Gulu losadetsa nkhawa, Ayuda akhalidwe labwino awa. Mukangoganiza kuti muli ndi zokopa zawo, pamabwera kusintha kwamphamvu kwa US ndipo amatembenuza masewerawo mozondoka.
Kodi mukukumbukira nthawi yomwe inali yoyipa kuyerekezera gulu lankhondo la Israeli ndi Anazi? Rabbi Shmuley Boteach (yemwe wadzudzula anthu ambiri odana ndi Ayuda kuposa momwe ndingalembetsedwe bwino mderali) adati adadabwa kwambiri ndi kutsutsana kwa Roger Waters. kuchita ku Palestine wolandidwa monga chofanana ndi "kusewera [kusewera] boma la Vichy mu France yomwe idalandidwa."
Chifukwa cha โkufanizira Ayuda ndi ogwirizana ndi Nazi,โ analemba Boteach wokwiya, Waters anali "wonunkha" yemwe anali woyenera - ndipo adalandira - nkhani yogwedeza chala kuchokera kwa rabi: "[Y]ulibe ulemu, ulibe mtima, ulibe moyo."
Chabwino, izo zinali pamenepo. Lero ndi David Friedman, Donald Trump yemwe anasankha kazembe wa US ku Israel, yemwe amatsutsa poyera Ayuda omasuka a Zionist a J Street kukhala ngakhale zoipa "kuposa kapos - Ayuda omwe adalowa m'misasa yakupha ya Nazi." Koma masiku ano, "kufanizira Ayuda ndi ogwira nawo ntchito a Nazi" si tchimo losakhululukidwa lomwe lidali - osachepera, osati molingana ndi Rabbi Boteach, amene amaumirira kuti ngakhale kuti โchinenero chake chinali chosayenera,โ Friedman ndi โmunthu wabwino,โ amene kuipitsidwa kwake โkunali kogwirizana ndi maganizo a Ayuda ndi Aisrayeli ambiri.โ
Mwina mukuganiza kuti cheesy Boteach ndi chosavuta chandamale? Koma si iye yekha amene akusewera masewerawo. Nathan Diament, mkulu wa bungwe la Orthodox la malamulo a boma, sanayamikirepo chilichonse koma Friedman, kuwuza JTA kuti kazembe woti adzakhale akuyimira molondola malingaliro a Ayuda amenewo (ambiri mdera la Orthodox, malinga ndi Diament) omwe adavotera Trump. Wofalitsa nkhani wochirikiza kumanja Ira Stoll anapita kutali kwambiri mu tchalitchi cha Orthodox Algemeiner, kukwiya kuti New York Times anavumbula โkukonderaโ kwa โAyuda ochirikiza Israyeliโ mwa kungonena za miseche ya Friedman โyoipa kuposa kaposโ. (Stoll adaperekanso pulagi ku ulamuliro wankhanza wa Azerbaijan - pazinthu zonse - mwina chifukwa, monga Times malipoti, boma lake โlikugula zida zotsogola ku Israel kuti ligule mafuta.โ)
Tsopano, simukuyenera kukhala katswiri kuti mutenge chitsanzo chakumbuyo konseku. Monga momwe a Donald Trump akukondera odana ndi Asilamu adaphimba kulephera kwake pamakhalidwe a rabi wachipembedzo cha Islamophobic Orthodox, kulimbikitsa kwakukulu kwa David Friedman pankhani yolanda Israeli mosaloledwa kwakakamiza akatswiri achiyuda kuti aganizirenso za kuipidwa kwawo pakuyerekeza pakati pa Ayuda ndi chipani cha Nazi - monga malinga ngati mafananidwewo akujambulidwa mโdzina la dziko lachiyuda.
Kungoti wina akanaphonyabe mfundoyo, tchalitchi cha Orthodox Jewish Press kuphulika kuti Friedman adalongosola kale "ndondomeko" ya Mideast malinga ndi zomwe, m'mawu ake omwe, "[r] zigawenga zapalestine zowonongeka ziyenera kuchotsedwa ndi kuthetsedwa" kotero kuti "otsala - mwinamwake ambiri - a Palestine" angathe. "kupindula" kuchokera ku mayamwidwe a Israeli ku West Bank yonse. Tengani kamphindi kulingalira tanthauzo la mawuwa - "zigawenga" zomwe ziyenera "kuthetsedwa" zimapanga, "mwina," osachepera theka la anthu onse aku Palestine - ndipo mudzazindikira kuti yemwe akuyembekezeka kukhala kazembeyo atha kukhalapo. mbiri yolimbikitsa kupha anthu, osanena kanthu za kunyoza kwake malamulo apadziko lonse lapansi. Ndipo izi, madona ndi njonda, ndi chifukwa chake anthu okonda Mulungu ali pamwambowu Jewish Press musadandaule ngati Friedman nayenso akuphwanya lamulo lakale la "kufanizira Ayuda ndi ogwira nawo ntchito a Nazi."
Koma bwanji ponena za kudana ndi Ayuda kwachikalekale? Zoonadi, anthu achiyuda amatsutsabe kuti?
Ayi, osatinso - osati ngati ikuchokera ku Trump & Co. Miyezi yosakwana 10 yadutsa kuchokera pamene Bethany Mandel, wachiyuda wolankhula molimba mtima, adandaula kuti adakumana ndi "zowopsa komanso zotsutsana ndi Ayuda" kuchokera kwa otsatira a Trump atalemba ndemanga zingapo zotsutsa za munthu yemwe akufuna "kuti ndidagula mfuti koyambirira kwa mwezi uno." Mandel adanenanso kuti "Breitbart News, yomwe tsopano ndi nsanja yolimbikitsira a Trump," inali malo omwe ankakonda kwambiri pozunza achiyuda.
The Chamoyo Chamasiku Onse adagwirizana ndi Mandel, kufotokoza momwe Breitbart - ndi wapampando wake wamkulu, Steve Bannon - "adamasula anthu odana" ndi otsutsa ake panthawi ya kampeni yapurezidenti. The Chirombo adagwira mawu wachiyuda wa neo-Conservative John Podhoretz, yemwe adalongosola kukangana ndi "akuluakulu a Neo-Nazi White" atadzudzula Trump ndi Breitbart. "[T] apa pali kuphatikizika pano [ndi Breitbart ndi Trump]," adatero Podhoretz. "Sindikuganiza kuti ndinganene kuti kukhala wothandizira a Trump kukhala wotsimikizira kapena wofotokozera malingaliro awa ... koma china chake adachisiya."
Ndiye chinachitika ndi chiyani pamene Steve Bannon mwiniwake - wamkulu pakatikati pa zonsezi zotsutsana ndi Ayuda - adatchulidwa kuti ndi mmodzi mwa alangizi apamtima a Purezidenti wosankhidwa Trump?
Pakalipano, mukudziwa yankho: ngakhale anti-Semitism ndi kosher ngati ili ndi chizindikiro cha Trump.
Mwachidziwikire, Rabbi Boteach anali m'gulu la anthu oyamba kugula mtundu watsopano, kuyika zithunzi zake pambali pa alt-right Svengali ndikuwonjezera kuti, "Steve Bannon wasonyeza chithandizo chachikulu ku Israeli ndipo boma likulonjeza kuti lidzakhala lamphamvu ku dziko lachiyuda." Dziwani, uyu anali Boteach yemweyo anadzudzulidwa poyera bwenzi lakale, Senator Cory Booker, pamene womalizayo adathandizira mgwirizano wa nyukiliya wa Purezidenti Obama ndi Iran; mwachiwonekere Boteach amapita kukhululukiro-ndi-kuyiwala kokha pamene kukulitsa kwa Israeli kupindula.
Lori Lowenthal Marcus ' chitetezo cha Bannon mu Jewish Press chinali, ngati chilipo, chochititsa manyazi kwambiri, osati chifukwa chakuti adadzudzula omwe adazunzidwa ndi Ayuda chifukwa cha "mphamvu zawo zoipa" koma chifukwa chakuti adatsutsa umboni womveka bwino wa kusakonda kwa Bannon kwa Ayuda monga "zonena za mkazi wakale panthawi ya chisudzulo. โ Otsutsa chipani cha Nazi akhala akudziwika kuti akudandaula za milandu yotsutsa-Semitism, ndipo kusadalirika kwa "mkazi wotayidwa" ndi truism yomwe amakonda kwambiri ya misogynists; koma kupeza mtolankhani wachiyuda wachikazi akuvomereza malingaliro onse awiri, kungolimbikitsa wina yemwe ali ndi mbiri yoyipa ya Bannon, ndizosangalatsa kwambiri. O, inde - a Marcus adazindikira kuti "Bannon akukana mlanduwu." ndikuganiza kuti ayenera kuthetsa nkhaniyo.
Ngakhale wolemba nkhani womasuka J.J. Goldberg sanathe kudzibweretsa kutcha ma ethos ozungulira Trump ndi dzina lake lolondola - chiwopsezo cha tsankho ndi mantha ndale momwe chidani cha Ayuda chikusewera kale gawo lake losapeลตeka. Potcha mlandu wotsutsana ndi Bannon "pafupifupi mopanda pake," Goldberg adawutaya ndi malingaliro ake opusa: zomwe zimasonkhezera kumanja, adalemba kuti, "si tsankho koma mfundo zenizeni zotsutsana ndi chikhalidwe cha Ayuda. anthuโ pa zinthu monga โzochuluka, ufulu wa anthu ochepa, kupatukana kwa tchalitchi ndi mayiko.โ Izi zitha kukhala choncho, monga chikumbutso chothandizira cha Goldberg kuti "chisilamu / Israeli wakumanzere" nawonso "nthawi zina" amatsogozedwa ndi "kusagwirizana kwakukulu ... ndi mfundo ndi zochita za Israeli." Koma kodi izi zikufotokozera bwanji mkuntho wankhanza womwe, motsogozedwa ndi Bannon, otsutsa a Trump amatchedwa zinthu ngati "Myuda wocheperako" komanso "woyenera ng'anjo"? Pokhapokha ngati mawu achidani amtundu woterewa ali chodabwitsa kumanja-kumanja - ndipo sichoncho - palibe kufanizitsa ndi kudzudzula nkhanza za dziko, ngakhale kuchitiridwa nkhanza.
Kufanana kwa Goldberg sikuli kopanda chilungamo kwa otsutsa a Israeli; zimathwanima kuyipa kwenikweni kwa tsankho lamanja lomwe limayendetsedwa ndi Bannon. Breitbart News yokha yathandiza anafotokoza kusiyana kwake pakati pa anthu akhungu la alt-right ndi neo-Nazi: โAkhungu, mokulira, ndi achiwembu odziลตika bwino, opanda IQ osonkhezeredwa ndi chisangalalo chachiwawa ndi chidani cha mafuko. Ufulu wina ndi gulu lanzeru kwambiri la anthu. โ Mwamvetsa zimenezo? Khamu la Bannon ndi losiyana ndi akhungu chifukwa ali wochenjera kuposa akhungu.
Ndipo nayi Ben Shapiro akufotokoza chifukwa chake Mphamvu ya Bannon ku Breitbart News chinali chimodzi mwa zifukwa zomwe adachoka: โ[Malemu] Andrew Breitbart kunyozedwa kusankhana mitundu. Ananyozadiโฆ. Iye anaumirira kuti nkhani za mafuko zizichitidwa mosamala kwambiri kuti zipewe ngakhale chipwirikiti cha tsankho. [Koma] ndi Bannon kukumbatira Trump, zonse zidasintha. Tsopano Breitbart wakhala alt-right kupita ku webusaiti ...
Pambuyo pa umboni ngati umenewo, kodi omasuka achiyuda akuyembekezera chiyani asanatenge gulu la a Trump? Kufufuza kwatsopano kwa Un-American Activities?
Inemwini, sindikuganiza kuti vuto ndi kusowa kwa chidziwitso kapena kusowa kwa luntha. Sindikuwona nkomwe ngati kulephera kwa chifuniro cha ndale.
Ayi, ndikuwopa kuti vutoli limakhala losavuta komanso lozama. Kwa nthawi yayitali kwambiri, utsogoleri wachiyuda umadziona ngati wocheperako ngati wosunga miyambo yamakhalidwe abwino kuposa ngati woteteza fuko, zomwe zofuna zake - kaya ndi chikoka cha ndale ku US kapena mphamvu zankhondo ku Israeli - zimabwera patsogolo pa ena onse. kulingalira. Trump's thuggish ethnocentrism mwachilengedwe imakopa Rabbi Boteach, komanso rabbi yemwe adagulitsa likulu lake lamakhalidwe abwino ku ndale zamphamvu zachiyuda ndi Israeli kalekale. Pakadali pano, kumbali yaufulu, odziwika bwino achiyuda monga Goldberg akhala akusamala kuti asalole Israeli kuzinthu zofunikira zakupita patsogolo kwawo. Ngati sanatero, sakadakondwera mu ulemerero wonyezimira wa mphamvu yachiyuda.
Chifukwa chake, pamapeto pake, a Trumps, Bannons, Boteachs ndi Goldbergs adziko lapansi onse amakumana pamalo amodzi: malo omwe angapangire bwino, komwe Realpolitik chimakhudza tsankho, kumene chiwawa chachikulu ndi tsankho angadzitcha okha diplomacy, ndipo pamene kunena zoona pa zonsezi ndi chinthu chimodzi chimene sichingachitike.
Zoonadi, pali Ayuda - ndi ena - omwe amasula zomangirazo ndipo akutcha Trump ndi khamu lake zomwe akuyenera kutchedwa. Koma pokhapokha ngati Ayuda ambiri, makamaka utsogoleri wawo, apereka mawu awo onse kutsutsidwa ndikuyimirira ndi mtima wonse motsutsana ndi mtambo wakuda womwe ukutsikira ku Washington, zitha kugwetsa gulu lachiyuda la ku America m'malo osafunikira. Kumwamba kumatithandiza tonse ngati atsogoleri achipembedzo asankha njira imeneyo.
ZNetwork imalandira ndalama kudzera mu kuwolowa manja kwa owerenga ake.
Ndalama