Lerolino, May Day—omwenso amadziŵikanso kuti International Workers’ Day—ndi nthaŵi yabwino kulingalira funso ili: Tsogolo la ogwira ntchito mwadongosolo ndi lotani? Uwu unali mutu wa bukhu la 2006, lolembedwa ndi Craig Phelan. Bukuli lili ndi mawu oyamba osangalatsa a Dan Gallin. Mmenemo Gallin akupanga mfundo zingapo zofunika. Zikuphatikizapo:
- Gulu la ogwira ntchito lili pamavuto.
- Vutoli nthawi zambiri limabwera chifukwa cha kudalirana kwadziko kwatsopano.
- Pali chowonadi chonena 2 koma izi ndi "zowonadi pang'ono ndi kuzindikira pang'ono".
- Chowonadi chozama ndichakuti vutoli lidayamba kuyambika kwa kudalirana kwadziko lonse lapansi ndi neoliberal ndipo ndi chifukwa cha vuto "lokulirapo" komanso "lokulirapo" mkati mwa gulu la ogwira ntchito.
Gallin akupitiriza kunena kuti gwero la zovuta mkati mwa ogwira ntchito mwadongosolo ndilo vuto la "chidziwitso ndi malingaliro". Monga Gallin akufotokozera:
"Kufunika kwa nthawiyi ndizovuta kwambiri ku likulu la mayiko padziko lonse lapansi komanso dongosolo ladziko lapansi lomwe lapanga, koma vuto lotere silingakwaniritsidwe pokhapokha ngati gululi litapezanso chidziwitso chofanana ndi masomphenya ena a anthu."
Kodi njira ina iyi ndi chiyani? Monga Gallin akunenera, "mbiri yakale, njira iyi yakhala socialism". Monga momwe akusonyezera, komabe, "Socialism ikukumananso ndi vuto, ndipo ndilo vuto la tanthauzo la socialism". Poyankha zovuta izi Gallin akuti kufunikira kwa "masomphenya wamba":
"Mwachiwonekere, tiyenera kufotokozeranso chikhalidwe cha chikhalidwe cha chikhalidwe cha chikhalidwe cha anthu kuti chidziwikenso ngati ndale zomwe mwachibadwa ndi zathu, za gulu la anthu ogwira ntchito zakale - zozindikirika komanso zovomerezeka ngakhale ndi omwe adakana, pazifukwa zomveka, katundu wowonongeka wogulitsidwa pansi pa izo. label."
Komabe, Gallin akuchenjeza kuti tiyenera kumanganso kutengera "chidziwitso chogawana" komanso "makhalidwe ogawana". Kukonzekera mozungulira "chinthu chochepa kwambiri" sichingagwire ntchito. Monga akunenera, "ndizo zomwe tili nazo lero ndipo kayendetsedwe kameneka, monga momwe ziliri, kangathe kutaya". Zomwe tikufunikira, Gallin akutsutsa, ndi "mafotokozedwe ena a dziko lapansi, zolinga zina za anthu ndi ndondomeko ya momwe mungapitire komwe onse angalembetse". Akupitiriza kuti:
"Gulu latsopano la ogwira ntchito padziko lonse lapansi, lokhala ndi malingaliro a ntchito yokulirapo, litha kukhala maziko a mgwirizano wapadziko lonse lapansi kuphatikiza magulu ena onse omwe ali ndi zolinga zofanana. Kusuntha koteroko kungasinthe dziko lapansi. Ukhoza kukhalanso gulu lomasula anthu lomwe linakonzekera zaka zana limodzi ndi makumi asanu zapitazo. "
Koma kodi ntchito yachitukukoyi ndi zomwe takambiranazi zingakhale zotani? Apa tikufuna kunena kuti Green New Deal ikukwanira bwino ndalamazo. Green New Deal nthawi zambiri imamveka ngati njira yothetsera vuto la nyengo. Chifukwa chake ena angadabwe kuti, momwe Green New Deal ikugwirizanirana ndi zovuta zantchito yolinganizidwa. Chotsalira cha nkhaniyi chiyesa kuwonetsa kuti zovuta ziwirizi ndi Green New Deal ndizogwirizana komanso zogwirizana kwambiri. logic ndi ubwenzi umenewu umapita motere:
- Green New Deal ndiye njira yothetsera vuto la nyengo.
- Komabe, kuti tipange Green New Deal kukhala kampeni yamphamvu yapadziko lonse lapansi, ndikukhazikitsanso kusintha koyenera, tifunika kutsitsimutsa anthu ogwira ntchito.
- Kuti titsitsimutse ntchito zokonzedwa, tifunika, monga tafotokozera kale, ntchito yatsopano yachitukuko.
- Green New Deal ndiye ntchito yatsopanoyi.
Malinga ndi katswiri wa zachuma Ann Pettifor, lingaliro la Green New Deal likhoza kuyambika ku 2007 pamene mtolankhani Thomas L. Friedman analemba nkhani ya New York Times yotchedwa "Chenjezo lochokera ku Munda". Pambuyo pake chaka chomwecho woyambitsa kampeni waku Britain wakale waku GreenPeace, a Colin Hines, adasonkhanitsa gulu la anthu omwe ali ndi malingaliro ofanana kuti apange lingaliro la Green New Deal. Malinga ndi Pettifor, lingalirolo, lomwe lidasindikizidwa mu 2008, ndikufanana ndi zomwe Friedman adalemba kale, adafuna "kuphatikiza mfundo zothetsera mavuto atatu a ngongole, kusintha kwanyengo komanso kukwera mtengo kwamafuta". Monga olemba adanenera:
"Zochitika zitatu zomwe zikutsatizanazi zikuwopseza kukhala chimphepo chamkuntho, chomwe sichinawonekere kuyambira nthawi yamavuto akulu. Pofuna kupewa izi kuti zisachitike tikukonza za Green New Deal ”.
Kuyambira pachiyambi pomwe, Green New Deal sinali yongothana ndi vuto la nyengo. M'malo mwake, nthawi zonse zakhala zothana ndi vuto lomwe liripo chifukwa cha kusintha kwachilengedwe kopangidwa ndi anthu komanso kuthana ndi zovuta zina zofunika kwambiri zamagulu, zomwe zakulitsidwa ndi kuphatikizika kwa ndale zachipongwe komanso kudalirana kwachuma kwatsopano. Monga Pettifor akunenera:
"Green New Deal imafuna kusintha kwakukulu kwadongosolo: kusintha kwachuma komanso chilengedwe. Ikufuna kusintha kwadongosolo (maboma ndi maboma) osati kusintha kwa kachitidwe, dera kapena luso laukadaulo, pamachitidwe athu pazachuma, chuma chapadziko lonse lapansi ndi chilengedwe”.
Mwachiwonekere, chifukwa cha kufulumira kwa mkhalidwe wamakono, pakufunika kwambiri gulu lotchuka lomwe silinachitikepo ndi kale lonse. Gulu loterolo liyenera kukhazikitsidwa pa kampeni yapadziko lonse lapansi yomwe ili ndi mawu akulu komanso mfundo zoganiziridwa kuti zithandizire. Uku ndiko kuzama ndi kufalikira kwa Green New Deal, ngati pulogalamu ya kampeni, zomwe zimapangitsa kuti pakhale mayendedwe otere. Nayi Pettifor kachiwiri:
"Green New Deal ikhoza kulimbikitsa zoyesayesa za anthu mamiliyoni ambiri omwe akulimbana ndi chiwopsezo cha kusokonekera kwa dongosolo ladziko lapansi, kulephera kwachuma komanso kusalingana kwachuma padziko lonse lapansi komanso kusatetezeka. Pansi pa denga lake tikuyembekeza kugwirizanitsa ndikulimbikitsa omenyera ufulu wambiri padziko lonse lapansi ndikuyambitsanso boma kuti lipereke ndalama zothandizira anthu komanso zachilengedwe - potero kuonetsetsa kuti dziko lapansi likukhalamo kwa anthu omwe ali ndi moyo masiku ano komanso mibadwo yamtsogolo. "
Kuti tithe kumanga bwino kayendetsedwe kameneka, komabe, padzakhala kofunika kuthetsa chisokonezo chilichonse pa kutsutsana komwe kulipo pakati pa kuthana ndi vuto la nyengo, kumbali imodzi, ndi kupititsa patsogolo umoyo wa anthu onse ndikuthana ndi ulova wambiri ndi kusalingana kwa ndalama, kumbali inayo. . M’buku lawo la Global Green New Deal, Noam Chomsky ndi Robert Pollin akufotokoza bwino mfundoyi:
"Chofunika kwambiri pakupititsa patsogolo kayendetsedwe kameneka, m'mayiko omwe akutukuka kumene ndi kwina kulikonse, kusonyeza mosakayikira momwe kukhazikika kwa nyengo kumagwirizana ndi kukulitsa mwayi wa ntchito zabwino, kukweza moyo wa anthu ambiri, ndi kulimbana ndi umphawi m'madera onse a dziko lapansi. Izi zikuyenera kuzindikirika ngati lingaliro loyambira pansi pa Green New Deal yapadziko lonse lapansi. Kupititsa patsogolo mgwirizano wapadziko lonse wa Green New Deal kuyenera kumveka ngati njira yomwe "chiyembekezo cha chifuniro" chimakhala chamoyo pakutanthauzira chuma chandale chopulumutsa dziko lapansi.
Monga tikuonera kuchokera m'mawu omwe akudutsa m'nkhaniyi, zokhumba za Green New Deal, monga momwe Pettifor, Chomsky ndi Pollin adafotokozera zimagwirizana kwathunthu ndi zomwe Gallin adafotokoza. M'lingaliro limenelo, Green New Deal ndi "masomphenya wamba" omwe Gallin akuyang'ana ndikukonzekera zosowa za ogwira ntchito kuti atsitsimutse. Komabe, zikhoza kutsutsidwa kuti Green New Deal si socialism choncho sichimakwaniritsa zofunikira za Gallin.
Ngati mwa socialism tikutanthauza chuma / chikhalidwe chopanda kalasi ndiye, kunena mosapita m'mbali, ndizowona kuti Green New Deal si socialism ndipo kutsutsa komweku kuli koyenera. Pali, komabe, njira zosiyanasiyana zowonera izi. Choyamba, tiyenera kumvetsetsa kuti palibe chinthu chimodzi chomwe ndi socialism. Monga momwe katswiri wina wa sosholisti - Bernard Crick - ananenera, "pali mitundu yambiri ya sosholizimu." Mwachitsanzo, pali "zosiyana pa mutu wa Marx", "decentralist, syndicalist ndi cooperative miyambo ya socialism yomwe imachokera kwa Proudhon ndi Robert Owen". Palinso "mitundu yoyang'anira kapena yosakanikirana yachuma yomwe idachokera ku Germany revisionists ndi British Fabians". Ndiye pali mitundu ya "anarchist ndi communitarian" ya socialism.
Kuchokera kukutanthawuza kokulirapo kwa zomwe zitha kupanga sosholizimu, Green New Deal ikhoza kuonedwa kuti ndi ya sosholisti - mwina ngati chitsanzo cha machitidwe owongolera kapena osakanikirana achuma - motero amakwaniritsa zofunikira za Gallin za masomphenya omwe amagawana nawo. Kwa iwo omwe sapeza malingaliro okhutiritsa, komabe, mfundo zingapo zomaliza kuchokera ku Chomsky, ponena za Green New Deal ndi socialism, ndizofunikira kuziganizira mozama:
“Mtsutso wabwino ungapangidwe wakuti mikhalidwe yobadwa nayo ya ukapitalizimu imatsogolera kuwononga chilengedwe mosalekeza, ndi kuti kuthetsa ukapitalizimu kuyenera kukhala chinthu chofunika kwambiri cha kayendetsedwe ka chilengedwe. Pali vuto limodzi lofunikira pa mkanganowu: kuchuluka kwa nthawi. Kuthetsa ukapitalizimu n’kosatheka mkati mwa nthaŵi yofunikira kuchitapo kanthu mwamsanga, kumene kumafunikira kusonkhezera dziko lalikulu—ndithudi padziko lonse lapansi ngati vuto lalikulu lipewedwe.”
“Kuphatikiza apo, zokambirana zonse ndi zabodza. Zoyesayesa ziwirizi—kupeŵa tsoka la chilengedwe, kuthetsa ukapitalisti m’malo mwa anthu olungama, omasuka ndi ademokalase—ziyenera kuchitika ndipo zikhoza kupitirira limodzi. Ndipo akhoza kupita kutali ndi mabungwe otchuka kwambiri. "
Mwachidule, tikufunika mabungwe onse ogwira ntchito zamalonda, padziko lonse lapansi, kuti abwere pamodzi mogwirizana pa Green New Deal monga maziko otsitsimula ntchito zapadziko lonse lapansi kuti athe kuthana ndi vuto la nyengo ndikumanga njira ina yotsutsana ndi ndale zachitukuko komanso zachuma za neoliberal. kudalirana kwa mayiko. Ngati ogwira ntchito mwadongosolo ali ndi tsogolo - ngati aliyense wa ife ali ndi tsogolo - ndiye Green New Deal ndi.
Ndemanga:
Mawu onse a Gallin akuchokera: Craig Phelan (Ed) Tsogolo la Ntchito Yolinganizidwa: Malingaliro Padziko Lonse. (2006)
Mawu onse a Ann Pettifor akuchokera: Mlandu wa Green New Deal. (2020)
Mawu onse a Noam Chomsky ndi Robert Pollin akuchokera: Mavuto a Zanyengo ndi Global Green New Deal. (2020)
Mawu onse a Bernard Crick akuchokera: Socialism. (1987)
Mark Evans ndi wogwira ntchito zachipatala komanso wogwira ntchito zamalonda yemwe amakhala ndikugwira ntchito ku Birmingham (UK).
Bridget Meehan ndi mlembi komanso womenyera ufulu wokhala ku Ireland yemwe ndi woyambitsa nawo kampeni ya banki yaku Northern Mutual komanso membala wa Collaboration for Change, gulu la anthu omenyera ufulu wa anthu omwe amalimbikitsa kulimbikitsa anthu onse.
Iwo onse ndi mamembala a Utopia Yeniyeni: Maziko a Gulu Logwira Ntchito.
ZNetwork imalandira ndalama kudzera mu kuwolowa manja kwa owerenga ake.
Ndalama
2 Comments
O, ndi Bridget. Bugger.
Mverani Mark. 👍