Ndinamva za ngozi ya Malaysia Airlines Flight MH17 pamene ndege yanga inatera ku Montreal tsiku lomwelo, July 17, pobwerera kwathu kuchokera ku Moscow. Ndege ya Moscow-Munich inanyamuka ola limodzi (kuchedwa) kunyamuka pa Flight MH17 kuchokera ku Amsterdam nthawi ya 12:30 pm nthawi zakwathu. Ndikuganiza kuti mayendedwe owuluka amadutsana kwinakwake chakumadzulo kwa Ukraine.
Chithunzi cha MH17 anapita pansi m'dera lolamulidwa ndi asilikali odzitetezera a zigawo yodzilamulira ya kum'mwera chakum'mawa kwa Ukraine, pafupi ndi mudzi Grabovo (Hrabove), theka pakati Donetsk ndi Luhansk mizinda, 50 Km kumpoto ndi 100 Km kumadzulo kwa malire a Russia. Pali 298 omwe akuti adazunzidwa. Pano pali maulendo oyendetsa ndege map njira.
Nkhani yodziwika bwino yaku Western media inali yabwino patsamba loyamba la Vancouver Sun tsiku lotsatira. Linati, โndege ya ku Malaysia yawomberedwa ndi zigawengaโ. Mlandu watsekedwa. Wolakwa monga woimba mlandu.
Paul Koring wa Globe ndi Mail akulemba kuti, "Zomwe zidagwetsa Malaysia Airlines Flight 17 zimadziwika kale. Mzinga wapanthawi ya Soviet Union wowombera kuchokera kumadera odzipatula kum'maลตa kwa Ukraine unang'amba ndege ya Boeing 777 pamene inkayenda mtunda woposa makilomita 10 kuchokera kudera la Donetsk."
The Guardian mutu wa July 19 nkhani ndi, 'MH17: zigawenga zimatsekereza mwayi wopita kumalo a ngozi monga umboni wotsutsa iwo ukukula'. Koma nkhaniyi ilibe mawu a umboni wonenedwa.
Toronto Star mtolankhani Mitch Potter akudzudzula omwe amawatcha "zigawenga zopanda pake" komanso "chilombo cha Putin" kum'mawa kwa Ukraine, kenako amavomereza kuti umboni womwe adagwetsa ndegeyo "ndiwongochitika". Amatchula a Washington Post wolemba yemwe akuti tsokali lidachitika chifukwa cha "tsoka loyipa la Putin lomwe adapanga ku Ukraine".
Mkonzi lero, Toronto Star akonzi amatchula Stephen Harper mโkuimba mlandu: โKuukira kwa Russia ndi kulanda Ukraine mosaloledwa (sic) . . . ndiye gwero la mikangano yomwe ikuchitika mโderali.โ Purezidenti wa Russia Vladimir Putin, akuti akonzi, ayenera "kumanga agalu ake ankhondo".
Atolankhani a wailesi ya CBC ndi wailesi yakanema athamangira pamalopo kuti akapezenso ntchentche zina, atulutsa malipoti a tsoka. ndi la chivomezi cha Haiti mu 2010 komanso mphepo yamkuntho yotchedwa Haiyan (Yolanda) yomwe inagunda dziko la Philippines mu 2013. Iwo amadziwa kale nkhaniyo. Mafunso awo sali akuti, โKodi ndani anagwetsa ndegeyo ndipo nโchifukwa chiyani?โ, koma, โKodi dziko la Russia linapatsa bwanji zigawenga za kumโmaลตa kwa Ukraine luso la kugwetsa ndegeyo, ndipo nโchifukwa chiyani likanachitira zimenezo?โ
Ma tabloids aku Britain ali ponseponse pamasamba awo akutsogolo kuti 'Putin' kapena olemba ganyu ku Ukraine ndi akupha anthu ambiri.
Purezidenti waku Ukraine akudziwa. Mโmaola ochepa chabe ngoziyo itachitika, iye anati: โLero zigawenga zapha anthu mazana atatu ndi mfuti imodzi. Pakati pawo ana osalakwa, anthu a mโmaiko ambiri padziko lapansi.โ Ulamuliro wa Kyiv ukanena za kum'maลตa kwa Ukraine, mawu akuti "zigawenga" ndi ofanana ndi "anthu okhala kumeneko".
Tsoka la ndege ngati chifukwa cha nkhondo
Osadandaula kuti zonena za zomwe zidachitika ku Flight MH17 ndizongopeka ndipo kufufuza sikunayambe. Kuwunika kwandale komwe kunachitika pambuyo pa ngozi ndi chinthu chosiyana kwambiri ndi kupeza chowonadi - chikutengedwa ngati mwayi wofufuza mfiti komanso zachiwawa zolimbana ndi anthu akum'mawa kwa Ukraine. Kwa miyezi ingapo, akhala akukana ndikukana kutembenukira kwankhanza, zachuma ku Europe ndikutsagana ndi ziwawa zankhondo ndi boma lolamulira ku Kyiv ndi othandizira ake a NATO. Nkhondo yapadziko ya Kyiv yolimbana nawo yayimilira chifukwa asilikali ake oyenda pansi sakukhudzidwa ndi zomwe adayambitsa kapena sanakonzekere zomwe akuyenera kuchita.
M'masiku awiri chiwonongekocho, chiwawa cha boma chafika pachimake chankhanza. Zida zankhondo ndi matope zikugwetsa imfa ndi chiwonongeko pa anthu ndi midzi m'chigawo chonse chopanduka. Ku Luhansk, mzinda wa anthu 425,000. anthu osachepera 20 anafa kuchokera ku zipolopolo pa tsiku la ngozi. Zipolopolo zadula magetsi ndi madzi. Kulankhulana kwakukulu kumachepetsedwanso.
Atolankhani ku Luhansk People's Republic adati pa Julayi 18, "Zipolopolo zikuphulitsa pafupifupi zigawo zonse zamzindawu, kuphatikiza pakati pake. Chiwerengero cha anthu ophedwa ndi ovulala sichikudziwika nthawi yomweyo. (Onani makanema Pano ndi Pano za zotsatira za zipolopolo za mkati mwa mzinda pa July 18-chenjezo, zithunzi zochititsa mantha.)
Malo oyeretsera mafuta a Lisichansk mu mzindawu, a kampani ya Rosneft ya ku Russia, ndi amene akukhudzidwa kwambiri ndipo akuyaka kwambiri. (mavidiyo Pano ndi Pano).
Kale pa Julayi 16, wowonera ndi Sepcial Monitoring Mission of the Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) adanenanso kuti gawo limodzi mwa magawo atatu a nyumba zomwe zili pakatikati pa Luhansk zidawonongeka ndi zipolopolo komanso kuchuluka kwa kuwonongeka kwa mzindawu. kunja (Kuyankhulana kwavidiyo kwa mphindi khumi Pano). A Chidziwitso cha Julayi 18 a ntchito yowunikirayi atchula malipoti ochokera kwa madokotala am'deralo kuti mu June ndi July, anthu wamba 250 m'chigawo cha Luhansk anaphedwa ndi mabomba ndi zipolopolo ndipo 850 anavulala.
Kufufuza kofunikira
Zotsutsa zotsutsana ndi omenyera chitetezo chakum'mawa kwa Ukraine sizongotsimikizirika, ndizochitika. Kodi zigawenga za kum'mwera chakum'mawa kwa Ukraine zidalanda zida zankhondo zapamwamba zomwe akuti zidaponya ndegeyo? Sitikudziwa. Akadatero, akatswiri amati analibe maphunziro apamwamba kwambiri oti agwiritse ntchito.
Kodi mzingawo unaomberedwa kuti? Sitikudziwa. Dera lalitali la zinyalala la ngoziyo (makilomita asanu ndi limodzi utali, malinga ndi lipoti lina) ndi mayendedwe ake kumadzulo kupita kummawa zingayambitse kukayikira za zomwe zanenedwa za kugunda kwa mizinga kuchokera kummawa (ie kuchokera ku Russia kapena dera lake lamalire).
Ndege ya MH17 inali makilomita mazanamazana kumpoto kwa njira yake yachibadwa. Chifukwa chiyani oyang'anira ndege ku Ukraine adawongolera ndege kumeneko, kudutsa dera lankhondo lomwe ndege zambiri zankhondo zidawomberedwa ndi zida zodzitchinjiriza (pamalo otsika kwambiri) m'miyezi ingapo yapitayo ndi ndege ziti zomwe zakhala zikuzipewa? Kale mu April, mwachitsanzo, U.S. Federal Aviation Administration inaletsa ndege za ku United States kuwuluka kumene Flight 17 inatsikira. Lamulo lake linati, "Chifukwa cha kuthekera kwa malangizo otsutsana a kayendetsedwe ka ndege kuchokera kwa akuluakulu a ku Ukraine ndi ku Russia komanso chifukwa chodziwika bwino cha ndege zamtundu wa anthu, kayendetsedwe ka ndege ku United States sikuletsedwa mpaka chidziwitso china pa ndege ya Crimea, Black Sea ndi Nyanja ya Azov".
Mayankho amafunikira kuti ndani mu gulu lankhondo lankhondo la Ukraine yemwe ali ndi mphamvu zowombera mivi komanso momwe izi zimayendetsedwa mwamphamvu. Kodi ndi gawo lotani komanso mwayi wopeza zida zoponya zomwe akuluakulu ankhondo zachifasisti ndi zolondola ali nazo? Zigawengazi zikutsogola pa zipolopolo zakupha komanso zigawenga zomwe zachitika kummawa kwa dzikolo.
Asilikali odzitchinjiriza akukana kuwombera mzinga pa ndege. Nkhani iyi in Vox tsatanetsatane wabodza wapaintaneti pomwe zigawenga zidanenedwa kuti zidavomera. Olemba nkhani aulesi kapena atsankho m'manyuzipepala ambiri anena zambiri zabodza, ndipo akuluakulu aboma la US akubwereza ngati ndalama zabwino, kuphatikiza kazembe wa US Samantha Power pamaso pa UN Security Council pa Julayi 18.
Mphamvu zodzitchinjiriza ndizo kugwirizana pobweretsa gulu lofufuza a Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe to the site. Anthu okhala mโderali, kuphatikizapo anthu ogwira ntchito mโmigodi ya malasha, akutenga nawo mbali pa ntchito yofufuza zowonongeka ndi matupi awo.
Boma la Ukraine ku Kyiv komanso boma la Russia akukana kuti asitikali awo adaponya mizinga. Pulofesa wa ku U.S. Stephen Cohen anatero Demokarase Tsopano mu June 18 kuyankhulana, "Pali zotheka kuti a Russia adawathandiza ndikuwathandizira [ankhondo odzitchinjiriza], mwina kuchokera kudera la Russia, koma ndikutsutsa chifukwa, pamapeto pake, pamene simukudziwa yemwe adachita upandu, funso loyamba. katswiri wofufuza anafunsa kuti, โKodi pali amene anali ndi cholinga?โ ndipo anthu a ku Russia analibe cholinga pano.โ
Cohen amatcha anthu omwe adamwalira mu ndege, "oyamba kuzunzidwa ndi Cold War yatsopano", ponena za ziwopsezo zomwe zakhala zikuchitika kwanthawi yayitali ku Russia ndi mayiko a NATO zomwe zakula kuyambira chaka chatha ku Ukraine. Walemba pafupipafupi za kukwera, kuphatikiza m'nkhani ino ya June 30, 'Chete cha nkhandwe zaku America pazankhanza za Kiev'.
Mwina, mwina, kafukufuku wovomerezeka awululira chowonadi, kapena chowonadi chokwanira kuti apange zisankho ku NATO kaye kaye asanalowe usilikali. Koma pali zifukwa zazikulu zokayikirira zimenezo. Zomwe mayiko a NATO ali pankhondo yomwe akuimbidwa mlandu kum'mawa kwa Ukraine ndi boma ndi ogwirizana nawo, magulu ankhondo achifashisti ndi okwera kwambiri kuti asalole kufufuza kovutirapo.
Mlingo womwe atolankhani aku Canada komanso apadziko lonse lapansi akunyalanyaza kusokonekera komanso nkhondo yaulamuliro wa Kyiv ndi asitikali akum'mawa kwa Ukraine ndizochititsa manyazi. Zimangotchulidwa mwachidule monga "kumenyana" kosadziwika. The Guardian lili ndi nkhani 14 patsamba lake lankhani za ku Ukraine lerolino zonena za zotsatirapo za ngoziyi; palibe ndi mmodzi yemwe amene akunena za zipolopolo za asilikali a Ukraine. Mmodzi wa gulu lankhondo lodzitchinjiriza adauza BBC pamalo angoziwo, "Muli pano chifukwa alendo amwalira".
Chochititsa mantha nโchakuti, ngakhale kuti atolankhani amaulutsa misozi kwa anthu amene anakhudzidwa ndi ngoziyi, koma palibenso anthu amene anaphedwa chifukwa cha zipolopolo ndi mabomba. Zowonadi, zikuwoneka kuti nkhondo yochulukirapo ikufunika chifukwa "chinachake" chiyenera kuchitidwa kuti apulumutse oyenda pandege opanda chitetezo kuchokera ku "Putin" komanso omenyera ufulu wodziteteza kum'mawa kwa Ukraine.
Zonsezi zimabweretsa kukwera kwa kulowererapo kwankhondo komwe NATO ikupereka kale ku Kyiv. Ndi zolembedwa kotero kuti zimayesa wowonera kukhulupirira kuti anthu aku Washington ndi Brussels adakankha mabatani kuti atulutse zonse. Koma ayi, izi zitha kukhala zongopeka, ndipo ndicho chinthu chomaliza chomwe chikufunika pakali pano.
Nawa ena owonjezera pa kuyankhulana kwa Julayi 18 ndi Pulofesa Stephen Cohen pa Demokarase Tsopano:
Mwa njira, boma la Ukraine linawombera ndege ya ku Russia, ndikuganiza kuti mu 2001 [Siberia Airlines Flight 1812, Oct 4, 2001, 76 anamwalira]. Inali kuwuluka kuchokera ku Tel Aviv kupita ku Siberia [kwenikweni, Siberia kupita ku Tel Aviv]. Inali ngozi. Kudziwa nthawi zonse kumakhala kofunikira mukakhala ndi zida iziโฆ
Kuthekera kwina nkwakuti zigawengazo โ timazitcha odzilekanitsa, koma sanali odzilekanitsa pachiyambi, ankangofuna ulamuliro wa kwawo ku Ukraineโanali ndi kuthekera. Koma pali mkangano, chifukwa ndegeyi inali kuwuluka pazamalonda, nthawi zambiri osatha kunyamula mapewa awo.
Ndiroleni nditchule, chifukwa ndikuganiza kuti ndizogwirizana ndi zomwe mukulemba pano, magawo anu amphamvu kwambiri ndisanabwere lero zomwe zikuchitika ku Gaza, kugunda kwa mizinda iyi, kusowa chitetezo kwa anthu wamba. Zomwezo zakhala zikuchitika mโmizinda ya Kumโmaลตa kwa Ukraineโkuphulitsa mabomba, kuphulitsa zipolopolo, kuphulitsa matope ndi boma la Kievโchilichonse chimene tingaganize ponena za boma limenelo. Koma boma limenelo limathandizidwa ndi 150 peresenti ndi White House.
Chidziwitso choperekedwa ndi a Msonkhano wotsutsana ndi nkhondo womwe unachitikira ku Yalta, Crimea koyambirira kwa mwezi uno akuyitanitsa mfundo zisanu ndi zinayi zoletsa nkhondo ya Kyiv kum'mawa kwa Ukraine. Imodzi mwa mfundozo ndi "Kwa kafukufuku wapadziko lonse wotsogoleredwa ndi oweruza ndi omenyera ufulu wachibadwidwe pa kuphwanya ufulu wa anthu ndi ziwawa zankhondo zomwe zachitika panthawi ya nkhondoyi". Makampeni ndi kulimbikitsana kwachigwirizano kuzungulira mfundozi tsopano ndikofunika kwambiri kuposa kale.
Roger Annis posachedwapa wabwerera ku Canada kuchokera ku ulendo wa milungu iwiri ku Crimea ndi Moscow. Anapezeka pa msonkhano wotsutsa nkhondo umene unachitikira ku Yalta, Crimea pa July 6, 7. Angapezeke pa [imelo ndiotetezedwa]. Mutha kusaina ku statement ya msonkhano pa tsamba lawebusayiti iyi.
ZNetwork imalandira ndalama kudzera mu kuwolowa manja kwa owerenga ake.
Ndalama