Source: FAIR
Koj puas tau hnov xov xwm? Thawj Tswj Hwm ntawm Democratic Frontrunner Bernie Sanders yog antisemitic. Yog, yog, nws yog neeg Yudais, thiab muaj ib tug keeb kwm ntev ntawm kev tawm tsam kev ntxub ntxaug lwm haiv neeg - tab sis qhov ntawd tsis muaj teeb meem.
Yog li mus rau zaj dab neeg hauv ntau lub xov xwm tseem ceeb tshaj tawm, uas tau liam tias nws ua "kev tawm tsam ntau tshaj plaws [kev tawm tsam] hauv kaum xyoo" (Washington Examiner, 12/13/19). Thaum tsis tuaj yeem taw tes rau Sanders 'tus kheej ua lossis cov lus, cov xov xwm hauv tebchaws tau cuam tshuam nws nrog kev ntxub ntxaug cov neeg Yudais los ntawm kev tawm tsam cov neeg nyob ib puag ncig nws. Thoob plaws xyoo 2019, piv txwv li, Sanders tus neeg txhawb nqa Rep. Ilhan Omar yog tas li sau npe antisemitic thoob plaws hauv xov xwm rau cov lus nws tau hais txog kev cuam tshuam tsis zoo ntawm US / Israeli lobbying pab pawg AIPAC ntawm Asmeskas kev nom kev tswv (xws li, New York Times, 3/7/19; Phab ntsa Street Journal, 7/12/19; Washington Post, 8/20/19).
Hma liab xov xwm (1/9/20) tau thov Sanders yuav yog "tus thawj tswj hwm tawm tsam Israel" tshaj plaws, ua rau muaj kev thuam ntawm cov neeg Ixayees thiab / lossis Netanyahu cov thawj coj nrog kev tawm tsam:
Nws yog kev txaj muag uas tsis yog kev sawv ntsug, tsis txhob siv lub sijhawm no los hloov tib neeg lub siab txog kev phom sij ntawm kev tawm tsam, Sanders ua rau thiab pom zoo rau kev tawm tsam Zionist rhetoric ntawm nws lub hauv paus.
cov National Review (12/17/19) tau thov tias "tus yam ntxwv tsis zoo" ntawm Bernie txoj kev sib tw, "twb ua rau cov neeg Yudais tawm tsam kev tawm tsam," yog "qhov txaus ntshai." Lus tawm (12/13/19) pom zoo, thov Sanders yog "thov" cov antisemitic "indulgences" ntawm nws cov thwjtim. Qee lub sij hawm, kev saib xyuas cov chaw muag khoom zoo li tab tom sim rov ua qhov kev vam meej uas cov xov xwm Askiv tau muaj nyob rau hauv tarring Labor tus thawj coj Jeremy Corbyn raws li ib tug antisemite - ib tug smear uas yeej ua rau nws txiav txim siab 2019 poob (FAIR.org, 12/21/19).
Antisemitism yeej muaj nyob rau hauv lub tebchaws United States; tus naj npawb ntawm cov xwm txheej sau tseg los ntawm Lub Koom Haum Tiv Thaiv Kev Ua Phem Txhaum Cai tau nce mus txog ib qho txhua lub sijhawm zoo. Thaum Lub Kaum Hli 2018 ib tus neeg tua phom tiv thaiv neeg tsiv teb tsaws chaw tawm tsam tsob ntoo ntawm lub neej lub tsev teev ntuj nyob rau hauv Pittsburgh, tua 11. Thaum lub Plaub Hlis Ntuj thaum Passover, ib tug dawb nationalist qhib hluav taws ntawm Poway Synagogue ze San Diego. Thiab lub hli tas los, tus neeg tua neeg nkaug tsib tus neeg ua kev zoo siab Hanukkah hauv Monsey, New York. Ntau qhov kev ua phem phem tshaj plaws tau ua txhaum los ntawm txoj cai sab nraud, uas, xyoo 2017, tau coj mus rau zoo tshaj tawm Kev sib tw hauv Charlottesville, Virginia chanting, "Cov neeg Yudais yuav tsis hloov peb" - thiab tom qab ntawd Thawj Tswj Hwm Donald Trump piav qhia cov marchers li "cov neeg zoo heev."
Trump tau nquag evoked antisemitic tropes zoo li qhov kev iab liam ntawm ob lub siab ncaj ncees, qhia Asmeskas cov neeg Yudais tias Netanyahu yog "koj tus thawj tswj hwm" thiab Israel "koj lub teb chaws," thiab piav txog cov neeg Yudais uas pov npav Democrat li "tsis ncaj ncees"rau Asmeskas thiab Israel.
Trump, leej twg ib zaug hais tias nws tsuas xav tau "cov txiv neej luv luv hnav yarmulkes" los suav nws cov nyiaj ntsuab, tau rov hais dua qhov kev xav uas cov neeg Yudais nyiam tsuas yog nyiaj. Hauv 2015, nws hais rau ib pab pawg neeg Yudais Republicans (Txoj Kev Muaj Tseeb Clear, 12/3/15), “Koj yuav tsis txhawb kuv vim kuv tsis xav tau koj cov nyiaj…. Koj xav tswj koj tus kheej cov nom tswv. " Txhawm rau mus nrog cov neeg Yudais ua tus saib xyuas menyuam roj hmab, Trump tau cuam tshuam rau cov neeg Yudais uas xav tsis thoob:
Puas muaj leej twg hauv chav no uas tsis rov sib tham dua? Tej zaum 99% ntawm koj. Tej zaum ntau tshaj li txhua chav kuv tau hais hauv…. Kuv yog ib tug neeg sib tham, zoo li koj cov neeg.
Lub hli dhau los (CNN, 12/9/19), Trump tau hais rau cov neeg Yudais coob coob ntawm Israeli American Council National Summit tias lawv yog "cov neeg tua neeg phem, tsis yog cov neeg zoo" -vim "ntau ntawm koj nyob hauv kev lag luam vaj tsev." Tab sis, nws hais ntxiv tias, "Koj yuav tsum pov npav rau kuv, koj tsis muaj kev xaiv," nws hais tias, "koj yuav tsis mus pov npav rau cov se nplua nuj" - txhais tau hais tias cov neeg Yudais tsuas saib xyuas lawv tus kheej cov nyiaj txiag: "Koj" rov yuav yog kuv cov neeg txhawb nqa loj tshaj plaws vim tias koj yuav tawm ntawm kev lag luam li 15 feeb yog tias lawv tau txais. "
Txhawb cov Tropes
Thaum media nthuav tawm kev txhawj xeeb hais txog kev siv cov tshuaj tiv thaiv kab mob los ntawm sab laug, lawv zoo li oblivious tias lawv tus kheej kev sib tham ntawm Sanders phiaj los nqis tes yuav ua rau lawv. Ib qho piv txwv uas tshwm sim ntau zaus hauv Sanders profile yog koom nrog Vermont senator nrog Phau Qub, dab tsi cov ntseeg hu ua cov neeg Yudais cov vaj lug kub dawb huv. Cov Washington Post (8/29/19) tau thov tias Sanders yog "cov ntsiab lus rau xob quaj tawm tsam cov neeg phem zoo li tus yaj saub Phau Qub," thaum New York Times (8/2/19) tau piav txog nws li "qhov muag qus, scowling thiab npau taws li ib tug yaj saub Phau Qub nyob rau ntawm downside ntawm kev twv ua ntej racket." Cov Detroit News (7/30/19) tau sau tias Sanders "tshem tawm raws li Phau Qub tus yaj saub ntawm kev puas tsuaj, kev mob siab rau qw ntawm lub roob tsis muaj zog."
Rau qee qhov laj thawj, qhov piv txwv tshwj xeeb no los rau hauv lub siab ntawm ntau tus neeg sau xov xwm npog Sanders: piv txwv li, Washington Post, 9/24/19; Newsday, 9/17/19; London Independent, 1/24/16; Tshiab Yorker, 10/5/15; Bulwark, 1/8/20). Cov Tshiab Yorker (10/19/19) tau sau tias Bernie lub suab yog "qhov sib npaug qub Brooklyn yawg thiab tus Xib Hwb Phau Qub," tswj kom nyem ob lub ntsiab lus rau hauv ib kab lus.
Cov xov xwm hauv tuam txhab kuj tau ua qee qhov kev xaiv cov duab tsis txaus ntseeg thaum tham txog Sanders. Ntau tus kws kos duab kos duab tau xaiv los ua lub qhov ntswg sib txuas - tseem ceeb hauv kev tawm tsam cov neeg Yudais stereotypes, tsis yog qhov tseem ceeb ntawm Sanders lub ntsej muag tiag tiag - lub cim ntawm lawv cov duab kos ntawm tus neeg sib tw.
Ntau lub khw muag khoom muaj cov duab tshwj xeeb uas muaj qhov sib txawv zoo ib yam li "zoo siab tub lag luam" meme, ib txwm muaj alt-txoj cai duab condemned los ntawm ob lub Yav Qab Teb Pej Thuam Kev Cai Txom Nyem thiab cov Cov Kev Sib Koom Tes Pov Thaiv raws li lub cim ntxub thiab piav qhia los ntawm Buzzfeed Xov xwm (2/5/15) raws li "Internet nyiam cov duab antisemitic."
Ntawm cov xov xwm uas nws txoj kev sib tw tau coj mus rau ntau dua $ 34 lab hauv lub quarter thib plaub ntawm 2019, lub Huffington Post (1/2/20) thiab a tooj of NPR Cov koom tes txiav txim siab los piav qhia lawv cov dab neeg nrog cov duab ntawm Sanders rub nws txhais tes ua ke thiab luag ntxhi. Nyob rau hauv cov ntaub ntawv koj xav tias lub symbolism yog xwm txheej, lub Washington Post (1/2/20) hais txog tib zaj dab neeg hais txog ib tug neeg Yudais uas muaj hmoov zoo nrog ib tug txawv duab ntawm Sanders rubbing nws txhais tes nyob rau hauv zoo siab ua lag luam style, hloov nws tsuas yog tom qab ib tug pej xeem tawm tsam.
Kev xyaum tsis txwv rau Sanders, txawm li cas los xij. Ntawm zaj dab neeg ntawm cov tub ntxhais kawm tshiab New York cov koom txoos thiab Sanders tus txhawb nqa Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez qhia cov neeg Yudais caj ces nyob deb ntawm qhov kev tshwm sim Hanukkah, ob qho tib si Teb chaws USA no (12/11/18) thiab Hma liab xov xwm (12/12/18) siv cov duab ntawm nws tuav nws txhais tes ua ke zoo ib yam li Sanders.
Ocasio-Cortez tau hu tawm cov xov xwm ntawm cov yeeb yaj kiab antisemitic ua ntej. Nws coj Politico (5/24/19) ua haujlwm Twitter (5/25/19) rau photoshopping nyiaj ntoo rau ib daim duab ntawm Sanders. Cov kab lus nws tau piav qhia tau hais tias "Lub Secret of Bernie's Millions," Politico qhia nws nrog cov lus: "Sanders tseem yuav pheej yig, tab sis nws paub tseeb tias tsis yog neeg pluag." Hav! Vim li cas kuv tus dev dheev npau taws?!
Cov xov xwm rhiab heev rau kev tawm tsam kom lawv pom tau lo lus "bedbug" raws li kev tawm tsam cov neeg Yudais trope (raws li New York Times'Bret Stephens puas tau) tsis tuaj yeem lees paub qhov tsis paub ntawm txhua tus aub antisemitic xuav nws yog tshuab hais txog Sanders.
Cov tuam txhab xov xwm kuj tau ua nws txoj haujlwm hauv kev ua kom muaj txoj cai nyob deb, muab cov duab ci ntsa iab ntawm cov neeg Asmeskas fascists tseem ceeb (FAIR.org, 11/23/16, 11/1/19). Tseeb tiag, tus kws sau ntawv Washington Examiner tsab xov xwm hais txog thaum pib ntawm tsab xov xwm no, txhawj xeeb tias Sanders tab tom nqa nrog nws lub sijhawm ntawm kev tawm tsam kev ntseeg, nws tus kheej yog phooj ywg ntawm txoj cai tawm tsam kev cai dab qhuas Milo Yiannopoulos, uas nws hu ua "txaus, ”Thiab tsis tu ncua khav ntawm nws txoj kev khav theeb ntawm nws yawg Nazi-coj tus yawg, uas nws lub koom haum tau koom nrog Holocaust uas tua Sanders cov txheeb ze ze.
Media motives tshwm sim tsis tshua muaj kev txhawj xeeb txog kev tawm tsam cov neeg Yudais kev xav thiab ntau ntxiv txog riam phom smears tawm tsam kev sib tw ua kom muaj zog ntawm cov neeg muaj nyiaj txiag - thiab ntau tus neeg lees paub - cov neeg tseem ceeb uas yog tus tswv thiab tswj hwm lub tuam txhab xov xwm. Yog tias cov xov xwm xav tham txog qhov tshwm sim tiag tiag ntawm kev tawm tsam, lawv yuav tsum pib los ntawm kev saib lawv tus kheej.
ZNetwork tau txais nyiaj tsuas yog los ntawm kev ua siab zoo ntawm nws cov neeg nyeem.
Pab Nyiaj