Wataƙila ba ku taɓa jin labarin ɗan wasan barkwanci Bayahude David Baddiel ko baƙar fata tsohon ɗan wasan ƙwallon ƙafa Jason Lee ba. Wataƙila ba za ku damu da ɗayansu ba. Amma taronsu na farko - wanda aka watsa a cikin nau'i biyu daban-daban a wannan makon - yakamata duk wanda ya damu game da yadda yakin da ake yi kan wariyar launin fata da siyasa na ainihi ke amfani da rayuwarmu ta siyasa ta hanyoyin muguwar dabi'a.
Ganawar dai anyi shi ne domin Baddiel ya nemi gafarar Lee shekaru 25 bayan da ya yi ta cin zarafi akai-akai a wani wasan kwaikwayo na BBC da ake kira Fantasy Football League - ta hanyoyin da ko a lokacin akwai nuna wariyar launin fata. Baddiel ya yi baƙar fata kamar Lee, yana sanye da abarba a kansa don ba'a bayyanar Lee saboda ya sa ɗora a ɗaure a saman kansa don wasa.
A cikin ɗayan waɗannan nau'ikan, Baddiel ya bayyana akan nunin ƙaddamarwa na Sabuwar tashar podcast ta Lee, wanda a halin yanzu ya tattara sama da masu biyan kuɗi 700, har ma da taimakon bayyanar Baddiel.
Lee ya yi amfani da damar don yin shari'a mai motsi don dalilin da ya sa aka cutar da rayuwar sa da sauran baƙar fata da yawa ta hanyar ba'a na wariyar launin fata na Baddiel a cikin 1990s. Lee cikin hanzari ya zama abin izgili a cikin ƙasa baki ɗaya, a ciki da wajen fili. Yaransa kanana sun rude da fargabar cewa duk lokacin da suka taka titi tare da mahaifinsu masu wucewa sai su rika ihun zagi. Kuma wasu yaran baƙaƙen da misalin Lee ya ƙarfafa su su yi alfahari da al’adunsu ba zato ba tsammani sun fuskanci zagi da cin zarafi a makaranta don yadda suke kama.
Tsarin na biyu shine na Baddiel. Tun da Fantasy Football League, ɗan wasan barkwanci - wanda tarihin Twitter ya karanta a sauƙaƙe "Yahudawa" - ya gabatar da kansa a matsayin wani ƙwararren ƙwararren wariyar launin fata. An yarda da wannan kima da kai ba tare da juriya daga masana a kafafan yada labarai ba, koda kuwa wasu masu amfani da shafukan sada zumunta sun kasa gafarta masa wariyar launin fata a baya.
Bayan 'yan shekarun da suka gabata Baddiel ya rubuta wani littafi da alama yana da tasiri kan kyamar Yahudawa, kuma a wannan makon an ba da labarinsa har ma a cikin shirin Channel 4 mai suna iri ɗaya: Yahudu Ba Su Kidaya. Hujjar Baddiel ita ce ƙiyayyar Bayahude wani nau'i ne na musamman na wariyar launin fata, musamman ma saboda yawancin 'yan Birtaniyya sun kasa yarda da hakan ta yadda suke yin wasu nau'ikan wariyar launin fata, kamar wariyar launin fata ga baƙi da al'ummomin Asiya.
Baddiel ya sanya wannan batu cikin zayyani kuma a bayyane akan nunin Sabon Tsarin Duniya na Frankie Boyle a cikin 2018 zuwa tafi gaba ɗaya, gwada wariyar launin fata ga Yahudawa zuwa ciwon daji, da wariyar launin fata ga sauran tsiraru zuwa shingles.
Fanning harshen wuta
Tabbas Baddiel ya yi aiki tuƙuru don yin kyakkyawan ra'ayi akan faifan bidiyon Lee, yana ba da uzuri ga dogon tarihinsa na wariyar launin fata. Ya yarda cewa tsoro da kunya sun taka rawa wajen jinkirta ganawarsa da Lee na tsawon lokaci.
A cikin shirin nasa, Baddiel ya ɗan rage girman girman rufe ƙasa ɗaya. Ya yi ta suka maimaituwa a kafafen sada zumunta na wariyar launin fata ga Lee, da munafuncinsa, a matsayin cin zarafi ta yanar gizo - kuma ya yi amfani da waɗancan misalan don ba da hujjar cewa maganinsa, a matsayin Bayahude, ya kasance na musamman kuma daban.
Cikin kwanciyar hankali a kafofin watsa labarai da yake sarrafawa, ya ji kamar Lee ya sami jinkirin uzurinsa kawai don Baddiel ya ji kunyar yin hakan, ko kuma don Baddiel yana kallonta a matsayin tuban da ake buƙata kafin ya sami babban matsayi na ɗabi'a a TV yayin da yake kallonsa. yana neman hakkin a yi masa shari'a daban-daban saboda wariyar launin fata.
Amma baya kan faifan bidiyo na Lee, Baddiel ya kuma yarda cewa ya ɗauki gogewar wariyar launin fata don buɗe idanunsa ga wulakanci da wulakancin da Lee ya fuskanta yayin da ya kasance a kai a kai a BBC.
Baddiel ya lura da wani abin da ya faru a filin wasan ƙwallon ƙafa a ƙarshen 2000s: wani ya gane shi kuma ya yi ihu da kalmar "Yid". Dan uwansa ya dan jima yana takun saka cikin wata barazana da mai son wariyar launin fata. Baddiel ya nuna cewa a wannan lokacin ne ya fara fahimtar irin haɗarin da kansa na hura wutar da Lee ya kasance.
Wannan ya tayar da batu Baddiel bai yi magana akan faifan bidiyo na Lee ba ko kai tsaye a cikin nasa shirin. Ta yaya mai wasan barkwanci ya sami damar tsira da dadewa kafin ya fuskanci irin na visceral, barazana, wariyar launin fata - dabam da abin da kakanninsa da Yahudawa suka fuskanta a tarihi - wanda ya ba shi ɗanɗano yadda ya kasance Lee?
Klan ne suka kashe shi
Na ɗaga wannan ba don ya zama mai ban haushi ba, amma a matsayin mahallin bincika wani ƙalubale da Lee ya taso. Ya tambayi Baddiel wanda ɗan wasan barkwanci yake da "abokan haɗin gwiwa" tare da: wa ya yi tunanin abokan yaƙi da wariyar launin fata? Lokaci guda ne - fiye da lokacin da ya nemi gafara - cewa Baddiel ya yi kama da gaske. Wanene daidai yi yana gani a matsayin abokan yaki da wariyar launin fata?
Baddiel ya ja baya ya lura cewa a shekarun 1960 da 1970 al'ummar Yahudawa da bakar fata sun tsaya kafada da kafada a gwagwarmayar kare hakkin jama'a a Amurka. Malaman sun yi tattaki tare da Martin Luther King a Selma don adawa da masu kishin addini, in ji shi. A cikin Yahudawa Don't Count, shi da ɗan wasan kwaikwayo na Amurka David Schwimmer sun ci gaba da lura cewa a cikin 1964, Ku Klux Klan sun kashe wasu samari Yahudawa biyu a lokacin da suka nufi yankin Deep South don taimaka wa wani baƙar fata mai fafutukar kare hakkin jama'a - lamarin da ya juya baya. a cikin Hollywood movie, Mississipi Burning.
Baddiel ya yarda cewa irin wannan haɗin kai ya yi asara sosai, ya ƙara da cewa bai fahimci komai ba. A cikin wani sashe na faifan bidiyo wanda ba a saba gani ba, ya yi mamakin ko saboda launin fata "ya zama ruwan dare a Amurka musamman - kuma a nan ne duk abin da ke da alama ya samo asali". Ya kara da cewa: "[abokan hadin gwiwa] na iya dawowa, amma a wasu lokuta kamar alakar ba ta kasance ba."
A cikin neman amsa, ya koma ga bala’in da dangin mahaifiyarsa suka fuskanta a Jamus na Nazi. Wadancan tabo sun bar al’ummar Yahudawa, in ji shi, musamman masu kula da wariyar da wasu ke fuskanta: “A cikin shekarun 1960 da 1970, saboda irin wannan gogewar da Yahudawa da yawa suka samu, suna jin ganin cewa ana nuna wa baƙar fata wariya da ƙarfi. musamman a Amurka, su [Yahudawa] sun so su kai ga abin da suka sani."
Sai dai kusan kamar mai tada hankali, sai Baddiel ya garzaya kai tsaye zuwa Whoopi Goldberg, 'yar wasan baƙar fata Ba'amurke ta juya mai gabatar da jawabi a gidan talabijin, don yi mata baƙar magana game da Holocaust, inda ta ba da shawarar kisan gillar masana'antu na Nazis ba game da shi ba. tseren. Na yi magana mai tsawo a baya tare da fushin da kalaman Goldberg suka tsokane da kuma matsalar koma baya daga kungiyoyin Yahudawa kamar Anti-Defamation League, don haka ba zan sake duba wannan lamarin ba a nan. Kuna iya karanta ainihin labarin.
Ba kamar a cikin faifan bidiyo na Lee ba, batun rugujewar kawance tsakanin al'ummomin Yahudawa da bakar fata a yakin da ake yi da wariyar launin fata ba a ambace su ba a cikin shirin na Baddiel. Kuma hakan na iya zama saboda yana kama da mabuɗin buɗe ɗimbin ruɗani da Baddiel da ƙawayen Yahudawa masu sassaucin ra'ayi da ya yi hira da su a shirinsa na TV suka nuna.
Da'irar azzalumai
A farkon Yahudawa Ba su ƙidaya ba, Baddiel ya sami abin da ke damun shi game da ƙiyayya a Biritaniya. Ya ƙunshi masu son ci gaba na hagu da baƙi masu adawa da wariyar launin fata, ba mutanen da ke kai hari a majami'u ba, ko da yake an ambata su ma.
Hotunan taron jam'iyyar Labour na 2019 sun nuna jawabin da Dawn Butler, dan majalisar bakar fata wanda a lokacin ya kasance sakataren inuwar jam'iyyar Labour na mata da daidaito. A cikin ta, ta lissafta wasu kungiyoyi masu rauni da marasa galihu da Labour ke fatan maraba a matsayin wani bangare na kawancen zabe don kayar da jam'iyyar Tory mai mulki. Ta haɗa da waɗanda ke cikin gidajen jama'a, 'yan luwaɗi, 'yan madigo da al'ummomin trans, ma'aikata, nakasassu, 'yan ƙasa da 18, da baƙi, farare da Asiyawa. Amma babu, kamar yadda Baddiel ya jaddada, babu wani ambaton Yahudawa.
Baddiel ya yi fatan tsara wannan a matsayin ƙarami amma yana ba da misali na ƙiyayya da rashin tunani. Gamayyar zaben bakan gizo na Labour karkashin tsohon shugaban jam'iyyar Labour Jeremy Corbyn ya kasance da gangan sai dai in ji Baddiel, lokacin da ya shafi Yahudawa. Ya yi tambaya cikin rarrabuwar kawuna me ya sa Yahudawa ba sa ƙidaya ga hagu na ci gaba.
Lalle ne ƙetare mai ban sha'awa. Amma ina tsammanin hakan baya kwatanta abin da Baddiel ke tunanin yana yi - kuma yana iya ba da ma'anar dalilin da ya sa al'ummomin Yahudawa da baƙar fata suka rasa wannan ƙawance da suke jin daɗinsu a shekarun 1960 da 1970. Ko kuma a sanya wata hanya, me ya sa ga wani kamar Dawn Butler, Yahudawa kamar Baddiel suna shiga cikin nau'in "farar fata", kamar yadda Sikhs, Buddhist da Sinanci suke cikin nau'in "Asiya".
Baddiel ya ba da hujjar cewa “akwai amsoshi da yawa” ga tambayar dalilin da ya sa Yahudawa masu ci gaba suka yi watsi da su, amma mafi mahimmanci a fili wannan shi ne: “Yahudawa ne kawai abubuwan wariyar launin fata waɗanda ake ɗauka a matsayin manya da ƙananan matsayi.” Ana ganin su duka biyu "datti, ɓarawo, wari, mugaye", amma kuma a matsayin "maied, masu gata, masu iko da asirce masu iko da duniya".
Don haka, Baddiel ya kammala, hagu na hagu ya ƙaryata Yahudawa wuri "a cikin da'irar waɗanda aka zalunta". A gaskiya ma, ya ci gaba, sau da yawa ana la'akari da su sosai a matsayin "a cikin da'irar azzalumai". Masu ci gaba suna tunanin suna buge-buge. Baddiel bai yarda ba.
Teflon shafi
A zahiri, mai bitar gidan Talabijin na Guardian ya ƙaunaci shirin gaskiya na Baddiel, abin da ta kira "dukan taurarin simintin gyare-gyare" na al'adun Yahudawa waɗanda suka yi na'am da gardamar Baddiel. Takarda ta kanun labarai ya bayyana shirin a matsayin "mai ban mamaki yana kama da siren".
Amma abin lura shi ne cewa Baddiel Yahudawa masu sassaucin ra'ayi ya ambata wajen gabatar da shari'arsa - da kuma wadanda ba Yahudawa ba masu sassaucin ra'ayi waɗanda ba su da niyyar aiwatar da shirin nasa - kamar ba su damu ba kamar Baddiel da kansa saboda gaskiyar cewa manyan hare-haren na "Yahudawa ba sa yin hakan". Ƙididdigar littafin ta kasance masu son ci gaba da ƙabilanci, musamman shugabannin al'umma baki.
Baddiel da alama ya fi damuwa da zage-zage su ta hanyar zayyana musu ƙiyayya ko rashin tunani fiye da ciyar da lokaci mai yawa don damuwa game da masu wariyar launin fata a filin wasan ƙwallon ƙafa ko kuma wani mutum kamar Boris Johnson wanda tashin siyasarsa gaba ɗaya bai cutar da shi ba - watakila ya amfana da shi - rubuta labari wanda tsakiya, Johnsonesque hali ya yi imanin Yahudawa sun kamu da hanci da kuma sarrafa kafofin watsa labarai.
Abin sha'awa, wani mai bitar littafin ya yi nasara miss Johnson antisemitism ko da a ƙarshen bazara na 2019, lokacin da kyamar baki ke yin kanun labarai na yau da kullun yayin da kafofin watsa labarai suka yi wa Corbyn da jam'iyyar Labour a ƙasa.
Baddiel zai iya fassara waɗannan rikice-rikice na gaskiyar sabanin yadda ya zaɓa: cewa Yahudawa ba sa ƙidaya kawai idan yana cikin muradun kafa Birtaniyya - daga Boris Johnson zuwa Guardian - cewa ba sa ƙidaya. Suna ƙidaya sosai lokacin da kafa ɗaya ke son su ƙidaya, kamar yadda masu ci gaba suka gano da zaran Corbyn ya zama shugaban jam'iyyar Labour.
Kuma ga wani abu. Johnson's Teflon-coating a kan zargin wariyar launin fata ya nuna nasarar da Baddiel ya samu na kaucewa biyan farashi don dogon tarihin wariyar launin fata.
Masanin siyasa Ash Sarkar yayi wannan magana da kyau:
Gaskiyar cewa [wariyar wariyar launin fata] Baddiel ba ta taɓa shafe shi ba ta rushe ra'ayinsa na cewa ƙiyayyar Islama, kyamar baki, wasu nau'ikan kyamar baki suna jin daɗin gata idan aka kwatanta da kyamar baki - saboda aikinsa bai taɓa yin tasiri da ɗayan waɗannan abubuwan ba.
A gaskiya ma, akwai ɗan tasirin tarihin kansa na wariyar launin fata wanda ya iya zama gwani a kan wariyar launin fata. ... Shi mai tafiya ne, numfashi, magana mai raɗaɗi ga ra'ayin cewa an ɗauki anti-baƙar fata sosai a cikin da'irar ci gaba kuma anti-Semitism ba.
Yi la'akari da sauƙi wanda Johnson da Baddiel suka guje wa duk wani lissafin siyasa ko kafofin watsa labaru don rubutattun wariyar launin fata: a cikin shari'ar Johnson don kyamar Yahudawa, kuma a cikin Baddiel don nuna wariyar launin fata.
Sa'an nan kuma ya bambanta da wannan da shaidan na Corbyn, wanda shekaru da yawa ya rushe shi ta hanyar zarge-zargen nuna kyama ga jam'iyyar Labour a lokacin mulkinsa.
Wadannan zarge-zargen an ba su rai ta hanyar zarge-zarge daga hadewar jam'iyyar Tory, kafafan yada labarai, da Haƙƙin tsarin mulki na Corbyn na Labour Party, da Yahudawa masu sassaucin ra'ayi kamar Baddiel. Dukkaninsu sun fuskanci barazana daga masu adawa da mulkin mallaka na Corbyn, musamman, a cikin batutuwan da suka shafi manyan tsare-tsare na al'ummar Yahudawa, da sukar da ya yi wa Isra'ila da manufofinta na wariyar launin fata ga Palasdinawa. Kuma mafi yawansu sun ji tsoron shirinsa na gurguzu mai matsakaicin ra'ayi wanda zai iya kawo karshen rashin daidaito.
"Isra'ila, Schmisrael"
Ba kamar ya faru ga Baddiel ko sauran Yahudawa masu sassaucin ra'ayi da ya yi hira da su cewa ba za su yi kama da abokan gaba ga al'ummar ci gaba, masu adawa da wariyar launin fata, ko kuma ga al'ummar baki ba, don wani dalili mai sauƙi. Domin ƙungiyoyin shugabannin Yahudawa waɗanda ke da'awar wakiltar mafi yawan Yahudawan Burtaniya - kamar Majalisar Wakilai, Ƙungiyar Tsaro ta Al'umma, Kamfen Yaƙi da Yaƙin Yahudawa, Ƙungiyar Ƙwararrun Yahudawa, jerin sun ci gaba - duk suna ci gaba da yin ƙaho cewa Yahudawa ba abokan tarayya ba ne. masu ci gaba.
Jagoran al'ummar Yahudawan da aka shirya, da kuma fitattun masu sharhi kamar Jonathan Freedland a cikin Guardian, sun yi iƙirari akai-akai cewa zaɓen ya nuna. tara daga cikin 10 Yahudawan Burtaniya goyon bayan Isra'ila - ko da a fili da yawa ba sa son gwamnatinta na yanzu, wadda ta gabace ta da wadda ke bayanta.
Suna goyon bayan Isra'ila, ga alama, a matsayin wani nau'i na zarge-zarge, duk da cewa ta fito fili kuma ta kasance mai nuna kyama ga zalunci da korar al'ummar Palasdinu, ta kuma yi wa al'ummar Palasdinu kawanya tare da kashe fararen hula a lokaci-lokaci, kuma ta ayyana kasar wariyar launin fata ta hanyar jagorancin kungiyoyin kare hakkin bil'adama. Yana da ma'ana sosai kamar na goyi bayan mulkin wariyar launin fata a Afirka ta Kudu shekaru 40 da suka gabata amma nace ba na nuna wariyar launin fata ba saboda ina adawa da gwamnatin PW Botha.
Ba wai kawai ba, amma Freedland da sauran Yahudawa masu sassaucin ra'ayi suna jayayya cewa Isra'ila tana kan gaba ainihin asalin su kuma sukan Isra'ila shine kushe su. Suna jayayya cewa adawa daga hagu na hagu zuwa akidar siyasa ta sahyoniyanci - akidar da ta haifar da mulkin mallaka na mahaifar Palasdinawa da kuma korar al'ummarta - daidai ne da ƙiyayya ga Yahudawa.
Idan wannan ra'ayi ba ya yaɗu a tsakanin al'ummar Yahudawa, to ko dai kafofin watsa labaru ko kuma al'ummar Yahudawa da kansu sun yi aiki mai kyau na yaudare mu. Waɗanda Yahudawan da suka ɗauki wani matsayi dabam, kamar waɗanda suka goyi bayan Corbyn, ba koyaushe suna samun kansu a gaban sauran Yahudawa ba, ko dai a sarari ko a fakaice, a matsayin masu ƙiyayya ko kuma "nau'in Bayahude mara kyau".
Wadancan "Yahudawa ba daidai ba", kamar yadda Al Jazeera kwanan nan rubuce a cikin daki-daki, a halin yanzu ana tsarkake su cikin tsari daga jam'iyyar Labour ta Sir Keir Starmer - kuma babu wani bayani game da shi daga Baddiel ko wani abokansa Bayahude masu sassaucin ra'ayi.
A ci gaba da karfafa rudani, Isra'ila da kanta ta bukaci a amince da ita a matsayin kasar duk Yahudawan duniya. Dokokin Isra'ila sun bayyana cewa duk Yahudawa na cikin abin da ake kira "ƙasar Yahudawa". Isra'ila ta yi iƙirarin yin magana ga dukan Yahudawa. Tana rike da dukkan yankinta - har ma da yankin Falasdinu - amana ga Yahudawa a ko'ina. A lokacin da Isra'ila ke aiwatar da kisan kabilanci na Falasdinawa, kamar yadda take yi a kowace rana, tana yin hakan ne da sunan David Baddiel - ko Baddiel yana so ko bai so.
Wanne batu ne Baddiel zai iya taso da marubuci Howard Jacobson a yayin hirarsu lokacin da Jacobson ya yi iƙirarin za a ƙi Isra'ila duk abin da ta yi, ko da kuwa Switzerland ne. Ya yi iƙirarin, “za a ƙi shi cikin yaren da mutane suka yi amfani da shi game da Yahudawa shekaru 2000 da suka shige.”
Madadin haka, Baddiel ya tsallake dangantakar Yahudawan Burtaniya da Isra'ila tare da korar - kuma mai dacewa - "Isra'ila, Shmisrael".
Riba daga yaki
Baddiel yayi daidai da ya nuna cewa kyama ne a ɗora wa Yahudawa alhakin ayyukan Isra’ila, ko kuma tsammanin za su soki Isra’ila. Sai dai wadanda aka yi hira da su kamar su Jacobson da ’yar wasan barkwanci ta Amurka Sarah Silverman sun rikitar da gardamarsa ta hanyar zabar goyon bayan kyamara ga Isra’ila, suna masu cewa kasarsu ce kuma wata mafaka ce ga yahudawa, yayin da kuma suka bukaci kada su raba wani alhakin ayyukanta a cikin Isra’ila. yana mai da yankin guda ya zama mara lafiya ga Falasɗinawa.
To wanne ne? Shin Isra'ila kasa ce da ke wakiltar dukan Yahudawa, kamar yadda Isra'ila ke ikirari?
Ko kuwa wata kasa ce da ke wakiltar Yahudawa kawai kamar Freedland, Jacobson da Silverman - da kuma dukkanin manyan kungiyoyin Yahudawa na Biritaniya da ke da'awar yin magana ga al'ummar Yahudawa - cewa Isra'ila ce a tsakiyar asalinsu?
Ko kuwa Isra'ila ba daidai ba ce kuma tana wakiltar Yahudawa ne kawai 'yan ƙasar Isra'ila - kuma ba waɗanda suke ba, kamar masu ba da rahoto na Yahudawa na New York Times masu sassaucin ra'ayi a Urushalima, waɗanda suka zaɓi tsawon shekaru don tura 'ya'yansu don yin yaƙi a cikin sojojin Isra'ila?
Baddiel na iya gwammace ya guje wa magance wannan tambayar, amma masu ci gaba ba su da irin alatu lokacin da suka yanke shawarar waɗanda za su ƙidaya a matsayin abokan siyasa. Hagu dai yana fafutukar ganin ko wane ne yake da kawance da su lokacin da kungiyoyin da ke da'awar wakiltar al'ummar Yahudawan Burtaniya, ciki har da yahudawa masu sassaucin ra'ayi, suka ci gaba da ba da uzuri ga Isra'ila yayin da take kashe kananan yara a Gaza ko kuma ta sanya masu ci gaba a matsayin masu adawa da yakin neman dakatar da hada-hadar kasashen Yamma. kisan kai.
Baddiel ba shi da alhakin ayyukan Isra'ila, amma yana da alhaki a matsayin Bayahude tare da babban dandamali na yin shuru lokacin da Hukumar ta dauki shi da yawancin sauran Yahudawa zuwa ga zaluncin Isra'ila ga Falasdinawa ko kuma lokacin da ta yi amfani da makamai masu linzami a kan wadanda suka ci gaba, masu adawa. dalilai na mulkin mallaka.
Isra'ila ta cika da makamai da kayan agaji da na kasashen yammaci da huldar kasuwanci da kuma goyon bayan diflomasiyya yayin da take aikata laifukan da take aikatawa kan Falasdinawa da sunan kowane Bayahude a duniya. Sojojin Isra'ila da suka wuce gona da iri, wadanda Amurka ke biyan su, suna kai hare-hare a gabas ta tsakiya tare da ikirarin rawar da take takawa a matsayin gendarmen yankin. Tana ci gaba da yakin cacar baki da Iran wanda zai iya fashe cikin tashin hankali a kowane lokaci. Tana gwagwarmayar gwada makamanta kan Falasdinawa da makwabtanta na Larabawa don amfanar sojojin kasashen yamma da dillalan makamai. Tana fitar da makamanta ta yanar gizo zuwa ga masu mulkin kama-karya da ke amfani da su wajen sa ido kan ‘yan adawa. Kuma yana ƙara taimakawa wajen haɓaka munanan gwamnatocin musulmi kamar na Saudi Arabiya tare da mahimman bayanai.
Don haka abin tambaya ga masu son ci gaba yayin da suke zabar abokansu shine wanene yake tare da su a yakin da ake yi da kasashen Yamma da ke cin riba daga yake-yaken albarkatu marasa iyaka, wanda ke ba da damar ci gaba da mulkin mallaka, wanda ke daukar yawancin sauran kasashen duniya a matsayin bangaren da bai dace ba. rarrabuwar wayewa, kuma hakan ya sanya Isra'ila zurfafa cikin wannan yanar gizo na bukatu?
Matsayin wariyar launin fata
Wataƙila rashin daidaituwa na al'ummar hagu da baƙar fata game da ƙawance tare da al'ummar Yahudawa - sabanin ɗayan Yahudawa - yana nuna wannan hoto mai ruɗani, rikice-rikicen shugabannin Yahudawa da Isra'ila sun haɓaka sosai.
Wataƙila gaskiyar cewa masu ci gaba suna kallon al'ummar Yahudawa a matsayin masu rauni kuma masu ƙarfi a lokaci guda ya zama ƙasa da sake farfado da ƙiyayya da ta daɗe fiye da ɗimbin ɗimbin ƙawayen da ake zaton wakilan ƙungiyoyin shugabannin Yahudawa ne kamar kwamitin wakilai. Sun goyi bayan wani yanki mai amfani da makamin nukiliya, Isra'ila, yayin da suke kawance da wata kafa ta Birtaniyya kawai suna da sha'awar yin amfani da kyamar baki a matsayin abin kunya don bacewar wani hagu mai ci gaba daga siyasar Burtaniya - wani abu da Starmer ke aiwatarwa a yanzu a madadin kafa.
Baddiel ya bayyana a cikin shirin nasa raunin raunin da yahudawa ke ji, musamman fuskantar wata annoba da ake zaton ta ƙiyayya ta Labor a ƙarƙashin jagorancin Corbyn. Amma masu ci gaba na hagu a Biritaniya dole ne su ga waɗannan abubuwan ta hanyar ruwan tabarau na daban.
Alal misali, dole ne su kalli rashin ƙarfi yayin da 'yar majalisar Labour ta Yahudawa, Ruth Smeeth, ta jagoranci abin da ke da ban tsoro. zanga zanga na wasu 'yan majalisar wakilai 50 na jam'iyyar Labour - Yahudawa da wadanda ba Yahudawa ba - suna adawa da wani keɓe, mai rauni, tsohon mai fafutukar yaƙi da wariyar launin fata, Marc Wadsworth, yana buƙatar jam'iyyar ta kore shi a matsayin mai kyamar baki.
Laifin Wadsworth ya kasance zargi Smeeth na yin daidai abin da ya nuna tana yi: yin bayani ga mai biliyan biliyan, jaridar Telegraph mai hakki - zuciyar kafuwar - a kan Corbyn, zababben shugaban jam'iyyarta, don taimakawa wajen durkusar da shi.
Menene masu ci gaba da ya kamata su ƙare game da "abokin haɗin gwiwa" yayin wannan taron?
Baddiel ya lura da kyau yadda tsoro - tsoron sabon Holocaust, na sake korar - ke ci gaba da mamaye al'ummar Yahudawa na Biritaniya. Sai dai ya yi watsi da fargabar da ke tattare da jiga-jigan ‘yan takarar da ba su yi rajista a siyasar Burtaniya sama da rabin karni ba, baya ga hatsaniya da na dan kankanin lokaci tare da Corbyn, kuma a halin yanzu ana samunsa. shake waje ga wani tsara ta Starmer.
Hagu masu ci gaba, kamar Yahudawa, su ma an sanya su - ta kafa ɗaya - su kasance masu rauni da ƙarfi a lokaci guda. Starmer ya san cewa zai iya kawar da na hagu daga Labour ba tare da wani kudin siyasa ba, domin kafafen yada labarai za su rufa masa baya yayin da yake yin haka. Amma a lokaci guda, an gabatar da hagu a matsayin mai ƙarfi sosai wanda ake zaton yana nuna "barazanar wanzuwa” ga al’ummar Yahudawa a Biritaniya. Idan Corbyn ya ci mulki, da alama zai mayar da Biritaniya ta zama Reich ta Uku.
Baddiel yana amfani da shirin nasa, kuma, don ƙarfafa tsarin wariyar launin fata, don roƙon ƙiyayya Bayahude a matsayin wani nau'i na daban. Roƙonsa na musamman kan kyamar Yahudawa shaida ce ta gata da yake tsammani da kuma ƙawancen da yake raini.
Gaskiyar ita ce, al'ummomi masu rauni, masu rauni suna buƙatar mannewa tare, kuma lokacin da ake kai musu hari - ko ɗan ƙwallon ƙafa baƙar fata kamar Jason Lee, mai adawa da wariyar launin fata kamar Marc Wadsworth, '' Bayahude mara kyau 'kamar Naomi Wimborne-Idrissi, ko kuma Yaron Falasdinu kamar ɗaliban Masafer Yatta - suna buƙatar haɗin kanmu, ba zagin mu ba. Suna buƙatar haɗin kai daidai, wanda aka tsara akan daidaito. Kuma wannan shine ainihin abin da Corbyn ke bayarwa.
Jason Lee ya tambayi Baddiel su waye abokansa. Baddiel bai san yadda zai amsa ba. Kuma a wannan lokacin, Lee ya sami amsarsa.
ZNetwork ana samun kuɗi ta hanyar karimcin masu karatun sa.
Bada Tallafi