Mutane suna aikin jarida kuma Washington Post ta fusata. Yadda za a amsa? A bayyane yake amsar da editocin Post suka zo ita ce kawai su daina kan duk wani Ba'amurke da ke sanar da kansa da kuma kai hari ga Amurkawan da suka yarda da duk wani abu da manyan mutane ke faɗi. Ta yaya kuma za a yi bayanin op-ed mai cike da rubuce-rubucen karya kuma aka buga a ranar Juma'ar da ta gabata akan layin Sanatocin Demokradiyya biyu, Carl Levin da Jack Reed?
Kanun labarai shi ne "Kwarin da Afganistan ke Bukatar Har yanzu." Haɓaka ba ƙa'ida ce don abinci ko zaman lafiya ko maido da muhalli ba ko ɗan ɗan lokaci kaɗan daga hankalin masu shaye-shayen mai, iskar gas da wutar lantarki na duniya. Surge, a cikin jahilai-Jaridar-American-readerspeak kalma ce da ke nuna ƙage-zage na ban dariya cewa za a iya fansar masu laifi da kisan gilla da mamayewa ta hanyar haɓaka shi. An yi amfani da kalmar ne dangane da Iraki, cewa jahannama a duniya inda a yanzu gwamnati ke kashe masu zanga-zangar demokradiyya da aka shafe shekaru 20 ana yaki da takunkumi, duk da cewa gwamnatin ta bukaci a biya diyya ga halakar Amurka kwanan nan.
A duk lokacin da yakin da ba shi da bege ya kai shekara zuwa shekara, tare da samun nasara ba a fayyace kuma ba za a iya misalta ba, ko da yaushe za a sami amsa ga rashin ci gaba, kuma amsar ita ce "aike da karin sojoji." Lokacin da tashin hankali ya ragu, ana buƙatar ƙarin sojoji don haɓaka kan nasarar. Lokacin da tashin hankali ya tashi, ana buƙatar ƙarin sojoji don murkushe ƙasa. Kamar yadda na yi nazari a cikin "Yaki Is A Lie," wannan al'ada ce, kuma kiran shi sabon suna kamar "taruwa" ba zai sa ya zama halin kirki, doka, ko ma "mai tasiri ba."
Harin bama-bamai na Hanoi da Haiphong wata hanya ce ta kawo karshen yaki tare da nuna rashin ma'ana na karin tauri. Kamar yadda Vietnamese za su amince da sharuɗɗa iri ɗaya kafin tashin bom ɗin da suka amince da su bayan haka, da gwamnatin Iraqi za ta yi maraba da duk wata yarjejeniya da Amurka za ta janye shekaru kafin "haɓaka," kafin ta, ko kuma a lokacinta. A lokacin da Majalisar Iraki ta amince da yarjejeniyar da ake kira Matsayin Sojoji a shekarar 2008, ta yi hakan ne kawai da sharadin cewa za a gudanar da zaben raba gardama na jama'a kan ko a yi watsi da yarjejeniyar da kuma ficewa cikin gaggawa maimakon jinkirin shekaru uku. Ba a taba gudanar da zaben raba gardama ba.
Yarjejeniyar da shugaba Bush ya yi na ficewa daga Iraki - ko da yake an shafe shekaru uku ana jinkiri da rashin tabbas kan ko a zahiri Amurka za ta mutunta yarjejeniyar - ba a kira shan kaye ba kawai saboda an samu wani ci gaba na baya-bayan nan da aka kira nasara. A shekara ta 2007, Amurka ta aike da karin sojoji 30,000 zuwa cikin Iraki tare da babban kwamanda, Janar David Petraeus.
Majalisa da shugaban kasa, kungiyoyin masu nazari da masu bincike duk sun kafa "ma'auni" ta yadda za su auna nasara a Iraki tun daga 2005. Majalisa ta sa ran shugaban kasa zai cika ma'auni a cikin Janairu 2007. Bai sadu da su da haka ba. wa’adin, a ƙarshen “taɓawar,” ko kuma lokacin da ya bar ofis a watan Janairu 2009. Haka kuma wanda zai maye gurbinsa bai gamu da su ba. Babu dokar man fetur da za ta amfanar da manyan kamfanonin mai, babu dokar hana ruwa gudu, kuma ba a sake duba tsarin mulki ba. Hasali ma, babu wani ci gaba a fannin wutar lantarki, ruwa, ko wasu muhimman matakan farfadowa a Iraki. Kuma masu zanga-zangar suna da hakkin a harbe su. "Ƙarar" ita ce ci gaba da waɗannan "ma'auni" da kuma samar da "sarari" don ba da damar sulhu da kwanciyar hankali na siyasa. Ko an fahimci hakan a matsayin ka'idar ikon Amurka na mulkin Iraki, har ma da masu taya shi murna sun yarda cewa bai cimma wani ci gaba na siyasa ba.
An rage ma'aunin nasara ga "tashin hankali" da sauri don haɗa da abu ɗaya kawai: rage tashin hankali. Wannan ya dace, da farko saboda ya shafe daga tunanin Amurkawa wani abu da ya kamata a yi amfani da aikin tiyata, na biyu kuma saboda tashin hankali ya zo daidai da yanayin tashin hankali na dogon lokaci. Yunƙurin ya yi ƙanƙanta sosai, kuma tasirinsa nan da nan na iya zama haɓakar tashin hankali. Brian Katulis da Lawrence Korb sun yi nuni da cewa, "Karuwar" da sojojin Amurka suka yi a Iraki ya kasance wani karamin karuwar kusan kashi 15 cikin 15,000 - kuma idan aka yi la'akari da rage yawan sojojin kasashen waje, wanda ya fadi daga 2006 a 5,000. zuwa 2008 ta 20,000." Don haka, mun kara yawan dakaru 30,000, ba XNUMX ba.
Karin sojojin sun kasance a Iraki a watan Mayun 2007, kuma Yuni da Yuli sune watanni mafi tashin hankali na lokacin zafi na dukan yakin har zuwa wannan lokacin. Lokacin da tashin hankali ya ragu, akwai dalilai na raguwa waɗanda ba su da alaƙa da "tashin hankali." An samu raguwar raguwar sannu a hankali, kuma ci gaban da aka samu ya danganta da munanan matakan tashe-tashen hankula a farkon shekarar 2007. Ya zuwa faduwar shekara ta 2007 a Bagadaza an kai hare-hare sau 20 a kowace rana da kuma kashe fararen hula 600 a tashe-tashen hankula na siyasa kowane wata, ba tare da kirga sojoji ko 'yan sanda ba. 'Yan Iraki sun ci gaba da yin imani cewa, mamayar Amurka ce ta haddasa tashe tashen hankula, kuma sun ci gaba da son kawo karshen ta cikin sauri.
Hare-haren da ake kaiwa sojojin Birtaniyya a Basra ya ragu matuka a lokacin da Birtaniyyan suka daina sintiri a cibiyoyin jama'a suka tashi zuwa filin jirgin sama. Babu wani karuwa da ya shiga. Sabanin haka, saboda yawan tashin hankalin da mamaya ne ya haddasa shi, kamar yadda jami'an sojan Amurka da ba a san sunansu ba suka yarda da Afghanistan, mayar da mamayar da aka yi hasashe ya haifar da raguwar tashe-tashen hankula, kuma a Afghanistan.
Hare-haren 'yan ta'adda a lardin al-Anbar ya ragu daga 400 a kowane mako a watan Yulin 2006 zuwa 100 a kowane mako a watan Yulin 2007, amma "harin da ake yi" a al-Anbar ya kunshi sabbin sojoji 2,000 ne kawai. A haƙiƙa, wani abu dabam ya bayyana faɗuwar tashin hankali a al-Anbar. A cikin Janairun 2008, Michael Schwartz ya ɗauki kansa don karyata tatsuniya cewa "haɓaka ya haifar da sasanta manyan sassan lardin Anbar da Bagadaza." Ga abin da ya rubuta:
"Tsarin sulhu da sulhu ba abu ɗaya ba ne kawai, kuma wannan ba shakka lamari ne na rashin jin daɗi. A gaskiya ma, raguwar tashe-tashen hankula da muke gani a zahiri ya samo asali ne sakamakon dakatar da hare-haren da Amurka ke kaiwa yankunan 'yan tawaye, wanda ya kasance - daga farkon yakin - mafi girman tushen tashin hankali da asarar fararen hula a Iraki Wadannan hare-haren, wanda ya kunshi mamaye gida don neman wadanda ake zargi da tayar da hankali, suna haifar da kama da hare-haren da sojojin Amurka suka yi da damuwa game da juriya, fadan bindiga lokacin da iyalai suka yi tsayayya. kutsawa cikin gidajensu, da bama-baman da ke gefen hanya suna tashe-tashen hankula da kuma karkatar da kai hare-hare a duk lokacin da 'yan Irakin ke yaki da wadannan hare-hare, to akwai yuwuwar samun ci gaba da yakin da ake yi da bindigogi, wanda hakan ke haifar da hare-hare ta sama da Amurka. rusa gine-gine har ma da dukan tubalan.
"Ayyukan da ake yi' ya rage wannan tashin hankali, amma ba wai don 'yan Iraki sun daina tinkarar hare-haren ba, ko kuma goyon bayan masu tayar da kayar baya. Tashin hankalin ya ragu a yawancin garuruwan Anbar da kuma yankunan Bagadaza saboda Amurka ta amince da dakatar da wadannan hare-haren; ma'ana, Amurka za ta daina. Ba su sake neman kamawa ko kashe 'yan Sunna da suka kwashe shekaru hudu suna yakarsu ba, a maimakon haka, 'yan tawayen sun amince da 'yan sanda a yankunansu (wanda suka dade suna yi, ba tare da goyon bayan Amurka ba), da kuma dakile bama-bamai na motoci masu jihadi. Sakamakon haka shi ne cewa sojojin Amurka a yanzu suna zama a wajen al'ummomin da suka yi tawaye a baya, ko kuma su bi ta ba tare da kutsawa wani gida ko kai hari kan wani gini ba. al’umma, har ma da samar musu da albashi da kayan aiki don dorewar da kuma mika ikonsu ga al’umma”.
A karshe Amurka ta yi daidai fiye da rage kai hare-hare a gidajen mutane. Ta kasance tana bayyana niyyarta, ko ba dade ko ba dade, ta fice daga ƙasar. Ƙungiyoyin zaman lafiya a Amurka sun gina goyon bayan majalisa don janyewa tsakanin 2005 da 2008. Zaɓen 2006 ya aika da sako ga Iraki cewa Amurkawa suna so. Wataƙila 'yan Iraki sun saurari wannan saƙon a tsanake fiye da yadda 'yan majalisar Amurka da kansu suka yi. Hatta ƙungiyar nazarin Iraki da ke goyon bayan yaƙi a cikin 2006 ta goyi bayan janyewar lokaci. Brian Katulis da Lawrence Korb suna jayayya cewa,
"... Sakon cewa sadaukarwar da Amurka (sojoji) ta yi wa Iraki ba budaddiyar soji ba ce irin ta farkawa ta Sunni a lardin Anbar don yin hadin gwiwa da Amurka don yakar Al Qaeda a 2006, wani yunkuri da ya fara tun kafin yakin 2007 na Amurka. Sakon da Amurkawa ke fita ya kuma zaburar da 'yan Iraqin yin rajistar shiga jami'an tsaron kasar a adadi mai yawa."
Tun a watan Nuwamban 2005, shugabannin manyan kungiyoyin 'yan Sunni masu dauke da makamai sun nemi yin sulhu da Amurka, wadda ba ta da sha'awa. Babban raguwar tashe-tashen hankula ya zo ne a ƙarshen 2008 da Bush ya yi alkawarin janyewa gaba ɗaya a ƙarshen 2011, kuma tashe-tashen hankula sun ƙara ƙaruwa bayan janyewar sojojin Amurka daga birane a lokacin rani na 2009. yaki. Cewa ana iya mayar da wannan a matsayin wani ci gaba da yakin ya ce game da tsarin sadarwar jama'a na Amurka fiye da amfanin karuwar laifuka don kawo karshen su.
Wani babban abin da ya haifar da raguwar tashe-tashen hankula, wanda ba shi da wata alaka da "haɓaka," shi ne shawarar da Moqtada al-Sadr, shugaban ƙungiyar gwagwarmaya mafi girma, ya yi, na ba da umarnin tsagaita wuta na bai ɗaya. Kamar yadda Gareth Porter ya ruwaito.
"Ya zuwa karshen shekarar 2007, sabanin tarihin Iraki na hukuma, gwamnatin al-Maliki da gwamnatin Bush duk sun fito fili suna yabawa Iran da matsawa Sadr lamba kan ya amince da tsagaita bude wuta - abin takaicin Petraeus. . . - ba dabarar tada kayar baya na Petraeus ba - wanda ya kawo karshen barazanar 'yan Shi'a yadda ya kamata."
Wani muhimmin karfi da ya takaita tashin hankalin Iraki shi ne samar da kudade na kudi da makamai ga 'yan Sunni "Majalisun Farkawa" - dabara na wucin gadi na ba da makamai da ba da cin hanci ga wasu 'yan Sunna 80,000, yawancinsu mutane iri daya ne da suka kai hari kwanan nan ga sojojin Amurka. A cewar dan jarida Nir Rosen, shugaban daya daga cikin mayakan da ke kan albashin Amurka "ya yarda cewa wasu daga cikin mutanensa na Al Qaeda ne. ], don haka za su iya samun katin shaida a matsayin kariya idan an kama su."
Amurka dai na biyan 'yan Sunni ne don yakar 'yan ta'addar Shi'a yayin da ta baiwa 'yan sandan kasar da mabiya Shi'a damar mayar da hankali kan yankunan 'yan Sunna. Wannan dabarar raba-da-nasara ba hanya ce amintacciyar hanyar kwanciyar hankali ba. Kuma kwanciyar hankali ya kasance har yanzu ba a ganuwa, a ce ko kadan.
A lokacin "haɓaka" a cikin 2007, sojojin Amurka sun tattara tare da ɗaure dubun-dubatar mazajen da suka kai shekarun soja. Idan ba za ku iya doke su ba, kuma ba za ku iya ba su cin hanci ba, kuna iya sanya su a bayan sanduna. Wannan kusan ya taimaka wajen rage tashin hankali.
Amma babban dalilin rage tashin hankali na iya kasancewa mafi banƙyama kuma akalla magana game da. Daga tsakanin Janairu 2007 da Yuli 2007 birnin Baghdad ya canza daga 65 bisa dari Shiite zuwa 75 bisa dari Shiite. Rahotanni na Majalisar Dinkin Duniya a 2007 na 'yan gudun hijirar Iraqi a Siriya sun gano cewa 78 kashi daga Baghdad ne, kuma kusan kusan' yan gudun hijirar 'yan gudun hijirar sun tashi zuwa Syria daga Iraki a 2007 kadai. Kamar yadda Juan Cole ya rubuta a watan Disamba na 2007,
Wannan bayanai sun nuna cewa sama da mazauna Bagadaza sama da 700,000 ne suka tsere daga wannan birni mai mutane miliyan 6 a lokacin da Amurka ta yi tashin gwauron zabo, wato sama da kashi 10 cikin XNUMX na al'ummar babban birnin kasar. babban birnin Shi'a da kuma raba dubban daruruwan 'yan Iraqi daga babban birnin kasar."
Ƙarshen Cole yana samun goyan bayan nazarin hasken hayaki daga yankunan Baghdad. Yankunan Sunni sun yi duhu yayin da aka kashe ko aka kori mazaunansu, tsarin da ya kai kololuwa kafin “haɓaka” (Disamba 2006 – Janairu 2007). A watan Maris na 2007, "… tare da yawancin al'ummar Sunni sun bar gudun hijira zuwa lardin Anbar, Siriya, da Jordan, sauran kuma sun yi gudun hijira a yankunan da 'yan Sunni suka yi karfi a yammacin Bagadaza da wasu sassan Ahamiyya a gabashin Bagadaza, abin da ya haifar da zubar da jini. ‘Yan Shi’a sun yi nasara, sun mika wuya, aka gama fada”.
A farkon 2008, Nir Rosen ya rubuta game da yanayin a Iraq a karshen 2007:
"A cikin watan Disamba, rana ce mai sanyi, mai launin toka, kuma ina tafiya kan titin Sixtieth a gundumar Dora ta Bagadaza, daya daga cikin mafi tashin hankali da fargaba a yankunan birnin. 'Yan bindigar Shi'a, kungiyoyin gwagwarmaya na Sunni da Al Qaeda, yawancin Dora yanzu ya zama garin fatalwa Mafi yawan tagogin da ke cikin gidajen masu launin yashi sun karye, kuma iska ta bi ta cikin su, tana kururuwa.
"Gida bayan gida ba kowa ne, ramukan harsashi suna nuna bangon su, kofofinsu a bude suke kuma ba a tsare su, da yawa daga cikin kayan daki. Wasu 'yan kayan da suka rage sun rufe da kura mai kauri da ke mamaye kowane wuri a Iraki. Ganuwar tsaro mai tsayin ƙafa goma sha biyu da Amurkawa suka gina don raba ƙungiyoyin yaƙi da kuma killace mutane a unguwarsu. -Apocalyptic maze na kankare tunnels fiye da mai rai, mazauna unguwar, ban da sawunmu, akwai cikakken shiru."
Wannan baya kwatanta wurin da mutane suke zaman lafiya. A wannan wuri mutane sun mutu ko kuma sun yi gudun hijira. Sojojin Amurka sun yi aiki don rufe sabbin yankunan da aka ware daga juna. ‘Yan ta’addan sunni “sun farka” tare da hada kai da ‘yan mamaya, domin ‘yan Shi’a sun kusa halaka su gaba daya.
A watan Maris 2009 mayakan farkawa sun koma yakar Amurkawa, amma a lokacin an kafa tatsuniya. A lokacin, Barack Obama ya zama shugaban kasa, bayan da ya yi iƙirarin a matsayin ɗan takara cewa an sami nasara fiye da mafarkin mu. Nan da nan aka yi amfani da tatsuniyar ta karuwa don amfani da shi wanda ba shakka an tsara shi - yana tabbatar da haɓakar wasu yaƙe-yaƙe. Bayan da aka yi nasara a Iraki a matsayin nasara, lokaci ya yi da za a mayar da wannan farfagandar juyin mulki zuwa yakin Afghanistan. Obama ya nada babban jarumin, Petraeus, a Afghanistan, kuma ya ba shi dakaru masu tarin yawa.
Amma babu wani daga cikin ainihin musabbabin rage tashe-tashen hankula a Iraki da ya wanzu a Afganistan, kuma ta'addancin da kansa zai iya kara dagula al'amura. A gaskiya ma, wannan ita ce gogewar da ta biyo bayan tashin hankalin da Obama ya yi a 2009 da 2010 a Afghanistan. Sana'ar ita ce ke haifar da tashin hankali, kuma karuwar sana'ar tana kara tashin hankali. Kisan yara daga jirage masu saukar ungulu, ko wani bangare na "tasowa" ko a'a, yana haifar da gagarumin juriya na tashin hankali. Amurka ta riga ta ba da tallafin Taliban, wanda ba ya siyan haɗin gwiwa. Yanayin ƙasa da yawan jama'ar Afganistan sun sanya ɗaurin kurkuku da kabilanci da ba zai yuwu ba don rage tashin hankali a can. Dubi cikin wani baƙar fata na gazawar da ba ta ƙare ba, martanin sojojin Amurka shine da'awar, kowace shekara, cewa ci gaban yana kusa da kusurwoyi kuma duk abin da muke buƙata shine wani ƙari.
A makon da ya gabata ne Mujallar Rolling Stone ta fallasa irin kokarin da sojojin Amurka ke yi na yaudari jami'anta, da masu tunani, da kuma 'yan majalisar dattawan Amurka da ke ziyara a Afghanistan. Rashin nasara, an gaya wa waɗannan manyan masu ziyarar, an yi nasara. Sama ya sauka. Baki fari ne. Ko kuma zai kasance da jimawa sosai, kamar yadda ya kasance a koyaushe yana gab da zama da wuri sosai. Daga cikin ’yan majalisar dattijai da aka yi wa wannan goge-goge ko kuma “aiki na tunani” akwai ‘yan jam’iyyar Democrat Carl Levin da Jack Reed, da suka dage da sauri cewa, a matsayinsu na ‘yan reshe na farko na gwamnatinmu da ke kula da aikin soja, za su ci gaba da zage-zagen cewa sojoji zai binciki kanta. Jaridar Washington Post, a nata bangaren, da alama ba ta damu da aikin jarida na Rolling Stone ba. Bayan haka, aikin jarida shine abin da Wikileaks ke yi. Menene wannan, 1970s? WaPo ya zaɓi ya buga Levin da Reed's oped, "The Surge Afganistan Har yanzu yana Bukatar," tare da wannan sakin layi na buɗewa:
"Rahoton da ba a amince da shi a yanzu ba a Rolling Stone ya yi zargin cewa jami'an sojan Amurka a Afghanistan sun yi amfani da dabarun gudanar da bayanan da ba su dace ba don kokarin shawo kan mu, da kuma shugaban hafsan hafsoshin hafsoshin soja da sauran su, don tallafa wa karin kayan aiki don horar da karin sojojin Afghanistan. ."
Ta yaya aka yi watsi da rahoton? Ba su ce. Gaskiya ne "Maza Masu Kallon Sanatoci" sun musanta cewa sun yi wani abu ba daidai ba, kuma lauyan soja ya bayyana laifukan da aka aikata a matsayin "halakanci," kuma ƙwararrun ƙwararrun masana sun bayyana cewa yin ƙarya ga mutane ba daidai ba ne da wanke kwakwalwa. Sai dai babu wanda ya yi yunkurin tabbatar da cewa karyar gaskiya ce ko ma yin cikakken bayani kan abin da ta kasance, kuma babu wani binciken majalisar da ya kai ga cimma matsaya, domin ba a samu komai ba. Levinreed, kamar yadda za mu iya ba da sunan duk ƙungiyar ma'aikatan editan da ta ƙunshi wannan jumloli, ya ƙi ra'ayin cewa wani abu ko da "bai dace ba" an yi shi a ƙoƙarin shawo kansu su aika da ƙarin sojoji don kashe su mutu, amma ba su da'awar cewa irin wannan kokarin da kansa bai dace ba. Ba daidai ba ne ƙungiyar malamai ta yi amfani da kuɗin membobinta don tattaunawa da ƙarin kuɗi ga membobinta. Babban yunƙurin da sojoji ke ba da tallafin PR don neman ƙarin kuɗin soja bai dace ba idan ƙaryar ba ta dace ba. Kuma me ke sa karyar da ba ta dace ba? Mai yiwuwa karyar da Sanatoci ba sa so su yarda da ita.
Kuma ta yaya muka san cewa wadannan Sanatoci biyu sun so jin karya? Domin sun ci gaba da yin karya a sakin layi na biyu:
"Gaskiyar magana ita ce, mun dade muna jayayya cewa hanya mafi kyau na dawo da sojojin mu gida da wuri yayin da suke samun nasara a Afghanistan ita ce gina sojoji da gwamnati masu karfi. Shugaban kasa da yawancin jama'ar Amurka ma haka suke."
A bayyane yake hanya mafi kyau don dawo da sojoji gida da wuri shine a loda su a cikin jiragen sama. Hanya daya da ta tabbata ba za a taba gina gwamnatin Afganistan ba tare da mutunta al'ummar Afghanistan ita ce amfani da sojojin Amurka wajen yin ta. Saka hannun jari a cikin sojoji da gwamnati "mafi karfi" tare da fuskar gida - kamar yadda muka yi a Iraki, Tunisiya, Masar, da Libya, a tsakanin sauran wurare, na iya samun goyon bayan Shugaba Obama, amma hakan da kansa ya yi daidai da goyon bayan jama'ar Amurka? Mu duba.
A cewar kuri'un kamfanoni, Amurkawa suna so rage kashe kashen sojoji, janyewa daga Afghanistan ya tashi, shiga cikin yakin Afghanistan ya ƙare, tunanin yaki ne faruwa mummuna, adawa yakin, tunanin bai kamata mu kasance ba hannu ko kadan, Da kuma ƙi amincewa na yadda shugaban ke tafiyar da yakin.
Ina shaidun da za su goyi bayan da'awar Levinreed? Idan kai ko ni ƙaddamar da op-ed ga Washington Post kuma wani ya ba wa editocin cin hanci don su yi la'akari da shi sosai, za su nemi mu rubuta duk wani da'awar. Anan babu wani takarda ko da aka nuna. Tabbas gaskiya ne cewa waɗannan Sanatoci sun ƙaunaci yaƙi kafin sabon psyop. Tabbas sun yi magana ta wannan hanya don mafi kyawun ɓangaren shekaru goma. Tabbas jama'ar Amurka suna son a janye sojojin. Amma damuwarmu ba wai laifin Sanatoci bane illa KUDIN da suke yi na laifin da ake tafkawa. Kuma shaidar goyon bayanmu don tallafawa ci gabanta tare da fuskar Afghanistan ba ta wanzu.
Haka kuma bai kamata a yaudare mu da tunanin Levinreed na cewa sojojin Afghanistan ne kawai ke cikin hadari a nan ba. Labarin Rollingstone ya bayyana ayyukan psy-op sama da shekara guda da ta gabata, tun lokacin da Levin da Reed suka ba da gudummawar ci gaba da haɓaka yakin Amurka a Afghanistan.
Shin zamu kalli sakin layi na uku da hudu?
"Mun ga lokacin da muka yi tafiya zuwa Afganistan a cikin watan Janairu cewa, Amurka da kawayenmu na Afghanistan da kuma abokanmu na NATO sun samu gagarumin ci gaba wajen mayar da martanin 'yan tada kayar baya, da daukar matakin da kuma taimaka wa 'yan kasar ta Afghanistan wajen tabbatar da makomarsu.
"Yankunan da aka rufe don tafiye-tafiye da kasuwanci a bude suke. Amincewar 'yan Afganistan na karuwa, kuma jami'an tsaron kasar na kara jagorantar ayyukan."
Wannan ya ci karo da juna duk rahoton da ba na soja ba wanda ke fitowa daga Afganistan tun watan Janairu, da kuma a baya. Babu ɗayan sabbin wuraren da aka buɗe suna, babu ɗayan kasuwancin da aka kayyade, babu matakan “kwarin gwiwa” da aka ambata. Ko Pentagon ta fi yawan kiran mataimakanta na Afganistan a matsayin "shugabannin" a cikin ayyuka yana da wuya a sani, amma ba zai zama alamar ci gaba ga zaman lafiya ko adalci ba.
"Ci gaba" ya kasance shekaru aru-aru don ci gaba da yake-yake, amma kada ya zama dalilin kawo karshen su, kullum yana tare da gargadin cewa "ci gaba" yana buƙatar ƙarin ƙoƙari don tabbatar da dorewa. Levinreed ya rubuta:
"Yayin da muka fara juya halin da ake ciki a Afganistan, babu tabbacin ci gaban da muke samu zai ci gaba ko kuma cewa nasarorin da muka samu za su dawwama. Da a ce an ƙirƙiro kalmar 'mai rauni kuma mai yiwuwa' ga Afghanistan."
Ba haka ba. An yi amfani da shi tsawon shekaru millenni ta masu yin yaƙi a duk faɗin duniya.
"Rundunar sojojinmu za su ci gaba da fuskantar hadari da wahalhalu, musamman ma yayin da 'yan Taliban ke sabunta kai hare-hare tare da kawo karshen lokacin sanyi. Sa'an nan kuma, masu tsara manufofi a Washington za su ci gaba da fuskantar zabuka masu wuyar gaske, shawarar fara rage yawan sojojin Amurka a kasar. Afganistan a watan Yuli na nufin cewa dole ne 'yan Afghanistan, Amurka da abokan aikinmu na NATO su shirya cikin gaggawa don mika mulki ga gwamnatin Afghanistan. tashi fada."
Dole ne mu, dole ne mu? Wanene ke da iko a nan, ko yaya?
"Muna fargabar cewa kawancen kasa da kasa na iya gazawa wajen tallafawa tsarin tsaron Afghanistan da zai iya kare al'ummar Afganistan. Muna kuma damu da cewa, yayin da sojojin Amurka ke sauya sheka daga aikin jagoranci zuwa na goyon baya, abubuwan farar hula na manufofin Amurka, ciki har da Harkokin diflomasiyya da ci gaban tattalin arziki, ba za su kasance a shirye su shiga ba kamar yadda ake bukata, musamman idan ba su sami albarkatun da za su yi wannan aiki mai wuyar gaske ba, na iya yin barazana ga nasarorin da mutane da yawa suka yi fama da su Ci gaba da kasancewar Amurka mai girma a nan gaba zai fi yadda za a kashe, a cikin gajeren lokaci, na gina babban sojojin Afghanistan."
Dole ne mu kashe saboda wadanda suka rigaya sun kashe kuma suka mutu, kuma zabinmu ya takaita ga yin haka ta hanyar Afganistan ko kuma kan mu? Wannan yana fitar da zaɓin da Amurkawa ke goyan bayan daga mafi rinjaye na hagu zuwa ga babban taron shan shayi: zaɓin dawo da sojojin gida. Har ila yau, Levinreed yana riƙe da nasara, zaman lafiya, da wadata Iraki a matsayin abin koyi:
"Kwantatawa da Iraki yana da mahimmanci a nan. Iraki na da jami'an tsaro kimanin 665,000 da ke kare al'ummar mutane miliyan 27 da ke da fadin murabba'in kilomita 168,000. Za a bukaci dakarun jami'an tsaron Afghanistan 378,000 don ba da kariya kwatankwacin ga 'yan Afghanistan miliyan 30 da ke bazuwa. fiye da murabba'in mil 250,000 na mafi wahala, filin da ba a haɓaka ba irin wannan haɓaka zai buƙaci ƙarin ƙoƙari da kuɗi."
Shawarwarina? Tambayi David Koch idan yana so ya ba da kuɗi. Tambayi yaranku idan suna son tafiya. Ka bar sauran mu daga ciki.
-
David Swanson shine marubucin "War Is A Lie"
http://facebook.com/pages/David-Swanson/297768373319
http://twitter.com/davidcnswanson
http://youtube.com/afterdowningstreet
ZNetwork ana samun kuɗi ta hanyar karimcin masu karatun sa.
Bada Tallafi