Nkhani yofalitsidwa ndi CounterPunch dzulo, "Zowona Zovuta Zokhudza Tar Sands Action, "akutsutsa kuti kampeni yolimbana ndi payipi ya Keystone XL inali chabe "chinyengo choyendetsedwa, chothandizidwa ndi ndalama zambiri kuchokera ku pro-Obama Democrats kudzera m'mabungwe osawonekera ngati Tides Foundation." Izi zikutsatira, malinga ndi nkhaniyi, kuti cholinga chenicheni cha Tar Sands Action "chinali kupanga Obama 'chigonjetso chobiriwira' pa nthawi yake yoyamba pokonzekera chisankho cha 2012."
Mwachidule, kwa zikwizikwi za inu omwe mudatenga nawo gawo mu White House kukhala-ins kapena kuzungulira ndikukhala "Okhulupirira Owona mu mishoni," munapusitsidwa. Zomwe mudatenga nawo gawo "sizinali kusintha kwa chikhalidwe cha anthu, komanso sikunali kupatsa mphamvu anthu oyambira." Simunakhale china koma dzina pa mndandanda wa imelo. "Munasandulika kukhala okonda kusokoneza anthu omwe mwachiyembekezo adzapereka ndalama ku kampeni ya Purezidenti Obama 'I'm In' 2012, chilengedwe chidzathetsedwa."
Ndikadakufunsani momwe zimakhalira, koma ndiyenera kudziwa. Ndine mmodzi wa inu. Nkhaniyi imatchula za Waging Nonviolence pamodzi ndi gulu la Socialist Solidarity ndi mlembi Naomi Klein kuti anali mโgulu la โanthu ankhanza kwambiriโ amene โanamwa kool-aid.โ Ndiye ndikumva bwanji? Chabwino, kwa munthu amene akuti adamwa mankhwala osokoneza bongo, ndimamva kuti ndine woledzeretsa komanso wosakhutira.
Kukhulupirira kuti ma Democrat adalimbikitsa anthu masauzande ambiri kuti amangidwe ngati gawo loyesera kupanga chigonjetso cha chilengedwe kwa Obama ndikunyalanyaza mfundo yoti adakana kupambana kwake kophimbidwa ndi dzanja. Sanavomereze mokwanira zomwe zanenedwa za kampeniyi, ndipo posachedwapa walankhula zabwino za payipi, potero akuwonetsetsa kuti chilengedwe sichipambana kapena kuthandizira osamalira zachilengedwe.
Ngakhale mawu osangalatsa ("BIG NEWS: Tawina. Munapambana.") omwe adatuluka mu kampeni pambuyo pake. Chilengezo cha Obama cha Novembalakuti achedwetsa chigamulo chokhudza mapaipi mpaka 2013, chisangalalo chachepa m'miyezi kuchokera pamenepo. Maimelo aposachedwa kwambiri ochokera kwa wokonza mapulani a Bill McKibben ayang'ana kwambiri zovuta zapaipiyi - mwachitsanzo, ulendo waposachedwa wa Obama wopita ku Oklahoma, komwe "adayamika kayendetsedwe kake kakuthamangitsa mwendo wakumwera kwa payipi ya mchenga wa Keystone XL."
Izi sizikumveka ngati kampeni kapena purezidenti yemwe amagwira ntchito m'magulu. Komabe, malinga ndi wolemba nkhani ya CounterPunch yemwe amatchula dzina lachidziwitso la The Insider, awiriwa akhala akuyenda pang'onopang'ono, kunyengerera okonda zachilengedwe kuti achite zofuna za Democrat. Osadandaula kuti purezidenti sanasunge mathero ake pazokambirana; umboni wachinyengo umaonekera kwa The Insider. Poyamba, pali mfundo yoti mafuta a mchenga a phula azidzalowa mdziko muno kapena popanda Keystone XL. Chifukwa chake, popeza Tar Sands Action (TSA) sikuloza malo onse olowera nthawi imodzi kapena kuyesa kuphwanya makampani onse nthawi imodzi, mwachiwonekere ndi chinyengo chabe. Kuchokera pamalingaliro a The Insider, kuyesayesa kwa TSA kuti apange mayendedwe ambiri kuchokera pachiwopsezo kudzera pa kupambana konkriti sikuthandiza. Chofunika kwambiri ndi chiyero chamalingaliro.
Apa ndipamene chiwembu cha Tides Foundation chimabwera kudzasewera - pomwe nkhaniyo imayamba kumveka ngati Glenn Beck phokoso. Ngakhale palibe TSA kapena mabungwe ake ogwirizana 350.org adalandira ndalama zilizonse za Tides (makamaka malinga ndi chikalata chotchulidwa ndi The Insider), magulu ambiri omwe adathandizira adachita - mwachitsanzo, Sierra Club, NRDC ndi Friends of the Earth. Nโchifukwa chiyani zimenezi zili zofunika? Zimatengera ma Tides kukhala ndi "othandizira ndalama za demokalase". Ndiyo mfuti yosuta. Ndipo mwachiwonekere tikhoza kungokhulupirira kuti aliyense amene amavomereza ndalama kuchokera ku Tides akugwira ntchito mwakhama kuti asankhenso Obama. Umboni ndi wakuti anthu ena adawonekera ku White House okhala ndi kuzungulira atavala mapini ndi malaya a Obama.
The Insider ikufotokozanso lingaliro ili lakusinthana. "Tar Sands Action inali njira yotsogola, yolipidwa bwino kwambiri popanga chinyengo cha zomangamanga, zodzaza ndi kusamvera kwa anthu ambiri," inatero nkhaniyo, "koma cholinga chenicheni, kuwonetsa msuweni wake, 'The 99 Spring,' chinali ( ndi) kumenya anthu aku Republican ndikuwonjezera chidwi chambiri pa kampeni yosankhanso zisankho za Barack Obama. "
Co-option nthawi zonse imakhala yovomerezeka komanso yodetsa nkhawa, koma ngati Nathan Schneider adanena ponena za 99% Spring, ndikofunikira kufunsa, "Ndani akusankha ndani?"
Lingaliro la gulu lolimbana ndi anthu nthawi zonse ndikutenga magulu omwe alipo a anthu ozungulira iwo, kuwalimbikitsa, kuwachotsa pa zomwe zilipo ndikuchita zinthu zosinthadi. Ndipo ndendende posankha mabungwewa kuti gululi limatha kupanga mphamvu zokwanira kuti lisinthe kwenikweni.
Umu ndi momwe ndakhala ndikuwonera Tar Sands Action: ngati kampeni yomwe idazindikira mphamvu zamagulu a anthu koma idadziwa kuti ikufunika kufikira ma NGO akuluakulu obiriwira kuti akhale ogwira mtima. Monga Erica Chenoweth ndi Maria Stephan, olemba buku la 2011 Chifukwa Chake Kusagwirizana Kwachigawo Kumagwira Ntchito, onetsani, "Ubwino wamaluso ndi njira zamagulu osiyanasiyana otenga nawo mbali amafotokoza - makamaka - kupambana kwambiri kwamakampeni osachita zachiwawa." Chifukwa chake, kunyalanyaza zobiriwira zazikulu ndi maziko awo akuluakulu akuthandizira ndikupangitsa kuti ntchito yanu yokonzekera ikhale yovuta kwambiri. Koma kuti muwasankhe, mndandanda wawo wa imelo ndi chikoka chawo pazandale ndikulimbikitsa kampeni yanu.
Inde, kuchita zimenezi sikophweka, ngakhale kuti The Insider akuganiza za ndalama za Tides zomwe zinapangitsa kuti zidutswa zonse zitheke. Posachedwapa ndinalankhula ndi Linda Capato, yemwe ankagwira ntchito yolemba anthu ku TSA, ndipo adalongosola momwe analiri okha pachiyambi, pamene milungu iwiri ya kusamvera anthu inalengezedwa.
Nthawi zonse takhala tikuuzidwa kuti musamachite chinthu chovuta kwambiri. Kusamvera anthu ambiri pamaso pa zipata za White House kwa milungu iwiri, ndizopenga. Sierra Club sisayina chifukwa choti sangathe. Iwo ali ndi mphamvu zimenezo. NRDC sikuthandiza. Zobiriwira zazikulu zonsezi sizibwera patebulo ndipo zinali ngati zabwino, titha kuchita popanda iwo. Ndipo kotero inali nthawi ino ya tiyeni tiyese. Ndiyeno, m'mene zinkachitika komanso pamene tinali kukonzekera, aliyense anali kudumphira m'bwalo chifukwa linali lingaliro lanzeru, inali nthawi yoti achite izo, inali chandamale choyenera, njira yoyenera, ndi njira yoyenera.
Izi, pamapeto pake, ndi zomwe The Insider ikuyang'ana. Keystone XL inali chandamale chomwe chinali ndi gawo lalikulu kwa purezidenti, popeza chisankho chinali chake yekha kuvomereza kapena kukana. Sizinapangidwe kuti zigwetse makampani a mchenga wa phula. Kulakwitsa chifukwa chosachita izi kuli ngati kulakwitsa malo ochitira nkhomaliro chifukwa chosathetsa tsankho. Ndiponso, kunena kuti โMartin Luther King ayenera kukhala akutembenukira mโmanda ake,โ ndiko kukana kuti Mfumu sinangosonkhezera mawu a Lyndon Johnson a makhalidwe abwino komanso anakumana naye.
TSA kukhala-ins ndi kuzungulira kwa White House sikunali misonkhano ya kampeni ya Obama. Zinali zochita mwanzeru zokopa anthu osiyanasiyana. Ma radicals ochepa pa ma tripod kapena ma armlocks ndiabwino, koma kuti apambane, kuyesetsa kumafunika mgwirizano wokulirapo. Musalakwitse, ambiri mwa okonza omwe adathandizira kuwongolera TSA amachokera kumagulu okonzekera bwino; kwa iwo, kugwiritsa ntchito malankhulidwe a Obama inali njira yotsimikizira kusiyana komwe kulipo pakati pa mbiri ya Purezidenti ndi mawu ake olimbikitsa.
Mauthenga amtunduwu ali ndi kuthekera kokulirapo kuposa kukuwa kwaukali komwe kumachitika nthawi zambiri potsutsa ndipo ndichifukwa chake McKibben nthawi ina adati, "Sitipanga Purezidenti Obama kufuna kumuukira. Tikhala ndi kampeni ya a Obama molingana ndi momwe adakhazikitsira mu 2008. Kukana payipi iyi kungatumize kugwedezeka kwa magetsi kudzera mwa anthu omwe adasankha pulezidentiyu. " Kwa ine, izi zikuwoneka ngati kuyesa kwa TSA kuti agwirizane ndi gulu lalikulu kwambiri la ndale m'zaka zaposachedwa ndikulilimbikitsa kuti lithandizire chilengedwe. Koma zonse zomwe The Insider imamva ndi "ndalama zabwino, zisudzo zandale komanso ubale wapagulu."
Vuto la malingaliro ochitira chiwembu ambiri ndikuti amachotsa zopereka za anthu wamba. M'malo mopereka mbiri kwa omwe atenga nawo gawo ku TSA chifukwa chopanga kampeni yawoyawo, yomwe idatenga nthawi ndi thupi, katswiri wa zachiwembu amanyoza omwe adatenga nawo gawo ngati "njuchi zatsiku ndi tsiku."
Izi sizili choncho ku Tar Sands Action. Zoona zake nโzakuti ngakhale kuti kampeniyi inali yokhudza kubweretsa anthu masauzande ambiri ku White House, inalinso yopatsa mphamvu anthu amderali kuti achitepo kanthu polimbana ndi mapaipiwo. "Madera ambiri m'mphepete mwa mapaipi akugwira ntchito limodzi kuposa kale," Linda Capato anandiuza. "Anthu aku Nebraska omwe akhala akugwira ntchito ndi omwe akuyandikira akugwira ntchito ndi anthu aku Texas pankhaniyi. Ngati payipi ya zombie ikabweranso, tikhala ndi mphamvu zambiri ndipo gawo limodzi mwamphamvuzo ndikuti maderawa akulankhulana. โ
The Insider ikumaliza ndi mawu omenyera ufulu John Stauber, wokayikira wina wa TSA, yemwe akuti, "Ndingakonde kuwona anthu enieni omwe agula hype ndikutenga maphunziro awa akusamvera anthu, komanso omwe adamangidwa, adzuka ndikugwira. kulamulira kayendedwe kawo.โ Mwina amangofunika kutsegula maso ake.
ZNetwork imalandira ndalama kudzera mu kuwolowa manja kwa owerenga ake.
Ndalama