A ranar 1 ga Afrilu, an ba da sanarwar sirri mai shafi 81 wanda tsohon Mataimakin Mataimakin Atoni Janar John Yoo ya rubuta a cikin Maris 2003. A cikin wannan bayanin, Yoo ya shawarci gwamnatin Bush cewa Ma'aikatar Shari'a ta Ofishin Lauyoyin Shari'a ba za ta tilasta
Bayan kwanaki biyu, Cibiyar kare hakkin tsarin mulki ta fitar da wata wasika da ke goyon bayan kiran da NLG ta yi na a kori Yoo da gurfanar da shi gaban kuliya. Babban Darakta na CCR Vincent Warren ya rubuta, "'The'Torture Memo' ba wani abu ne na ilimi ba.
Kwana daya bayan da NLG ta fitar da sanarwar manema labarai, Boalt Hall Dean Christopher Edley, Jr. ya buga wata sanarwa a gidan yanar gizon Boalt Hall, yana mai da martani ga " New York Times (editori na Afrilu 4), Ƙungiyar Lauyoyi ta ƙasa, da ɗaruruwan mutane daga ko'ina cikin duniya" waɗanda suka yi suka ko kuma tambayar Yoo ci gaba da aiki a Boalt Hall.
Dean Edley ya ambaci hakan
Edley ya ji halin Yoo bai yi daidai da na abokan cinikinsa ba, Sakatare Rumsfeld, da al., ko kwatankwacin yadda masu yin tambayoyi ke da nisa a lokaci, matsayi, da wuri." Edley ya rubuta, "Eh, ba komai Yoo ya kasance mai ba da shawara, amma shugaba Bush da nadin tsaron kasa ne suka yanke shawara."
Tabbas, ABC News ta ruwaito a makon da ya gabata cewa Dick Cheney, Condoleezza Rice, Donald Rumsfeld, Colin Powell, George Tenet, da John Ashcroft sun gana a fadar White House kuma sun yi watsi da azabtar da wadanda ake zargi da ta'addanci ta hanyar amincewa da wasu fasahohin azabtarwa irin su shiga ruwa. George W. Bush, babban mai yanke shawara, ya yarda, "eh, ina sane da cewa jami'an tsaron kasarmu sun gana kan wannan batu. Kuma na amince."
Wadannan saman
Amma John Yoo da sauran lauyoyin Sashen Shari'a, da suka hada da David Addington, Jay Bybee, William Haynes da Alberto Gonzales, suma suna da alhakin aikata laifuka iri daya. Sun kasance wani muhimmin sashe na haɗin kai na laifi don keta
Al'amuran Altstoetter kuma na lauyoyin Bush suna da alaƙa iri ɗaya. Dukansu sun yi mu'amala da mutanen da aka tsare a lokacin yaƙi waɗanda ba POWs ba; a cikin duka biyun, yana da kyau a iya gane cewa shawarar da suka bayar za ta haifar da babbar illa ta jiki ko ta hankali ko kuma kisa ga yawancin fursunoni; kuma a cikin duka, shawarar ta kasance kuskure a shari'a. Fiye da mutane 108 ne suka mutu a ciki
Bugu da ƙari kuma, lauyoyin Bush sun shiga cin zarafi na ɗabi'a wanda ya kamata a yi watsi da su. Kamar yadda Makarantar Shari'a ta Jami'ar New York Farfesa Stephen Gilers ya rubuta a The Nation, H. Marshall Jarrett, mai ba da shawara ga Ofishin Ma'aikatar Shari'a ta Ma'aikatar Harkokin Kasuwanci, wanda ke nazarin shawarwarin shari'a da waɗannan lauyoyi suka bayar, "ya kamata su gano cewa wannan aikin bai dace da ka'idodin ƙwararrun da suka shafi lauyoyin Ma'aikatar Shari'a ba."
Ko da Dean Edley ya bayyana ya gane cewa batun John Yoo ba batu ne mai sauƙi na 'yancin ilimi ba, kamar "wasu farfesa kawai yana bayyana ra'ayi mai rikitarwa har ma da matsananciyar ra'ayi."
Kamar yadda shugaban CCR Michael Ratner ya rubuta a cikin littafi mai zuwa, Shari'ar Donald Rumsfeld, "Da a ce an rubuta wadannan ra'ayoyi daban-daban a matsayin makarantar lauya ko aikin ilimi, za a iya la'anta su kawai kuma marubutan su za su kasa ajin su, amma ba za a yi musu laifi ba. Amma ba aikin ilimi ba ne. manyan lauyoyi [kamar John Yoo] a cikin mahallin inda ra'ayoyin ke wakiltar dokar mulki kuma shugaban zai yi aiki da shi wajen tsara manufofin tsare fursunoni. doka ta hanyar tabbatar da aikata wani laifi ta hanyar amfani da maganganun shari'a na karya."
Ba za a taba tunanin cewa babban mai shari'a Michael Mukasey, wanda ya kasance tambarin roba ga haramtacciyar manufofin Bush, zai gurfanar da kowane daga cikin wadannan shugabanni ko lauyoyi a gaban kuliya. Akwai damar cewa babban lauya na gaba zai yi hakan. Barack Obama ya yi alkawarin sa ma’aikatar shari’ar sa da babban mai shari’a “ta gaggauta duba bayanan da ke akwai da kuma gano ko akwai wasu tambayoyi da ya kamata a bi...idan an aikata laifuka, to a bincika su...Yanzu. idan na gano cewa akwai wasu manyan jami’ai da suke sane, suka karya dokokin da ake da su, suna yin rufa-rufa a kan wadannan laifuffuka da ilimi a gaba-gaba, to ina ganin babban ka’ida na Kundin Tsarin Mulkinmu ba wanda ya fi karfin doka.” Ya kamata Majalisa ta soke tanadin dokar kwamitocin soja wanda zai ba wa waɗannan masu yanke hukunci da lauyoyi kariya daga tuhumar azabtarwa da sauran zalunci da aka yi daga Satumba 11, 2001 zuwa Disamba 30, 2005.
Baya ga tuhume-tuhumen laifuffuka, sallamar aiki, da kuma korar John Yoo daga jami’ar Boalt Hall, Jay Bybee, wanda aka ba shi tukuicin shawarar da ya ba shi ba bisa ka’ida ba tare da shari’ar tarayya, ya kamata a cire shi daga benci ta hanyar tsige shi.
Lokaci yayi da rashin hukunta gwamnatin Bush zai kawo karshe.
Marjorie Cohn farfesa ce a
ZNetwork ana samun kuɗi ta hanyar karimcin masu karatun sa.
Bada Tallafi