Ga ainihin labarin, wanda wannan shafin ya amsa: (Alan Guebert, “Insuring Elephants,” Farm and Food File, 12/23/14, http://farmandfoodfile.com/2014/12/23/insuring-elephants/).
Shuka (RevenueInshora na iya zama, kamar yadda Alan Guebert ya yi jayayya, "giwa a cikin kantin sayar da kayan abinci na Farm Bill," amma idan haka ne, to da alama bai lura ba. LOKACI a cikin dakin, da kuma gaskiyar cewa dukan dakin yana karkashin ruwa.
Yana nufin "Big Ag," kuma yana da "babban ci da shaƙatawa," amma ba masu siyar da kayayyaki na Agribusiness (WHALE,) kuma ba RUWA ba ("rashin amsawar farashin" "a kan duka wadata da buƙatun don tarawa". noma,”) wanda ke haifar da nutsewa.
Tabbas tunanin cewa mai son shiga Ofishin Farm na iya yin ma'anar abubuwa yana ɗaga babbar tutar ja. Ya kamata mu ɗauka da gaskiyar cewa ta fito da misalin aikin aikin kula da ƙasa, wata muhimmiyar ƙungiyar al'amuran gona ta ci gaba. Kamar yadda ya fito, a'a.
Guebert ya fara ne da dalilai guda biyu (nazarin GAO guda biyu da Ma'aikatar Harkokin Kasuwancin Farm ta ambata, game da farashi da sauyin yanayi,) game da dalilin da yasa Majalisa za ta sake duba inshorar amfanin gona. Bai fadi manyan dalilan ba.
Misali, babu wani dalili na tattalin arziki da zai sa shirin inshorar kudaden shigar amfanin gona ya wanzu, domin yana yin garantin farashi mai rahusa, wanda ya haifar da tattalin arziki sakamakon gazawar kasuwannin ‘yanci, kuma ta hanyar siyasa ta Majalisa, wanda da wuya ya ambaci wani abu kusa da wadannan. , manyan abubuwan da ke faruwa. Don haka wasa ne na rashin nasara gaba daya, wanda sai ya bukaci gwamnati ta samar da shi, (bayan tallafin manoma/inshorar-kamfanin,) domin a yi kamar yana aiki.
Akwai dalilai na siyasa kawai don irin wannan shirin: yana aiki azaman juzu'i, aƙalla ga wasu masu sauraro, (kuma babu wani yanki na masu sauraro da ya fi fahimtar ainihin batutuwan, [sai dai masu fafutukar kare hakkin gonaki]). Matsalar juyi ita ce haɗa haɗin kai ta hanyar "Biyan Kuɗi kai tsaye" babban gazawa ne kamar juyi, kuma kusan kowa ya manta abin da ainihin ra'ayin (ƙarya) har ma ya kasance. Sabuwar juzu'i, (inshorar kuɗin shiga,) shine kayan aikin "Gudanar da haɗari". Kai, inshora ne. Duk wani kasuwanci yana buƙatar inshora don sarrafa haɗari, daidai?
Ba daidai ba. Ba inshora ba ne. Shiri ne da a wasu lokutan ake biyan tallafi a lokacin da manoma ke bukata, da ma fiye da haka idan ba sa bukatar su, kuma ba ya biyan su komai a lokacin da ake bukatar su. Me ya sa, saboda ba shi da ƙayyadaddun ƙayyadaddun buƙatu, na farashin samarwa, alal misali, ta hanyar auna fa'idodin. Maimakon haka yana bin kasuwannin 'kyauta', ta amfani da ka'idojin "shekarar Olympic". Sai dai kasuwannin 'kyauta' yawanci sun gaza, tsawon shekaru 150, kuma ana hasashen za su gaza nan da 2023! Don haka bin ƙa'idar gazawa, da biyan kuɗi mai yawa lokacin da ba a buƙata ba, da bambance-bambancen da ke tsakanin, ba, a cikin kowane ma'anar ma'ana ba, "Gudanar da haɗari."
Kuma, a zahiri, ya gaza kamar yadda yake tun farko, kodayake kusan babu ɗaya daga cikin masu suka da ya san ainihin abin da ke faruwa.
Manoma, duk da haka, sun san wani abu game da shi. Sun yi watsi da tsarin inshorar kudaden shiga na lissafin gona na 2008, musamman a Iowa. Har yanzu, Majalisa, tare da tallafi daga Farm Bureau, NCGA, ASA da sauransu, sun zaɓi ta a matsayin hanyar da za a bi.
Guebert ya nakalto rahoton GAO kan batun cewa za a iya rage tallafin kuɗi "tare da ƙaramin tasiri' ga farashin manoma da sa hannu a ciki." To, manoma ba su da zabi na gaske, don haka a, dole ne su shiga. A halin yanzu ban ga wani m bincike na manoma farashin (vs farashin) a cikin wani daga cikin kafofin (Guebert, Farm Bureau, GAO, Land Stewardship Project).
Ɗaya daga cikin rahotannin GAO ya ma yi amfani da ƙididdiga na kudaden shiga na gidan gona don tabbatar da ƙarshensa. A cikin shekarun da suka gabata, yayin da kuɗin shiga gona ya ragu, ya ragu, ya ragu, a ƙarshe mun gano cewa kuɗin shiga gidan gona ya haura! Kai, ta yaya hakan zai kasance? GAO yana kula da shi kamar idan tattalin arzikin gona dole ne yayi kyau. To, mu gani. Muna da mafi ƙarancin farashin gona a tarihi, (watau mafi ƙanƙanta 8 na 9 na masara da waken soya, da makamantansu ga sauran amfanin gona,) 1997-2005. Sannan muna da shekaru 7 lokacin da masara, waken soya da farashin shinkafa ya fi tsada. Kash! Abin da muke da shi shi ne, ƙara, masu arziki ne kawai, suna rubuta wasu kudaden shiga, za su iya rayuwa a cikin noma. Sa'an nan kuma mun sami wasu shekaru lokacin da manyan amfanin gona suka sami kuɗi. Yawancin hakan ya ƙare tare da farashin masara ya faɗi ƙasa da farashi. Amma babu ɗaya daga cikin waɗannan haƙiƙanin da alama da za a yi la'akari da su a cikin kowane tushe.
A ƙarshe, Guebert ya yaba da rahotannin LSP, kamar haka:
Inshorar amfanin gona (kudaden shiga) yana da tsada sosai.
Ee.
- "bayanai… yana da ban tsoro." "Ayyukan 26 sun sami sama da dala miliyan 1 kowanne…"
To, ba kusan abin ban mamaki ba kamar bayanan da suka ɓace, nawa Cargill ke samu daga shirin gabaɗaya. A'a, Cargill ba ya samun tallafi. Tana samun haƙƙin 'kyauta' kasuwa, daga rashin shirye-shiryen bene na Farashin, inda Amurka ta yi asarar kuɗi da yawa kan fitar da gonaki tsawon shekaru 26-32 a jere. Wannan yana haifar da fa'idodin US DA na duniya, kuma waɗanda ke cikin biliyoyin a duniya, amma babu fayyace kan waɗannan fa'idodin. Ba a ma ambaci su ba.
- “Mafi 10%… 2.3 bisa dari na manoman Amurka” “sun karɓi fiye da rabin… na duk tallafin kuɗi.”
Haka ne, amma gonakin amfanin gona na cikakken lokaci duk suna cikin kashi goma na sama. Matsakaicin ƙasa 80% ƙasa da 10% na girman cikakken lokaci. Wannan ba a taba ambata ba. Kuma tallafin na kayan amfanin gona ne, wanda ke samun kuɗi kaɗan fiye da sauran amfanin gona marasa tallafi, har ma da tallafin. Wannan ma ba a taba ambatonsa ba.
- "Bincike bayan nazari ya nuna cewa amfanin shirin gonakin gwamnatin tarayya galibi ana yin sa ne a farashin filaye" "inshorar amfanin gona" yana haɓaka maida hankali.
A gaskiya ma, a cikin shekarun da suka gabata, manoma sun sami raguwar kuɗi kaɗan, har ma da tallafi, kuma yawancin manoma sun lalace. To ina bayanin dalilin da ya sa farashin filaye ke da yawa dangane da iya samun kuɗi daga ƙasar? Me ya sa ake zargin amfanin gonakin kayayyaki, alhalin sun yi kasa da ‘ya’yan itatuwa da kayan marmari, har ma da tallafin? Me yasa aka cire waɗannan abubuwan daga waɗannan rahotanni? Kuma me ya sa ake noman asarar haraji, inda masu hannu da shuni za su iya yin gogayya da masu ƙoƙarin samun kuɗi ta hanyar noma da kansu, ba wani ɓangare na nazari ba?
A ƙarshe, Guebert ya bayyana ƙarshen LSP. Yaya game da "dukkanin inshorar amfanin gona" da ke mai da hankali kan "tare albarkatun gona, gonaki iri-iri" don "manoma na farko." To, wannan duk yana da kyau idan aka yi la’akari da giwaye. Amma menene game da WALE!? Ambaton kuma fa? LSP ba ta yin wani abu don magance gaskiyar cewa CAFOs suna samun tallafi mai yawa ta farashi mai arha, ko da a cikin shawarwarin nasu. Shi ya sa, yayin da yake da kyau a kan ƙananan batutuwa, ya gaza a mafi girman ma'ana, ba ya yin komai a kan matsalar abinci mai arha wanda ya sa yawancin manoma suka yi asarar dabbobi masu daraja, kuma tare da shi, tushen tattalin arziki don kiyaye albarkatu. Juyawa amfanin gona, (watau amfani da alfalfa, clover da ƙananan hatsi). Shawarar ta yi watsi da matsalar dumbin barna na ababen more rayuwa don dorewa, kamar rumfunan sayar da kayayyaki, da injinan hawa da za su sayi hatsi da niƙa, da dai sauransu.
Guebert ya kammala da cewa: "An gama aikin kuma tambayar ta kasance: me yasa masu biyan haraji ke inshorar giwaye?" Abin takaici, shi da sauran duk sun kasa amsa wannan tambayar.
Whale ne a cikin dakin! Gaskiya dakin ya cika da ruwa! Whale Ne A Dakin!! Gaskiya Dakin Yayi Ruwa. SHINE KWANCIYAR DAKI!!! GASKIYAR DAKIN YA WUCE!!!
DON KARIN KARATU
Daryll E. Ray, “Rashin amsan farashi ne! Yana Amsar Farashin!! AMSA FARASHI NE!!!” APAC, Jami'ar Tennessee, 5/6/05, http://agpolicy.org/weekcol/248.html .
Daryll E. Ray & Harwood D. Schaffer, "Inshorar Kuɗi: Ƙididdigar Safety net," APAC, Jami'ar Tennessee, 2/20/15, http://agpolicy.org/weekcol/760.html .
Brad Wilson, "PRIMER: Inshorar Kuɗi a cikin Dokar Farm ta 2012," ZSpace, 5/11/12, https://znetwork.org/zblogs/primer-revenue-insurance-in-the-2012-farm-bill-by-brad-wilson/, (haɗi zuwa mahimman labarai na Daryll E. Ray, IATP, Brad Wilson, da sauransu).
Brad Wilson, "Abubuwan Magana don Dokar Farm ta 2012," ZSpace, 5/13/12, https://znetwork.org/talking-points-for-the-2012-farm-bill-by-brad-wilson .
Brad Wilson, "De Mystifying Crop Insurance in the Farm Bill," ZSpace, 6/17/13, https://znetwork.org/zblogs/de-mystifying-crop-insurance-in-the-farm-bill-by-brad-wilson/ .
Brad Wilson, "Siyasa da Inshorar amfanin gona," ZSpace, 9/13/13, https://znetwork.org/zblogs/politics-and-crop-insurance-by-brad-wilson/ .
Brad Wilson, "Kamfanoni da Inshorar amfanin gona: Rebuting White Paper na LSP 1, " ZSpace, 1/3/15, https://znetwork.org/zblogs/corporations-and-crop-insurance-rebutting-lsps-white-paper-1/ .
Brad Wilson, "Mafi Girma a asirce babba a cikin' Gyarawa': Sake Buga Farin Takardar LSP 2," ZSpace, 1/3/15, https://znetwork.org/zblogs/biggest-secretly-bigger-in-reform-rebutting-lsps-white-paper-2/
Brad Wilson, "Tasirin lissafin kuɗin noma: Wace Jiha ce Mafi Rasa?" SlideShare, 8/12/14, http://www.slideshare.net/bradwilson581525/farm-bill-net-impacts-which-state-is-the-biggest-loser .
ZNetwork ana samun kuɗi ta hanyar karimcin masu karatun sa.
Bada Tallafi