Hillary Clinton na iya yin fushi da Barack Obama kamar yadda take so. Gaskiya ta bashi lokaci mai yawa.
Yana da ɗan ƙaramin yanki mai kyau na tushen ci gaba na Jam'iyyar Demokraɗiyya don haka ba zai iya yin tunani kai tsaye ba don ƙaddamar da ƙalubale mai tasiri ga ajandar kamfani-mai ikon mallakarta kuma daga haka zuwa ga babban tsarin kamfanoni-mai ba da izini wanda ke mulkin dimokiradiyya ta Amurka. ”
Hillary ba shine abin da masu fushi, marasa natsuwa, da mafi yawan ma'aikata ajin Democrat ke so da buƙatu ba.
Wannan tushe yana son ɗan takara mai son ci gaba, mai son jama'a, kuma mai son zaman lafiya - wanda zai ƙalubalanci ikon kamfanoni, yaƙar ma'aikata, kai farmaki da rage faɗaɗa al'ummar ƙasa da rarrabuwar kabilanci, da sake daidaita al'amuran al'umma daga tsarin mulkin mallaka da samun zaman lafiya. , Adalci, da Dimokuradiyya.
Har ila yau, tana buƙatar wanda ya yi nasara - ɗan takarar da ke da tabbacin zai ba wa ƴan jam'iyyar Republican azzalumai, masu ra'ayin juyin mulki da kuma Almasihu-rika-takiyya a 2008.
Kuma Hillary ba ta cika lissafin ba.
Ita ma'aikaciyar kamfani ce kuma mai mulkin demokraɗiyya.
Ita ce zakara na neoliberal na irin wadannan munanan manufofin da suka dace kamar Yarjejeniyar Kasuwancin Kasuwanci ta Arewacin Amurka (NAFTA) da kuma kawar da haƙƙin iyalai marasa galihu na taimakon kuɗi na tarayya. Ta fitar da wani ɗan gajeren tsari na inshorar lafiya na duniya (wanda aka ɗaga daga yaƙin neman zaɓe na John Edwards) sannan ta yi iƙirarin ƙarya cewa ta yi ƙoƙari mai ƙarfi da aminci don ciyar da lafiyar duniya gaba a farkon 1990s (1).
Kasancewar ta kasance mamaya na Iraki da ya wuce inda 'yan Democrat da yawa masu matsakaicin ra'ayi suka sauka daga jirgin "yaki" (2), Hillary ta sanar da gaske (tare da kiranta na kiyaye sojojin da ke yaki a Iraki don "yakar ta'addanci") yunƙurinta na ci gaba har abada. na zubar da jini, ba bisa ka'ida ba, wariyar launin fata, kisa-kisa, da mamaya na mulkin mallaka na Mesofotamiya. Ta ci gaba da ci gaba da da'awar cewa ba ta da wasu kyawawan dalilai na sanin cewa gwamnatin Bush na karya game da makaman Iraki na hallaka jama'a lokacin da ta kada kuri'a don ba da izini ga Bush ya mamaye a cikin shekara ta 2002 (3).
Ta tabbata za ta goyi bayan mummunan harin da gwamnatin Bush ta kai wa Iran. Har ma kwanan nan ta kada kuri'a don nuna goyon baya ga yakin basasa, tsokana, da saber-saber na Fadar White House don ayyana Kare Juyin Juya Halin Iran a matsayin "kungiyar ta'addanci ta kasa da kasa."
Ba ta da kunya sosai game da karɓar manyan gudummawa daga tarin dukiya, gami da manyan kamfanoni na kiwon lafiya da inshora waɗanda ke biyan ta da kyau don nisanta daga mafita ta dimokiradiyya ta zamantakewa ga rikicin kula da lafiyar al'umma: inshorar lafiya na gwamnatin Kanada mai biyan kuɗi guda ɗaya.
Ta ƙi tallafawa haɓaka matakin farko a cikin haraji na yawan kuɗin shiga masu gata don haɓaka kuɗin Tsaron Jama'a.
Kuma ita maƙaryaciya ce, mahaukaciyar ƙarfi wacce ta daɗe tana bata matsayinta akan muhimman batutuwa.
Idan aka yi la’akari da irin manyan abubuwan da ta ke da shi a tsakanin masu jefa ƙuri’a na Amurka (a yi tunanin), ba ta yin takara musamman a zaɓen da ke adawa da manyan ‘yan takarar shugaban ƙasa na Republican. Ko da yake ba zato ba tsammani, idan aka yi la'akari da yadda 'yan jam'iyyar Republican suka yi wa al'ummar kasar zagon kasa a cikin shekaru 8 da suka gabata, mai kishin yaki, Rudy Guliani - mafi kusantar 'yan takarar shugaban kasa na jam'iyyar Republican - zai sami dama mai kyau don kayar da Hillary Clinton a gaba ɗaya. zabe. Ta tabbata za ta tattara tushen bisharar da Guliani ke son rasa tare da matsayinsa a kan "matsalolin ɗabi'a" kamar zubar da ciki da bindigogi.
Wanda ake zaton "wanda ba makawa" da "marasa aibi" (bisa ga manyan muryoyi a cikin kafofin watsa labaru na kamfanoni) Hillary kamfani ce, mai mulki, marar rai, mai mulkin mallaka, kuma ba musamman zaɓaɓɓu ba. Hanyar da alama za ta kasance a buɗe ga wanda ke shirye ya buga 1968 Bobby Kennedy zuwa LBJ dinta: mai kwarjini kuma mai ra'ayin tada kayar baya yana gudu zuwa ga talauci, kamfanoni, da antiwar ya bar.
A nan ne Barack Obama ya shigo. An ƙarfafa miliyoyin masu jefa ƙuri'a na Demokraɗiyya masu ra'ayin mazan jiya da su yi tunanin Obama shi ne muryar masu tayar da kayar baya ta populism, zaman lafiya, dimokuradiyya, kuma, da kyau, "fata." Imani gabaɗaya ne, shirmen banza ne marar rangwame. Bautar mulki ta Obama (da hauka) ga mulkokin cikin gida da na duniya/sarauta da koyaswar an rubuta su sosai kuma ana iya ganewa cikin sauƙin ganewa - ga waɗanda ke kula da su - a cikin ƙwaƙƙwaransa da ra'ayin mazan jiya, taka tsantsan, da rubuce-rubucen "Hamiltonian". jawabai. Yana bayyana sosai a cikin halayensa na siyasa da manufofinsa. Kamar yadda na nuna a cikin labarai da yawa har zuwa yau (4), Barack ("ƙaunar mai zaluntar ku" Obama ƙwararren mai triangular ne kuma mayaudari a cikin tsarin kamfani-neoliberal Clinton-DLC.
Amma duk da haka, an sa jama'a da ba a san su ba sun yi tunanin cewa shi mai ra'ayin jama'a ne kuma mai adawa da yaki. Wani da ke cikin Iowa City "mai ci gaba" ya gaya mani cewa babban dan gwagwarmayar yaki da tsohon mai shirya al'umma Obama za a "watakila a kashe shi" saboda "fasawar sa" - "kamar Martin Luther King, Jr. da Che Guevera." Ba wasa bane.
Wani “mai ci gaba” da aka ruɗe kwanan nan ya rubuta imel ɗin ɗan yaro zuwa ɗan jaridar The Nation Katha Pollit. "Ya fusata," in ji Pollit, "saboda na yi magana a wata hira da cewa idan mutane ba su daina yin kalaman jima'i game da Hillary Clinton ba, zan iya zabe ta kawai ... soja da matsananciyar matsananci; za ta ci gaba da aiwatar da manufofin Bush na mamayar Iraki na dogon lokaci, ta ayyana manufofin kasashen waje game da 'yakin da ta'addanci,' tallafawa masu tsaurin ra'ayi a Isra'ila da kuma inganta akidar dimokiradiyya ta hagu na DLC. Muna bukatar mu sake gina hagu, in ji shi, kuma shi ya sa yake goyon bayan ... Barack Obama" (5)
Rikicin mutane irin su wakilin Pollit a zahiri ya samu kwarin gwiwa daga yakin neman zaben Obama, wanda ke tabbatar da alakanta dan takararsu da alkawuran ci gaba da zaman lafiya da ya saba sabawa akai-akai, wadanda kuma za a ba shi tabbacin cin amana nan take a lokacin da ake zaton mulkin shugaban kasa.
Har ila yau, al'adun siyasar Amurka kunkuntar kunkuntar yana ƙarfafa shi wanda ke ɗaga hotunan ɗan takara na zahiri akan ingantacciyar manufa da gaskiya, al'amari, da sa hannun akida da bincike. Wannan al'adar ta bar masu jefa ƙuri'a suna matsananciyar wahala ga wanda ke da alama yana wakiltar madadin mutane zuwa mulkin kasuwanci-na mulkin mallaka-kamar yadda aka saba a cikin "mafi kyawun dimokuradiyya wanda kuɗi zai iya [kuma ya yi] saya."
Ba ya cutar da cewa Obama baƙar fata ne a zahiri, wani abu da ke da alama yana ci gaba a ciki da kansa ga yawancin masu sassaucin ra'ayi (Clarence Thomas, Colin Powell, Oprah Winfrey da Condoleezza Rice duk da haka), musamman a jihohin da ainihin baƙar fata ba su da yawa. Baƙar fata na Obama na fasaha yana taimaka masa ya jawo hankalin fararen Iowans masu sassaucin ra'ayi da New Hampshire-ites masu sha'awar nuna rashin nuna wariyar launin fata ta hanyar zaɓe ga Ba'amurke Ba-Amurke.
Idan na fi karkata ga maganganun makirci, zan ce Obama ya kirkiro kuma ya dauki hayar kafafen yada labarai na kamfanoni, Wall Street, da kafa manufofin kasashen waje. Aikinsa? Don rarrabawa da rikitar da tushen ci gaba da kiyaye zaɓen 2008 lafiya ga mulkin mallaka ta hanyar kafa wata gasa mai kunkuntar bakan tsakanin kamfani Hillary da kamfani Rudy.
Wataƙila wannan bincike ne mai sauƙi. Yawancin manyan kuɗaɗen BaRockstar na dare da (bari mu kasance masu gaskiya) masu ƙirƙira suna da damuwa na gaske da fahimta game da halin Hillary da zaɓenta kuma mutumin Obama da manyan kwastomominsa sun karɓe su da gaske. Amma maƙarƙashiya a gefe, ka'idar ta ɗauki gaskiyar aiki na yadda al'amuran Obama ke takawa a fagen yaƙin neman zaɓe - rawar da yake takawa a cikin ɓarna na zaɓe na shekara huɗu na kamfanoni a halin yanzu. Wataƙila Obama ba zai iya doke Misis Clinton ba. Zai iya, duk da haka, ya lalata, rarrabuwa, laifin kabilanci, kabilanci-hankali, bamboozle kuma a zahiri ya lalata tushen ci gaba, populist. (5A). Watakila yana iya yin kamar shi mai adawa da Clinton ya dade don hana bullar wani dan tada kayar baya na Demokradiyya na gaske. Kuma don haka Hillary, Inc. ya kamata ya yi godiya.
Ga abin da ya dace - kuma duk wanda ke jin tsoro (tare da kyakkyawan dalili) ci gaba da mulkin Republican zai yi fatan zai yi amfani da yawa - mai yuwuwar dan takarar Democrat na Republican wanda bai so ya fuskanta a watan Nuwamba shine John Edwards. Edwards ya kayar da dukkan jiga-jigan 'yan jam'iyyar Republican a zaben da aka kwaikwayi. Yana da fa'idar kasancewarsa ɗan kudu fari ne kuma ba a haɗa shi da ɗaya daga cikin tarihin dangi mafi ɓarna da hauka a tarihin siyasar zamani (Clintons). Amma kuma ya sami goyon baya saboda a fili ya yanke shawarar tsayawa takarar Hillary (da Obama) populist portside. Ya sanya kawo karshen talauci, kai hari ga rashin daidaito tsakanin aji/tattalin arzikin jama'a da ciyar da haƙƙin ƙwadago su zama babban kukan yaƙin neman zaɓensa. Da yake kiran kansa a matsayin "Democrat na gaske, ba jam'iyyar Democrat ba," ya ce hanya daya tilo da za a iya ciyar da manufofin jam'iyyar ta gargajiya na yaki da talauci da rashin daidaito ita ce ta hanyar "yaki da doke" karfin tattalin arziki (kamfanoni) da kuma kawo karshen kamfanoni. "wasan damfara" na manyan kuɗaɗen mamayewa. Ya yi iƙirarin ƙin rage gata ga raguwa kan rage talauci da kuma yin magana cikin hikima game da bukatar Amirkawa "su kasance masu kishin ƙasa game da wani abu banda [abin da ake kira] yaƙi." Abin mamaki idan aka yi la’akari da rarrabuwar kawuna-siyasa na bakar fata tsakanin Hillary da Obama, Edwards shi ne mafi tsauri, balaga, da kuma sanar da manyan Dems uku idan ana maganar tattaunawa da yin tir da sojojin da ke haifarwa da kuma dorewar rashin daidaiton launin fata da wariyar launin fata. a cikin U.S.
Ba don komai ba ne Edwards ya rasa babban tallafin kamfanoni (6) da soyayyar kafofin watsa labaru (7) waɗanda Hillary da Obama ke karɓa ko kuma Edwards yana jan hankalin ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ma'aikata, gami da United Steelworkers, Ma'aikatan Transit na New York City da ( mafi yawan kwanan nan) babban adadin sassan jihohi na Ƙungiyar Ma'aikata ta Duniya (SEIU). Kuma ba don komai ba (ko kawai saboda launin fata da jinsi) Edwards yana da dama ta gaske - duk da ƙarancin tallafin kuɗi - ya ci nasara a Iowa, inda 'yan takara za su ci gaba da haɗawa da masu jefa ƙuri'a fuska da fuska (tsada tallan tallace-tallacen ya ci nasara' t yi dabarar gasa) don cin nasara. Yana yin kyau tare da tushen ci gaba na jihar saboda ƙarfinsa da zazzagewa da nuna sha'awar tsayawa - an gabatar da shi akai-akai a tarurrukan majalisar gari da barbecues na matakin gundumomi da makamantansu - a kan rashin daidaiton tattalin arziki, talauci, mulkin kamfanoni, da "yaki". .”
Ba ina cewa Edwards ba shine ɗan tawayen populist ko kuma bashi da wani laifi a cikin ruɗani na tushen ci gaba. Ainihin manufar manufofinsa ba ta Hagu kuma mai kishin jama'a - na zahiri "marasa iyawa" Kucinich da Gravel suna cikin bala'i su kadai wajen ciyar da ingantaccen tsarin kula da lafiya mai biyan kuɗi guda ɗaya kuma Edwards yana da wuya a sama da rungumar mugayen alkawuran sarauta (8) - fiye da abin da mutane da yawa Amirkawa (masu ci gaba a kan takamaiman batutuwan manufofin) za su goyi baya. Ya kasance mai arziki da yawa don amfanin kansa kuma kwanan nan kuma ya shiga cikin Hillary da Obama wajen ƙin (a wata muhawarar New Hampshire) don ƙaddamar da ƙaddamar da shigar da sojojin Amurka a Iraki nan da 2013. Kuma babu wani abu na musamman game da shelar sa. sha'awar canza Amurka don kowa ya sami damar zama mai arziki kamar shi.
Amma ko da Edwards an bar shi don tsarin mulki a halin yanzu na ci gaba mai iko kuma yana da ban sha'awa a yi la'akari da yadda kamfen ɗin sa na "real Democratic" zai yi kyakkyawan aiki ba tare da tallafin kamfanoni ba, masu ra'ayin mazan jiya, da faux- Obama mai ci-gaba yana tauye martabar masu sassaucin ra'ayi da masu ra'ayin rikau. A cewar James Ridgeway, a cikin wani bincike na baya-bayan nan na yakin neman zaben Edwards:
"A watan Yuli na 2007, lambobin Edwards suna raguwa. Bisa ga mafi yawan kuri'un (ko da yake ba duka ba), yana shawagi a wani wuri kusan kashi 15 cikin 20, tare da Barack Obama gabaɗaya a cikin 40s kuma Hillary yana tura 9. sassaƙa wa kansa matsayi zuwa hagu na Clinton. Ba tare da shi a cikin tseren ba, Edwards na iya da'awar yawancin gungun masu jefa ƙuri'a waɗanda suka same ta mai ra'ayin mazan jiya ko kuma Hillary ma, kuma lambobin yau na iya bambanta sosai" (XNUMX).
Matsayin Obama da watakila ma aikinsa a yakin 2008 ba kyakkyawa ba ne. Kuɗin giciye daga kamfanoni da sauran masu ba da kuɗaɗen gargajiya na Republican ga duka Hillary da Obama - kowannensu zai iya yin rashin nasara ga ɗan Republican a watan Nuwamba (wani ɓangare saboda munanan dalilai da suka shafi jinsi da kabilanci, abin bakin ciki isa) - yakamata a yi nazari sosai.
A halin da ake ciki, kuma abin bakin ciki watakila, abin da ya fi ci gaba da faruwa a cikin kunkuntar zabukan Amurka shi ne gwagwarmayar yakin neman zaben Edwards don dakile manyan kafafen yada labarai na Hillary da Obama da na'urorin kudi (dukansu sun tara 'yan takara miliyan 80. ya zuwa yanzu) a Iowa. Haɗe tare da haɓaka haɗin gwiwa na ƙungiyar Edwards a duk faɗin ƙasar, nasarar Edwards a cikin mahimman abubuwan Iowa na iya haifar da kisa na Hillary da ke haifar da aura na "ba makawa" da kuma taimakawa wajen tura abin mamaki na Obama (yanzu a cikin shekara huɗu, yi imani da shi ko a'a) margin. Zai iya jawo hankalin ƙasa da goyon bayan ƙasa ga mafi gaskiya da ƙwaƙƙwaran "mai ra'ayin jama'a" na manyan 'yan takarar Demokraɗiyya guda uku - wanda ke da babbar dama ta doke masu tsattsauran ra'ayi, masu tsattsauran ra'ayi, masu mulki, da 'yan Republican na Almasihu- soja a cikin Nuwamba na 2008. Paul Street marubuci ne, mai magana kuma mai fafutuka a cikin Iowa City, IA da Chicago, IL. Littafinsa na baya-bayan nan shine Zaluntar launin fata a cikin Global Metropolis (New York: Rowman & Littlefield, 2007). Ana iya samun sa a [email kariya].
NOTES
1. Duba Christopher Hitchens, Babu Wanda Ya Bar Don Ƙarya Ga: Darajojin Mafi Munin Iyali (New York: Verso, 2000), shafi na 51-52, kan karkatar da halayen kamfanoni-triangulationist na Hillary da Bill Clinton da ake zaton suna da daraja da ci gaba. yakin neman lafiya. A kan 'neoliberal da regressive (duka ta fuskar tattalin arziki da kabilanci) na mulkin Clinton na 1990s, duba Robert Pollin, Ƙididdiga na Zuriya: Rugujewar Tattalin Arziƙi na Amurka da Tsarin Tsarin Duniya na Austerity (New York: Verso, 2003), shafi3-75; Elaine Brown, Hukuncin Ƙananan B (Boston: Beacon, 2002), shafi 173-206.
2. Lokaci ya wuce da za a daina kiran harin da Amurka ta kai wa Iraki “yaki” na Amurka. Tun a watan Maris na shekara ta 2003 daular Amurka ta fara kai wa Iraki hari da wulakanci ta hanyar kai hare-hare, amma babu wanda ya kai hari daga Iraki. To ina yakin? "Aikin 'Yancin Iraki" yana da lebur kuma zalunci ne na mulkin mallaka, mai tsabta da sauki.
3. Kuma akasin iƙirarinta na cewa tana so kuma tana tsammanin George W. Bush zai ƙyale duk "zaɓuɓɓukan diflomasiyya" kafin ya zaɓi "yaƙi" (tsirara na mulkin mallaka, wato) akan Iraki, ta shiga cikin wasu 'yan majalisar dattijan Amurka 74 don kada kuri'a a kan Sanata Carl. Levin's (D-MI) a baya (sa'o'i da yawa kafin kuri'ar izinin yakin) shawara na gyaran fuska wanda zai bukaci Fadar White House ta bi tsarin diflomasiyya (komawa Majalisar Dinkin Duniya da watakila sake zuwa Majalisa) kafin reshen majalisa zai ba da cikakken izini. amfani da karfi. A cikin jawaban yakin neman zabe da tarurruka inda ta ke son zargin Bush da cewa ya ba da "gajeren aikin diflomasiyya," a zahiri Clinton ba ta taba ambaton "kuri'arta na adawa da gyaran Levin na 2002 ba, wanda zai bukaci shugaban kasa ya bi tsarin diflomasiyya kafin kowane. mamaye Iraki." Dubi Jeff Gerth da Don Van Natta Jr., "Hillary's War," New York Times Sunday Magazine (Yuni 3 2007), shafi. 43, 60, da 66. A kan daular mulkin mallaka na Hillary da da'awar kuri'ar "yakin", duba Paul Street, "Wane ne Hillary Tana Tunanin Tana Kidding?" ZNet (Fabrairu 14, 2007), akwai akan layi a http://www.zmag. org/content/showarticle.cfm?ItemID=12120; da "Hillary's War da na gaba 9/11," ZNet (Yuli 5, 2007), samuwa a kan layi a www.zmag.org/content/showarticle.cfm?SectionID=72&ItemID=13215
4. Duba kasidu na masu zuwa: “The Illusion of Obama: The ‘Bee of Slaves’ da ‘Burin Hamilton’ na ‘Dan wasa’ na Kamfanin-Imperial,”Z Magazine (Fabrairu 2007); "Obama's Audacious Deference to Power," ZNet (Janairu 24, 2007), samuwa a kan layi a http://www.zmag.org/content/showarticle.cfm?ItemID=11936; "Tunanin Kodi: Barack Obama, Martin Luther King, Jr., da Ma'anar Juyin Juyin Halitta," ZNet (Maris 16, 2007), karanta a http://www.zmag.org/content/showarticle.cfm? Item ID=12336; "Barack Obama's Wonderful Wealth Primary," ZNet (Afrilu 11, 2007), karanta a http://www.zmag.org/content/showarticle.cfm?ItemID=12551; "Zamanin Rawar Obama a Garin Iowa," ZNet (Afrilu 28, 2007), ana samun su akan layi a http://www.zmag.org/content/showarticle.cfm?ItemID=12687; "Jarraba na Imperial: John Edwards, Barack Obama, da Tatsuniyar Jin Dadin Amurka Bayan Yaƙin Duniya na Biyu," ZNet (Mayu 28, 2007), karanta a http://www.zmag.org/content/showarticle.cfm?ItemID = 12928; "Running Dog Obama," ZNet (Yuli 29, 2007), samuwa a kan layi a http://www.zmag.org/content/showarticle.cfm?ItemID=13396; "Zagin Obama," ZNet (Oktoba 3, 2007), karanta a http://www.zmag.org/content/showarticle.cfm?ItemID=13940; "Me Obama Zai Yi? Zabi Yaƙin kuma Yi Ƙarya Game da Shi - Kamar Hillary," ZNet (Oktoba 13, 2007), karanta a http://www.zmag.org/content/showarticle.cfm?ItemID=14030;
5. Katha Pollitt, "Yaya Bambanci Ne Manyan Dems Uku?" Kasa, Oktoba 22, 2007. 5A. Ya ƙware musamman wajen tsotsa a cikin wannan tushe fiye da abubuwan da suka shafi hankali da ilimi. Kamar abin koyinsa na jam'iyyar Democrat John Fitzgerald Kennedy, Obama ya kware sosai wajen zaburar da masu tunani, wanda yake daukar kansa a matsayin babban memba.
6. Daga cikin "manyan uku," Edwards ne kawai zai dogara ga tallafin jama'a don ragowar yakin neman zabe. Hakan zai sanya masa kayyade kashe kudade yayin da Hillary da Obama ke ci gaba da kafa sabbin tarihi wajen tara kudade da kashe kudade a yakin neman zabe. Akan tallafin Hillary & Obama, duba Paul Street, John Edwards da Zaɓin Zaɓar Munafuncin Jama'a,'ZNet (29 ga Yuni, 2007), karanta a http://www.zmag.org/content/showarticle.cfm?ItemID=13177; "Zauna a waje da Obama Dance;" "Obama's Wonderful Wealth Primary."
7. Duba Jeff Cohen, "Shin Kafofin watsa labaru sun fita don samun Edwards?" ZNet (Yuni 3 2007), akwai kan layi a http://www.zmag.org/content/showarticle.cfm?SectionID=21&ItemID=12981; Titin, "John Edwards da Zaɓaɓɓen Skewering na Media Media."
8. A kan manufofin ƙasashen waje, duba Titin, “Jarraban Imperial.”
9. James Ridgeway, “John Edwards,” shafi na 148-149 a cikin Laura Flanders, Richard Goldstein, Dean Kuipers, James Ridgeway, Eli Sanders, da Dan Savage, The Contenders (New York: Labarun Bakwai, 2008)
ZNetwork ana samun kuɗi ta hanyar karimcin masu karatun sa.
Bada Tallafi