Makore anopfuura zana apfuura, nyanzvi yekuGermany Werner Sombart akaburitsa bhuku rine musoro unoti โWarum gibt es in den Vereinigten Staaten keinen Sozialismus?โ kana kuti, โNei MuUnited States Musisina Socialism?โ Nhasi, nyanzvi dzakawanda nenyanzvi dzezvematongerwe enyika dzinobvunza mubvunzo mumwe chetewo, uye mhinduro dzacho dzinosiyana zvikuru. Nepo dzakawanda dzemhinduro - rusaruraganda, ivo kusawirirana kweSeneti, federalism, pro-business Supreme Court, mazinga akaderera e kubatanidzwa kwevanhu - vese vane chokwadi uye simba rekutsanangura, zvinoramba zvakaoma kukona democracy uye kusaenzana. Democracy zvaifungidzirwa kuva โnzira inoenda kugutsaruzhinji,โ pashure pezvose.
Iye zvino chidzidzo chitsva naNicholas Stephanopoulos inovhenekera chiedza pamusoro pekuti sei โdemocracyโ isina kuderedza kusaenzana: nekuti haipo.
Stephanopoulos akashandisa zvinyorwa zviviri pakuongorora kwake: kutanga, dhatabhesi huru yeongororo yemafungiro everuzhinji inofukidza mibvunzo zviuru zviviri nemazana manomwe neshanu mukati memakore makumi maviri nemashanu (2,074-25) yakanyorwa naMartin Gilens yebhuku rake "Kupfuma uye Kufurira;โ chechipiri, akabatanidza sarudzo dzekubuda mumatunhu kubva pakati pa2000 na2010 aine index of state policy liberalism, zvichimubvumira kuti aenzanise zvinofarirwa nemapoka akasiyana nezvakabuda mugwara. Aidzora hukuru hweboka nekuwanza tsigiro yeboka yegwaro nemugove waro wehuwandu. SaGilens, Stephanopoulos akangoenzanisa mapoinzi umo zvido pakati pemapoka maviri ari kudzidzwa zvakasiyaniswa nemapoinzi anopfuura gumi.
Sezvinoratidzwa mumachati ari pazasi, dhatabheti raGilens rinoratidza zvinogutsa kuti zvinofarirwa nevakadzi, vanhu veruvara uye avo vanowira mumabhuraketi emari yepasi nepakati hazvina zvazvinoita pagwara. Mutsetse wakatsetseka unoratidza kuti zvinofarirwa nepolicy hazvinei nepolicy, mutsara wokudzika-kudzika zvinoreva kuti zvinofarirwa neboka zvine zvazvinokanganisa papolicy. Mutsetse unokwidza kumusoro unoratidza kuti zvinofarirwa neboka zvine zvazvinoita pamitemo - kureva kuti, vanowana zvavanoda. Iyi dataset inobatsira zvinoshamisa, nekuti pane kuongorora yakafara nhanho nhanho, inobvunza zvakananga: Vanhu vanowana zvavanoda here?
Mhinduro ndeyokuti: Hongu, kana vari vapfumi vachena varume.
Mutsara usina kunaka wevakadzi unonyanya kunetsa. Kune inopfuura hafu yehuwandu hweUnited States, kutsigira gwara kunoreva kuti vanogadzira marongero havakwanisi kuipfuudza. Sekutsanangura kunoita Stephanopoulos,
โSezvo rutsigiro rwevarume runowedzera kubva pa0 muzana kusvika pazana muzana, mikana yekudzikwa kwemitemo inokwira kubva pachikamu che100 kusvika pachikamu che0 muzana. Asi serutsigiro rwechikadzi rwunosiyana pachiyero chakafanana, mukana wekurerwa unodonha kubva pa90 muzana kusvika pagumi muzana. Apo varume nevakadzi vanosabvumirana, ipapoka, kutsigira kwakasimba kwevakadzi nokuda kwegadziriro kunoratidzika kuva kusina maturo chose chose.โ
Uku kupenga chaiko.
Nepo dhata reGilens rinongoyera zvinobuda padanho remubatanidzwa, dhatabheti rechipiri rinoongorora kuti maonero nepolitiko zvinopindirana sei padanho renyika. Machati ari pasi apa anonyora kuti pfungwa dzemapoka akasiyana dzinopindirana sei nemafungiro emitemo yenyika.
Sezvauri kuona, vachena neLatinos vane yakanaka uye statistically yakakosha pesvedzero pagwaro, nepo vatema vasina. Izvi zvinoreva kuti kana vatema muMississippi vaine rusununguko kupfuura vatema muAlabama, izvo hazvizokanganisa marongero edunhu rega rega. Uye, zvakare, vakadzi havana pesvedzero pamitemo zvachose, kana vanhu vane mari shoma. Chokwadi, Stephanopoulos anonyora kuti "kusunungurwa kwemitemo yenyika kunodzikira kubva pa1 (kana kuti ingangoita mutemo weOhio) kuenda kune -1 (kana ingangoita New Hampshire's) sepfungwa yeavo vanoita isingasviki $30,000 inosiyana pamhando imwe chete." Kureva kuti, zvinofarirwa nevarombo zvine chekuita nezvematongerwo enyika.
Zvakawanda zveizvo Stephanopoulos anowana meshes pamwe nekumwe kutsvagisa nezvenyaya: Zvimwe zvidzidzo (kunyanya basa raJohn Griffin naBrian Newman) vanoona kuti vanhu vane ruvara vane zvavanoda zvakasiyana uye kuti izvo zvavanofarira hazvina kunyatsomiririrwa. Nekudaro, Stephanopoulos anowana mikaha yakakura yevakadzi kupfuura imwe tsvakiridzo yakataura. Griffin naNewman, semuenzaniso, vakawana kuti kusiyana kwevakadzi mukumiririra vaive vadiki. Zvakadaro, nzira yavo yaive yakavakirwa pakuti kazhinji vakadzi vaive nepolicy โkuhwina,โ zvichireva kuti mutemo wavaitsigira wakadzikwa. Izvi zvinoreva kuti maitiro avo haakwanise kuziva "democracy netsaona," iyo yaStephanopoulos inoratidza kuti inogona kunge iri kuitika.
Mune rimwe basa, Griffin naNewman naChristina Wolbrecht vanoona kuti yakawanda yegevha yevakadzi inogona kutsanangurwa nenyaya yekuti maRepublicans. vanoda kupikisa mitemo inotsigira vakadzi. Chokwadi, basa rakawanda pakirasi uye nhangemutange pakumiririra anoona kuti Mapoka anogona kushumira setsananguro dzisina kukwana dzemikaha yekumiririra kuburikidza nekuyananisa zvido. Bato reRepublican yava "muchina unoshanda wekutsigira vachena uye yepamusoro 1 muzana yevanowana US." Nekuti bato reRepublican rinoitira kubatsira vachena chete vakapfuma, nepo bato reDemocratic rinofanira kuita mubatanidzwa wakafara uye wakasiyana, hurongwa hwebato hunogona kuunza mikaha yekumiririra. Nekudaro, mapato haasi iwo ega anotsanangura shanduko, nekuti iripo simba umboo iyo bato reDemocratic change kuruoko rwerudyi kuitira kugarisa pesvedzero inowedzera yevapfumi (uye kuderera kwesimba remibatanidzwa) Mukuwedzera, Griffin naNewman note (ona chitsauko 5) kuti nepo maDemocrats achimiririra vatema neLatinos zviri nani pane maRepublicans, ivo vachiri kufarira zvido zvevachena.
ZNetwork inopihwa mari chete kuburikidza nerupo rwevaverengi vayo.
dhoneta