Zvakadaro CPI (M), kusanganisira gurukota guru reWest Bengal, vangademba mapurisa akapfura Nandigram munaKurume 14, izwi rekupedzisira hariratidzike kutaurwa nezvenyaya iyi.
Zvinhu zvasvika pari zvino apo ane mukurumbira wesocialist saSurinder Mohan akadana Left-Front (LF) vanobatana neCPI (M) kuti vabvise rutsigiro rwavo kuhurumende yeWest Bengal votanga kutsvaga kugadzira. "Bato rekuruboshwe rechokwadi mushure mekudzingwa kweCPI (M) kubva mumusasa." Surinder Mohan, achitenda kuti "avo vanotengesa kuvimbika kwavo kune vakapfuma zvavanoda havagone kubva pane ingwe yavakasarudza kukwira, zviri nyore,รขโฌ inofunga kuti CPI(M) yakaita saizvozvo. (Mainstream, Kurume 30-Kubvumbi 5, 07).
Rega nditaure ipapo, mibvunzo yangu kana kusachengeteka pamusoro pehurongwa hwehurumende inotungamirwa neCPI(M) zvisinei, ndinomira zvakasimba neLF. Ndinodaro nekuti ndine nhoroondo nebasa rayo mumakore makumi matatu apfuura sekunge ndakanyanya kukosha mukugadzirisa tsika yeIndia yepakati pezvematongerwo enyika kune zvakanaka pane zvakasiyana-siyana zvinonetsa nyika, uye nekuve iro rinotendeseka zvakanyanya rakarongeka simba rinopesana nevakuru. fascism.
Ini ndaigona kuwedzera izvo nekamwe kadiki-yepakati-yemhando yekufungira: Ini ndinofunga kuti kazhinji hunyoro uye hutsika hwakadzidza hwehutungamiriri hweKuruboshwe kazhinji zororo rinonyaradza kubva mukushungurudzwa kweruzha rwezvimwe zvakawanda zviri kuramba zvichipihwa. Munyaya yeNandigram, semuenzaniso, mushure mekudzivirira kwese kwakaiswa nevatauri veCPI (M), uye zvisiri zvese izvo zvisina mhosva, kuuraya kwaKurume 14 kwevanhu gumi nevaviri kwakadzora kuzvidemba kubva kubato. Izvi pachazvo zvinoita sezvinozorodza kana zvichirangarirwa kuti hapana kuzvidemba kuri kuuya kubva kuNarinder Modi kana chero ani zvake kubva kuSangh Parivar nehutsinye husingafungidzike hweGujarat 14 kunyangwe makore mashanu mushure mekuuraya.
Zvakawanda zvakakanganisika paNandigram, uye chokwadi chekuti pane zvimwe zvinotsoropodza zveCPI (M) munyaya iyi hazvigone kurambwa. Chokwadi, chokwadi chekuti izvi zvave kubvumwa nevatungamiriri vebato zvakare hachisi chidiki chezvikonzero zvekuramba kukoka kwakashata myopic ( reactionary kana rudo) kukanda mwana nemvura yekugeza. Ruregerero, saka, kuna Surinder Mohan wandinofunga nezvake zvakanyanya. Uye kune dzimwe shamwari dzingave nepfungwa dzakafanana mundangariro.
II
Kurwiswa kweCPI (M) kwabva kunzvimbo dzakasiyana, uye kusavimbika kunoda kuti izvi zvisefa kubva kune imwe.
Kune, chekutanga pane zvese, avo vane kurova mazamu kunobata zvishoma pahupenyu nezvido zvevarimi veBengal, zvakanyanya pakutora nguva yekuona kumashure kweLF - chimwe chinhu chavakatadza kuita kuburikidza nedemocracy maitiro manomwe akateedzana. sarudzo dzeMusangano. Chokwadi, pano pane zvakawanda zvegarwe zviri kuratidzwa. Hatifanire kukanganwa kuti aya mauto akachema kusvika rimwe zuva "kubhururuka kweindasitiri" kubva kuWest Bengal, vachibata CPI (M) kunyanya ine mhosva yekupuruzira varimi kuti vabatanidze "bhangi revhoti." Kuti ivo pachavo รขโฌลbhangi revhotiรขโฌ pakati peguta rebhadralok harina kushivirira nhasi mukusimudzira maindasitiri rinoita sekunge iri nyaya yekunetsa. Naizvozvo, zvishoma zvataurwa pano zviri nani.
Kuremekedzwa kukuru kunokonzerwa nevatsoropodzi vanonzwisisika kuti vakaodzwa mwoyo kuti chiitiko chakafanana nekupfurwa kwaKurume 14 chinofanira kunge chakaitika pasi penguva yeLF. Kuodzwa mwoyo kwakadaro kunobva kwaratidza hunhu hwekutarisira kuti zvikamu zvakakura zvevaIndia vanofambira mberi vauya kuzobatana netsika yakajairika yezvematongerwo enyika Kuruboshwe. Nekudaro, nepo mhirizhonga yenyika inoitirwa vanhuwo zvavo ingaite seyakajairwa munzvimbo zhinji dzenyika, izvo zvaifanira kunge zvakaitika kuWest Bengal zvakashamisa vazhinji. Kuti huwandu hwevashandi veCPI (M) vakaurayiwa, vakapiswa, uye vakadzingwa muNandigram pakati paNdira, 3 naKurume 14 zvakapembedza kufa kwaKurume 14 zvishoma sezvo Godhra akaruramisa kuuraya kwaGujarat, kunyangwe fananidzo ichi ingori nharo. . Ndinogona kukurumidza kuwedzera kuti, ndaverenga nhoroondo yakazara yezviitiko paNandigram pakati paNdira naKurume, ndinokwanisa kuona kusasimba uko nyika inofanira kunge yakanzwa pakusabviswa zvachose munzvimbo iyi. Njodzi yacho yakanga iri mukusaziva kwakadzama uko nyika yakabva yasarudza kutarisana nedambudziko.
Chikamu chechitatu chinosanganisira vasiri vebato Kuruboshwe pfungwa dzekuzvipira dzakasimbiswa dzisingakwanise kuyananisa zvivakwa zvavo zvakadzidza uye zvakanatswa zveKuruboshwe praxis pamwe nekupokana kwakashata pasi. Nepo zvingava nyore kwazvo kuti vataure zvinovanetsa sezvinhu zve รขโฌลabstraction,รขโฌ zvinofanira kurangarirwa kuti vanoita basa rakakosha rekuita kuti Kuruboshwe kune zviziviso zvawo zvepamusoro. Tanyatsoverenga zvakawanikwa neCitizensรขโฌโข Committee yakashanyira Nandigram kuti vaone mamiriro akaita zvinhu, mhedziso yakakosha yekuti "ruzhinji rwevagari vemumusha" "vanopesana nekutorwa kweminda uye vazhinji vari kuramba kubhadharwa" โฌ inomutsa mubvunzo unokatyamadzaรขโฌโkuvhiringidza pakuti munhu ari kutaura mumamiriro ezvinhu ehurumende inotongwa neLF.
Zviripachena, kusawirirana pakati pehurumende yeLF nevagari veNandigram kunoratidza hunhu hwakakura hwekutora vanhu sevasina basa, senge nekuti mabhenefiti mazhinji akavawana kubva mukutonga kweLF mumutemo wepasi. Uku kurerekera kwendangariro kweubaba kunosimbisa misungo inowanzomirira avo vanotera kumuyedzo wekuisa zviratidzo zvehudzvanyiriri kusimba redemokrasi. Iwo masimba, maiwe, haawanzo bvumidza humbozha hwekuita-gooders kuti vazorore pamararamiro avo.
Chokwadi kumira uku muCPI(M)'s democratic praxis inopupurirwa nekutaura kwakawanda kwakaitwa kwete nevatungamiriri veCPI, RSP, Forward Block asi nemunhu asiri Jyoti Basu uyo โโakapopotera zvakanyanya. gurukota guru nekuda kwemaitiro ake evatyairi kwete chete kune vabatsiri veLF asi nhengo dzekanzuru yake. Kana paine chokwadi kune izvi zvikumbiro, ndichada kuwedzera izwi revagari vangu vasina kukosha kune yambiro yakataurwa nevashuvisi veKuruboshwe. Chero nguva iyo tsika yezvematongerwo enyika yeKuruboshwe inokundwa nekusagadzikana kunoikwevedzera mukufurira kwehudzvanyiriri, mhedzisiro yacho haigone kungoenderana asi kusvika kure. Panyaya iyi, zvidzidzo zvenhoroondo yehutongi hwechivanhu munguva pfupi yapfuura zvinogona kukanganwika panjodzi huru kune ramangwana rezvematongerwo enyika. Chokwadi iyi inzira inotyisidzira kuunza mubvunzo iwoyo fungidziro dzinozivisa hunhu hweKuruboshwe; chimiro chayo sechinochinja munharaunda yemisimboti yehupfumi yatove munjodzi, Kuruboshwe kunomira kuve bato mukubviswa kwechimiro chayo sekuchinja kwezvematongerwo enyika zvakare. Funga kuti rudzi urwu rwekubhadharisa rwakataurwa zviri pamutemo neCPI pakupera kwemusangano wayo wenyika wemazuva maviri. Bato rinotarisa kuti LF muWest Bengal yakundikana kubuda semuenzaniso munyika; basa rayo chete rinoratidzika kunge riri kuedza kuramba uri musimba (Hinduatan Times, Kubvumbi 10, 2007). Pane imwe nzvimbo mune iyo yepakati-bato mhirizhonga inofanirwa kugara tsanga yechokwadi.
III
Zvino mubvunzo mukuru ndewekuti: gurukota guru reWest Bengal rakanyorwa sekutaura kuti hapana munhu anofanirwa kuve nekunyepedzera kuti zviri kuitwa neLF kuWest Bengal "ukuru" . Ndinoyeuka kuti Prakash Karat, iye zvino Munyori Mukuru weCPI (M), achinyora mune imwe nyaya yeMarxist, akazvitaura zvakafanana nemhedzisiro yekuti zvingave zvisina musoro kutarisira kuti nyika imwe chete muIndia ishandise hurongwa hwehupfumi kunze. nzira yeIndia capitalist yebudiriro.
Kutendeseka mune izvi kutaura kunorumbidzwa. Izvo, zvakadaro, zvichiri kusiya mubvunzo wemhando uye matemo eequation iyo LF inofanirwa kuve nayo nechikamu chazvino cheIndia capitalism. Semuenzaniso, zvinofanirwa kunzwisiswa here kuti hurumende yenyika haina sarudzo munhau yekutsigisa chirevo chekuti capitalism chete inogoneka ikozvino ndeye iyo inopfuura nemuSEZ? Uye ini handisarudzi pano kune iyo SEZ pfungwa sezvo makongiresi ayo uye mazwi ekushanda anogona kugadziridzwa zvinoenderana nezvisungo zvakaitwa neKuruboshwe. Tichifunga kuti izvo zvisungo kubva paminiti ino zvinoramba zvisina kutenderwa nehurumende yeUPA, muchimiro chayo, kutaura chinhu chimwe chete, mabvumirano emutero akakumbirwa kune varidzi veSEZ (izvi maererano nefungidziro yebazi rezvemari) zvinozokonzera kurasikirwa kwemari yevamwe. 1,60,000 macrores! Zvazvakadaro, hazvingadaro here kuti mari yebhenefiti yeSEZ ine chekuita nemari inoiswa uye kugadzirwa kwemabasa muchikamu chehurumende kunoratidzika kunge kusinganzwisisike mukunyanyisa? Uye isu totenda here kuti mubatanidzwa weSEZ investor anoisa kugadzirwa kwemabasa pamberi pekuwedzera purofiti? Kana kutigadzirira isu rudzi rwe infra-chimiro chinogona kubatsira kune akajairwa muIndia asi asina basa kwaari?
Icho chiripo ndechekuti panguva yekutonga kwehurumende yeUPA, Kuruboshwe kwave nguva nenguva kupindira kwevanhu muhurongwa hwehupfumi hwehupfumi hunodiwa nemoyo weavo vari pamusoro pekutonga kwemari (uye inodikanwa kumoyo weavo. iyo yakagadzira Washington Consensus ya1990). Ngazvive pamubvunzo wekubvisa mari muzviitwa neveruzhinji, kushanda kwehurumende yeFDI, kushandurwa kwemari paCapital account, chiyero chemutero wemakambani, kupinda kwemakambani mumusika wekutengesa, kutengeserana kweramangwana mune zvakakosha zvekudya, Vashandi Provident Fund , kuvhura chikamu cheInishuwarenzi, chiyero chekudyara munharaunda, mari yeruzhinji kusimudzira tarisiro yezvikamu zvisina kusimba, mitengo yezvinhu zvepetroleum, kana kushanda kwemitemo yevashandi nekodzero dzevashandi - mutoro weKuruboshwe. kwave kutungamira Indian capitalism kubva kune globalized monetarism kuenda kuhuman welfarism. Nhaurirano yepakati Kuruboshwe kwave kuchengetedza basa rekutanga renyika uye kurambidza vanotonga kubva pakutakurwa kukuru kwemidziyo kuenda kumawoko akazvimirira.
Ndiyo iri rekodhiรขโฌโuye inorumbidzwa zvikuru ipapoรขโฌโsei uchida kurumwa neKuruboshwe paapuro reSEZ zvachose? Uyezve kuti Kuruboshwe kuite semufambisi weSEZ investor zvechokwadi zvinomira kuti zvionekwe sekunge kutendeuka kusingabatsire vanhu veIndia kana ramangwana reKuruboshwe zvematongerwo enyika.
Nezve maindasitiri, zvave kuitika kuti West Bengal ine marara uye ivhu rakavhurika kure kupfuura 1% yakataurwa negurukota guru. Mumwe anoziva kuti makwikwi epakati-nyika munhau yekukwezva mari yemakambani muindasitiri ndeyechokwadi. Asi izvo zvinoreva here kuti LF inopinda mumakwikwi aya pamatemu akaiswa nekambani yemakambani? Chokwadi, iyo LF muWest Bengal ine mamwe maitiro ehungwaru uye ehurumende matanho, pamwe chete nepfuma huru yenzvimbo isina kusagadzikana yemagariro, inogona kupihwa seLF USPs. Uye nei iyo LF ichifanira kuonekwa sekutora kubva kune iyo yakapedza makumi matatu emakore ekurwira uye kutonga kupa kune (zvinoratidzirwa budiriro huru yekuenderana nevaridzi uye nekusingaperi kodzero dzerendi kuzvikamu zvakasiyana munharaunda yevarimi" zvirokwazvo akaisa LF pakati pemabhuku epasi rose ezvinyorwa) uye kupa kune avo, mukufungidzira, vachiri kutorwa sevavengi vemapoka? Uye kosi yakadai inovimbika zvakadii inoita kuti maLeftรขโฌโขs harangues achipesana nemaitiro akadaro mune mamwe matunhu enyika? Zvingave zvisingabatsiri kunyepedzera kuti maonero eruzhinji anokonzerwa nekupokana uku haabudise yakashandurwa yakaipa equations muhukama hwemagariro nenzira dzinotyisidzira kukanganisa kuzivikanwa kweKuruboshwe se.
Zvakaomawo kukwereta zvizere chirevo chekuti mari shoma uye kugadzirwa kwemabasa kunogona kutariswa kuburikidza nediki, uye epakati bhizinesi nevezvitoro zvikamu zvinogona kunge zvichibva pakurima.
Iwo mubvunzo wekuti nzira huru uye yakakosha indasitiri kana yekugadzira musanganiswa weiyo yekupedzisira inonyanya kusimudzira mihoro yekumaruwa uye simba rekutenga. Zvirokwazvo, uko indasitiri inoda kuuya, inofanirwa kunge iri mukati mezvishandiso zvehutungamiriri hweLF kukurudzira maindasitiri akadaro kuratidza chimwe chinhu chemweya wekupayona chakazivisa hurongwa hwavo pakutanga kwerusununguko. Chokwadi, Kuruboshwe hakugone kuonekwa sekuenderana mukuda, kune rumwe rutivi, mutero wepamusoro (kusanganisira capital gains tax) pamihoro yemakambani, uye, kune rimwe divi, ichipa kwavari kurudziro kumba.
Ini ndinofunga nezveCuba iyo isina limousine, uye hapana imwe yeaccoutrement yekushandisa inoenda neiyo limousine tsika. Izvo zvainazvo zvakadaro ihurongwa hwepasi rose hwekuchengetedza hutano, uye hurongwa hwedzidzo hwepasi rose. Ndekupi mukuverenga kweLF muWest Bengal panowanikwa izvi zvakakosha? Uye regai nditiwo, kuregererwa kunobudirira ndinovimba, papi mumhando yeKuruboshwe ruzhinji kupindirana kuri kupenya, kudziya kunotaurirwa, kusagadzikana kunoonekwa zvakanyanya nguva dzese Chavez kana Castro pavanosangana nemhomho yevanhu vavo? Seiko tsika yeKuruboshwe yeruzhinji ichiita seyagara iri โyekutauraโ kwete โyokugovana?โโSei kureruka kuya kwekunyemwerera kwekupihwa nzira kune vasingadi kushamwaridzana vakaimbwa vezviso zvevakuru? Sei kuziva kweKuruboshwe kwaita chando kuita chimiro chekuomarara kwepamusoro-soro? MuIndia Kuruboshwe, anofunga, haafanire kungotaura neushingi kupesana kwayo kune capitalism ine chinangwa chekunwira kuIndian's jugular, asi inofanirwawo kupfeka chiso chinokwevera kwairi mauto evarombo nevasina. kutarisira kuitira kuti pane imwe nguva telos yayo iripo yehumanizing capitalism metamorphoses kuita kutenda uye simba rerumwe rudzi. Izvo zvinoda kuti ikure nemufaro kupfuura ganda rayo kuti iite mibatanidzwa neyakanakisa yemafambisirwo emagariro ikozvino pasi, isina hanya nekugara iri pamberi. Vari Kuruboshwe vanofanira kuimba rwiyo runokwevera mutinhimira wakawanda munziyo imwe chete inorira, vachigara vachinzwa vakasununguka zvikuru nemuridzi wengoma akaremara ari kumashure kwevaimbi, uye nguva dzose achingwarira kuti haaoneki kuva ane shungu dzokuva inzwi rine ruzha zvikuru.
Zvichakadaro, isu tinofanirwa kuziva kuti imwe Nandigram haipi iyo CPI (M) isingachashandi, haiite kuti iite mushandirapamwe, hairegi kurwa kwayo kwenhoroondo kurwisa mapato nezvematongerwo enyika. Tichirangarira mitsara inoshungurudza yenhoroondo yedu serudzi, iyo yekupedzisira pachayo inopupurira kuenderera kwedu kudiwa kweCPI(M), uye LF. Kana iyo CPI (M) isingaite senge ichiziva nezvehuvepo hwedu (hapana munhu anoti mhoro kwandiri kunyangwe pedyo pedyo), isu tinofanirwa kuramba tichiziva nezvayo mukutendiswa kwekuti, kubvumwa kana kusadaro, nzeve yayo yakavhurika kune vasina hudyire uye vanonzwisisa. ane hanya zvechokwadi.
Rega iyo CPI (M) itange patsva, ibvume yayo yakanakisa kuzvitsoropodza, uye isa tsoka yayo yepamusoro mukufamba ichienda kune miriyoni tsoka.
ZNetwork inopihwa mari chete kuburikidza nerupo rwevaverengi vayo.
dhoneta