A watan Fabrairu, Ministan Muhalli Mista Jairam Ramesh ya dakatar da Bt. Brinjal. Yanzu yana tura gwaji na GM roba akan Kerala wanda ke da GMO kyauta. Babban Ministan Kerala VS Achuthanandan da Ministan Noma na Kerala, Mullakkara Ratnakaran duk sun sake jaddada kudurin su na ganin Kerala GMO ya zama kyauta.
Mista Jairam Ramesh ya bayyana cewa GM roba ba ta canzawa ba wato ba shi da kwayoyin halitta daga nau'in da ba su da alaka da su. Wannan gaba daya karya ne. Yayin da kwayar halittar MnSOD ta fito daga roba, ginin MnSOD ya zama transgenic. Ya ƙunshi CaMV35S, ƙwayar cuta da ake amfani da ita azaman mai talla, alamar juriya na ƙwayoyin cuta npt II (Kanamycin) da kuma kwayar cutar CUS daga kwayoyin cuta (E.Coli.). Sanya ƙwayoyin cuta da ƙwayoyin cuta a cikin shuka shine canjin transgenic. Bai kamata Ministan Muhalli ya yaudari al'umma kan batun GMO wanda ke da sakamako mai nisa ba.
Ana samar da robar GM don yada noman robar zuwa yankunan da ke bayan Kerala ta hanyar sanya shi jure fari. Koyaya, juriya na fari na injiniya yana da alaƙa da "tasirin pleiotropic". Pleiotropy shine ikon canjin kwayoyin halitta guda daya don haifar da tasirin ilimin halittar jiki mara niyya a cikin shuka. Kamfanonin da ke mai da hankali kan juriyar jurewar fari ta tsarin halitta suna gano cewa kwayoyin halitta don jurewar fari na iya yin tasirin da ba a so akan wasu halaye.
Masu binciken da ke bin tsarin jurewar fari na haɓakar ƙwayoyin cuta suna gano cewa bayyanar da kwayoyin halitta don jurewar fari na iya samun tasirin da ba a iya faɗi ba kuma maras so akan wasu halaye, gami da yawan amfanin ƙasa da inganci. Kamar kwamfutar tafi-da-gidanka da ke da ɗimbin kumbura, ƙwayoyin halittar da ke da alaƙa da jurewar fari suna rage saurin ci gaban shuka, wanda ke haifar da ƙananan ciyayi da jinkirta fure. A cewar wani rahoto da Kamfanin Bincike da Ci gaban hatsi na Ostiraliya ya shirya, “Aibi mai zurfi ne. Ya yi daidai da canza asarar amfanin gona da aka samu a lokacin rani zuwa shekaru masu kyau. " (Ref: Rahoton ETC)
Masu bincike a Cibiyar Binciken amfanin gona ta kasa da kasa na Semi-Arid Tropics (ICRISAT) a Indiya kuma sun ba da rahoton rashin daidaituwa da ke aiki tare da kwayoyin da ke amsa damuwa a cikin amfanin gona na transgenic. A cikin labarin 2007 sun rubuta cewa: "Kima da tsire-tsire masu tsire-tsire a ƙarƙashin yanayin damuwa, da fahimtar tasirin ilimin halittar jikin da aka saka a duk matakin shuka ya kasance a matsayin manyan ƙalubalen da za a shawo kan su. Injiniyan kwayoyin halitta don haka ba fasaha ce abin dogaro ba don jurewar fari.
Bayan haɗarin muhalli na ƙara ƙwayoyin cuta da ƙwayoyin cuta a cikin shuke-shuke, GM roba zai inganta monocultures kuma ya kawar da bambancin. Ta hanyar maye gurbin noman abinci a wasu yankuna zai kara ta'azzara matsalar yunwa a Indiya wanda ya hana rabin yara da manya kashi daya bisa uku na kason su zuwa isassun abinci mai inganci da inganci.
Wani rikici na GMO ya haifar da memba na CPM Politburo S. Ramachandran Pillai wanda a wani taron karawa juna sani a Kerala ya ce yana da camfi don adawa da GM tsaba. Mista Pillai ya bayar da hujjar cewa tsaba na GM zasu taimaka wajen kara yawan aiki da magance rashin abinci mai gina jiki, kuma bai kamata a yi adawa da ci gaban kimiyya da fasaha a makance ba.
Makauniyar yarda da GMOs a matsayin mafita ga yunwa shine ainihin camfi domin injiniyan kwayoyin halitta baya kara yawan amfanin gona. Wani danyen kayan aiki ne wanda ya dogara da kimiyyar ragewa wanda yayi watsi da sabbin abubuwan da suka faru shine kimiyyar fannonin ilimin halittu, epigenetics da tattalin arzikin agro. Kididdigar kasa da kasa kan ilmin noma da kimiya da fasaha don raya kasa (IAASTD) da masana kimiya 400 suka gudanar a tsawon shekaru hudu ga MDD ya bayyana sarai cewa makomar samar da abinci ba ta ta'allaka ne kan injiniyan kwayoyin halitta. Wannan shine ƙima mafi girma kuma na baya-bayan nan na injiniyan kwayoyin halitta da ake samu daga al'ummar kimiyya. Injiniyan Halittu fasaha ce maras nauyi domin ta dogara ne akan mugun kimiyya wanda ke da ragi da injina wanda ya kasa yin la'akari da sarƙaƙƙiya da tsarin kai na tsarin rayuwa.
Kamar yadda Bayanin Ilimi na Hukumar Kasa da Kasa kan Makomar Abinci da Noma ta faɗi, al'ummomin kimiyya gabaɗaya sun yarda da waɗannan ka'idoji:
a) Tsarin rayuwa da marasa rai duk suna da alaƙa da juna, sakamakon kasancewar duk wani canji a cikin kashi ɗaya dole ne ya haifar da canje-canjen da ba za a iya faɗi ba a sauran sassan cibiyar sadarwa;
b) sãɓãwar launukansa shi ne ginshikin canji da daidaitawa yayin da rashinsa ya kai ga mutuwa babu makawa;
c) Tsarin rayuwa yana canza yanayin rayayye kuma ana canza shi ta hanyar daidaitawa;
Misalin tsarin ragewa shine abin da ake kira "Enviropigs" wanda aka yi amfani da shi da kwayoyin halitta daga beraye da kuma daga kwayoyin E.Coli don fitar da ƙarancin fosphorous. Matsalar ba shakka ba ita ce phosphorous kanta ba. Phosphorous sinadari ne da tsirrai ke bukata. Koyaya, noman masana'anta tare da dubun dubatar aladu yana juya wannan muhimmin sinadari mai gurɓataccen abu. Yawan sinadarin phosphorus yana shiga cikin ruwa na sama inda yake haɓaka algae girma, wanda ke hana hasken rana kaiwa zurfin zurfi kuma yana amfani da narkar da iskar oxygen ta haka yana kashe kifi da sauran halittu. "Enviropigs" ba shine maganin "kore" ba. Tana kiyaye tsarin noma na tashin hankali wanda zai ci gaba da azabtar da dabbobi, kuma yana kula da tsarin noman masana'anta da ba shi da dorewa wanda ke amfani da furotin na hatsi sau goma a matsayin abinci fiye da yadda ake samarwa a matsayin nama. Wannan yana ba da gudummawa ga matsalar abinci.
Lokaci ya yi da za a cire ƙwaƙƙwaran ƙiftawa waɗanda ke ba da damar aikin injiniyan kwayoyin halitta don ganin a matsayin mafita mai dorewa da aminci ga yunwa. Muna buƙatar kimiyya ta gaske da dorewa ta gaske ba kimiyyar karya ba da dorewar ƙirƙira da hukumomi da masana kimiyya ke bayarwa a hidimar kamfanoni. Madadin alade da aka kirkira ta kwayoyin halitta shine alade mai kewayo. Madadin GM roba monocultures da ke yaduwa a duk faɗin ƙasar yana haɓaka samar da halittu masu rai don haɓaka amincin abinci ta hanyar haɓaka abinci mai gina jiki a kowace kadada da kuma jure yanayin yanayi.
Kayan aikin agribusiness na kamfanoni kayan aiki ne don riba. Ba za a iya ɗaukar su azaman ma'aunin kimiyya ba. Yarda da kayan aiki da tsarin kimiyyar kamfani shine fada cikin camfi na kamfanoni.
Kamar yadda Einstein ya ce, matsalolin ba za a iya magance su ta hanyar tunani ɗaya wanda ya haifar da su ba.
Muna buƙatar matsawa fiye da Monocultures na Hankali da rashin tausayi na rage yawan aikin injiniya wanda aka dogara da camfin mafita na ƙarya na injiniyan kwayoyin halitta.