Stephen Maher ndi wophunzira wophunzira ku ndi
Pansipa pali zokambirana ndi Maher, zomwe zimayang'ana mwachidwi mkangano, komanso zomwe zachitika posachedwa m'derali. Lapangidwa kuti lipatse omwe sadziwa kwambiri mayankho a mafunso ofunikira.
Maher akufunsidwa ndi Michael Corcoran, mtolankhani yemwe adalembera Boston Globe and the Nation, komanso wophunzira womaliza maphunziro a ubale wapadziko lonse pa John McCormack Graduate School of Policy Studies ku UMass Boston.
MC: Mungauze owerenga zomwe zakufikitsani
SM: Ndinapita koyamba chilimwe chatha kwa miyezi itatu, pamene ndinatenga nawo mbali pa zokambirana zomwe zinayesa kupereka malingaliro ambiri okhudzana ndi kusamvana. Pambuyo pa msonkhanowu, womwe udatenga masiku khumi, ndidachita maphunziro ku Palestinian Legislative Council, yomwe ndi bungwe lazamalamulo la Ulamuliro wa Palestine, makamaka kontrakitala wa Israeli pakufuna kuphatikizira zigawo zazikulu za
Msonkhano ndi pulogalamu inali ndi mavuto ambiri, omwe tingalowemo, koma chomwe chinandidabwitsa ndi kuchuluka kwa zomwe mungaphunzire poyang'ana momwe zinthu zikuyendera ndikudziyika nokha pa phunziro la phunziro. Mwadzidzidzi, "nkhani" yomwe mukufufuza imasiya kukhala "nkhani" konse, koma moyo wa anzanu mumzinda womwe mudakhalamo. Ndizodabwitsa kuti gawo lalikulu la zomwe timawona ndikumva tsiku ndi tsiku za nkhondo ya Palestine ndi mkangano wa Arabi-Israel mochuluka amatsutsidwa kapena kukonzedwa mwa kuthera nthawi pansi, kulankhula ndi anthu, kupanga mabwenzi, kuyenda m'deralo, ndi kuphunzira. zomwe zikuchitika pakukhala moyo wa iwo omwe mukufuna kuti mumvetse, kuwona dziko ndi maso awo. Mosafunikira kunena, zimapita kutali.
Nthawi yanga yogwira ntchito ndi PLC m'nyengo yachilimweyi idandiphunzitsa zambiri za magwiridwe antchito a Ulamuliro wa Palestine, bungwe lomwe likuyenera kusandulika kukhala boma la dziko la Palestine lamtsogolo pambuyo pa "nthawi yocheperako" yautali wosadziwika, womwe tili. Panopa. Kuchokera pa zomwe ndakumana nazo ndidajambula mutu wanga wokhudzana ndi kudalira, kusagwira ntchito, komanso kusagwirizana ndi mabungwe andale aku Palestine. Itafika nthawi yoti ndiyambe kufufuza, ndidafuna kwambiri kubwereranso
Ndinatha kuchita kafukufuku wofunika kwambiri pamene ndinkakhala ku Ramallah kwa miyezi inayi. Komabe, ndikufuna kukhulupirira kuti zifukwa zanga zopitira ku
MC: Kwa owerenga omwe sadziwa bwino momwe zinthu zilili mu Israeli/Palestine, mungafotokoze, nthawi zambiri, zomwe zikuchitika kumeneko?
SM: Ili ndi funso lalikulu, lomwe limafunikira yankho lokwanira. Komabe, ndiyesera kuziyika mwachidule momwe ndingathere.
Kuyambira pakati pa zaka za m'ma 1970, pakhala mgwirizano waukulu wapadziko lonse pothetsa nkhondo yomwe imatchedwa Palestine-Israel, yomwe imatchedwa "maboma awiri." Yankho ili likuchokera pa quid-pro-quo yosavuta: kuchoka kwa Israeli kudera lomwe adalanda mokakamiza mu 1967, komanso kuzindikira kwa Palestina.
Milandu ya Israeli yolimbana ndi Apalestina ndi yodabwitsa kwambiri, komanso yowonekera kwambiri, kotero kuti njira yokhayo yomveka ndiyokwiyitsa komanso ukali. Chofunika kwambiri, zolakwa izi - posachedwapa kuphatikizapo kupha anthu ku Gaza - sizikanatha kupitirira popanda thandizo lovuta la US limene Israeli amalandira m'madera onse, zomwe sizinachitikepo m'mbiri ya mayiko. Malinga ndi lipoti la 2008 la Congressional Research Service, thandizo la US ku Israeli ndilokwera $ 6.8 miliyoni. patsiku. Pakadali pano, US imateteza mfundo za Israeli kuti zitsutsidwe ndi mayiko ena pogwiritsa ntchito veto yofunika kwambiri ya UN Security Council, yomwe idagwiritsidwa ntchito posachedwa kwambiri kuletsa kwa milungu ingapo kuyimitsa moto kwa UN komwe kukanakakamiza Israeli kuti asiye kupha anthu osauka, osadziteteza ku Palestine. Gaza (kupha 1500 mwa anthu 1.5 miliyoni, makamaka anthu wamba). Kuukira koopsaku kunaphatikizapo kugwiritsa ntchito phosphorous yoyera, chida chowopsya, chopanda tsankho chomwe chimayambitsa kutentha kwakukulu kwa mankhwala kwa iwo omwe amakumana nawo, m'misasa ya anthu othawa kwawo yomwe ili ndi anthu ambiri. Phosphorous yogwiritsidwa ntchito ndi a Israeli - pamodzi ndi zida zina zomwe zinagwiritsidwa ntchito popha anthu - zinapangidwa ndikuperekedwa ndi United States.
Komabe zolakwa za Israeli ndizokhazikika, ndipo - ngakhale ndimanjenjemera kugwiritsa ntchito mawuwa - chizolowezi kuposa kuwononga nthawi zina kwa othawa kwawo osauka, opanda chitetezo. Kuchokera ku 1967, Israeli yayamba ntchito yaikulu yowonjezera ku West Bank, yomwe imadziwika ndi kuba kosalekeza kwa nthaka ndi chuma cha Palestina kudzera m'njira zosiyanasiyana. Chodziwika kwambiri, komanso chatsopano kwambiri, ndi Khoma la Tsankho / Zowonjezera (kapena "mpanda wolekanitsa" monga momwe Israeli amanenera molakwika). Ngakhale malire pakati pa Israeli ndi West Bank ndi ongopitirira pang'ono kuposa 300 km kutalika, khomalo ndi loposa 800 km m'litali, kutanthauza kuti khomalo limayenda mtunda wa makilomita kupita kudera la Palestine, kutenga malo amtengo wapatali ndi chuma chakumadzulo, " Kumbali ya Israeli, ndikusandutsa madera aku Palestina kukhala ndende, osauka kwambiri opanda chuma kapena malo oti azitha kudzisamalira.
Bizinesi iyi imatsogolanso ndikukula kosalekeza kwa madera osaloledwa ku West Bank, omwe amalanda chuma cha Palestina ndi malo mothandizidwa ndi dziko la Israeli. Maderawa ndi olumikizidwa kwa wina ndi mnzake komanso m'matauni akuluakulu ku Israeli okhala ndi "misewu yodutsa," yopangidwa kuti idutse madera aku Palestina, ndikupangitsa kuti pakhale chitukuko chatsopano chazachuma chomwe chimalepheretsa dala ndikusaukitsa madera achiarabu ku West Bank. Zonsezi, izi zimasiya midzi ya Palestina italandidwa malo awo ndi khoma ndi midzi ndikuzunguliridwa ndi misewu yodutsa, osauka, ndi oponderezedwa, olekanitsidwa kukhala ma cantons, zipinda zandende zomwe zimayendetsedwa kuchokera kunja ndi Israeli.
MC: Mumatchula za thandizo la US, lomwe limabwera ngati thandizo lalikulu la mayiko onse, monga momwe mwatchulira, komanso kusayanjanitsika kwa anthu kapena, nthawi zina kuthandizira kwenikweni, nkhanza za Israeli. Popeza US ili ndi gawo lofunikira kwambiri pankhaniyi, kodi aku America angachite chiyani, ngati chilipo, kutsutsa mfundozi? Ndipo pali gawo la gulu la ogwira ntchito?
SM: Kwenikweni ngakhale owonera ambiri, makamaka aufulu, amadzudzula US chifukwa cha "kuyang'ana kwina" pomwe Israeli ikuchita zophwanya mitundu yonse, izi sizili choncho. Israeli sakanatha kupitiriza ntchito yake ndi kuphatikizira kwa tsiku limodzi, kapena kupitiriza kumenyana ndi Gaza, popanda thandizo lalikulu la US. United States imathandizira bizinesi yonse, kwinaku ikuteteza Israeli ku zovuta zapadziko lonse lapansi kuti asinthe machitidwe ake. Chifukwa chake, a US ndiwotenga nawo mbali komanso amathandizira kwambiri milandu yowopsa ya Israeli ku West Bank, Gaza, ndi kwina.
M'malingaliro anga anthu aku America ali ndi gawo lofunikira kwambiri pakuletsa nkhanza za Israeli. Popeza boma la America ndilomwe likuyambitsa zigawenga za Israeli, bungwe lodziwika bwino ku United States ndilofunika kwambiri kusintha ndondomekoyi. Izi ziyenera kuyamba ndi kufalitsa chidziwitso ndi kuphunzitsa anthu za chikhalidwe cha milandu, yomwe imanyalanyazidwa kwambiri ndi atolankhani aku America. Ngati gawo lofunikirali - kuphunzitsa anthu - silinali gawo loyamba la ntchito yomenyera ufulu wachibadwidwe, ndiye kuti kudzudzula kulikonse kwa Israeli kumatha kutsekedwa (monga momwe zimakhalira nthawi zambiri) polemba otsutsa otsutsa Semites. Kugwiritsiridwa ntchito molakwa koteroko kwa anti-semitism kwalembedwa bwino ndi Norman Finkelstein, mโbuku lake Pafupi ndi Chutzpah ndi Makampani a Holocaust, mabuku onse aลตiri amene ali abwino kwambiri ndipo ayenera kuลตerengedwa ndi aliyense amene ali ndi chidwi ndi nkhani zimenezi. Ngati maphunziro satenga mbali yofunika kwambiri, nโzosatheka kuyembekezera kuti anthu amvetse chifukwa chake zinthu zofunika kwambiri monga kuchotsa ndalama ndi zina zotero zili zomveka ndiponso zofunika.
Ntchito ya gulu la ogwira ntchito ndikuthandizira zoyesayesa izi, mogwirizana ndi anthu omwe akukumana ndi mavuto aakulu, kuphatikizapo kupha anthu ambiri, m'manja mwa ufumu wa US. Tsoka ilo, chidziลตitso changa chochepa ndi gulu la anthu ogwira ntchito ku United States sichinandilimbikitse. Ngakhale kuli kofunika kuyang'ana kwambiri maganizo a "antchito abwino, abwana oipa", kukakamira kuona dziko lonse lapansi kupyolera mu prism iyi ndikokhazikika ndipo nthawi zambiri kumakhala kosagwirizana. Ndizomveka chifukwa chake socialists ndi anarchists angazengereze kuvomereza mayendedwe adziko, monga nkhondo yapalestine. Komabe, pankhaniyi, pomwe anthu adalandidwa m'manja mwa gulu lachiyuda lachiyuda, gulu la Zionist, kukana kuyimira mgwirizano ndi nkhondo yapalestine pofuna kutsatira chiphunzitso chamanzere ndikusokeretsa moyipa, komanso mwayi kwa maufulu a Ayuda, omwe apeza kale ulamuliro, pa Aluya, omwe ali pansi pa ntchito ndi ulamuliro wonse wa gulu lachiyuda. Monga Howard Zinn adanena, "simungakhale osalowerera pa sitima yoyenda." Ngati tikana kuima ndi a Palestine polimbana ndi boma ku West Bank ku Gaza, kodi tinganene kuti ulamuliro wawo wankhondo ndi Israeli upitirire mpaka mayiko onse athetsedwe? Zotsatira za malingaliro odziyimira pawokha, ufulu, ufulu wa anthu, ndi demokalase ndi zazikulu. Monga munthu wotsutsa boma, sindine wothandizira boma. Komabe, monga wokhulupirira demokalase ndi kudziyimira pawokha, komanso kumasuka ku ulamuliro, kulandidwa, ndi kupha anthu ambiri m'manja mwa ufumu wa America sindikupeza njira ina koma kuvomereza gulu la dziko la Palestine.
MC: Kodi dziko la US liyenera kupindula chiyani pothandizira nkhanza za Israeli, kusiyapo mkwiyo wa mayiko ambiri a Aarabu, komanso mayiko ambiri?
SM: Ili ndi funso lochititsa chidwi, ndipo limafika pamtima momwe ufumu wa America umagwirira ntchito, padziko lonse lapansi. Kuti tifotokoze, ndikuganiza kuti zingakhale zothandiza kuyang'ana chitsanzo china. Kodi US ingapindule chiyani chifukwa chowopseza anthu osauka kwambiri aku Nicaragua omwe akumenyera ufulu wachibadwidwe, choyamba polimbikitsa utsogoleri wankhanza wa Somoza, ndiye, atakwanitsa kumugonjetsa, kung'amba dzikolo kwazaka khumi ndi ndalama. , kuphunzitsa, ngakhalenso kulamula mwachindunji zigawenga za Contra? Ndi iko komwe, Nicaragua ndi dziko laling'ono, losauka. Ndipo sichikutha ku Nicaragua. Kwa zaka pafupifupi khumi, dziko la United States linachita kampeni yoopsa kwambiri yogwiririra, kupha, ndi kuwononga, yomwe inawononga mayiko atatu, mwina osakonzedwanso. Chifukwa chiyani? Nโchifukwa chiyani mโzaka zimenezi munali kazembe wamkulu kwambiri padziko lonse ku Honduras? Zachidziwikire, osati chifukwa Honduras inali dziko lofunikira kwambiri pazifukwa zilizonse zomveka. Chifukwa chiyani US yagwira ntchito molimbika kwazaka zambiri kuti iwononge chuma pachilumba chaching'ono cha Cuba?
Mayankho a mafunsowa angapezeke m'zikalata zokonzekera zamkati za US, ndipo mfundo zomwe amalankhula zimakhala zokhazikika muulamuliro uliwonse wa ufumu. Monga okonza mapulani aku US akufotokozera, Castro ndi munthu wowopsa osati chifukwa adayika chiwopsezo chilichonse ku United States, koma chifukwa Revolution ya Cuba idayimira chitsanzo "kukana bwino" kwa mfundo za US. Mwachidule, anthu a ku Cuba adachita tchimo lalikulu: adagonjetsa wolamulira wankhanza wa ku United States, Batista, ndipo adalowa m'malo mwake ndi wina amene adasankha, Fidel Castro, yemwe anakana kutsatira malamulo a US. Chifukwa cha zimenezi, anayenera kuphedwa ndi njala, kuopsezedwa, kuukiridwa, kuopsezedwa, ndi zina zotero mpaka atavomereza udindo wawo wosankhidwa ndi Washington monga anthu apansi ndi kuchita zofuna zathu moyenerera. Chowopseza ndi chakuti ngati kusamveraku kuloledwa kuchita bwino, kungathe kulimbikitsa anthu omwe amakopeka nawo kwina kuti atsatire zomwezo, ndikukana kugonjera ambuye awo atsamunda, omwe mwachiwonekere ali ndi cholinga chotukula magulu ankhanza padziko lapansi.
Ku Nicaragua, vuto linalinso chimodzimodzi. Monga lipoti la Oxfam lolembedwa ndi Diana Melrose lidanenera, lidayimira "chiwopsezo cha chitsanzo chabwino" kwa osankhika aku US. Mwachidule, anthu osauka ambiri ku Nicaragua adakwanitsa kukonzekera, ndikumenyana bwino ndi ulamuliro wankhanza wa Somoza kuti akhale ndi ufulu monga zaumoyo, maphunziro, ndi kugawa chuma mwachilungamo pansi pa boma la Sandinista. A US ndiye adadzipereka kuwononga kusinthaku, pamtengo wokulirapo wa anthu, pogwiritsa ntchito uchigawenga wakhungu. Monga ku Cuban Revolution, ngati Revolution ya Nicaragua idapambana, ikadaphunzitsa ena padziko lonse lapansi kuti sayenera kutsatira malamulo aku America, sayenera kusiya moyo womvetsa chisoni m'matangadza awo a neocolonial. Ndizotheka kuwuka, ndipo ndizotheka kuchita bwino pakupanga moyo wabwino, kapena kusankha tsogolo lanu. Mfundo imeneyi ndi yokhazikika kwambiri mu ufumu wa America, monga momwe zinalili ku Britain ndi ena.
Ndawonapo chiwopsezo ichi pantchito pamaulendo anga, ndipo nditha kutsimikizira kuti okonza mapulani ku Washington ali ndi nkhawa. Ngwazi pankhondo yolimbana ndi imperialism padziko lonse lapansi amakhala zitsanzo, komanso zitsanzo pomenyera ufulu ndi kudziyimira pawokha. Mwachitsanzo, ku Egypt, pali bwalo lotchedwa Simon Bolivar, lodzaza ndi fano lake. Bolivar, mtsogoleri waku Latin America yemwe adatsogolera kontinentiyo ku ufulu wawo wodzilamulira kuchokera ku atsamunda aku Spain, walimbikitsa anthu theka la dziko komanso mibadwo ingapo kutali. M'misasa ya anthu othawa kwawo ya Sabra ndi Chatilla kunja kwa Beirut, pali zikwangwani zazikulu za Purezidenti waku Venezuela Hugo Chavez. Othawa kwawo aku Palestine oponderezedwa ndi olandidwa, monga anthu osauka kwambiri kwina kulikonse padziko lapansi lachitatu, amalimbikitsidwa ndi munthu uyu, yemwe m'malingaliro awo adayimilira pamadongosolo azachuma a Washington padziko lonse lapansi ndikulola anthu osauka, ngati iwowo, kuti adziwe zawo. tsogolo ndi ulemu, ngakhale izi zikutanthauza kutsutsana ndi zomwe US โโโโikufuna. Kupulumuka kwa ziwerengerozi, zomwe zimakwiyitsa kwambiri Washington, zikuwonetsa kuti US yamphamvu ndiyosagonjetseka, kuti pali njira zomwe ulamuliro wake wapadziko lonse ungatsutsidwe ngakhale kugonja. Ichi ndiye chiwopsezo chenicheni.
Ku Middle East, dera lalikulu lopanga mphamvu padziko lonse lapansi, kuteteza kuwonekera kwa mtundu wotere ndi cholinga chofunikira kwambiri. Ichi ndichifukwa chake US idathandizira kale maboma ochitapo kanthu, olamulira mderali, omwe adathandizira kuti athetse mphamvu zomwe zikupita patsogolo, kapena zodziyimira pawokha, monga pan-Arabism ya Nasser, kapena Qasim's. Iraq. Ngati a Palestine atapambana pankhondo yawo yadziko lolimbana ndi Israeli, uthengawo udamveka momveka bwino, ndikutumiza zododometsa kumakona onse aderali komanso padziko lonse lapansi: Israeli sangagonjetsedwe, monga aku America angafune kuti mukhulupirire. Ufumu wamphamvu ukhoza kugonjetsedwa, ukhoza kugwa; ngati mumenya nkhondo motalika komanso molimbika mokwanira, mutha kupambana. Zotsatira za izi zingakhale zazikulu, monga momwe mungaganizire.
Pamlingo wina, ntchito ndi ndondomeko zina zaukali nthawi zambiri zimathandiza Israeli kusunga kapena kulamulira zinthu zofunika kwambiri, monga madzi, omwe ndi osowa m'derali, ndipo amatha mofulumira. Mwachitsanzo, nkhondo ya 1967 inawona Israeli akugonjetsa madzi olemera (ndi ofunika kwambiri) a Golan Heights ochokera ku Syria, komanso kulanda malo achonde a West Bank, omwe madzi ake Israeli tsopano akulamulira.
MC: Mafotokozedwe anu ndi osiyana kwambiri ndi momwe akuluakulu aku US amanenera; kutanthauza kuti mgwirizano wapadera pakati pa mayiko awiriwa ndi zotsatira za mgwirizano wawo ku demokalase. Kodi pali chowonadi pa izi? Komanso, kodi mungafotokoze lingaliro la "malo olandirira alendo ku Israeli," monga ena amatchulira, ndipo ndi gawo lanji, ngati liripo, limagwira ntchito popanga mfundo za US kapena mkangano mdziko muno?
SM: Mwachilengedwe, zolankhula zotuluka m'malo olamulira ndi ubale wapagulu, kulengeza zolinga "zathu" zabwino komanso kudzipereka kosasunthika kumalingaliro apamwamba kwambiri monga chifukwa chachikulu chakutsata mfundo zathu padziko lonse lapansi. Ngakhale kuyang'ana mwachipongwe pa zowona ndi lingaliro la kamphindi kungawulule nthawi yomweyo kuti izi ndi zopanda pake zomwe zilidi. Ngati kudzipereka ku demokalase ndiye cholinga chachikulu chomwe chikuyendetsa ubale waku US, chifukwa chiyani wothandizana nawo wa US wofunikira kwambiri padziko lonse lapansi Saudi Arabia? Kodi nchifukwa ninji dziko la United States likuchirikiza ulamuliro wankhanza wa ku Aigupto, kuchirikiza kotheratu zoyesayesa zake zoletsa demokalase mโdzikolo? Ngati tikufuna kufotokoza zomwe zimapangitsa kuti ndondomeko ya US ku mayiko awiri ikhale yosiyana, ndiye kuti tiyenera kuyesetsa kuzindikira chomwe chiri chosiyana pakati pa mayiko amenewo poyamba. Kotero, mwachitsanzo, kubwerera ku chitsanzo chomwe tangogwiritsa ntchito, pali kusiyana kotani pakati pa Venezuela ndi Colombia? Onse ali ndi gawo lina la demokalase (Venezuela mochuluka kwambiri). Koma Uribe, Purezidenti wa Colombia, amatsatira malamulo aku US mokhulupirika, pomwe Chavez amakana madera aku US. Zotsatira zake, boma la Colombia ndilomwe limalandira chithandizo chambiri cha US ku hemisphere, kufananiza kusiyanitsa kwake ngati wophwanya ufulu wachibadwidwe, pomwe dziko la Venezuela likunyozedwa komanso kuzunzidwa.
Kuti titenge chitsanzo china pafupi ndi nkhani yomwe ili pafupi, yang'anani Iran ndi Saudi Arabia. Onsewa ndi maulamuliro opondereza, opondereza, ngakhale Iran ndi ya demokalase kwambiri kuposa Saudi Arabia (yomwe siyikunena zambiri, kutsimikiza). Chifukwa chiyani Iran imayikidwa pansi pazilango zodzipatula, zopunduka pomwe Saudis amapatsidwa mabiliyoni a madola mu mgwirizano wa zida ndi zina zotero? Kusiya kufunikira kwenikweni kwa mlanduwu, wina akhoza kutsutsana, monga Washington, kuti Iran imathandizira otchedwa "magulu achigawenga" monga Hezbollah. Koma izi sizingafotokoze kusiyana ndi Saudi Arabia, yomwe yakhala ikuyendetsa magulu a Sunni padziko lonse lapansi kwa zaka makumi ambiri ndi chilolezo ndi chilolezo cha US, kuphatikizapo kukhazikitsa madrassas ku Pakistan komwe kunayambitsa a Taliban, mowolowa manja kupereka ndalama zothandizira mujahadeen. Afghanistan yomwe idabala gawo la zomwe tsopano zimatchedwa "Al-Qaeda," ndi kupitilira apo. Kusiyana kwake ndikuti Saudi Arabia yakhala yodalirika ku US kuyambira pomwe idakhazikitsidwa ku 1932, pomwe a Irani adagonjetsa wolamulira wankhanza waku US ku 1979, tchimo lomwe, monga aku Cuba ndi Nicaragua, ayenera kulangidwa.
Mkangano wa Israel Lobby ndi wovuta, ndipo womwe nthawi zambiri umangokhala ngati wotsutsana ndi Ayuda. Choyamba, tiyenera kumvetsetsa kuti zomwe zimatchedwa "Israel Lobby" sikuti ndi zachiyuda kapenanso kuti ndi zachiyuda, koma zimapangidwa ndi ma Evangelical achikhristu ambiri omwe amatuluka thovu pakamwa ndi enanso. Vuto ndi mkangano wa Walt ndi Mearsheimer, monga ndikumvetsetsa, ndikuti amatsitsa kwambiri kukula ndi mphamvu ya malo olandirira alendo. Ngakhale kuti "magulu olandirira alendo" omwe Walt ndi Mearsheimer amawaganizira atha kuchita zinthu ngati Congress kuti ipereke chigamulo chosamukira ku ofesi ya kazembe wa US ku Yerusalemu, ndi ubale wanthawi zonse ndi Israeli womwe umatsogolera mfundo za US, osati gulu laling'ono loyipa lankhondo. anthu ku Washington. Ngati mgwirizano wa anthu osankhikawo sunali wowona kuti ubale wa US ndi Israeli ndiwofunikira kwambiri, pofuna kuwopseza derali kuti litsatire malamulo a US, ndiye kuti Lobby ikhala itatha masiku angapo.
M'nkhaniyi (sindinawerenge bukuli) tanthauzo lawo la malo olandirira alendo ndi pafupifupi magulu a anthu, omwe amafuna kupotoza malingaliro a anthu pankhaniyi kuti athandizire Israeli. Kuti mufufuze mwanzeru, chotsatira pambuyo pofotokozera gulu lomwe liyenera kuunika ndikupeza chifukwa chomwe magulu otere amachita mwanjira yotere. Yankho, monga momwe Chomsky ndi Herman, mwachitsanzo, asonyezera, ndikuti amachita motere (pothandizira Israeli) chifukwa zolakwa zomwe Israeli amachita ndizofuna anthu apamwamba a US. Kupatula apo, mamembala a AIPAC samalemba zolembedwa mu New York Times, omwe amakana kutsutsa Israeli chifukwa cha zochita zake, kapena zolemba zomwe zimakana kuzitchula. Ntchitozi zimachitidwa ndi mamembala a aluntha aluntha, omwe adayenera kuphatikizidwa mu tanthauzo la Walt ndi Mearsheimer la "Lobby." Zolakwika zina zimawululidwa tikawona kuti si Israeli yekha amene amalandira ufulu woterewu kuchokera ku chitsutso kuchokera kwa aluntha, koma onse ogwirizana ndi US, kapena mayiko omwe akuchita zofuna za US. Ngati zolakwazi sizigwiranso ntchito izi, zidzatsutsidwa, kuchokera kumagulu awa ndi ena apamwamba. Chifukwa chake zomwe Walt ndi Mearsheimer akuwona sizochita zachinyengo za magulu ang'onoang'ono, koma kugwira ntchito kwanthawi zonse kwa aluntha osatsutsika aku US, omwe, monga magulu onse oterowo, amakwaniritsa cholinga cha "kugulitsa" mfundo za boma, zomwe zimapangidwira zofuna za anthu. kwa anthu osankhika, kwa anthu.
Mwachitsanzo, mu 2005 bungwe la Bush Administration lidapereka zilango zokhwima zankhondo ndi zachuma ku Israeli, pofuna kukakamiza kutsata nkhani zosiyanasiyana, ponamizira kuti apereka chilango kwa Israeli chifukwa chogwirizana ndi zida zankhondo ndi achi China. Israel idachitapo izi m'mbuyomu, ndipo nthawi zambiri amangoyimitsa pomwe Washington idawonetsa zovuta. Komabe, pankhaniyi, zilangozo zinatenga miyezi yambiri, kuphatikizapo kuchotsa Israeli pamndandanda wa ogwirizana nawo pakukula kwa F-35 Joint Strike Fighter yatsopano, kuyimitsidwa kwa thandizo lankhondo ndi mgwirizano, ndi zina zotero. Mwanjira yochititsa manyazi kwambiri, Israeli idakakamizika kupereka ndalama zambiri kukampani yaku China chifukwa chophwanya mgwirizano, kulemberanso njira zake zonse zogulitsa zida, kukonzanso antchito, ndikukhazikitsa zosintha zambiri pamalamulo ake. madera omwe adalandidwa kuphatikizapo dongosolo la "kuchotsa" ku Gaza. Sharon anali wodzikuza kwambiri, ndipo US inagwiritsa ntchito kukakamizidwa kofunikira, komwe kunamupangitsa kuti agwade, akutsatira zofuna zonse. Chofunika kwambiri pazifuno zathu, komabe, chinali chakuti nthawi yonseyi "malo olandirira alendo" anali chete - sanalankhule ngakhale liwu limodzi lodandaula. Titha kuwona kuti Lobby ndiyololedwa kukhalapo chifukwa imathandizira zofuna za anthu osankhika aku US mokulira, osati mwanjira ina. Ngati zotsutsana za Walt ndi Mearsheimer zinali zoona, tiyenera kuyembekezera kuti US idzakakamizika kumvera zofuna za Israeli, kukhala akapolo komanso kukakamizidwa ndi machitidwe a "Lobby" yankhanza, yomwe imasokoneza ndondomeko zathu zabwino komanso zabwino.
ZNetwork imalandira ndalama kudzera mu kuwolowa manja kwa owerenga ake.
Ndalama