Funso la Khalidwe: Noam Chomsky motsutsana ndi otsutsa ake
Nthawi ina yapitayo ndidayika cholembera chabulogu pa Noam Chomsky komanso pafunso lomuteteza. Ngakhale ndimafunitsitsa ndipo ndikufunabe kumupatsa Chomsky mwayi wokayikira ndikungoganiza kuti omwe amamutsutsa akulakwitsa kapena, choyipa, adamuneneza ndikumunyoza kuti asindikize, zina mwazotsutsa zomwe ndawerenga za Dr. Chomsky zasokoneza kwambiri. ine ndikundisiya ndili ndi maganizo. Chimodzi mwazinthu zomwe ndatchula mu positi yanga chinali Anti-Chomsky Reader ndi magwero ena otsutsa Chomsky. Ndinatchulanso blog ya Oliver Kamm komanso kusinthana pakati pa Chomsky ndi Arthur Schlesinger Jr. M'malo mongoganizira za mkangano pakati pa Chomsky ndi Schlesinger apa (omwe angakhale mutu wa positi ina ya blog, kukhala yayitali kwambiri) ndikufuna kuyang'ana pa milandu ingapo yakusakhulupirika pazigawo za Chomsky. Ndikufuna kudziwa chomwe chiri cholakwika ndi zodzudzula zomwe ndilemba pano. Onsewa atengedwa kuchokera ku blog ya Oliver Kamm (Ndinasankha dala kuchokera kwa munthu wodzitcha kuti ndi womasuka m'malo motsutsa Chomsky wokonda ndale).
Kodi zotsutsa izi za Chomsky ndi ziti? Chimodzi ndi chakuti Chomsky adasokoneza mopanda chilungamo udindo wa Samuel Huntington. China ndi chakuti Chomsky adasokoneza mwadala mawu a kazembe wakale Daniel Patrick Moynihan. Oliver Kamm adamunamizira Chomsky kuti asokoneza china chake iye analemba m'mawu ake oyipa a Chomsky ngati woyimira pagulu lanzeru za anthu. Pambuyo pokambirana zitsanzo izi, ndikufuna kupita ku zotsutsa zenizeni zomwe zalembedwa mu Anti-Chomsky Reader.
Yoyamba: Chomsky sanaimirire
"M'gawo la ndime zitatu zazifupi m'magazini yanu ya Januware 1, Noam Chomsky amatha kusokoneza chowonadi m'njira zosiyanasiyana potengera malingaliro ndi zochita zanga pa.
"Polemba m'mayiko akunja, iye [Huntington] akufotokoza kuti Viet Cong ndi 'mphamvu yamphamvu yomwe siingathe kuchotsedwa m'dera lake pokhapokha ngati chigawocho chikupitirizabe kukhalapo.' Titha kuwonetsetsa kuti chigawochi chisiya kukhalapo mwa 'kugwiritsa ntchito mwachindunji mphamvu zamakina ndi wambaโฆpamlingo waukulu kotero kuti anthu ambiri asamuka kuchoka kumidzi kupita kumizindaโฆ.' "
"Zingakhale zovuta kuganiza za kusaona mtima kwachiwonekere posankha mawu kuchokera m'nkhani yake kuti apereke tanthauzo losiyana ndi limene wolembayo ananena. Kuti mupindule ndi owerenga anu, apa pali "mapeto oonekera" Ndidatengera mawu anga okhudza Viet Cong:
"...dziko la Viet Cong likhalabe lamphamvu kwambiri lomwe silingachotsedwe m'chigawo chake malinga ngati chigawochi chidakalipo. Mtendere posachedwapa uyenera kukhazikitsidwa pa malo ogona."
"Pochotsa chiganizo changa chotsatira-" Mtendere wa m'tsogolomu uyenera kukhala wokhazikika pa malo ogona "-ndi kugwirizanitsa mawu anga okhudza Viet Cong ndi mawu ena awiri omwe akuwonekera kumayambiriro kwa nkhaniyi, a Chomsky anasintha maganizo anga."
Pounikanso nkhani iyi yochokera
"
Ndangochita izi ndikuwerenga yankho la Chomsky
"Ananenanso kuti a Viet Cong ndi "mphamvu yamphamvu yomwe singathe kuchotsedwa m'dera lake malinga ngati chigawochi chikupitirizabe kukhalapo."
"Mawuwa mosakayikira ndi olondola ndipo, monga ndidalembera, akupereka kufotokozera mwachidule za njira za America. Popeza Viet Cong ndi gulu lamphamvu lomwe silingathe kuchotsedwa m'madera ake malinga ngati chigawochi chikupitirizabe kukhalapo, tapita kunkhondo. mphamvu, zomwe zimapangitsa kuti anthu akumidzi asamuke kupita kumisasa ya anthu othawa kwawo komanso madera akumidzi komwe, akuyembekezeka, chigawo cha Viet Cong chikhoza kuyendetsedwa bwino.
"Ndinanenanso kuti Bambo Huntington "sakubwerera" ku mfundo izi. Ndemangayi ikanalimbikitsidwa. Choncho akunena kuti "kukakamiza mizinda ndi zamakono," kalembedwe ka Vietnam, kungakhale " Yankho" ponseponse ku zigawenga za anthu wamba. Ndipotu iye sakudandaula, kapena kuweruza m'pang'onong'ono pomwe pa njira zoterezi (zomwe zimakhudzanso "milandu yankhondo" monga momwe imafotokozera Nuremberg Principle VI, mwachitsanzo). zonenedwa ndi akatswiri awiri otsutsana ndi otsutsa mu Zachilendo, October, 1969: โNkhani zonse [zolimbana ndi zigaลตenga] nโzothandiza ndipo nโzosaloลตerera mโlingaliro la makhalidwe monga mmene malamulo a sayansi amachitira.โ Choncho
Koma bwanji
"Bambo Huntington akunenanso kuti ndinanena kuti "akufuna" kuthetsa chigawo cha Viet Cong ndi mabomba, pamene amangonena kuti "kukula kwa mizinda mokakamizidwa" koteroko kungakhale "yankho ku 'nkhondo zomasula dziko'" zomwe tapunthwa. ku Vietnam. Kusiyanitsa kuli bwino. Munthu amene amaumirira ayenera kuzindikiranso kuti sindinanene kuti โanakondaโ yankho limeneli koma kuti โanalifotokoza,โ โanalifotokozaโ ndiponso โsachileka,โ zonsezi nโzoonadi.."
Wotsutsa Chomsky angayankhe kuti Chomsky sanayenera kunena zimenezo
If
Mlandu 2: Chomsky Adawonetsa molakwika udindo wa Daniel Patrick Moynihan.
Kamm akutsutsa kuti Chomsky sanafotokoze molakwika mawu ochokera kwa Daniel Patrick Moynihan m'buku lake Chibadwidwe Chatsopano Chimayandikira: Kosovo,
"Mfundo zotsogola zidamveka bwino kuyambira pachiyambi ndi omwe ali ndi udindo wotsimikizira kupambana kwa
"The
Moynihan anatchula malipoti akuti mโmiyezi iลตiri anthu pafupifupi 60,000 anaphedwa, โ10 peresenti ya anthu, pafupifupi chiลตerengero cha ovulazidwa ndi Soviet Union mโNkhondo Yadziko Yachiลตiri.โ Chizindikiro cha chipambano. , akuwonjezera kuti, mkati mwa chaka chimodzi "nkhaniyo inasowa m'manyuzipepala."
Kamm akupitiriza kutchula ndime yeniyeni yomwe Moynihan adalembapo mawu omwe ali pamwambawa omwe Chomsky adanena:
"[S] uch inali mphamvu ya lingaliro lotsutsana ndi atsamunda lakuti maulamuliro akuluakulu ochokera kunja kwa dera anali ndi mphamvu zochepa pokhapokha ngati anali okonzeka kugwiritsa ntchito mphamvu.
Kamm anagwira mawu Chomsky, kachiwiri, nthawi ino kuchokera m'buku lake Mbiri ya Kusamvana:
โPonena za kuukira kwa dziko la Indonesia ku East Timor, [Moynihan] ananena kuti dziko la United States linkafuna kuti zinthu ziwayendere bwino ndipo anali ndi udindo woonetsetsa kuti bungwe la United Nations silingathe kuchita zinthu mwanzeru pothetsa kapena kusintha zinthu. Iye anagwira ntchitoyi mwachipambano, ndipo mโchiganizo chotsatira akupitiriza kunena kuti akudziwa mmene zinthu zinalili bwino. 10 peresenti ya anthu mu
Kamm anayankha kuti: "Chabwino, ndili ndi bukhu la Moynihan lotsegulidwa patsogolo panga. Chiganizo pambuyo pa mawu akuti "ndinachipititsa patsogolo popanda kupambana kosawerengeka" chimawerengedwa mokwanira:
"N'zovuta kunena nthawi yeniyeni
"
Ngati Kamm akulakwitsa ndipo Chomsky adawongolera mawu a Moynihan, bwanji?
Zotsutsa Zachitatu: Chomsky pa "Denazification"
Oliver Kamm akuwoneka kuti akutsutsa kwambiri Magazini ya Prospect kuganiziridwa kwa Chomsky monga katswiri wamaphunziro apamwamba padziko lonse lapansi mu November 2005. Polemba motsutsana ndi Chomsky, Kamm analemba izi:
"Buku loyamba la Chomsky la ndale, American Power and the New Mandarins (1969) lidakula kuchokera ku ziwonetsero zotsutsana ndi nkhondo ya Vietnam. Koma Chomsky adapitilira kutsutsa kumanzere kwa imperialism yaku US kuti akhulupirire kuti "chofunikira
Comsky anayankha kuti:
"Kupitiliza kuwonetsa chiphunzitso changa "chapakati", Kamm amalakwitsa mawu anga akuti "Tiyenera kudzifunsa tokha ngati zomwe zikufunika
Kamm anayankha kuti:
"Kwazaka 40, Noam Chomsky (Januwale) adadzudzula amuna ambiri olemekezeka kuposa ine "kuvomereza mwachibwanawewe milandu yowopsa." Chochititsa chidwi kwambiri chikanakhala chitetezo cha kupotoza kwake. Timangopeza kubwereza. Nkhani ya Chomsky ya ndemanga za Daniel Patrick Moynihan pa
"I adatchulidwa (November) kuti kuchokera m'zolemba zake zoyambirira Chomsky "adapitilira kutsutsa kumanzere kwa imperialism ya US kupita ku chikhulupiriro chakuti 'chofunikira [mu
"Mawu athunthu akuthamanga: "Tiyenera kudzifunsa tokha ngati zomwe zikufunika mu
Ndikuvutika kumvetsetsa apa momwe Kamm akulakwitsa pa zonsezi. Kamm walakwa bwanji? Makamaka pankhani ya kusinthana uku pa "denazification" ya
Ichi ndichifukwa chake ndabwera kudzakayikira khalidwe la Chomsky ndikufuna kumupatsa mwayi wokayika. Kamm si kuthyolako kolondola, koma, kachiwiri, ngakhale Schlesinger sanali. Ndi zonena za kusaona mtima izi zomwe zimandidetsa nkhawa ndipo, moona mtima- sindikudziwa momwe ndingachitire nazo. Ine sindine munthu amene amakana mwachimbulimbuli zonena ngati izi chifukwa Chomsky amandiuza zomwe ndikufuna kumva. Ndine wokonzeka kumvera otsutsa kwambiri a udindo uliwonse, kwenikweni. Ndiye ndimafuna ndifunse kuti chavuta ndi chani pazimenezi? Kodi anthu monga Kamm, Huntington, ndi ena amene ayankha Chomsky amaphonya kuti, titero kunena kwake?
Matthew
ZNetwork imalandira ndalama kudzera mu kuwolowa manja kwa owerenga ake.
Ndalama