino zvave 2018 uye, sekureva kwaunoverenga nekutenda, isu tinogona kubatwa mukati memakore manomwe (ona Paul Street naKlein)
Unoongorora bhuku rake. Unonongedzera kuzvinhu zvaunofunga zvakanaka. Iwe unokurudzira zvinhu zvako uye zvikonzero zvako. Unonongedzera papi iwe naiye mungatsigirana. Hukuru. Asi iwe ndiwe chete uye aya angori maonero ako semaonero aGar Alperovitz ekuti Parecon haagoneke ingori maonero ake, kwete iwo iwo chaiwo uye maonero chete. Asi vamwe vakawanda vanofungei? Vakaverenga Practical Utopia? Vakaverenga here pfungwa dzako, zvirevo uye zvemagariro / nhoroondo musings pamusoro pekuti takasvika sei pano uye nemabatiro atinoda kuziva zvese izvo, nekuzvinzwisisa, kuti tibude? Vese vanobvumirana pane ako bio-regional mazano, sisitimu yakashoropodzwa naAlbert naHahnel kare? Albert achakunetsa here?
Ndekupi, nei uye kwenguva yakareba sei uye vangani vanhu vachaverenga gakava rakadaro kana nezveimwe yeiyi shit? Parizvino ivo vanofanirwa kufamba kwese kwese, kupa mubairo uyu ruzivo kubva kune zvakatsemuka uye vaverenge uye vafunge nezvazvo vega. An$ ndivo vanhu ve telegenic varikuzviita.
Ndaigona kuenderera mberi. Asi dambudziko sezvandinoona harisi rekuti Albert anodonha here kana kuti anoroverera pano neapo kana kuti unotadza kana kuroverera pano kana apo, ndeyekuti vangani vanhu vari kuverenga pfungwa dzakadaro remamwe masisitimu, mazano uye zvinangwa zvekuchinja. Pfungwa yacho haisi kunyora nezvazvo, kana kupa hurukuro nezvazvo, kana kudzidzisa vadzidzi kumwe kunhu nezvazvo, ndezvenhamba. Asi zvakare zvishoma nezve izvo zvaunonongedza nezvakoโฆkuti wanga uchiita zvinhu izvi uye uchifunga nezvazvo kwemakumi matatu emakore. Albert anga ari pairi kweanenge mashanu. Izvi zvinoreva kuti imi mese mune ruzivo chairwo uye ruzivo chairwo, pakunyora, kutaura, kutaura, kukurukura, kukakavara, kupopotedzana nezvakadaro, pamwe nenzira yakasimukira nguva zhinji, kusiyana neni. Imi vaviri pakati pevamwe vazhinji.
Nyaya ndeye kubviswa uye kusarudzika chimiro che "makumi emakore mazhinji akaitika" Kuruboshwe, kwete izvo zvazvinoziva kana kuti wako kana Albert anazvo here kana kuti kwete. Kuruboshwe chaiko, mumaonero angu akazvininipisa, haazive kutaura ega, auye pamwe chete nenzira isiri yesekete uye ita chaizvo izvo Albert anoti zvinofanira, kuongorora, nharo uye kukurukura. Kwete izvozvo chete asi zvinoita kwandiri, Kuruboshwe (uye zvechokwadi, izwi iri harina zvarinoreva nekuti rinoreva chaizvo zvandiri kutaura kuti hazvisiโฆchinhu chakabatana) hachina zano rekuwana pfungwa dzayo, pfungwa dzakapararira kwese. nzvimbo uye kuhwanda mumucheto chaiwo uye chaiwo makatsemuka vasingazivi vakawanda laypersons (uyo kupfuura zvimwe havadi kuverenga guru sociological nhoroondo maitirwo kuti nei takasvika patiri), kunze uye kupinda kuziva nhamba huru. Ini ndinokahadzika zvakanyanya kana kunyangwe mukati memubatanidzwa, izvo zvakasara kwavari, iwe uchawana ruzivo rwakakura rweParecon (rasa mabhuku mukamuri yetii) uye mamwe mamwe masisitimu (uye nenzira, Parecon IYE inotsanangurwa muhurongwa, yakajeka uye inowirirana. , sehurongwa hwehupfumi.Zvikonzero kuti mamwe mativi asave chinhu chimwe chete, zvakatonyanya kuoma kuroverera pazviri uye zviviri, Albert ndiye anonyanya kuongorora economist, sezvakaita Hahnel.Ona zvinyorwa zvemamwe mativi naCynthia Peters, Justin Podur naStephen Shalom kuZNet).
Kana ndiri kukanganisa pamusoro penhengo dzemubatanidzwa zvino mukuru. Tanga kubva ipapo. Tanga kupararira kwakaoma kweshoko raAlbert, yechiratidzo chako, uye batanidza zvese izvo kune ese anopfuura makumi matatu kana zvakadaro zvinyorwa zvakabuda muNext System Project, iyo P2P kufamba / nheyo uye zvinhu naBauwens naSiefkes uye avo vanosimudzira. the Commons and commons transition inosanganisira pfungwa dzakaita sedzimwe nyika, shanduko dzatovepo dziri kuitika seCatalan Integral Cooperative uye muKerala, Rojava, Chiapas nedzimwe nzvimbo, kuderera kwakasiyana-siyana uye kupusa mafambiro, seSimplicity Institute muAustralia uye Ted Trainer's The Simpler Way etc.
Asi zvino danho rinotevera nderekuti unobatanidza sei shit iyi kunze kwekungorasa mabhuku, hurukuro, hurukuro nezvimwe zvakadaro kunhengo dzemubatanidzwa kutenderera nyika? Iwe unoita sei chaizvo kuti nhengo dziverenge dzose, dzinzwisise zvese zvakajeka kuitira kuti dziite sarudzo dzine ruzivo uye dziparadzire kune vamwe? Ndakaverenga zvakawanda chaizvo zvinyorwa zveParecon, nharo, zvinoshoropodza nezvimwe, zvakawanda pazvinhu zveP2P, mapepa akawanda ari kubuda mumwana weDemocracy Collaborative's The Next System Project, zvinyorwa uye zvinyorwa kubva kuBIEN nezve mari yekutanga, Takis Fotopoulos's. anarchist type economic system, mazano aTed Trainer, Kovel, Hahnel, nezve donut economics, uye mamwe mazano anopenga uye mamwe anobva kune avo vanonyanya kuverenga nezvekuvandudzwa kweinternet uye nepasirese seKugadzira Ramangwana: Postcapitalism uye Nyika Isina Basa, Utopia For. Realists uye mabhuku akasiyana-siyana pamarobhoti, kuvepo kwakashata uye UBIs, uye zvichienda mberi, zvakadaro ndichiri kunzwa kusakwana UYE zvakanyanya kukosha ndine mukana mudiki wekutaura nevamwe, kujekesa shit, kubvunza mibvunzo, kuparadzira shiti iyi kana kuiburitsa, kwete. izvo zvandisati ndaedza uye ndichiri kuzviita.
Iwe haugone kutarisira kuti vanhu vazhinji vaverenge zvese izvi shit pamwe nenhaurirano dzisingadzivisike dzehuzivi dzinowanzo batwa pamusoro pekuenzana nekururamisira. Zvakawandisa uye vanhu vazhinji havangazive kuti ndeapi masisitimu anofarirwa, kunyangwe achiratidzika seanoshanda uye ari kutungamira mune mamwe matunhu pasirese, ayo anogona kuwedzeredzwa uye kuwedzeredzwa kune imwe nyika system, senge musika capitalism, kana kunyangwe iwe uchigona chaizvo kuve nehuwandu hwemapurojekiti akasiyana uye kuti anoenderana here kana kuti kwete. Kana kuti, masangano akadhindwa uye akatsanangurwa akaiswa munzvimbo yeChiapas, Kerala, Rojava, Catalan uye kumwewo, anoshanda kune mamwe marudzi enzvimbo, semudhorobha kana guta? Muchokwadi, ndeapi aya masangano, anotsanangurwa zvakajeka, uye pane akafanana uye akasiyana uye nei akasiyana? Misiyano iyoyo ingori rudzi rwezvipfeko zvetsika, senge nzira yechiBuddha inotaridzika uye inoitwa muIndia, Tibet, China, Korea, Thailand neJapan. Japanese Zen yakasiyana nenzira kubva kuTibetan, asi ndizvo chaizvoโฆkwete.
Chokwadi ndechokuti, vanhu vakawanda havatombozivi kuti socialism chii chaizvo kana kuti chingava chii. Bvunza mumwe munhu. A layperson. Chii chinonzi socialism Sanders ari kusimudzira? Yakasimba zvakakwana here kutora segwaro chimwe chinhu senge The Climate Mobilization Victory Plan, rudzi rwe hardcore green new deal? Chii chinonzi socialism Corbyn ari kusimudzira uye anogona kuita zvimwe chete? Pane arikusundidzira shiti iyi pavari vese, vachitsvaga zvese, vese vanochinja uye vakakasira semazano anoratidzwa muPictical Utopia neyako? Mibatanidzwa muUS iri kuramba ichitaurirana neavo kumwewo here? Masangano makuru muUS ari kuseri uye anotsigira masangano akazvimirira muChina, India, South Africa, South America, vashandi ivavo vari kubatwa zvakaipisisa sezvakatsanangurwa muSouthern Insurgency naImmanuel Ness? Mibatanidzwa yakazvimirira, iyo Ness anoti pane dzimwe nguva mubhuku, haisi kurwira padanho rehurongwa asi kune yakajairika, mihoro iri nani uye mamiriro. Haisi nguva here iyo zvinhu zviviri izvi, kurwa kudiki kwemutsigiri uye hombe shanduko yehurongwa, yakabatana nekujekeswa?
Haisati yasvika here nguva yekuti nzvimbo kana nzvimbo, zvese zvenyama nezviri pachena, zvigadzirwe nevese vane ruzivo rwekuratidzira, vashandi vemubatanidzwa, vanyori vakanyanya, vatauri, vanofunga, vaoni kuitira kusimudzira mhando dzenhaurirano dzinoenderana uye dzenguva dzose. hwaro? Nzvimbo iyo munhu akasarudzika anogona kushanyira, kuverenga, kukurukura uye kunyange kutaura zvakananga kune vane ruzivo uye chaivo vagadziri vezviono? Kuno nhepfenyuro inogona kuenda kuti iwane ruzivo rwese rwunodiwa, nharo uye nhaurirano. Russell Brand anogona kuenda kupi kuti adzidze? Tose tinogona kupi?
Iyo Inotevera System Project yave pedyo, asi haina kunaka zvakakwana. Iri kutaura nevezvematongerwo enyika senge DiEM 25 muEurope? Mamwe mafambiro epasi rose? Hongu zviri neimwe nzira, asi zvakadaro vazhinji vevanhu havazvizive uye kashoma handioni vanhu vakaita sewe vachisimudzira zvinhu izvi. Panofanira kunge paine zvinongedzo murondedzero yako kune nzvimbo dzakawanda dzinogoneka dzinokurudzira mazano anowirirana sezvinobvira, asi nekuti ingori ongororo pane imwe nzira, semuverengi ndinongowana Albert uye maitiro ako. Hazvina kukwana.
Iyo Inotevera System Project inofanirwa kunge ichisimudzira Inoshanda Utopia UYE RPS/2044, Asi hazvisi. Bhuku raGeorge Lakey rinonzi Viking Economics rinofanira kusimudzirwa here? Bhuku raKate Raworth rinonzi Donut Economics raiva. Ndakaverenga ese ari maviri, asi haana kubatsira zvakanyanya nekuti ini, munhu akasarudzika, ndinoitei neruzivo rwese? LA Kaufman, akanyora bhuku achitarisa kumashure pamakore makumi mana ekuita zvakananga anofanirwa - kwete ini handitaure kuti zvinofanirwa, ndichati ndinogona - kutaura naAlbert akanyora bhuku nezveramangwana rinogona kuitika rechinhu chimwe chete uye. zvakawanda. Ndivo here? Vaizodaro here? Ipfungwa yakapusa here? Pamwe, nekuti ndiri munhu ari kuverenga nekufunga zvese izvi shiti.
Pane kupi kwandinogona kuenda chaizvoizvo kuti ndiratidze kuti munyori wenhau dzakaitika weMarxist nomunyori, Ellen Meiksins Wood akataura kudaro mubhuku rake, The Origins of Capitalism: A Longer View, kuti socialism yemusika haibviri? Misika nesocialism hazvigone kubatanidzwa. Izvo zvinodikanwa zvemusika zvaizokanganisa chikamu chesocialist? Kupi? Uye chikamu chesocialist chinorevei kana kutaridzika? Zvakakosha here? Ndinofunga saka tichifunga nezvemusika wesocialism yakaedzwa uye yakakundikana, uye kuti chiono chaDavid Schweickart, sekutsanangurwa kwazvinoitwa muAfter Capitalism uye zvinyorwa kune imwe nzvimbo, ndizvo chaizvo uye ari Marxist zvakare, uye kuti Albert naHahnel vakatsoropodza socialism yemusika zvakanyanya. Asi, inoramba iri chikamu chemhinduro kune vamwe vari Kuruboshwe vasingafungi nezvemisika, senge dzakatsiga staters. Zvose izvi zvinofanira kukurukurwa here? Uye nani uye vangani?
Unotsanangura sei zvakajeka zvese izvi shit kune vanhu vakasarudzika - uye vazhinji vanozofunga kuti ichokwadi zvese shit nenzira - saka vanokwanisa kuita sarudzo dzine ruzivo nezvemhando yemisika tisiye mamwe mazano nemhando dzakabatana? Kwete chete kune mashoma nutcase radicals achiverenga shit pamarginal kuruboshwe mawebhusaiti asi nhamba huru? Unozviita sei? Uye isu tinofanirwa kuita zvese izvi nekukasira nekuti sekureva kwevamwe, kusanganisira arch rationalist uye mumwe munhu asingatani kugumbuka, Noam Chomsky, nguva yave kupera, saka hatigone kugara pasi nekukwenya zvigunwe zvedu kana kunyora rondedzero isinganzwisisike nezve shit iyi nguva nenguva.
Saka kunze kwezviri pachena kuti tese tinoda kuverenga, kuongorora, kukurukura, nharo, kupokana uye kuisa mukati medzidziso yakanaka, chiono uye zano, tose tinoendepi izvozvi, chaizvo chaizvo? Ini nevamwe toita sei neongororo iyi? Ndeapi makumi emakore akawana radical revolutionary activist agitators vese vachiita nemazano aya? Vari kutozviverenga here kana kuti vese vane hanya nezvavo zvidiki mapurojekiti uye zviitiko zvavanga vachinyanya kunetseka nazvo kwenguva zhinji?
Semunhu akadzikama ndinobvunza uye ndinonyora zvese izvi zvakakomba nekuti ivo ndini ndinorasa pfungwa pachinhu chinopokana uye handikwanise kudzibvisa.