Bungwe la "Commission on the Intelligence Capabilities of the United States Pankhani ya Zida Zowononga Kwambiri" lachita bwino lomwe lidapangidwa kuti lichite. Tsoka ilo, idapangidwa kuti ipereke chivundikiro cha ndale kwa olamulira a Bush pakati pavuto lomwe limasokoneza Watergate, Iran-contra, komanso ngakhale Lewinsky-gate, koma kuti, mosiyana ndi zomwe zidachitikazi, sizinapangitse kufufuza mozama. , kuwulutsa pang'ono pawailesi yakanema, ndipo palibe kuyimba kulikonse kwa mitu yomwe ili ndi udindo.
Ganizirani mmbuyo kumapeto kwa Januware 2004 ndi lipoti loyamba la Iraq Survey Group, lomwe linanena kuti palibe zida zowononga anthu ambiri zomwe zidapezeka ku Iraq. Izi zidabwera pamwamba pa zomwe zidawululidwa panthawiyo zomwe olamulira a Bush adapusitsa anthu aku America mobwerezabwereza komanso mwadala - ndikuyesa kunyenga dziko lapansi - paumboni womwe umadzinenera kukhala nawo wokhudza WMD ya Iraq.
Pambuyo pa nkhondo, mavumbulutso amenewo adayamba ndi akaunti ya a Joseph Wilson kuti, akuyimira boma la Bush, adatsutsa zonena kuti Iraq ikugula uranium kuchokera ku Niger. Zinaphatikizanso kupepesa kwa boma la Britain chifukwa cha "dodgy dossier," momwe idalemba zambiri zazaka 12 kuchokera papepala la wophunzira yemwe wamaliza maphunziro ake ndikuzipereka ngati nzeru zamakono, komanso kuwulula kuti zomwe Tony Blair adanena kuti Iraq ikhoza kugwiritsa ntchito mankhwala ake omwe palibe. ndipo zida zophera tizilombo m'mphindi 45 zidadziwika kutengera mawu amodzi osatsimikizika a munthu wosadalirika. Idaphatikizanso kuwerengera kwathunthu mu Washington Post kuwonetsa kuti Iraq sinali ndipo sakanatha kugwiritsa ntchito machubu ake odziwika bwino a aluminiyamu pakulemeretsa uranium. Zinaphatikizaponso kutsutsa kwathunthu mu Associated Press pafupifupi chilichonse cha Colin Powell pa February 5, 2003, ku UN Security Council. Idaphatikizanso kufotokozera za udindo wa Cheney, Rumsfeld, ndi Ofesi yawo ya Mapulani Apadera pakukakamiza CIA, kupotoza zomwe akuganiza, komanso kuziyika pambali kuti apange kulungamitsidwa kwachangu komanso kokakamiza kwankhondo.
Mafundewa, komanso kusakhutira kwandale ndi kayendetsedwe ka Bush, kudayamba pomwe lipoti la David Kay linatuluka. Komabe, m'masiku ochepa atatulutsidwa, olamulira, mothandizidwa ndi ma Democrat odziwika bwino monga Jane Harman pa House Intelligence Committee, anali atathetsa kale nkhaniyo kuyambira chinyengo cha oyang'anira kupita ku chinthu chomwe chimatchedwa "kulephera kwanzeru," kusuntha mlandu kuchokera kwa akuluakulu. Akuluakulu omwe anatinamiza kunkhondo ku mabungwe a intelligence adakakamizika kunena mabodza amenewo. Kupangidwa kwa bungweli kunali gawo lomaliza pantchitoyi, ndipo kunathandizira kuthetsa mwayi uliwonse wofufuza mabodzawa.
M'malo motsutsa Bush, tidawona luso laukadaulo lomwe linapha mbalame ziwiri ndi mwala umodzi - kusokoneza chidwi komanso kuwukira kwa CIA, komwe kumawoneka ngati cholepheretsa kukhazikitsidwa kwa mfundo zakunja za Cheney-Rumsfeld-neoconservative. . Cheke yoperekedwa ndi CIA ndiyabwino, osati yamakhalidwe abwino, koma ikatsatiridwa, ikanapangitsa olamulirawo kuti asakumane ndi zochititsa manyazi monga kuthandizira kuyeserera kwa asitikali ku Venezuela komanso mwinanso kuchoka pantchito yopitilira zaka ziwiri. wa Iraq.
Ngakhale kuti bungweli silinagwire ntchito yoganizira momwe akuluakulu amagwiritsira ntchito zidziwitso, adapitabe kukanena kuti kukakamizidwa ndi akuluakulu aboma sikunachite nawo "kulephera kwanzeru," chifukwa "Ofufuza omwe adagwiritsa ntchito zida za Iraqi akutsutsa padziko lonse lapansi. adavomereza kuti palibe chifukwa chilichonse chokakamizidwa ndi ndale chomwe chinawapangitsa kupotoza kapena kusintha malingaliro awo. Inde, kuvomera koteroko sikungafanane ndi kunena kuti munthu sanagwire bwino ntchito yake, mโnyengo yamasiku ano akatswiri ofufuza za intelligence anayenera kudziwa kuti adzalangidwa chifukwa cha zimenezi.
Momwemonso, bungweli limadzudzula mwamphamvu momwe Purezidenti wa Daily Brief amakonzekera, kuwatcha "owopsa komanso osasunthika" kuposa malipoti atali ngati a National Intelligence Estimate ya Okutobala 2002 (yomwe idagwiritsidwa ntchito kwambiri ndi Office of Special Plans. ). "Mitu yawo yokopa chidwi ndi mawu obwerezabwereza" akuti anapatsa akuluakulu a boma lingaliro lakuti zonena zochititsa chidwi zinali zomveka bwino komanso zotsimikiziridwa kwambiri kuposa momwe zinaliri.
Komitiyi ikuyesera kutanthauza kuti zoopsa zina zochokera ku gulu la intelligence zidasokoneza utsogoleri kunkhondo. Ndipo komabe, palibe kutchulidwapo za "mutu wina wochititsa chidwi" kuchokera pa Ogasiti 6, 2001 PDB - "Bin Laden Watsimikiza Kuukira ku US." Kwa osadziwa, izi zitha kuwoneka ngati zowopsa, komabe sizinathandize kuti Bush adule tchuthi chake ku Crawford kapena kubweretsa akuluakulu ena ku Washington DC. Ndizovuta kuthawa kunena kuti olamulira "adachita mantha" ndi zonena zomwe zimagwirizana ndi mapulani ake omwe analipo kale, monga kuwukira kwa Iraq, koma sakanatha kuvutitsidwa ndi zonena zomwe zinalibe chochita pang'ono ndi ndondomeko yachifumu, koma, za Inde, ntchitoyo ithawa mosavuta.
Zambiri zomwe bungweli likumaliza ponena za zofooka za gulu lanzeru ndizowona ndipo zimabwereza zomwe otsutsa oganiza bwino mkati monga Richard Clarke ndi Michael Scheuer akhala akunena. Mwanjira ina, si vuto lalikulu la bungweli koma la Bush Administration lomwe lidapangitsa kuti likhale losokoneza komanso la ndale kuchokera kumadera osiyanasiyana omwe adadzilola kuti apatutsidwe.
Chodetsa nkhawa kwambiri pa lipotili ndikuti zigawo zanzeru zokhudzana ndi Iran ndi North Korea zasungidwa m'magulu. Kulungamitsidwa komwe kwaperekedwa ndikuti palibe chifukwa choti boma la US lipereke dzanja kwa mamembala otsala a Bush "axis of evil". Koma, poganizira kugwedezeka kwa kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe kake m'mayiko onsewa, ufulu wa anthu wodziwa ndi wofunika kwambiri. Ngati kusuntha pang'ono kupangitsedwe kumenya nkhondo iliyonse yolimbana ndi Iran (zowoneka ngati ziwirizi), chinthu choyamba chomwe tiyenera kufunsa ndikuchotsa masambawo.
Pambuyo pake, mwina tikhoza kuyankhanso funso la kutsutsidwa.
Rahul Mahajan ndi wofalitsa blog Empire'>Empire Notes. Iye wakhala akugonjetsa Iraq kawiri ndipo adanena kuchokera ku Fallujah panthawi ya kuzingidwa kwa April 2004. Buku lake laposachedwapa ndi "Ulamuliro Wathunthu Wamphamvu: Mphamvu zaku US ku Iraq ndi Kupitilira'> Ulamuliro Wathunthu: Mphamvu zaku US ku Iraq ndi Kupitilira. Iye akhoza kufikiridwa pa [imelo ndiotetezedwa].
ZNetwork imalandira ndalama kudzera mu kuwolowa manja kwa owerenga ake.
Ndalama