Ee, na sani. Uri Avnery ya samu nasarori da dama a matsayinsa na dan jarida kuma mai fafutukar neman zaman lafiya. Watakila ya yi kokarin ilimantar da mutane a duniya game da mummunan halin da ake ciki a yankunan Falasdinawa da aka mamaye, da kuma tsawon lokaci, fiye da kowane mutum guda. Kuma, don taya, yana bikin cikarsa 90th ranar haihuwar wannan makon. Don haka fatan alheri gareshi.
Duk da haka, yana da mahimmanci a kalubalanci ikirari da yawa da Avnery ya yi don ƙarfafa muhawara a cikin sabon labarinsa, yana watsi da girma kwatancen da ake yi tsakanin Isra'ila da wariyar launin fata Afirka ta Kudu. [http://zope.gush-shalom.org/home/en/channels/avnery/1382707541/]
Akwai abubuwa da yawa da za a soki a cikin raunin gardama nasa, dangane da tattaunawar kwanan nan tare da "kwararre" wanda ba a bayyana sunansa ba. Avnery, kamar da yawa a gabansa, ya yi kuskuren tunanin cewa, ta hanyar nuna bambance-bambancen da ke tsakanin Isra'ila da wariyar launin fata ta Afirka ta Kudu, ya tabbatar da cewa Isra'ila ba kasa ce ta wariyar launin fata ba. Amma wannan ita ce babbar gardamar bambaro. Babu wanda ya ce Isra'ila ta yi kama da Afirka ta Kudu. Ba kwa buƙatar gwani don gane hakan.
Lokacin da mutane suka kira Isra'ila a matsayin kasar wariyar launin fata, suna nufin laifin wariyar launin fata kamar yadda dokokin kasa da kasa suka bayyana. Bisa ga yarjejeniyar Rome ta 2002 ta Kotun hukunta laifukan yaki ta duniya, wariyar launin fata ta ƙunshi ayyukan rashin mutuntaka "wanda aka yi a cikin tsarin tsarin mulki na zalunci da rinjaye da wata ƙungiya ta kabilanci a kan kowace ƙungiya ko ƙungiyoyi da aka yi da nufin ci gaba da mulkin. ".
To wane irin launi ne wadanda mulkin wariyar launin fata ya shafa, ko wane kaso na al'ummar da suke da shi, ko tattalin arzikin ya dogara da aikin da suke da shi, ko sahyoniyawan farko sun kasance masu ra'ayin gurguzu, ko Palasdinawa suna da Nelson Mandela, da dai sauransu ba su da wata ma'ana ta musamman ga tantancewa. ko Isra'ila kasar wariyar launin fata ce.
Babban bambanci ga Avnery shine tsakanin “Isra’ila ta dace” da yankunan da aka mamaye. A cikin yankunan, Avnery ya yarda, akwai wasu kamanceceniya da mulkin wariyar launin fata a Afirka ta Kudu. Amma a cikin Isra'ila, yana tsammanin kwatanta ba daidai ba ne.
Mu ajiye batun da ba shi da muhimmanci wanda Isra'ila ta ki amincewa da iyakokinta da aka ayyana; ko kuma daya daga cikin manyan dabarunta shi ne tsarin raba da mulkin mallaka irin na mulkin mallaka wanda ya dogara da samar da bambance-bambancen hakki ga Falasdinawa a karkashin mulkinta a matsayin hanyar da za ta fi murkushe su.
Burin Avnery na nuna wannan banbance na yanki yakamata ya fito fili. Ya yi imanin cewa aikin laifi ne kuma dole ne a kawo karshen hakan. Amma kuma ya yi imanin cewa ya kamata Isra'ila a matsayin ta yahudawa ta ci gaba bayan kawo karshen mamayar. Hasali ma, yana ganin al’amura biyu suna daure da juna. A nasa ra'ayin, dorewar rayuwar Isra'ila a matsayinta na yahudawa ya dogara ne da raba ta daga yankunan da ta mamaye.
Wannan ya yi daidai da daidaitacciyar akidar sahyoniya ta 'yan sassaucin ra'ayi: ana kallon wariya a matsayin bayar da kariya daga barazanar al'umma da wadanda ba Yahudawa ba suke yi ga nasarar da kasar Yahudu za ta samu a nan gaba, kuma ta kai ga gagararta wajen gina katangar Yammacin Kogin Jordan da kuma ballewa daga Gaza. . Avnery shine kawai daya daga cikin mafi yawan masu goyon bayan wannan layin tunani.
Amma saboda wannan dalili, kamar yadda na sha fada a baya, ya kamata a dauki Avnery a matsayin jagora marar dogaro da jagora kan al'amuran da suka shafi Falasdinawa a cikin Isra'ila - kungiyar da ta fi wahala a yi tir da ita a karkashin tsarin wariya. [http://www.jonathan-cook.net/2006-11-18/hollow-visions-of-palestines-future/]
Ba zai yi yuwuwa Avnery ya kula da sukar “Isra’ila daidai” ba, kamar kwatanta wariyar launin fata, dangane da cancantar lamarin. Zai mayar da martani mai karewa. Yarda da cewa Isra'ila kasa ce mai nuna wariyar launin fata a cikin iyakokinta da kasashen duniya suka amince da ita, zai gurgunta halaccin kasarsa ta yahudawa. Hakan zai nuna cewa aikin rayuwarsa na fafutukar samar da kasar Falasdinu don kare kasarsa yahudawa bata ce, kuma mai yiwuwa cutarwa ce.
Babban da'awar Avnery ya yi a cikin labarin, daidai don kawar da hankali daga matsalar ƙasar Yahudawa mai cin gashin kanta da kuma dangantakarta da ɗimbin tsirarun Falasɗinawa, ita ce kamar haka:
"Gaba ɗaya, yanayin tsirarun Larabawa a cikin Isra'ila ya yi kama da na yawancin tsirarun ƙasa a Turai da sauran wurare. Suna jin daɗin daidaito a ƙarƙashin doka, zaɓen majalisar dokoki, jam'iyyunsu masu ɗorewa ne ke wakilta, amma a zahiri suna fuskantar wariya a fagage da dama. Kiran wannan wariyar launin fata zai zama babban kuskure. "
Ba dole ba ne mutum ya yarda cewa kwatancen da wariyar launin fata yayi daidai, a cikin yankunan da aka mamaye da kuma cikin "Isra'ila daidai" - ko da yake na yi - don fahimtar cewa, a gaskiya, Avnery ne ke yaudarar mutane sosai a nan.
Babu wata ma’ana da irin halin da Isra’ila ta yi wa ‘yan kasar Falasdinawa miliyan 1.5, kamar yadda Avnery ya fada, da yanayin ‘yan tsiraru na kasa a kasashen Turai. fuskanci nuna bambanci na hukuma, na yau da kullun ko na kwatsam. Yana da tsari, tsari da tsari.
Ga 'yan tambayoyi Avnery ko waɗanda suka yarda da shi suna buƙatar amsa:
* Wadanne kasashe na Turai ne, kamar Isra'ila, suka ba da kashi 93 cikin XNUMX na kasarsu ta yadda wata kabila (a bangaren Isra'ila, Yahudawa 'yan kasar) za su ware wata kabila ('yan Falasdinu Larabawa)?
* Wadanne kasashe na Turai ne ke gudanar da kwamitocin tantancewa, wadanda aka sanya a cikin doka, a cikin daruruwan al'ummomin karkara domin hana wata kabila (Larabawan Falasdinu) zama a cikin wadannan al'ummomi? [http://www.jonathan-cook.net/2010-12-15/arab-familys-home-win-blow-to-israeli-jews-only-policy/]
* Waɗanne ƙasashen Turai ne ke da dokokin zama ɗan ƙasa daban-a cikin yanayin Isra'ila, Dokar Komawa (1950) da Dokar zama ɗan ƙasa (1952) - dangane da ƙabila?
* Wadanne kasashen Turai ne suka tsara dokokin zama dan kasa, kamar yadda Isra’ila ta yi, don ba wa ‘yan wata kabila hakki (a bangaren Isra’ila, Yahudawa) wadanda a zahiri ba ’yan kasa ba ne ko kuma ba a cikin jihar, suna ba su gata a kan kungiya (Falasdinawa). Larabawa) su waye suke da ‘yan kasa kuma suna nan a jihar?
* Wadanne kasashe na Turai ne ke da dokoki sama da 55 wadanda ke nuna wariya karara dangane da kabilar da dan kasa ya fito? [http://adalah.org/eng/Israeli-Discriminatory-Law-Database]
* Waɗanne ƙasashe ne na Turai, kamar Isra'ila, ke ba da wasu daga cikin abin da ya kamata ya zama ikon mallakarsu ga ƙungiyoyin ƙetare - a cikin al'amarin Isra'ila, ga Hukumar Yahudawa da Asusun Yahudawa - waɗanda ƙa'idodinsu ya wajabta musu wariya bisa kabilanci?
* Waɗanne ƙasashe ne ƙasashen Turai ke hana ’yan ƙasarsu damar shiga duk wata hukuma game da batutuwan da suka shafi aure, saki da binne mutane, da ke bukatar dukan ’yan ƙasa su yi biyayya ga son zuciya da ra’ayin shugabannin addini? [http://www.jonathan-cook.net/2009-08-06/russian-jews-defy-israeli-rabbis-ban-on-marriage/]
* Waɗanne ƙasashe ne ƙasashen Turai ba su amince da ƙasarsu ba, kuma suka ba da damar shiga ƙungiyar ƙasa mafi rinjaye (a cikin al'amarin Isra'ila, Yahudawa) ko kuma yin hijira ta hanyar tuba kawai? [http://www.jonathan-cook.net/2013-10-18/court-nixes-push-for-israeli-nationality/]
Wataƙila Avnery na iya samun ƙaƙƙarfan ƙasar Turai tare da irin wannan karkatacciyar hanya, ko wani abu makamancin haka. Amma ba na shakka ba zai iya samun kasar Turai da ke da irin wannan dabi'a fiye da daya ba. Isra'ila tana da waɗannan duka da ƙari; a gaskiya, sun yi yawa don in lissafta su duka.
Don haka idan Isra'ila a cikin iyakokinta da aka amince da ita ba komai ba ne kamar ƙasashen Turai ko Amurka, ko kuma wata ƙasa da yawanci muke sanyawa a matsayin dimokuradiyya, watakila Avnery ko magoya bayansa za su iya bayyana ainihin irin ƙasar Isra'ila.
Jonathan Cook shine wanda ya lashe lambar yabo ta musamman ta Martha Gellhorn akan aikin jarida. Littattafansa na baya-bayan nan sune "Isra'ila da Karo na wayewa: Iraki, Iran da Shirin Sake Gabas Ta Tsakiya" (Pluto Press) da "Bacewar Falasdinu: Gwaje-gwajen Isra'ila a cikin Rashin Kauna" (Zed Books). Gidan yanar gizon sa shine www.jonathan-cook.net.
ZNetwork ana samun kuɗi ta hanyar karimcin masu karatun sa.
Bada Tallafi