Kamar yadda Isra'ila'Operation Pillar of DefenceAn fara ne a ranar 14-15 ga watan Nuwamba wani mutum mai suna Jonathan Sacerdoti ya bayyana sau hudu a matsayin bako a shirye-shiryen talabijin na BBC daban-daban, inda ya nemi yin tsokaci kan ayyukan Isra'ila a Gaza. A ranar 14 ga Nuwamba ya yi iƙirari cewa Isra'ila tana aiki da 'kamewa'; a farkon bayyanar uku washegari da karfe 09:41 yayi magana game da ‘yancin kāre kanta’ Isra’ila; a BBC World daga baya a ranar ya yi zargin cewa Hamas tana 'kafa kanta a yankunan farar hula'; kuma a shirin labarai na karfe 19:30 na yammacin wannan rana ya bayyana cewa yawancin Falasdinawa da aka kashe a Gaza 'gawawwakin 'yan ta'adda ne, suna yin biris da da yawa fararen hulaciki har da yara akalla 3 kashe ta Isra'ila a cikin kwanaki da makonni da suka gabata.
Kowanne daga cikin kamanninsa ba a ƙalubalanci ba. A wani lokaci kuma wani mai sharhi Shashank Joshi na rundunar soji yayi tunani na gode Royal United Services Institute, amma Joshi ya ba da ra'ayi kusan iri ɗaya. BBC ta gabatar da Sacerdoti a matsayin mai sharhi na gabas ta tsakiya tsaka tsaki, darektan wata kungiya mai suna da ba ta da laifi da ake kira da Cibiyar Dimokuradiyya ta Gabas ta Tsakiya; Wannan tsaka-tsakin ya fito fili ta rashin wata hanya ta daban da aka bayar da kuma rashin bayyana shi a matsayin mai alaka da ko dai Isra'ila ko Palasdinawa 'sansanin'. A duk lokacin da ya bayyana, ma'aikacin labarai ya gabatar da shi da wasu bambance-bambancen "za mu iya samun ƙarin bayani kan wannan a yanzu kuma mu yi magana da Jonathan Sacerdoti na Cibiyar Demokraɗiyya ta Gabas ta Tsakiya".
'Kwarewa' masu sha'awar
Amma Sacerdoti dai kishiyar muryar kwararre ce mara sha'awar tashe-tashen hankulan da ke faruwa. Shekaru biyu kacal da suka wuce ya kasance Daraktan Hulda da Jama'a na Tarayyar Sahayoniya, mai yiwuwa ƙungiyar masu fafutukar kare Isra'ila da surutu da hayaniya a cikin Burtaniya.
Kwana daya bayan da Isra'ila ta kashe masu fafutuka tara a kan jirgin ruwan Mavi Marmara, ya bayyana yana kare wannan harin na Al Jazeera da kuma na Sky News. A watan Agusta 2011 ya yayi magana a wani gangamin goyon bayan Isra'ila a dandalin Trafalgar da kawancen Isra'ila na Burtaniya ya shirya da kuma goyon bayan gwamnatin Isra'ila mai alaka TsayaWithUs.
A ranar 6 ga Yuli, 2010 ya gana da shugaban Isra'ila Shimon Peres kuma an ɗora dukkan kundi a kan Flicker yana tattara bayanan bikin. Ya buga hotonsa yana musafaha da Peres, 'Jonathan Sacerdoti, na Sashin Sirrin Mai Martaba'.
Fabrairu mai zuwa ya sadu da Ron Prosor, tsohon jakadan Isra'ila a Burtaniya, kuma an dauki hotonsa tare da shi, tare da masu fafutukar kare Isra'ila Gili Brenner na StandWithUs UK da Chas Newkey-Burden, wani mawallafin yanar gizo na Isra'ila kuma aminin Sacerdoti, a cewar shafin yanar gizon Newkey-Burden. A ciki wannan hoton, dukkansu hudun suna sanye da ratsin rawaya a matsayin alamar goyon bayansu ga sojan Isra'ila da aka kama Gilad Shalit (tun lokacin da aka sake su a musayar fursunoni.)
Sacerdoti ya yi aiki tare da Brenner don yin a 'Sayi Ranar Kayayyakin Isra'ila' bidiyo an yi niyya don fuskantarKauracewa Juyawa da TakunkumaiKiran da kar a siyo kayan da aka yi a Isra'ila ko na kamfanonin da ke da hannu a cikin aikin. Ya kasance kuma aka zabe shi a Kwamitin Wakilai na Sashen Duniya na Yahudawa na Burtaniya, kungiya mai goyon bayan Isra'ila. A watan Mayu 2010 Sacerdoti rahotanni sun yi magana a bainar jama'a game da 'hanyoyin amfani da Facebook, Twitter da sauran albarkatun kan layi don ba da shawara ga Isra'ila' a taron bayar da shawarwarin kungiyar Sahayoniya ta Isra'ila mai suna 'Talk for Israel'.
A bayyane yake cewa Sacerdoti mai fafutuka ne mai goyon bayan Isra'ila. Amma labaran BBC sun ba wa masu kallo ra'ayi gurbatacce game da tarihinsa.
Sacerdoti na da hakkin kare harin da Isra'ila ke kai wa Gaza idan ya so. Amma BBC tana da aikin 'sanarwa da ilmantarwa'. Aƙalla, wannan yana nufin faɗin gaskiya kuma ba watsar da farfaganda kamar yadda aka sanar, 'maƙasudi', bincike.
Watakila BBC ba ta yi cikakkun bayanai dalla-dalla game da wanda aka zanta da su ba. Ana iya bayyana wannan a wani bangare ta gibin da ke ciki Sacerdoti's LinkedIn profile, Inda aikinsa na yanzu a kwamitin wakilai da tarihin aikin sa na baya a Tarayyar Sihiyoniya yakamata ya bayyana.
A maimakon haka, shafin LinkedIn ya ambaci shawararsa da kuma sabuwar ƙungiyar da ya ƙirƙira Cibiyar Dimokuradiyya ta Gabas ta Tsakiya, wacce ke da ɗan kama da alaƙa na 'Masanin Gabas ta Tsakiya' mai zaman kansa. Ya kasance ake kira daidai wannan ta BBC a watan Janairun 2011. Amma watanni biyar kacal kafin wannan. a cikin wata hira Satumba 2010, BBC ta fayyace rawar da Sacerdoti ya taka a Tarayyar Sahayoniya (ko da yake har yanzu shi kadai ne mai hira da su). A ciki wani bayyanar a cikin Janairu 2010 BBC ma ta ga ya dace don tabbatar da adalci ta hanyar gayyatar Sarah Colborne na Kamfen Haɗin kai na Falasdinu don ba da ra'ayi na gaba. Lokacin da aka nuna shi a Al Jazeera, sun gayyace su da hankali Ghada Karmi or Ali Abunimah don bayar da hangen nesa mai daidaitawa.
Cibiyar 'Cibiyar Dimokuradiyya ta Gabas ta Tsakiya'
Ko da a ce an daidaita ra'ayoyin Sacerdoti tare da ra'ayin goyon bayan Falasdinu, abin mamaki ne da BBC ta juya zuwa cibiyar 'Cibiyar Dimokuradiyya ta Gabas ta Tsakiya' wacce ba a san ta ba don bayar da sharhi.
An kafa 'InstMED' a cikin 2009 kuma tana kiran kanta 'tunanin tunani' amma ba a kafa shi sosai a kowane fanni ba. Gidan yanar gizon sa ba ya ba da bayani game da yadda ake samun kuɗi, kuma baya lissafin adireshi. Sacerdoti ne ya kafa shi tare da 'co-director' Sam Westrop, wani na hannun daman goyon bayan Isra'ila wanda kuma ya kafa wata kungiya mai suna The Birtaniya Isra'ila Coalition. InstMED's 'Associate Director' mutum ne da ake kira Hasan Afzalwanda -tare da Westrop - halitta'Musulman Birtaniya ga Isra'ila', ƙungiya wadda, da Urushalima Post rahotanni, 'yana karkashin inuwar Cibiyar Dimokuradiyya ta Gabas ta Tsakiya'.
Babban mai suna 'Cibiyar' ta fitar da jimillar wallafe-wallafe guda takwas, ɗaya daga cikinsu shine 'takardar bayanai' wanda ke ƙoƙarin gabatar da Kamfen ɗin Haɗin kai na Falasdinu a matsayin ɗan wariyar launin fata da ɗan luwaɗi. Binciken da aka yi da sauri na bayanan 'yan jaridu Nexis ya nuna cewa ɗaya daga cikin wallafe-wallafensa ne kawai ya sami kowane ɗaukar hoto a cikin manyan kafofin watsa labarai -ambaton guda ɗaya a cikin Urushalima Post. Rubutun jaridun Burtaniya ya kai wasiƙu biyu daga Sacerdoti da aka buga a cikin tangarahu da kuma Guardian. Cancantar Sacerdoti a matsayin manazarcin Gabas ta Tsakiya, a halin da ake ciki, da alama sun ƙunshi wani karatun digiri na Ingilishi daga Balliol College, Oxford. Takardun 'Co-director' na Westrop sun ma fi rauni. Yanzu a farkonsa na ashirin, Westrop ya sauke karatu daga Jami'ar York tare da digiri a kan kiɗa. Sacerdoti da alama ya yi aiki a cikin kafofin watsa labarai a taƙaice, gami da ITV, kuma wataƙila a nan ya yi tuntuɓar da suka taimaka masa ya ci gaba da samun labarai na lokaci.
Shi kansa Sacerdoti ya yi mamakin yadda BBC ta yunƙurin samar masa da dandamali. A ranar Alhamis 15 ga Nuwamba ya yi dariya a Facebook cewa 'zai iya shiga' a Beeb bayan da aka jera wata hira. A karkashin wani bidiyo na daya daga cikin bayyanarsa na farko, daya daga cikin 'abokan' na Facebook, yana kwatanta shi da Richard Kemp (wani kanar sojan Birtaniya wanda ya kare halin da Isra'ila ta yi a lokacin harin 2008-9 a Gaza duk da cewa bai taba zuwa ba), yayi sharhi: ' Na yi mamakin gaske da suka ci gaba da tambayar ku.
Wani abu ya kasance ba daidai ba game da labaran da BBC ta yi a Isra'ila a kalla shekaru goma da suka gabata. Bincike ta Greg Philo da Mike Berry, kwatanta lokacin da aka ware da muryoyi daban-daban da kuma nazarin yadda aka bayar da rahoton musabbabin faruwar lamarin a kowane bangare na rikicin Isra'ila da Falasdinu, ya nuna cewa rahoton na BBC ya ba da fifiko ga Isra'ila ta hanyar kashe Falasdinawa. Haka kuma ba wannan ne karon farko da BBC ke gabatar da wani bangare na Isra'ila a matsayin mai sharhi ba. Tsohon wakilin BBC Gabas ta Tsakiya Tim Llewellyn dole ne ya yi yaƙi da kamfani a yi masa lakabi daidai Dennis Ross, wanda a baya ya yi aiki da Kwamitin Tsaro na Obama, a matsayin mai goyon bayan Isra'ila. An sanar da Llewellyn cewa babu wata shaida ta Sihiyoniya ta Ross, duk da tarin alaƙa da ƙungiyoyi masu goyon bayan Isra'ila kamar Cibiyar Washington don manufofin Gabas Kusa, wanda ya co-kafa, da Cibiyar Siyasar Jama'ar Yahudawa, cibiyar tunani da aka kafa Hukumar Yahudawa.
Idan ana so jama'ar Birtaniyya su samu labari da kyau game da harin da ake kaiwa Gaza a halin yanzu, dole ne BBC ta fara yin aikinta, ta daidaita labaranta yadda ya kamata, sannan ta daina gabatar da masu yada farfaganda a matsayin kwararrun manazarta.
Hilary Aked mai bincike ne mai zaman kansa kuma marubuci, ƙwararren ɗan jarida ne na NCTJ kuma ɗan takarar digiri na uku a Jami'ar Bath.
ZNetwork ana samun kuɗi ta hanyar karimcin masu karatun sa.
Bada Tallafi