Gulu la maloya a Israeli ndi akuluakulu adapereka chitetezo ku The Hague Lachisanu pa tsiku lachiwiri la mlandu wopha anthu anabweretsedwa ku bwalo la milandu la International Court of Justice ndi boma la South Africa. Maloyawo adawonetsa Israeli ngati yemwe adaphedwa, osati Gaza, adadzudzula dziko la South Africa kuti likuthandiza Hamas, ndipo adajambula boma la South Africa kuti likugwira ntchito ngati mkono wovomerezeka wa zigawenga zaku Palestine zomwe zidatsogolera zigawenga zakupha ku Israel pa Okutobala 7.
Israeli anapindula kwambiri chifukwa chakuti kunalibe kufufuza kosiyana kololedwa kapena kukangana kololedwa mkati mwa milanduyi. Anayamba ntchito yolimba mtima kuti achite m'khoti la malamulo apadziko lonse zomwe akuluakulu ake ankhondo ndi ndale achita usana ndi usiku panthawi yonse ya nkhondoyi yolimbana ndi Gaza: kumasula chigumula cha zomwe zinkadziwika mkati mwa kayendetsedwe ka Trump monga "zinthu zina. โ
Chitetezo cha Israeli chinali chotsutsana ndi mlandu wa South Africa dzulo, komanso chofooka popereka zolembedwa monga momwe South Africa inalili yamphamvu. Mbiri inayamba pa October 7, Israeli ankawoneka kuti, South Africa ndi Hamas, South Africa sanapatse Israeli mwayi wokumana ndi kukambirana za Gaza asanaimbidwe mlandu wakupha anthu, ndipo kwenikweni Israeli Defense Forces ndilo gulu labwino kwambiri padziko lapansi. . Ponena za zonena zapagulu za akuluakulu aku Israeli zomwe zikuwonetsa cholinga chophera fuko, izi zinali "zongonena mwachisawawa" za anthu ena osafunikira. Kodi Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu akunena nkhani yakupha ya m'Baibulo yokhudza kupha akazi, makanda, ndi ng'ombe za adani anu? Anthu aku South Africa samamvetsetsa zamulungu ndipo adapereka mawu a Netanyahu mosiyana.
Ngakhale maloya a Israeli adapereka zifukwa zamalamulo kuti milandu yopha anthu onse ndi yosavomerezeka, njira yawo yayikulu inali yokadandaula kukhoti pazaulamuliro ndi machitidwe, akuyembekeza kuti atha kupanga maziko oti oweruza apadziko lonse lapansi asiye mlandu wa South Africa. Podziwa za omvera padziko lonse lapansi, Israeli adafunanso kulimbikitsa zonena zake zachilungamo komanso kudziteteza pomenya nkhondo ku Gaza.
Woimira Israeli a Tal Becker adatsegula chigamulo cha boma lake pouza oweruza ku ICJ kuti mlandu wa South Africa "unasokoneza kwambiri chithunzithunzi chenichenicho ndi malamulo," ponena kuti likufuna kufafaniza mbiri ya Chiyuda. Adanenanso kuti zotsutsana ndi gulu la South Africa "zinali zosiyanitsidwa" ndi zolankhula za Hamas ndipo adawadzudzula kuti "adapanga zida" mawu akuti "kupha anthu."
Becker adatcha Okutobala 7 "kuphedwa kwakukulu kowerengeka kwa Ayuda kuyambira chiwonongeko cha Nazi" ndipo adachonderera khoti kuti liwonetsere "nkhanza ndi kusayeruzika" kwa adani a Israeli akuti akumenya nkhondo ku Gaza. Israel, adatero, ali ndi ufulu wololedwa kugwiritsa ntchito njira zonse zomwe zilipo poyankha "kuphedwa kwa Okutobala 7 komwe Hamas idalumbira kubwereza."
Anatsutsa boma la South Africa mobwerezabwereza, akumatsutsa kuti achita zofuna za Hamas ndikunena kuti cholinga chake chenicheni chinali "kulepheretsa" ufulu wa Israeli wodziteteza. "South Africa ili ndi ubale wapamtima ndi Hamas," adatero Becker. "Ubalewu udapitilirabe ngakhale zitachitika nkhanza za pa Okutobala 7." Ananenanso kuti South Africa, osati Israeli, iyenera kutsatiridwa ndi ICJ chifukwa chothandizira Hamas. Becker ananyalanyaza kunena kuti Netanyahu mwiniwake nthawi yayitali yolimbikitsa kuti Hamas akhalebe ndi mphamvu ku Gaza ndipo adagwira ntchito kuti awonetsetse kuti ndalama zoyendetsera gulu kuchokera ku Qatar zikupitirizabe kwa zaka zambiri, pokhulupirira kuti ndi njira yabwino kwambiri yothetsera kukhazikitsidwa kwa dziko la Palestina.
Becker adakana zomwe dziko la South Africa likunena za mbiri ya chiwonongeko cha anthu wamba ku Gaza - chomwe chapha ana opitilira 10,000 - ponena kuti chomwe "chosayerekezeka komanso chomwe sichinachitikepo" pankhondoyi ndi Hamas "kuyambitsa nkhondo zake ku Gaza mkati ndi pansi" mochuluka. madera okhala anthu. Becker adalankhula ngati kuti zomwe Israeli akunena zachilendo kwambiri zokhudzana ndi ntchito za Hamas mobisa sizinatsimikizidwe zabodza kapena zasonyezedwa kuti ndizokokomeza kwambiri, monga zomwe Israeli akunena kuti kunali Hamas Pentagon. pansi pa chipatala cha al-Shifa.
Becker adanenanso kuti maloya aku South Africa adalephera kutchula kuchuluka kwa nyumba zomwe zidawombedwa ndikuwonongedwa ku Gaza m'miyezi itatu yapitayi ya bomba la Israeli lomwe linali "boobytrapped" ndi Hamas m'malo mowonongedwa ndi Israeli. Zinali zomveka zomwe sizinaperekedwe kokha kukula kwa kuphulika kwa mabomba kwa Israeli m'madera onse, komanso chifukwa asilikali a Israeli ali nawo. adayika mavidiyo za iwo eni mwachangu ndikudina batani la detonate kuwononga madera onse. Anakana ziwerengero za imfa ya anthu wamba ndi kuvulala zomwe zidaperekedwa ndi akuluakulu azaumoyo ku Gaza, ponena kuti maloya aku South Africa alephera kutchula kuti ndi angati mwa anthu akufa aku Palestine omwe anali ogwira ntchito ku Hamas. Zinali zochititsa chidwi kuti akuluakulu a Israeli adanena momveka bwino komanso mobwerezabwereza kuti ku Gaza kulibe anthu osalakwa, komanso kuti ogwira ntchito ku United Nations ndi atolankhani omwe anaphedwa ndi Israeli alidi achinsinsi a Hamas.
"Malo owopsa opangidwa ndi Hamas abisika ndi" South Africa, Becker adaimba mlandu. "Israeli yadzipereka kutsata lamuloli, koma ikuchita izi pamaso pa Hamas kunyoza lamulolo." Becker sanavutike kuyankha chilichonse mwa izi zigamulo zambiri za U.N Pazaka makumi angapo akudzudzula kusaloleka kwa ulamuliro watsankho wa Israeli ndi ntchito zake zosaloledwa, osatchulanso zomwe zidalembedwa bwino za ana aku Palestine monga zishango za anthu wamba ndi mwadala kupha ndi kulemala za anthu osachita ziwawa.
Becker adanenanso kuti Israeli ikutsatira malamulo apadziko lonse pazochitika zake zonse ku Gaza. "Israeli sakufuna kuwononga anthu, koma kuteteza anthu - anthu ake," adatero, ndikuwonjezera kuti Israeli ikuchita "nkhondo yoteteza Hamas, osati anthu aku Palestina." โSipangakhale mlandu wabodza komanso woipa kwambiri kuposa mlandu wopha anthu.โ Anadzudzula dziko la South Africa chifukwa chochitira nkhanza khoti lapadziko lonse lapansi ndikulisintha kukhala โchikalata cha zigawengaโ.
A Malcolm Shaw, loya waku Britain woimira Israeli, adatsegula mkangano wake potsutsa zomwe South Africa idanena Lachinayi pazomwe idafotokoza ngati Nakba wazaka 75 wa Israeli motsutsana ndi Palestine. Shaw adatcha izi ngati "zokwiyitsa" ndipo adati "nkhani" yokhayo yomwe idagwirizana ndi mbiri yakale ndi zomwe zidachitika pa Okutobala 7, zomwe adazitcha "kuphana kwenikweni mumkhalidwewu." Poganizira kuchuluka kwa anthu wamba omwe adaphedwa ndi Israeli ku Gaza - opitilira 23,000 kuyambira sabata ino - anali mawu odabwitsa. Malinga ndi chiลตerengero cha akuluakulu a boma la Israel, anthu pafupifupi 1,200 anaphedwa pa October 7. Mwa ameneลตa, 274 anali asilikali, 764 anali anthu wamba, 57 anali apolisi a Israeli, ndipo 38 anali alonda akumaloko. Sizinadziwikebe kuti ndi angati a Israeli omwe adaphedwa pazochitika za "moto wochezeka" ndi asitikali aku Israeli omwe adayankha kuukira kwa Hamas tsiku lomwelo.
Shaw ndi maloya ena oimira Israeli adavomereza kuti anthu wamba adaphedwa panthawi yankhondo ya Israeli, ngakhale Shaw adatsutsa kuti "nkhondo yankhondo, ngakhale itakhala yovomerezeka komanso yovomerezeka, ndi yankhanza ndipo imawononga miyoyo." Koma, adati, Israeli idachita nawo kampeni yovomerezeka komanso yofananira ndipo adati ICJ sinali malo oyenera kuwunikanso nkhondo ya Gaza. โGulu lokhalo lomwe lili mโkhoti lino ndi kupha anthu. Si mikangano iliyonse yomwe imapha anthu,โ adatero Shaw. "Ngati zonena za kupha fuko zikadakhala njira yomwe timagwiritsa ntchito pankhondo yathu ... tanthauzo la upanduwu likhoza kuchepetsedwa ndikutayika."
Shaw adakhala nthawi yayitali akunena kuti dziko la South Africa lalephera kutsata njira zomwe adalamula kuti apereke mlandu wopha anthu ku khoti lapadziko lonse lapansi. Iye adadzudzula boma la South Africa kuti lalephera mokwanira kulumikizana mwachindunji ndi Israeli kuti lidziwitse kuti pali kusamvana pakati pa mayiko awiriwa. South Africa "ikuwoneka kuti ikukhulupirira kuti sizitengera awiri ku tango," adatero. South Africa "idasankha unilaterally kuti mkangano ulipo" pakati pa Israeli ndi South Africa, ngakhale kuti Shaw adatcha Israeli "mgwirizano ndi wochezeka" akupereka kuti akumane ndi South Africa kuti akambirane nkhawa zake za nkhondo ya Gaza. Izi zikusemphana ndi nzeru, chifukwa mu Novembala, Pretoria idadzudzula Israeli popha anthu komanso akuitanidwa Khothi la International Criminal Court kuti lipereke chilolezo chomangidwa kwa Netanyahu. Israel idayankha pochotsa kazembe wake.
Shaw adalankhulanso zomwe akuluakulu aku Israeli adanenedwa m'khothi ndi South Africa ngati umboni wa "cholinga chopha fuko." Shaw adatsutsa mawu awa ngati "zidziwitso zachisawawa" zomwe zidalephera "kuwonetsa kuti Israeli ali ndi cholinga chowononga" anthu aku Palestina. Ananenanso kuti palibe chilichonse mwa mawuwa chomwe chinali chovomerezeka ndi boma la Israeli ndipo adati chinthu chokhacho chomwe khothi liyenera kuliganizira ndikuti ngati mawuwa akuwonetsa zigamulo kapena malangizo omwe atsogoleri a Israeli ndi nduna yake yankhondo. Shaw adalengeza kuti sanatero, natchulapo mawu angapo aku Israeli omwe akuwongolera magulu ankhondo kuti atsatire malamulo apadziko lonse lapansi ndikuyesetsa kuteteza anthu wamba kuvulazidwa kapena kuphedwa. Ananyalanyaza kuyankha pamalumikizidwe achindunji omwe adapangidwa, kuphatikiza umboni wa kanema, ndi gulu lazamalamulo la South Africa lomwe likuwonetsa momwe asitikali aku Israeli omwe ali pansiwo adagwirizana ndi zomwe akuluakulu a Israeli adalankhula ponena za kuwononga Gaza pamene adazungulira mpanda.
Loya wa ku Britain analankhula mwachindunji ponena za kupembedzera kwa Netanyahu nkhani ya mโBaibulo ya kuwonongedwa kwa Amaleki, pamene Mulungu analamula Aisrayeli โkukantha Aamaleki, ndi kuononga konse chuma chawo. musawalekerere; muphe amuna ndi akazi, ana ndi makanda, ngโombe ndi nkhosa, ngamila ndi abulu.โ Shaw anatsutsa kuti "palibe chifukwa pano cha zokambirana zaumulungu." South Africa, adadzudzula, idachotsa mawu a Netanyahu ndipo sanaphatikizepo gawo la mawu ake pomwe adatsindika kuti IDF ndi "gulu lankhondo labwino kwambiri padziko lonse lapansi" ndipo "limachita chilichonse kuti lipewe kuvulaza omwe sakhudzidwa." Tanthauzo la mkangano wa Shaw ndikuti malingaliro a Netanyahu okhudza olemekezeka a IDF mwanjira ina adalepheretsa tanthauzo la kuyitanitsa lamulo lachiwawa la m'Baibulo lofotokoza zankhondo yolimbana ndi anthu Nduna ya Zachitetezo ku Israeli Yoav Gallant omwe adawafotokozera kuti "nyama zaumunthu."
Atapereka mndandanda wa ziganizo za Israeli zoteteza anthu wamba komanso kupereka chithandizo kwa anthu aku Palestine, Shaw ananena moseka kuti, โCholinga chakupha anthu?โ ngati kuti mawu awa ndi zonena mwanjira ina zimafafaniza zochitika zenizeni zomwe dziko lapansi lawonera tsiku lililonse kwa miyezi yopitilira itatu. Mopanda manyazi, Shaw adawonetsa zomwe Israeli adauza anthu aku Palestine ku Gaza kuti atuluke mnyumba zawo ngati chithandizo. Dzulo, dziko la South Africa lidatcha lamulo loti anthu opitilira miliyoni miliyoni asamuke posachedwa ngati kupha fuko lokha.
Mโkamphindi komwe kunayatsa gasi kwadzaoneni, Shaw anamaliza nkhani yake poimba mlandu boma la South Africa kuti โlikuchita nawo kupha anthuโ komanso kulephera โntchito yake yoletsa kuphanaโ. Ananenanso kuti, "South Africa yapereka chithandizo ndi chithandizo ku Hamas ngakhale pang'ono." Anati zonena za Israeli "zikuyandikira kwambiri" ndipo adati machitidwe a Hamas, osati a Israeli, amakumana ndi "tanthauzo lovomerezeka la kupha anthu." Mosiyana ndi Hamas, adapitilizabe, Israeli yachita "zoyesayesa zomwe sizinachitikepo kuti achepetse kuvulaza anthu wamba ...
Galit Rajuan, loya wina waku Israeli, adati Israeli ikugwira ntchito motsatira malamulo pakuwukira ku Gaza. Adakhala nthawi yayitali akudzudzula Hamas kuti amagwiritsa ntchito zipatala ndi malo ena wamba kuti agwire ntchito zankhondo komanso kusunga akaidi aku Israeli. South Africa, adatero, amadzinamizira "ngati Israeli ikugwira ntchito ku Gaza popanda mdani wankhondo" ndipo adati imfa ya anthu wamba ndi chiwonongeko chomwe chinayambitsidwa ndi ntchito za Israeli ndi "zotsatira zomwe Hamas akufuna". "Imfa zambiri za anthu wamba zimayambitsidwa ndi Hamas," adatero.
Anabwerezanso zomwe zanenedwa kuti Hamas amagwiritsa ntchito zipatala kuti azigwira ntchito zankhondo ndikusunga anthu ogwidwa, ponena kuti kuwonongeka kulikonse komwe Israeli adachita kuzipatala ku Gaza "nthawi zonse kunali chifukwa cha njira yonyansa yankhondo ya Hamas."
Poyankha zonena za South Africa kuti anthu aku Palestine adangopatsidwa maola 24 okha kuti athawe mnyumba ndi zipatala, a Rajuan adati Israeli idapereka machenjezowo milungu ingapo pasadakhale kudzera m'mapepala, mamapu apa intaneti, ndi maakaunti azama TV. Sananene kuti Israeli yatseka intaneti pafupipafupi kumadera a Gaza ndipo yagunda madera omwe idauza anthu kuti athawireko.
Atatha kufotokoza zomwe adaziwonetsa ngati kuyesayesa kwakukulu kwa Israeli popereka thandizo kwa anthu aku Gaza, Rajuan adati ndi umboni kuti mlandu wopha anthu "ndiwosavomerezeka." Ananenanso kuti adangouza khothi kuti "kagawo kakang'ono" kazomwe Israeli adachita pochenjeza anthu wamba kuti achoke mnyumba zawo ndikupereka thandizo koma "ndizokwanira kuwonetsa ... zopanda maziko.โ Kuwonetsera kwake kwa Israeli ngati mapiri opindulitsa osuntha anthu kuti athetse mavuto a Palestine kungakhale koseketsa ngati sikunali kupha. Koma mawu otere ndi osavuta kupereka ngati mfundo zanu zovomerezeka ndikuwonetsa mabungwe othandizira ndi ogwira ntchito ku U.N. ngati othandizira a Hamas.
Kwa miyezi, mabungwe othandizira padziko lonse lapansi adzudzula Israeli, yomwe imagwira ntchito ngati mtsogoleri wa zomwe zimalowa ndi kutuluka ku Gaza, chifukwa cholepheretsa kupereka chithandizo ku Gaza. Sabata ino yokha, Akuluakulu a U.N kuti Israeli akuletsa kuti asalandire thandizo kumpoto kwa Gaza, pomwe World Health Organisation idatero ikukumana ndi mavuto "osatheka" popereka chithandizo. Komabe, Omri Sender, loya wina wa Israeli, adanena kuti Israeli ikupereka chithandizo chochuluka tsiku ndi tsiku ku Gaza, ngakhale "Hamas imaba nthawi zonse." Adauza oweruza kuti "Israeli mosakayika imakumana ndi mayeso azamalamulo omwe cholinga chake chinali makamaka ...
Christopher Staker adatseka zotsutsana za Israeli ponena kuti dziko la South Africa likuyesera kukakamiza Israeli kuti athetse nkhondo ndi kuti izi zidzalola Hamas kukhala "omasuka kupitiriza kuukira, zomwe zanena [zofuna] kuchita." Ananenanso kuti kupha anthu wamba komanso chiwonongeko ku Gaza komwe South Africa yatchulidwa sikutanthauza kupha anthu komanso kuti "sizili m'manja mwa khothi" kulamula kuti Israeli asiye ntchito zonse zankhondo pansi pa Msonkhano Wachifwamba. Ananenanso kuti Israeli ali ndi ufulu wochita nawo usilikali ku Gaza kuti South Africa ikufuna kuletsa, komanso kuti lamulo la ICJ loti asiye ntchito zonse lingayambitse "tsankho losatheka" ku ufulu wa Israeli. Dziko la South Africa, pamakangano ake Lachinayi, linanena kuti pokana kusiya ntchito zake, Israeli ikuwonetsetsa kuti mulu wa mitembo ya Palestine upitirire kukula limodzi ndi kudula miyendo popanda opaleshoni komanso makanda akufa ndi matenda ochiritsika.
Staker anatenga tsamba kuchokera m'buku la propaganda lodziwika bwino la Netanyahu ndikufanizira nkhondo ya Gaza ndi Nkhondo Yachiwiri Yadziko Lonse, ponena kuti khoti lapadziko lonse lolamula Israeli kuti asiye ntchito ku Gaza lidzakhala lofanana ndi khoti mu 1940s kukakamiza Allies mu Nkhondo Yachiwiri Yadziko Lonse kuti apereke. ku Axis mphamvu ku Europe. Anati kuyimitsidwa kwa ntchito zankhondo "kulepheretsa Israeli kukhala ndi mphamvu yolimbana ndi chiwopsezo cha chitetezo" ndikulola Hamas kuchita nkhanza zina. Zoterezi za ICJ, akuti, zingathandize Hamas. Ananenanso kuti malamulo omwe dziko la South Africa adapempha adapangidwa mozama kwambiri ndipo, ngati atatsatiridwa ndi khothi lapadziko lonse lapansi, alepheretsa ntchito za Israeli kumadera aku Palestine kupatula Gaza. Ananena izi ngati kuti Israeli ikuteteza kalabu ya ku West Bank kwa achifwamba ndi owononga m'malo motsogolera boma losaloledwa la tsankho komwe anthu aku Palestine amakumana ndi zovuta zosiyana ndi zomwe zidapezeka ku South Africa zaka makumi angapo zapitazo.
Staker adanenanso kuti pempho la South Africa kuti khoti lilamulire Israeli kuti asunge umboni wa milandu yomwe ingachitike palibe umboni ndipo palibe umboni wosonyeza kuti Israeli akuwononga umboni ku Gaza. Iye anati lamulo loterolo lidzakhala โkuipitsa mbiri [ya Israyeli] mopanda mfundo ndi mosayenera.โ Staker angafune kuyang'ana mndandanda wa malaibulale aku Palestine, zosungira zakale, malo azikhalidwe, zipilala, mipingo yakale, ndi mizikiti yomwe Israeli adawononga. Osatchulanso za akatswiri amaphunziro, olemba ndakatulo, osimba nthano, ndi olemba mbiri mphamvu zake zafafanizidwa padziko lapansi.
Woimira Israeli Gilad Noam adatseka chitetezo cha boma lake ponena kuti dziko la South Africa likuwonetsa Israeli ngati "dziko losayeruzika lomwe limadziona ngati lopitirira komanso loposa lamulo. . . . kumene anthu onseโ โathedwa nzeru ndi kuwononga anthu onse.โ Izi zinali zochititsa chidwi chifukwa zidayimira zolondola zomwe South Africa idatsutsa pofotokoza zake. Zoonadi, Nowa anatsimikizira khotilo kuti khalidweli linali โlabodza.โ
South Africa, Noam anati, "sikunyozetsa utsogoleri wa Israeli komanso anthu [a Israeli]." Pobwerera ku zomwe akuluakulu a Israeli adanena kuti maloya aku South Africa adanena kuti ndi umboni wofuna kupha fuko, Noam adanena kuti ena mwa mawu "ankhanza" a atsogoleri a Israeli anali poyankha "kuwonongedwa kwa Ayuda ndi Israeli." Ananenanso kuti makhothi a ku Israel amaona zolimbikitsa kwambiri ndipo pano akufufuza milandu yotereyi.
Noam anadzudzula dziko la South Africa kuti likuchita โntchito yogwirizana komanso yonyozera kupotoza mawu akuti โkupulula fukoโ lenilenilo. Adapempha oweruza kuti akane zopempha kuti aletse kuyimitsa ntchito zankhondo za Israeli ku Gaza ndikuchotsa mlandu wa South Africa kwathunthu. Purezidenti wa khotilo, Jaji Joan Donoghue wa ku United States, anaimitsa mlanduwo ponena kuti oweruza agamula mwamsanga.
M'mawu ake kukhothi, Israeli sananenepo zotsutsana ndi zomwe amachita ku Gaza kuti iwo - ndi othandizira ake muulamuliro wa Biden pankhaniyi - sananene mobwerezabwereza m'miyezi itatu yapitayi ngati gawo la kampeni yawo yofalitsa nkhani zabodza. lungamitsa zosayenera. Tsiku lililonse likadutsa, anthu ambiri aku Palestine adzafera m'manja mwa zida zankhondo zaku US zothamangitsidwa ndi asitikali aku Israeli ndipo zovuta zomwe zathandiza anthu zidzaipiraipira. Ngati khoti lingatenge mbali ya Israeli ndikukana zonena za South Africa, Israeli iwonetsa kuti ndi umboni wa chilungamo chake. Ngati oweruza avomereza pempho la dziko la South Africa loti aletse kuukira kwa asilikali a Israeli, funso lidzafunsidwa ngati Israeli ndi othandizira ake ku Washington, D.C., adzalemekeza malamulo a mayiko. Ngati mbiri ikupereka chidziwitso chilichonse pankhaniyi, tsogolo likadali loyipa kwa ma Palestine aku Gaza.
ZNetwork imalandira ndalama kudzera mu kuwolowa manja kwa owerenga ake.
Ndalama