ASchwartz ya kasance matsala. Jarumar fina-finan Isra'ila kuma tsohuwar jami'ar leken asirin sojojin sama ta New York Times ta ba ta aiki tare da dan uwan abokin aikinta Adam Sella da kuma tsohon dan jaridar Times Jeffrey Gettleman kan binciken cin zarafin da Hamas ta yi a ranar 7 ga Oktoba wanda zai iya sake fasalin yadda duniya ta fahimta. Yakin da Isra'ila ke ci gaba da yi a zirin Gaza. Ya zuwa watan Nuwamba, adawa a duniya na dada karuwa game da yakin sojin Isra'ila, wanda ya riga ya kashe dubban yara, mata, da tsofaffi. A shafinta na sada zumunta, wanda jaridar Times ta ce haka ne yin bita, Schwartz na son tweet yana cewa Isra’ila tana bukatar “ta mayar da tsirin zuwa wurin yanka.”
"Ku keta kowane al'ada, a kan hanyar zuwa nasara," karanta sakon. "Wadanda a gabanmu dabbobi ne na mutane waɗanda ba sa shakkar keta ƙa'idodi kaɗan."
The New York Times, duk da haka, yana da dokoki da ka'idoji. Schwartz ba shi da gogewar rahoto a baya. Abokin aikinta mai bayar da rahoto Gettleman ya bayyana mata abubuwan da suka dace, Schwartz ya ce a cikin faifan podcast hira a ranar 3 ga Janairu, tashar tashar Isra'ila ta 12 ta samar kuma an gudanar da ita cikin Ibrananci.
Gettleman, in ji ta, ya damu da cewa "suna samun aƙalla tushe guda biyu don kowane cikakken bayani da muka sanya a cikin labarin, bincika bayanan. Shin muna da shaidar bincike? Shin muna da shaidar gani? Baya ga gaya wa mai karatunmu 'hakan ya faru,' me za mu ce? Za mu iya gaya mana abin da ya faru da wa?
Schwartz ta ce tun da farko ta hakura da daukar aikin saboda ba ta son kallon hotunan da za a iya kai mata hari kuma saboda ba ta da kwarewar gudanar da irin wannan bincike.
“Wadanda aka yi wa lalata su ne matan da suka fuskanci wani abu, sannan su zo su zauna a gaban irin wannan mace. - ko wanene ni?” Ta ce. "Ba ni da cancanta."
Duk da haka, ta fara aiki tare da Gettleman akan labarin, ta bayyana a cikin hirar podcast. Gettleman, wakilin Pulitzer wanda ya lashe lambar yabo, wakilin kasa da kasa ne, kuma idan aka tura shi ofishin, yana aiki da mataimakan labarai da masu zaman kansu kan labarai. A wannan yanayin, majiyoyin ɗakin labarai da yawa waɗanda suka saba da tsarin sun ce, Schwartz da Sella sun yi mafi yawan rahoton ƙasa, yayin da Gettleman ya mai da hankali kan tsarawa da rubutu.
Sakamakon rahoton, wanda aka buga a ƙarshen Disamba, yana kan taken "'Screams Without Words': Yadda Hamas ta yi amfani da makamai masu linzami a ranar 7 ga Oktoba." Harin bama-bamai ne da kuma rura wutar yakin da Isra'ila ke yi a daidai lokacin da wasu kawayen Isra'ila ke nuna damuwarsu kan yadda take kashe fararen hula a Gaza. A cikin dakin labarai, labarin ya gamu da yabo daga shugabannin editoci amma sauran 'yan jaridar Times sun sha shakku. Podcast na jaridar “The Daily” ya yi ƙoƙarin mayar da labarin zuwa wani shiri, amma bai sami damar yin bincike na gaskiya ba, kamar yadda The Intercept a baya. ruwaito. (A cikin wata sanarwa da aka samu bayan bugawa, mai magana da yawun Times ya ce, "Ba a kashe wani labari na yau da kullun ba saboda gazawar tantance gaskiya.")
Tsoron da ke cikin ma'aikatan Times da suka yi suka game da labaran Gaza na jaridar shine cewa Schwartz zai zama abin kunya ga abin da ya fi zurfi. Tana iya ɗaukar ƙiyayya ga Falasɗinawa, ba ta da gogewa game da aikin jarida na bincike, kuma tana jin matsin lamba tsakanin kasancewa mai goyon bayan ƙoƙarin yaƙin Isra'ila da mai ba da rahoto na Times, amma Schwartz ba ta ba kanta da Sella ba da rahoton ɗaya daga cikin labaran da suka haifar da yakin. . Babban jagoranci a New York Times ya yi.
Schwartz ya ce da yawa a cikin wani hira tare da Rediyon Sojojin Isra'ila a ranar 31 ga Disamba. "The New York Times ta ce, 'Bari mu yi bincike kan cin zarafi na jima'i' - ya kasance mafi yawan shari'ar da za su gamsar da ni," in ji ta. Mai masaukin nata ya yanke ta: "Shawara ce ta New York Times, duka?"
“Ba tare da shakka ba. Ba tare da shakka ba. Babu shakka. Tabbas,” in ji ta. "Takardar ta tsaya a bayanmu kashi 200 kuma ta ba mu lokaci, zuba jari, albarkatun da za mu yi zurfin bincike kan wannan binciken gwargwadon bukata."
Jim kadan bayan barkewar yakin, wasu editoci da ‘yan jarida sun yi korafin cewa ka’idojin Times sun hana su kiran Hamas a matsayin “’yan ta’adda”. Dalilin da ya fito daga sashin ma'auni, wanda Philip Corbett ya gudanar na tsawon shekaru 14, ya dade da cewa Hamas ita ce mai kula da wani yanki na musamman, maimakon kungiyar ta'addanci mara kasa. Kashe farar hula da gangan, aka tafi gardama, bai isa a lakabi wata kungiya ta 'yan ta'adda ba, saboda wannan lakabin na iya aiki sosai.
Corbett, bayan 7 ga Oktoba, ya kare manufofin a fuskantar matsin lamba, majiyoyin dakin labarai sun ce, amma ya sha kashi. A ranar 19 ga Oktoba, imel ya fita a madadin Babban Editan Joe Kahn yana cewa Corbett ya tambaya don ja da baya daga matsayinsa. "Bayan shekaru 14 a matsayin ma'auni na Times, Phil Corbett ya gaya mana cewa zai so ya koma baya kuma ya bar wani ya dauki nauyin jagoranci a wannan muhimmin kokarin." Shugabancin Times yayi bayani. Majiyoyin dakunan labarai guda uku sun ce matakin yana da nasaba da matsin lamba da ya ke yi na sassauta labaran da Isra'ila ta yi. Daya daga cikin shafukan sada zumunta Schwartz ya so, yana haifar da bita na Times, ya sanya batun cewa, don manufar farfagandar Isra'ila, Hamas ya kamata a kwatanta shi a kowane lokaci da Islamic State. Wani mai magana da yawun Times ya gaya wa The Intercept, "Fahimtar ku game da Phil Corbett ba gaskiya bane." A cikin wata sanarwa da aka samu bayan bugawa, "Phil ya nemi ya canza mukamai kafin Joe Kahn ya zama editan zartarwa a watan Yuni 2022. Kuma ba shi da alaƙa da takaddama kan ɗaukar hoto."
Tun bayan bayyanar da ayyukan da Schwartz ya yi a kafafen sada zumunta na baya-bayan nan, layinta bai bayyana a cikin takarda ba kuma ba ta halarci tarurrukan edita ba. Jaridar ta ce ana ci gaba da bita a kafafen sada zumunta na “likes” nata. "Waɗannan 'masu son'' cin zarafi ne da ba za a yarda da su ba na manufofin kamfaninmu," in ji mai magana da yawun Times.
Babbar abin kunya na iya zama rahoton da kanta, da tsarin da ya ba da damar buga shi, da kuma tasirin da rahoton ya yi ga dubban Falasdinawa da aka tabbatar da mutuwarsu ta hanyar cin zarafi na lalata da Hamas da jaridar ta yi iƙirarin fallasa.
Wani dan jaridar Times mai takaici wanda kuma ya yi aiki a matsayin edita a wurin ya ce, "Yawancin mayar da hankali za a fahimta, daidai, za a ba da umarni ga Schwartz amma wannan a bayyane yake yanke shawara mara kyau na edita wanda ke lalata duk sauran manyan ayyukan da ake yi ba tare da gajiyawa ba a cikin takarda. - duka suna da alaƙa kuma gaba ɗaya ba su da alaƙa da yaƙi - wanda ke kula da ƙalubalantar masu karatunmu da cika ka'idodinmu. "
"Yawancin mayar da hankali za a fahimta a bayyane, daidai, a ba da umarni ga Schwartz amma wannan shine mafi ƙarancin yanke shawara na edita."
Tattaunawar podcast ta Channel 12 tare da Schwartz, wacce Intercept ta fassara daga Ibrananci, ta buɗe taga cikin tsarin ba da rahoto kan labarin da ke da cece-kuce kuma yana nuna cewa manufar New York Times ita ce ta ƙarfafa labarin da aka ƙaddara.
A cikin martani ga tambayoyin The Intercept game da hirar podcast na Schwartz, mai magana da yawun jaridar New York Times ya mayar da baya kan yadda labarin ya nuna cewa Hamas ta yi amfani da makamin lalata don da'awar cewa "watakila an yi amfani da su ta hanyar lalata."
Editan Times International Phil Pan ya ce a cikin wata sanarwa cewa ya tsaya kan aikin. “Ms. Schwartz wani bangare ne na tsauraran rahotanni da tsarin gyarawa," in ji shi. "Ta ba da gudummawa mai mahimmanci kuma ba mu ga wata alama ta nuna son kai a cikin aikinta ba. Muna da kwarin guiwa kan sahihancin rahotanninmu kuma mun tsaya kan binciken ƙungiyar. Amma kamar yadda muka ce, 'masu son' ta na abubuwan ban haushi da ra'ayi a shafukan sada zumunta, wadanda suka fara aiki da mu, ba za a amince da su ba."
Bayan da aka buga wannan labarin, Schwartz, wanda bai amsa bukatar yin sharhi ba, tweeted don gode wa Times don "tsaye a bayan mahimman labarun da muka buga." Ta kara da cewa, "Hare-haren da aka kai mani na baya-bayan nan ba zai hana ni ci gaba da aiki na ba." Da take jawabi a shafukanta na sada zumunta, Schwartz ta ce, "Na fahimci dalilin da ya sa mutanen da ba su san ni ba suka yi fushi da 'kamar' da na danna a kan 10/7 kuma ina neman afuwar hakan." Akalla uku daga cikin "likes" nata sun kasance magana of jama'a bincika.
A cikin hirar faifan bidiyo, Schwartz ta ba da cikakken bayani game da ƙoƙarinta na samun tabbaci daga asibitocin Isra'ila, cibiyoyin rikicin fyade, wuraren warkewa daga rauni, da layukan jima'i a Isra'ila, da kuma gazawarta ta samun tabbaci guda ɗaya daga ɗayansu. "An gaya mata cewa babu wani korafi da aka yi game da cin zarafi," in ji kakakin Times bayan The Intercept ta gabatar da shirin faifan bidiyo na Channel 12 ga jaridar. “Wannan shine kawai matakin farko na bincikenta. Daga nan sai ta yi bayanin bayyanar shaidu, shaidu, da kuma shaidun da ke nuna cewa akwai yuwuwar an yi amfani da su ta hanyar lalata da su,” in ji kakakin. "Tana dalla-dalla matakan bincikenta kuma ta jaddada tsauraran matakan Times don tabbatar da shaida, da kuma ganawa da manema labarai da masu gyara don tattauna tambayoyin bincike da tunani mai zurfi game da labarin."
Tambayar ba ta taɓa kasancewa ba ko wani harin jima'i na mutum na iya faruwa a ranar 7 ga Oktoba. Yin fyade ba sabon abu ba ne a cikin yaki, kuma akwai wasu fararen hula da dama da suka kwarara zuwa Isra'ila daga Gaza a wannan rana a cikin "gudanar ruwa na biyu," suna ba da gudummawa ga kuma shiga cikin tashin hankali da tashin hankali. Batu na tsakiya shine ko jaridar New York Times ta gabatar da kwararan hujjoji don tallafawa da'awarta cewa akwai sabbin bayanai da aka bayar da rahoton "tabbatar da cewa hare-haren da ake kaiwa mata ba wai abubuwan da suka faru ba ne amma wani bangare ne na babban tsarin cin zarafin jinsi a ranar 7 ga Oktoba" - Wani ikirari ya bayyana a cikin kanun labarai cewa, da gangan Hamas ta tura cin zarafin mata a matsayin makamin yaki.
Schwartz ya fara mata yi aiki a kan tashin hankali na Oktoba 7 inda mutum zai yi tsammani, ta hanyar kira a kusa da wuraren da aka keɓe na "Room 4" a cikin asibitocin Isra'ila 11 da ke bincika da kuma kula da wadanda ke fama da tashin hankali, ciki har da fyade. "Abu na farko na kira su duka, kuma sun gaya mani, 'A'a, ba a sami wani korafi na cin zarafi ba," in ji ta a cikin hirar podcast. “Na yi hira da yawa da ba su kai ko’ina ba. Kamar, zan je kowane nau'in asibitocin tabin hankali, in zauna a gaban ma'aikatan, dukkansu sun jajirce wajen aikin kuma babu wanda ya gamu da wanda aka yi masa fyade."
Mataki na gaba shi ne a kira manajan layin cin zarafi a kudancin Isra’ila, wanda bai yi amfani ba. Manajan ya shaida mata cewa ba su da rahoton cin zarafin mata. Ta bayyana kiran a matsayin "mahaukacin zance mai zurfi" inda ta danna kan takamaiman batutuwa. “Ko akwai wanda ya kira ki? Kin ji wani abu?” Ta tuno tana tambaya. "Yaya zai zama ba ku yi ba?"
Yayin da Schwartz ta fara ƙoƙarinta na nemo shaidar cin zarafi ta hanyar jima'i, takamaiman zarge-zargen fyade na farko ya fara bayyana. Wani mutum da aka bayyana a cikin hirarrakin da ba a bayyana sunansa ba a matsayin ma’aikacin jinya daga sashin kula da lafiya na rundunar sojojin saman Isra’ila mai lamba 669 ya ce ya ga shaidar cewa wasu ‘yan mata biyu a Kibbutz Nahal Oz an yi musu fyade tare da kashe su a cikin ɗakin kwana. Mutumin ya yi wasu munanan ikirari, duk da haka, wanda ya sanya ayar tambaya game da rahoton nasa. Ya yi iƙirarin cewa wani mai ceto ya “fito daga cikin datti” jaririn da aka caka masa wuka sau da yawa. Ya kuma ce ya ga "Jumlolin Larabci da aka rubuta a kan hanyoyin shiga gidaje… tare da jinin mutanen da ke zaune a gidajen." Babu irin waɗannan saƙonnin, kuma labarin jaririn a cikin kwandon shara ya kasance dabarun. Babbar matsalar ita ce babu 'yan mata biyu a kibbutz da suka dace da bayanin majiyar. A cikin tambayoyin nan gaba, ya canza wurin zuwa Kibbutz Beeri. Amma babu wanda aka kashe a wurin da ya yi daidai da bayanin ko dai, kamar yadda Mondoweiss ruwaito.
Bayan ya ga wadannan tambayoyin, Schwartz ya fara kiran mutane a Kibbutz Be'eri da sauran kibbutzim da aka yi niyya a ranar 7 ga Oktoba a kokarin gano labarin. “Ba komai. Babu komai,” in ji ta. "Ba wanda ya gani ko ya ji wani abu." Daga nan sai ta isa sashin ma’aikatan lafiya na 669 wanda ya ba wa Schwartz labarin daya ba da labarin da ya ba wasu kafafen yada labarai, wanda ta ce ya gamsu da cewa akwai wani tsari na cin zarafin jima’i. “Na ce, ‘Ok, haka ta faru, mutum daya ya ga abin ya faru a Be’eri, don haka ba za a iya zama mutum daya ba, domin ‘yan mata biyu ne. Yan uwa mata ne. Yana cikin daki. Wani abu game da shi tsari ne, wani abu game da shi yana ji a gare ni cewa ba bazuwar ba ne,” Schwartz ya kammala a kan faifan podcast.
Schwartz ta ce daga nan ta fara tattaunawa da jami'an Isra'ila daga Zaka, wata kungiyar ceto mai zaman kanta mai tsattsauran ra'ayi wacce ta kasance. rubuce don yin kuskuren shaida kuma ya yada da yawa labaran karya game da abubuwan da suka faru a ranar 7 ga Oktoba, ciki har da zargin da ake yi na cewa jami'an Hamas sun fille kawunan jarirai da yanke tayin daga jikin mace mai ciki. Ma'aikatanta ba ƙwararrun masana kimiyya ba ne ko ƙwararrun wuraren aikata laifuka. "Idan muka shiga gida, muna amfani da tunaninmu," ya ce Yossi Landau, babban jami’in Zaka, ya bayyana irin ayyukan kungiyar a wuraren da aka kai harin ranar 7 ga Oktoba. "Gawawwakin suna gaya mana abin da ya faru, abin da ya faru ke nan." Landau yana cikin rahoton Times, kodayake ba a ambaci nasa ba rubuce-rubuce sosai tarihin yada labarai masu ban sha'awa na zalunci da aka tabbatar da karya. Schwartz ta ce a cikin hirar da aka yi da ita ta farko, mambobin Zaka ba su yi wani takamaiman zarge-zargen fyade ba, amma ta bayyana yanayin gawarwakin da suka ce sun gani. “Sun ce mini, ‘Eh, mun ga mata tsirara,’ ko kuma ‘Mun ga mace marar riga. Dukansu tsirara ne ba tare da rigar kamfai ba, kuma an ɗaure su da zip. Kuma wani lokacin ba zip tie ba, wani lokacin igiya ko igiyar hoodie.”
Schwartz ya ci gaba da neman shaida a wurare daban-daban da aka kai harin kuma bai samu shaidar da ke tabbatar da labaran fyade ba. "Saboda haka na bincika da yawa a cikin kibbutzim, kuma baya ga wannan shaidar [ma'aikacin jinya na Isra'ila] da kuma nan da can, mutanen Zaka - labaran, kamar, ba su fito daga can ba," in ji ta.
Yayin da ta ci gaba da yin aiki da wayoyi tare da jami'an ceto, Schwartz ta ga hirarraki cewa tashoshi na labarai na duniya sun fara yawo tare da Shari Mendes, wani masanin gine-ginen Ba'amurke wanda ke aiki a rukunin rabbai na Sojojin Isra'ila. Mendes, wanda aka tura dakin ajiye gawawwaki don shirya gawarwakin da za a binne bayan harin na ranar 7 ga Oktoba, ya yi ikirarin cewa ya ga kwararan hujjoji na cin zarafi.
"Mun ga shaidar fyade," in ji Mendes a daya hira. “An karye ƙashin ƙugu, kuma ana ɗaukar abubuwa da yawa don karya ƙashin ƙugu… kuma wannan yana cikin kakanni har zuwa ƙanana. Wannan ba wani abu ne da muka gani a intanet ba, mun ga wadannan gawarwakin da idanunmu." Mendes ya kasance mai girma a ko'ina cikin Isra'ila gwamnatin da kuma manyan kafofin watsa labaru, labarai akan cin zarafin jima'i a ranar 7 ga Oktoba, duk da cewa ta yi babu likita ko bincike takardun shaida don tantance fyade bisa doka. Ta kuma yi magana game da wasu tashe-tashen hankula a ranar 7 ga Oktoba, ga jaridar Daily Mail a watan Oktoba, "An yanke wani jariri daga cikin mace mai ciki aka fille kansa sannan aka fille kan mahaifiyar." Babu wata mace mai ciki da ta mutu a ranar, a cewar jaridar official list na Isra'ila na wadanda aka kashe a hare-haren, da kuma kungiyar bincike mai zaman kanta ta ranar 7 ga Oktoba ya ce Labarin Mendes karya ne.
"Na ci gaba da yin mamaki ko da yaushe na ji labarin fyade kuma na ga fyade kuma in yi tunani a kansa, ko don kawai na kai ga hakan."
Bayan da Schwartz ta ga hirarraki da Mendes, ta ƙara da tabbacin cewa labarin fyade na yau da kullun gaskiya ne. "Ina kama - wow, menene wannan?" Ta tuno. "Kuma yana ji a gare ni kamar ya fara kusantar jama'a, koda kuwa ba ku san adadin da za ku saka ba tukuna."
A lokaci guda kuma, Schwartz ta ce tana jin sabani a wasu lokuta, tana mamakin ko ta gamsu da gaskiyar wannan babban labarin ne domin tana neman hujjar da za ta goyi bayan da'awar. "Na ci gaba da yin tunani ko da yaushe na ji labarin fyade kuma na ga fyade kuma in yi tunani a kai, ko don kawai na kai ga hakan," in ji ta. Ta kawar da wadancan shakku a gefe. A lokacin da Schwartz ya yi hira da Mendes, labarin ma'aikacin tsaro na IDF ya yi tashe a duniya kuma an yi watsi da shi gabaɗaya: Ba a yanke wani jariri daga uwa aka fille kansa ba. Duk da haka Schwartz da New York Times za su ci gaba da dogara ga shaidar Mendes, da na sauran shaidu da ke da tarihin yin da'awar da ba za a iya dogara da su ba da kuma rashin cikakkun takaddun shaida. Ba a ambaci tambayoyi game da amincin Mendes ba.
How Schwartz ya sauka a cikin irin wannan matsayi na ban mamaki a wani muhimmin lokaci a cikin yakin ba a bayyana gaba daya ba. Kafin shiga cikin Times a matsayin babban faɗuwar ƙarshe, Sella ɗan jarida ne mai zaman kansa wanda ke ba da labarai kan batutuwan da suka haɗa da "abinci, daukar hoto, da al'adu zuwa ƙoƙarin zaman lafiya, tattalin arziki, da kuma sana'a," a cewar LinkedIn. Cikakken Bayani. Sella ta farko Haɗin gwiwa tare da Gettleman, wanda aka buga a ranar 14 ga Oktoba, ya duba irin raunin da ɗalibai a wata jami’a a kudancin Isra’ila suka fuskanta. Ga Schwartz, layinta na farko ya sauka a ranar 14 ga Nuwamba.
"Jami'an 'yan sandan Isra'ila sun ba da ƙarin shaida a ranar Talata na ta'asar da aka aikata a lokacin harin da Hamas ta kai a ranar 7 ga Oktoba, inda suka ce sun tattara shaidu fiye da dubu ɗaya da waɗanda suka tsira game da cin zarafin jima'i da sauran cin zarafi." Schwartz ya ruwaito. Labarin ya ci gaba da ambato babban jami’in ‘yan sandan Isra’ila, Kobi Shabtai, yana bayyana dimbin shaidun kisan gilla da cin zarafin mata a ranar 7 ga Oktoba.
Shabtai ya ce a cikin labarin Schwartz, "Wannan shi ne bincike mafi girma da Isra'ila ta taba sani, yana mai alkawarin ba da dadewa ba za a samar da kwararan hujjoji.
Lokacin da Times daga baya ta fitar da tabbataccen bincikenta na "Screams Without Words", duk da haka, Schwartz da abokan aikinta sun ba da rahoton cewa, sabanin iƙirarin Shabtai, shaidar da ta tabbatar da cin zarafin jima'i ba ta wanzu. Ba tare da amincewa da maganganun Shabtai da suka gabata a cikin Times ba, jaridar ta ruwaito cewa jana'izar da sauri bisa ga al'adar Yahudawa na nufin ba a adana shaida. Masana sun gaya wa Times cewa cin zarafin jima'i a yaƙe-yaƙe sau da yawa yana barin "iyakantaccen shaida."
A cikin faifan podcast, Schwartz ta ce matakinta na gaba shi ne ta je wani sabon wurin jiyya da aka kafa don magance raunin da aka samu a ranar 7 ga Oktoba, musamman wadanda suka jimre da kisan gilla a bikin kida na Nova. An buɗe mako guda bayan harin, wurin ya fara maraba ɗaruruwan waɗanda suka tsira inda za su iya neman shawarwari, yin yoga, da karɓar madadin magani, da kuma acupuncture, warkarwa mai kyau, da jiyya na reflexology. Sun kira shi Merhav Marpe, ko Healing Space.
A cikin ziyartan Merhav Marpe da yawa, Schwartz ta sake cewa a cikin hirar podcast cewa ba ta sami wata shaida kai tsaye na fyade ko cin zarafi ba. Ta bayyana takaicin ta ga masu aikin jinya da masu ba da shawara a wurin, tana mai cewa sun tsunduma cikin "makircin shiru." "Kowa, har ma da wadanda suka ji irin wadannan abubuwa daga mutane, sun ji matukar sadaukar da kansu ga majinyatan su, ko ma kawai ga mutanen da suka taimaka wa majinyatan su, ba don bayyana abubuwa ba," in ji ta.
A ƙarshe, Schwartz ya zo da baƙar fata kawai da maganganun gabaɗaya daga masu ilimin hanyoyin kwantar da hankali game da yadda mutane ke aiwatar da rauni, gami da cin zarafin jima'i da fyade. Ta ce wadanda abin ya shafa na iya jin kunyar magana, fuskantar laifin wadanda suka tsira, ko kuma har yanzu suna cikin kaduwa. "Wataƙila kuma saboda al'ummar Isra'ila na da ra'ayin mazan jiya, akwai wasu sha'awar yin shiru game da wannan batu na lalata," in ji Schwartz. Ta kara da cewa, "A kan wannan, mai yiwuwa akwai karin girman bangaren addini da na kasa, cewa wani dan ta'adda ne ya aikata hakan." "Akwai da yawa da yadudduka da suka sa shi ya sa ba su yi magana ba."
A cewar jaridar Times da aka buga, "Masu kwantar da hankali biyu sun ce suna aiki tare da wata mata da aka yi wa fyade ga dangi a cikin rabe kuma ba ta da wani sharadi na yin magana da masu bincike ko 'yan jarida."
Schwartz ta ce ta mai da hankali kan kibbutzim ne saboda da farko ta yanke shawarar cewa ba za a iya yin lalata da su ba a bikin wakokin Nova. "Na yi matukar shakku cewa lamarin ya faru ne a yankin jam'iyyar, saboda duk wanda na yi magana da shi a cikin wadanda suka tsira sun fada min wani korafe-korafe, da kabilanci, kamar, game da ƙaura daga wuri zuwa wuri," in ji ta. "Ta yaya za su kasance (suna da lokaci) don yin rikici da mace, kamar - ba zai yiwu ba. Ko dai ka ɓoye, ko kai - ko ka mutu. Hakanan na jama'a ne, Nova… irin wannan wurin budewa."
Schwartz ya kalli hirarraki Raz Cohen wanda ya halarci bikin Nova ya ba wa kafofin watsa labaru na duniya. Wani tsohon sojan Isra'ila na musamman, Cohen ya yi hira da yawa game da fyade da ya ce ya gani. Bayan 'yan kwanaki bayan harin, ya ce PBS NewsHour cewa ya shaidi fyade da yawa. “’Yan ta’adda, mutanen Gaza, sun yi wa ‘yan mata fyade. Kuma bayan sun yi musu fyade, sun kashe su, sun kashe su da wukake, ko akasin haka, an kashe su - kuma bayan sun yi fyade, sun yi hakan," in ji shi. A wani bayyanar da CNN a ranar 4 ga Janairu, ya aka bayyana ganin yadda aka yi wa fyade guda daya kuma ya ce maharan "mutane biyar ne - farar hula biyar daga Gaza, mutane na yau da kullun, ba sojoji ba, ba Nukhba ba," suna nufin manyan kwamandojin Hamas. "Mutanen Gaza ne na yau da kullun da tufafi na yau da kullun."
A cikin hirar Cohen da Schwartz na Times:
Ya ce sai ya ga wasu mutane biyar sanye da kayan farar hula, dukkansu dauke da wukake, daya kuma dauke da guduma, suna jan wata mata a kasa. Yarinya ce, tsirara tana kururuwa.
'Duk sun taru a kusa da ita,' in ji Mista Cohen. 'Tana tsaye. Suka fara yi mata fyade. Na ga mutanen a tsaye a cikin rabin da'irar kewaye da ita. Daya ratsa ta. Tayi ihu. Har yanzu ina tuna muryarta, tana kururuwa ba tare da magana ba.
"Sai ɗaya daga cikinsu ya ɗaga wuka," in ji shi, "sai kawai suka yanka ta."
Wannan hirar ce ta bai wa Times takenta: "'Screams without Words': Yadda Hamas ta yi amfani da makamai masu linzami a ranar 7 ga Oktoba." Cohen ya bayyana cewa wadanda ake zargi da kai harin da cewa ba mambobin Hamas ba ne ya karya labarin, amma har yanzu bai canza ba. The Times bai yi magana game da iƙirarin da Cohen ya yi a baya ba cewa ya ga yadda ake yi wa fyade da yawa.
Schwartz ya fada a cikin hirar faifan bidiyo cewa, tun da jaridar Times ta dage a kan akalla majiyoyi biyu, ta bukaci Cohen ya ba ta bayanan tuntubar sauran mutanen da yake boye da su a cikin daji, ta yadda za ta iya tabbatar da labarinsa na fyaden. Ta tuno, “Raz ya buya. A cikin daji kusa da shi yana kwance abokinsa Shoam. Suna isa wannan daji. Akwai wasu mutane biyu a gefe guda suna kallon wancan gefe, kuma wani, na biyar, mutum. Mutane biyar a daji guda. Raz ne kawai yake ganin duk abubuwan da yake gani, kowa yana kallo ta wata hanya dabam. "
Duk da cewa a cikin faifan bidiyo cewa Cohen ne kawai ya shaida taron kuma sauran suna kallo ta bangarori daban-daban, a cikin labarin Times Shoam Gueta an gabatar da shi a matsayin shaida mai tabbatar da fyaden: “Ya ce ya ga akalla mutane hudu sun fito daga cikin motar. kuma suka kai wa matar hari, wanda ya ƙare 'tsakanin kafafunsu.' Ya ce suna ta zance, suna dariya da ihu, kuma daya daga cikinsu ya caka mata wuka akai-akai, yana yanka ta a zahiri.” Gueta bai ambaci shaidar fyade a wata mata ba. hira ya yi da NBC News a ranar 8 ga Oktoba, kwana guda bayan harin, amma ya bayyana yadda aka kashe wata mata da wuka. "Mun ga 'yan ta'adda suna kashe mutane, kona motoci, suna ihu a ko'ina," Gueta ya shaida wa NBC. "Idan ka ce wani abu kawai, idan ka yi wani surutu, za a kashe ka." Daga baya Gueta ya tura zuwa Gaza tare da IDF kuma ya buga da yawa videos A kan TikTok da kansa yana yawo a gidajen Falasdinawa. Cohen da Gueta ba su amsa buƙatun yin sharhi ba.
Shafin mai zaman kansa Duban Gaskiya 7 ga Oktoba, Mondoweiss, da ‘yan jarida Ali Abunimah na Intifada na Electronic da kuma Max Blumenthal na The Grayzone sun nuna rashin daidaituwa da sabani da yawa a cikin labarun da aka bayar a cikin rahoton Times, ciki har da asusun Cohen, wanda da farko ya ce "ya zaɓi kada ya duba, amma yana jin su suna dariya akai-akai."
Karkashin matsin lamba na ciki don kare gaskiyar labarin, Times ta sake sanya Gettleman, Schwartz, da Sella don sake ba da rahoton labarin yadda ya kamata, wanda ya haifar da labarin da aka buga a ranar 29 ga Janairu. Cohen. ya ki yin magana da su, sun ba da rahoto: “Da aka tambaye shi a wannan watan dalilin da ya sa bai ambaci fyade da farko ba, Mista Cohen ya ba da misali da damuwar da ya fuskanta, kuma ya ce a cikin sakon da ya aike masa ta wayar salula cewa a lokacin bai gane cewa yana daya daga cikin tsirarun shaidun da suka tsira ba. Ya ki sake yin hira da shi, yana mai cewa yana kokarin murmurewa daga halin da ya shiga ciki.”
Baya ga shaidar Cohen, Schwartz ta fada a gidan talabijin na Channel 12 cewa, ta kuma kalli bidiyon tambayar wani fursunonin Falasdinu da IDF ta dauka wanda ta ce 'yan matan da maharan Falasdinawan suka ja su cikin dazuzzuka a kusa da bikin Nova. Ta kuma ji haushi, in ji ta, ta wani faifan hirar da ta gani a watan Nuwamba a wani taron manema labarai da jami'an Isra'ila suka shirya, wanda ya zama abin mayar da hankali kan labarinta na Times na farko.
Wani akawun mai suna Sapir ya bayyana wani yanayi mai ban sha'awa na fyade da yankan rago, kuma Schwartz ta ce ta gamsu da cewa akwai wani shiri na lalata da Hamas. "Shaidar ta hauka ce, kuma gashi, kuma babba, kuma dabbanci," in ji Schwartz. "Kuma ba kawai fyade ba - fyade ne, da yankewa, kuma ... kuma na gane cewa babban labari ne fiye da yadda na zato, [tare da] wurare da yawa, sannan hoton ya fara bayyana, Menene ke faruwa a nan?"
Rahoton na Times ya ce sun yi hira da Sapir na tsawon sa’o’i biyu a wani wurin shan magani a kudancin Isra’ila, kuma ta bayyana yadda ta ga yadda ake yi mata fyade da dama, ciki har da lamarin da wani maharin ya yi wa wata mata fyade yayin da wani ya yanke mata nono da yankan akwati.
A taron manema labarai da aka yi a watan Nuwamba, hukumomin Isra'ila sun ce suna tattarawa da kuma nazarin kayan aikin da za su tabbatar da cikakken bayanan Sapir. "'Yan sanda sun ce har yanzu suna tattara shaidu (DNA da dai sauransu) daga wadanda aka yi wa fyade baya ga shaidun gani da ido don gina shari'ar mafi karfi," In ji wakilin wanda ya ba da labarin taron manema labarai. Irin wannan yanayin zai haifar da adadi mai yawa na shaida na zahiri, duk da haka jami'an Isra'ila, har yau, ba su iya ba da shi ba. "Ina da kwakkwaran shaida, amma a karshe, ya zama wajibi na ne in nemo shaidun da ke tabbatar da labarinta da gano sunayen wadanda abin ya shafa," ya ce Sufeto Adi Edri, jami'in Isra'ila da ke jagorantar binciken cin zarafin mata a ranar 7 ga Oktoba, mako guda bayan rahoton Times ya shiga yanar gizo. "A wannan matakin, ba ni da takamaiman jikin."
A cikin faifan bidiyo na Channel 12, an tambayi Schwartz ko akwai shaidar matan da suka tsira daga fyade a ranar 7 ga Oktoba. "Ba zan iya magana da gaske game da wannan ba, amma yawancin matan da aka yi wa lalata a ranar 7 ga Oktoba an harbe su nan da nan, kuma a nan ne [inda] manyan lambobi suke," in ji ta. “Yawancin gawawwaki ne. Wasu matan sun yi nasarar tserewa sun tsira.” Ta kara da cewa, "Na san cewa akwai wani muhimmin abu na rabuwar aure idan ya zo ga cin zarafi. Don haka sau da yawa ba sa tunawa. Ba su tuna komai. Suna tunawa da ɓangarorin abubuwan da suka faru, kuma ba koyaushe za su iya kwatanta yadda suka ƙare a hanya da [yadda aka cece su] ba.”
A farkon watan Disamba, jami'an Isra'ila sun kaddamar da wani gagarumin gangami a bainar jama'a, inda suka zargi kasashen duniya da musamman shugabannin mata da yin shiru kan yadda ake fuskantar cin zarafi na lalata da kungiyar Hamas ta kai a ranar 7 ga Oktoba. Ƙoƙarin PR ya kasance A ranar 4 ga watan Disamba a Majalisar Dinkin Duniya. tare da wani taron da jakadan Isra'ila da tsohuwar jami'ar Meta Sheryl Sandberg suka shirya. Kungiyoyin mata da masu goyon bayan Isra'ila suka kai wa hari, an kama su da hannu dumu-dumu, saboda tuhume-tuhumen da ake yi na cin zarafi ba ya yadu a ko'ina.
An kuma ambato Sandberg yana kai hari ga kungiyoyin kare hakkin mata a cikin labarin 4 ga Disamba na New York Times, mai taken "Abin da muka sani game da cin zarafin jima'i a lokacin harin 7 ga Oktoba a Isra'ila" kuma wanda littafinsa ya zo daidai da kaddamar da yakin PR a Majalisar Dinkin Duniya Labarin, wanda Gettleman, Schwartz, da Sella suka ruwaito, ya dogara da ikirarin da aka yi. Jami'an Isra'ila kuma sun yarda cewa Times ba ta iya tabbatar da zargin ba. Daga baya an haɗa wani gyara mai bayyanawa a cikin labarin: “Wani sigar farko na wannan labarin ta yi kuskuren irin shaidar da ‘yan sandan Isra’ila suka tattara na binciken tuhume-tuhumen da ake yi na lalata da Isra’ila a ranar 7 ga Oktoba a harin da Hamas ta kai Isra’ila. ‘Yan sandan sun dogara ne da shaidar shaidu, ba wai ga gawawwakin mutane ko kuma shaidun bincike ba.”
Isra'ila ta yi alƙawarin cewa ta sami shaidar shaidar gani da ido. "Masu bincike sun tattara 'dubun dubatar' shaidun cin zarafin jima'i da Hamas ta aikata a ranar 7 ga Oktoba, a cewar 'yan sandan Isra'ila, ciki har da wurin wani bikin waka da aka kai hari," Schwartz, Gettleman, da Stella sun ruwaito a watan Disamba. 4. Waɗancan shaidun ba su wanzu ba.
"Ni ma dan Isra'ila ne, amma kuma ina aiki da New York Times. Don haka duk lokacin da nake kamar a wannan wuri tsakanin guduma da magara.”
Firayim Minista Benjamin Netanyahu guduma a kan jigon a cikin wani jawabi da aka yi a ranar 5 ga Disamba a Tel Aviv. “Ina gaya wa kungiyoyin kare hakkin mata, ga kungiyoyin kare hakkin bil’adama, kun ji labarin fyaden da aka yi wa matan Isra’ila, munanan ta’asa, kaciya? Ina kaine?” A wannan rana, Shugaba Joe Biden ya ba da jawabi a cikinsa ya ce, “Duniya ba za ta iya waiwaya kawai ba - abin da ke faruwa. Ya rataya a wuya mu duka - gwamnati, kungiyoyin kasa da kasa, kungiyoyin farar hula, daidaikun mutane - mu yi tir da cin zarafin 'yan ta'addar Hamas da karfi ba tare da tangarda ba - ba tare da warwarewa ba, ba tare da togiya ba."
Binciken Times na tsawon watanni biyu yana ci gaba da gyarawa da sake dubawa, Schwartz ta fada a cikin faifan podcast, lokacin da ta fara jin damuwa game da lokacin. "Saboda haka na ce, 'Muna ɓacewa. Wataƙila Majalisar Dinkin Duniya ba ta magana game da cin zarafi da lalata domin babu wani [kafofin watsa labaru] da za su fito da sanarwar abin da ya faru a wurin.” Idan ba a buga labarin na Times nan ba da dadewa, ta ce, “watakila ba zai kasance da ban sha’awa ba.” Schwartz ta ce an bayyana mata jinkirin a cikin gida kamar, "Ba ma son sanya mutane bakin ciki kafin Kirsimeti."
Ta kuma ce majiyoyin 'yan sandan Isra'ila suna matsa mata lamba da ta gaggauta yin wallafawa. Ta ce sun tambaye ta, "Mene ne, shin New York Times ba ta yarda cewa akwai cin zarafi a nan ba?" Schwartz ta ji kamar tana tsakiya.
"Ni ma ina wannan wurin, ni ma dan Isra'ila ne, amma kuma ina aiki da New York Times," in ji ta. "Don haka duk lokacin da nake kamar a wannan wuri tsakanin guduma da magara."
Ta ranar 28 ga Disamba labarin "Screams Without Words" ya buɗe tare da labarin Gal Abdush, wanda Times ya kwatanta da "matar da ke sanye da baƙar fata." Bidiyon jikinta da ya kone ya bayyana ya nuna ba ta da tushe. "Jami'an 'yan sandan Isra'ila sun ce sun yi imanin cewa an yi wa Ms. Abdush fyade," in ji Times. Labarin da aka yiwa lakabi da Abdush "alama ce ta munin da aka kai wa mata da 'yan matan Isra'ila yayin harin na ranar 7 ga Oktoba." Rahoton Times ya ambaci sakonnin WhatsApp daga Abdush da mijinta zuwa ga danginsu, amma bai ambaci hakan ba cewa wasu 'yan uwa yi imani da cewa muhimman sakonnin sun sa ikirarin jami'an Isra'ila ya zama abin kunya. Kamar yadda Mondoweiss ya ruwaito daga baya, Abdush ya aike wa iyalan gidan sakon waya da karfe 6:51 na safe, yana mai cewa suna cikin matsala a bakin iyaka. Da karfe 7:00, mijinta ya aika da sakon cewa an kashe ta. Iyalin nata sun ce an yi chajin ne daga gurneti.
"Ba shi da ma'ana,"ya ce ‘Yar’uwar Abdush, cewa cikin kankanin lokaci “sun yi mata fyade, suka yanka ta, suka kone ta?” Da take magana akan zargin fyaden, sirikinta ya ce: "Kafofin watsa labaru sun ƙirƙira shi."
Wani dangi ya ba da shawarar cewa an matsa wa dangin, a karkashin karya, su yi magana da manema labarai. 'Yar uwar Abdush ta rubuta a shafin Instagram cewa 'yan jaridar Times "sun ambaci suna son rubuta rahoto don tunawa da Gal, kuma shi ke nan. Idan mun san cewa lakabin zai kasance game da fyade da yankan dabbobi, ba za mu taba yarda da hakan ba." A cikin labarin da ya biyo baya, jaridar Times ta nemi bata sunan ta ta na farko, inda ta ambato ‘yar uwar Abdush tana cewa “ta ‘rikice da abin da ya faru’ kuma tana kokarin ‘kare kanwata.
Matar da ta dauki fim din Abdush a ranar 7 ga Oktoba ta shaida wa shafin na Isra'ila YNet cewa Schwartz da Sella sun matsa mata lamba ta ba wa takardar damar yin amfani da hotuna da bidiyoyinta don hidimar farfagandar Isra'ila. "Sun sake kirana kuma sun bayyana yadda yake da mahimmanci ga hasbara Isra'ila," in ji ta ya tuna, ta yin amfani da kalmar don diflomasiyyar jama'a, wanda a aikace yana nufin ƙoƙarin farfagandar Isra'ila wanda ke jagorantar masu sauraron duniya.
A kowane juzu'i, lokacin da 'yan jaridar New York Times suka shiga cikin cikas masu tabbatar da shawarwari, sun juya ga jami'an Isra'ila ko shaidu waɗanda ba a san su ba waɗanda aka riga aka yi hira da su akai-akai a cikin 'yan jaridu. Watanni bayan tashi daga aikin nasu, 'yan jaridar sun tsinci kansu a daidai inda suka fara, inda suka dogara kacokam kan maganar jami'an Isra'ila, da sojoji, da ma'aikatan Zakka domin tabbatar da ikirarinsu na cewa an gano gawarwakin mata da 'yan mata sama da 30 da alamun. cin zarafin jima'i. A cikin faifan faifan bidiyo na Channel 12, Schwartz ta ce yanki na ƙarshe da ta ke buƙata don labarin wani adadi ne mai ƙarfi daga hukumomin Isra'ila game da duk wani mai yuwuwar tsira daga lalata. "Muna da hudu kuma za mu iya tsayawa bayan wannan lambar," in ji ta ma'aikatar walwala da jin dadin jama'a. Ba a bayar da cikakken bayani ba. Labarin Times a ƙarshe ya ruwaito cewa akwai "aƙalla mata uku da mutum ɗaya da aka yi lalata da su kuma suka tsira."
Lokacin da aka buga labarin a ƙarshe a ranar 28 ga Disamba Schwartz ya bayyana ambaliyar motsin rai da halayen kan layi da kuma cikin Isra'ila. "Da farko, a cikin takarda, mun ba shi wuri mai mahimmanci, wanda shine, yana ba da dukkan tsoro na - babu wani babban abin nuna kwarin gwiwa fiye da sanya shi a shafin farko," in ji ta. "A cikin Isra'ila, halayen suna da ban mamaki. Anan ina tsammanin an ba ni rufewa, ganin cewa duk kafofin watsa labaru suna ɗaukar labarin kuma suna ɗaukar shi a matsayin wani abu na [a] na gode don sanya lamba akan shi. Na gode da cewa akwai lokuta da yawa, cewa tsari ne. Na gode da ba shi lakabi wanda ke nuna cewa watakila akwai wasu dabaru na tsarawa a bayansa, cewa wannan ba wani keɓantacce ba ne na wani mutum ya yi da kansa.
Ma’aikatan Times da suka yi magana da The Intercept kan yanayin rashin bayyana sunayensu saboda tsoron ƙwararrun ladabtarwa sun bayyana labarin “Screams Without Words” a matsayin samfurin kura-kurai iri ɗaya da ya haifar da bayanin babban editan da ja da baya akan faifan Rukmini Callimachi na “Khalifa” da buga. jerin kan kungiyar Islamic State. Kahn, babban editan na yanzu, ya kasance sananne a matsayin mai tallata kuma mai kare Callimachi. Rahoton, wanda Times ta tantance a cikin wani nazarin ciki manyan editoci ba su yi cikakken bincike ba kuma ya gaza ga ƙa'idodin takarda kan tabbatar da daidaito, ya kasance ɗan wasan ƙarshe na lambar yabo ta Pulitzer na 2019. Wannan karramawa, tare da sauran kyaututtuka masu daraja, ta kasance soke a sakamakon badakalar.
Margaret Sullivan, editan jama'a na ƙarshe na New York Times don yin cikakken lokaci kafin takarda ta watsar da matsayin a cikin 2017, ya ce tana fatan za a kaddamar da irin wannan bincike kan labarin "Screams Without Words". "Wani lokaci nakan yi ba'a 'wata rana ce mai kyau ba zama editan jama'a na New York Times ba' amma kungiyar za ta iya * da gaske * amfani da daya a yanzu don yin bincike a madadin masu karatu," in ji ta.
A wasu tarurrukan labarai, Schwartz ya ce a kan tashar tashar tashar 12, masu gyara da ƙwararrun Gabas ta Tsakiya sun kasance don ba da tambayoyin bincike. "Mun yi taron mako-mako, kuma kuna fitar da matsayin aikinku kan aikin ku," in ji ta. “Kuma marubutan Times da masu gyara waɗanda suka damu da al’amuran Gabas ta Tsakiya da suka fito daga kowane irin wurare a duniya, suna tambayar ku tambayoyin da ke ƙalubalantar ku, kuma yana da kyau su yi hakan, saboda ku da kanku, koyaushe, kamar ku. kar ka yarda da kanka na ɗan lokaci.”
Waɗannan tambayoyin suna da ƙalubale don amsawa, ta ce: “Ɗaya daga cikin tambayoyin da ake yi muku—kuma ita ce mafi wuya ba za ku iya ba da amsa ba—idan hakan ya faru a wurare da yawa, ta yaya za a yi cewa babu wata shaida ta bincike. ? Ta yaya zai zama cewa babu takardun? Ta yaya zai zama babu bayanan? Rahoton? Tambayoyi na Excel? Kuna gaya mani game da Shari [Mendes]? Wannan ita ce wacce ta gani da idonta, kuma yanzu tana magana da kai - babu wani rahoto [rubuta] da zai sa abin da take faɗa ya zama mai iko?”
Mai gida ya shiga tsakani. "Kuma kun je a wancan matakin ga hukumomin Isra'ila, kun nemi su ba ku - wani abu, komi. Kuma yaya suka amsa?”
"Babu komai," Schwartz ta ce an gaya mata. "Babu wani tarin shaida daga wurin."
Amma a fili, in ji ta, editocin suna da cikakken goyon bayan aikin. "Babu shakka a bangarensu, koda yaushe," in ji ta. "Har yanzu ba yana nufin ina da [labarin] ba, domin ba ni da 'madogara ta biyu' ga abubuwa da yawa."
Wani mai magana da yawun Times ya yi nuni da wannan bangare na hirar a matsayin shaida na tsayayyen tsari na takarda: “Mun yi nazari a kan mafi girman rubutun kuma a bayyane yake cewa kuna dagewa wajen cire maganganun daga mahallin. A cikin ɓangaren hirar da kuke magana akai, Anat ta bayyana yadda editoci suka ƙarfafa su don tabbatar da shaida da tushe kafin mu buga binciken. Daga baya, ta tattauna tarurruka akai-akai tare da editoci inda za su yi tambayoyi 'masu wahala' da 'kalubale', da kuma lokacin da aka ɗauki matakai na biyu da na uku na samo asali. Wannan duk wani bangare ne na tsauraran tsarin bayar da rahoto kuma wanda muke ci gaba da tsayawa a baya."
A cikin hirarta da gidan talabijin na Channel 12, Schwartz ta ce ta fara aiki da Gettleman jim kadan bayan 7 ga Oktoba. “Aikina shi ne in taimake shi. Yana da tunani iri-iri game da abubuwa, game da labaran da yake son yi,” in ji ta. “A rana ta farko, an riga an sami abubuwa uku akan jerin gwanon [sa], sannan na ga lamba ta uku ita ce ‘Ciwon Jima’i. game da cin zarafi, amma a lokacin da ta fara aiki da Gettleman, jita-jita ta fara yada cewa an yi irin waɗannan ayyuka, yawanci bisa sharhin ma'aikatan Zaka da jami'an IDF da sojoji.
Bayan da aka buga labarin, an gayyaci Gettleman don yin magana a kan wani kwamiti game da cin zarafin jima'i a Makarantar Harkokin Kasa da Kasa da Jama'a ta Jami'ar Columbia. Kokarin nasa ya samu yabo daga kwamitin da mai masaukin baki, Sandberg, tsohon shugaban Facebook. Maimakon sau biyu kan rahoton da ya taimaka lashe lambar yabo ta New York Times lambar yabo ta Polk, Gettleman ya yi watsi da bukatar 'yan jarida su ba da "shaida."
"Abin da muka samu - Ba na son ko da amfani da kalmar 'shaida', saboda shaida kusan kusan kalmar shari'a ce da ke nuna cewa kuna ƙoƙarin tabbatar da zargi ko tabbatar da wata ƙara a kotu," Gettleman ya gaya wa Sandberg. “Ba aikina bane. Dukkanmu muna da matsayinmu. Kuma aikina shine rubutawa, shine gabatar da bayanai, shine baiwa mutane murya. Kuma mun sami bayanai tare da dukkanin jerin tashin hankali, don cin zarafin jima'i. "
Gettleman ya ce manufarsa ita ce motsa mutane. "Yana da matukar wahala samun wannan bayanin sannan a tsara su," in ji shi. "Wannan shine aikinmu na 'yan jarida: samun bayanai da kuma raba labarin ta hanyar da za ta sa mutane su damu. Ba don sanarwa kawai ba, amma don motsa mutane. Kuma abin da na dade ina yi ke nan.”
Wani wakilin Times ya ce abokan aiki suna mamakin yadda daidaiton tsari zai kasance: "Ina jiran in ga ko takardar za ta ba da rahoto mai zurfi, ta tura nau'ikan albarkatu da hanyoyin, a kan Majalisar Dinkin Duniya' Rahoton wanda ya rubuta ta'addancin da aka yi wa matan Palasdinawa."
Sabuntawa: Fabrairu 29, 2024
An sabunta wannan labarin don haɗawa da sharhi da aka buga a tweeted bayan buga ta Anat Schwartz. An kuma sabunta wannan labarin don haɗawa da sanarwa daga Times, wanda aka karɓa bayan bugawa, cewa editan ƙa'idodin Phil Corbett ya shirya barin har zuwa Yuni 2022 da kuma game da wani labarin "The Daily" wanda bai taɓa fitowa ba.
Gyara: 29 ga Fabrairu, 2024
An gyara wannan labarin don kawar da kuskuren magana ga masana da ba a bayyana sunayensu ba a cikin labarin New York Times; Times ta ambaci kwararre daya. An cire batun baƙi a taron edita na Times, wanda aka yi saboda kuskuren fassara; masu halarta sun kasance masu gyara. An gyara wannan labarin don nuna cewa Adam Sella dan uwan Anat Schwartz ne, ba Schwartz ba.
ZNetwork ana samun kuɗi ta hanyar karimcin masu karatun sa.
Bada Tallafi