Ndichangoziva kuti aimbove shamwari yangu uye shamwari yangu yenguva refu, Richard Falk, akadzingwa muHuman Rights Watch (HRW). Heano maitiro ayo akadzika, sekunzwisisa kwandinoita: Kenneth Roth weHRW akagamuchira tsamba kubva kuna Hillel Neuer, Mutungamiriri Mukuru wesangano rinonzi UN Tarisa, yaDecember 17 th, kurwisa Richard se "rusaruraganda uye muvengi wekodzero dzevanhu," uye, zvechokwadi, anopikisa Semite.1 (sezvo - kushamisika! - UN Watch idonhwe reNeocon American Jewish Committee uye chikamu cheuber-Zionist watchdog network). Roth naHRW vakabva vatendeukira kuna Richard, uye, ndisina kumuudza nezvetsamba iyi, akamukumbira kusiya basa nokuti chinzvimbo chake cheUN soMumiririri Anokosha2 zvinopesana negwaro reHRW rekuti nhengo (dze "makomiti erutsigiro ematunhu"?) havafanirwe kuve nechinzvimbo chepamutemo nesangano rehurumende seUN. Sezviri pachena, HRW yakanga yakanganwa nezvegwaro iri mukati memakore mana kubva 2008, pakagadzwa Richard, asi zvakangoitika kuti akazvirangarira mukati memaawa makumi maviri nemana ekugamuchira tsamba yeUN Watch. Munhu akanaka uye anovimba naye zvaari, Richard akabvuma kutevedzera mutemo wainge uchangobva kufukunurwa uyu. Chete kana mutauri pablog rake3 akamubvunza nezvazvo, Richard akaziva kuti pane "zvakawanda panhau" pane zvaakanga audzwa:
Ms. Açelya Dano?lu
Zvita 18, 2012 na3:34 am #
Wadiwa Purofesa Dr. Falk,
Ndakanzwa kuti Human Rights Watch yakakubvisa kubva kubhodhi ravo revatungamiriri! Ichokwadi here? Zita rako harichanyorwa pawebhusaiti: http://www.hrw.org/cities/santa_barbara/committee
Wakasiya basa nekuda kwekumanikidzwa neUN Watch NGO iyo yaikupomera "antisemitism"? Bhodhi rakakubvisa here? Handinzwisise.
Mune rugare,Açelya
REPLY
Richard Falk
Zvita 18, 2012 na7:30 am #
Ndakakumbirwa kusiya basa, asi zvichinzi nekuda kwekubatana kwangu neUN, izvo zvinopesana nemutemo weHRW. Pamwe, ipapo zviri kunetsa pane zvandaudzwa.
Tarisa zvitambi zvenguva pano. Rangarira kuti tsamba yeUN Watch yakanyorwa muna Zvita 17. Ndiyo imwe inokurumidza basa revatengi!
Sezvo adzidza kuti pane "zvakawanda kunyaya" kupfuura zvaakanga atungamirwa kuti atende, Richard, sezvandinonzwisisa, akabva adzokera Roth, et. al., kuti zvijekeswe. HRW yanga ichimukumbira kusiya basa nekuda kwekupokana kuchangobva kuwanikwa, kana nekuti vaigamuchira uye vachitsigira chichemo cheUN Watch? Kana asiri iye wekupedzisira, saka HRW yaizotaura zvinomutsigira, uye kumupa vimbiso yekuti achagamuchirwa kana basa rake kuUN rapera? Ehe, hapana chirevo chakadaro chekutsigira kana ruremekedzo changa chiri kuuya kubva kuHRW. UN Watch haina kupokana nezve zvakaitika, uye nei: "'Wadzingwa': Richard Falk Anodzingwa muHuman Rights Watch."
Nesuwo hatifanire kudaro. Wese munhu anoziva zvaipindurwa neHRW. Ardent Zionist, avo vari kuramba vari voga munyika, vari kuda kuvhara nekuvhara chero ani zvake - kunyanya chero munhu muUS, kunyanya muzivi weAmerican Jewish akangwara - anoshinga kupa izwi rekodzero uye zvishuwo zvevanhu vePalestine. Richard Falik's ndiyo chaiyo mhando yekudzikama, inonzwisisika izwi rekushoropodza iro rinonyanya kutyisidzira chirongwa cheIsrael colonial (uye Imperial yeAmerica). Chiito cheHRW kumiririra kuUN Watch uye zvese zvainomiririra. Chiratidzo chinotyisa cheRoth, et. al., kudzika midzi mumitemo yeHRW kune chimwe chinhu chekuudza Richard chinoita kuti zviite sekunge vari kuita chimwe chinhu kunze kwekunge vauya kuUN Watch kunofanirwa kunzi zvazvazviri: chikonzero chisina musoro, chinosiririsa. Ngavave nezvivindi zvavo pachake zvavakaita chaizvo, ndokuti: "Ehe, Richard, kunyangwe isu tinokuzivai uye nebasa rawakaita nesu, uye nepasirese, kwemakumi emakore, isu tinotora zvakanyanya mhosva yekuti uri" rusarura. uye muvengi wekodzero dzevanhu,' uye, nechikonzero ichocho, tiri kukumbira kuti uende .." Rega HRW, naRichard Falk, vatongwe pane izvozvo.
Hapana mubvunzo kuti ndiani achawanikwa achishayiwa. Kuti chero ani zvake aizoteerera kune vanhu vanozoratidza Richard Falk nenzira iyi zvine musoro, uye - kune avo vasingadi Richard kune pfungwa yekudzikama uye kushivirira - kutsamwa. Zvakanyanya kudaro kuHRW, sangano rinozviti rakazvimirira uye rinofambira mberi. Chero ani anoziva Richard - uye kune vakawandisa vaakadzidzisa nekubata kuti izvi zviende neimwe nzira - anoziva kuti ndiye anofanirwa kudada, uye HRW inofanirwa kunyara. Kuvimbika kwavo, uko manzwi akaita saRichard Falk akavapa, kwakaderedzwa. Kurasikirwa kwavo, kwete kwake.
Tese takatarisa kurwira kweHRW kuti kuve kwakanaka. Pakuenzanisa, ndinofunga kuti vakaita basa rakanaka uye ndanga ndiri mutsigiri. Vachipihwa hwaro hwevanopa uye zvisungo zvavo kune veUS elite, vari pasi pekumanikidzwa kukuru. Zvakangodaro, tichipihwa iko zvino kunogara kuri pachena kuda kweUS neIsrael kuita chero chavanoda pasina mhosva, masangano anorwira kodzero dzevanhu ekuAmerica seHRW achaona zvichiwedzera kuoma kuchengetedza kuvimbika kwavo kunze kwekunge vachida. kutsoropodza zvakajeka uye zvisina kujeka zviitiko zvisiri pamutemo zvenyika izvo vanopa vadzo vanowanzo zivikanwa nazvo. Vanoziva kuti, kusvika uye kunze kwekunge vadaidzira vezvematongerwo enyika veAmerica neIsrael muchiteshi cheICC, kushora kwavo vadzvinyiriri veAfrica neTatu World kucharira. Kana vasingakwanise kumiririra murume anga ari mumwe wemanzwi akatanhamara erunyararo uye kodzero dzevanhu dzezera redu, pamberi pemhosva dzakapusa kubva kune reactionary neocons vanopedza hupenyu hwavo vachikurudzira hondo, saka pane mukana mudiki wekuti vachaita chero chimwe chinhu. kupfuura kunzvenga mitongo yakaoma ingangove iri madikanwa mukutarisana nezviito zvomunguva yemberi navanyanduri vakaipisisa venyika.
Ini handichazove nechekuita neHRW kunze kwekunge vataura chimwe chichemo chekuramba chichemo cheUN Watch, uye kuvimbisa Richard Falk kuti achagamuchirwa kudzoka kana kugadzwa kwake kweUN kwapera. Ndinokurudzira munhu wese kuti azivise manzwiro avo kune HRW.
Notes
1Neuer anoshora Richard nezve "anti-Semitic" zviito uye kutaura kanenge kasere mutsamba, iyo yaunogona kuwana pano: http://blog.unwatch.org/index.php/2012/12/17/human-rights-watch-should-remove-antisemitic-u-n-official-richard-falk-from-its-board/. Tsamba yacho inokanganisa, inodzokororwa kumwe kunhu, ichizivisa Falk senhengo yeHRW "Board." Anga ari, anga ari nhengo yeSanta Barbara City Committee, chikamu cheicho HRW inodana "netiweki yepasi rose yemakomiti ekutsigira ematunhu."
Ibasa rebenzi kuedza kupindura kune chero chakananga chetsamba. Richard anonangwa nekuti anga ari mumiriri akanaka uye anonyengetedza wekururamisira kuPalestine nevanhu vePalestine. Period. Zvimwe zvacho ihogwash. Uye munhu wose anozviziva.
2Zita rake repamutemo rinonzi "Special Rapporteur on the Situation of Human Rights in the Palestinian Territories Occupied kubvira 1967."
3Nhaurirano yeHRW flap iri muchikamu chekutaura cheichi positi paFalk's blog: http://richardfalk.wordpress.com/2012/12/15/responding-to-the-unspeakable-killings-at-newtown-connecticut/ . Muchaonawo zvandiri kureva pamusoro pezwi raRichard rakadzikama uye nemoyo murefu richipindura kutsika-tsika kweZionist kuri kutamba.
ZNetwork inopihwa mari chete kuburikidza nerupo rwevaverengi vayo.
dhoneta