Ndakapomerwa mhosva yekuvimba nezvinyorwa zvinotsigirwa neCIA - kunyanya, mishumo yeInstitute of War and Peace Reporting (IWPR) iyo inotsigirwa neNational Endowment for Democracy uye United States Institute for Peace (pakati pemamwe masangano emari makumi matatu). Saka zvinotevera kwaive kururamisa kwangu kuverenga mishumo yavo, uye kunyangwe kutenda zvimwe zvikamu zvavo. Chinyorwa chaitaurwa chaiva Kuti Hondo yeGeorgia yakatanga sei.
Kune avo vaverengi vanonetsekana zvachose kuti sei NED neUSIP zvichifanira kuonekwa seCIA zviridzwa, ini ndinokurudzira Hondo yeGlobal Civil Society uye Sourcewatch's chinyorwa cheNED. Mamiriro angu pachedu pachinhu ichi ndechekuti hurumende yeNED/CIA/US yakadurura mamirioni mumasangano e'hurumende' (nemasangano akazvimirira) pasi rese mukuteedza zvibodzwa zvayo zvakasviba. Uye izvo, kazhinji, zano iri rakabudirira (mumashoko avo). Masangano akadai seIWPR anenge ari kuita nekusaziva hurongwa hwehurumende yeUS vachitsvaga hurongwa hwavo; asi vatori venhau vega vega vachinyorera sangano vari kuitawo zvavo ajenda yangu - yandingapokana ichiri yakasiyana zvakanyanya.
Saka torega here kuverenga mareports emasangano anopihwa mari muchidimbu nemari yakasviba? Ini ndinofunga zvakanyanya kwete, nekuda kwezvikonzero zvinotevera:
1. Kupihwa mari kwemasangano akazvimirira ega neCIA - nevamwe - inzira huru, zvinoreva kuti pane mukana wezvimwe zvirongwa zvisingaende 'sekurongwa'. Panofanira kuve nekunonoka, nekuti zano racho raisazoshanda kana avo varikuita pasi vakafunga kuti ivo (vangori) vachiita hurongwa hweCIA. Uyezve, nehuwandu hwemari iri kudururwa uye huwandu hwezvirongwa zviri kupihwa mari, pamwe nenyaya yekuti cheni iri pakati pepiper neCIA-inodaidza-iyo-tune yakarebesa chaizvo zvakaoma - hazvigoneke - kuti vagadzire. chokwadi chekuti mutori wenhau wese wemuno anopihwa basa ari 'pameseji'. Tisingatauri chokwadi chekuti CIA - kana ichibatanidzwa mune rimwe sangano - ingori imwe yevamwe vakawanda vanobhadhara mari, avo vese vane yavo yakasiyana zvishoma.
Kushandisa imwe fananidzo: iyo CIA yakadurura mamirioni mujahideen. Iyo yaive 'yakanaka zano' (munguva pfupi - maererano nekukunda Soviet Union). Asi kunyangwe munguva pfupi, havana kukwanisa kudzora mujahid wega wega: kusvika kwakarebesa. Iro zano rakashanda sese, asi raisaenderana nekuve nekutonga kwese kwese kushanda (hazvaigona kutsamira pane izvo). Mukupedzisira chokwadi, vakatadza kudzora zvachose - uye wobva wawana blowback. Ini ndinofungidzira zvimwe chete zvinogona kuitika / zvinogona kunge zvakaitika kare nemari yakawanda yeruzhinji rwevanhu.
2. Ichokwadi kuti ini ndinotenda kuti kune akawanda chinks muhurongwa - masangano ane utsinye, vatori venhau vane utsinye uye mujahideen ane utsinye - uye chokwadi chokuti kuwana ruzivo kubva munharaunda kwakaoma, pamwe chete nechokwadi chokuti ndinotenda zvakasimba kuti tinofanira kuverenga munharaunda. mishumo uye ongororo yemunharaunda pane kungovimba nevatauri vepasi rose - zvese zvinoreva kuti ndinobvunza zvinyorwa / vatori venhau vanobva mudunhu. Asi nekuda kwemamiriro akaita hupfumi mudunhu rose, idzi dziri muhuwandu hwenyaya dzinopihwa mari neUS kana dzimwe hurumende, kana nemasangano epasi rose.
Zvinofanira kutaurwa kuti mhando yekuongorora uye huwandu hwemafungiro huchiri kukwira zvakanyanya mune idzi 'nhengo dzinotsigirwa neCIA' pane izvo zvaunowana muzvinyorwa zvinotsigirwa nehurumende (izvo zvinewo yavo ajenda!). Kune yakawanda mienzaniso - kunyanya muRussia - yezvinyorwa zvakanyorwa nemari yekumadokero inopesana neCIA mutsetse. Heano maviri emutauro wechiRungu kubva kuIWPR pachayo, ese akaburitswa mumazuva gumi apfuura: Abkhaz vhura 'yechipiri kumberi' uye Akaona: Kuurayiwa kwevanhu muTskhinvali
3. Nezvezvirongwa โ izvi ndezvechokwadi zvemunhu wese, tisingarevi muridzi/mupepeti wese wenhau. Ndosaka kazhinji ndichifunga kuti zvinyorwa zvinofanirwa kubvumidzwa kuzvimiririra. Ehezve vanyori vane chinzvimbo chavo uye kusarura, uyezve kune imwe nhanho (uye kazhinji) izvi 'zvinoenderana' neizvo CIA kana chero mumwe mupi wemari anoda kunzwa. Asi chero tichifunga izvi; chero tichinzwisisa kuti sei munyori achitaura chero zvaari kutaura, uye isu tinobvunza mishumo kubva kumativi ese ari maviri mukukonana, ndingadai ndakafunga kuti kupokana (kunobva pamoyo, kwete CIA) uye chero ruzivo rwekuwedzera. waizova mupiro unokosha chete. Zvirinani, munyaya yechinyorwa chino, kuti tinzwe nyaya yakanakisa yedivi iro isu (kuruboshwe) tiri kupomera.
Kazhinji, hazvina kuoma kuziva 'ajenda' yevatapi venhau vazhinji mudunhu rino - sezvazviri nyore kunzwisisa 'ajenda' yemutori wenhau weGuardian, kana zvechokwadi mutori wenhau ari kuruboshwe webhusaiti kana chinyorwa. Tichiziva izvozvo, tinongoda kungwarira, mukuverenga chero chinyorwa zvachose, kutarisa kune nharo dzisina simba, zvikumbiro zvisina musoro, kurerekera, kana chero zvimwe zvinorambidzwa zvinoiswa nevapepeti kana vanopa mari.
Zvakakoshawo kuti tiyeuke kuti mudunhu rino kunyanya, vanhu vakave nyanzvi pakuita zvinhu zvavo asi kunze vachikodzera straitjacket yemafungiro enyika. Zvimwechetezvo, vatori venhau nemasangano mazhinji vave kupihwa mari nemasangano ekumavirira vanonyatsoziva hurongwa hwevanopa mari, uye vanonyanya kukwanisa kukama masangano asi vachiita zvavanofunga kuti zvakakosha. Saka ndinotenda zvechokwadi kuti vanyori ava vari kunyora pamusoro pezvavanoona - uye ndinoona kuti zvinonakidza, kunyange kana chiono chavo chingave chinokanganisa zvose nerusaruro rwavo uye kubatana nekukakavadzana uye - kusvika pamwero muduku - nezvavanoziva. vanobvumirwa kunyora mukati meIWPR framework. Nditsvagireiwo munyori asina rusaruro zvachose, kunyangwe kuruboshwe.
4. Zvinyorwa zvechinyorwa chiri mubvunzo zvinopindirana zvakanaka nezvandave ndichizviona mumakore mashomanana adarika uye zvinoratidzika kwandiri kusimudza nhamba dzepfungwa dzisina kukurukurwa kuruboshwe zvachose. Sezvo ndapedza nguva yakawanda ndiri mudunhu / ndichidzidza dunhu, ndinobvuma kushungurudzwa nekutadza kweruboshwe kuona izvo zvandinoona sebasa reRussia riri pasi pasi uye rinokurudzira mukuchengeta kusawirirana uku pamota, uye nekuishandisa kune yayo. zvido zvako. Izvo hazvisi kutaura kuti ndinoregerera Georgia, kana kutaura kuti ndinoramba mupiro weNATO / US, wanga wakakura. Asi ini ndinoona Russia seyakanyanya kune ngozi uye inotsamwisa mumiririri pane zvakabvumwa mune kuruboshwe tsinhiro. Kungotarisa zviri nyore pamufananidzo wepanzvimbo kungaratidza izvi.
Zvizhinji zvezvirevo zvakaitwa muchinyorwa chiri mubvunzo ndakanga ndatoverenga muzvinyorwa zvakasiyana - kusanganisira kusati kwatanga kupokana - kana kunzwa kubva kuvanhu mudunhu. Ndingafarire kunzwa nezve zvirevo zvakananga izvo kune humbowo hwekunyepa kwavo.
5. Panyika pano hapana kana muGeorgia asingadi kunyora chinyorwa chinogona kufara kutsigirwa neCIA: nyika yakabatana mukuvenga kwayo Russia. Asi zvinoda kureva here, nekuda kwekuti CIA yakabatanawo mukuvenga kwayo Russia, kuti hapana zvinyorwa zveGeorgians zvakakodzera kuverenga? Kana kuti havakodzeri kuverenga nekukurumidza kana CIA yavabhadharira?
Izvi hazvisi izvo zviri kutaurwa nevapomeri vangu, asi nemamiriro emari panguva ino muGeorgia, uye nekupihwa chokwadi chekuti haugone kuve muGeorgia uye kwete 'kushandira chirongwa cheCIA' - mumwe anenge amanikidzwa kugumisa. Izvozvo zvinotisiya tiri pachinzvimbo chekuva neanenge asina manyuko ari kurarama iko kusawirirana uku. Ini handifunge kuti ndiyo nzira yekunzwisisa hunhu hwayo hwakaoma uye hwakasiyana-siyana - uye ndinotenda zvakasimba kuti ruzhinji rwekutaura kuruboshwe rwakatambura semhedzisiro.
6. Pakupedzisira: hatirambi kuverenga chinyorwa chimwe chete muGuardian nekuda kwekuti Scott Foundation ine hurongwa hwekuita mari yakawanda sezvinobvira; uye isu hatiregi kutenda zvese zvakataurwa paBBC, zvisinei nekuti iyi inzvimbo yehurumende inodzorwa zvakanyanya nehurumende. Neiko zvino tichifanira kushandisa mipimo yakasiana kumasangano ezvenhau mune dzimwe nyika, uko mari yakaoma zvikuru kuwana uye mikana yokuzvitsvakira timene yakaganhurirwa zvikuru? Masangano enhau haasi maumbirwo akazara uye vatapi venhau vega vanogona kuve nechimwe chinhu chinonakidza - uye chinovimbika - kutaura kunyangwe mukati megadziriro yesangano inopihwa mari nechinangwa chakati.
Miyero yacho haina kana kushandiswa pasi rese kumatanho enhau munharaunda: mashoma mashoma enhau nevatori venhau vasiri vekumadokero anotorwa nekuruboshwe anowanzo kubva kuRussia Nhasi, inova chimbowo chekuparadzira nhema dzehurumende yeRussia. rumwe rutivi zviridzwa zvenhema dzeUS. Ndingataura zvakanyanya zvakanyanya, nekuti kutonga mune yeRussia Nhasi kuri maoko, kumusoro pasi uye kwakazara. Iwe haungangowana chinyorwa pane iyi chiteshi chinotora chero mutsara kunze kweiyo yepamutemo yeRussia.
Saka: Ndicharamba ndichiverenga mishumo yeIWPR yeruzivo irwo vatauri vekumadokero vasina mukana, uye kuti ndidzidze nezvemaonero evanhu mudunhu.
ZNetwork inopihwa mari chete kuburikidza nerupo rwevaverengi vayo.
dhoneta