Muaj ib yam dab tsi ua rau muaj kev lees paub zoo txog cov tuam txhab xov xwm tirades tawm tsam Sab laug hauv cov ntsiab lus ntawm Sab laug qhov kev tawm tsam rau Is Nrias teb txoj kev cog lus nuclear nrog Asmeskas - Sab laug yuav tsum ua qee yam yog. Thiab mus los ntawm lub shrillness ntawm kev tawm tsam, nws tsoo qhov twg nws mob.
Saib tsuas yog ib daim ntawv xov xwm, Hindustan Times, nyob rau plaub hnub dhau los. Thaum Lub Yim Hli 16, CNN-IBN's Rajdeep Sardesai tau sau rau sab laug qhov kev tawm tsam rau kev cog lus nuclear. (http://www.hindustantimes.com/StoryPage/StoryPage.aspx?id=847b5aea-11f2-43fe-b221-67323df41c3d&ParentID=671f1d5e-8fad-4cc1-9e4e-65f5eefb9cad) siv los tsoo sab laug, tshwj xeeb tshaj yog Prakash Karat, CPM's General Secretary. Sardesai los rau qhov kev pom zoo nws tus kheej hauv nqe lus kawg, tsuas yog qhia peb tias 'Qhov no tsis yog hais txog cov ntsiab lus ntawm 29 daim ntawv cog lus ntxiv lawm, tsis yog hais txog kev sib tham muaj zog ntawm lub teb chaws xav tau lub zog, qhov no tsuas yog tam sim no hais txog qhov tsis pom ' Kev phom sij' ntawm kev ua kom muaj kev sib raug zoo nrog kev sib raug zoo nrog 'Evil Empire' hauv Washington.' Txij li thaum Left ideologues tau 'siv lub neej pom lub ntiaj teb dhau los ntawm kev ua tsov ua rog Txias, kev tawg ntawm Soviet Union tsis tau txhais tias qhov kawg ntawm kev xav. .' Nws liam rau sab laug ntawm ib qho 'tsis kam loj hlob, kom paub tias thaum ib tus muaj txoj cai tawm tsam, qhov xwm txheej ntawm qhov kev tawm tsam tsis tuaj yeem yog qhov uas nws pib zoo li tus txiv neej lwj uas raug tsis lees paub tag nrho cov ncuav mog qab zib ntawm lub zog.'
Tsis yog ib lo lus hais txog vim li cas qhov kev cog lus nuclear yog qhov tseeb zoo rau Is Nrias teb.
Tsis yog yuav tsum tau outdone, Sardesai tus qub npoj yaig, Barkha Dutt ntawm NDTV 24 ร 7, pib mus rau sab laug nrog gusto nyob rau hauv nws tus kheej kem hnub tom qab. (http://www.hindustantimes.com/StoryPage/StoryPage.aspx?id=671f1d5e-8fad-4cc1-9e4e-65f5efb9c29e&&Headline=Left in a time warp) Txhua tus ib txwm tawm tsam sab laug clichรฉs muaj: cov thawj coj sab laug yog ' dour fim,' lawv suab zoo li 'Stalinists,' uas muaj 'tsoom fwv ntawm nws lub hauv caug, blackmailed mus rau hauv submission'. . 'Qhov teeb meem nrog Sab laug, . . . Qhov laj thawj rau niaj hnub Isdias tsis saib xyuas rau lawv, yog tias thaum lawv lub siab nyob rau hauv qhov chaw, lawv lub siab yog woefully tawm ntawm sync nrog peb lub siab nyiam.' Cov kev ntshaw no 'coj peb mus rau sab hnub poob.' Txawm tias 'peb yuav tawm tsam kev tsov rog hauv Iraq. thiab Afghanistan,' '(peb) yav tom ntej raws li cov neeg ua si thoob ntiaj teb txuas nrog Asmeskas npau suav,' vim '(peb) paub qhov txawv ntawm Bush thiab lub teb chaws nws kav.'
Qhov no ntxim hlub. Kuv tawm tsam kev tsov rog hauv Iraq thiab Afghanistan tab sis tsis txhob nug dab tsi ua rau tsov rog. Kuv paub qhov txawv ntawm Bush thiab lub teb chaws nws kav, yog vim li cas kuv cia siab rau cov thawj coj nws taub hau muab ib tug treaty uas muaj txiaj ntsim rau peb. Thiab, txij li peb lub neej yav tom ntej txuas nrog rau Asmeskas kev npau suav, kuv ntseeg siab tias cov neeg Amelikas yuav tsis thim rov qab rau qhov kev cog lus ntawd, hais txog kev cai lij choj hauv tebchaws.
Tsis xav tsis thoob, yog li ntawd, cov ntsiab lus ntawm 123 daim ntawv cog lus yog 'gobbledygook' rau nws.
Hnub tom qab, nws yog Vir Sanghvi tig. (http://www.hindustantimes.com/StoryPage/StoryPage.aspx?id=17e23240-f37f-460e-877b-61bca13067a5&&Headline=Dab tsi yog cov Communist mus txog %3f) Nws tau dhau los ua qhov yuav tsum tau ua kom pom cov duab ntawm sab laug thiab huv. kom lees paub tias cov thawj coj sab laug yog 'txiv neej - thiab poj niam - ntawm kev ncaj ncees thiab txoj hauv kev,' thiab Sanghvi kuj tseem xav tau: 'Nyob rau hauv ib puag ncig kev nom kev tswv uas tsuas yog nyiaj txiag thiab lub hwj chim nkaus xwb, sab laug sawv tawm raws li ib pawg neeg ntseeg. ideology thiab txoj cai. Muab lub Politburo nyob ib sab ntawm Pawg Neeg Ua Haujlwm Pabcuam lossis BJP National Executive thiab txawm tias menyuam yaus yuav tuaj yeem qhia qhov txawv ntawm kev txawj ntse, qhov siab thiab kev ncaj ncees.'
Muaj ib co loj Left-bashing ntawm no. Sanghvi slyly qhia tias 'CPI tsis ua lub luag haujlwm hauv kev tawm tsam kev ywj pheej;' tab sis tau kawg nws tsis tau hais nws, nws tsuas yog tshaj tawm 'txoj cai smear'. 'Joseph Stalin tua 20 lab tus tib neeg - tshaj peb zaug tus lej raug tua los ntawm Adolf Hitler's Nazis. Cov duab rau cov neeg tuag hauv Suav teb thaum CPM tab tom txhais Thawj Tswj Hwm Mao Phau Ntawv Liab Me rau hauv Bengali yog qhov nyuaj dua los ntawm, tab sis muaj tus lej ntawm 50 lab zoo li kev saib xyuas (ntau tus account hais tias nws yog 70 lab).' Qhov twg cov lej no tau los ntawm. yog obviously tsis muaj txim.
Sanghvi txoj kev quaj ntsuag yog tias 'thaum UPA tsoomfwv raug xaiv, Sab laug muaj lub sijhawm keeb kwm. . . kom rov thim nws tus kheej ua lub zog ywj pheej rau qhov zoo uas tau tawm tsam lub zog ntawm ntau haiv neeg, tawm tsam rau kev khaws cia ib puag ncig, thiab tiv thaiv cov cai ntawm tus kheej' - hauv lwm lo lus, tsis nco qab cov teeb meem hauv chav kawm, ua qhov muag tsis pom kev ntawm kev siv, ua namby-pamby ua-gooders - tab sis 'tu siab, Sab laug tau tshuab lub sijhawm keeb kwm no.'
Qhov ntawd yog qhov teeb meem. Prakash Karat thiab Sitaram Yechury taug kev zoo li peb, tham zoo li peb, vim li cas lub ntuj raug txim tsis tuaj yeem xav zoo li peb? Lawv yuav yog cov neeg zoo tiag tiag, koj paub, yog tias lawv tsis yog commies.
Thiab tom qab ntawd muaj cov lus tsis txaus ntseeg: nws tau liam tias 'UPA tau coj sab laug rau hauv kev ntseeg siab ua ntej kos npe rau daim ntawv cog lus,' thiab yog li ntawd sab laug txoj kev tawm tsam yog 'tsis muaj ntau tshaj li qhov kev xav ua nom tswv tom qab.'
Dab tsi sawv tawm hauv tag nrho cov tirades tawm tsam Sab laug yog, tau kawg, qhov tsis txaus siab los tham txog qhov teeb meem ntawm tes. Rau kuv lub siab, Hindu yog tib daim ntawv uas tau mus rau qhov tshwj xeeb ntawm qhov kev pom zoo, thiab taug qab nws dhau sijhawm. Saib, piv txwv li, Siddharth Varadarajan's piece ntawm Lub Yim Hli 20. (http://www.hindu.com/2007/08/20/stories/2007082058271500.htm) Thaum daim ntawv tau pom zoo 123 daim ntawv cog lus nws tus kheej editorially, nws tau tawm tswv yim tias Qhov kev pom zoo yuav raug tuav thaum tsoomfwv tau teem sijhawm 'kev sib tham ntawm txhua tog neeg, uas yuav tsum muaj kev tawm tsam, kev txhawj xeeb, kev tshwj tseg, thiab cov lus nug ntsig txog kev cog lus nuclear uas tau los ntawm txhua lub quarter loj.'
Tag nrho lwm tus, Hindustan Times, Lub Sijhawm ntawm Is Nrias teb, Indian Express, Pioneer, tag nrho cov ntawm lawv, tau hloov qhov kev cog lus nuclear rau hauv qhov Barkha Dutt tau piav qhia zoo li 'gobbledygook.'
Txij li thaum qhov kev pom zoo nws tus kheej yog 'gobbledygook,' Sab laug txoj kev tawm tsam yog qhov sib txawv raws li kev sib cav ntawm ego ntawm Prakash Karat thiab Manmohan Singh (uas yog txoj hauv kev zoo tshaj plaws ntawm kev tsis txaus ntseeg qhov teeb meem), raws li qhov muag tsis pom kev tawm tsam Asmeskas (tab sis tsis yog kev tawm tsam imperialism), los yog raws li kev ntxeev siab ntawm kev ntseeg siab (txawm tias peb yeej tsis tau qhia thaum twg raws nraim qhov Kev pom zoo ntawm Left qhov kev pom zoo tau txais tiag tiag).
Tom qab ntawd muaj lwm qhov bogey: Is Nrias teb lub zog ruaj ntseg. Sagarika Ghosh ntawm CNN-IBN muab lo lus nug rau CPM's Mohd. Salim nyob rau hauv TV nyob rau hmo ntuj ntawm lub yim hli ntuj 20 hais tias 'tsis muaj deal, tsis muaj bijli (hluav taws xob).' Salim nug nws ib lo lus nug yooj yim: peb yuav tau hluav taws xob ntau npaum li cas los ntawm qhov deal, thiab thaum twg? Ghosh nyob ntsiag to. Salim rov hais dua cov lus nug. Nyob ntsiag to. Thaum Salim pib teb nws tus kheej cov lus nug, Ghosh txiav nws tawm, nrog rau cov lus nug txog Left's 'anti-Americanism.' (Rau cov ntaub ntawv, nuclear zog txaus siab 3% ntawm Is Nrias teb lub zog xav tau tam sim no, uas xav tias yuav nce mus txog 7%. los ntawm 2020.) Thiab, thaum lub zog, vim li cas ho tsis muaj leej twg nug dab tsi yuav tshwm sim rau cov roj xa hluav taws xob los ntawm Iran?
Raws li rau sab laug qhov kev tawm tsam tiag tiag rau qhov kev pom zoo, thiab qhov laj thawj tom qab qhov kev tawm tsam, nws yeej tsis muaj. Yog li ntawd, koj hnov โโโโib lub suab ntawm kev raug mob exasperation - 'Dab tsi yog lub communist manifesto?', raws li Sanghvi lub npe.
Zoo, txhua yam lawv yuav tsum tau ua yog kom nco qab txog keeb kwm tsis ntev los no: Sab laug tau tawm tsam qhov kev pom zoo tsis tu ncua txij li xyoo 2005, thaum Indian Prime Minister thiab Asmeskas Thawj Tswj Hwm tau tshaj tawm lawv cov lus sib koom ua ke nto moo thaum Lub Xya Hli, uas nws tus kheej tuaj tom qab ntawm 10. -Xyoo Defence Framework Agreement. Sab laug tau rov hais dua ib zaug ntxiv tias qhov kev pom zoo nuclear yuav tsum tau pom nyob rau hauv cov ntsiab lus ntawm lub hom phiaj loj dua ntawm Teb Chaws Asmeskas, uas nws pom Is Nrias teb dhau los ua imperial loj tshaj plaws nyob rau hauv South Asia. Sab laug txoj kev tawm tsam hnyav tau yuam tus Thawj Kav Tebchaws los muab kev lees paub rau Indian Parliament raws nraim ib xyoos dhau los, thaum Lub Yim Hli 17, 2006. (Rau cov lus tsis txaus ntseeg ntawm Sab laug qhov kev tawm tsam, saib Prakash Karat tsab xov xwm, 'Vim li cas CPI (M) thiab cov Sab laug tawm tsam qhov kev cog lus nuclear,' muaj nyob ntawm http://www.hindu.com/2007/08/20/stories/2007082058071400.htm)
Ib tug yuav xav kom cov xov xwm thiab cov neeg tawm tswv yim los teb cov lus nug yooj yim rau sab laug: koj tau hais txog kev txaus siab ntawm tus Thawj Kav Tebchaws cov lus tshaj tawm hauv Parliament thaum Lub Yim Hli 2006, yog li koj xav li cas tam sim no 123 daim ntawv cog lus tsis txaus siab rau cov kev lees paub no?
Tab sis qhov no yog kev cia siab tsis muaj tseeb. Vim tias lub sijhawm koj nug cov lus nug no, koj lees tias Left txoj kev tawm tsam tsis tau tshwm sim tam sim ntawd, tawm ntawm huab cua nyias. Tseem ceeb tshaj, koj tsom ntsoov rau cov teeb meem.
Qhov ntawd yog qhov yooj yim kawg uas cov tuam txhab xov xwm xav tau. Txhua qhov kev thuam - lossis txawm hais txog - ntawm Asmeskas txoj haujlwm imperial yog qhov tsis muaj-tsis muaj.
Kev mloog lus rau tus tswv yog qhov kev txiav txim ntawm hnub. Tus so yog gobbledygook.
Sudhanva Deshpande yog tus editor nrog LeftWord Books, New Delhi www.leftword.com, thiab tuaj yeem hu rau ntawm [email tiv thaiv].