Ndi chizindikiro cha nthawi yomwe chigamulo chaposachedwa cha Khothi Lalikulu - chomwe, m'malingaliro mwanga, chikufanana ndi Kesavanand Bharati Chitsimikizo cha 1973 chokhudzana ndi "mapangidwe oyambira" a malamulo oyendetsera dziko - chikadakhala chosazindikirika komanso chosazindikirika ndi manyuzipepala athu, kuletsa Indian Express, yomwe mothokoza inatsogolera ndi nkhaniyi pa February 27.
Palibe njira yapa TV, monga momwe ndikudziwira, yomwe idanenapo izi, osasiyapo kuti tikambirane mkangano waukulu.
Fananizani izi ndi chigamulo cha 2022 chomwe chidadzudzula a Zakia Jafri, mkazi wamasiye wa MP wakale wophedwa, Ehsan Jafri, chifukwa chochonderera kuti kuphedwa kwa Gujarat mu 2002 kubwerezedwenso kuti awone udindo wa nduna yayikulu panthawiyo.
Wothandizirana ndi Zakia, Teesta Setalvad, adakokedwa ndi makala chifukwa chofuna kusunga mphikawo "pa chithupsaโ monga gawo la โchiwembuโ chonyansa.
Chigamulo chomalizachi chakhala chikufalitsidwa kwambiri ndi mapiko abwino kuti awononge zomwe zapezeka m'nyuzipepala ya BBC yomwe anthu amanyansidwa nayo ponena za kuphedwa kumeneku.
Koma zomwe anachita ku chigamulo chaposachedwa chokana pempho lofuna kubwezeretsa 'choyambirira' (Sic) mayina a mabungwe omwe adasinthidwa ndi "olanda ankhanza" amakhalabe osalankhula; ngakhale iwo omwe akupitirizabe kudandaula ndi momwe demokalase yoyendetsera dziko la India ilili akuwoneka kuti adutsa pa zomwe a Justices KM Joseph ndi BV Nagarathna adanena pankhaniyi.
Pempho lomwe likufunsidwalo lidaperekedwa ndi advocate Ashwini Upadhyay, yemwenso ndi mtsogoleri wa BJP.
Upadhyay, kumapeto kwa mlanduwu, adakana chisankho "chochotsa" pempho lake, lomwe "lidachotsedwa" mwalamulo.
Zowonera zoyipa
Nthawi zambiri, mwina, zigamulo za khothi lalikulu zimatsatiridwa ndi obiter ngati ili.
Osati pokhapokha ngati mawu onenedwa ndi oweruza ophunzitsidwa bwino aganiziridwa mokwanira, titha kumvetsetsa bwino zomwe zidapangitsa kuti pempho la Upadhyay lithe.
Tamverani chitsanzo cha zimene oweruza ananena:
โdziko silingakhale mkaidi wakale, ndipo khoti siliyenera kukhala chida choyambitsa chipwirikitiโ;
โIndia ndi dziko losapembedza, ndipo ili ndi msonkhano wadzikoโ;
โpalibe danga la tsankho mโChihinduโ;
โmufuna kusunga mlanduwo, ndi kusunga dziko pa chithupsaโ;
โZala zimalozeredwa pagulu linalake; mukufuna kusokoneza gawo linalake la anthuโ;
โChihindu ndi njira ya moyo; chifukwa chake India adatengera aliyense; chifukwa chake tiri okhoza kukhala pamodziโ; (Chenjezo: ndi nkhani ina yomwe akatswiri amalingaliro a Hindutva amaganiza kuti, popeza atengeka kwambiri, onse omwe si Ahindu tsopano ayenera kudziyesa Ahindu.)
โMalamulo ogaลตanitsa ndi kulamulira a Briteni anadzetsa magaลตano mโchitaganya chathu; tisabwere nayeโ;
"India idakwatiwa ndi malamulo, kusakonda zachipembedzo, kutsata malamulo oyendetsera dziko lomwe Ndime 14 imayimira ngati chitsimikiziro chachikulu cha kufanana ndi chilungamo pazochitika za boma";
"Mfundo yotsogolera yaubale yomwe yatchulidwanso mu Mawu Oyamba ndi yofunika kwambiri."
Mosafunikira kunena, kuphatikizika kwa ma averments uku ndikulengeza za kuchulukitsa kwa malamulo adziko komwe kunatsogolera gulu laufulu ndikukhazikitsa repabuliki ya demokalase pakutsata kopatulika kulingana kwa unzika ndi ufulu.
Mwanzeru kwambiri, komanso mogwirizana ndi chidziลตitso chabwino kwambiri cha akatswiri a mbiri yakale odziลตika kwambiri padziko lonse, khotilo latsindika mfundo yakuti malo alionse amene anthu amakhalako masiku ano amapangidwa ndi zochitika za mbiri yakale komanso zosasinthika. Mabungwe omwe amatengera bwino kuchulukiraku amapambana kwambiri pakugwiritsa ntchito demokalase ya republic.
M'nkhani yathu, mwachitsanzo, anali Man Singh, Rajput, yemwe anamenyana ndi Maharana Pratap, Rajput wina, m'malo mwa mfumu ya Moghul, Akbar ku. Haldighati; Shivaji anali ndi Asilamu ambiri mu gulu lake lankhondo, adapereka Afzal Khan maliro a boma, ndipo anapereka ndalama zosungira manda ake, ndipo taonani, Aurangzeb wonyozedwayo anapereka ambiri. zopereka ndi malo ku akachisi achihindu, monga ndi nthawi yake, mofanana ndi wolamulira wina aliyense wa chipembedzo chilichonse, izo zinali zogwirizana ndi realpolitik yake.
Communal historiography sitero fotokozani chifukwa chake Mafumu achihindu anaukira akachisi achihindu kuti atole zikho zankhondo, ndi zina zotero.
Kulakwitsa koyipa kwakhala kufananiza ufumu wa Gupta ndi ulamuliro wachihindu, ma Sultan ndi a Moghul ndi ulamuliro wachisilamu ndi zina zotero, pomwe zowona zikuwonetsa kuti olamulira onse amatsata zofuna zamagulu zomwe zimasiya osauka amtundu uliwonse kuti adzisamalira okha, monga momwe amachitira. nthawi zambiri amasokeretsedwa ndi maitanidwe achipembedzo.
Izi zinali choncho ndi ulamuliro wa atsamunda a ku Britain, ndipo nโchimodzimodzinso ndi ulamuliro wamagulu ku India masiku ano. Ndi zina zotero.
M'malo ophunzirira kwambiri, zitha kutsutsidwa kuti zakale za dziko lililonse sizikhala zakuda ndi zoyera monga momwe anthu onyanyira amakonda kufalitsa; ndi kuti kufalitsa kulikonse kotereku sikumakhudzidwa kwenikweni ndi zakale komanso kulungamitsa mtundu wina wamakono ndi mtsogolo womwe anthu monyanyira akufuna kupanga.
Pakadali pano, cholinga apa chinali makamaka kulemba zomwe oweruza olemekezeka adachita pamlandu wosintha dzina, kuti, mwachiyembekezo, iwo adatchedwanso Mughal Gardens, mocheperapo, (monga ngati kuchotsa mbali zolamulidwa ndi Moghul za mbiri yathu) akhoza kutafuna nzeru za Khothi Lalikulu, zomwe nthawi zambiri amazitchula pamene zikugwirizana ndi zolinga zawo, ndikuyimitsa ndondomeko yobwezeretsa kuchuluka kwa India m'malo mokakamiza. kufanana kwabodza.
Kulakwitsa koyipa kwakhala kufananiza ufumu wa Gupta ndi ulamuliro wachihindu, ma Sultan ndi a Moghul ndi ulamuliro wachisilamu ndi zina zotero, pomwe zowona zikuwonetsa kuti olamulira onse amatsata zofuna zamagulu zomwe zimasiya osauka amtundu uliwonse kuti adzisamalira okha, monga momwe amachitira. nthawi zambiri amasokeretsedwa ndi maitanidwe achipembedzo.
Izi zinali choncho ndi ulamuliro wa atsamunda a ku Britain, ndipo nโchimodzimodzinso ndi ulamuliro wamagulu ku India masiku ano. Ndi zina zotero.
M'malo ophunzirira kwambiri, zitha kutsutsidwa kuti zakale za dziko lililonse sizikhala zakuda ndi zoyera monga momwe anthu onyanyira amakonda kufalitsa; ndi kuti kufalitsa kulikonse kotereku sikumakhudzidwa kwenikweni ndi zakale komanso kulungamitsa mtundu wina wamakono ndi mtsogolo womwe anthu monyanyira akufuna kupanga.
Pakadali pano, cholinga apa chinali makamaka kulemba zomwe oweruza olemekezeka adachita pamlandu wosintha dzina, kuti, mwachiyembekezo, iwo adatchedwanso Mughal Gardens, mocheperapo, (monga ngati kuchotsa mbali zolamulidwa ndi Moghul za mbiri yathu) akhoza kutafuna nzeru za Khothi Lalikulu, zomwe nthawi zambiri amazitchula pamene zikugwirizana ndi zolinga zawo, ndikuyimitsa ndondomeko yobwezeretsa kuchuluka kwa India m'malo mokakamiza. kufanana kwabodza.
ZNetwork imalandira ndalama kudzera mu kuwolowa manja kwa owerenga ake.
Ndalama