Per SOP, kubvira Edward Snowden paakatanga kuburitsa pachena nezvechirongwa cheNSA cheOrwellian chekuongorora, vezvekugadzwa vange vachiita zvese zvavanogona kushora zviito zvake uye kuzvidza murume wacho. Iri ibasa riri nyore kune zvikamu zvine hutongi hwezvido zvevateereri vekuAmerica, avo vachaitirwa nekushoropodza kubva kune vanofarira Peter King, John Boehner, kana Dick Cheney. Kune vateereri vakawanda veavo vanozvifunga ivo vakadzidza, vane rusununguko rwepfungwa, vane hanya zvakanyanya nenyaya dzekodzero uye kuvanzika, kurwiswa kwakanyanya kuoma pane zviito zvaSnowden kana munhu wake kunofanirwa - chimwe chinhu chinorira kune izvo zvinonetsa, uye. inopenya nepatina yechiitwa chepfungwa.
Saka, pakabuda pfuti hombe dzehungwaru, dzakatakura zvombo zvine musoro, kuitira kuti oh-so-zvakaoma kutsoropodza zvakaitwa naSnowden. Somuenzaniso, tinonzwa kubva Geoffrey Stone, Purofesa paYunivhesiti yeChicago Law School, akahaya Barack Obama kuti adzidzise mutemo webumbiro:
[Ini] zvakakosha zvakanyanya kuti unzwisise kuti kana iwe uchida kuchengetedza rusununguko rwevanhu munyika ino, haungofanire kuchengetedza rusununguko rwevanhu, iwe unofanirwawo kudzivirira kubva kune hugandanga, nekuti chii chichaparadza rusununguko rwevanhu munyika ino zvakanyanya kupfuura chero chinhu. zvimwe ndezvimwe kurwisa kwa9/11. โฆ Saka zvakaoma kwazvo, kubvunza kuti ndeipi nzira yakanakisa yekudzivirira rusununguko rwevanhu muUnited States.
Uye isu tinonzwa kushoropodzwa kwakafanana kwezvakaitwa naSnowden kubva kuNew York Times anofarira zvemahara-ish mutauri, Thomas Friedman, tichitaura nenzira dzakafanana - kungave nekuti zvakanyorwa zvekutaura kana nekuti pfungwa dzepakati dzinofunga zvakafanana, zvakaoma kuziva:
Ini ndinonetsekana nazvo [imwe 9/11] zvakatowanda, kwete nekuti ini handina basa nerusununguko rwevanhu, asi nekuti chandinonyanya kufarira nezveAmerica inharaunda yedu yakavhurika, uye ndinotenda kuti kana paine imwezve 9/11 ... zvinogona kutungamirira kumagumo evanhu vakazaruka sezvatinozviziva.
Hmm. Imhaka yekuti ndine hanya nerusununguko rwevanhu rwandiri kukuudza kuti tinofanira kusiya rusununguko rwedu rwevanhu, uchishandisa kutya kwako panopticon surveillance system kuti iwe ugamuchire panopticon surveillance system. Wow, izvo zvinonzwika senge imwe mhando ye syllogism kana chimwe chinhu. Unogona kuudza vakomana ava vakaenda kukoreji, kwete seanorasika Snowden. Iyi haisi nyaya yekupindura yakapusa, asi yakanyatsofungwa ine musoro yerudzi rwatisingawanzonzwa. Tinofanira kuparadza musha nzanga yedu yakazaruka kuitira kuiponesa.
Isu tinogona kumaka izvi seizvo zvinosuruvarisa zvave kuita gakava rakajairwa rinonzi pakati nepakati rakasununguka pundits rinoita, kune avo vanoda kuzvifunga sevagari vane rusununguko, nezve kukosha kwe pre-emptive capitulation kune zvirongwa zverudyi (hondo, kuomarara. , dragnet surveillance): "Hakusi kuti ini ndinonzwa hasha saka ndinokukurudzirai kuti mutore chirongwa ichi chekupindura/ chehurumende, asi nekuti tese tiri vanhu vane rusununguko vari pakati nepakati, vane hanya nerunyararo, kodzero, uye kururamisira, uye tinofanira kuziva kuti : Kana tikasabvuma (zvinotyisa) chirongwa chemhinduro/chiremera A, zvinozotitungamira kumamiriro ezvinhu atinomanikidzwa kubvuma (zvakatonyanya kuipa) chirongwa chemhinduro/chiremera B. Naizvozvo, munoona, handisi ini nevangu confrรจres tinoda kumhan'ara Snowden (uye pamwe Glenn Greenwald) se 'mutengesi' anoisa njodzi kune yakasununguka demokrasi, asi Snowden nevaya vanomutsigira nehutsotsi hwake.
Iyo pfungwa - iyo yezvematongerwo enyika - ndeye ironclad uye, nguva pfupi yadarika, inoshanda zvakanyanya: chete zvirongwa zvekupindura zvinogona kutiponesa kubva kuzvirongwa zvekupindura.
Maparentheses angu ari pamusoro anoratidza, kune rimwe divi, chishuwo changu chekusanganisira, mukururama, zvinhu izvo vatauri vakadaro vangasimbise zvakakosha panharo yavo, uye, kune rimwewo, pfungwa yangu yekuti zvinhu izvi zvakasiyana uye zvinofanirwa kudzikiswa. "Inotyisa reactionary chirongwa A" kazhinji inoshanduka be "zvakatonyanya kuita chirongwa B." Zvirinani, zvinopa izvo zvakakosha, uye kazhinji zvisati zvamboitika, hwaro hwemutemo nezvematongerwo enyika hunoita kuti chirongwa B chisadzivisike. Ndinoreva, iwe haugone kupfenyura chero vanhu kupfuura vose.
Zvinoshamisa kuti zvematongerwo enyika ekutya zvakapinda sei mune rusununguko pamwe nehurukuro yezvematongerwo enyika yeAmerica. Kune vakasununguka, kutya kwekodzero kunoda kubatwa kune kodzero. Kune wese munhu, kutya kana kwe Yakakura Yakaipa Wolf "gandanga" rinoparadza rusununguko rwedu zvinoda kuti isu titange tazviparadza isu pachedu.
Ehe, pfungwa huru dzekugadzwa hadzigone kuita sedzinotevera nzira yeiyi pfungwa yekutya kwakakwana nekudzivirira. Kwaisava here kupamba kwaAriel Castro, kusungwa, uye kubata chibharo kwevakadzi vatatu kwemakore anopfuura gumi [sarudza hasha dzaunofarira] mhosva inotyisa yatisingade kuona ichiitika zvakare? Hatina kukwanisa here kuderedza mikana ye "mumwe Ariel Castro" kana tikabvumira kutsvaga kweimba yemunhu wese vhiki nevhiki? Haudi here kumisa zvinotyisa zvemhando idzi? Une chimwe chinhu chokuvanza here? Chaizvoizvo.
Zvakakosha kucherechedza, tichifunga nezvekutamba nguva dzose kweiyi "imwe 9/11" kadhi yehwamanda, kuti, pamberi pe9/11, pasina izvi zvisiri pamutemo, zvirongwa zvekudhonza, iyo NSA. vakaita ruzivo rwekumisa iyo chaiyo 9/11, uye haina kudaro nekuda kwezvematongerwo enyika. Muchokwadi, iyo NSA, neDhipatimendi reJustice pakurayira kwayo, vakatevera avo vevakuru vayo avo vaive vakashatirwa zvakanyanya nekutadza kwakabatana neiyo chaiyo 9/11. uye kunyanya kunetseka pamusoro pehutongi hwekuongorora husina kufanira zvachose hwakatangwa neNSA mushure me9/11. Ndivo vanonyatsonzwisisa kushandiswa kwe9/11 sea chikonzero. Heano Thomas Drake:
Handikwanise kutaura zvizere, nekuti zvakakamurwa. Asi ndakaratidza kuti NSA yaiziva zvakawanda pamusoro pekutyisidzira kwa9/11 neAl Qaeda, ichironda vanhu vakasiyana-siyana nemasangano kwemakoreโฆ Dambudziko nderekuti, yanga isiri kugovera data rese. Dai zvaive zvakadaro, mamwe matunhu ehurumende angadai akaita pazviri, uye zvakanyanya, NSA ingadai yakamira, ndinoti vakamira 9 / 11. Gare gare, inogona kunge yakawana Al Qaeda - panguva iyo US yairova Afghanistan. [Bolding mine. Kusimbisa kweitalic mune yekutanga.]
Usatombo funga, zvakare, kuti kutya kwaFridmanesque kwezvikara kungave kukakavara kwechirongwa cheNSA, asi chiri kwete gakava rinopokana nekuita kuti kuvepo kwechirongwa ichi kuzikanwe, sekuzvitorawo nekukanganisa kuve. Mushure mezvose, Edward Snowden haana kuburitsa chero chaiyo, yakasarudzika, ruzivo rwehunyanzvi iyo yaizogonesa chero munhu, achishandisa chero nzira yekutaurirana iyo NSA inoongorora, kumisa kana kunzvenga iyo kuongororwa, kana iyo inobvumira chero mumwe munhu kana simba kuitevedzera. Kwemakore gumi apfuura, hapana โgandangaโ rinozviremekedza rave risingazivi kudikanwa kwokunzvenga nzira idzodzo dzekurukurirano. Al-Qaeda haisi kuzoronga chiitiko chayo chikuru chinotevera muGoogle Hangout.
(Greg Sargent inoita pfungwa yakafanana pamusoro peizvi non-sequitur yekuvanza chikonzero chepamutemo chezvirongwa izvi.)
Uyezve, hazvisi izvo kuti Snowden ndiye "iye" akatanga kuburitsa kuvepo kwehutongi hwekutarisa. Sezvandaratidza mune a yapfuura romukova, ruzivo rwave rwuripo kwenguva yakati. Zvaakaita - uye zvakawanda - kuita kuti zvisaite kuti vanhu vekuAmerica varege kufuratira chiyero chakakura uye kudzika kwekuongororwa kwakaitwa pavari, uye kuita kuti zvive nyore kuti pave nekunyepedzera kwegakava pamusoro pe zviri pamutemo, bumbiro remitemo, uye kodzero yezvematongerwo enyika yedemocracy yezvirongwa izvi.
Nenzira iyoyo, kuburitswa kwaSnowden kungave kwakaita kuti zvematongerwo enyika zvinyanye kuoma - uye ini nevamwe taizotarisira, zvisingaite - kuenderera mberi nezvirongwa izvi sezvazviri. kuti ndosaka, zvisinei nekuti munhu anogona kunge ari maviri ezvirongwa uye vachitsigira kuridza muridzo kwaSnowden (seavo vanoti "vanogamuchira gakava" rinofanira kunge riri), Friedman nevamwe vake vanopokana nevose - kwete nekuti vanoda kuchengetedza "nzanga yakavhurika," kana nekuti ivo vanoda kutidzivirira kubva kune "imwe". 9/11," asi nekuti ivo vanoda kuchengetedza kodzero yevakuru vezvematongerwo enyika kuti vaite chero chavanoda muchivande.
Tichiri pazviri, ngatiise yese nyaya yekuti โakatyora mutemoโ muchirevo chayo. Pane nzira imwe chete yekupokana yekupomera Edward Snowden nekuti "akatyora mutemo," uye akamboridza muridzo weNSA. William Binney inotsanangura chaizvo:
Ndinotenda kuti anofanira kutongwa, kuitira. Anofanira kupinda mumutsara mushure mehutungamiri hwapfuura, President, Vice-President, vatungamiri vose ve.. Madzishe nemaDeputy ose eNSA - vose, vanhu vose vari munharaunda dzevasori dzakabvumira izvi. Vose vanofanira kutongwa. Uye anofanira kuvatevera vose.
Chimwe chinhu chipi zvacho unyengeri hwepamusoro. Kana George Bush, Dick Cheney, Josรฉ Rodriguez, et. al., inogona kumhanya yakasununguka uye kubudirira nekuti isu tinofanirwa Kutarisa Mberi Kwete Kudzoka, tobva tatenda Ed Snowden nekugonesa gakava rataida tese, toenda kumberi kubva ipapo.
Iyo yepamusoro-soro yepfungwa iri pasi pekurwiswa uku pane zvakaitwa naSnowden zvinoda kuti pave nekuenderana, kwekuwedzera seti yekurwiswa kwaSnowden pachezvake. Uye kana izvi kurwisa pachako zvichava zvinobudirira kupfuura ani nani-anovhiringidza-mauto-ungwaru-akaoma-mutengesi mhomho yevanhu, ivo vachada mutsetse wezvematongerwo enyika-pfungwa dzakaoma kunzwisisa. Zvinenge zvave nani pane kumufonera "a cross-dressing Little Red Riding Hood," rudzi rwekutuka, kwakagadzirwa kusinganyanyi kuderera nevateereri vane pfungwa dzakasununguka.
Saka pinda yepamutemo "moderate Republican" David Brooks, uyo, mune yake inimitable netsitsi anochengetedza nzira, anoratidza Edward Snowden semuenzaniso we "chikamu chinokura chevarume vechidiki vari mumakore ekuma20 avo vari kurarama .. munyika ine fuzzy pakati pemasangano avo ehuduku uye zvisungo zvemhuri zvevanhu vakuru," majaya avo, pakati pe "atomization yenzanga, kusunungurwa kwezvisungo zvevanhu, .. rarama hupenyu husina kuumbwa nemasangano ekuyananisa emasangano evanhu." Haakwanisi "kushanda nenzira yake kuburikidza nechikoro" chechikoro chesekondari nekoreji, Snowden ndomumwe weava vanodzungaira vakarasika avo, kunyangwe "vane tsika uye vakazvipira zvakanyanya kukutenda kwake," vanotadziswa ne "kunyumwira kwakadzama kwe chiremera, chitendero chakasimba chokuti mapoka nemasangano anonyumwirwa, kuzvipira kwakasimba pakuita zvinhu pachena, [uye] fungidziro yokuti zvinofarirwa nomunhu zvinofanira kuva zvikuru.โ Aya ndiwo, kuBrooks, "matanho akasiyana erusunungukoโฆ muzera rino rinopatsanuka." Sezvo Brooks anotiyeuchidza, Snowden akabatsira kumushandirapamwe wemutungamiri waRon Paul. QED.
Wow, David Brooks ari kuvhima Ayn-Randian American-Republican hyper-individualism! Kwete, chokwadi, kutsoropodza kwehumwe uye kuparadzaniswa kubva pamaonero eanosununguka gutsaruzhinji maonero, asi kudzivirira kwakasimba kwechinyakare RepubloCrat hierarchical uye manejimendi adzvinyiriri. Uye Brooks ihurumende yeRepublican (munoziva, PBS's yakasarudzwa antithesis kune yakajairwa hierarchical-maneja "moderate" Democrat, Mark Shields), saka izwi rake rinozivikanwa "rekuchengetedza" rinogona kusakwana kunyengetedza vakasununguka kuti Snowden "ari kuita kuti zvese zvinyanye."
Saka, cheka kunzvimbo yepamutemo yekusununguka kweterevhizheni, MSNBC, kwatinowana Lawrence O'Donnell, mune imwe nzwisa inoshamisa, achitora memes yese yeBrooks nzira yekuzvidza Snowden: kusiya chikoro chesekondari, hapana koreji kana imwe "kukura." " institution, uye - the piรจce de resistance zvakare - Ron Paul mushandirapamwe wemushandirapamwe.
O'Donnell akapa Glenn Greenwald kuratidzwa kwakanaka, kunyangwe zvakapindirana nekuzvidzikisira kwaO'Donnell, "Angori mukomana weIT". Kazhinji, O'Donnell anga akangwarira kuti angasvika papi mukuzvidza Snowden, asi hapana mubvunzo kuti ari kuramba achisimbisa chirevo chekuti, sekutaura kwaRoger Snowden zvakanyanya, Snowden ndiye "ane dofo akauya achibva kunotonhora" aine "zvese zvinodiwa kuti ave girosari."
Ndeyechidimbu neprojekti yaO'Donnell yekuvimbisa vakasununguka kuti nyonganiso yese yeNSA haina kukosha, kuti hapana chekuona pano, ngatifambei, sepaari. Chikumi 11 show: "Kufona kwese kwandati ndamboita muhupenyu hwangu kwakasiya rekodhi mune imwe kambani kune imwe nzvimbo, inogara iine, inogara ichidaro, ini kusvika parizvino handisati ndatya nezviri kuitwa neNSA." (Ndagadzirisa kusakosha uye kusakosha kweiyi nharo yekudzinga pano.)
O'Donnell's show Chitatu chapfuura (Chikumi 12th, Video, transcript), zvisinei, chaive chinhu chakasiyana uye chinoshamisa kuona. Yakanga iri imwe yeakanyanya kuomerwa, scurrilous, uye ekutaura nguva mu - pamwe iyo apotheosis ye - irikuenderera mberi media media kurwisa Snowden. Kuedza kwake kusinganzwisisike, kwakashata - kwemaminetsi makumi maviri, pasina zororo rekutengesa - kuunza chimwe chinhu, chero chinhu, chakaipa kana chinoshoreka pamusoro paEdward Snowden kubva kumubvunzurudzo wake akaita kutsunga kwake kuzvidza murume mumaziso evateereri vake vakasununguka. Kukundikana kwake zvachose kwakasimbisa kuti zvichave zvakaoma sei kune vanochengetedza kana vakasununguka pundits kuti vadzinge zviito zvaSnowden pamusana peunhu hwake, uye chaive chiitiko chakaguma chave kusaremekedza chimwe chinhu kunze kweiyo yose yemitambo yemitambo yekuzvidza pachayo.
Muenzi waO'Donnell aive Mavanee Anderson, shamwari yepamoyo yaSnowden, akange ashanda naye kuGeneva, kwaakange aine mvumo yekuvanzika. Akanga anyora op-ed mu Chattanooga Times Yemahara Press "kuratidza kutsigira Ed chero nzira yandinogona." Kunyangwe zvake asinga tsigire kuburitswa kweruzivo rwakasarudzika, uye "angadai akamuraira kuti arwise kurwa kwake neimwe nzira," anobvuma kuti "maitiro ake anga ari mutsara unoshanda wenhaurirano inodiwa zvakanyanya nezvenyaya dzekuvanzika uye. kuchengeteka munyika ino nokumhiri,โ uye anopedzisa achiti kwaari: โNdinodada newe.
Lawrence anofanira kunge akafunga kuti, nehunyanzvi hwake hwekubvunzurudza, aikwanisa kutora rumwe ruzivo kubva kumukadzi wechidiki uyu izvo zvaizoisa Snowden muchiedza chakashata kune vaoni vake. Chaaive nacho chaive gweta rechidiki rakadzikama, raitaura, uye raidzorwa, iro raisazobvuma kudhonzerwa mumutambo uyu usina basa uye unotyisa.
Mushure meimwe Kubvunzurudzwa 101 rapport yakatangwa, O'Donnell akatanga kuredza akatsunga. Akabvunza Mavanee kana aisafunga kuti Snowden aive "asina njere." Paraphrasing Snowden's interview with The Guardian, O'Donnell anoti Snowden akapinda muchiuto:
"zvichibva pachishuvo chekuenda kuIraq uye kuita zvakanaka. Uye akashamiswa zvikuru mukudzidziswa kwechiuto uye izvi ndizvo zvandakawana ... zvinoshamisa zvisinganzwisisike. Akashamisika kuti kudzidziswa kwechiuto kwainyanya kukoshesa kuuraya vanhu. Akanga asina chokwadi here? ziva kuti ndizvo izvo mauto aripo kuti aite, kuuraya vanhu muhondo?
Mhinduro yaMavanee yakatendeutsa kuti:
"Handifungi kuti aibvunza kuti uri kuedza kuuraya vanhu here kana kuti kwete paunopinda muchiuto .... Handizivi, zvichida haana ruzivo, kana kuti anongova munhu anoda nyika yake anoda kuita chikamu chake Nyika."
Kufanana nemamiriyoni evamwe vechidiki vekuAmerica, ndiko. O'Donnell haasi kuratidza pano kuti mauto mazhinji eAmerica akabatana nemauto asina "naรฏve" chinangwa che "kuita zvakanaka," asi nechinangwa chakanyatsogadzirwa chekuva mhondi? Zvakanaka.
O'Donnell anobva adzvanya Anderson pamusoro pekuti Snowden akadzokera kubasa rehungwaru mushure mekunge ataura "dambudziko rekuvimba":
"Unofunga kuti angave akadzokera mukati aine chinangwa chekunyatsoita chinhu chakadai kubva mukati mehurongwa?"
Anderson akapindura akadzikama zvakare:
"Handina chokwadi kuti ndizvo zvazviri ... handizivi kuti sei akasarudza kushandira NSA mushure mekuodzwa mwoyo, asi anogona kunge ane humwe unyanzvi hwakarongwa. Uye akanga ane ruzivo rwekutangazve. Uye akanga atove nechekare. anoziva zvakawanda pamusoro penyika iyoyo. Uye ndizvo zvaanoziva kuita. Saka -."
Nemamwe mashoko, nekuti ndiro basa raivepo raaigona. Ita izvozvo zvaunoda.
O'Donnell anobva aedza kuona kana paine hurongwa hwezvematongerwo enyika hwakavanzika huchikurudzira "kuodzwa mwoyo" kwaSnowden:
"[D] akamboti unoziva, isu hatifanirwe kunge tichiita izvi, uye isu tinofanirwa kunge tichiita X panzvimbo?"
Mavanee zvakare anoramba kufungidzira, uye anodzokera kune zvaanoziva, achipa maonero akanaka pane hunhu hwaSnowden:
"Kwete, ... takanga tiri shamwari uye ... handiyeuki tichiita hurukuro dzezvematongerwo enyika naye. Saka, ichi hachisi chinhu chandinogona kutaura nacho. Ndinogona kutaura nechimiro chake. Ndinogona kutaura chokwadi chokuti maonero angu, aigara ari shamwari yakavimbika uye mukomana akanaka. Ainyanya kufunga. Aifunga kwenguva refu uye zvakaoma pamusoro pezvinhu - aifunga kwenguva refu uye zvakaoma pamusoro pemigumisiro yezvinhu asati aita zvinhu, mune zvakaitika kwandiri naye.
Pakutanga mubvunzurudzo, Lawrence akavharwa mukuedza kwake kuderedza unyanzvi hwedhijitari hwaSnowden nechiyeuchidzo chaMavanee kuti: "Munoziva, mumwe munhu akadai saBill Gates, somuenzaniso, handifungi kuti akambopedza kudzidza kukoreji." Kutaura zvazviri, Mavanee anodana Showden kuti "IT genius." Saka, gare gare, achitevera mutsara wekuda kwaDavid Brooks nezvekusasimba kwepasi kwaSnowden, O'Donnell akaedza kuita kuti Mavanee abvumirane pane kumwe kunyomba, kwakagadzirwa, kunongedzera kukoreji uye "kukura":
"Zvakanaka, ndinofungidzira pfungwa yekupedzisira yandinoda kusimudza pamusoro pake semunhu ... pfungwa yake yekuenzanisa, kukwanisa kwake kuenzanisa zvinhu uye kukwanisa kwake kuenzanisa zvinhu zvinopokana panguva imwe chete, inova nzira yekukura kwepfungwa - iyo, nenzira, isu tinovimba zvinoitika kune imwe dhigirii kukorejiโฆ.
Uye zvandiri kushamisika ndezvekuti - hunhu uhwu, hwave nemhando yekukura iyo inogona kuenzanisa zvinhu zvemhando iyi uye kutarisa zvimwe zvinhu uye kuva nemaonero pazviri? Kana kuti hunhu hunobvumira zvimwe zvinhu kuti zviwedzere, uye anogona kutarisa hurumende yeUnited States ofunga nezvayo semagadzirirwo ekudzvinyirira?"
Mavanee anovhara zvakare chinyararire mutsara wekurwisa uyu:
"Unoziva, ndiri kufunga nezveruzivo rwangu rwepakoreji uye ruzivo rwangu pachangu pachikoro chezvemitemo, zvakare. Uye handina chokwadi kuti kupinda makirasi andaipinda ndiko kwakaparira muitiro iwoyo wekukura."
Achiona kuti izvi zviri kuenda kupi, O'Donnell anomuvhiringidza - achitsika pamashoko ake "iyo nzira yekukura" - vateereri vasati vayeuchidzwa nezvehukama huri pakati pepfungwa dze "pati" ne "koreji" muUnited States, iyo. haisi kuzobatsira "kukura" kwake kwese chinhu. Ehe, Lawrence, unogona kukura usingaendi kukoreji.
Anobva aedza kusvika pa "balance" uye "kukura" imwe nzira - nekugadzirisa kushandiswa kwaSnowden kweshoko rokuti "architecture of pressure" sechiratidzo che "kusaenzana" kwakadzika. Mavanee akange ati mutsara uyu waive "pamwe ... kuwedzeredza" - kunyangwe akapokana kuti "haazivi ruzivo rwese rwaaiziva," uye "kazhinji vanotaura zvinhu nenzira yakayerwa." O'Donnell anoenderera mberi:
"Iwe unofunga kuti musiyano uripo pakati pako neshamwari yako, Ed, kana iwe ukatarisa hurumende yeAmerica uye inoona mavakirwo ehudzvanyiriri, uye iwe haudaro? Iwe unofunga kuti musiyano upi pakati penyu imi vaviri ikoko ?"
Nehurombo kuna O'Donnell, Mavanee anopindura nenzira inonzwika saEd Snowden kupfuura David Brooks:
"Ini ndinofunga kuti pane, pamwe nekuda kwekuti vamwe vakuru vakapfuura. Uye zvinogona kudzikiswa.
โNdiri mumiriri mukuru kune vatongi uye nemagwaro ekutsvagisa uye ndinofunga kuti panofanirwa kutariswa, kunyanya munzvimbo yakaita seiyi, munyika dzehungwaru pasina vatori venhau vane mukana, vanogona kutsanangura. kuunza zvinhu muchiedza chezuva. Ndinofunga kuti zvakakosha zvikuru, zvichida kuva - kuve nechokwadi chokuti tine huwandu hwakakodzera hwekutarisira."
Mukati mese, mhinduro dzaMavanee dzinopa Lawrence pane zvaaitsvaga. Zvakapesana chete. Paanomusundidzira zvakanyanya, anowedzera kunzwira Snowden anonzwika. Murangariro wake mukuru paari ndewekuti:
"Aigara ari shamwari yakavimbika uye mukomana akanaka. Ainyanya kufunga. Akafunga kwenguva refu uye zvakaoma pamusoro pezvinhu - aifunga kwenguva refu pamusoro pemigumisiro yezvinhu asati aita zvinhu, mune zvakaitika kwandiri naye. "
Zvakawanda zvekusaenzana uye kusakura.
Iyo isinganzwisisike, yepamusoro-yakaderera poindi yekubvunzurudzwa inowana O'Donnell achitendeukira kune isinganzwisisike, yakarongwa, kunze-ye-kuruboshwe-munda kuedza kutamba Ron Paul. uye Osama Bin Laden makadhi panguva imwe chete. Ane vhidhiyo yakamisikidzwa, uye anotsanangura zvikonzero zvake zvekuiratidza neiyi convoluted logic:
"[Isu tave kuziva, Ed Snowden akabatsira kumushandirapamwe waRon Paul, uye zvichida, kana akavhota, zvichida, akamuvhotera. Saka ngatiteererei zvaakataura pamusoro paOsama bin Laden uye al Qaeda, iyo yainyanya kufarira, zviri pachena, zveEd Snowden's."
Lawrence anobva aridzira Mavanee clip inotevera (Ingangoita masekonzi makumi mana. Unofanira kuiona.):
Mubvunzo waO'Donnell unofanotaurwa: "Ed Snowden akataura izvozvo, semuenzaniso, saRon Paul, kuti aifunga kuti Osama bin Laden uye al Qaeda vakatsamwiswa muzviito zvavo nezviito zveUnited States?"
Hu?
Ndiyo iyo transitive pfuma yemhosva neyakakurudzirwa kushamwaridzana zvakare. Izvi zvinongorwadza zvinorwadza, nenzira iri pachena, edza kudyara mubvunzo - kungoti itty mubvunzo - mupfungwa dzevaoni kuti, sezvo Snowden akabatsira kumushandirapamwe weRon Paul, uye nekudaro "zvichida" (kana "pamwe") akamuvhotera, uye sezvo Ron Paul akatora kubva kuna Osama uye al-Qaeda - "zviri pachena" "chaiwo kufarira." " yaEd Snowden (Anoti ndiani?) - saka Ko Ed Snowden chiteshi Ron Paul achifambisa Osama Bin Laden achipomera United States 9/11? O'Donnell haana kunyatsotaura izvozvo, hongu, akangoratidza mifananidzo yaikurudzira.
Anderson akarambazve chirauro, achingoti: "Handiyeuki tichikurukura nezvazvo. Saka handigoni kutaura nezvazvo."
Asi Lawrence O'Donnell anonyatsoziva kuti mifananidzo ine simba kupfuura mazwi, uye aishanda aya OBLโRPโES. achipomera United States mifananidzo kuitira kuti ive nechokwadi chekuti mubvunzo, mubvunzo chete, waizorira mupfungwa dzevaoni. Unoziva: Usafunge nezve nzou yebhuruu!
Ndinoda kushandisa mifananidzo iyi kuratidza chimwe chinhu. O'Donnell, ndinofunga, akairidza zvishoma padyo nekumucheto pano. Mushure mezvose, akaratidza chidimbu chehurukuro yeRepublican Presidential, umo Ron Paul akadzvinyirirwa, uye akatarisa sechisikwa kubva kune imwe nyika, nokuti aiudza vateereri kuti vateerere (kwete kubvumirana nazvo) izvo zvinokurudzira-zvakajeka zve "magandanga." Kune avo vateereri, chero zano rakadaro nderokusvotwa, kupenga. Asi ini, uye ndinofunga vazhinji vevaoni veO'Donnell, havawani chinhu chinopokana mune izvo Ron Paul aive achiita ipapo - munzvimbo iyoyo, uye mumufananidzo unofamba.
Nekune rimwe divi, mukuratidza clip iyi sezvaaiita, O'Donnell ainyatso kuzviisa, uye achiedza kuisa vaoni vake, muchidzidzo chimwechete-chinzvimbo chinowanikwa mumufananidzo iwoyo neโฆ Rick Santorum - Muromo nepfungwa dzisina chinhu dzinoshama pachiitiko chisinga nzwisisike chemurume ari kuedza chaizvo kuratidza kuti tinofanira kuteerera kune chero chinhu vavengi vedu vakasarudzwa vangatiudza nezvekuti sei vachiita zvavanoita. Nemufananidzo uyu, O'Donnell anonyatso kurudzira uye anogovera maonero eSantorum.
Ndine urombo, Lawrence, asi kuva Rick Santorum haisi nyaya yezvematongerwo enyika inondinakidza - kana, ndinofungidzira, kune vazhinji vevaoni vako.
Izvi, zvamazvirokwazvo, chikamu chekuedza kuri kuramba kuchiitwa nevazhinji veMSNBC vane rusununguko kuita dhimoni Ron Paul, "libertarianism," uye, nemubatanidzwa ane mhosva, wese anobata chero chazvo. Ivo vanopedza yakawanda yenguva yavo vachiita dhimoni, nekuti hapana zvakawanda mukuda kwavo Obamican Democratic liberalism yekutsvenesa.
ndinoreva dhimoni kusiyana nekushoropodza. Ini ndinoramba Ron Paul's Ayn-Randian "libertarian" social dzidziso. Ini ndinozviona zvichisekesa uye zvinoparadza, munzira dzakasiyana neanonyadzisa uye anoparadza imperialist neo-liberalism yevazhinji maDemocrats nemaRepublicans. Saka, chokwadi, kutsoropodza kwakakomba kwakakodzera. Handizvo.
Ndinozivawo kuti sei vanhu vazhinji vekuAmerica, uye kunyanya vechidiki vekuAmerica, vasina kuzvifunga zvese, vachikwezvwa nemafungiro erusununguko uye zvinzvimbo - izvo zvisingagumire pakupokana kweRepublican "Randians" (senge, taura, Rick Santorum). ) asi wedzera kune huwandu hwakawanda hwe "anarchist" dzidziso, iyo resonance inogona kuwanikwa, semuenzaniso, mubasa re Noam Chomsky (uye pano).
Zviri nyore zvakare kunzwisisa kuti mudiki wekuAmerica akaita saSnowden angakwezvwa sei kumushandirapamwe weRon Paul muna 2012, sezvo yanga iri anti-imperialist. Pamwe akaona Pauro anonyatso shanda kurwisa hondo, anti-imperialist campaign ad. Iko kukwezva kwezviziviso zvakadaro kune vechidiki vekuAmerica vakaita saSnowden izvo zvinoita kuti kusununguka kwaRon Paul kutsamwise "kune mwero," kubvumirana kwemaimperiya pakati peRepublicans neDemocrats - saDavid Brooks naLawrence O'Donnell.
Saka Lawrence's Ron-Paul/Bin-Laden gambit yakapfuura zvakashata sevamwe. Mavanee Anderson akavhara kuyedza kwese kwaO'Donnell kutora imwe nugget yeruzivo rwekuzvidza, nekutonhorera uye nemazvo. Kure nekuenderera mberi nekuraswa kwaEdward Snowden, kubvunzurudza kwaO'Donnell kwakangobudirira kufumura hurongwa hwake hwepazasi zvese zvakajeka.
Paive ne "rimwezve ruzivo" rwebvunzurudzo iyi yatinofanira kutaura. Sokunge Ron Paul naOsama Bin Laden vanga vasina kupererwa nemazano akakwana, O'Donnell anoendazve rimwe bhiriji kure zvakanyanya, uye anoburitsa mubvunzo unoita kunge wakabva kuMars:
Anderson: Ndine urombo, handidi - zvakare, hachisi chinhu chandingazoziva.
Pane chimwe chinhu pamusoro peIsraeri? Zvakabva kupi izvozvo?
Zvakanaka, ndinofunga tese tinoziva: Ndapota, ndapota, ndiudzei kuti Snowden anobvumirana naRon Paul kuti tinofanira kugumisa rubatsiro kuIsrael. Ndapota taurai kuti anotsoropodza Israeri nenzira ipi zvayo. Nekuti ini ndoziva kuti i taboo, uye ichaita kuti Snowden aite kunge nzungu.
Zvekare, ndinofunga (uye tariro) O'Donnell haanzwisisi vazhinji vevateereri vake, uye achiratidza zvakawandisa nezve musungo wake muhungwaru hwakafanana. Kutsoropodza - kunyangwe kushoropodza kwakanyanya - kweIsrael, zvinosuruvarisa, kuchiri kunetsa mune vezvematongerwo enyika veAmerica nevezvenhau, asi zviri kuramba zvichigamuchirwa pakati pehuwandu huri kuwedzera hwevaAmerica vari kudzidza nezveIsrael neZionism kunze kweaya madenderedzwa. Saka, chaizvo, mubvunzo wese waitwa uyu kusimbisa zvakare kuti O'Donnell ane shungu sei yekutsvaga tara yekuzora Edward Snowden.
Asi zvakadaroโฆLawrence, sekutaura kunoita magweta, akavhura musuwo. Uye suwo rinonakidza iro, mune ino mamiriro. Ndichange ndichifamba nepamusuwo iwoyo mune inotevera post.
Parizvino, ndinoda kufungisisa nezve izvo O'Donnell akadana Edward Snowden's "anoshamisa naรฏvetรฉ."
Munhu anofanira kungwarira pamusoro peshoko rokuti "naรฏve." Iri izwi rinotorwa kureva chimwe chinhu senge "kusaziva pamwe nekusava nemhosva," uye, saizvozvo, rinowanzoshandiswa kuisa mutemo weAmerica wekune dzimwe nyika nemauto nemhepo yekusava nemhosva, Unoziva: "Takakweverwa kuVietnam, Iraq, [nyika yako-yakapinda-pano] nekuti hatina ruzivo," zvichireva kuti kuwandisa kwevavariro dzakanaka, uye hatina mhosva kuti zvitinakire isu pachedu.
Iyi ndiyo hogwash. Nyika ine simba guru renyika yecapitalist papasi, kuburikidza nehutungamiriri hwayo hwezvematongerwo enyika nemauto, hainyatsoronga nekuita kurwisa kwemauto nezvombo zvinouraya uye nemakumi kana mazana ezviuru zvevarwi kuitira kuti โvaite zvakanakaโ; Inoita kudaro kumanikidza kutevedza. Hapana "kusava nemhosva" kunobatanidzwa. Hutungamiri hweAmerica hunogona kuita neimwe nhanho yekusaziva, kuve nechokwadi, asi ndiko kusaziva kunobva, uye mukutsigira, kuzvikudza, kwete kusava nemhosva. Uye kusaziva plus kuzvikudza kunoita kwete equal naรฏvetรฉ.
Pachikamu chevarume nevakadzi vechidiki vakadzidziswa uye vanotorwa nehurumende yeumambo, zvisinei, vagari vechidiki vakaita saBradley Manning naEdward Snowden, "naรฏve" inogona kuva tsanangudzo yakakodzera.
Saka, hongu, zvakanaka kutaura kuti Snowden aive asina ruzivo mune yakakosha pfungwa. Zvichida, pamwe chete nemakumi ezviuru zvevamwe varume vechidiki vekuAmerica vanogara mu "nyika ine fuzzy" pakati pehudiki nekukura, varume vaive nedzidzo yakakwana yekuva "girosari" kana musoja / mhondi / cannon fodder, akatenda. zvese izvo zvisinganzwisisike zvaakadzidziswa nezve basa reAmerica munyika - munoziva, kuti tinopinda dzimwe nyika kuti "tiite zvakanaka," uye kuti kupinda mubhizinesi iri "kuda nyika." Ndinoshamisika kana Lawrence O'Donnell angave achibvunza chikamu chaangave akaita mukukurudzira naรฏvetรฉ yakadai, uye ndinogamuchira kuedza kwake kutsva, kwandine chokwadi kuti kucharamba kuchienderera mberi, kuzvidza majaya eAmerica efungidziro yekusavimbika uye inouraya.
Nekune rumwe rutivi, handigoverane izvo zvinoita sekutenda kwaO'Donnell kuti mauto echidiki mazhinji emuAmerica akange asina chinangwa chakadaro che "naรฏve", asi kuti akapinda muchiuto kuti agamuchire zvizere basa ravo semhondi. Ndinozivawo kuti, sezvakarehwa naMavanee Anderson, hapana chinhu mune zvakataurwa naSnowden kuti akanga asina ruzivo, mupfungwa ye "kubvunza kana iwe uri kuedza kuuraya vanhu kana iwe paunopinda muchiuto." Chii iye chaizvoizvo akaratidzwa to The Guardian kwaiva kuora mwoyo kwake uye kuora mwoyo mukuwana kuti "Vazhinji yevanhu vanotidzidzisa aiita seane shungu pamusoro pekuuraya maArabu, pasina kubatsira chero munhu." [Kusimbisa kwangu] Snowden aive asina ruzivo rwakadii nezvemauto nevamwe vake varwi?
Isu tinofanirwa kucherechedza zvakafanana pakati pemaitiro aSnowden naBradley Manning kubva ku naรฏvetรฉ kusvika pakuodzwa mwoyo kusvika pakuridza muridzo. Sezvinoita mauto mazhinji eAmerica, vese vakabatana nemauto ehungwaru muchikamu kuzadza kumwe kushomeka muhupenyu hwavo. Vese vakapinda vaine pfungwa dzisiridzo uye nekusanzwisisa kwakakwana pamusoro pezvavachange vachiita, uye vese vakaodzwa mwoyo nehutsinye husingafungirwe uye hutsotsi hwavakazopedzisira vapupura nekuva chikamu chazvo - izvo zvavainge vasingatarisire uye vasingafungi kuti vanhu vekuAmerica vaitarisira, kana vaiziva, kana kuti vaizobvuma kana vaiziva.
Segweta raBradley Manning, David E. Coombs, anotiudza, Manning akanetseka nokuona "kukoshesa kwataiita upenyu hwevanhu muIraq [huduku]. Akanetseka nazvo. Uye aidavira kuti kana voruzhinji vokuAmerica vakazviona, ivowo vaizonetseka uye zvichida zvinhu zvaizochinja." Nokudaro, vose vanotsanangura zvinokurudzira nenzira yakafanana: "Ndaida kutanga nharo" (Manning), uye "Ini ndinoda chaizvo kuti pfungwa ive pamagwaro aya uye gakava randinovimba kuti richatanga pakati pevagari vepasirese" (Snowden).
Vaitarisira kuti gakava raisazova pamusoro paRon Paul kana zvido zvavo zvepabonde. Mafungiro avaiita pamusoro peizvi ari muhukama hwakananga kune kushoma kwekutenda kwakanaka kune munhau pundits saLawrence O'Donnell naDavid Brooks.
Saka vaive vasina ruzivo, zvakanaka, uye haisi yepfungwa, asi mamiriro emagariro. Haisi chibereko che (kunyangwe ichigona kubatsira) kuvhiringidzika kwepfungwa. Icho chibereko chehungwaru hwekudzidzisa magariro evanhu, hunoparidzirwa nezvikoro zvekumanikidzira uye vezvenhau vanosarudzwa asi vari kwose kwose, izvo zvinonyangarika kubva mupfungwa dzevadiki musiyano uripo pakati pekuzvibata kweAmerica narcissistic uye nhoroondo chaiyo yeAmerica nebasa rayo rinouraya munyika yanhasi. Imhaka yekuti isu tiri, seGB Shaw akanyora: "akadzidziswa zvisirizvo nemaune."
Saka, chokwadi, ngatikurudzire vamwe vechidiki vekuAmerica kuti vaite rwendo rwumwechete rwakaitwa naSnowden naManning kubva mukurovererwa naรฏvetรฉ. "Kusava nemhosva" kwekupedzisira kwevarwi vehondo yeumambo, pamwe chete nevagari vehurumende yehurumende, inosarudzwa nezvavanoita kana vakarasikirwa nekusaziva kwavo.
Pane zvakare poindi pano pamusoro pekuti iyo mhunga yeAmerican pwere naรฏvetรฉ zvese zviri zviviri zvakakosha pasi uye Achilles chitsitsinho che21st-century yeAmerica empire. Izvo zvinoratidzwa nekusaziva mukutsinhana uko O'Donnell - kwete zvisina musoro, zvingaite senge - anobvunza Anderson kana chokwadi chekuti vechidiki vaviri vakaita saiye naAnderson vakawana mvumo yekuchengetedzwa kwepamusoro zvinoreva kuti "vari nyore kuwana kupfuura isu kunze kuno, kunze kwe. nharaunda yevangwaru, yazviona here?" Anderson, zvisinei, anomushora nepfungwa iyoyo, achiti: "Idzo dzakatooma kuwana."
Muchokwadi, munhu anofanirwa kupasa yakadzama yekumashure cheki kuti awane chepamusoro-chakavanzika chemvumo. Nokuda kwechikonzero ichocho, vanhu vaduku, vane nzvimbo shoma yokudzokera shure, vangakuwana kuri nyore kukwanirisa. Kana iwe uine hunyanzvi, iyo NSA haisi kuzova nehanya kana iwe uchiputa mubatanidzwa muchikoro chesekondari. Izvo chaizvo nekuda kweAmerican-exceptionalist nhoroondo yedzidzo uye kuwedzera kunyungudika uye kuchengetedza midhiya chikafu chavakadyiswa - zvirokwazvo vechidiki avo vari kutsvaga mabasa ehungwaru - kuti vangave vashoma kuve nerekodhi yekupokana kana zvematongerwo enyika. hunhu hunonetsa. Ivo zvakare vanozoda, zvechokwadi, kuve vasina naรฏve nezve izvo zvavachave chaizvo vachiita muuto rehungwaru. Mune mamwe mazwi, dzidzo yavo yezvematongerwo enyika neyenhoroondo iri pamberi pavo. Aya ndiwo makadhi ayo anokurumidza kuwedzera hungwaru uye yekutarisa zvishandiso zvinoda, uye inoda yakawanda, kuti ishande. (Kuwanda se 4 miriyoni vanhu vane chepamusoro-chakavanzika clearances pari zvino.)
Asi ivo vakangwara, uye vane ruzivo rwedhijitari, uye kune iyo internet inotyisa, uye zuva rega rega ravanoshanda vanozoona nekunzwisisa zvakanyanya zvavari kuita. Vechidiki mumwecheteyo, kusadzidziswa kwezvematongerwo enyika, uye kunyengedzwa naรฏvetรฉ izvo zvakaita kuti zvive nyore kwavari kuwana mvumo yepasi-chakavanzika zvinoita kuti vaore mwoyo mune ramangwana.
Ichi ndicho chikonzero kuchave nevakawanda Edward Snowdens naBradley Mannings - kwete nekuti kune akawanda majaya akavhiringika asina kufunga kuti angakura sei, asi nekuti pane mutsauko chaiwo pakati pezvinotaurwa neAmerican kuti inoita uye zvazvinoita. anoita, uye vazhinji vechidiki vakangwara vanozodzidza nezve iyo labyrinth yenhema uye vanoda kutsvaga nzira nyowani, ivo uye isu tese, kubva mairi.
ZNetwork inopihwa mari chete kuburikidza nerupo rwevaverengi vayo.
dhoneta