Zvichida chizvarwa chose chezvamatongerwe enyika chakarongerwa kushamiswa nechachichibudirira. Mumakore ekuma1960, vazivi venguva refu vesocialist vakatyisidzirwa nemasimba masimba eruboshwe rutsva. Ipapo vamwe veavo vatsva vekuruboshwe vakasvika zera repakati uye vakatarisa, vachikatyamadzwa, sezvo macode matsva ekutaura achiwedzera pamakoreji ekoreji panguva yekutanga kudzokororwa kwezvematongerwo enyika. Ndakanga ndiri mukoreji ipapo uye ndave nemakore makumi matatu, zvinoreva kuti inguva yangu yekuodzwa mwoyo nekukura kuri kuita bapiro rekuruboshwe kune censoriousness uye bvudzi-rikonzeresa mhosva.
Zviri kuramba zviri pachena kuti tiri kupinda munguva itsva yekururama kwezvematongerwo enyika. Munguva pfupi yapfuura, takaona mafoni kune #CancelColbert nekuda kwechimwe chinhu chinonyangadza chakataurwa naStephen Colbert's blowhard alter ego, anga achitaura zvinhu zvinonyadzisa nguva dzose kwemakore mapfumbamwe. Ipapo ndipo pane kamwe kamwe chinodikanwa nokuda kweโkutanga yambiroโ pazvidzidzo zvekoreji, zvaireva kudzivirira vadzidzi kuti vasasangana nemazano kana mifananidzo inogona kuvashungurudza; dhipatimendi reOberlin Document inotopa zano rekushandisa jeti โkumutsa zvinhu kana zvisingabatsire zvakananga kuzvinangwa zvekudzidza.โ KuWellesley, vadzidzi vane akakumbira kuita kuti chidhori chekunze chemurume anofamba akarara chibviswe nokuti zvakanga zvichivaparira โkushushikana kusingakodzeri.โ Sezvo ini akanyora in The Nation, pane kumanikidzwa mune mamwe madenderedzwa kuti vasashandise izwi rekuti โmukadziโ zvine chekuita nekodzero dzekubereka, kutyira kuti zvinogumbura trans people.
Uye izvi hazvisi kungoitika pano. MuEngland kuruboshwe-bapiro New Statesman, Sarah Ditum akanyora yekupararira kwekusava neplatforming โ kumisa vanhu vane pfungwa dzinoonekwa sedzinogumbura kutaura pachena. Anotaura kushevedzera kweanopikisa bato reBDS kuGalway University nekutyisidzirwa nekutyisidzirwa kunoitwa mumiriri wechikadzi Julie Bindel, akataura zvinhu zvehutsinye nezve trans people. "Hapana chikuva chinoshandisa fungidziro yekupikisa kutaura kweruvengo kuratidza mutauro unonyadzisa, uye kugadzira nzvimbo yakanaka ye'nzvimbo dzakachengeteka' umo vamwe vanhu vanogona kushungurudzwa," akanyora kudaro Ditum. "Chishandiso chaimbogadzirirwa kuchengetedza democracy kubva kumafambiro asina demokrasi chave chombo chinoshandiswa nevasina demokrasi vachipokana nedemocracy."
Idaidze iyo kuruboshwe-bapiro anti-liberalism: iyo pfungwa, yakatorwa naHerbert Marcuse mune yake 1965. sumo โKushivirira Kunodzvinyirira,โ ihwohwu kururamisira munzanga kunoda kudzora rusununguko rwokutaura. "[Ini] zvinogoneka kutsanangura nzira iyo masangano aripo, mitemo, maonero anozofanira kuchinjwa kuitira kuvandudza mukana werunyararo urwo rwakafanana nehondo inotonhora uye hondo inopisa, uye kugutsikana. zvinodiwa zvisingadyidzani nourombo, udzvinyiriri, uye kudzvinyirirwa,โ akanyora kudaro. โNekuda kweizvozvo, zvinokwanisika zvakare kuona marongero, maonero, mafambiro angasimudzira mukana uyu, uye izvo zvingaite zvakapesana. Kudzvinyirirwa kwevanodzokera shure chinhu chinodiwa kuti vanofambira mberi vasimbiswe. "
Cherekedza pano zvose zviri zviviri chitendero chokuti mirangariro yakarurama inogona kuzivikanwa nenzira yokusafarira, uye chivimbo choushingi muuchenjeri hwaavo vanopiwa simba rokudzvinyirira. Kufunga kwerudzi urwu kunogoneka chete pane dzimwe nguva: apo kusununguka kunoratidzika kunge kwakundikana asi kodzero haisati yatonga. Panguva dzakadai, tsika dzechinyakare dzakasununguka dzakaita sekutaura kwakasununguka uye gakava rakasimba, rakavhurika rinoratidzika kunge rakasvibiswa rehurongwa hwehudzvanyiriri, uye zvichiri kugoneka kuti vezvematongerwo enyika vatende kuti pfungwa dzakatsikirirwa seruvengo hadzizove dzadzo.
"Chimwe chezvinhu zvinoshamisa zve'60s radicalism kwaive kuvenga rusununguko," akanyora kudaro Alice Echols mu. Kushinga Kuita Zvakaipa, nhoroondo yake yekunyanyisa evakadzi. โKuramba rusununguko kwevanyanyisi kwakanga kusiri kwokukurumidza; asi, yakakura mukupindura kukanganisa kwerusununguko - kunyanya, kutya kwayo pamusoro pekodzero dzevanhu vatema uye kuwedzera kwayo Hondo yeVietnam. Chimwe chinhu chakafanana, kunyangwe pachiyero chidiki, chakaitika mushure Bill Clinton yakagumisa hutano sezvatinozviziva, uye zviri kuitika iye zvino, sezvo dambudziko rehupfumi richienderera mberi Barack Obama. Pane kusagutsikana kwete nezvematongerwo enyika zvesarudzo chete, asi nehunhu hwakasununguka huzere. "White liberal" yave, zvakare, yakabuda seyaidiwa-kuruboshwe epithet.
Panguva dzakadai, chibvumirano chezvematongerwo enyika. Pamusoro, rhetoric inoratidzika kunge ine chido uye utopian kupfuura kare - chapupu, semuenzaniso, sezviri pachena zvakataurwa naSuey Park, mugadziri we #CancelColbert hashtag, kuti vatsigiri ve Twitter vanotarisira "kuparadza nyika." Asi panguva imwecheteyo, kuratidzira kunowedzera kushoma pamusoro pekukunda vatendeuki uye kushandura nyika uye nezvimwe nezve kugadzira akachengetedzwa enclaves uye kutaura kwemapurisa. Sezvakanyorwa nemutsoropodzi mukuru wetsika Ellen Willis muna 1997, pane imwe nguva yekupararira kweruboshwe-kuruboshwe, "Ndiko kudzvanyirirwa kwemagariro evanhu kunokurudzira danho rekurambidza kutaura kunogumbura kana kutsanangura chero nzira yekudzvinyirirwa kwepabonde munzvimbo yebasa sekunetswa kwepabonde. . Muuyo mukuru wamanomano aya kukurudzira kuvhiringidzika, kutsoropodza uye kutsvaka varoyi mune zvevatano, kurerutsa chisimba chevatano, uye kuita kuti zvido zvinoramba zvichiitwa kuti zvidziviswe zviri pamutemoโukuwo zvichiregeredza tsika yakakwirira yokutaura zvakasununguka kune zvakarurama.โ
Pane mushonga weichi chinhu, kunyangwe chakaipisisa kupfuura chirwere. Kana rudyi ruchitora simba, ruboshwe runowanzoona kukosha kwekutaura kusina kusungirirwa. Mumakore ekuma1980, nevanochengetedza vaitungamirira hondo yekurwisana neNational Endowment for the Arts yekutsigira mari mapurojekiti aionekwa seanopikisa chiKristu uye zvinonyadzisira, kushivirira kwakanga kusingacharatidziki semabhunu. Zvimwechete zvaive zvechokwadi panguva yekutonga kwaBush, apo kupikiswa kweHondo yeIraq kwakawana Phil Donahue akadzingwa kubva kuMSNBC uye Dixie Chicks akatora kunze kweredhiyo playlists munyika yose. Ndosaka Mushumo weColbert waive wakashata pawakatanga kuonekaโkunyomba kwake kusingadzoreki kwakagura nepakati pemabombastic jingoism, bapiro rekurudyi rezvematongerwo enyika, izvo zvaititadzisa.
Hazvishamisi, hongu, kuti mapapiro ekurudyi saMichelle Malkin, munyori wekudzivirira kwekuvharirwa kweJapan, glommed kune ichangoburwa anti-Colbert campaign. Anti-liberalism, shure kwezvose, inobatsira zvikuru kune kodzero. Rimwe zuva mutungamiri wenyika Paul Ryan kana Ted Cruz kana Rand Paul vachatoreswa mhiko, uye anokwira, ane masimba ekuchengetedza masimba achaedza zvakare kudzikamisa kupokana mutsika dzepop uye dzidzo, sezvazvinongoita. Unyanzvi hweveruzhinji hahuzodzivisirwe nekuti hunofungidzirwa kuti huchikonzeresa-huchatorwa pasi (kana yakavharwa) nokuti zvinonzi hazvina kunaka. Panogona kunge paine imwe #CancelColbert mushandirapamwe, asi haisi kuzobva kuruboshwe. Zvichida vanhu vachanyara, ipapo, kuti uyu akaita.
ZNetwork inopihwa mari chete kuburikidza nerupo rwevaverengi vayo.
dhoneta