Pa Disembala 7, 2009, wolemba mabulogu Suzi Gablik wa Virgil Speaks adadziwitsa dziko lapansi kuti ali "osatinso womasuka". Anasiya zomwe amadzitcha kuti "zaufulu" poyankha kudzudzula kwa Obama ndi mfundo zake "mbali zonse (mapiko a kumanja ndi kumanzere)", makamaka zolankhula zake ku Afghanistan komwe adalonjeza ndalama zowonjezera komanso kutumiza magulu ankhondo ambiri. Makamaka, Suzi adakwiya kwambiri nkhani yolembedwa ndi Christian Parenti wa Huffington Post zomwe zinati kufalikira kwa nkhondo ya Afghanistan sikunali kanthu koma chisankho cha ndale cholimbikitsa udindo wa Obama ndi "kuyang'ana molimba" kupita patsogolo. M'nkhani yomweyi, Parenti adatsutsanso zokonda zankhondo, zamakampani kapena zanthawi yayitali zomwe US โโingakhale nayo popitiliza nkhondo kapena kuukira Afghanistan poyambirira. Komabe, Mayi Gablik sanakhumudwe ndi kukana kwa Parenti zifukwa zambiri za nkhondo zomwe ziri zoonekeratu mopweteka kwa aliyense amene akhala akumvetsera moona mtima. M'malo mwake, "nkhani yoyipa kwambiri komanso yotukwana" idamupangitsa kunena kuti "Obama amakhala mwamantha otchedwa wimp ndi a Republican" komanso kuti "iye [Obama] ndi wokonzeka kupha kuti asinthidwenso".
Ndiye, Suzi adachita chiyani kuti athane ndi mapiko owopsa akumanzere ndi kumanja omwe amazunza kwambiri Obama wokondedwa wake, kupatula kulemba mabulogu za kusakhulupirira kwake? Anasiya kukhala waufulu ndikukhala "Taoist", zomwe amaziwona kukhala pafupi ndi machitidwe olamulira a Obama ndipo ali ndi chochita ndi "kulingalira mbali zonse za funso" ndi "kutsata] maphunziro awiri osiyana nthawi imodzi". Adapeza lingaliro kuchokera kwa Andrew Sullivan waku The Atlantic, yemwe anali ndi nkhani yosangalatsa yofananiza mawonekedwe a Obama ndi mphunzitsi wa nyani woyamba kugawira anyani ake makapu 3 a chestnut m'mawa ndi 4 masana, kenako akakhumudwa, kubweza zomwe apereka. ndi kuwalimbikitsa. "Ndipo ndine wokondwa kwambiri kukhala ndi purezidenti yemwe ali wolimba mtima komanso wofunitsitsa kuchita chimodzimodzi", adamaliza ntchito yake monyadira, pomaliza kumvetsetsa momwe Obama amagwirira ntchito komanso makapu angati a mgoza omwe azipeza tsiku lililonse. . (Zero.)
Zinapezeka kuti Suzi sanali yekha. Monga zolembedwa ndi Andrew Sullivan panthawiyo (1, 2) ndipo adakambidwa ndi Glenn Greenwald mu chidutswa chozindikira, ambiri akuwoneka kuti akuganiza kuti "achoke kumanzere" kuti asonyeze kuipidwa ndi "kumanzere" kutsutsa kwa Obama ndi ndondomeko zake. Monga momwe Greenwald ananenera panthawiyo, "chochititsa chidwi kwambiri ponena za chitetezo champhamvu cha Obama ndi momwe iwo aliri opanda mfundo iliyonse ndi momwe, m'malo mwake, amakhudzidwira ndi malingaliro odabwitsa, ngakhale osayenera, omwe ali nawo." Inde, izi sizachilendo pankhani ya ndale zachipani. Chotsatira chomvetsa chisoni, komanso chomwe chikuyembekezeka, chotsatira cha "demokalase" yaku US ya zipani ziwiri komanso kampeni yayikulu yowukira yomwe imachirikiza (ndi zokonda zake) ndikukakamiza anthu kusankha mbali ndikuganiza mozama za kumanzere / kumanja. kapena zomanga za Democrat / Republican - malire ake amafotokozedwa mozama kwambiri ndi malo omwe ali ndi chidwi chowongolera mkangano, monga adatchulidwa pafupipafupi ndi Noam Chomsky.
Chani is Chatsopano apa, ndi kuchuluka kwa chisokonezo ndi mikangano yamkati yomwe anthu akukumana nayo chifukwa cha chiyembekezo chomwe Obama adachiyika kuti chikuphwanyidwa momveka bwino ndi zotsutsa za ndondomeko ndi zochita zake, makamaka pamene zonyansazo zimachokera kumbali yomweyo ( kumanzere) zomwe, m'malingaliro awo, ziyenera kukhala kuthandizira Obama. M'malo moulula kusasamala komanso kudzikonda kopanda malire kwa Obama ndi omuthandizira ake - palibe amene anali ndi ufulu wopereka chiyembekezo chamtunduwu kwa aliyense amene amachifuna poyambirira - kwa anthu ngati Suzi, zotsutsa "zotsalira" zotere. za Purezidenti wawo wokondedwa sizili kanthu koma kusakhulupirika kosokoneza. Komabe, mukaphatikiza kudodometsedwa kwa omwe ali ngati Suzi ndi zolankhula zaufulu zochokera kwa omwe amakonda Sullivan ndi Parenti, zomwe zikuwonekera ndi ming'alu yakusamvana komwe kukupitilira a Obama (komanso mokulira, chipani cha Democratic) ndi onse "kumanzere. โ ndi tanthauzo lililonse loyenerera la umphumphu wa makhalidwe abwino. M'malo mwake, zomwe tikuwona pano ndi mtundu wa kusagwirizana kwachidziwitso (m'mawu ogula, "kudandaula kwa wogula") zomwe zingapangitse kukana "kuwombola", monga momwe Suzi adachitira, kapena Obama ndi ndondomeko zake, zonse. (Chachitatu, chotheka chocheperako, chingakhale kuvomereza kufunikira kwa kukanidwa kwa dongosolo lonse lamakampani-kapitalisti palokha.)
Ndikofunika kuzindikira apa kuti kulimbana ndi ufulu waufulu kapena Obama m'lingaliro limeneli, monga Greenwald amanenera, makamaka kudzakhala chifukwa cha "chidziwitso cha chikhalidwe ndi kuyamikira umunthu ndipo sikukugwirizana ndi zifukwa zomwe ziyenera kugwiritsidwa ntchito kuweruza atsogoleri a ndale. .โ Pamapeto pake, mikangano yomwe ilipo idzasungidwa ndipo pang'ono sungapindule potengera zovuta zamagulu akuluakulu amphamvu kapena kupititsa patsogolo zokambirana zapagulu pazochita zomwe ayenera kutengedwera pamitundu yosiyanasiyana ya zolephera za Obama, kuyambira pankhondo kupita ku chithandizo chamankhwala mpaka kulamulira mumakampani azachuma kupita ku chithandizo chamagulu, ndi zina. Ntchito, ndiye, ndikupeza njira yolumikizirana ndi omwe akusokonekera kale pa Obama poyera, moona mtima. kukambirana, osati pa nkhani zomwe zili pafupi, komanso za, makamaka, ndi dziko lotani lomwe tonse tikufuna kukhalamo - ndikubweretsa mkangano woterewu poyera, kuti tikhazikitse zokambirana zenizeni ndi kusagwirizana pagulu. Monga momwe anthu ambiri amakhala ndi zofanana kwambiri ndi Suzi kuposa Sullivan kapena Parenti - okhudzidwa ndi kupwetekedwa mtima ndi kufunafuna mayankho m'malo modzitukumula, osakhudzidwa komanso odzimva, atataya mtundu uliwonse wa makhalidwe kapena nzeru. kukhulupirika kalekale - pali chiyembekezo chenicheni cha izi.
Zina mwa izo, ndikuganiza, zikuphatikizapo kumuuza Suzi kuti si vuto lake kuti zinthu zili momwe zilili, posatengera momwe adavotera, ndipo mwatsoka, Obama sakufuna kumukonzera chilichonse, koma akhoza kusintha zinthu. kwabwino ngati akufuna. Ayeneranso kudziwa kuti pali anthu enanso mamiliyoni ambiri amene angakhale osangalala komanso ofunitsitsa kumuthandiza. Chowonadi ndi chakuti, Obama ndi aliyense onga iye, womasuka komanso wokonda kusamala, onse kukhala ma capitalist amtundu woyipa kwambiri, amangodziganizira okha komanso chuma chawo, mphamvu ndi udindo wawo kuposa china chilichonse. Pomwe iwo ali ndi kugawana chuma mopambanitsa ndi mphamvu kumbali yawo, nthawi zonse tidzakhala ndi manambala athu.
ZNetwork imalandira ndalama kudzera mu kuwolowa manja kwa owerenga ake.
Ndalama