Maso onse anali kuyang'ana pa tsamba lokwezeka la komiti ya Winograd. Woweruza adakhala pansi pamaso pa makamera ndikuwerenga lipotilo. Koma tsambalo silinatsike. Palibe msilikali wachitetezo adakweza mutu wamagazi, wodulidwa. Mutu unakhalabe mโmalo mwake. Ehud Olmert si marquis, ndipo mutu wake umakhalabe pa mapewa ake.
Kuchokera kumalekezero ena a dziko kupita ku ena, kuusa mtima kwakukulu kokhumudwitsidwa. Atolankhani ndi olemba ndemanga adatuluka pamipando yawo, ngati ma hags oluka a
Komiti ya Winograd yalephera, olemba ndemanga adafuula mokwiya. Pazolephera zambiri zankhondo, kulephera kwa komitiyo kuyenera kuwonjezeredwa.
ALIYENSE wodziwa za ndale amadziwa mfundo yakuti: Amene amasankha mamembala a bungwe amadziwiratu zomwe wasankha.
Izi zikungodzionetsera zokha. Ndi iko komwe, mamembala a bungweli ndi anthu. Anthu ali ndi malingaliro ndi malingaliro. Izi zimadziwikiratu kwa munthu amene wawasankha. Akhoza kusankha mamembala mwa kufuna kwake. Ngati asankha anthu olemera kwambiri, angayembekezere kuti sadzasankha kukweza misonkho kwa olemera. Ngati asankha otsalira m'malo mwake, malingaliro ake adzakhala osiyana kwambiri.
Choncho, atakambirana za Lamulo la Mabungwe Ofufuza, tidaganiza kuti mamembala a "official" Commission of Inquiry sayenera kusankhidwa ndi boma, koma Purezidenti wa Supreme Court. Ndinali membala wa Knesset panthawiyo ndipo ndinatenga nawo mbali pa zokambiranazo. Ndidapereka lingaliro loti Chief Justice asasankhe mamembala a bungweli, komanso kuti iye - osati boma - ligamule pakupanga kafukufuku poyambira. (Izi zidakanidwa.)
Zimenezo zinachitika zaka zisanu ndi ziลตiri Ehud Olmert wachichepereyo asanasankhidwe koyamba kukhala mu Knesset. Koma amamvetsetsa bwino lamulo. Pamene, pambuyo pa nkhondo yachiwiri ya ku Lebanon, kusankhidwa kwa komiti yofufuza "yovomerezeka", iye anatsutsa mwamphamvu. Iye anaumirira komiti yofufuza yomwe inasankhidwa ndi boma. Pamene mamembala a bungwe lovomerezeka amasankhidwa ndi Chief Justice, mamembala a bungwe la boma amasankhidwa ndi boma lomwe.
Vive la petite kusiyana.
Kusankhidwa kwa komiti ya Winograd kunalandiridwa ndi zokayikitsa zambiri. Koma izi zinasanduka nthunzi kotheratu pamene lipoti lachidule linatulutsidwa mu April watha. Zinali zankhanza komanso zosagwirizana. Inali ndi mawu oipa kwambiri onena za Olmert.
Choncho anthu anamasuka. Kusiyana kwa mitundu iwiri ya ntchitozo kunaiwalika. Komiti ya Winograd idachita ndendende ngati komiti "yovomerezeka", idatenga zisankho ngati imodzi ndikulankhula ngati imodzi. Inakweza nsonga yodumphadumpha, ndipo aliyense ankadikirira kuti igwere pakhosi la Olmert.
Ndiyeno zinaonekeratu kuti kusiyana le petite kunali kusiyana kwakukulu ndithu. Komiti yosankhidwa ndi Olmert tsopano yapereka lipoti lomaliza lomwe lingakhale labwino kwa Olmert panthawi yonseyi, makamaka ponena za mlandu woti Olmert adasankha "opaleshoni yapansi" yomaliza ndipo adatumiza asilikali kuti aphedwe kuti apulumutse kutchuka kwake.
Bungweli silinaimbe mlandu wandale kapena mkulu wa asilikali. Apa chikhoza kukhazikika pa chigamulo cha Khoti Lalikulu, lomwe lidaletsa poyera kuti bungweli litsutse aliyense payekha.
Zatheka bwanji? Pamene Knesset idavomereza Commission of Inquiry Law, tidatchera khutu ku Ndime 15. Imaletsa kudzudzula aliyense popanda kuwapatsa mpata wabwino wodziteteza. Munthu woteroyo ayenera kuchenjezedwa pasadakhale ndi kuitanidwa kuti asankhe loya, kufunsa mafunso mboni ndi kuitana mboni zawo.
Izi ndizovuta kwambiri, ndipo komiti yofufuza nthawi zambiri imakhala yofulumira kumaliza lipoti lake isanayiwalidwe. Mwachitsanzo, bungwe lofufuza lomwe linakhazikitsidwa pambuyo pa nkhondo ya Yom Kippur, motsogozedwa ndi Woweruza Agranat, linangonyalanyaza nkhaniyo kotheratu ndipo linaganiza zochotsa mkulu wa asilikali, Mtsogoleri wa Southern Front ndi akuluakulu ena akuluakulu, popanda kuwapatsa patsogolo. chenjezo konse.
Komiti ya Winograd inachitanso njila ina: pamene akuluakulu a asilikali anakadandaula ku Khoti Lalikulu ndi kukakamiza bungweli kuti lizilemekeza Gawo 15, bungweli linalonjeza kuti silidzaimba mlandu munthu aliyense payekha.
Nโzoona kuti bungweli likanafotokoza zimene Olmert anachita pankhondoyo mokwiya kwambiri moti zinamukakamiza kusiya ntchito yake. Sizinatero. Mโmalo mwake, linaganiza kuti zosankha zake zinali zomveka.
Tsamba silinagwe, Olmert anavulazidwa, koma adakali chiyimire.
PAMBUYO pa kuphana kwa Sabra ndi Shatila mchaka cha 1982, komiti yofufuza โyovomerezekaโ yotsogozedwa ndi Judge Kahan idatulutsa lipoti lachitsanzo lomwe lidaulula zonse. Koma zimenezi zikanachititsa kuti aganize zokhwima kwambiri kuposa mmene anafikira. M'malo mopeza kuti Ariel Sharon ndi otsatira ake anali ndi "udindo wosalunjika" wakupha, zikanaganiza kuti ali ndi udindo wachindunji. Mfundo zake zinali zotsimikizira zimenezi. Nanga nโcifukwa ciani sanacite zimenezo, nacotsa Sharoni ndi akapitawo ena? Ndikuganiza kuti adabwerera kumbuyo kuopa kuwononga kwambiri Boma la Israeli.
Tsopano nditha kulembanso chimodzimodzi za komiti ya Winograd. Mfundo zovumbulutsidwa ndi izo zimalungamitsa ziganizo zonyanyira. Kodi chinawalepheretsa n'chiyani? Mmodzi angakhoze kulingalira: mamembala asanu a komiti, mizati yonse ya kukhazikitsidwa - akuluakulu a 2, akatswiri a maphunziro apamwamba a 2, woweruza mmodzi - sanafune kugonjetsa Olmert, munthu woyamba wa 1. Mwina amawopa kuti malo ake atengedwa ndi wina woyipa kwambiri - nkhawa yomwe anthu ambiri m'dzikoli amakumana nayo.
Monga anthu odziwika bwino, mamembala a bungweli adasiyanso kufunsa mafunso awiri okhudzana ndi Nkhondo Yachiwiri ya Lebanon: (a) Chifukwa chiyani idayambika, ndi (b) Zomwe zidapangitsa kuti gulu lankhondo liwonongeke modabwitsa.
Mโmalipoti ake awiri, bungweli lidati ganizo loyambitsa nkhondoyi lidachitika mwachangu komanso mopanda udindo. Zolinga zankhondo zomwe zidanenedwazo zinali zosatheka. Koma bungweli silinanene zomwe zidapangitsa Olmert & Co. - boma la
Tsopano tikudziwa motsimikiza kuti mapulani ankhondo anali atakonzedwa kalekale. Izi zinabwerezedwa mwezi wokha nkhondo isanayambe ndipo zosintha zinapangidwa malinga ndi zotsatira zake. Pamapeto pake, mapulaniwa sanakwaniritsidwe nkomwe. Koma zikuwonekeratu kuti boma ndi asilikali akhala akuganiza zowukira Hizbullah.
Kwa zaka zisanu ndi chimodzi, malire a Kumpoto anali opanda phokoso. Hizbullah adatumizanso maroketi (monga momwe akuchitira pano) koma adawonetsa nthawiyo (monga pano) kuti alibe chidwi chofuna kuwukira.
Kuwoloka kwa malire komwe asitikali awiri aku Israeli adagwidwa zinali zosiyana. Ntchitoyi idapangidwa kuti ipereke tchipisi tokambirana kuti amasulidwe akaidi a Hizbullah omwe adamangidwa
Monga ndanenera poyamba paja, chochitika ichi chinali chifukwa cha nkhondo, osati chifukwa chake. Ngati ndi choncho, chifukwa chenicheni chinali chiyani? Chikhumbo cha Olmert wamba chaulemerero wankhondo? Maloto a Chief of Staff, Dan Halutz, kuti atsimikizire kuti Air Force ikhoza kupambana nkhondo yokha, ndi bombardment yaikulu ya anthu wamba? Chinyengo choti Hizbullah ikhoza kuthetsedwa ndi kumenya kwakukulu kumodzi?
Pamene Woweruza Winograd anayesa kufotokoza chifukwa chake mbali ya lipotilo iyenera kusungidwa mwachinsinsi, mawu omwe anagwiritsa ntchito sanakopeke nawo: "Chitetezo cha boma ndi maubwenzi ake akunja". Maubwenzi akunja? Ndi maubwenzi otani akunja? Ubale ndi ndani? Pali yankho limodzi lokha lololera: ubale ndi a
Ichi chikhoza kukhala maziko a nkhaniyi: Olmert adakwaniritsa zofuna za America. Purezidenti Bush akufuna kukhazikitsa protรฉgรฉ wake, Fouad Siniora, ngati wolamulira
Ndikukhulupirira kuti uwu ndiye ulalo womwe ukusowa mu unyolo wa Winograd. Olmert akanatha kunena kuti: "Ndimangomvera malamulo". Koma zimenezo, ndithudi, nโzosaneneka.
ZINTHU zakuda zakuda mu lipotili zimakhudza gulu lankhondo la Israeli. Lipotilo likutsutsa zakupha. Utsogoleri wa asilikali sunayambe wafotokozedwa motere - ngati gulu la anthu opanda khalidwe, luso kapena luso; akuluakulu a asilikali amene ali okonzeka kutumiza asilikali kuti aphedwe mโgulu lankhondo limene akukhulupirira kuti liyenera kulephera, chifukwa chakuti sangayerekeze kulimbana ndi akuluakulu awo; akazembe amene safuna tanthauzo lomveka la zolinga asanapite kunkhondo; Akuluakulu omwe sazindikira zolakwa za gulu lawo lankhondo, komanso omwe ali ndi udindo - iwo ndi omwe adawatsogolera - pa zolakwa zomwezi.
Zonsezi zikunenedwa tsopano. Chimene sichinanenedwe ndi chakuti: tinapeza bwanji utsogoleri wotere? Kodi zolakwa zimenezi zachititsa chiyani?
Mayankho angafotokozedwe mwachidule m'mawu awiri: ntchito.
Mโzaka zingapo zapitazi ndalemba nkhani zambirimbiri zokhudza zotsatirapo zoipa za ntchito ya asilikali. Munthu sangagwiritse ntchito gulu lonse lankhondo kwa zaka zambiri ngati apolisi achitsamunda pofuna kuthana ndi kukana kwa anthu omwe agwidwa, osasintha mawonekedwe ake. Asilikali omwe amathamangira ana oponya miyala m'zigwa za Qasbah, omwe amamenya nyundo usiku pazitseko za anthu wamba, omwe amagwiritsa ntchito bulldozer kuwononga nyumba za anthu, ndipo zonsezi zimachitika chaka ndi chaka - asilikali otere sakhala odziwa kumenyana ndi zamakono. nkhondo.
Choyipa kwambiri: gulu lankhondo la atsamunda lotere silimakopa zabwino komanso zowala kwambiri. Izi tsopano zikupita kuukadaulo wapamwamba ndi sayansi. Ntchito yankhanza ya gulu lankhondo yolimbana ndi anthu wamba ndi zigawenga zimanyansidwa ndi anthu achikumbumtima ndi ozindikira, omwe ali msana wa gulu lankhondo labwino. Imasokoneza malingaliro a omwe atsala, kapena kuwatumiza kwawo kuchokera kumadera olandidwa okhumudwa.
Mโzaka 40 zokhala mโdzikolo, gulu lankhondo la Israyeli lataya mtundu wa akazembe amene analitsogolera mโnkhondo za 1948 ndi 1967, anthu onga Yitzhak Sadeh, Yigal Allon, Yitzhak Rabin, Ezer Weitzman, Matti Peled, Haim Bar-Lev ndi David Elazar. , kungotchulapo zochepa chabe. Malo awo adatengedwa ndi gulu laling'ono, lopanda mawonekedwe, akatswiri otuwa koma odzikuza, anthu oganiza mozama, atsamunda komanso amapiko akumanja monyanyira, omwe akuchulukirachulukirachulukira omwe amavala kippa oluka.
Ndilo gulu lomwe lipoti likunena - koma osanena choncho. Ndi gulu lankhondo lomwe limagwira ntchito molakwika - aliyense amene sakumva bwino mderali amangochoka. Monga gulu lililonse lankhondo, mlengalenga womwe uli pamwamba - wabwino kapena woyipa - umatsika mpaka msirikali woipitsitsa.
Izi si gulu lankhondo
ZNetwork imalandira ndalama kudzera mu kuwolowa manja kwa owerenga ake.
Ndalama