Howard Friel anoshanda pamwe naRichard Falk we Iyo Rekodhi yePepa: Sei iyo New York Times Inorekodha US Foreign Policy (Verso, 2004), uye neFalk ye Israel-Palestine paRekodhi: Iyo New York Times Inorekodha Kusawirirana muMiddle East (Verso, 2007).
Ngatitii iwe uri purezidhendi wekoreji diki muUnited States, kana kuti sachigaro wedare revatariri pachikoro chimwe chete, uye purofesa ane mukurumbira kubva kuyunivhesiti ine simba uye ine mukurumbira muUnited States anorwisa zvisiri izvo boka revadzidzi vako pasina chikonzero. kupomedzerwa hudzvanyiriri hunopesana neIsrael uye kunyanyisa mune zvematongerwo enyika. Ko iwe kutanga uye zvikuru unomira nevadzidzi vakoโkana zvamazvirokwazvo pomero dzacho dzisina hwaro uye dzinoshatirisaโkana kuti unotumira tsamba yakazaruka kupepanhau reIsrael, inonyorerwa kuna purofesa weyunivhesiti ari kutaurwa, uye uchikumbira kunzwirwa ngoni, uchiziva kuti uyu purofesa mumwe chete unogona kuenda kure kure mukuparadza mukurumbira wekoreji yako nezvinopomerwa zvekupokana neSemitism uye anti-Israel kusarurana?
Koreji iri mubvunzo iHampshire College muAmherst, Massachusetts, mutungamiri wekoreji ndiRalph Hexter, sachigaro webhodhi rematirasti ndiSigmund Roos, purofesa ane mukurumbira kunze kweguta ndiAlan Dershowitz weHarvard Law School, uye vadzidzi ndeveHampshire. Bazi rekukoreji reVadzidzi veRuramisiro muPalestine (SJP). Kunyangwe vadzidzi vakazivisa zvisina kufanira kuti koreji yakasiya zvishoma kubva kumari yekudyara inobatsira kugara kweIsrael munzvimbo dzePalestine haina kutaurwa pano, kunyangwe chiri chikamu chakakosha chegakava rakaitika paHamphire campus uye mu Jerusalem Post. Asi, chiri kunetsa pano ndechekuti Hexter naRoos vakaregeredza kudzivirira chikonzero chevadzidzi veHampshire vachipokana neMcCarthy-era yaipomerwa Alan Dershowitz, uye panzvimbo pacho vakaita mutsimba uye neunyanzvi kuedza veruzhinji kuti vasiyane nezviri pamutemo zvezvematongerwo enyika uye zvekubatsira vanhu. yevadzidzi.
Muchikamu chake che "Double Standard Watch" mune Jerusalem Post musi waKukadzi 15, 2009, Dershowitz akataura nezvevadzidzi veSJP kuHamphire se "boka rinopokana neIsrael," "boka rinorwisa-Israel rine hutsinye rakadaidzwa kuti Students for Justice muPalestine," "boka rinopikisa Israel," "anti-Israel". -Vadzidzi veIsrael," uye "boka revadzidzi rinopesana neIsrael." Zvichakadaro, Dershowitz akakoka "rusarura" katanhatu sechikonzero chikuru che "vadzidzi vanopokana neIsrael," ivo vachida kuti koreji irange vadzidzi veSJP nekuda kwe "rusaruro" rwavo. Hezvino zvakanyorwa naDershowitz panyaya iyi: โPanofanira kuva nemutengo unobhadharwa nokuda kwokusaruranaโ; "kusarudzira Israeri chete nokuda kwekuparadzana kwakajeka uye kuri nyore"; "ichi chisarudzo chikuru" (chichitsanangura chirongwa chevadzidzi veHamphire chekubvisa); "Vadzidzi nevadzidzisi [paHampshire] zvakare vanofanira kunzwisisa kuti rusarura rune mutengo warwo"; "kuzvibata hakugone kurarama nerusaruro rwakapetwa ruviri rwakanangana nenyika yemaJuda chete"; uye:
Hampshire ikoreji diki isina simba rakawanda. Asi avo vari kuita mushandirapamwe wenyika [yekudivestment] vanoona "kukunda" kwavo kuHamphire semukana wekuvhura wekuita kuti mamwe mayunivhesiti ane mukurumbira atevedzere nekutora zvikumbiro zvakakura zvakafanana. Iri igomarara riri kutyisidzira kupararira pasi rose, uye rinofanirwa kumiswa pakatangira โ kuHamphire.
Iyo "gomarara" pano ndiyo isina mhirizhonga SJP mushandirapamwe wekubvisa kubva kumabhizinesi anobatsira mukutora kweIsrael makumi mana emakore enzvimbo dzePalestine mukutyora mutemo wenyika.
Panzvimbo pekudzivirira vadzidzi veHamphire College kubva kumhosva yekupokana neIsrael kwavakaitirwa, Hexter naRoos veHampshire vakatanga tsamba yavo Jerusalem Post sezvinotevera: "Anodiwa Alan: Tinotanga nekusimbisa kukoshesa kwedu kukuru kwauri, zvose senyanzvi yezvemitemo uye izwi rine simba rinopesana neSemitism." Uye vachipindura kurudziro yaDershowitz pamusoro pevadzidzi - ichiti "panofanira kunge paine mutengo wakabhadharwa kune rusaruro" - Hexter naRoos vakatsvaga kuvimbisa Dershowitz kuti manejimendi eHamphire achatora "chirango" kuvadzidzi:
Asi isu zvakare takajeka, uye tinokukurudzira kuti utinzwisise zvakajeka, kana tichiti vadzidzi havatauri zvekoreji uye vangasarevesa chikoro nemaune. Ichave, uye inofanirwa kuve, basa rekoreji kuita chero danho rekuranga, zvinoenderana nemitemo yayo yakadzikwa uye maitiro. Chirango chirongwa chemukati chisingagovani neruzhinji.
Kana "chirango chiri chiitiko chemukati chisingagovaniswe neveruzhinji," sekunyora kwakaita Hexter naRoos, nei vachivimbisa kupa vadzidzi veSJP mutsamba yakavhurika kuna Alan Dershowitz, kuitira kuti vanyaradze Dershowitz, asi ari pachena kuti haana. maneja paHampshire College? Uye pakarepo mushure mekusaina zvisizvo kuti vadzidzi veHamphire vaizokandwa pasi pebhazi, Hexter naRoos vakapedzisa nechikumbiro chekupedzisira chekuti varambe vachiurayiwa kubva mudzvinyiriri Dershowitz:
Maonero enyu akanaka ane basa kwatiri; zvine basa, hongu, nekuti uri munhu ane pesvedzero paruzhinji, asi zvinotonyanya kukosha nekuti tinokutora semumwe wemhuri yeHamphire, uye tinovimba kuti uchazvifungawo saizvozvo.[1]
Saka vadzidzi vanowana zviri kuuya kwavari - vachipindurawo kutyisidzira kwaDershowitz kukurudzira kurambidzwa kwemari muHamphire, vachipihwa "anti-Israel hutsinye" pakambasi - ukuwo mutungamiri weHamphire nebhodhi rematirastii vachiteterera nekuteterera Dershowitz kuti arambe ari mukati. Hampshire "mhuri." Muchokwadi, saka, nekubvuma sekudaro kune zvaaida uye kutyisidzira kwake, Hexter naRoos vakasimbisa zvirevo zvaDershowitz zvekuti vadzidzi veHamphire vaive vaita "kupokana neIsrael" pacampus.
Zviripachena, zvisinei, Hexter naRoos vaive neimwe sarudzo: Kuisa mhosva dzaDershowitz dze "anti-Israel rusaruro" kuHamphire tichifunga nezve serial hunhu hwekupomerwa kwakadai naDershowitz vachipokana nevatsoropodzi veIsrael. Kunyangwe zvichikwenya pamusoro, rekodhi iri pazasi yekusvibisa maitiro aDershowitz evamwe vazhinji sevakakurisa, vavengi veIsrael vanopokana neSemitic vanozopa mamwe mamiriro anodiwa pamhando yezvipomero izvi, uye nhoroondo yekupomerwa kwevadzidzi veHamphire, izvo, zvinosuruvarisa. , vaiita sevakatenderwa uye vaitsigirwa napurezidhendi nevatarisiri vekoreji.
Bhuku raDershowitz razvino, Nyaya Yevavengi veIsraeri (2008), ichokwadi chinyorwa cheNixon-esque chevavengi-chaizvo rondedzero yevavengi-yevatsoropodzi vari pamutemo vemitemo yeIsrael. Ndichiri kunyora rondedzero yevavengi vaNixon, White House zano Charles Colson akatsanangura Bernard Feld, nyanzvi yeMIT yefizikisi uye mutsigiri wekuderedzwa kwezvombo zvenyukireya, seanogamuchira "mari inorema kuruboshwe," mutori wenhau Daniel Schorr se "muvengi chaiye wenhau." munyori Mary McGrory semunyori we "zuva nezuva kuvenga Nixon zvinyorwa," uye mutambi Paul Newman semutsigiri we "radic-lib zvikonzero."[2] Rondedzero yevavengi yakaunganidzwa naDershowitz mubhuku rake ra2008, ine aimbova mutungamiri weUS, nyanzvi dzedzidzo, uye masangano anorwira kodzero dzevanhu, inoratidzwa nenzira ine hutsinye hwakanyanya.
Nezve aimbova Mutungamiriri Jimmy Carter, Dershowitz akanyora kuti: "Chero chikonzero kana zvikonzero zvekuti Jimmy Carter achangobuda mugwara rerusarura, nhoroondo haizomutongi nemutsa."[3] Mubvunzurudzo paShalom TV muIsrael, Dershowitz akati: "Jimmy Carter atova munhu anopesana neIsrael, zvekuti kune imwe nzvimbo inokosha mugehena yakachengeterwa mumwe munhu akadaro."[4] Izvi ndizvo zvaida kutsigirwa naHexter naRoos, pamusoro peDershowitz vachidaidza vadzidzi veHampshire sevanopesana neIsrael, pavakanyorera Dershowitz Jerusalem Post kuti "maonero ako akanaka ane basa kwatiri"?
Pamusoro paJohn J. Mearsheimer, R. Wendell Harrison Distinguished Service Purofesa wePolitical Science paYunivhesiti yeChicago, naStephen M. Walt, Robert naRenee Belfer Purofesa weInternational Affairs paJohn F. Kennedy Chikoro cheHurumende paHarvard University. , avo vakanyora pamwe chete Iyo Israel Lobby uye US Foreign Policy (2007), Dershowitz akanyora kuti "ivo vane ruvengo vakasiya nharo dzevadzidzi uye maitiro ehurumende kuitira kuti vave magamba-nyeredzi ekurwisana neIsrael."[5] Izvi zvinosanganisirwa mune izvo Hexter naRoos vanoyemura nezveDershowitz?
Nekuda kwekuti Amnesty International neHuman Rights Watch - ese ari parunyorwa rwevavengi veDershowitz - yakabudisa mishumo yaishora maitiro eIsrael muGaza Strip neRebhanoni muzhizha ra2006, Dershowitz akavadaidza se "anonzi mapoka ekodzero dzevanhu," uye vakarondedzera mishumo yavo seโkufungira mano akaipaโkwakachena uye kwakapfava.โ[6] Dershowitz akataurawo nezve "Amnesty International's predisposition yekupomera zvese kuIsrael," vakati "Amnesty International haigone kuita senge inokwanisa kuzvibatsira kana zvasvika pakupomera Israeri mhosva yehuipi hwenyika," uye akatsanangura Amnesty se "sangano raimbove nemukurumbira. iyo yakaparadza kuvimbika kwayo nokuramba ichishandisa mipimo miviri kuna Israeri.โ[7]
Dershowitz akanyorawo kuti "Human Rights Watch (HRW) yakatonyanya kusarura mukutaura kwechokwadi pasi" panguva yehondo yeIsrael-Lebanon muzhizha ra2006.
ZNetwork inopihwa mari chete kuburikidza nerupo rwevaverengi vayo.
dhoneta