Howard Friel ndi wolemba ndi Richard Falk wa Zolemba Papepala: Momwe New York Times Imanenera Zolakwika Zakunja kwa US (Verso, 2004), komanso ndi Falk of Israel-Palestine Yolembedwa: Momwe The New York Times Imanenera Molakwika Mikangano ku Middle East (Chiwerengero, 2007).
Tiyerekeze kuti ndinu pulezidenti wa koleji yaingโono ku United States, kapena tcheyamani wa bungwe la matrasti pasukulu imodzimodziyo, ndipo pulofesa wotchuka wa payunivesite yotchuka kwambiri ku United States akuukira gulu la ophunzira anu mopanda chilungamo. milandu yotsutsana ndi Israeli komanso kunyanyira ndale. Kodi choyamba mumaimirira ndi ophunzira anuโngati milanduyo ili yopanda maziko ndi yotupaโkapena mumatumiza kalata yotseguka ku nyuzipepala ya ku Israel, yopita kwa pulofesa wa payunivesiteyo, ndi kuchonderera chifundo, podziลตa kuti pulofesa mmodzi ameneyu? kodi mungapite kutali kuwononga mbiri ya koleji yanu ndi zonena zotsutsana ndi Ayuda ndi zotsutsana ndi Israeli?
Koleji yomwe ikufunsidwa ndi Hampshire College ku Amherst, Massachusetts, purezidenti wa koleji ndi Ralph Hexter, wapampando wa board of trustees ndi Sigmund Roos, pulofesa wodziwika wakunja kwa tawuni ndi Alan Dershowitz wa Harvard Law School, ndipo ophunzirawo ndi a Hampshire. Nthambi ya College of Students for Justice ku Palestine (SJP). Kaya ophunzirawo adalengeza molakwika kuti kolejiyo idasiya ndalama zogulira zomwe zimapindulitsa Israeli kukhala m'malo a Palestine sizinayankhidwe pano, ngakhale ndi gawo lalikulu la mikangano yomwe yachitika pa kampu ya Hampshire komanso Jerusalem Post. M'malo mwake, chodetsa nkhawa apa ndikuti Hexter ndi Roos adanyalanyaza kuteteza zomwe zidapangitsa ophunzira a Hamphire kutsutsa zomwe a McCarthy adanenera Alan Dershowitz, ndipo m'malo mwake adayesetsa kuti adzipatule kuzinthu zovomerezeka zandale komanso zothandiza anthu. a ophunzira.
Mu gawo lake la "Double Standard Watch" mu gawo la Jerusalem Post pa February 15, 2009, Dershowitz adatchula ophunzira a SJP ku Hampshire kuti "gulu lodana ndi Israeli," "gulu lodana ndi Israeli lotchedwa Students for Justice in Palestine," "gulu lodana ndi Israeli," "anti-Israel". -Ophunzira a Israeli," ndi "gulu la ophunzira lodana ndi Israeli." Pakadali pano, Dershowitz adapempha "tsankho" kasanu ndi kamodzi ngati cholinga chachikulu cha "ophunzira odana ndi Israeli," pomwe akufuna kuti kolejiyo iwalange ophunzira a SJP chifukwa cha "tsankho" lawo. Izi ndi zomwe Dershowitz analemba pankhaniyi: "Payenera kukhala mtengo wolipidwa chifukwa cha tsankho"; "kusankha Israeli yekha kuti atengere ndalama ndi tsankho komanso zosavuta"; "chigamulo chachikuluchi" (pofotokoza za njira yochotsera ophunzira ku Hampshire); "Ophunzira ndi aphunzitsi [ku Hampshire] nawonso ayenera kumvetsetsa kuti tsankho lili ndi mtengo wake"; "ulemu sungakhalepo ndi tsankho lachiyuda lokhalo lotsutsana ndi boma lachiyuda"; ndi:
Hampshire ndi koleji yaying'ono yopanda mphamvu zambiri. Koma iwo omwe akupanga kampeni ya dziko [divestment] amawona "kupambana" kwawo ku Hampshire ngati njira yotsegulira kuti mayunivesite ena otchuka atsatire zomwezo potengera malingaliro omwewo. Iyi ndi khansa yomwe ikuwopseza kufalikira padziko lonse lapansi, ndipo iyenera kuyimitsidwa pomwe idayambira ku Hampshire.
"khansa" apa ndi kampeni yopanda chiwawa ya SJP yosiyana ndi mabizinesi omwe amathandizira Israeli kukhala m'malo a Palestina kwa zaka khumi mophwanya malamulo apadziko lonse lapansi.
M'malo moteteza ophunzira a Hamphire College ku mlandu wotsutsana ndi Israeli komwe adawachitira, Hexter ndi Roos a Hampshire adayamba kalata yawo kwa Jerusalem Post motere: "Wokondedwa Alan: Timayamba ndi kutsimikizira kulemekeza kwathu kwakukulu kwa inu, monga katswiri wa zamalamulo komanso mawu amphamvu otsutsa anti-Semitism." Ndipo poyankha zomwe Dershowitz adalimbikitsa ophunzirawo - kunena kuti "payenera kukhala mtengo wolipiridwa chifukwa cha tsankho" - Hexter ndi Roos adafuna kutsimikizira Dershowitz kuti olamulira a Hampshire atenga "chilango" kwa ophunzirawo:
Koma tikumvekanso momveka bwino, ndipo tikukulimbikitsani kuti mutimvetse bwino, tikamanena kuti ophunzira salankhula za koleji ndipo mwina sanganene molakwika za sukuluyo. Idzakhala, ndipo iyenera kukhala, ntchito ya koleji kuchitapo kanthu kalikonse koyenera, motsatira malamulo ndi ndondomeko zomwe zakhazikitsidwa. Chilango ndi ndondomeko ya mkati yomwe siigawidwa ndi anthu.
Ngati "chilango ndi njira yamkati yomwe sikugawidwa ndi anthu," monga Hexter ndi Roos adalemba, bwanji angalumbirire ophunzira a SJP m'kalata yopita kwa Alan Dershowitz, kuti akhazikitse Dershowitz, koma mwachiwonekere sichoncho. ndi administrator ku Hampshire College? Ndipo atangowonetsa mowopsa kuti ophunzira a Hamphire aponyedwa pansi pa basi, Hexter ndi Roos adamaliza ndi pempho lomaliza kuti aphedwe kuchokera kwa wopondereza Dershowitz:
Malingaliro anu abwino ndi ofunika kwa ife; zikufunika, inde, chifukwa ndinu munthu wodziwika bwino pagulu, koma ndizofunikira kwambiri chifukwa timakuwerengerani ngati m'modzi wabanja la Hamphire, ndipo tikukhulupirira kuti mudzadziganiziranso motero.[1]
Chifukwa chake ophunzira apeza zomwe zikubwera kwa iwo - poyankhanso kuwopseza kwa Dershowitz kulimbikitsa kunyalanyaza zachuma ku Hampshire, chifukwa cha "anti-Israel tsankho" pasukulupo - pomwe Purezidenti wa Hampshire ndi board of trustees akupempha ndikuchonderera a Dershowitz kuti akhalebe mkati mwa sukuluyi. Hampshire "banja." M'malo mwake, povomereza zomwe akufuna komanso zomwe adamuwopseza, a Hexter ndi Roos adatsimikizira zonena za Dershowitz kuti ophunzira a Hampshire adachita "zotsutsana ndi Israeli" pasukulupo.
Mwachiwonekere, komabe, Hexter ndi Roos anali ndi njira ina: Kuyika milandu ya Dershowitz ya "nkhani yotsutsana ndi Israeli" ku Hampshire potengera zomwe a Dershowitz akutsutsa ovomerezeka a Israeli. Ngakhale zikuwonekeratu, mbiri yomwe ili pansipa ya zomwe Dershowitz adayipitsa mbiri ya anthu ena ambiri monga adani a Israeli, odana ndi Ayuda a Israeli apereka nkhani yofunikira pazimenezi, komanso maziko amilandu yomwe ophunzira a Hamphire amaimba, zomwe, mwatsoka. , zikuoneka kuti zatsimikiziridwa ndi kuthandizidwa ndi pulezidenti ndi matrasti a koleji.
Buku laposachedwa kwambiri la Dershowitz, Mlandu Wokhudza Adani a Isiraeli (2008), m'malo mwake ndi mndandanda wa adani a Nixon-kwenikweni mndandanda wa adani-wa otsutsa mfundo za Israeli. Polemba mndandanda wa adani oyambirira a Nixon, mlangizi wa White House a Charles Colson adalongosola Bernard Feld, katswiri wa sayansi ya MIT komanso wothandizira kuchepetsa zida za nyukiliya, monga wolandira "ndalama zolemera kumanzere," mtolankhani Daniel Schorr monga "mdani weniweni wa TV," adatero. Mary McGrory monga mlembi wa "Daly Hate Nixon articles," ndi Paul Newman monga wothandizira "radic-lib causes."[2] Mndandanda wa adani omwe adalembedwa ndi Dershowitz m'buku lake la 2008, lomwe lili ndi purezidenti wakale wa US, akatswiri odziwika bwino, komanso mabungwe omenyera ufulu wachibadwidwe, akufotokozedwa mwankhanza kwambiri.
Ponena za Purezidenti wakale Jimmy Carter, Dershowitz analemba kuti: "Mosasamala kanthu za chifukwa kapena zifukwa zomwe Jimmy Carter adatsikira posachedwa mumtsinje wa tsankho, mbiri sidzamuweruza mokoma mtima."[3] Poyankhulana pa Shalom TV ku Israel, Dershowitz adati: "Jimmy Carter wakhaladi munthu wotsutsa Israeli, kotero kuti pali mtundu wa malo apadera mu gehena wosungidwa kwa munthu woteroyo."[4] Kodi izi ndi zomwe Hexter ndi Roos amafuna kuthandizira, kuwonjezera pa Dershowitz kutcha ophunzira a Hampshire ngati otsutsana ndi Israeli, pomwe adalembera Dershowitz ku Jerusalem Post kuti "malingaliro anu abwino ndi ofunika kwa ife"?
About John J. Mearsheimer, R. Wendell Harrison Distinguished Service Pulofesa wa Political Science pa yunivesite ya Chicago, ndi Stephen M. Walt, Robert ndi Renee Belfer Pulofesa wa International Affairs pa John F. Kennedy School of Government ku Harvard University , amene pamodzi analemba Israel Lobby Ndi US Foreign Policy (2007), Dershowitz analemba kuti "ndioyambitsa chidani omwe asiya kutsutsana kwamaphunziro ndi ndondomeko ya demokalase kuti akhale ngwazi za rock-star za otsutsa-Israel."[5] Kodi izi zikuphatikizidwa mu zomwe Hexter ndi Roos amasilira za Dershowitz?
Chifukwa Amnesty International ndi Human Rights Watch - onse omwe ali pamndandanda wa adani a Dershowitz - adatulutsa malipoti omwe amatsutsa zomwe Israeli adachita ku Gaza Strip ndi Lebanon m'chilimwe cha 2006, Dershowitz adawatcha "omwe amatchedwa "magulu omenyera ufulu wa anthu," ndipo adalongosola malipoti awo kukhala "kukondera-koyera ndi kosavuta."[6] Dershowitz adatchulanso "malingaliro a Amnesty International kuti aziimba mlandu chilichonse pa Israeli," adanenanso kuti "Amnesty International sikuwoneka kuti ingathe kudzithandiza poimba mlandu Israeli chifukwa cha kuipa kwa dziko," ndipo adalongosola Amnesty kuti "gulu lomwe kale linali lodziwika bwino. zomwe zawononga kudalirika kwake mwa kugwiritsa ntchito mobwerezabwereza miyezo iwiri ya Israeli."[7]
Dershowitz adalembanso kuti "Human Rights Watch (HRW) idakondera kwambiri popereka lipoti lazowona pansi" pankhondo ya Israel-Lebanon mchaka cha 2006.
ZNetwork imalandira ndalama kudzera mu kuwolowa manja kwa owerenga ake.
Ndalama